{ "complete": true, "scope": "frozen v3 test evaluation of every formal adapter and matched base", "protocol": { "test_revision": "ba161c6fbb2829631ac9fef67ea296f0c4c1fbc4", "test_items_per_behavior": 400, "tasks": { "color": 200, "count": 200 }, "conditions": [ "original", "treatment", "control" ], "generation": "greedy, max_new_tokens=12, original alone; treatment/control paired", "dtype": "float16", "preprocessing": "original backbone-specific infer.py protocol", "runtime_fix": "cuDNN SDPA disabled for all evaluation models per updated GitHub", "evaluation_source_commit": "f0b8f2b91e412311052bbf92b674231df56d285e", "training_source_commit": "52dd2b32d33fce9d26ae143868bc28f78c01d84b", "training_parameters_frozen": true, "test_set_used_for_parameter_selection": false, "uploads_required": false, "primary_metrics": "matched effects and paired gains, Color/Count equally weighted", "secondary_metrics": "original-image accuracy, top-answer share, abstention", "ci_resamples": { "matched_effects": 10000, "single_layer_gain": 2000, "placement_and_joint": 3000 } }, "validated_inference_jobs": 162, "validated_records": 64800, "formal_adapters": 147, "analyses": { "joint_qwen_removal": { "behavior": "removal", "arms": { "Joint": { "color": { "gain": 17.166666666666668, "ci95": [ 10.76335406793049, 23.880597014925375 ] }, "count": { "gain": 2.8333333333333335, "ci95": [ -0.9524948735475052, 6.666666666666667 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 10.0, "ci95": [ 6.417576413464781, 13.700670858980695 ] }, "runs": 3 } }, "contrasts": {} }, "joint_qwen_replacement": { "behavior": "replacement", "arms": { "Joint": { "color": { "gain": 1.3333333333333333, "ci95": [ -2.0345884832806362, 4.975124378109453 ] }, "count": { "gain": 0.3333333333333335, "ci95": [ -4.568527918781726, 4.912280701754386 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 0.8333333333333334, "ci95": [ -2.377475578750167, 4.0000100010001 ] }, "runs": 3 } }, "contrasts": {} }, "joint_qwen_context": { "behavior": "context", "arms": { "Joint": { "color": { "gain": -1.3333333333333333, "ci95": [ -4.340466485507246, 1.6026069518716577 ] }, "count": { "gain": -0.6666666666666666, "ci95": [ -4.035087719298246, 2.680269627708435 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -3.3041347979672726, 1.2403811824635946 ] }, "runs": 3 } }, "contrasts": {} }, "fixed_internvl_removal": { "behavior": "removal", "arms": { "Deep8": { "color": { "gain": 10.166666666666666, "ci95": [ 4.537149096266674, 15.781662433388119 ] }, "count": { "gain": 5.333333333333333, "ci95": [ 0.0, 10.72728106143948 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 7.75, "ci95": [ 3.916349296128708, 11.591823277769754 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Full": { "color": { "gain": 9.333333333333334, "ci95": [ 3.7233612201335817, 15.183566882250283 ] }, "count": { "gain": 9.166666666666666, "ci95": [ 4.323476942288824, 14.361775596567533 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 9.25, "ci95": [ 5.482616495413512, 13.075335023803161 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Middle8": { "color": { "gain": 12.166666666666666, "ci95": [ 6.7306957186544345, 17.894823265059202 ] }, "count": { "gain": 8.333333333333334, "ci95": [ 3.2783364317503243, 13.756986362620168 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 10.25, "ci95": [ 6.360450609418865, 14.26668681251842 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Random8": { "color": { "gain": 9.95, "ci95": [ 3.951123234916559, 16.048490427098677 ] }, "count": { "gain": 8.7, "ci95": [ 3.9285246821241584, 14.077718205091049 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 9.325, "ci95": [ 5.38261732847098, 13.281660126767152 ] }, "runs": 10 }, "Shallow8": { "color": { "gain": 10.833333333333334, "ci95": [ 5.102603605634744, 16.838625063976018 ] }, "count": { "gain": 7.333333333333333, "ci95": [ 1.9999231950844854, 12.908993036466924 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 9.083333333333334, "ci95": [ 5.151902337103394, 13.160007402628557 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Top8": { "color": { "gain": 10.5, "ci95": [ 4.614942528735632, 16.26428097167846 ] }, "count": { "gain": 7.833333333333333, "ci95": [ 2.897635778070561, 13.089161057092996 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 9.166666666666666, "ci95": [ 5.217074793047767, 13.128772781465317 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "TopDelta8": { "color": { "gain": 11.833333333333334, "ci95": [ 6.292517006802721, 17.51297738227661 ] }, "count": { "gain": 8.5, "ci95": [ 3.7037037037037037, 13.592741320591674 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 10.166666666666666, "ci95": [ 6.272588456853881, 13.977588910057953 ] }, "runs": 3 } }, "contrasts": { "Top8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 0.5500000000000007, "ci95": [ -2.181528835236759, 3.200743853547795 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.8666666666666663, "ci95": [ -3.832101237864477, 1.9146118721461194 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.15833333333333321, "ci95": [ -2.281880436956537, 1.9427180643443083 ] } }, "TopDelta8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 1.8833333333333346, "ci95": [ -0.5586611938528271, 4.410613529614792 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.1999999999999993, "ci95": [ -3.093110380116958, 2.729087602783051 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.8416666666666668, "ci95": [ -0.9637530638165153, 2.8065518555178453 ] } }, "Shallow8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 0.8833333333333346, "ci95": [ -2.079517704517706, 4.029173252050881 ] }, "count": { "difference": -1.3666666666666663, "ci95": [ -4.640565650343903, 1.6243967392663345 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.24166666666666536, "ci95": [ -2.327714592834495, 1.9401803985788748 ] } }, "Middle8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 2.216666666666667, "ci95": [ 0.055489417989417845, 4.628924648223668 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.36666666666666536, "ci95": [ -3.621885738831616, 2.7726371951219524 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.9250000000000007, "ci95": [ -1.18797866186717, 3.0659404566424278 ] } }, "Deep8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 0.21666666666666679, "ci95": [ -2.68340210355987, 3.155196264111707 ] }, "count": { "difference": -3.3666666666666663, "ci95": [ -7.067083333333334, 0.10530537573881361 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -1.5749999999999993, "ci95": [ -3.9747666664836414, 0.7099735526578647 ] } }, "Top8-Shallow8": { "color": { "difference": -0.3333333333333339, "ci95": [ -3.166666666666666, 2.475247524752475 ] }, "count": { "difference": 0.5, "ci95": [ -1.9419843713000227, 3.4050179211469533 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.08333333333333215, "ci95": [ -1.8518795120736862, 2.1669680102528024 ] } }, "Deep8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 0.8333333333333321, "ci95": [ -2.3809523809523796, 4.051799085733517 ] }, "count": { "difference": -3.833333333333333, "ci95": [ -7.741522152807696, -0.17262390082673582 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -1.5, "ci95": [ -3.862156197590915, 0.8220405373870728 ] } }, "Middle8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 2.833333333333332, "ci95": [ 0.341793570219965, 5.666666666666666 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.8333333333333321, "ci95": [ -4.477851128970534, 2.4062436253510975 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 1.0, "ci95": [ -1.2043076726577198, 3.107975547150466 ] } }, "Random8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 0.6166666666666654, "ci95": [ -1.3499999999999996, 3.0694619185675487 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.4666666666666668, "ci95": [ -3.333758503401361, 1.96538709875784 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.07499999999999929, "ci95": [ -1.629657520345539, 1.512899304749076 ] } }, "Shallow8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 1.5, "ci95": [ -1.629649758454108, 4.975124378109451 ] }, "count": { "difference": -1.833333333333333, "ci95": [ -5.218952194758646, 1.258161126085656 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.16666666666666607, "ci95": [ -2.3435467387311233, 1.995625026660409 ] } }, "Top8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 1.166666666666666, "ci95": [ -1.7242123756774457, 4.355108877721944 ] }, "count": { "difference": -1.333333333333333, "ci95": [ -4.431624851391792, 1.738383309029046 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.08333333333333393, "ci95": [ -2.152799599172603, 2.0720516281469554 ] } }, "TopDelta8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 2.5, "ci95": [ 1.7763568394002505e-15, 5.034870426829269 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.6666666666666661, "ci95": [ -3.780161604903872, 2.3150839793281666 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.9166666666666661, "ci95": [ -0.898544170848408, 2.7615857987030425 ] } } } }, "fixed_internvl_replacement": { "behavior": "replacement", "arms": { "Deep8": { "color": { "gain": 5.5, "ci95": [ 2.1975709475709477, 9.153808195258971 ] }, "count": { "gain": 0.6666666666666666, "ci95": [ -4.283120510774142, 5.699597314196522 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.0833333333333335, "ci95": [ 0.041972000238318305, 6.1282139502268365 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Full": { "color": { "gain": 5.833333333333333, "ci95": [ 2.4560113519091846, 9.479161358270058 ] }, "count": { "gain": 0.6666666666666666, "ci95": [ -4.715958061219957, 6.250560035842296 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.25, "ci95": [ 0.03493230625583557, 6.558021532610946 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Middle8": { "color": { "gain": 6.166666666666667, "ci95": [ 2.640046899426785, 10.047846889952153 ] }, "count": { "gain": 0.0, "ci95": [ -5.5555555555555545, 5.641093474426809 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.0833333333333335, "ci95": [ -0.1524001016193441, 6.519581833336135 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Random8": { "color": { "gain": 5.05, "ci95": [ 1.8817071223251354, 8.398106796116503 ] }, "count": { "gain": 0.8, "ci95": [ -4.0308084772370485, 5.868597155069721 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.925, "ci95": [ -0.028902785810680506, 5.880289649718909 ] }, "runs": 10 }, "Shallow8": { "color": { "gain": 4.5, "ci95": [ 1.0415317357512954, 8.243819975612459 ] }, "count": { "gain": 0.3333333333333333, "ci95": [ -5.263854079643553, 6.122896527031868 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.4166666666666665, "ci95": [ -0.9788146698554657, 5.777629470307291 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Top8": { "color": { "gain": 4.833333333333333, "ci95": [ 1.4771185835653606, 8.421908429610614 ] }, "count": { "gain": -0.16666666666666666, "ci95": [ -5.729916557591623, 5.492762445887447 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.3333333333333335, "ci95": [ -0.916828529657477, 5.568640197353072 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "TopDelta8": { "color": { "gain": 6.0, "ci95": [ 2.512562814070352, 9.667063492063493 ] }, "count": { "gain": 0.3333333333333333, "ci95": [ -4.957264957264957, 5.582943662324023 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.1666666666666665, "ci95": [ -0.07104606737497907, 6.437948987509699 ] }, "runs": 3 } }, "contrasts": { "Top8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": -0.21666666666666679, "ci95": [ -1.7863636363636373, 1.2592563621193162 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.9666666666666667, "ci95": [ -3.583524557165861, 1.7464901988953845 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.5916666666666663, "ci95": [ -2.124358758652281, 0.9655486008411758 ] } }, "TopDelta8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 0.9500000000000002, "ci95": [ -2.7755575615619447e-18, 2.349755536381937 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.46666666666666673, "ci95": [ -2.4317695104337864, 1.4085655235762413 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.2416666666666667, "ci95": [ -0.9317343049122525, 1.551202012472187 ] } }, "Shallow8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": -0.5499999999999998, "ci95": [ -2.4752475247524752, 1.1836242138364783 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.46666666666666673, "ci95": [ -3.414695428361319, 2.7127896613190745 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.5083333333333333, "ci95": [ -2.2997894154415555, 1.3372060167433903 ] } }, "Middle8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 1.1166666666666671, "ci95": [ -0.338409475465312, 2.947043066144653 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.8, "ci95": [ -3.4155755768732177, 2.0574264394753117 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.15833333333333366, "ci95": [ -1.300025255127855, 1.886065176539661 ] } }, "Deep8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 0.4500000000000002, "ci95": [ -0.6767266360782422, 1.7058284667353703 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.13333333333333341, "ci95": [ -2.227644288819126, 1.8501392804403283 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.15833333333333366, "ci95": [ -0.9475457822480527, 1.2506931292087544 ] } }, "Top8-Shallow8": { "color": { "difference": 0.33333333333333304, "ci95": [ -0.6472491909385107, 1.4219065480565345 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.5, "ci95": [ -3.0895147095800852, 1.8425460636515916 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.08333333333333304, "ci95": [ -1.4753264033196176, 1.250011198196622 ] } }, "Deep8-Full": { "color": { "difference": -0.33333333333333304, "ci95": [ -1.8518518518518512, 0.9569377990430628 ] }, "count": { "difference": 0.0, "ci95": [ -2.8709550757373354, 2.4179620034542313 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.16666666666666652, "ci95": [ -1.8273203478127629, 1.1345159142640158 ] } }, "Middle8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 0.3333333333333339, "ci95": [ -1.2404549735564718, 2.1166835528537673 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.6666666666666666, "ci95": [ -3.608450042144849, 2.4563131967850667 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.16666666666666652, "ci95": [ -1.7780610883128138, 1.6718349602314826 ] } }, "Random8-Full": { "color": { "difference": -0.7833333333333332, "ci95": [ -2.1539682539682525, 0.09393024815559997 ] }, "count": { "difference": 0.13333333333333341, "ci95": [ -2.425782770584751, 2.3811846689895484 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.3250000000000002, "ci95": [ -1.9248199954998866, 0.8313538662677991 ] } }, "Shallow8-Full": { "color": { "difference": -1.333333333333333, "ci95": [ -3.472304502369669, 0.49757462686567183 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.3333333333333333, "ci95": [ -3.3874103552626122, 2.966841186736475 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.8333333333333335, "ci95": [ -2.727315779882576, 1.011495180903665 ] } }, "Top8-Full": { "color": { "difference": -1.0, "ci95": [ -2.837047494201875, 0.5025125628140703 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.8333333333333333, "ci95": [ -3.426791277258567, 1.9906648078289892 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.9166666666666665, "ci95": [ -2.5295529286117837, 0.7356618762855107 ] } }, "TopDelta8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 0.16666666666666696, "ci95": [ -1.0002525252525252, 1.4563327851168058 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.3333333333333333, "ci95": [ -2.724358974358974, 1.8730125079499695 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.08333333333333348, "ci95": [ -1.5632915846466247, 1.261240453313624 ] } } } }, "fixed_internvl_context": { "behavior": "context", "arms": { "Deep8": { "color": { "gain": 0.6666666666666666, "ci95": [ -2.8851495726495724, 4.30134274862248 ] }, "count": { "gain": 6.0, "ci95": [ -0.3089387464387463, 12.440634414318627 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.3333333333333335, "ci95": [ -0.14629087479152567, 6.896319368090022 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Full": { "color": { "gain": -1.3333333333333333, "ci95": [ -5.235845713627626, 2.525252525252525 ] }, "count": { "gain": 6.166666666666667, "ci95": [ 0.1593250223139166, 12.439365671641797 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.4166666666666665, "ci95": [ -1.0492949917524397, 6.024416320892247 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Middle8": { "color": { "gain": -1.1666666666666667, "ci95": [ -5.090369002006933, 2.551677887649907 ] }, "count": { "gain": 5.833333333333333, "ci95": [ -0.15515003152702056, 11.800633309566754 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.3333333333333335, "ci95": [ -1.1875944213336809, 5.952674244050197 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Random8": { "color": { "gain": -1.35, "ci95": [ -5.240502450980392, 2.376411122420653 ] }, "count": { "gain": 5.5, "ci95": [ -0.5127975549332181, 11.65011934386268 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.075, "ci95": [ -1.4575639045988473, 5.653853078777224 ] }, "runs": 10 }, "Shallow8": { "color": { "gain": -1.6666666666666667, "ci95": [ -5.650520030816641, 2.041077969649399 ] }, "count": { "gain": 8.0, "ci95": [ 1.1709938581797883, 15.13607496138552 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.1666666666666665, "ci95": [ -0.7516368938263859, 7.30842545834873 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "Top8": { "color": { "gain": -1.1666666666666667, "ci95": [ -5.0, 2.6604251737230493 ] }, "count": { "gain": 7.333333333333333, "ci95": [ 1.2930001198609617, 13.70608141733851 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.0833333333333335, "ci95": [ -0.38387615699588057, 6.626760928184765 ] }, "runs": 3 }, "TopDelta8": { "color": { "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -5.009047829822689, 2.7178325901152003 ] }, "count": { "gain": 6.166666666666667, "ci95": [ 0.0, 12.661406765676572 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.5833333333333335, "ci95": [ -1.0620537828110266, 6.287815742174594 ] }, "runs": 3 } }, "contrasts": { "Top8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 0.18333333333333335, "ci95": [ -2.160848960248397, 2.364025682736864 ] }, "count": { "difference": 1.833333333333333, "ci95": [ -1.2166732804232814, 5.50582260267291 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 1.0083333333333333, "ci95": [ -0.8398903832366266, 2.9564089965896843 ] } }, "TopDelta8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 0.3500000000000001, "ci95": [ -1.4716913468049464, 2.1976762207848584 ] }, "count": { "difference": 0.666666666666667, "ci95": [ -2.492174857724686, 4.010644745814078 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.5083333333333333, "ci95": [ -1.4081065709933367, 2.507500587254224 ] } }, "Shallow8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": -0.31666666666666665, "ci95": [ -3.317155993278566, 2.921225885475147 ] }, "count": { "difference": 2.5, "ci95": [ -2.0037219970730615, 7.081490686115112 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 1.0916666666666663, "ci95": [ -1.890742755680293, 4.073317216367707 ] } }, "Middle8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 0.18333333333333335, "ci95": [ -2.1770606300772735, 2.1987757514353268 ] }, "count": { "difference": 0.33333333333333304, "ci95": [ -2.908586511527689, 3.6753663003663 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.2583333333333333, "ci95": [ -1.876531954887218, 2.247400161900185 ] } }, "Deep8-Random8": { "color": { "difference": 2.0166666666666666, "ci95": [ -0.862992179997256, 5.200811991162236 ] }, "count": { "difference": 0.5, "ci95": [ -3.760459056186194, 4.877094393164028 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 1.2583333333333333, "ci95": [ -1.2798553307024108, 3.905312345388439 ] } }, "Top8-Shallow8": { "color": { "difference": 0.5, "ci95": [ -2.623659844054581, 3.4017966160823323 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.666666666666667, "ci95": [ -5.664223219658161, 4.592425431711148 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.08333333333333304, "ci95": [ -3.2126736137582186, 2.9376729918440287 ] } }, "Deep8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 2.0, "ci95": [ -0.9760951340856691, 5.263381668456858 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.16666666666666696, "ci95": [ -4.598006847640008, 4.146455223880598 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.916666666666667, "ci95": [ -1.5576810891528263, 3.418970352564103 ] } }, "Middle8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 0.16666666666666652, "ci95": [ -2.427480464125029, 2.5516571362844678 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.3333333333333339, "ci95": [ -4.085338680926918, 3.2815836715247113 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.08333333333333304, "ci95": [ -2.33340673272612, 1.9279814647004245 ] } }, "Random8-Full": { "color": { "difference": -0.01666666666666683, "ci95": [ -1.8790123917587334, 1.7173896323642523 ] }, "count": { "difference": -0.666666666666667, "ci95": [ -3.688064942288972, 2.397506105540414 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": -0.34166666666666634, "ci95": [ -1.9993687147141845, 1.3131350530382426 ] } }, "Shallow8-Full": { "color": { "difference": -0.3333333333333335, "ci95": [ -3.465777547904044, 3.0748924031628486 ] }, "count": { "difference": 1.833333333333333, "ci95": [ -3.151305970149254, 7.193224896411884 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.75, "ci95": [ -2.329369379284607, 3.9194275271084056 ] } }, "Top8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 0.16666666666666652, "ci95": [ -2.39298493525382, 2.4756716325838206 ] }, "count": { "difference": 1.166666666666666, "ci95": [ -2.469596462133776, 5.1158288905813665 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.666666666666667, "ci95": [ -1.4385378065395786, 2.642019828518 ] } }, "TopDelta8-Full": { "color": { "difference": 0.33333333333333326, "ci95": [ -1.5708872967759713, 2.1835347654124955 ] }, "count": { "difference": 0.0, "ci95": [ -3.61292656359232, 3.6088003130209954 ] }, "behavior": { "difference": 0.16666666666666696, "ci95": [ -1.8426120250215976, 2.082723897389739 ] } } } }, "single_internvl_removal": { "behavior": "removal", "runs": [ { "layer": 1, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -0.5, "ci95": [ -4.371584699453552, 3.5916230366492043 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 9.95260663507109 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.25, "ci95": [ -0.8067265712179895, 5.422825376773071 ] } }, { "layer": 2, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 1.0, "ci95": [ -2.689149560117302, 5.025644276428009 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ -1.0418030104712042, 8.45087940578796 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.25, "ci95": [ -0.741377665288737, 5.354181079244707 ] } }, { "layer": 7, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 8.5, "ci95": [ 2.2337160046657254, 14.438811783252449 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 10.309278350515465 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 6.75, "ci95": [ 2.7626606399757736, 10.758627872651084 ] } }, { "layer": 9, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.0, "ci95": [ -1.0050251256281406, 10.796186738519209 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 6.0, "ci95": [ 1.0415317357512954, 11.112403100775186 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 5.5, "ci95": [ 1.6650991548451843, 9.48074463899272 ] } }, { "layer": 11, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 9.0, "ci95": [ 3.4995646766169153, 14.438811783252449 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.5, "ci95": [ 0.5460847575863272, 10.312209898861568 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 7.25, "ci95": [ 3.7335642023222713, 10.937554178224687 ] } }, { "layer": 16, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 7.000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.9998756218905472, 13.170731707317072 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 7.5, "ci95": [ 2.55069667460893, 12.821428571428568 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 7.25, "ci95": [ 3.473338104337174, 11.41884378260093 ] } }, { "layer": 20, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 8.5, "ci95": [ 2.984339386809794, 14.045579018688946 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 8.5, "ci95": [ 3.979119182413058, 13.334224598930478 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 8.5, "ci95": [ 4.9918503381439425, 12.470606629143212 ] } }, { "layer": 25, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 7.000000000000001, "ci95": [ 1.075125064688632, 13.298758865248221 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 7.5, "ci95": [ 1.5147727272727274, 13.021399456521737 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 7.25, "ci95": [ 3.1573756909695843, 11.548631821036997 ] } }, { "layer": 29, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 7.5, "ci95": [ 2.0613296865137807, 13.208046321253866 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 7.5, "ci95": [ 1.8957345971563981, 12.82079646017699 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 7.5, "ci95": [ 3.544871871150046, 11.536953773471842 ] } }, { "layer": 34, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 9.0, "ci95": [ 4.2105263157894735, 14.079263508875151 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ -1.5625, 8.629441624365482 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 6.25, "ci95": [ 2.6447498748085305, 9.89256471681922 ] } } ], "layers": [ 1, 2, 7, 9, 11, 16, 20, 25, 29, 34 ], "layer_gain": [ 2.25, 2.25, 6.75, 5.5, 7.25, 7.25, 8.5, 7.25, 7.5, 6.25 ], "spearman_gamma_gain": -0.5662208585049305 }, "single_internvl_replacement": { "behavior": "replacement", "runs": [ { "layer": 1, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.9659524304833229, 6.566489770804488 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -2.0, "ci95": [ -6.418376034267166, 2.0730814095434416 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 0.7500000000000002, "ci95": [ -1.904864949776407, 3.3343535310393158 ] } }, { "layer": 2, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.0, "ci95": [ 1.0415317357512954, 7.281553398058253 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -2.5, "ci95": [ -6.372549019607843, 1.5003787878787858 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 0.75, "ci95": [ -1.7565732484240026, 3.340770753133655 ] } }, { "layer": 7, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.0, "ci95": [ 1.0415317357512954, 7.281553398058253 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -5.612244897959184, 3.333732057416266 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 1.5, "ci95": [ -1.2689268895210943, 4.266941740931832 ] } }, { "layer": 9, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.5, "ci95": [ 1.5075376884422111, 8.001005025125624 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -6.122448979591836, 3.865676917638736 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 1.75, "ci95": [ -1.115608798189774, 4.709702006909681 ] } }, { "layer": 11, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.5492277992277993, 6.63265306122449 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -6.350050658561297, 4.040404040404041 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 1.2500000000000002, "ci95": [ -1.6821572564404461, 4.2092315938910945 ] } }, { "layer": 16, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 6.0, "ci95": [ 2.5122487437185934, 9.743589743589743 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 0.5, "ci95": [ -4.976374409360234, 5.7976765585461205 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.25, "ci95": [ 0.07943779537896004, 6.524006038701953 ] } }, { "layer": 20, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.5, "ci95": [ 2.116123642439432, 9.090909090909092 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 1.0, "ci95": [ -4.478171641791044, 6.436444017536078 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.25, "ci95": [ -0.0009716893603148982, 6.62662292928895 ] } }, { "layer": 25, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.5, "ci95": [ 1.4851485148514851, 7.870655446086479 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 0.5, "ci95": [ -4.976374409360234, 5.7976765585461205 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.5, "ci95": [ -0.6082272139162945, 5.660514010539885 ] } }, { "layer": 29, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.8766440131032127, 6.567331478045754 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.5, "ci95": [ -6.666666666666667, 3.3828857630008455 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 1.0000000000000002, "ci95": [ -1.972781046881313, 3.8965921868572906 ] } }, { "layer": 34, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ 0.8766440131032127, 6.567331478045754 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -0.5, "ci95": [ -4.787234042553192, 3.684271161775406 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 1.5000000000000002, "ci95": [ -1.0660448389882267, 4.095679921546328 ] } } ], "layers": [ 1, 2, 7, 9, 11, 16, 20, 25, 29, 34 ], "layer_gain": [ 0.7500000000000002, 0.75, 1.5, 1.75, 1.2500000000000002, 3.25, 3.25, 2.5, 1.0000000000000002, 1.5000000000000002 ], "spearman_gamma_gain": -0.4012176588288426 }, "single_internvl_context": { "behavior": "context", "runs": [ { "layer": 1, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -4.285714285714286, 2.0103040454799235 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 6.5, "ci95": [ 0.0, 13.461787564766839 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.75, "ci95": [ -0.9800188879127214, 6.555780578057806 ] } }, { "layer": 2, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -0.5, "ci95": [ -3.0303030303030303, 2.304414149172212 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 7.000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.529030910609858, 13.588191699604737 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.2500000000000004, "ci95": [ -0.11554094741067852, 6.813306330633063 ] } }, { "layer": 7, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -2.0, "ci95": [ -5.26379048582996, 0.970873786407767 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 7.000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 14.57286432160804 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ -1.2755678320738824, 6.4819444444444425 ] } }, { "layer": 9, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -4.306737670224512, 2.0204583910167653 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.5, "ci95": [ -1.7275461106655972, 11.458956339712916 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 1.75, "ci95": [ -1.7086297740999141, 5.441599359855966 ] } }, { "layer": 11, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -2.0, "ci95": [ -5.208938953488372, 0.9526098901098888 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.0, "ci95": [ -2.9275501622011295, 11.822792520790296 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 1.0, "ci95": [ -2.9426614935162325, 5.126663050541317 ] } }, { "layer": 16, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.5, "ci95": [ -4.7368421052631575, 1.087105013067236 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 6.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 13.147589239138524 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.25, "ci95": [ -1.1105623381637695, 6.108861758763935 ] } }, { "layer": 20, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.5, "ci95": [ -4.7368421052631575, 1.087105013067236 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.5, "ci95": [ -1.5465920623898297, 11.283505154639169 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 1.5, "ci95": [ -1.9800744163479962, 5.112937480623073 ] } }, { "layer": 25, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -4.2867445054945055, 2.000251256281406 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.5, "ci95": [ -0.9902221565440126, 12.386568902410033 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.25, "ci95": [ -1.2933704860056685, 5.923184095302921 ] } }, { "layer": 29, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -0.5, "ci95": [ -3.4482758620689653, 1.9233091787439602 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -3.8109040717736367, 9.944823696161523 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 1.25, "ci95": [ -2.252752299343037, 5.000559454785878 ] } }, { "layer": 34, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.5, "ci95": [ -5.377403464166534, 2.5255729887709566 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 7.000000000000001, "ci95": [ 0.0, 14.436242618356504 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.7500000000000004, "ci95": [ -1.1416853126282702, 6.977125546464398 ] } } ], "layers": [ 1, 2, 7, 9, 11, 16, 20, 25, 29, 34 ], "layer_gain": [ 2.75, 3.2500000000000004, 2.5000000000000004, 1.75, 1.0, 2.25, 1.5, 2.25, 1.25, 2.7500000000000004 ], "spearman_gamma_gain": -0.40729671426564323 }, "single_llava_removal": { "behavior": "removal", "runs": [ { "layer": 1, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 13.0, "ci95": [ 7.034296482412061, 18.906769470184614 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.5, "ci95": [ -0.5025760113699812, 11.483672248803826 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 9.25, "ci95": [ 5.142881597138968, 13.636871325705943 ] } }, { "layer": 2, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 12.5, "ci95": [ 5.6980204596784905, 20.21276595744681 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 0.0, "ci95": [ -6.167400881057269, 6.598984771573604 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 6.25, "ci95": [ 1.6090638525344352, 11.239593392046283 ] } }, { "layer": 6, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 15.5, "ci95": [ 9.895833333333334, 21.579674689235645 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.0, "ci95": [ -0.5559350333940493, 11.000229357798164 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 10.25, "ci95": [ 6.217265689904091, 14.493690890990543 ] } }, { "layer": 8, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 16.5, "ci95": [ 10.144927536231885, 23.189264372553055 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 2.0, "ci95": [ -3.175146771037182, 7.620879120879111 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 9.25, "ci95": [ 5.1586331095872895, 13.585090843405434 ] } }, { "layer": 10, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 18.0, "ci95": [ 11.650485436893204, 24.726301735647525 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.5, "ci95": [ -0.5524861878453039, 10.054112554112546 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 11.25, "ci95": [ 7.115203128628778, 15.669871857280869 ] } }, { "layer": 14, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 16.5, "ci95": [ 10.76829268292683, 22.748815165876778 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.5, "ci95": [ -1.5001884422110552, 10.606060606060606 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 10.5, "ci95": [ 6.452646768436243, 14.983362424869926 ] } }, { "layer": 18, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 13.0, "ci95": [ 6.498790322580645, 19.474937343358388 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.5, "ci95": [ -1.5001884422110552, 10.550516343183808 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 8.75, "ci95": [ 4.36626958475698, 13.041379126693098 ] } }, { "layer": 22, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 15.0, "ci95": [ 8.808290155440414, 21.634615384615383 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 6.0, "ci95": [ 0.5126903553299492, 11.558699293569292 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 10.5, "ci95": [ 6.497500148216218, 14.925461449806292 ] } }, { "layer": 26, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 11.0, "ci95": [ 5.290941697191697, 17.18836805555555 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 2.0, "ci95": [ -3.5175879396984926, 7.368939590355195 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 6.5, "ci95": [ 2.6321138211382116, 10.546899293754509 ] } }, { "layer": 30, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 15.0, "ci95": [ 8.910631900886424, 21.31997738590709 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.5, "ci95": [ -0.975609756097561, 10.153331526292439 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 9.75, "ci95": [ 5.611576437951277, 14.282649948085417 ] } } ], "layers": [ 1, 2, 6, 8, 10, 14, 18, 22, 26, 30 ], "layer_gain": [ 9.25, 6.25, 10.25, 9.25, 11.25, 10.5, 8.75, 10.5, 6.5, 9.75 ] }, "single_llava_replacement": { "behavior": "replacement", "runs": [ { "layer": 1, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.0, "ci95": [ 0.5050505050505051, 7.651324085750309 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -6.0, "ci95": [ -12.935774495398656, 1.5469989744696897 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -4.976266438879213, 3.0546531505058674 ] } }, { "layer": 2, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.0, "ci95": [ 0.48303372352285395, 7.870655446086479 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -7.000000000000001, "ci95": [ -14.354189669979142, 0.4904411764705869 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -1.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ -5.3814031440538095, 2.7080512007290194 ] } }, { "layer": 6, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.0, "ci95": [ 0.4431818181818188, 7.805068597560974 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -8.0, "ci95": [ -15.657821672219576, 0.0 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -2.0, "ci95": [ -6.17859386804219, 2.296907461640508 ] } }, { "layer": 8, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 2.5, "ci95": [ -1.442481884057971, 6.467661691542289 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -9.5, "ci95": [ -16.582469775474955, -2.0405573396871453 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -3.5, "ci95": [ -7.5131492665535005, 0.613791719025769 ] } }, { "layer": 10, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.0, "ci95": [ 1.0927476835352816, 9.18381136238279 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -4.0, "ci95": [ -11.220714531088973, 3.5723490427098628 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 0.5, "ci95": [ -3.5706329606488394, 4.712367166174262 ] } }, { "layer": 14, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -0.576704545454545, 7.027027027027027 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -10.0, "ci95": [ -17.55477620989968, -2.1273781380164376 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -3.5, "ci95": [ -7.797335793357239, 0.7975996096261714 ] } }, { "layer": 18, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 8.45853280765981 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -7.000000000000001, "ci95": [ -14.136257866624359, 0.5027048507845339 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -1.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ -5.48551157337036, 2.680202128574467 ] } }, { "layer": 22, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 1.5, "ci95": [ -1.6044937036398137, 4.878048780487805 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -6.5, "ci95": [ -14.217436974789916, 1.4564882784750168 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -2.5, "ci95": [ -6.612527369599109, 1.8048049812029971 ] } }, { "layer": 26, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 6.011409506549136 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -4.5, "ci95": [ -11.708751793400287, 3.256578229064304 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -0.75, "ci95": [ -4.5458532695374805, 3.291276580833568 ] } }, { "layer": 30, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 2.0, "ci95": [ -0.9952748818720468, 5.208333333333333 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -3.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ -9.43443161550737, 2.592044301888854 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -0.7500000000000002, "ci95": [ -3.9838911210774635, 2.644496880499118 ] } } ], "layers": [ 1, 2, 6, 8, 10, 14, 18, 22, 26, 30 ], "layer_gain": [ -1.0, -1.5000000000000004, -2.0, -3.5, 0.5, -3.5, -1.5000000000000004, -2.5, -0.75, -0.7500000000000002 ] }, "single_llava_context": { "behavior": "context", "runs": [ { "layer": 1, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -1.442481884057971, 7.575757575757576 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 1.0, "ci95": [ -5.855100324402259, 7.895042839657281 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.0, "ci95": [ -2.047191712236892, 6.097149013672297 ] } }, { "layer": 2, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 2.5, "ci95": [ -2.128231525966598, 7.3040325901523575 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.5000000000000004, "ci95": [ -3.333732057416268, 10.606060606060606 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -1.022802887059845, 7.169356197249638 ] } }, { "layer": 6, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -0.9757293161166906, 6.8631341425459045 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -4.433497536945813, 10.5277081592871 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -1.2488399525333325, 7.152922077865719 ] } }, { "layer": 8, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 2.0, "ci95": [ -2.1052631578947367, 6.315789473684211 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.5, "ci95": [ -2.3006210165059646, 12.935774495398652 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.75, "ci95": [ -0.49279556650246303, 8.069760879156807 ] } }, { "layer": 10, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -5.853658536585366, 3.773839877613461 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 1.5, "ci95": [ -5.670103092783505, 8.719072164948447 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 0.25, "ci95": [ -4.246823119811982, 4.598743639655034 ] } }, { "layer": 14, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 2.0, "ci95": [ -3.1092130829015545, 7.143772893772889 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 4.0, "ci95": [ -2.5387218534426657, 10.68047850208044 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -1.25, 7.214662523777282 ] } }, { "layer": 18, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 1.0, "ci95": [ -4.1894034363247545, 6.522012235088484 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 5.0, "ci95": [ -1.4087844603164006, 11.766154737757164 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -1.1368897306397308, 7.464407135382959 ] } }, { "layer": 22, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 1.0, "ci95": [ -3.500439698492462, 5.613448209472462 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 6.5, "ci95": [ -0.5105379848274388, 14.215686274509803 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 3.75, "ci95": [ -0.4799292429242924, 8.190972176996683 ] } }, { "layer": 26, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": 2.5, "ci95": [ -1.9801980198019802, 6.967101114147562 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": 3.0, "ci95": [ -3.535802184279342, 9.853307163382588 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": 2.75, "ci95": [ -1.1970661826842977, 6.955142240616607 ] } }, { "layer": 30, "seed": 13, "color": { "items": 200, "gain": -0.5, "ci95": [ -4.592425431711146, 3.5714285714285716 ] }, "count": { "items": 200, "gain": -1.0, "ci95": [ -6.599886929535448, 4.712165365998222 ] }, "behavior": { "gain": -0.75, "ci95": [ -4.25, 2.7513551953335282 ] } } ], "layers": [ 1, 2, 6, 8, 10, 14, 18, 22, 26, 30 ], "layer_gain": [ 2.0, 3.0, 3.0, 3.75, 0.25, 3.0, 3.0, 3.75, 2.75, -0.75 ] } }, "uploads_required": false, "llava_gamma_gain_correlation": "Not computed: this experiment has no LLaVA training-localization profile" }