-- Lean 4 Proof Sketch: Goldilocks Reduction Step Correctness -- File: GoldilocksStep.lean namespace Goldilocks -- 1. State Definition def Bit := Fin 2 def State := Bit × Bit × Bit -- (x, c_in, c_out) -- 2. Gate Semantics (Classical Action on Basis States) def X (s : State) : State := (s.1 + 1, s.2.1, s.2.2) def CNOT (control_target : Bit × Bit) (s : State) : State := -- This is a helper; actual gates act on specific wires. -- We define specific wire actions below. s -- Wire-specific Gates -- Wire indices: 0 = x, 1 = c_in, 2 = c_out def X_x (s : State) : State := ⟨(s.1 + 1 : Bit), s.2.1, s.2.2⟩ def CNOT_cin_x (s : State) : State := ⟨s.1 + s.2.1, s.2.1, s.2.2⟩ def CNOT_cin_cout (s : State) : State := ⟨s.1, s.2.1, s.2.2 + s.2.1⟩ def CCX_x_cin_cout (s : State) : State := ⟨s.1, s.2.1, s.2.2 + (s.1 * s.2.1 : Bit)⟩ -- 3. Circuit Definitions def lower_step (s : State) : State := (X_x ∘ CNOT_cin_x ∘ X_x ∘ CCX_x_cin_cout ∘ X_x) s def upper_step (s : State) : State := (CNOT_cin_x ∘ CCX_x_cin_cout) s -- 4. Specifications def spec_lower (s : State) : State := ⟨s.1 + 1 + s.2.1, s.2.1, s.1 * s.2.1⟩ def spec_upper (s : State) : State := ⟨s.1 + s.2.1, s.2.1, s.1 * s.2.1⟩ -- 5. Correctness Theorems theorem lower_step_correct : ∀ (s : State), s.2.2 = 0 → lower_step s = spec_lower s := by intro s h_zero -- Proof by exhaustive case analysis on 4 relevant states (c_out=0 fixed) -- x ∈ {0,1}, c_in ∈ {0,1} fin_cases s <;> simp_all [lower_step, spec_lower, X_x, CNOT_cin_x, CCX_x_cin_cout, Bit, Fin.ext_iff, Fin.val_zero, Fin.val_add, Fin.val_one] <;> norm_num at * <;> rfl theorem upper_step_correct : ∀ (s : State), s.2.2 = 0 → upper_step s = spec_upper s := by intro s h_zero fin_cases s <;> simp_all [upper_step, spec_upper, CNOT_cin_x, CCX_x_cin_cout, Bit, Fin.ext_iff, Fin.val_zero, Fin.val_add, Fin.val_one] <;> norm_num at * <;> rfl -- 6. Inverse Correctness (Uncomputation) def lower_step_dag (s : State) : State := (X_x ∘ CNOT_cin_x ∘ X_x ∘ CCX_x_cin_cout ∘ X_x) s -- Self-inverse check? No, reverse order. -- Actual Dagger: -- (X_x)⁻¹ ∘ (CCX)⁻¹ ∘ (X_x)⁻¹ ∘ (CNOT)⁻¹ ∘ (X_x)⁻¹ -- X⁻¹ = X, CNOT⁻¹ = CNOT, CCX⁻¹ = CCX -- So: X_x ∘ CCX_x_cin_cout ∘ X_x ∘ CNOT_cin_x ∘ X_x def lower_step_dag_correct (s : State) : State := (X_x ∘ CCX_x_cin_cout ∘ X_x ∘ CNOT_cin_x ∘ X_x) s theorem lower_step_dag_is_inverse : ∀ (s : State), lower_step_dag_correct (lower_step s) = s := by intro s fin_cases s <;> simp [lower_step, lower_step_dag_correct, X_x, CNOT_cin_x, CCX_x_cin_cout, Bit, Fin.ext_iff, Fin.val_zero, Fin.val_add, Fin.val_one] <;> norm_num <;> rfl -- 7. Full 64-bit Composition Correctness (Sketch) -- We model the Ping-Pong carry chain as a state machine. -- State: (x_vec : Vector Bit 64, carry_in : Bit, carry_out : Bit, phase : Phase) -- Phase: Lower (0..31), Upper (32..63), ReverseUpper, ReverseLower -- Invariant: carry_out = 0 at step start. -- Transition: Apply lower_step/upper_step, swap carry_in/carry_out. -- Theorem: Final x_vec = x_init + (C * carry_init) mod 2^64, carry_in = carry_init, carry_out = 0. def CarryState := Bit × Bit -- (active_carry, passive_carry) -- Ping-Pong Step for Lower Bits def pp_lower_step (x_bit : Bit) (carries : CarryState) : (Bit × CarryState) := let s : State := ⟨x_bit, carries.1, carries.2⟩ let s' := lower_step s ⟨s'.1, ⟨s'.2.2, s'.2.1⟩⟩ -- Output x', Swap carries (new_active = old_c_out, new_passive = old_c_in) -- Ping-Pong Step for Upper Bits def pp_upper_step (x_bit : Bit) (carries : CarryState) : (Bit × CarryState) := let s : State := ⟨x_bit, carries.1, carries.2⟩ let s' := upper_step s ⟨s'.1, ⟨s'.2.2, s'.2.1⟩⟩ -- Reverse Steps def pp_lower_step_dag (x_bit : Bit) (carries : CarryState) : (Bit × CarryState) := let s : State := ⟨x_bit, carries.1, carries.2⟩ let s' := lower_step_dag_correct s ⟨s'.1, ⟨s'.2.2, s'.2.1⟩⟩ def pp_upper_step_dag (x_bit : Bit) (carries : CarryState) : (Bit × CarryState) := let s : State := ⟨x_bit, carries.1, carries.2⟩ let s' := (CNOT_cin_x ∘ CCX_x_cin_cout)⁻¹ s -- Defined explicitly as upper_step_dg ⟨s'.1, ⟨s'.2.2, s'.2.1⟩⟩ -- Main Theorem Statement (Informal) -- theorem goldilocks_reduce_correct (x_init : Vector Bit 64) (ctrl : Bit) : -- let final_state := run_full_circuit x_init ctrl -- final_state.x = (x_init + ctrl * (2^32 - 1)) % 2^64 ∧ -- final_state.carry_in = ctrl ∧ -- final_state.carry_out = 0 := by sorry end Goldilocks