{ "subset": { "n": 1000, "warmup": 20, "seed": 0, "keys": [ [ 2666, 2 ], [ 12648, 4 ], [ 18360, 5 ], [ 3715, 0 ], [ 13502, 3 ], [ 16562, 4 ], [ 12123, 10 ], [ 7509, 1 ], [ 18645, 1 ], [ 16951, 3 ], [ 10058, 2 ], [ 2269, 11 ], [ 548, 0 ], [ 3292, 0 ], [ 15225, 2 ], [ 54, 1 ], [ 19300, 2 ], [ 12754, 1 ], [ 9168, 0 ], [ 12499, 3 ], [ 2288, 3 ], [ 6903, 0 ], [ 8188, 0 ], [ 8917, 3 ], [ 5288, 5 ], [ 17180, 0 ], [ 3224, 0 ], [ 2856, 3 ], [ 12289, 3 ], [ 19833, 1 ], [ 19170, 0 ], [ 4158, 1 ], [ 11571, 3 ], [ 11274, 8 ], [ 4674, 2 ], [ 12743, 4 ], [ 7455, 5 ], [ 11187, 6 ], [ 17085, 3 ], [ 3238, 0 ], [ 14735, 1 ], [ 12176, 4 ], [ 9120, 3 ], [ 11242, 3 ], [ 6623, 6 ], [ 6792, 6 ], [ 6707, 2 ], [ 1082, 10 ], [ 10033, 0 ], [ 18619, 3 ], [ 2488, 18 ], [ 3152, 0 ], [ 4833, 0 ], [ 5563, 3 ], [ 1309, 6 ], [ 2836, 3 ], [ 14985, 5 ], [ 10726, 0 ], [ 8871, 1 ], [ 7866, 1 ], [ 15935, 3 ], [ 10724, 6 ], [ 17325, 0 ], [ 19269, 5 ], [ 13651, 2 ], [ 2916, 1 ], [ 12483, 5 ], [ 4406, 7 ], [ 19003, 2 ], [ 12885, 1 ], [ 6871, 2 ], [ 9131, 0 ], [ 586, 4 ], [ 10558, 4 ], [ 4451, 3 ], [ 8146, 3 ], [ 14230, 3 ], [ 6258, 1 ], [ 12743, 1 ], [ 16212, 3 ], [ 2269, 9 ], [ 3708, 2 ], [ 5407, 3 ], [ 7999, 1 ], [ 1581, 3 ], [ 2669, 2 ], [ 916, 0 ], [ 4670, 0 ], [ 6768, 3 ], [ 4560, 1 ], [ 14985, 4 ], [ 3224, 5 ], [ 14157, 9 ], [ 4414, 5 ], [ 1206, 1 ], [ 759, 4 ], [ 6996, 6 ], [ 6640, 5 ], [ 4640, 1 ], [ 18741, 3 ], [ 7753, 1 ], [ 2232, 2 ], [ 803, 3 ], [ 16208, 2 ], [ 3751, 5 ], [ 9963, 3 ], [ 2553, 2 ], [ 8158, 1 ], [ 2609, 7 ], [ 11551, 7 ], [ 13440, 5 ], [ 16614, 0 ], [ 6472, 6 ], [ 19676, 9 ], [ 18141, 2 ], [ 1330, 2 ], [ 3747, 1 ], [ 7249, 1 ], [ 10037, 0 ], [ 13669, 3 ], [ 18302, 7 ], [ 6236, 3 ], [ 7456, 2 ], [ 2093, 5 ], [ 5791, 9 ], [ 5926, 4 ], [ 13182, 1 ], [ 9628, 3 ], [ 4451, 4 ], [ 16924, 0 ], [ 6405, 5 ], [ 470, 2 ], [ 18351, 0 ], [ 15658, 1 ], [ 19880, 2 ], [ 11890, 2 ], [ 13619, 5 ], [ 14928, 1 ], [ 9634, 2 ], [ 5680, 2 ], [ 406, 10 ], [ 17629, 4 ], [ 2777, 6 ], [ 12904, 0 ], [ 1586, 1 ], [ 10966, 0 ], [ 5016, 0 ], [ 8982, 11 ], [ 18883, 3 ], [ 13470, 1 ], [ 11198, 1 ], [ 13674, 3 ], [ 4916, 7 ], [ 11870, 2 ], [ 14843, 0 ], [ 15775, 3 ], [ 2860, 3 ], [ 55, 5 ], [ 6919, 0 ], [ 12823, 5 ], [ 5852, 2 ], [ 8963, 3 ], [ 8202, 2 ], [ 17180, 3 ], [ 14454, 1 ], [ 1049, 5 ], [ 15405, 0 ], [ 15890, 4 ], [ 1632, 5 ], [ 6119, 1 ], [ 17098, 4 ], [ 2302, 12 ], [ 9935, 9 ], [ 5791, 0 ], [ 17114, 0 ], [ 19019, 4 ], [ 27, 1 ], [ 1311, 0 ], [ 19315, 1 ], [ 12514, 4 ], [ 11912, 0 ], [ 18124, 2 ], [ 1741, 6 ], [ 15802, 0 ], [ 6760, 1 ], [ 2991, 0 ], [ 4833, 5 ], [ 569, 4 ], [ 15386, 1 ], [ 15865, 2 ], [ 122, 5 ], [ 7826, 8 ], [ 548, 4 ], [ 62, 10 ], [ 3507, 4 ], [ 6876, 0 ], [ 4545, 3 ], [ 7204, 3 ], [ 11622, 8 ], [ 10925, 4 ], [ 6574, 0 ], [ 3700, 2 ], [ 18577, 0 ], [ 15100, 8 ], [ 2886, 1 ], [ 777, 2 ], [ 10711, 6 ], [ 17452, 0 ], [ 4414, 0 ], [ 9823, 8 ], [ 4976, 3 ], [ 13355, 1 ], [ 4406, 3 ], [ 5707, 3 ], [ 10844, 7 ], [ 662, 0 ], [ 1464, 2 ], [ 1364, 0 ], [ 7565, 0 ], [ 9961, 2 ], [ 12045, 6 ], [ 13970, 3 ], [ 1438, 4 ], [ 19300, 17 ], [ 17661, 3 ], [ 16593, 2 ], [ 14251, 2 ], [ 6443, 4 ], [ 7608, 8 ], [ 14307, 2 ], [ 11274, 7 ], [ 270, 0 ], [ 5199, 1 ], [ 5611, 4 ], [ 10559, 4 ], [ 12758, 0 ], [ 12926, 2 ], [ 13975, 3 ], [ 3315, 2 ], [ 12933, 3 ], [ 1198, 0 ], [ 1378, 1 ], [ 10501, 0 ], [ 5990, 4 ], [ 5563, 1 ], [ 11234, 4 ], [ 13731, 2 ], [ 15063, 0 ], [ 4812, 1 ], [ 11326, 1 ], [ 4406, 0 ], [ 18679, 0 ], [ 8982, 4 ], [ 1704, 0 ], [ 11831, 4 ], [ 6463, 0 ], [ 2582, 6 ], [ 11623, 3 ], [ 15425, 2 ], [ 12624, 5 ], [ 11501, 1 ], [ 15775, 8 ], [ 4114, 3 ], [ 3592, 2 ], [ 18828, 5 ], [ 18521, 3 ], [ 12904, 19 ], [ 13247, 2 ], [ 4662, 2 ], [ 18741, 1 ], [ 4414, 4 ], [ 19453, 4 ], [ 16259, 0 ], [ 1302, 0 ], [ 11622, 0 ], [ 12863, 0 ], [ 5741, 6 ], [ 6153, 0 ], [ 3031, 2 ], [ 2405, 3 ], [ 3000, 10 ], [ 7195, 3 ], [ 8158, 4 ], [ 2232, 3 ], [ 14723, 8 ], [ 229, 3 ], [ 3519, 3 ], [ 15048, 1 ], [ 11234, 9 ], [ 17181, 3 ], [ 19038, 5 ], [ 7935, 6 ], [ 16072, 3 ], [ 2991, 3 ], [ 14103, 2 ], [ 8084, 1 ], [ 10058, 9 ], [ 6153, 1 ], [ 16464, 21 ], [ 6904, 12 ], [ 13669, 2 ], [ 4406, 2 ], [ 937, 6 ], [ 17402, 8 ], [ 7379, 1 ], [ 19382, 2 ], [ 15204, 1 ], [ 7607, 2 ], [ 1458, 0 ], [ 7884, 1 ], [ 3833, 0 ], [ 7195, 2 ], [ 17647, 4 ], [ 14390, 3 ], [ 13745, 5 ], [ 5636, 3 ], [ 3833, 2 ], [ 19033, 1 ], [ 5459, 5 ], [ 15527, 4 ], [ 16101, 2 ], [ 19347, 0 ], [ 12429, 0 ], [ 19510, 1 ], [ 19537, 0 ], [ 7382, 2 ], [ 296, 0 ], [ 13070, 1 ], [ 12223, 0 ], [ 12364, 1 ], [ 1194, 2 ], [ 5459, 4 ], [ 9823, 14 ], [ 5742, 2 ], [ 14454, 7 ], [ 11379, 1 ], [ 18302, 10 ], [ 2406, 3 ], [ 3000, 9 ], [ 8282, 2 ], [ 1360, 6 ], [ 11550, 0 ], [ 569, 13 ], [ 17181, 4 ], [ 12649, 1 ], [ 5899, 0 ], [ 5497, 4 ], [ 17842, 1 ], [ 14212, 4 ], [ 19719, 4 ], [ 14607, 1 ], [ 19657, 5 ], [ 1089, 6 ], [ 3195, 1 ], [ 2748, 2 ], [ 16228, 1 ], [ 7585, 0 ], [ 11234, 6 ], [ 15886, 1 ], [ 18894, 0 ], [ 14928, 0 ], [ 8770, 1 ], [ 723, 0 ], [ 27, 3 ], [ 6562, 9 ], [ 11623, 0 ], [ 19812, 4 ], [ 9793, 2 ], [ 12743, 3 ], [ 2405, 0 ], [ 19300, 1 ], [ 10081, 2 ], [ 11632, 2 ], [ 15613, 1 ], [ 14681, 2 ], [ 14654, 1 ], [ 5990, 3 ], [ 4782, 0 ], [ 8939, 1 ], [ 11185, 10 ], [ 12816, 4 ], [ 1969, 3 ], [ 1198, 4 ], [ 18875, 2 ], [ 15886, 2 ], [ 5251, 6 ], [ 19268, 2 ], [ 2889, 1 ], [ 5636, 4 ], [ 13490, 4 ], [ 15718, 1 ], [ 1193, 2 ], [ 18087, 4 ], [ 14774, 4 ], [ 17677, 0 ], [ 1654, 0 ], [ 18306, 4 ], [ 719, 4 ], [ 1082, 1 ], [ 4943, 0 ], [ 12479, 0 ], [ 3845, 2 ], [ 13349, 8 ], [ 7020, 0 ], [ 14651, 1 ], [ 19197, 1 ], [ 4195, 4 ], [ 2195, 4 ], [ 18141, 3 ], [ 12926, 8 ], [ 11417, 3 ], [ 4745, 4 ], [ 14804, 0 ], [ 11332, 2 ], [ 4608, 3 ], [ 6792, 2 ], [ 1306, 3 ], [ 15017, 1 ], [ 17065, 2 ], [ 14220, 0 ], [ 17533, 2 ], [ 13605, 4 ], [ 2685, 0 ], [ 1542, 0 ], [ 1359, 1 ], [ 18991, 1 ], [ 9804, 8 ], [ 907, 11 ], [ 7884, 2 ], [ 8537, 17 ], [ 3297, 0 ], [ 15966, 9 ], [ 19813, 2 ], [ 11726, 10 ], [ 4297, 5 ], [ 5373, 6 ], [ 16212, 1 ], [ 16002, 2 ], [ 2991, 9 ], [ 15832, 1 ], [ 2288, 2 ], [ 3591, 4 ], [ 15802, 1 ], [ 5742, 6 ], [ 1045, 8 ], [ 17127, 2 ], [ 16464, 18 ], [ 15857, 7 ], [ 1027, 2 ], [ 19375, 1 ], [ 12483, 8 ], [ 9753, 0 ], [ 2775, 3 ], [ 13490, 0 ], [ 2553, 8 ], [ 4608, 0 ], [ 13674, 4 ], [ 1024, 3 ], [ 13314, 5 ], [ 13390, 2 ], [ 6430, 0 ], [ 300, 0 ], [ 8658, 3 ], [ 13886, 1 ], [ 2582, 0 ], [ 5342, 0 ], [ 7609, 0 ], [ 122, 2 ], [ 7509, 6 ], [ 4635, 6 ], [ 228, 1 ], [ 11306, 3 ], [ 14114, 4 ], [ 898, 1 ], [ 8738, 5 ], [ 5276, 7 ], [ 6710, 1 ], [ 17479, 3 ], [ 4244, 1 ], [ 18619, 6 ], [ 13274, 4 ], [ 9921, 3 ], [ 4812, 9 ], [ 937, 11 ], [ 7614, 0 ], [ 13752, 2 ], [ 12856, 4 ], [ 18488, 0 ], [ 11304, 4 ], [ 12571, 3 ], [ 6638, 1 ], [ 2860, 4 ], [ 3770, 0 ], [ 11831, 2 ], [ 5773, 3 ], [ 14321, 5 ], [ 4680, 4 ], [ 8197, 0 ], [ 12123, 5 ], [ 19877, 2 ], [ 9128, 1 ], [ 8885, 2 ], [ 6623, 7 ], [ 15966, 3 ], [ 1624, 0 ], [ 4916, 5 ], [ 723, 1 ], [ 2771, 8 ], [ 2630, 1 ], [ 4916, 2 ], [ 15966, 11 ], [ 11501, 4 ], [ 15857, 3 ], [ 5288, 2 ], [ 16004, 0 ], [ 11488, 1 ], [ 13526, 1 ], [ 3000, 8 ], [ 9394, 4 ], [ 17085, 0 ], [ 14129, 0 ], [ 2093, 1 ], [ 14321, 2 ], [ 15613, 10 ], [ 231, 5 ], [ 15857, 10 ], [ 12303, 3 ], [ 16837, 2 ], [ 7472, 4 ], [ 14220, 1 ], [ 11306, 4 ], [ 3198, 2 ], [ 6666, 1 ], [ 4114, 2 ], [ 10786, 2 ], [ 4226, 6 ], [ 5684, 7 ], [ 17111, 1 ], [ 15225, 1 ], [ 6666, 0 ], [ 15999, 0 ], [ 16467, 5 ], [ 6405, 3 ], [ 9394, 2 ], [ 17457, 0 ], [ 13072, 0 ], [ 5288, 6 ], [ 13554, 1 ], [ 17900, 6 ], [ 3026, 8 ], [ 18938, 1 ], [ 7456, 6 ], [ 11390, 4 ], [ 62, 2 ], [ 17237, 0 ], [ 17880, 7 ], [ 229, 2 ], [ 7999, 0 ], [ 11490, 5 ], [ 4358, 1 ], [ 11559, 0 ], [ 5773, 0 ], [ 16140, 0 ], [ 18335, 4 ], [ 3242, 5 ], [ 19453, 3 ], [ 8730, 3 ], [ 15476, 8 ], [ 10925, 5 ], [ 4602, 2 ], [ 10531, 0 ], [ 1360, 5 ], [ 27, 4 ], [ 9823, 9 ], [ 15204, 8 ], [ 15100, 0 ], [ 17065, 3 ], [ 3761, 0 ], [ 13502, 4 ], [ 11077, 0 ], [ 7045, 1 ], [ 3010, 0 ], [ 1194, 1 ], [ 2553, 10 ], [ 10137, 0 ], [ 11728, 1 ], [ 13061, 0 ], [ 4535, 1 ], [ 9464, 0 ], [ 5973, 2 ], [ 2488, 2 ], [ 15778, 0 ], [ 11234, 7 ], [ 11040, 9 ], [ 4979, 2 ], [ 7733, 5 ], [ 15703, 2 ], [ 15438, 2 ], [ 10844, 10 ], [ 11296, 10 ], [ 16924, 1 ], [ 14220, 4 ], [ 5154, 0 ], [ 5776, 5 ], [ 4635, 8 ], [ 4581, 3 ], [ 14556, 3 ], [ 15349, 2 ], [ 18182, 0 ], [ 5215, 1 ], [ 11494, 2 ], [ 13512, 2 ], [ 18438, 1 ], [ 7969, 1 ], [ 19061, 3 ], [ 19636, 1 ], [ 19269, 6 ], [ 2200, 0 ], [ 17037, 1 ], [ 11549, 2 ], [ 5312, 2 ], [ 19347, 2 ], [ 1842, 2 ], [ 7878, 3 ], [ 904, 7 ], [ 18340, 1 ], [ 14985, 0 ], [ 300, 2 ], [ 2412, 0 ], [ 2886, 2 ], [ 15070, 0 ], [ 219, 0 ], [ 13735, 2 ], [ 1378, 0 ], [ 4422, 1 ], [ 136, 0 ], [ 10531, 5 ], [ 11304, 2 ], [ 8455, 2 ], [ 5251, 2 ], [ 11198, 2 ], [ 6904, 0 ], [ 3845, 4 ], [ 16562, 1 ], [ 17842, 4 ], [ 14681, 1 ], [ 6207, 8 ], [ 12649, 3 ], [ 16588, 4 ], [ 5455, 5 ], [ 17154, 2 ], [ 5446, 0 ], [ 12123, 8 ], [ 4806, 6 ], [ 7633, 6 ], [ 6707, 3 ], [ 17037, 3 ], [ 13428, 7 ], [ 14928, 5 ], [ 16275, 0 ], [ 19268, 4 ], [ 14942, 3 ], [ 8084, 2 ], [ 7045, 4 ], [ 16760, 1 ], [ 7499, 3 ], [ 1741, 5 ], [ 14843, 5 ], [ 1089, 1 ], [ 8780, 3 ], [ 13805, 3 ], [ 2078, 0 ], [ 6353, 2 ], [ 8740, 1 ], [ 11482, 2 ], [ 3026, 10 ], [ 19979, 5 ], [ 11128, 2 ], [ 13497, 3 ], [ 15746, 0 ], [ 17647, 2 ], [ 1908, 1 ], [ 16464, 11 ], [ 17510, 0 ], [ 19190, 3 ], [ 9793, 6 ], [ 18577, 1 ], [ 7869, 1 ], [ 12904, 21 ], [ 10255, 4 ], [ 1464, 0 ], [ 1501, 0 ], [ 1842, 5 ], [ 5968, 0 ], [ 13437, 0 ], [ 136, 2 ], [ 228, 0 ], [ 5241, 4 ], [ 2302, 9 ], [ 16324, 0 ], [ 8193, 0 ], [ 15100, 5 ], [ 8158, 3 ], [ 17457, 4 ], [ 6930, 4 ], [ 13019, 1 ], [ 3761, 5 ], [ 3023, 2 ], [ 12245, 0 ], [ 12434, 2 ], [ 17538, 2 ], [ 12499, 2 ], [ 9806, 1 ], [ 971, 0 ], [ 1512, 0 ], [ 6844, 3 ], [ 14107, 3 ], [ 2836, 1 ], [ 7682, 2 ], [ 13327, 1 ], [ 6759, 2 ], [ 7379, 0 ], [ 9683, 0 ], [ 11571, 1 ], [ 11912, 3 ], [ 14723, 6 ], [ 9793, 5 ], [ 18883, 7 ], [ 13248, 1 ], [ 8982, 8 ], [ 1512, 3 ], [ 11728, 4 ], [ 2612, 4 ], [ 270, 5 ], [ 19339, 5 ], [ 16696, 4 ], [ 1672, 2 ], [ 15749, 9 ], [ 17841, 5 ], [ 16768, 2 ], [ 4535, 0 ], [ 2886, 3 ], [ 8998, 5 ], [ 3559, 6 ], [ 5684, 5 ], [ 15768, 14 ], [ 7826, 7 ], [ 16829, 0 ], [ 2757, 1 ], [ 16259, 6 ], [ 15055, 5 ], [ 1330, 1 ], [ 6505, 0 ], [ 9467, 0 ], [ 19190, 0 ], [ 8084, 0 ], [ 4796, 1 ], [ 10911, 0 ], [ 13468, 12 ], [ 12248, 3 ], [ 16584, 4 ], [ 4045, 0 ], [ 11132, 4 ], [ 7337, 0 ], [ 11429, 3 ], [ 16860, 0 ], [ 20097, 2 ], [ 17900, 0 ], [ 10058, 11 ], [ 10608, 2 ], [ 8725, 3 ], [ 591, 0 ], [ 4545, 0 ], [ 3566, 2 ], [ 6338, 4 ], [ 15775, 7 ], [ 9431, 1 ], [ 7969, 2 ], [ 11128, 4 ], [ 20189, 6 ], [ 16353, 2 ], [ 4618, 0 ], [ 10608, 1 ], [ 4535, 2 ], [ 13669, 9 ], [ 8537, 16 ], [ 11040, 0 ], [ 8165, 6 ], [ 2387, 2 ], [ 11829, 2 ], [ 12581, 2 ], [ 8770, 2 ], [ 14265, 4 ], [ 18800, 0 ], [ 11185, 6 ], [ 6304, 5 ], [ 5147, 1 ], [ 569, 16 ], [ 19719, 2 ], [ 12614, 2 ], [ 13970, 4 ], [ 904, 3 ], [ 4812, 4 ], [ 15076, 0 ], [ 5732, 5 ], [ 6418, 11 ], [ 19939, 4 ], [ 2748, 3 ], [ 5025, 0 ], [ 7587, 2 ], [ 19375, 3 ], [ 8826, 9 ], [ 4916, 3 ], [ 8770, 3 ], [ 14723, 5 ], [ 13498, 3 ], [ 4936, 2 ], [ 4090, 1 ], [ 907, 1 ], [ 13669, 4 ], [ 19088, 1 ], [ 17538, 0 ], [ 11843, 1 ], [ 407, 0 ], [ 5968, 3 ], [ 19315, 3 ], [ 18828, 1 ], [ 11972, 0 ], [ 2777, 1 ], [ 9935, 8 ], [ 5147, 3 ], [ 12163, 2 ], [ 11296, 1 ], [ 14681, 0 ], [ 2146, 0 ], [ 7633, 2 ], [ 1309, 0 ], [ 12076, 0 ], [ 9466, 1 ], [ 13217, 4 ], [ 16837, 0 ], [ 8333, 2 ], [ 10033, 1 ], [ 13256, 0 ], [ 5956, 2 ], [ 11726, 3 ], [ 591, 7 ], [ 13605, 1 ], [ 2098, 1 ], [ 5636, 1 ], [ 13498, 2 ], [ 777, 5 ], [ 19242, 2 ], [ 2250, 1 ], [ 898, 0 ], [ 9072, 1 ], [ 1569, 0 ], [ 8333, 0 ], [ 12546, 2 ], [ 2426, 0 ], [ 2269, 13 ], [ 13307, 5 ], [ 16035, 1 ], [ 5029, 0 ], [ 7903, 4 ], [ 17207, 2 ], [ 16588, 3 ], [ 5278, 2 ], [ 11900, 4 ], [ 6418, 13 ], [ 12624, 10 ], [ 15613, 11 ], [ 14620, 3 ], [ 282, 4 ], [ 15646, 0 ], [ 10167, 6 ], [ 17953, 0 ], [ 1438, 3 ], [ 4618, 13 ], [ 15613, 15 ], [ 14942, 15 ], [ 6304, 4 ], [ 122, 0 ], [ 19572, 4 ], [ 5185, 2 ], [ 20097, 1 ], [ 5459, 1 ], [ 2814, 5 ], [ 12648, 2 ], [ 8898, 3 ], [ 6418, 3 ], [ 9318, 5 ], [ 6207, 18 ], [ 6207, 9 ], [ 2775, 2 ], [ 16259, 10 ], [ 3793, 6 ], [ 17628, 2 ], [ 5564, 1 ], [ 1359, 2 ], [ 9747, 3 ], [ 14321, 3 ], [ 937, 0 ], [ 1206, 0 ], [ 19366, 3 ], [ 3148, 2 ], [ 13669, 0 ], [ 11304, 6 ], [ 5611, 0 ], [ 17629, 6 ], [ 8871, 12 ], [ 19813, 7 ], [ 13560, 0 ], [ 5956, 1 ], [ 15457, 4 ], [ 12926, 4 ], [ 10527, 2 ], [ 19269, 0 ], [ 15020, 5 ], [ 569, 5 ], [ 11885, 2 ], [ 11198, 7 ], [ 18231, 1 ], [ 1170, 4 ], [ 10098, 0 ], [ 17563, 0 ], [ 15063, 4 ], [ 4579, 0 ], [ 15442, 3 ], [ 13349, 7 ], [ 19349, 5 ], [ 1819, 5 ], [ 723, 3 ], [ 10672, 1 ], [ 1089, 17 ], [ 9783, 4 ], [ 11234, 8 ], [ 7607, 0 ], [ 13070, 2 ], [ 14768, 10 ], [ 9628, 2 ], [ 7643, 0 ], [ 12633, 3 ], [ 9120, 12 ], [ 13498, 1 ], [ 5961, 2 ], [ 5676, 11 ], [ 12649, 2 ], [ 270, 3 ], [ 1819, 6 ], [ 13274, 6 ], [ 13800, 2 ], [ 11274, 9 ], [ 12434, 4 ], [ 19315, 5 ], [ 15442, 1 ], [ 16464, 17 ], [ 6239, 3 ], [ 53, 5 ], [ 5251, 4 ], [ 1489, 6 ], [ 16860, 1 ], [ 4699, 3 ], [ 13126, 3 ], [ 270, 7 ], [ 18800, 3 ], [ 9893, 2 ], [ 6759, 0 ], [ 2553, 6 ], [ 16128, 2 ], [ 10844, 12 ], [ 6385, 1 ], [ 6239, 0 ], [ 2302, 2 ], [ 5779, 4 ], [ 4190, 1 ], [ 19680, 2 ], [ 16584, 1 ], [ 10255, 2 ], [ 11890, 1 ], [ 11128, 10 ], [ 480, 6 ], [ 16379, 4 ], [ 10928, 4 ], [ 12182, 12 ], [ 13182, 0 ], [ 6844, 0 ], [ 16467, 4 ], [ 5276, 4 ], [ 190, 10 ], [ 19956, 1 ], [ 5741, 0 ], [ 18046, 0 ], [ 15749, 1 ], [ 8501, 5 ], [ 575, 1 ], [ 5794, 3 ], [ 6996, 4 ], [ 13522, 5 ], [ 19382, 0 ] ] }, "gpu": "NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4090", "protocol": "Same-input generative baselines vs Laya-Android: latency and AndroidControl-High Type / Grounding.\n\npython scripts/bench_llm_baselines.py --out results/baselines/same_input_1000.json\nSubset: 1,000 steps sampled (seed 0) from the 8,444 official test steps; identical for every model.\nInput for every model: goal + last 3 gold actions + the same accessibility-derived candidates (src/serialization.py).\nLLMs (zero-shot, greedy, batch 1) must answer {\"operation\": ..., \"target\": index}. Laya-Android answers both questions\nin one forward pass. Latency = tokenization + model call (+ generation), CUDA-synchronized, after 20 warm-up steps.\nScoring: unmodified InfiGUI-R1 judge via scripts/evaluate_androidcontrol.to_reference.", "models": { "Laya-Android (322M)": { "params_b": 0.32, "type": 77.2, "grounding": 62.8, "unparseable": 0, "latency_ms": { "median": 38.7, "p95": 47.5, "mean": 39.8 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 0, "peak_vram_gb": 1.73 }, "ollama:qwen3.5:9b-fit": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "9.7B", "quantization": "Q4_K_M", "family": "qwen35", "type": 63.6, "grounding": 51.6, "unparseable": 9, "latency_ms": { "median": 228.6, "p95": 273.2, "mean": 231.2 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 14.0, "mean_input_tokens": 407.5 }, "ollama:gemma4:fit": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "8.0B", "quantization": "Q4_K_M", "family": "gemma4", "type": 57.4, "grounding": 45.0, "unparseable": 2, "latency_ms": { "median": 171.1, "p95": 202.2, "mean": 172.4 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 14.1, "mean_input_tokens": 408.8 }, "ollama:ministral-3:14b": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "13.9B", "quantization": "Q4_K_M", "family": "mistral3", "type": 53.2, "grounding": 42.0, "unparseable": 4, "latency_ms": { "median": 285.3, "p95": 424.2, "mean": 301.2 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 19.8, "mean_input_tokens": 401.3 }, "ollama:gemma4:26b": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "25.2B", "quantization": "Q4_K_M", "family": "gemma4", "type": 64.8, "grounding": 56.6, "unparseable": 2, "latency_ms": { "median": 201.1, "p95": 256.3, "mean": 211.9 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 14.1, "mean_input_tokens": 412.8 }, "ollama:qwen3.8:27b": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "27.3B", "quantization": "Q4_K_M", "family": "qwen35", "type": 76.8, "grounding": 64.5, "unparseable": 0, "latency_ms": { "median": 574.7, "p95": 693.9, "mean": 585.3 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 13.4, "mean_input_tokens": 407.5 }, "ollama:qwen3.5:0.8b": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "752.39M", "quantization": "Q8_0", "family": "qwen35", "type": 41.3, "grounding": 0.0, "unparseable": 5, "latency_ms": { "median": 124.5, "p95": 158.4, "mean": 127.6 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 15.0, "mean_input_tokens": 407.5, "think": false, "num_predict": 32 }, "ollama:qwen3.5:2b": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "1.9B", "quantization": "Q8_0", "family": "qwen35", "type": 57.4, "grounding": 24.5, "unparseable": 3, "latency_ms": { "median": 126.1, "p95": 143.8, "mean": 125.8 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 13.5, "mean_input_tokens": 407.5, "think": false, "num_predict": 32 }, "ollama:qwen3.5:4b": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "4.2B", "quantization": "Q4_K_M", "family": "qwen35", "type": 67.3, "grounding": 52.8, "unparseable": 0, "latency_ms": { "median": 192.9, "p95": 251.5, "mean": 197.8 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 15.6, "mean_input_tokens": 407.5, "think": false, "num_predict": 32 }, "ollama:gemma4:e2b": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "4.6B", "quantization": "Q4_K_M", "family": "gemma4", "type": 56.9, "grounding": 22.7, "unparseable": 2, "latency_ms": { "median": 115.6, "p95": 139.4, "mean": 116.9 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 15.4, "mean_input_tokens": 408.8, "think": false, "num_predict": 32 }, "ollama:gemma4:e4b": { "serving": "Ollama 0.34.0 (GGUF)", "params": "7.5B", "quantization": "Q4_K_M", "family": "gemma4", "type": 57.1, "grounding": 44.1, "unparseable": 3, "latency_ms": { "median": 145.7, "p95": 174.9, "mean": 146.7 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 14.1, "mean_input_tokens": 408.8, "think": false, "num_predict": 32 }, "Qwen/Qwen3.5-0.8B": { "serving": "vLLM 0.31.0 (Docker)", "type": 40.9, "grounding": 0.4, "unparseable": 4, "latency_ms": { "median": 125.3, "p95": 178.2, "mean": 131.4 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 14.6, "mean_input_tokens": 407.5, "gpu_memory_used_mb_incl_kv_cache_reservation": 21355 }, "Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B": { "serving": "vLLM 0.31.0 (Docker)", "type": 57.5, "grounding": 23.0, "unparseable": 4, "latency_ms": { "median": 149.4, "p95": 201.9, "mean": 154.6 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 13.2, "mean_input_tokens": 407.5, "gpu_memory_used_mb_incl_kv_cache_reservation": 20999 }, "Qwen/Qwen3.5-4B": { "serving": "vLLM 0.31.0 (Docker)", "type": 67.1, "grounding": 50.5, "unparseable": 0, "latency_ms": { "median": 242.5, "p95": 304.8, "mean": 250.2 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 15.4, "mean_input_tokens": 407.5, "gpu_memory_used_mb_incl_kv_cache_reservation": 21087 }, "google/gemma-4-E2B-it": { "serving": "vLLM 0.31.0 (Docker)", "type": 58.4, "grounding": 23.6, "unparseable": 4, "latency_ms": { "median": 154.7, "p95": 209.8, "mean": 159.3 }, "mean_generated_tokens": 15.4, "mean_input_tokens": 409.8, "gpu_memory_used_mb_incl_kv_cache_reservation": 22463 } } }