"""Yürütme doğruluğu (execution accuracy, EX) tabanlı değerlendirme. EX: sistemin SQL'i kendi (çıkarımla oluşturulmuş) veritabanında çalıştırıldığında dönen sonuç kümesi, altın SQL'in referans veritabanındaki sonucuyla eşleşiyorsa 1. - Satır sırası önemsiz (çoklu küme karşılaştırması) - Sayılar: |a-b| <= 0,01 + 0,001·|b| (yuvarlama farklarına tolerans) - Metinler: Türkçe katlanmış karşılaştırma (İ/ı, büyük/küçük harf) - Sistem fazladan sütun döndürürse, altın sütunlarla eşleşen bir sütun alt kümesi aranır Cevapsız sorularda (altın SQL yok) sistem cevap vermeyi reddederse doğru sayılır; cevaplanabilir sorularda reddetmek yanlıştır. """ from __future__ import annotations import itertools import json import time from collections import Counter, defaultdict from dataclasses import dataclass from pathlib import Path from .agent import Text2SQLAgent from .errors import ErrorLog, diagnose_failure from .schema import connect from .trnum import fold ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent BENCH = ROOT / "benchmark" / "tr_tablosoru.json" def load_benchmark(path=BENCH) -> list[dict]: return json.loads(Path(path).read_text(encoding="utf-8"))["sorular"] def _val_eq(a, b) -> bool: if a is None or b is None: return a is None and b is None na = isinstance(a, (int, float)) and not isinstance(a, bool) nb = isinstance(b, (int, float)) and not isinstance(b, bool) if na and nb: return abs(a - b) <= 0.01 + 1e-3 * abs(b) if na != nb: return False return fold(str(a)) == fold(str(b)) def _sort_key(row): return tuple((0, round(v, 1)) if isinstance(v, (int, float)) and not isinstance(v, bool) else (1, fold(str(v))) for v in row) def _rows_eq(p, g) -> bool: if len(p) != len(g): return False ps, gs = sorted(p, key=_sort_key), sorted(g, key=_sort_key) if all(all(_val_eq(x, y) for x, y in zip(rp, rg)) for rp, rg in zip(ps, gs)): return True # sıralama anahtarı yuvarlamadan etkilenmiş olabilir: açgözlü eşleştirme used = [False] * len(gs) for rp in p: for k, rg in enumerate(gs): if not used[k] and all(_val_eq(x, y) for x, y in zip(rp, rg)): used[k] = True break else: return False return True def results_match(pred: list[tuple], gold: list[tuple]) -> bool: if pred is None: return False if not gold: return not pred gw = len(gold[0]) if not pred: return False pw = len(pred[0]) if pw == gw and _rows_eq(pred, gold): return True if pw > gw and pw <= 6: for idx in itertools.permutations(range(pw), gw): if _rows_eq([tuple(r[i] for i in idx) for r in pred], gold): return True if pw == gw and gw > 1: for idx in itertools.permutations(range(pw)): if _rows_eq([tuple(r[i] for i in idx) for r in pred], gold): return True return False @dataclass class SystemSpec: name: str backend: object # "kural" | LLMBackend db_mode: str = "tr" # tr | en | text self_correct: bool = True use_evidence: bool = True max_attempts: int = 3 static_check: bool = True # statik denetim (ablasyon için kapatılabilir) def gold_results(items, ref_db) -> dict[str, list]: con = connect(ref_db, readonly=True) out = {} for it in items: out[it["id"]] = [tuple(r) for r in con.execute(it["altin_sql"]).fetchall()] if it["altin_sql"] else None con.close() return out def evaluate_system(spec: SystemSpec, items, db_paths: dict, ref_db, out_dir: Path, error_log: ErrorLog | None = None, progress=None) -> dict: gold = gold_results(items, ref_db) con = connect(db_paths[spec.db_mode], readonly=True) agent = Text2SQLAgent(con, spec.backend, max_attempts=spec.max_attempts, self_correct=spec.self_correct, static_check=spec.static_check, error_log=error_log, log_source=f"degerlendirme:{spec.name}", fallback_rule=False) # deneylerde LLM sonucu kural tabanlı cevapla karışmasın records = [] for k, it in enumerate(items): t0 = time.time() res = agent.run(it["soru"], evidence=it.get("kanit") if spec.use_evidence else None) g = gold[it["id"]] if not it["cevaplanabilir"]: ok = res.abstained first_ok = res.first_sql is None # ilk denemede de reddetti mi else: ok = (not res.abstained) and results_match(res.rows, g) first_ok = res.first_rows is not None and res.first_error is None and results_match(res.first_rows, g) err = None if ok else diagnose_failure(it, res.sql, res.rows, g or [], res.abstained, res.exec_error, spec.db_mode) rec = {"id": it["id"], "bolum": it.get("bolum", "gelistirme"), "soru": it["soru"], "zorluk": it["zorluk"], "kategoriler": it["kategoriler"], "cevaplanabilir": it["cevaplanabilir"], "altin_sql": it["altin_sql"], "tahmin_sql": res.sql, "ilk_sql": res.first_sql, "durum": res.status, "cevap": res.answer, "dogru": ok, "ilk_deneme_dogru": first_ok, "deneme": res.attempts, "hata_tipi": err, "calisma_hatalari": [e.tip for e in res.events], "sure": round(time.time() - t0, 3), "tahmin_sonuc": [list(map(_jsonable, r)) for r in (res.rows or [])[:10]], "altin_sonuc": [list(map(_jsonable, r)) for r in (g or [])[:10]]} records.append(rec) if progress: progress(k + 1, len(items), rec) con.close() out_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) (out_dir / f"sonuclar_{spec.name}.jsonl").write_text( "\n".join(json.dumps(r, ensure_ascii=False) for r in records), encoding="utf-8") return summarize(spec, records) def _jsonable(v): return v if isinstance(v, (int, float, str)) or v is None else str(v) def _ex(recs): return round(100.0 * sum(r["dogru"] for r in recs) / len(recs), 1) if recs else None def summarize(spec: SystemSpec, records: list[dict]) -> dict: ans = [r for r in records if r["cevaplanabilir"]] una = [r for r in records if not r["cevaplanabilir"]] by = lambda key: {k: _ex(v) for k, v in sorted(_group(records, key).items())} cats = defaultdict(list) for r in records: for c in r["kategoriler"]: cats[c].append(r) return { "sistem": spec.name, "arka_uc": spec.backend if isinstance(spec.backend, str) else spec.backend.name, "sayi_kipi": spec.db_mode, "kendini_duzeltme": spec.self_correct, "kanit": spec.use_evidence, "n": len(records), "EX": _ex(records), "EX_ilk_deneme": round(100.0 * sum(r["ilk_deneme_dogru"] for r in records) / len(records), 1), "EX_cevaplanabilir": _ex(ans), "cevapsiz_dogru_red": _ex(una), "yanlis_red_orani": round(100.0 * sum(1 for r in ans if r["durum"] != "cevap") / len(ans), 1) if ans else None, "bolum": by("bolum"), "zorluk": by("zorluk"), "kategori": {k: _ex(v) for k, v in sorted(cats.items())}, "kategori_n": {k: len(v) for k, v in sorted(cats.items())}, "hata_tipleri": dict(Counter(r["hata_tipi"] for r in records if r["hata_tipi"]).most_common()), "ort_deneme": round(sum(r["deneme"] for r in records) / len(records), 2), "ort_sure_sn": round(sum(r["sure"] for r in records) / len(records), 3), } def _group(records, key): g = defaultdict(list) for r in records: g[r[key]].append(r) return g def gold_on_naive_db(items, db_paths: dict, ref_db) -> list[dict]: """Altın SQL'i naif sayı kipleriyle kurulmuş veritabanlarında çalıştırır. Sorgu doğru olsa bile yalnızca sayı biçimi yüzünden kaç cevabın bozulduğunu ölçer.""" gold = gold_results(items, ref_db) out = [] for mode, p in db_paths.items(): con = connect(p, readonly=True) ok = err = 0 broken = [] n = 0 for it in items: if not it["altin_sql"]: continue n += 1 try: rows = [tuple(r) for r in con.execute(it["altin_sql"]).fetchall()] if results_match(rows, gold[it["id"]]): ok += 1 else: broken.append(it["id"]) except Exception: err += 1 broken.append(it["id"]) con.close() out.append({"kip": mode, "n": n, "EX": round(100.0 * ok / n, 1), "yurutme_hatasi": err, "bozulan": broken}) return out