{ "id": "animations-videos-145", "source": "vas", "artifact_type": "dynamic_media", "category": "animations-videos", "acceptance_groups": { "G01": [ "IF01" ], "G02": [ "IF02", "IF04" ], "G03": [ "IF03", "IF06" ], "G04": [ "IF05", "IF07" ], "G05": [ "IF08", "IF11", "IF46", "IF47", "IF48", "IF49" ], "G06": [ "IF09", "IF10", "IF58" ], "G07": [ "IF12", "IF13", "IF14", "IF15", "IF16", "IF17", "IF18", "IF19", "IF20", "IF21" ], "G08": [ "IF22", "IF30", "IF40", "IF41" ], "G09": [ "IF23", "IF24", "IF25", "IF26", "IF27", "IF28", "IF29" ], "G10": [ "IF31", "IF32", "IF33", "IF34", "IF35", "IF36", "IF37", "IF38", "IF39" ], "G11": [ "IF42", "IF43", "IF44", "IF45", "IF50", "IF51", "IF52", "IF53" ], "G12": [ "IF54", "IF55", "IF56", "IF57" ] }, "provenance": { "source": "artifactspec", "original_id": "P145", "legacy_task_id": "artifactspec-P145" }, "acceptance_objectives": { "G01": { "title": "Required artifact language", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The on-screen text of the animation and any narration use English for instructional expression." ], "objective_key": "constraint:language" }, "G02": { "title": "Required artifact format, extent and duration", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The total duration of the main MP4 video is 35–45 seconds.", "Requirement: Deliver a 1920×1080 MP4 main video." ], "objective_key": "constraint:format" }, "G03": { "title": "Create a 35–45 second English teaching animation for an introductory ocean-science class. Compare an idealized salt-wedge estuary with a vertically mixed estuary. Deliver a 1920×1080 MP4, smaller GIF preview, editable source and regeneration instructions, four PNG checkpoints, and notes.md in artifact/.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The animation compares the two cases of an idealized salt-wedge estuary and a vertically mixed estuary.", "Requirement: Deliver editable source files/project." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:3" }, "G04": { "title": "Required faithful previews and companion exports", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Deliver a GIF preview smaller than the main video.", "Requirement: Deliver four PNG checkpoint images." ], "objective_key": "constraint:preview" }, "G05": { "title": "Complete reproducibility and delivery documentation", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: notes.md is located in artifact/.", "Requirement: notes.md discloses that the Vertically Mixed Estuary caption conflicts with this section's body text.", "Requirement: notes.md cites the NOAA source.", "Requirement: notes.md cites the original media URLs.", "Requirement: notes.md documents the qualitative simplifications.", "Requirement: notes.md explains the regeneration method." ], "objective_key": "constraint:notes" }, "G06": { "title": "Use the supplied NOAA article and two short reference animations. Create your own editable explanatory diagrams and motion; do not just replay the supplied clips. Source caveat: the caption beneath “Vertically Mixed Estuary” repeats the preceding slightly-stratified caption and conflicts with its own section. Follow the vertically-mixed section's explanatory text and disclose this conflict in notes.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The supplied NOAA article and two short reference animations are used as source material.", "Requirement: The vertically mixed case is presented according to that section's explanatory body text, rather than adopting the conflicting caption.", "Requirement: Create your own explanatory diagrams and motion, not directly replaying the supplied reference clips." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:5" }, "G07": { "title": "Keep the ocean on the left and river/upstream on the right throughout. Use the same salinity legend across both cases, supported by words or symbols as well as colour. Show the less-dense fresher river water above denser seawater in the salt-wedge case, with river flow toward the ocean and a salt wedge thinning upstream. Label relatively strong river flow and weak tidal currents. Show slight mixing at the interface; do not claim zero mixing.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The ocean remains on the left side of the frame throughout the film.", "Requirement: The river/upstream remains on the right side of the frame throughout the film.", "Requirement: The salt-wedge case and the vertically mixed case use the same salinity legend.", "Requirement: The salinity legend is supported by words or symbols in addition to color.", "Requirement: The salt-wedge case shows less-dense, fresher river water above saltier, denser seawater.", "Requirement: The salt-wedge case shows river flow toward the ocean.", "Requirement: The salt-wedge case shows the salt wedge thinning upstream.", "Requirement: The salt-wedge case labels relatively strong river flow.", "Requirement: The salt-wedge case labels weak tidal currents.", "Requirement: The salt-wedge interface shows slight mixing." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:7" }, "G08": { "title": "Evidence-bounded claims and truthful scenario identity", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The animation does not claim zero mixing at the salt-wedge interface.", "Requirement: The illustrative values in the diagram are not presented as measured values.", "Requirement: Do not imply that well-mixed water everywhere has only one salinity.", "Requirement: Do not imply that salinity determines all density differences under every condition." ], "objective_key": "constraint:evidence-boundary" }, "G09": { "title": "For the vertically mixed case, label relatively low river flow and moderate-to-strong tidal currents. Animate tidal stirring/exchange distinctly from net river outflow. Show approximately uniform salinity from surface to bottom at a given position, while retaining saltier water toward the ocean and fresher water upstream. At two labeled positions in this case, use vertical sampling markers and aligned qualitative salinity profiles to make both vertical uniformity and the longitudinal difference legible. No numerical simulation is required; avoid presenting illustrative values as measurements.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The vertically mixed case labels relatively low river flow.", "Requirement: The vertically mixed case labels moderate-to-strong tidal currents.", "Requirement: The tidal stirring/exchange animation is visually distinguishable from the net river outflow.", "Requirement: The vertically mixed case shows approximately uniform salinity from surface to bottom at a given position.", "Requirement: The vertically mixed case retains the longitudinal salinity difference of saltier toward the ocean and fresher upstream.", "Requirement: The vertically mixed case has two labeled positions with vertical sampling markers.", "Requirement: Next to the two sampling positions there are qualitative salinity profiles aligned with the sampling markers." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:9" }, "G10": { "title": "Use separate labeled cases, not an inevitable real-time transformation of every estuary. If you show a transition, label it as a conceptual change in conditions with no real-world timescale. Geometry and particles are schematic. Briefly acknowledge that tides, river flow, wind and geometry affect circulation; seasonal changes are possible. Do not imply that well-mixed water everywhere has one salinity or that salinity determines all density differences under every condition.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The two cases are presented as separately labeled cases.", "Requirement: The cases are not presented as a real-time transformation that inevitably occurs in every estuary.", "Requirement: If a transition is shown, it is labeled as a conceptual change in conditions with no real-world timescale.", "Requirement: The geometry and particles are stated to be schematic.", "Requirement: Briefly state that tides affect estuarine circulation.", "Requirement: Briefly state that river flow affects estuarine circulation.", "Requirement: Briefly state that wind affects estuarine circulation.", "Requirement: Briefly state that estuary geometry affects circulation.", "Requirement: State that seasonal changes are possible." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:11" }, "G11": { "title": "Progressively reveal conditions, water motion, and salinity evidence, rather than only crossfading static slides. Finish with a side-by-side comparison held for at least three seconds. The four checkpoints should show orientation/legend, salt wedge, vertically mixed with two profiles, and the final comparison. Keep labels readable on a classroom screen and motion slow enough to follow. Sound is optional and must not carry information absent from the visuals. In notes cite NOAA and original media URLs, document the caption conflict and qualitative simplifications, and explain regeneration. Source diagrams, labels, profiles and animation timing must remain editable.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Progressively reveal conditions, water motion, and salinity evidence, rather than only crossfading static slides.", "Requirement: End with a side-by-side comparison held.", "Requirement: The ending side-by-side comparison frame is held for at least three seconds.", "Requirement: If there is sound, sound does not carry information absent from the visuals.", "Requirement: Checkpoint 1 shows orientation/legend.", "Requirement: Checkpoint 2 shows the salt wedge case.", "Requirement: Checkpoint 3 shows the vertically mixed case with two profiles.", "Requirement: Checkpoint 4 shows the final comparison." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:13" }, "G12": { "title": "Required native editability and source structure", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Source diagrams remain editable.", "Requirement: Source labels remain editable.", "Requirement: Source salinity profiles remain editable.", "Requirement: Animation timing remains editable." ], "objective_key": "constraint:editability" } }, "grouping_revision": "cp-fn-objectives-v2-20261114" }