{ "checkpoint_step": 97397, "checkpoint_sha256": "9613d50e7d5cc7e7bf097b13a3987d29d086f82c84596c4a7b35411dcfa92c52", "validation_indices": [ 582, 605, 1659, 477, 97, 1001, 1492, 1850, 520, 543, 1601, 414, 1097, 726, 494, 1178, 755, 46, 837, 158, 1797, 820, 1628, 419, 642, 713, 610, 1212, 533, 1186, 1955, 731, 88, 1166, 829, 40, 296, 938, 1778, 1825, 1226, 1671, 774, 303, 600, 1516, 1966, 111, 586, 462, 1181, 839, 535, 1731, 1600, 769, 1459, 677, 81, 1168, 62, 1469, 1744, 1934 ], "shown_indices": [ 582, 605, 1659, 477, 97, 1001, 1492, 1850 ], "mask_mode": "random", "precision": "FP32", "inference_batch_size": 1, "device": "NVIDIA H100 80GB HBM3", "summary": { "rough": { "l1": 0.021904564389842562, "l2": 0.005303776788878167, "psnr": 24.6804519120106, "ssim": 0.8633151510730386, "hole_l1": 0.08347352084820159, "hole_l2": 0.019533408842107747, "hole_psnr": 18.416342504965336, "hole_fraction": 0.25002217292785645 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.021953618168481626, "l2": 0.0057381069852908695, "psnr": 24.420373515638474, "ssim": 0.8673222148790956, "hole_l1": 0.08344423418748192, "hole_l2": 0.02115398597015883, "hole_psnr": 18.156264090753268, "hole_fraction": 0.25002217292785645 }, "images": 64, "improved_hole_psnr": 13, "improved_hole_l1": 32 }, "protocol": "Fixed 64-record holdout spot check with deterministic masks; not an official benchmark. Validation split is record-level, not content-deduplicated.", "per_image": [ { "validation_index": 582, "rough": { "l1": 0.008401324972510338, "l2": 0.0011387200793251395, "psnr": 29.43583021263471, "ssim": 0.9243270754814148, "hole_l1": 0.03815058618783951, "hole_l2": 0.005170950200408697, "hole_psnr": 22.86429644744242, "hole_fraction": 0.22021484375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.007925714366137981, "l2": 0.0012594984145835042, "psnr": 28.99802374841588, "ssim": 0.9355592727661133, "hole_l1": 0.03599082678556442, "hole_l2": 0.00571940653026104, "hole_psnr": 22.426490330958696, "hole_fraction": 0.22021484375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.43780611648372414 }, { "validation_index": 605, "rough": { "l1": 0.007000061217695475, "l2": 0.0012524938210844994, "psnr": 29.02224407956146, "ssim": 0.9610041975975037, "hole_l1": 0.0332648828625679, "hole_l2": 0.005951956380158663, "hole_psnr": 22.25340260245412, "hole_fraction": 0.2104339599609375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.006424724590033293, "l2": 0.0011647577630355954, "psnr": 29.337643863252993, "ssim": 0.9656614661216736, "hole_l1": 0.030530838295817375, "hole_l2": 0.00553502794355154, "hole_psnr": 22.56880182246938, "hole_fraction": 0.2104339599609375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.31539922001525866 }, { "validation_index": 1659, "rough": { "l1": 0.021098142489790916, "l2": 0.004017828963696957, "psnr": 23.960085548211254, "ssim": 0.8345670700073242, "hole_l1": 0.07903331518173218, "hole_l2": 0.015050726011395454, "hole_psnr": 18.22442550227082, "hole_fraction": 0.2669525146484375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.021535471081733704, "l2": 0.004540577996522188, "psnr": 23.4288885975908, "ssim": 0.8362911343574524, "hole_l1": 0.0806715339422226, "hole_l2": 0.017008936032652855, "hole_psnr": 17.693228521487292, "hole_fraction": 0.2669525146484375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.5311969807835268 }, { "validation_index": 477, "rough": { "l1": 0.025301998481154442, "l2": 0.005398120265454054, "psnr": 22.677574439660106, "ssim": 0.8321418762207031, "hole_l1": 0.122556671500206, "hole_l2": 0.02614716999232769, "hole_psnr": 15.82575309596943, "hole_fraction": 0.206451416015625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.024354472756385803, "l2": 0.005272611975669861, "psnr": 22.779741882790145, "ssim": 0.8407254219055176, "hole_l1": 0.11796709150075912, "hole_l2": 0.02553923800587654, "hole_psnr": 15.927920645816034, "hole_fraction": 0.206451416015625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.10216754984660348 }, { "validation_index": 97, "rough": { "l1": 0.008816254325211048, "l2": 0.001162520726211369, "psnr": 29.345992954711377, "ssim": 0.9220604300498962, "hole_l1": 0.04556281492114067, "hole_l2": 0.006007960997521877, "hole_psnr": 22.21272895347432, "hole_fraction": 0.1934967041015625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.008941390551626682, "l2": 0.0013026646338403225, "psnr": 28.851673773949994, "ssim": 0.925675094127655, "hole_l1": 0.04620952531695366, "hole_l2": 0.00673223240301013, "hole_psnr": 21.718409001824387, "hole_fraction": 0.1934967041015625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.49431995164993126 }, { "validation_index": 1001, "rough": { "l1": 0.058225084096193314, "l2": 0.015888916328549385, "psnr": 17.989057219606572, "ssim": 0.6545725464820862, "hole_l1": 0.14814189076423645, "hole_l2": 0.04042612388730049, "hole_psnr": 13.93337897426063, "hole_fraction": 0.393035888671875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.058986108750104904, "l2": 0.017073960974812508, "psnr": 17.67665715560647, "ssim": 0.6699748039245605, "hole_l1": 0.1500781774520874, "hole_l2": 0.043441228568553925, "hole_psnr": 13.620979008916155, "hole_fraction": 0.393035888671875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.31239996534447556 }, { "validation_index": 1492, "rough": { "l1": 0.01298223901540041, "l2": 0.0014818223426118493, "psnr": 28.2920386130156, "ssim": 0.9175623059272766, "hole_l1": 0.04589761048555374, "hole_l2": 0.005238858051598072, "hole_psnr": 22.807633687295382, "hole_fraction": 0.2828521728515625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.012912414036691189, "l2": 0.001577987801283598, "psnr": 28.018963584496003, "ssim": 0.9180622100830078, "hole_l1": 0.04565075412392616, "hole_l2": 0.0055788434110581875, "hole_psnr": 22.534558283490416, "hole_fraction": 0.2828521728515625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.27307540380496675 }, { "validation_index": 1850, "rough": { "l1": 0.05069633200764656, "l2": 0.012323816306889057, "psnr": 19.092547836997092, "ssim": 0.6865387558937073, "hole_l1": 0.1501801311969757, "hole_l2": 0.03650742396712303, "hole_psnr": 14.376188106091206, "hole_fraction": 0.3375701904296875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.0517975389957428, "l2": 0.01336076483130455, "psnr": 18.741686801458222, "ssim": 0.689080536365509, "hole_l1": 0.15344227850437164, "hole_l2": 0.03957922011613846, "hole_psnr": 14.025327675473713, "hole_fraction": 0.3375701904296875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.3508604306174927 }, { "validation_index": 520, "rough": { "l1": 0.02396816946566105, "l2": 0.007013566792011261, "psnr": 21.540610627558188, "ssim": 0.8697216510772705, "hole_l1": 0.15031367540359497, "hole_l2": 0.043984800577163696, "hole_psnr": 13.56697372737958, "hole_fraction": 0.159454345703125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.02458667755126953, "l2": 0.007283130660653114, "psnr": 21.376818986559677, "ssim": 0.8703622817993164, "hole_l1": 0.15419259667396545, "hole_l2": 0.045675329864025116, "hole_psnr": 13.403183075198452, "hole_fraction": 0.159454345703125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.16379065218112743 }, { "validation_index": 543, "rough": { "l1": 0.015615314245223999, "l2": 0.0021060945000499487, "psnr": 26.765221460045346, "ssim": 0.8362414240837097, "hole_l1": 0.059089165180921555, "hole_l2": 0.007969570346176624, "hole_psnr": 20.98565091566799, "hole_fraction": 0.2642669677734375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.016181955114006996, "l2": 0.0022590477019548416, "psnr": 26.46074598439072, "ssim": 0.8400807976722717, "hole_l1": 0.061233360320329666, "hole_l2": 0.008548355661332607, "hole_psnr": 20.681174169547532, "hole_fraction": 0.2642669677734375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.30447674612045716 }, { "validation_index": 1601, "rough": { "l1": 0.01773962564766407, "l2": 0.0038901285734027624, "psnr": 24.10036044484945, "ssim": 0.885178804397583, "hole_l1": 0.10854113847017288, "hole_l2": 0.023802023380994797, "hole_psnr": 16.233861225296508, "hole_fraction": 0.1634368896484375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.018272757530212402, "l2": 0.0047075278125703335, "psnr": 23.272071054461584, "ssim": 0.8864343762397766, "hole_l1": 0.11180315166711807, "hole_l2": 0.02880333736538887, "hole_psnr": 15.405571887893723, "hole_fraction": 0.1634368896484375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.8282893374027847 }, { "validation_index": 414, "rough": { "l1": 0.020391589030623436, "l2": 0.0025753809604793787, "psnr": 25.89158519323187, "ssim": 0.836259663105011, "hole_l1": 0.06321286410093307, "hole_l2": 0.007983546704053879, "hole_psnr": 20.978041297262976, "hole_fraction": 0.3225860595703125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.019147707149386406, "l2": 0.0024259984493255615, "psnr": 26.15109481066135, "ssim": 0.8466467261314392, "hole_l1": 0.059356894344091415, "hole_l2": 0.007520467974245548, "hole_psnr": 21.237551338353597, "hole_fraction": 0.3225860595703125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.25951004109062126 }, { "validation_index": 1097, "rough": { "l1": 0.022683067247271538, "l2": 0.006208063568919897, "psnr": 22.070438446671066, "ssim": 0.8846310973167419, "hole_l1": 0.13593247532844543, "hole_l2": 0.03720296546816826, "hole_psnr": 14.294224408941425, "hole_fraction": 0.1668701171875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.02404860220849514, "l2": 0.0076120453886687756, "psnr": 21.18498630791005, "ssim": 0.8852441906929016, "hole_l1": 0.14411568641662598, "hole_l2": 0.04561658576130867, "hole_psnr": 13.408772232354497, "hole_fraction": 0.1668701171875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.8854521765869272 }, { "validation_index": 726, "rough": { "l1": 0.013859686441719532, "l2": 0.002885418711230159, "psnr": 25.397911562405948, "ssim": 0.9065002799034119, "hole_l1": 0.07948096096515656, "hole_l2": 0.01654697209596634, "hole_psnr": 17.812814654726296, "hole_fraction": 0.17437744140625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.0146483788266778, "l2": 0.0033636437729001045, "psnr": 24.731900044483396, "ssim": 0.9082213044166565, "hole_l1": 0.08400386571884155, "hole_l2": 0.019289443269371986, "hole_psnr": 17.14680306753669, "hole_fraction": 0.17437744140625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.6660115871896046 }, { "validation_index": 494, "rough": { "l1": 0.02705373428761959, "l2": 0.006217540707439184, "psnr": 22.06381362638913, "ssim": 0.8469991087913513, "hole_l1": 0.09133492410182953, "hole_l2": 0.02099076472222805, "hole_psnr": 16.779717391882492, "hole_fraction": 0.29620361328125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.027053549885749817, "l2": 0.006749539170414209, "psnr": 21.707258779213095, "ssim": 0.8505911231040955, "hole_l1": 0.09133430570363998, "hole_l2": 0.022786820307374, "hole_psnr": 16.423162724196565, "hole_fraction": 0.29620361328125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.35655466768592703 }, { "validation_index": 1178, "rough": { "l1": 0.017641989514231682, "l2": 0.002958129160106182, "psnr": 25.28982867426084, "ssim": 0.8915762901306152, "hole_l1": 0.05182596296072006, "hole_l2": 0.008689943701028824, "hole_psnr": 20.609830371775388, "hole_fraction": 0.3404083251953125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.017124533653259277, "l2": 0.003194305347278714, "psnr": 24.956235715100572, "ssim": 0.8968844413757324, "hole_l1": 0.05030586197972298, "hole_l2": 0.009383746422827244, "hole_psnr": 20.276237366826845, "hole_fraction": 0.3404083251953125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.3335930049485434 }, { "validation_index": 755, "rough": { "l1": 0.053479935973882675, "l2": 0.01617414318025112, "psnr": 17.91178716652771, "ssim": 0.7333217263221741, "hole_l1": 0.1556747406721115, "hole_l2": 0.047081317752599716, "hole_psnr": 13.271513902493, "hole_fraction": 0.343536376953125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.05452245473861694, "l2": 0.017671706154942513, "psnr": 17.527215185234475, "ssim": 0.7414097189903259, "hole_l1": 0.15870939195156097, "hole_l2": 0.051440563052892685, "hole_psnr": 12.886942864013688, "hole_fraction": 0.343536376953125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.3845710384793115 }, { "validation_index": 46, "rough": { "l1": 0.024367602542042732, "l2": 0.004909344017505646, "psnr": 23.089765340705206, "ssim": 0.8428141474723816, "hole_l1": 0.09165786951780319, "hole_l2": 0.018466323614120483, "hole_psnr": 17.336195578907816, "hole_fraction": 0.2658538818359375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.02447536028921604, "l2": 0.005204843357205391, "psnr": 22.835923363023415, "ssim": 0.8459692597389221, "hole_l1": 0.09206319600343704, "hole_l2": 0.019577834755182266, "hole_psnr": 17.08235341433516, "hole_fraction": 0.2658538818359375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.2538421645726565 }, { "validation_index": 837, "rough": { "l1": 0.012195291928946972, "l2": 0.0023405614774674177, "psnr": 26.306799471559735, "ssim": 0.9256070256233215, "hole_l1": 0.05168330669403076, "hole_l2": 0.009919233620166779, "hole_psnr": 20.03521881010137, "hole_fraction": 0.2359619140625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.012457004748284817, "l2": 0.0026876814663410187, "psnr": 25.706222034782126, "ssim": 0.9284799695014954, "hole_l1": 0.052792441099882126, "hole_l2": 0.011390319094061852, "hole_psnr": 19.434641092089493, "hole_fraction": 0.2359619140625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.600577718011877 }, { "validation_index": 158, "rough": { "l1": 0.016234224662184715, "l2": 0.0032181355636566877, "psnr": 24.923956652376148, "ssim": 0.8765662312507629, "hole_l1": 0.07168347388505936, "hole_l2": 0.014209928922355175, "hole_psnr": 18.474080943952703, "hole_fraction": 0.226470947265625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.015723643824458122, "l2": 0.003635605564340949, "psnr": 24.394232405552128, "ssim": 0.881432831287384, "hole_l1": 0.06942896544933319, "hole_l2": 0.016053298488259315, "hole_psnr": 17.944357191426388, "hole_fraction": 0.226470947265625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.5297237525263156 }, { "validation_index": 1797, "rough": { "l1": 0.0032678444404155016, "l2": 0.00041435318416915834, "psnr": 33.82629319395926, "ssim": 0.9745879173278809, "hole_l1": 0.022531453520059586, "hole_l2": 0.0028569228015840054, "hole_psnr": 25.441014947586808, "hole_fraction": 0.1450347900390625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.0029845479875802994, "l2": 0.0004042634682264179, "psnr": 33.933355024568634, "ssim": 0.9769298434257507, "hole_l1": 0.02057815156877041, "hole_l2": 0.002787355100736022, "hole_psnr": 25.54807699938909, "hole_fraction": 0.1450347900390625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.10706205180228068 }, { "validation_index": 820, "rough": { "l1": 0.03604203835129738, "l2": 0.00852555688470602, "psnr": 20.69277243531255, "ssim": 0.7336974143981934, "hole_l1": 0.1054016575217247, "hole_l2": 0.024932213127613068, "hole_psnr": 16.032391692920445, "hole_fraction": 0.341949462890625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.037677038460969925, "l2": 0.009441663511097431, "psnr": 20.249514813330222, "ssim": 0.7369303107261658, "hole_l1": 0.11018306761980057, "hole_l2": 0.02761128358542919, "hole_psnr": 15.589134035341752, "hole_fraction": 0.341949462890625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.44325765757869284 }, { "validation_index": 1628, "rough": { "l1": 0.021362707018852234, "l2": 0.0037968691904097795, "psnr": 24.2057436489913, "ssim": 0.870206356048584, "hole_l1": 0.06195081025362015, "hole_l2": 0.011010734364390373, "hole_psnr": 19.581837146552576, "hole_fraction": 0.3448333740234375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.021470993757247925, "l2": 0.004255532752722502, "psnr": 23.71046062586626, "ssim": 0.8660085201263428, "hole_l1": 0.06226483732461929, "hole_l2": 0.012340838089585304, "hole_psnr": 19.086553455440452, "hole_fraction": 0.3448333740234375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.49528369111212456 }, { "validation_index": 419, "rough": { "l1": 0.011140449903905392, "l2": 0.0020415938924998045, "psnr": 26.90030642164261, "ssim": 0.923088550567627, "hole_l1": 0.048631224781274796, "hole_l2": 0.008912135846912861, "hole_psnr": 20.500182022068152, "hole_fraction": 0.2290802001953125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.010920722968876362, "l2": 0.0020599260460585356, "psnr": 26.861483710702743, "ssim": 0.9266481399536133, "hole_l1": 0.047672051936388016, "hole_l2": 0.008992161601781845, "hole_psnr": 20.461358968226705, "hole_fraction": 0.2290802001953125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.038823053841447575 }, { "validation_index": 642, "rough": { "l1": 0.019656965509057045, "l2": 0.002908111549913883, "psnr": 25.363889387404747, "ssim": 0.7970277667045593, "hole_l1": 0.04933701828122139, "hole_l2": 0.007299069315195084, "hole_psnr": 21.367325120771806, "hole_fraction": 0.3984222412109375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.01858784817159176, "l2": 0.002979378215968609, "psnr": 25.258743619471193, "ssim": 0.8054568767547607, "hole_l1": 0.0466536320745945, "hole_l2": 0.007477940525859594, "hole_psnr": 21.26217993232843, "hole_fraction": 0.3984222412109375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.10514518844337672 }, { "validation_index": 713, "rough": { "l1": 0.009799918159842491, "l2": 0.0024700642097741365, "psnr": 26.072917570285373, "ssim": 0.9287114143371582, "hole_l1": 0.0710529237985611, "hole_l2": 0.0179088544100523, "hole_psnr": 17.46932194123342, "hole_fraction": 0.1379241943359375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.009278843179345131, "l2": 0.0023806942626833916, "psnr": 26.232963746729002, "ssim": 0.9271144270896912, "hole_l1": 0.06727494299411774, "hole_l2": 0.01726088859140873, "hole_psnr": 17.629368505436386, "hole_fraction": 0.1379241943359375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.1600465642029647 }, { "validation_index": 610, "rough": { "l1": 0.018021369352936745, "l2": 0.0020671284291893244, "psnr": 26.84632540133457, "ssim": 0.8415217399597168, "hole_l1": 0.054226282984018326, "hole_l2": 0.006219987291842699, "hole_psnr": 22.062105026224014, "hole_fraction": 0.33233642578125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.01697121001780033, "l2": 0.0020391244906932116, "psnr": 26.905562592779194, "ssim": 0.8554422855377197, "hole_l1": 0.051066357642412186, "hole_l2": 0.006135724019259214, "hole_psnr": 22.1213418289355, "hole_fraction": 0.33233642578125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.059236802711485126 }, { "validation_index": 1212, "rough": { "l1": 0.0207538902759552, "l2": 0.0061581810005009174, "psnr": 22.105475505150636, "ssim": 0.8808484673500061, "hole_l1": 0.1203758716583252, "hole_l2": 0.03571843355894089, "hole_psnr": 14.471075954616904, "hole_fraction": 0.1724090576171875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.019857756793498993, "l2": 0.006859846878796816, "psnr": 21.636855782343247, "ssim": 0.8971085548400879, "hole_l1": 0.11517815291881561, "hole_l2": 0.03978820890188217, "hole_psnr": 14.002456105278249, "hole_fraction": 0.1724090576171875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.46861984933865486 }, { "validation_index": 533, "rough": { "l1": 0.046900179237127304, "l2": 0.01056162640452385, "psnr": 19.762691988361016, "ssim": 0.7056794166564941, "hole_l1": 0.12035595625638962, "hole_l2": 0.027103405445814133, "hole_psnr": 15.66976138151122, "hole_fraction": 0.389678955078125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.046576350927352905, "l2": 0.01097678393125534, "psnr": 19.595248844306134, "ssim": 0.7194433212280273, "hole_l1": 0.11952493339776993, "hole_l2": 0.02816879190504551, "hole_psnr": 15.502317785102548, "hole_fraction": 0.389678955078125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.16744359640867224 }, { "validation_index": 1186, "rough": { "l1": 0.09401022642850876, "l2": 0.038052573800086975, "psnr": 14.196159630886253, "ssim": 0.6291274428367615, "hole_l1": 0.2368178516626358, "hole_l2": 0.0958569124341011, "hole_psnr": 10.183765638110334, "hole_fraction": 0.39697265625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.09363678842782974, "l2": 0.03976093605160713, "psnr": 14.005433999974972, "ssim": 0.6328679919242859, "hole_l1": 0.23587718605995178, "hole_l2": 0.1001603826880455, "hole_psnr": 9.993040247986919, "hole_fraction": 0.39697265625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.19072539012341494 }, { "validation_index": 1955, "rough": { "l1": 0.005012401379644871, "l2": 0.0010053250007331371, "psnr": 29.976935171412386, "ssim": 0.9823117256164551, "hole_l1": 0.026195595040917397, "hole_l2": 0.005253984592854977, "hole_psnr": 22.795112051030273, "hole_fraction": 0.19134521484375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.0041014160960912704, "l2": 0.0009441829170100391, "psnr": 30.249438614724298, "ssim": 0.9837431311607361, "hole_l1": 0.021434642374515533, "hole_l2": 0.004934447351843119, "hole_psnr": 23.067614803773026, "hole_fraction": 0.19134521484375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.2725027527427528 }, { "validation_index": 731, "rough": { "l1": 0.01987740397453308, "l2": 0.004006985574960709, "psnr": 23.97182221012831, "ssim": 0.888681173324585, "hole_l1": 0.06931759417057037, "hole_l2": 0.013973383232951164, "hole_psnr": 18.546984298549194, "hole_fraction": 0.2867584228515625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.020182056352496147, "l2": 0.004635015036910772, "psnr": 23.3394885257951, "ssim": 0.890579879283905, "hole_l1": 0.07037999480962753, "hole_l2": 0.016163481399416924, "hole_psnr": 17.914650922175515, "hole_fraction": 0.2867584228515625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.6323333763736798 }, { "validation_index": 88, "rough": { "l1": 0.006287040188908577, "l2": 0.0006922244210727513, "psnr": 31.597530832417586, "ssim": 0.9244663715362549, "hole_l1": 0.06186598539352417, "hole_l2": 0.006811654660850763, "hole_psnr": 21.667473781329054, "hole_fraction": 0.10162353515625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.0065538170747458935, "l2": 0.0007843137136660516, "psnr": 31.05510191317304, "ssim": 0.9264327883720398, "hole_l1": 0.0644911378622055, "hole_l2": 0.007717835251241922, "hole_psnr": 21.125044963321518, "hole_fraction": 0.10162353515625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.5424288180075365 }, { "validation_index": 1166, "rough": { "l1": 0.03794226422905922, "l2": 0.00742914667353034, "psnr": 21.29061067297279, "ssim": 0.702674388885498, "hole_l1": 0.11385980993509293, "hole_l2": 0.022293902933597565, "hole_psnr": 16.518138940973987, "hole_fraction": 0.3332366943359375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.0395650789141655, "l2": 0.008147132582962513, "psnr": 20.889952161085922, "ssim": 0.7047566771507263, "hole_l1": 0.11872966587543488, "hole_l2": 0.024448484182357788, "hole_psnr": 16.11748062170012, "hole_fraction": 0.3332366943359375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.40065831927386597 }, { "validation_index": 829, "rough": { "l1": 0.03957081213593483, "l2": 0.00880467426031828, "psnr": 20.552867066544724, "ssim": 0.7318102717399597, "hole_l1": 0.11850810050964355, "hole_l2": 0.026368556544184685, "hole_psnr": 15.789136435115893, "hole_fraction": 0.3339080810546875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.03925541415810585, "l2": 0.009380217641592026, "psnr": 20.277870849209464, "ssim": 0.7328972816467285, "hole_l1": 0.11756352335214615, "hole_l2": 0.028092214837670326, "hole_psnr": 15.514140189380107, "hole_fraction": 0.3339080810546875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.2749962457357853 }, { "validation_index": 40, "rough": { "l1": 0.022042086347937584, "l2": 0.004933300893753767, "psnr": 23.06862395076743, "ssim": 0.8377962112426758, "hole_l1": 0.07389003038406372, "hole_l2": 0.016537535935640335, "hole_psnr": 17.81529199092676, "hole_fraction": 0.298309326171875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.02182733081281185, "l2": 0.005225703585892916, "psnr": 22.81855228106963, "ssim": 0.8451120853424072, "hole_l1": 0.07317011803388596, "hole_l2": 0.017517732456326485, "hole_psnr": 17.565221108071256, "hole_fraction": 0.298309326171875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.2500708828555034 }, { "validation_index": 296, "rough": { "l1": 0.0598626434803009, "l2": 0.025086617097258568, "psnr": 16.005578988706166, "ssim": 0.7714287638664246, "hole_l1": 0.15091973543167114, "hole_l2": 0.06324587762355804, "hole_psnr": 11.989677766135935, "hole_fraction": 0.3966522216796875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.06193532049655914, "l2": 0.028101937845349312, "psnr": 15.512637311082983, "ssim": 0.7698535919189453, "hole_l1": 0.1561451405286789, "hole_l2": 0.07084779441356659, "hole_psnr": 11.496736653731501, "hole_fraction": 0.3966522216796875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.4929411124044343 }, { "validation_index": 938, "rough": { "l1": 0.0031429387163370848, "l2": 0.00026295738643966615, "psnr": 35.80114625402215, "ssim": 0.982566773891449, "hole_l1": 0.027804479002952576, "hole_l2": 0.002326292684301734, "hole_psnr": 26.33335645075949, "hole_fraction": 0.113037109375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.0027928724884986877, "l2": 0.00020870771550107747, "psnr": 36.80461495651335, "ssim": 0.9843098521232605, "hole_l1": 0.024707572534680367, "hole_l2": 0.0018463644664734602, "hole_psnr": 27.33682566498254, "hole_fraction": 0.113037109375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 1.0034692142230526 }, { "validation_index": 1778, "rough": { "l1": 0.016899580135941505, "l2": 0.0030970617663115263, "psnr": 25.09050133196403, "ssim": 0.8870254158973694, "hole_l1": 0.10079458355903625, "hole_l2": 0.018471883609890938, "hole_psnr": 17.33488816542881, "hole_fraction": 0.16766357421875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.018261650577187538, "l2": 0.0037499219179153442, "psnr": 24.259777751980273, "ssim": 0.883298933506012, "hole_l1": 0.10891842097043991, "hole_l2": 0.022365752607584, "hole_psnr": 16.50416483235952, "hole_fraction": 0.16766357421875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.8307233330692902 }, { "validation_index": 1825, "rough": { "l1": 0.011387978680431843, "l2": 0.001009884406812489, "psnr": 29.95728333500969, "ssim": 0.8988690972328186, "hole_l1": 0.035107847303152084, "hole_l2": 0.0031133589800447226, "hole_psnr": 25.06770800915899, "hole_fraction": 0.324371337890625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.011536694131791592, "l2": 0.0011533111101016402, "psnr": 29.380535242967248, "ssim": 0.8914839625358582, "hole_l1": 0.03556631878018379, "hole_l2": 0.0035555276554077864, "hole_psnr": 24.490959390053515, "hole_fraction": 0.324371337890625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.5767486191054765 }, { "validation_index": 1226, "rough": { "l1": 0.02249549888074398, "l2": 0.006108056753873825, "psnr": 22.14096936288223, "ssim": 0.8774979114532471, "hole_l1": 0.12181994318962097, "hole_l2": 0.03307697921991348, "hole_psnr": 14.804741595797779, "hole_fraction": 0.184661865234375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.023123443126678467, "l2": 0.0068352012895047665, "psnr": 21.65248691391115, "ssim": 0.8811467289924622, "hole_l1": 0.12522046267986298, "hole_l2": 0.037014685571193695, "hole_psnr": 14.31625935469285, "hole_fraction": 0.184661865234375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.4884822411049292 }, { "validation_index": 1671, "rough": { "l1": 0.019956663250923157, "l2": 0.00282147154211998, "psnr": 25.495243257457343, "ssim": 0.8243646621704102, "hole_l1": 0.07647078484296799, "hole_l2": 0.010811434127390385, "hole_psnr": 19.661166934379022, "hole_fraction": 0.2609710693359375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.019974226132035255, "l2": 0.002949242712929845, "psnr": 25.30289484976653, "ssim": 0.8279411196708679, "hole_l1": 0.0765380859375, "hole_l2": 0.011301032267510891, "hole_psnr": 19.468818850468143, "hole_fraction": 0.2609710693359375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.1923480839108791 }, { "validation_index": 774, "rough": { "l1": 0.0143342986702919, "l2": 0.0038197310641407967, "psnr": 24.179672133896574, "ssim": 0.9209473729133606, "hole_l1": 0.09645883738994598, "hole_l2": 0.025703858584165573, "hole_psnr": 15.900016768233876, "hole_fraction": 0.1486053466796875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.014362520538270473, "l2": 0.004076144192367792, "psnr": 23.897504613579482, "ssim": 0.9252254962921143, "hole_l1": 0.09664874523878098, "hole_l2": 0.02742931619286537, "hole_psnr": 15.617850191314155, "hole_fraction": 0.1486053466796875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.282166576919721 }, { "validation_index": 303, "rough": { "l1": 0.034654323011636734, "l2": 0.009601580910384655, "psnr": 20.176572540301997, "ssim": 0.7823416590690613, "hole_l1": 0.12748995423316956, "hole_l2": 0.03532329946756363, "hole_psnr": 14.519387367583933, "hole_fraction": 0.271820068359375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.036649029701948166, "l2": 0.01108639407902956, "psnr": 19.55209687956607, "ssim": 0.7835074067115784, "hole_l1": 0.13482828438282013, "hole_l2": 0.040785789489746094, "hole_psnr": 13.894911266454848, "hole_fraction": 0.271820068359375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.6244761011290851 }, { "validation_index": 600, "rough": { "l1": 0.009330750443041325, "l2": 0.0016217706725001335, "psnr": 27.90010557467096, "ssim": 0.9239651560783386, "hole_l1": 0.06626570969820023, "hole_l2": 0.011517594568431377, "hole_psnr": 19.386382131643387, "hole_fraction": 0.14080810546875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.008663345128297806, "l2": 0.0015661092475056648, "psnr": 28.051779460239274, "ssim": 0.9297456741333008, "hole_l1": 0.061525892466306686, "hole_l2": 0.011122293770313263, "hole_psnr": 19.538056381980617, "hole_fraction": 0.14080810546875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.15167425033722992 }, { "validation_index": 1516, "rough": { "l1": 0.03001675195991993, "l2": 0.007618393283337355, "psnr": 21.181366115681485, "ssim": 0.8393765091896057, "hole_l1": 0.11154963076114655, "hole_l2": 0.028311824426054955, "hole_psnr": 15.480321436112852, "hole_fraction": 0.2690887451171875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.029575033113360405, "l2": 0.00793098658323288, "psnr": 21.00672784813161, "ssim": 0.8444389700889587, "hole_l1": 0.1099080890417099, "hole_l2": 0.029473502188920975, "hole_psnr": 15.305682560416908, "hole_fraction": 0.2690887451171875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.17463887569594405 }, { "validation_index": 1966, "rough": { "l1": 0.032736558467149734, "l2": 0.009081680327653885, "psnr": 20.41833789197806, "ssim": 0.8181911110877991, "hole_l1": 0.15357360243797302, "hole_l2": 0.04260393604636192, "hole_psnr": 13.70550275914891, "hole_fraction": 0.213165283203125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.03306162357330322, "l2": 0.009553872980177402, "psnr": 20.198205370085738, "ssim": 0.8237218856811523, "hole_l1": 0.1550985425710678, "hole_l2": 0.04481909051537514, "hole_psnr": 13.485369605667207, "hole_fraction": 0.213165283203125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.2201331534817026 }, { "validation_index": 111, "rough": { "l1": 0.012615458108484745, "l2": 0.003059709444642067, "psnr": 25.143198129236154, "ssim": 0.9405741691589355, "hole_l1": 0.05819022282958031, "hole_l2": 0.01411325391381979, "hole_psnr": 18.503728449347246, "hole_fraction": 0.216796875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.011848397552967072, "l2": 0.0031699715182185173, "psnr": 24.989446398441103, "ssim": 0.9480624794960022, "hole_l1": 0.05465206876397133, "hole_l2": 0.014621851034462452, "hole_psnr": 18.34997644945413, "hole_fraction": 0.216796875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.15375199989311739 }, { "validation_index": 586, "rough": { "l1": 0.004476530477404594, "l2": 0.0004708874912466854, "psnr": 33.27082846093048, "ssim": 0.9773461222648621, "hole_l1": 0.0321681872010231, "hole_l2": 0.0033837808296084404, "hole_psnr": 24.70597774348787, "hole_fraction": 0.13916015625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.0034194467589259148, "l2": 0.0004251417703926563, "psnr": 33.714662232854195, "ssim": 0.9835888743400574, "hole_l1": 0.024572022259235382, "hole_l2": 0.003055053763091564, "hole_psnr": 25.149811426035722, "hole_fraction": 0.13916015625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.4438336825478508 }, { "validation_index": 462, "rough": { "l1": 0.015107559971511364, "l2": 0.0027220372576266527, "psnr": 25.65105934727494, "ssim": 0.8985742926597595, "hole_l1": 0.05529370158910751, "hole_l2": 0.009962663054466248, "hole_psnr": 20.01624557633427, "hole_fraction": 0.273223876953125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.014945074915885925, "l2": 0.0029708941001445055, "psnr": 25.271128286886185, "ssim": 0.898262083530426, "hole_l1": 0.05469900742173195, "hole_l2": 0.010873479768633842, "hole_psnr": 19.63631449246423, "hole_fraction": 0.273223876953125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.3799310838700407 }, { "validation_index": 1181, "rough": { "l1": 0.01667766459286213, "l2": 0.00324572273530066, "psnr": 24.88688582375464, "ssim": 0.8632571697235107, "hole_l1": 0.05365409702062607, "hole_l2": 0.010441887192428112, "hole_psnr": 19.812210029439804, "hole_fraction": 0.3108367919921875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.015174287371337414, "l2": 0.0030216239392757416, "psnr": 25.197595874027414, "ssim": 0.8774250149726868, "hole_l1": 0.04881753772497177, "hole_l2": 0.009720933623611927, "hole_psnr": 20.1229202230509, "hole_fraction": 0.3108367919921875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.3107101936110972 }, { "validation_index": 839, "rough": { "l1": 0.0083765285089612, "l2": 0.0013276725076138973, "psnr": 28.769090376759596, "ssim": 0.9462795257568359, "hole_l1": 0.03545135632157326, "hole_l2": 0.005619008559733629, "hole_psnr": 22.503403063207877, "hole_fraction": 0.2362823486328125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.008237166330218315, "l2": 0.0015611778944730759, "psnr": 28.065476067479054, "ssim": 0.9497084617614746, "hole_l1": 0.03486153855919838, "hole_l2": 0.006607255898416042, "hole_psnr": 21.799788726804277, "hole_fraction": 0.2362823486328125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.7036143364036 }, { "validation_index": 535, "rough": { "l1": 0.013338207267224789, "l2": 0.0026927199214696884, "psnr": 25.698088166166745, "ssim": 0.9022871851921082, "hole_l1": 0.05453785881400108, "hole_l2": 0.01101011410355568, "hole_psnr": 19.582081801846684, "hole_fraction": 0.24456787109375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.013877292163670063, "l2": 0.0032755201682448387, "psnr": 24.847197221577083, "ssim": 0.9030420184135437, "hole_l1": 0.05674209073185921, "hole_l2": 0.013393093831837177, "hole_psnr": 18.73119088492713, "hole_fraction": 0.24456787109375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.8508909169195533 }, { "validation_index": 1731, "rough": { "l1": 0.04663988947868347, "l2": 0.013530497439205647, "psnr": 18.68686236578219, "ssim": 0.7780302166938782, "hole_l1": 0.1511368602514267, "hole_l2": 0.04384566470980644, "hole_psnr": 13.580733415382388, "hole_fraction": 0.30859375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.04870247840881348, "l2": 0.015451624989509583, "psnr": 18.110258407137948, "ssim": 0.7770935893058777, "hole_l1": 0.1578206866979599, "hole_l2": 0.05007108673453331, "hole_psnr": 13.00412982643644, "hole_fraction": 0.30859375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.5766035889459484 }, { "validation_index": 1600, "rough": { "l1": 0.013429203070700169, "l2": 0.0031035749707370996, "psnr": 25.081377592252032, "ssim": 0.9205520749092102, "hole_l1": 0.09047972410917282, "hole_l2": 0.020910443738102913, "hole_psnr": 16.796367509716767, "hole_fraction": 0.1484222412109375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.012562033720314503, "l2": 0.003125288523733616, "psnr": 25.051098828059082, "ssim": 0.9266920685768127, "hole_l1": 0.08463713526725769, "hole_l2": 0.02105673961341381, "hole_psnr": 16.76608873298705, "hole_fraction": 0.1484222412109375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.030278776729716128 }, { "validation_index": 769, "rough": { "l1": 0.02697957120835781, "l2": 0.006617127452045679, "psnr": 21.793305003591126, "ssim": 0.8151968121528625, "hole_l1": 0.10823538154363632, "hole_l2": 0.026546282693743706, "hole_psnr": 15.759962850767835, "hole_fraction": 0.249267578125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.02768552303314209, "l2": 0.007073222193866968, "psnr": 21.50382699042583, "ssim": 0.8175828456878662, "hole_l1": 0.11106748878955841, "hole_l2": 0.0283760204911232, "hole_psnr": 15.470485109197295, "hole_fraction": 0.249267578125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.28947774157053985 }, { "validation_index": 1459, "rough": { "l1": 0.013341682963073254, "l2": 0.002349199028685689, "psnr": 26.290801873951168, "ssim": 0.9226545691490173, "hole_l1": 0.0647626519203186, "hole_l2": 0.011403385549783707, "hole_psnr": 19.42966191882363, "hole_fraction": 0.2060089111328125 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.012789498083293438, "l2": 0.0024153387639671564, "psnr": 26.170219485548248, "ssim": 0.9269556403160095, "hole_l1": 0.06208225339651108, "hole_l2": 0.011724438518285751, "hole_psnr": 19.30907946416634, "hole_fraction": 0.2060089111328125 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.12058245465728845 }, { "validation_index": 677, "rough": { "l1": 0.015285152941942215, "l2": 0.0031844768673181534, "psnr": 24.96961901569517, "ssim": 0.8935141563415527, "hole_l1": 0.0859704539179802, "hole_l2": 0.017910903319716454, "hole_psnr": 17.46882510361171, "hole_fraction": 0.17779541015625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.015462968498468399, "l2": 0.003701949492096901, "psnr": 24.315695108811283, "ssim": 0.8978578448295593, "hole_l1": 0.08697057515382767, "hole_l2": 0.020821403712034225, "hole_psnr": 16.81489995102105, "hole_fraction": 0.17779541015625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.6539251525906593 }, { "validation_index": 81, "rough": { "l1": 0.013222870416939259, "l2": 0.0024573979899287224, "psnr": 26.095245013007382, "ssim": 0.9048671722412109, "hole_l1": 0.03679564222693443, "hole_l2": 0.006838266737759113, "hole_psnr": 21.65053962843672, "hole_fraction": 0.3593597412109375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.01335363369435072, "l2": 0.0025928423274308443, "psnr": 25.86223892181183, "ssim": 0.9063968658447266, "hole_l1": 0.037159513682127, "hole_l2": 0.007215172052383423, "hole_psnr": 21.417533082974707, "hole_fraction": 0.3593597412109375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.2330065454620147 }, { "validation_index": 1168, "rough": { "l1": 0.006746536586433649, "l2": 0.0009593518334440887, "psnr": 30.18022090117116, "ssim": 0.9693885445594788, "hole_l1": 0.047876667231321335, "hole_l2": 0.006808021105825901, "hole_psnr": 21.669791065472175, "hole_fraction": 0.1409149169921875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.0051671527326107025, "l2": 0.0007316291448660195, "psnr": 31.357090024816017, "ssim": 0.9777514338493347, "hole_l1": 0.036668598651885986, "hole_l2": 0.005191992502659559, "hole_psnr": 22.846659433371045, "hole_fraction": 0.1409149169921875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 1.1768683678988694 }, { "validation_index": 62, "rough": { "l1": 0.011284600012004375, "l2": 0.0014839592622593045, "psnr": 28.285780211721065, "ssim": 0.9114546179771423, "hole_l1": 0.061327435076236725, "hole_l2": 0.00806474406272173, "hole_psnr": 20.934094105330946, "hole_fraction": 0.1840057373046875 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.012053693644702435, "l2": 0.001808818313293159, "psnr": 27.4260505364705, "ssim": 0.910711944103241, "hole_l1": 0.06550715863704681, "hole_l2": 0.009830227121710777, "hole_psnr": 20.07436447929185, "hole_fraction": 0.1840057373046875 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.8597296260390941 }, { "validation_index": 1469, "rough": { "l1": 0.032724928110837936, "l2": 0.008343800902366638, "psnr": 20.786360674812315, "ssim": 0.8283528685569763, "hole_l1": 0.08712112158536911, "hole_l2": 0.022213077172636986, "hole_psnr": 16.533912745660558, "hole_fraction": 0.3756256103515625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.03219197317957878, "l2": 0.008644599467515945, "psnr": 20.632551242035227, "ssim": 0.8309615254402161, "hole_l1": 0.08570229262113571, "hole_l2": 0.023013873025774956, "hole_psnr": 16.380102873644336, "hole_fraction": 0.3756256103515625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.15380987201622176 }, { "validation_index": 1744, "rough": { "l1": 0.00988290086388588, "l2": 0.002194232540205121, "psnr": 26.587173486955322, "ssim": 0.9192679524421692, "hole_l1": 0.050513625144958496, "hole_l2": 0.011215195059776306, "hole_psnr": 19.501931685680574, "hole_fraction": 0.195648193359375 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.009150085039436817, "l2": 0.002018959494307637, "psnr": 26.948723940702997, "ssim": 0.9233610033988953, "hole_l1": 0.046768054366111755, "hole_l2": 0.01031933631747961, "hole_psnr": 19.863482332247898, "hole_fraction": 0.195648193359375 }, "delta_hole_psnr": 0.3615506465673235 }, { "validation_index": 1934, "rough": { "l1": 0.01750558614730835, "l2": 0.004541680216789246, "psnr": 23.427834480495836, "ssim": 0.913569450378418, "hole_l1": 0.07299861311912537, "hole_l2": 0.018938887864351273, "hole_psnr": 17.226455273684568, "hole_fraction": 0.23980712890625 }, "refined": { "l1": 0.01790742389857769, "l2": 0.005415800958871841, "psnr": 22.66337305189248, "ssim": 0.9182353615760803, "hole_l1": 0.07467427104711533, "hole_l2": 0.022583989426493645, "hole_psnr": 16.461993381916603, "hole_fraction": 0.23980712890625 }, "delta_hole_psnr": -0.7644618917679651 } ] }