{ "regime_a": [ { "d": 3, "p": 0.001, "trivial": 0.02308, "mwpm": 0.00072, "mlp": 0.000916, "convgru": 0.001246, "gnn": 0.001298, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict": "indistinguishable", "ratio_mwpm_over_neural": 0.7860262008733625 }, { "d": 3, "p": 0.003, "trivial": 0.065665, "mwpm": 0.00641, "mlp": 0.006174, "convgru": 0.006862, "gnn": 0.008296, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict": "indistinguishable", "ratio_mwpm_over_neural": 1.0382248137350178 }, { "d": 3, "p": 0.005, "trivial": 0.104545, "mwpm": 0.016680407391677286, "mlp": 0.016088, "convgru": 0.017218, "gnn": 0.01842, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict": "indistinguishable", "ratio_mwpm_over_neural": 1.03682293583275 }, { "d": 3, "p": 0.01, "trivial": 0.18744, "mwpm": 0.06056112103144578, "mlp": 0.055618, "convgru": 0.05758, "gnn": 0.062736, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict": "neural", "ratio_mwpm_over_neural": 1.088876281625477 }, { "d": 5, "p": 0.001, "trivial": 0.058005, "mwpm": 9.5e-05, "mlp": 0.003266, "convgru": 0.003134, "gnn": 0.00262, "best_neural": "gnn", "verdict": "mwpm", "ratio_mwpm_over_neural": 0.03625954198473283 }, { "d": 5, "p": 0.003, "trivial": 0.15393, "mwpm": 0.00338, "mlp": 0.019996, "convgru": 0.016982, "gnn": 0.011112, "best_neural": "gnn", "verdict": "mwpm", "ratio_mwpm_over_neural": 0.3041756659467243 }, { "d": 5, "p": 0.005, "trivial": 0.22917, "mwpm": 0.014014885158703083, "mlp": 0.05319, "convgru": 0.044748, "gnn": 0.037362, "best_neural": "gnn", "verdict": "mwpm", "ratio_mwpm_over_neural": 0.37511067819450467 }, { "d": 5, "p": 0.01, "trivial": 0.35625, "mwpm": 0.08121051148939595, "mlp": 0.197032, "convgru": 0.173618, "gnn": 0.154774, "best_neural": "gnn", "verdict": "mwpm", "ratio_mwpm_over_neural": 0.52470383584708 } ], "regime_b": [ { "d": 3, "noise": "s0_x0", "spread": 0.0, "crosstalk": 0.0, "trivial": 0.065086, "mwpm_true": 0.006518, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.006518, "mlp": 0.006174, "convgru": 0.00699, "gnn": 0.008296, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "indistinguishable", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 1.0557175251052804, "mismatch_penalty": 1.0, "verdict_vs_true": "indistinguishable" }, { "d": 3, "noise": "s0_x0.0005", "spread": 0.0, "crosstalk": 0.0005, "trivial": 0.087416, "mwpm_true": 0.015312, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.028354, "mlp": 0.015356, "convgru": 0.016322, "gnn": 0.016928, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "neural", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 1.846444386559, "mismatch_penalty": 1.85175026123302, "verdict_vs_true": "indistinguishable" }, { "d": 3, "noise": "s1.75_x0", "spread": 1.75, "crosstalk": 0.0, "trivial": 0.06243, "mwpm_true": 0.006394, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.00656, "mlp": 0.00591, "convgru": 0.006378, "gnn": 0.007654, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "neural", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 1.1099830795262267, "mismatch_penalty": 1.0259618392242726, "verdict_vs_true": "neural" }, { "d": 3, "noise": "s1.75_x0.0015", "spread": 1.75, "crosstalk": 0.0015, "trivial": 0.098352, "mwpm_true": 0.019744, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.039494, "mlp": 0.02006, "convgru": 0.020522, "gnn": 0.021386, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "neural", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 1.9687936191425721, "mismatch_penalty": 2.000303889789303, "verdict_vs_true": "indistinguishable" }, { "d": 3, "noise": "s1_x0", "spread": 1.0, "crosstalk": 0.0, "trivial": 0.06368, "mwpm_true": 0.006952, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.00702, "mlp": 0.006458, "convgru": 0.006998, "gnn": 0.007782, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "neural", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 1.0870238463920718, "mismatch_penalty": 1.0097813578826238, "verdict_vs_true": "neural" }, { "d": 3, "noise": "s1_x0.0005", "spread": 1.0, "crosstalk": 0.0005, "trivial": 0.07811, "mwpm_true": 0.012294, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.02002, "mlp": 0.011954, "convgru": 0.012774, "gnn": 0.012948, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "neural", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 1.6747532206792706, "mismatch_penalty": 1.62843663575728, "verdict_vs_true": "indistinguishable" }, { "d": 5, "noise": "s0_x0", "spread": 0.0, "crosstalk": 0.0, "trivial": 0.155064, "mwpm_true": 0.003338, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.003338, "mlp": 0.019996, "convgru": 0.017774, "gnn": 0.011112, "best_neural": "gnn", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "mwpm", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 0.3003959683225342, "mismatch_penalty": 1.0, "verdict_vs_true": "mwpm" }, { "d": 5, "noise": "s0_x0.0005", "spread": 0.0, "crosstalk": 0.0005, "trivial": 0.207968, "mwpm_true": 0.016026, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.021942, "mlp": 0.037846, "convgru": 0.036114, "gnn": 0.039408, "best_neural": "convgru", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "mwpm", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 0.607576009303871, "mismatch_penalty": 1.3691501310370648, "verdict_vs_true": "mwpm" }, { "d": 5, "noise": "s1.75_x0", "spread": 1.75, "crosstalk": 0.0, "trivial": 0.139936, "mwpm_true": 0.002902, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.003352, "mlp": 0.017908, "convgru": 0.014108, "gnn": 0.010516, "best_neural": "gnn", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "mwpm", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 0.3187523773297832, "mismatch_penalty": 1.155065472088215, "verdict_vs_true": "mwpm" }, { "d": 5, "noise": "s1.75_x0.0015", "spread": 1.75, "crosstalk": 0.0015, "trivial": 0.227382, "mwpm_true": 0.025152, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.035754, "mlp": 0.041584, "convgru": 0.048738, "gnn": 0.063192, "best_neural": "mlp", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "mwpm", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 0.8598018468641785, "mismatch_penalty": 1.421517175572519, "verdict_vs_true": "mwpm" }, { "d": 5, "noise": "s1_x0", "spread": 1.0, "crosstalk": 0.0, "trivial": 0.155866, "mwpm_true": 0.003168, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.003562, "mlp": 0.018724, "convgru": 0.015072, "gnn": 0.01668, "best_neural": "convgru", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "mwpm", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 0.23633227176220806, "mismatch_penalty": 1.1243686868686869, "verdict_vs_true": "mwpm" }, { "d": 5, "noise": "s1_x0.0005", "spread": 1.0, "crosstalk": 0.0005, "trivial": 0.191118, "mwpm_true": 0.011166, "mwpm_misspecified": 0.014386, "mlp": 0.030922, "convgru": 0.028544, "gnn": 0.032574, "best_neural": "convgru", "verdict_vs_misspecified": "mwpm", "ratio_misspecified_over_neural": 0.5039938340807175, "mismatch_penalty": 1.2883754253985311, "verdict_vs_true": "mwpm" } ], "device": [ { "d": 3, "rounds": 5, "best_neural": "convgru", "mlp": 0.1828, "convgru": 0.1572, "gnn": 0.1593, "pymatching": 0.1479, "correlated_matching": 0.1376, "tensor_network": 0.1252, "trivial": 0.2934, "verdict_vs_pymatching": "indistinguishable" }, { "d": 3, "rounds": 25, "best_neural": "convgru", "mlp": 0.4908, "convgru": 0.4892, "gnn": 0.4898, "pymatching": 0.4302, "correlated_matching": 0.4241, "tensor_network": 0.4052, "trivial": 0.4901, "verdict_vs_pymatching": "mwpm" }, { "d": 5, "rounds": 5, "best_neural": "gnn", "mlp": 0.3649, "convgru": 0.291, "gnn": 0.2643, "pymatching": 0.1473, "correlated_matching": 0.1275, "tensor_network": 0.106, "trivial": 0.3869, "verdict_vs_pymatching": "mwpm" } ], "notes": [], "completeness": { "regime_a": "24/24", "regime_b": "72/72", "device": "21/24" } }