[ { "id": "IF01", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: deliver the file artifact/telescopes.pptx. Verification method: check whether artifact/telescopes.pptx exists and can be opened as a PPTX. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: Deliver artifact/telescopes.pptx.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G01" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF02", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: the PPTX has exactly six slides. Verification method: open the PPTX and check that the total number of slides is six. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: Create a six-slide English science-communication PPTX for an astronomy club.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G02" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF03", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: the six slides include a cover slide. Verification method: view each slide and confirm that a slide recognizable as a cover exists, and that no seventh cover slide has been added. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: Include the cover within the six slides..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G03" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF04", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: the presentation language of the PPTX is English. Verification method: check that slide body text, titles, labels, and notes are all in English; proper nouns such as source names are exceptions. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: six-slide English science-communication PPTX.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G04" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF05", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: the slide aspect ratio is 16:9. Verification method: check in the PPTX page setup that the aspect ratio or size ratio is equivalent to 16:9. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: Use 16:9 slides.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G02" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF06", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: the text in the PPTX is native editable text. Verification method: check native object types, data/text structure, and resource relationships to confirm that the prompt-defined objects are editable; if necessary, build normally in evaluation/work/ according to the documentation. Do not modify the submission or score through a repaired version. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: editable native text.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G05" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF07", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: the comparison tables in the PPTX are native editable table objects. Verification method: check native object types, data/text structure, and resource relationships to confirm that the prompt-defined objects are editable; if necessary, build normally in evaluation/work/ according to the documentation. Do not modify the submission or score through a repaired version. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: editable native text and comparison tables.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G03" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF08", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: there are exactly six PNGs under artifact/preview/, named 01.png through 06.png. Verification method: list the files in artifact/preview/ and check that they are exactly 01.png, 02.png, 03.png, 04.png, 05.png, and 06.png, with no missing or extra preview images. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: six matching 1280 × 720 PNGs in artifact/preview/01.png through 06.png.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G06" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF09", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: all six PNGs have pixel dimensions of 1280 × 720. Verification method: read the PNG metadata of each image and confirm the width is 1280 and the height is 720. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: six matching 1280 × 720 PNGs in artifact/preview/01.png through 06.png.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G02" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF10", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: the six PNGs correspond to the content of the six PPTX slides respectively. Verification method: compare each image by number from 01-06 with the title, main charts, and layout of the corresponding slide, and confirm that the visual content matches. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: six matching 1280 × 720 PNGs.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G03" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF11", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: deliver the file artifact/sources.md. Verification method: confirm that artifact/sources.md exists and is readable. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 2: and artifact/sources.md.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G07" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF12", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: the input source snapshot files remain read-only and unmodified. [v7 verifiable boundary: check that the final inputs match the frozen snapshot file by file; it is not required to prove that no write ever occurred during production. Public runtime inputs are guaranteed by read-only mounting.]. Verification method: check that the input files are still at their original paths, and compare the final file contents or on-the-spot computed hashes against the frozen originals file by file to confirm that they have not been rewritten, deleted, or replaced; do not infer a violation from file modification times or the absence of historical initial hashes. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 12 excerpt: Inputs are read-only[…]deliver to artifact/..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G08" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF13", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: explain why the two observatories are complementary. Verification method: find an explicit explanation in the PPTX about the complementarity of Hubble and Webb, such as different wavelength coverage or different observation capabilities. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 4: Explain why the observatories complement one another.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G09" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF14", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: explain that a larger mirror alone is not sufficient to adequately state resolution. Verification method: find an explicit statement in the PPTX that resolution judgment cannot rely on mirror diameter alone and must combine conditions such as wavelength. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 4: why a bigger mirror alone is not an adequate statement about resolution..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G09" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF15", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: use and label source B's \"Primary Mirror Basics: Webb vs. Hubble\" table as the mirror basics data table. Verification method: find a visible table whose title or source label corresponds to source B's \"Primary Mirror Basics: Webb vs. Hubble\". Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 4: Use source B's “Primary Mirror Basics: Webb vs. Hubble” table to present shape/structure, total diameter, total collecting area, and the two wavelength ranges..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G09" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF16", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: present the shape/structure item in the source B table. Verification method: check that the B source table contains a row or column corresponding to shape/structure, and gives the corresponding descriptions for Hubble and Webb. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 4: Use source B's “Primary Mirror Basics: Webb vs. Hubble” table to present shape/structure, total diameter, total collecting area, and the two wavelength ranges..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G09" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF17", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: present the total diameter item in the source B table. Verification method: check that the B source table contains the data item corresponding to total diameter, and preserves the values and units in the B table. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 4: Use source B's “Primary Mirror Basics: Webb vs. Hubble” table to present shape/structure, total diameter, total collecting area, and the two wavelength ranges..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G09" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF18", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: present the total collecting area item in the source B table. Verification method: check that the B source table contains the data item corresponding to total collecting area, and preserves the values and area units in the B table. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 4: Use source B's “Primary Mirror Basics: Webb vs. Hubble” table to present shape/structure, total diameter, total collecting area, and the two wavelength ranges..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G09" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF19", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: present the two wavelength ranges in the source B table. Verification method: check that the B source table contains the respective wavelength ranges of Hubble and Webb, and that both ranges are visible. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 4: Use source B's “Primary Mirror Basics: Webb vs. Hubble” table to present shape/structure, total diameter, total collecting area, and the two wavelength ranges..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G09" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF20", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: resolution entries appear together with their corresponding wavelength. Verification method: check that each resolution/arcsec entry has its corresponding wavelength nearby or in the same table row/column, and that resolution values are not separated from wavelengths. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 4: Include the resolution entries together with their associated wavelengths; do not turn them into a same-wavelength head-to-head test..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G09" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF21", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: do not arrange the resolution entries as a same-wavelength head-to-head comparison. Verification method: check whether the resolution presentation preserves its respective wavelength context, and does not set up a \"Webb vs. Hubble at the same wavelength\" direct comparison column or conclusion. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 4: Include the resolution entries together with their associated wavelengths; do not turn them into a same-wavelength head-to-head test..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G09" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF22", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: include a visible source-comparison note for the diameter descriptions in source A's Mirrors section versus source B's table. Verification method: find in the visible content of the PPTX an explicit source-comparison note labeled as comparing the diameter descriptions of A Mirrors and B table. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 6: Include a visible source-comparison note for the diameter and collecting-area descriptions in source A's Mirrors section versus source B's table..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G10" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF23", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: include a visible source-comparison note for the collecting-area descriptions in source A's Mirrors section versus source B's table. Verification method: find in the visible content of the PPTX an explicit source-comparison note labeled as comparing the collecting-area descriptions of A Mirrors and B table. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 6: Include a visible source-comparison note for the diameter and collecting-area descriptions in source A's Mirrors section versus source B's table..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G10" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF24", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: preserve the attribution of each source, with A and B data/claims labeled with their respective sources. Verification method: check that all values, tables, and comparison notes from A or B visibly label source A or source B, and are not merged into data without source attribution. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 6: Preserve each source's attribution and units..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G10" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF25", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: preserve the units of source values, and do not mistake area units for linear units. Verification method: check that values such as diameter, collecting area, wavelength, and resolution preserve their corresponding units; check that m2/ft2 are treated as square meters/square feet, not linear meters/feet. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 6: Preserve each source's attribution and units..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G10" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF26", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: do not average the conflicting diameter or collecting-area values. Verification method: scan the slides and sources.md to confirm that no averaging of A/B conflicting values is performed or presented as a conclusion. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 6: Do not average the conflicting figures.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G10" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF27", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: do not silently choose a single \"corrected\" value to replace the conflicting source data. Verification method: check whether the conflicting values are still presented side by side by source, rather than keeping only one value labeled as correct/corrected without explaining the source difference. Pass criterion: fully meets this requirement; missing, incorrect, or partially met is No. Evaluation tool failure cannot be the basis for No. Verification boundary: verify against the frozen prompt and necessary source files/ground truth; the author's self-report does not replace artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 6: silently choose a single corrected number.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G10" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF28", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: Do not assert without evidence that rounding, an update, or a specific measurement definition explains the source discrepancy. Verification method: Check whether any text attributes the numerical difference to rounding, update, or measurement definition; if present, it must be supported by source evidence. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 6: or assert that rounding, an update, or a specific measurement definition explains the differences without evidence..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G11" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF29", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: Do not treat either source's modification date as a basis for factual precedence. Verification method: Check whether the slides or sources.md judge the A or B values as more authoritative on the grounds of a newer/more recent date; no such inference may appear. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Material basis (relative to inputs/): workspace/README.md original line 7: Neither modification date establishes factual precedence..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G12" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF30", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: Explicitly state that the supplied sources do not resolve the numerical discrepancy. Verification method: In the PPTX's visible source comparison explanation, look for an explicit statement that the supplied sources fail to resolve the discrepancy. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 6: It is acceptable and expected to say that these supplied sources do not resolve the discrepancy..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G10" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF31", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: Include a small editable diagram or comparison graphic that helps distinguish linear diameter from collecting area. Verification method: Look for a selectable, editable shape/diagram and check that its labels or structure clearly distinguish linear diameter from collecting area. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 8: Use a small editable diagram or comparison graphic to help the audience distinguish linear diameter from collecting area..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G13" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF32", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: Do not substitute an effective collecting area computed with a simple circular-disk formula for the collecting-area values in the table. Verification method: Scan formulas, diagram captions, and tables to confirm that no disk-area calculation such as π(d/2)² is used to replace the collecting-area values in the source B table. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 8: Do not calculate effective collecting area from a simple circular disk and substitute it for the table values..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G13" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF33", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: If a derived ratio or calculation appears, it must be explicitly labeled as a calculation. Verification method: If a ratio, ratio, or other derived value appears on the slides or in sources.md, check that it is explicitly labeled as a calculation/derived next to it; if there is no derived value, this item passes. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 8: Derived ratios are optional; label any calculation and its source..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G13" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF34", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: If a derived ratio or calculation appears, its source must be indicated. Verification method: If a derived calculation exists, check that it states the source used for the calculation (A/B and section/table); if there is no derived value, this item passes. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 8: Derived ratios are optional; label any calculation and its source..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G13" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF35", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: Each page has a clear purpose or key point. Verification method: Check page by page whether the title or first sentence states that page's single purpose/key point, with all six pages having an identifiable purpose. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 10: Give each slide a clear purpose.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G14" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF36", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: Table labels, conditions, and uncertainty notes are readable in normal presentation view. Verification method: View at normal 1280×720 view and check that headers/labels, applicable conditions, and uncertainty notes are not truncated and that font size and contrast are sufficient to make them out. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 10: make table labels, conditions and uncertainty notes readable in normal presentation view..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G15" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF37", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: Do not use current news cards, navigation items, or unbundled images as evidence. Verification method: Check whether the slides use news cards, navigation items, or external/unbundled images as support for arguments; simple self-drawn diagrams are allowed. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 10: Do not use current news cards, navigation items or unbundled images as evidence..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G14" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF38", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: sources.md maps each page's claims to source A/B and the corresponding section or table. Verification method: Check sources.md page by page: all six pages have a mapping of claims to source A or B, with section/table noted. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 12: Sources.md must map each slide's claims to source A/B and section/table.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G07" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF39", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: sources.md identifies derived calculations. Verification method: Check whether sources.md lists any derived calculations appearing in the slides; if no derived calculations appear, recording that there are none suffices. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 12: identify derived calculations.", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G07" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "IF40", "dimension": "Task Fulfillment / Compliance", "criterion": "Requirement: sources.md describes the unresolved discrepancy. Verification method: Check whether sources.md explains the A/B numerical difference and its unresolved status, rather than giving only a single conclusion. Pass criterion: This requirement is fully met; missing, incorrect, or partial satisfaction is No. Evaluation-tool failure cannot be the basis for a No. Verification boundary: Verify against the frozen prompt and necessary originals/ground truth; the author's self-report does not substitute for artifact evidence. Task basis: prompt.md original line 12: describe unresolved differences..", "answers": { "Yes": "Complete all necessary checks for this criterion, with actual evidence supporting satisfaction of the requirement; equivalent implementations within the task's scope are allowed.", "No": "At least one necessary requirement is not satisfied; identify evidence of actual omissions, errors, or partial satisfaction." }, "compliance_groups": [ "G07" ], "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "C1", "dimension": "Content", "criterion": "Astronomical terminology and unit expression.\nWhat is measured: Terminology such as primary mirror diameter, collecting area, angular resolution, and wavelength, and the use of the units m, m², arcsec, and µm are accurate; linear diameter and area concepts are not conflated. Audience fit and terminology scaffolding are evaluated by O1/O2 and are not repeated in this item.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Check whether m and m² in the table and body text correspond to the correct physical quantities. Check whether the resolution entry is stated in arcsec and is adjacent to the wavelength (µm). Check whether there is any statement treating the 2.75× factor as an area ratio or calling diameter area.\nScoring boundary: Whether the terminology, concepts, and wording allow this task's audience to understand accurately; IF checks factual implementation, and C1 does not award points for terminology quantity.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most easily confused concepts and qualifiers remain concise and accurate, and summaries, details, and actual examples show no drift in meaning.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: The core understanding or usage goal of this item cannot be achieved. Specific manifestation: treating the diameter ratio 2.75 as an area ratio, or mismatching arcsec/µm units with physical quantities, misleading the core concept. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple places conflate linear diameter and area, or incorrect expression of resolution units makes the meaning incomprehensible to the audience. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: individual terms (such as collecting area and mirror size) have ambiguous boundaries, but the context can correct them. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: Terminology and units are correct; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: key terms are all accurate, m, m², arcsec, and µm are used consistently, and linear diameter and area are not conflated. Quality improvement must be reflected in: easily confused terms, quantities, or references are briefly clarified where they appear, reducing the need for readers to guess. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: terminology is accurate and consistent, and the conceptual boundaries between linear diameter/area and wavelength/resolution are proactively clarified within the pages. Quality improvement must be reflected in: definitions, qualifiers, and actual labels support each other, so complex meanings require no cross-region assembly. terminology and units are rigorously and consistently used, and conceptual distinctions are conveyed naturally through layout and labeling without introducing extraneous terminology. The most easily confused concepts and qualifiers remain concise and accurate, and summaries, details, and actual examples show no drift in meaning. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: Terminology such as primary mirror diameter, collecting area, angular resolution, and wavelength, and the use of the units m, m², arcsec, and µm are accurate; linear diameter and area concepts are not conflated. Audience fit and terminology scaffolding are evaluated by O1/O2 and are not repeated in this item. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most easily confused concepts and qualifiers remain concise and accurate, and summaries, details, and actual examples show no drift in meaning. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. An unusually economical conceptual formulation makes a genuinely confusable distinction directly understandable, with less interpretation than an equally accurate, concise conventional explanation. Identify the distinction and the wording/representation that produces this extra understanding; merely correct terminology or fluent prose is not exceptional. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: Terminology such as primary mirror diameter, collecting area, angular resolution, and wavelength, and the use of the units m, m², arcsec, and µm are accurate; linear diameter and area concepts are not conflated. Audience fit and terminology scaffolding are evaluated by O1/O2 and are not repeated in this item. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most easily confused concepts and qualifiers remain concise and accurate, and summaries, details, and actual examples show no drift in meaning. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 9, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "C2", "dimension": "Content", "criterion": "Fidelity of facts, values, and source attribution.\nWhat is measured: B table's structure/diameter/area/wavelength/resolution entries and A's Mirrors narrative are all faithfully presented and attributable; no telescope capability assertions not present in the snapshot are introduced (e.g., Hubble cannot observe infrared at all, Webb is only stronger in magnification).\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Check values such as 6.5/6.6, 2.4, 25.37, 4.55, 0.6–28.8, 0.115–2.5, 0.03@0.6µm, 0.05@near0.5µm. Check whether each claim is labeled A/B and Mirrors/table name. Check whether absolutist capability assertions unsupported by the snapshot appear.\nScoring boundary: The support relationship between task claims and evidence/data/actual process; does not repeatedly evaluate graphic encoding or whether source documents are easy to find.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most complex key comparison or state chain can still be checked item by item; approximations, limitations, and counterexamples are not obscured by conclusions.\nScenario reference · content quality (no new thresholds): cover; why the two telescopes are complementary; B table structure/diameter/area/wavelength; resolution and corresponding wavelength; linear diameter vs collecting area diagram; source differences and unresolved explanation (may be integrated within the visible six pages).\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): no additional astronomical facts beyond Hubble/Webb parameters or internet research is required.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): A's source attribution and units (m, m²) and B's table row values must remain as-is; do not average, do not silently pick one, and do not speculate about the cause of differences.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: The core understanding or usage goal of this item cannot be achieved. Specific manifestation: fabricating or altering key values/capabilities, clearly conflicting with the fixed snapshot. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple numerical or attribution errors, or capability assertions unsupported by the snapshot that affect core understanding. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: individual values/attributions are imprecise (e.g., missing units or a minor wavelength-boundary error) but the source is identifiable. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: The mirror diameter/area, wavelength/resolution, and source attribution used are correct, and the two sources' divergence is not arbitrarily averaged or given fabricated explanations; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: values, units, and section attribution are all correct, and the A/B source of each claim is clearly identified. Quality improvement must be reflected in: key claims correspond closely to the values, conditions, or process evidence used, making checking more direct. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: all key claims can be traced item by item to A Mirrors or the specified B table, and derived values are separated from source data. Quality improvement must be reflected in: evidence selection, comparison basis, and conclusion strength work together, making clear what can and cannot be inferred. on the basis of complete fidelity, source attribution and expression of uncertainty become part of the explanatory structure. The most complex key comparison or state chain can still be checked item by item; approximations, limitations, and counterexamples are not obscured by conclusions. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: B table's structure/diameter/area/wavelength/resolution entries and A's Mirrors narrative are all faithfully presented and attributable; no telescope capability assertions not present in the snapshot are introduced (e.g., Hubble cannot observe infrared at all, Webb is only stronger in magnification). Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most complex key comparison or state chain can still be checked item by item; approximations, limitations, and counterexamples are not obscured by conclusions. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. A non-obvious presentation of the evidence exposes an important conditional relationship that a flawless fact-and-citation account would leave the reader to reconstruct. Show the additional understanding and its support, without inventing a claim, requiring more data, or rewarding the count of sources. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: B table's structure/diameter/area/wavelength/resolution entries and A's Mirrors narrative are all faithfully presented and attributable; no telescope capability assertions not present in the snapshot are introduced (e.g., Hubble cannot observe infrared at all, Webb is only stronger in magnification). In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most complex key comparison or state chain can still be checked item by item; approximations, limitations, and counterexamples are not obscured by conclusions. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 9, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "C3", "dimension": "Content", "criterion": "Conflict presentation and information selection.\nWhat is measured: Provide an explicit source-comparison explanation of the A/B differences in diameter and collecting area, retaining each one's values and units, without making unsupported judgments; at the same time, select information according to the science-communication purpose, without forcing every source fact onto the screen.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Look for side-by-side A/B comparisons and units in both the diameter and the area locations. Check whether unsupported explanations such as rounding/update/measurement definition appear. Check whether it explicitly states the supplied sources do not resolve the discrepancy.\nScoring boundary: Content selection, density, tone, and necessary qualifiers around the scenario purpose; not font size or page visual hierarchy.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even at the most information-dense points there is appropriate selection, key points and exceptions are understandable, and there is no redundant expansion or oversimplification.\nTask scenario: A six-page English science-communication PPTX for an astronomy club's online/offline sharing session; normal viewing on 16:9 projection, delivered together with six 1280×720 preview PNGs and a source-mapping explanation.\nScenario reference · audience (no new thresholds): Club members with basic astronomy knowledge who are willing to understand differences in mirror diameter/collecting area/resolution.\nScenario reference · purpose (no new thresholds): A roughly several-minute science-communication talk, focused on explaining the complementary relationship between the two telescopes, the difference in primary-mirror structure, and the unresolved numerical difference between the two NASA snapshots.\nScenario reference · content selection (no new thresholds): Restrained facts, clear units and attribution, conflicts explicitly presented and not arbitrarily adjudicated; tables and simple diagrams serve understanding rather than decoration.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): no redesign or repair of parts outside the prompt is required, and no adjudication of real telescope parameters or introduction of external authoritative sources is required.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): no display of page publication date/modification time is required; only snapshot traceability is required.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): no unification into a single \"standard\" collecting area or diameter is required.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): derived ratios such as 6.6/2.4=2.75 are not required to appear.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): resolution entries must appear paired with their corresponding wavelength, and must not be rewritten as same-wavelength head-to-head comparisons.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): if a diagram is qualitative it must be labeled \"not to scale\"; the area ratio must not be drawn as equal to the diameter ratio, and π(d/2)² must not be used to replace the table's collecting area.\nContent focus: Hubble/Webb mirror diameter-area/wavelength-resolution, the unresolved numerical difference between the two sources, complementarity rather than simple superiority\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: The core understanding or usage goal of this item cannot be achieved. Specific manifestation: silently choosing one value or asserting that A has corrected B, erasing the conflict. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: although values are presented side by side, implying that one side is correct, or omitting a key conflict explanation so that the audience mistakenly believes the values agree. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: a comparison is present but it does not clearly state that \"the available sources cannot resolve the difference,\" and readers may misread. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: The two sources' differences are presented side by side without adjudication; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: explicit comparison and a clear statement that the differences between snapshots are unexplained, with units and attribution retained. Quality improvement must be reflected in: removing restatements that do not aid understanding or placing necessary qualifiers where needed, making the key point more direct. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the comparison explanation is clearly structured, distinguishing \"factual differences\" from \"unverified explanations,\" with selection serving the explanatory purpose. Quality improvement must be reflected in: primary/secondary emphasis, depth of explanation, and tone suited to the audience; condensed content still retains necessary conditions. conflict handling is mature: it both faithfully preserves and serves the main explanatory thread, letting the audience understand the evidence boundary without getting lost in details. Even at the most information-dense points there is appropriate selection, key points and exceptions are understandable, and there is no redundant expansion or oversimplification. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: Provide an explicit source-comparison explanation of the A/B differences in diameter and collecting area, retaining each one's values and units, without making unsupported judgments; at the same time, select information according to the science-communication purpose, without forcing every source fact onto the screen. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even at the most information-dense points there is appropriate selection, key points and exceptions are understandable, and there is no redundant expansion or oversimplification. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. An unusually incisive selection resolves the tension between necessary qualifications and the audience’s main purpose: it conveys more useful understanding with no loss of required substance. Explain why a conventionally fully refined summary would still impose more interpretation; brevity, completeness or promotional impact alone is insufficient. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: Provide an explicit source-comparison explanation of the A/B differences in diameter and collecting area, retaining each one's values and units, without making unsupported judgments; at the same time, select information according to the science-communication purpose, without forcing every source fact onto the screen. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even at the most information-dense points there is appropriate selection, key points and exceptions are understandable, and there is no redundant expansion or oversimplification. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 7, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "O1", "dimension": "Organization", "criterion": "Six-page explanatory logical path.\nWhat is measured: The six pages (including the cover) form a clear science-communication progression: from complementarity and problem introduction, to structure/scale/wavelength, to resolution conditions, then to the conceptual distinction between linear diameter and area, and finally to source differences and the evidence boundary; only page order and each page's purpose are evaluated, while within-page argumentation belongs to O2.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Record the title and core message of each page and check whether they form a causal progression. Check whether the resolution page follows on from the structure/wavelength page. Check whether the differences page naturally concludes after the conceptual distinction.\nScoring boundary: The logic of the overall argumentation/decision/operation/conceptual path, not scored against a fixed structural template.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most complex branch or comparison can still be incorporated into the main line, the conclusion is grounded, and there are no dangling steps or repetitive detours.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: The core understanding or usage goal of this item cannot be achieved. Specific manifestation: chaotic page order, so readers cannot form a reasoning chain from complementarity to the conflict explanation. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple jumps or missing key connections that detach the resolution or difference explanation from the preceding text. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: there is broadly a path, but the causal relationships between some pages and their neighbors are weak. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: The six pages are reasonably ordered, and each page has an identifiable purpose; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: each page's purpose is clear, and transitions between pages are natural. Quality improvement must be reflected in: one key turning point clearly connects the premise to the next step, making the main line easier to follow. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the logical chain is complete and complementarity, scale, resolution, and the difference explanation support one another. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the premises, development, and conclusions of each part refer back to one another, and the order and length serve this task's explanation or decision. the explanatory path is compact and rhythmic, and the selection and order make the complex comparison easy for the club audience to follow. The most complex branch or comparison can still be incorporated into the main line, the conclusion is grounded, and there are no dangling steps or repetitive detours. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: The six pages (including the cover) form a clear science-communication progression: from complementarity and problem introduction, to structure/scale/wavelength, to resolution conditions, then to the conceptual distinction between linear diameter and area, and finally to source differences and the evidence boundary; only page order and each page's purpose are evaluated, while within-page argumentation belongs to O2. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most complex branch or comparison can still be incorporated into the main line, the conclusion is grounded, and there are no dangling steps or repetitive detours. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. A non-obvious organization of the existing argument or user path makes separate necessary parts illuminate one another and materially reduces reasoning or navigation steps. Compare the benefit with an equally complete, logically sound conventional order; no additional section or prescribed order is required. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: The six pages (including the cover) form a clear science-communication progression: from complementarity and problem introduction, to structure/scale/wavelength, to resolution conditions, then to the conceptual distinction between linear diameter and area, and finally to source differences and the evidence boundary; only page order and each page's purpose are evaluated, while within-page argumentation belongs to O2. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most complex branch or comparison can still be incorporated into the main line, the conclusion is grounded, and there are no dangling steps or repetitive detours. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 6, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "O2", "dimension": "Organization", "criterion": "Within-page argumentation and local development.\nWhat is measured: The information within each page develops around a single clear purpose, and table labels, conditions, and uncertainty notes are semantically connected to the adjacent discussion, so that readers do not have to assemble the causal relationships within the page themselves; only within-page argumentation structure is evaluated, not cross-page semantic continuity.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Check whether table labels and uncertainty notes are close to the corresponding values. Check whether each page has only one dominant purpose. Check whether resolution conditions are in the same semantic unit as the wavelength.\nScoring boundary: The semantic order and relationships of explanations within a single page, stage, node, or comparison unit.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the most complex units can be understood in the order needed, and local explanations are concise and self-contained while consistent with the overall main line.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: The core understanding or usage goal of this item cannot be achieved. Specific manifestation: within-page information is piled up with no primary/secondary structure, and key conditions and notes are detached from their objects. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple notes, conditions, or uncertainty explanations are ambiguously placed and easily misread. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: local development within individual pages is loose, but the main point is still discernible. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: The within-page structure is readable, and each piece of information has its place; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: local discussion is orderly, and conditions and notes are adjacent to their objects. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the arrangement of objects, explanations, and results within a local unit reduces one necessary re-check. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: within-page arguments, evidence, and notes form a clear hierarchy, and readers need no look-back to assemble them. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the graphics, text, conditions, and conclusions of each main unit form relationships that can be understood in place. the local development of each page is refined and guided, and the notes themselves serve the argumentation. Even the most complex units can be understood in the order needed, and local explanations are concise and self-contained while consistent with the overall main line. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: The information within each page develops around a single clear purpose, and table labels, conditions, and uncertainty notes are semantically connected to the adjacent discussion, so that readers do not have to assemble the causal relationships within the page themselves; only within-page argumentation structure is evaluated, not cross-page semantic continuity. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the most complex units can be understood in the order needed, and local explanations are concise and self-contained while consistent with the overall main line. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. An economical local organization makes a difficult relationship among conditions, evidence and objects understandable as one unit rather than assembled mentally from carefully grouped parts. Identify the semantic reconstruction it eliminates; proximity and tidy grouping alone do not qualify. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: The information within each page develops around a single clear purpose, and table labels, conditions, and uncertainty notes are semantically connected to the adjacent discussion, so that readers do not have to assemble the causal relationships within the page themselves; only within-page argumentation structure is evaluated, not cross-page semantic continuity. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the most complex units can be understood in the order needed, and local explanations are concise and self-contained while consistent with the overall main line. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 5, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "O3", "dimension": "Organization", "criterion": "Cross-page identity, terminology, and page-purpose inheritance.\nWhat is measured: The six pages share a consistent section identity and terminology (e.g., Webb/Hubble naming, the term collecting area), and when the same value is referenced across pages it stays consistent and lets readers know which thread is being continued; only cross-page identity/terminology/value inheritance and inter-page semantic continuity are evaluated, while within-page argumentation belongs to O2.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Compare the Webb/Hubble naming and unit notation across pages. Check whether the same value is consistent when it appears on multiple pages. Check whether there are cross-page reference markers (titles, colors, phrases).\nScoring boundary: Semantic inheritance across pages/states, or the closure of a single page's branch path with identity/action; does not force a new ending.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; complex branches, final states, or resets still maintain identity and causal continuity, and readers do not need later information to repair the current meaning.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nEvaluate meaning carried across the actual slides, not invented software branches or reset states.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: The core understanding or usage goal of this item cannot be achieved. Specific manifestation: the same value or term contradicts itself across pages, so readers mistake them for different objects. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple naming/unit inconsistencies or threads that abruptly break off. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: terminology or references on individual pages are not unified, but can be inferred. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: Cross-page consistency, and the thread can be followed; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: naming, units, and color semantics are stable across pages. Quality improvement must be reflected in: one cross-page, cross-region, or cross-state transition clearly preserves object identity and established meaning. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: cross-page identity and thread inheritance are clear, and value references are consistent. Quality improvement must be reflected in: main transitions, branches, and endings form continuous semantics; the position of repeated objects and necessary exceptions is traceable. the pages form a coherent explanatory identity, with terminology and value references natural and seamless. Complex branches, final states, or resets still maintain identity and causal continuity, and readers do not need later information to repair the current meaning. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: The six pages share a consistent section identity and terminology (e.g., Webb/Hubble naming, the term collecting area), and when the same value is referenced across pages it stays consistent and lets readers know which thread is being continued; only cross-page identity/terminology/value inheritance and inter-page semantic continuity are evaluated, while within-page argumentation belongs to O2. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; complex branches, final states, or resets still maintain identity and causal continuity, and readers do not need later information to repair the current meaning. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. A purposeful carry-over lets the audience preserve and develop the right meaning through the task’s actual transitions, materially reducing reconstruction beyond fully refined referential consistency. Identify what understanding accumulates; do not invent branches, endings or reset states absent from the task. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: The six pages share a consistent section identity and terminology (e.g., Webb/Hubble naming, the term collecting area), and when the same value is referenced across pages it stays consistent and lets readers know which thread is being continued; only cross-page identity/terminology/value inheritance and inter-page semantic continuity are evaluated, while within-page argumentation belongs to O2. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; complex branches, final states, or resets still maintain identity and causal continuity, and readers do not need later information to repair the current meaning. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 4, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "V1", "dimension": "Visuals", "criterion": "Visual hierarchy and focus.\nWhat is measured: Each page has a clear primary visual focus (title or key comparison table/diagram), and secondary information does not compete with it for attention, so that at projection distance readers see the core information first.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: View once as thumbnails and once at full size, and record where the eye lands first on each page. Check the font size and positional weight of titles, tables/diagrams, and notes.\nScoring boundary: The salience relationships among title, main body, evidence, and supporting information; evaluates the attention entry point, core focus, and emphasis strength.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the densest region or state shows the main information first and the evidence and qualifiers second, with no substantive attention competition between the whole and the parts.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nJudge negative visual grades by substantive harm and extent within this criterion, not a prerequisite of functional unusability. Harmless style differences are not defects; retain the original concrete defect examples.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: This criterion’s visual goal is severely impaired. Specific manifestation: the page has no focus, all elements have equal weight, and readers do not know where to look first. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: the focus is drowned out by decoration or long passages of text, and key tables/diagrams are not prominent. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: a focus exists but is locally disturbed by secondary elements. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: Each page has a discernible focus, and the information hierarchy is readable; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: the focus is stable, and the relationship between title and main body is clear. Quality improvement must be reflected in: a set of positional, scale, or contrast choices makes the primary focus clearer, so supporting information does not compete for reading attention. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the hierarchy has a primary/secondary rhythm, and key tables/diagrams become natural visual entry points. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the strength relationships among the primary focus, evidence, and necessary qualifiers are coordinated and adjusted reasonably with content complexity. the focus arrangement is refined and powerful, guiding reading order at projection scale. Even the densest region or state shows the main information first and the evidence and qualifiers second, with no substantive attention competition between the whole and the parts. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: Each page has a clear primary visual focus (title or key comparison table/diagram), and secondary information does not compete with it for attention, so that at projection distance readers see the core information first. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the densest region or state shows the main information first and the evidence and qualifiers second, with no substantive attention competition between the whole and the parts. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. A non-obvious hierarchy brings the decisive relationship and its necessary qualification into attention together without competing emphasis. Demonstrate a first-look interpretation benefit beyond an impeccably clear primary/secondary hierarchy, not just stronger contrast or larger type. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: Each page has a clear primary visual focus (title or key comparison table/diagram), and secondary information does not compete with it for attention, so that at projection distance readers see the core information first. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the densest region or state shows the main information first and the evidence and qualifiers second, with no substantive attention competition between the whole and the parts. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 5, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "V2", "dimension": "Visuals", "criterion": "Block proportions, layout, and whitespace.\nWhat is measured: Within the 16:9 page, block proportions are coordinated, margins and alignment of tables, diagrams, and text are consistent, and whitespace serves information grouping rather than creating emptiness or crowding.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Check the margins and the alignment baselines of tables/diagrams on each page. Check whether any content is close to the edge or whether whitespace is unbalanced. Check whether table column widths match the amount of information.\nScoring boundary: The area proportions, grid, edges, center of gravity, density, and whitespace among information blocks; evaluates overall composition and spatial organization.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the region with the greatest density or state variation retains a stable spatial order, with overall balance and local spacing both holding.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nJudge negative visual grades by substantive harm and extent within this criterion, not a prerequisite of functional unusability. Harmless style differences are not defects; retain the original concrete defect examples.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: This criterion’s visual goal is severely impaired. Specific manifestation: unbalanced layout, content overflow or large-area misalignment, obstructing normal viewing. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple block proportion imbalances or chaotic alignment that affect reading. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: whitespace or alignment on individual pages is clearly unstable. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: The layout is orderly, and proportions and whitespace are acceptable; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: margins, alignment, and zoning are unified, and whitespace has a grouping intent. Quality improvement must be reflected in: block edges, scale, or whitespace have a clear purpose, improving the spatial relationships of a class of content. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the layouts of the pages maintain proportional rhythm through variation, and whitespace reinforces the comparison structure. Quality improvement must be reflected in: area proportions, alignment, center of gravity, and whitespace together adapt to the actual content rather than mechanically applying the same layout. the layout is mature, and proportions and whitespace precisely serve explanation and projection viewing. Even the region with the greatest density or state variation retains a stable spatial order, with overall balance and local spacing both holding. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: Within the 16:9 page, block proportions are coordinated, margins and alignment of tables, diagrams, and text are consistent, and whitespace serves information grouping rather than creating emptiness or crowding. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the region with the greatest density or state variation retains a stable spatial order, with overall balance and local spacing both holding. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. A content-specific spatial solution reconciles competing demands of overview, detail and available space with exceptional clarity and balance. Identify the real space conflict resolved beyond a flawlessly fitted conventional composition; extra whitespace, density or a fashionable layout is not itself a benefit. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: Within the 16:9 page, block proportions are coordinated, margins and alignment of tables, diagrams, and text are consistent, and whitespace serves information grouping rather than creating emptiness or crowding. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the region with the greatest density or state variation retains a stable spatial order, with overall balance and local spacing both holding. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 8, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "V3", "dimension": "Visuals", "criterion": "Font sizes, line spacing, and projection readability.\nWhat is measured: The font sizes and line spacing of titles, headers, table bodies, and notes are readable at normal 1280×720 viewing distance, and table labels and uncertainty notes are not compressed to illegibility.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: At full 1280×720 size, check the minimum font size of table bodies and notes. Check the line breaks of long labels and wavelength ranges. Check whether line spacing makes the table crowded.\nScoring boundary: The complete visibility, font size, contrast, line spacing, and line breaking of text in the actual delivered image; evaluates text presentation and reading at the target scale.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the longest necessary labels, small qualifiers, or complex symbols remain complete and easy to read, and typographic quality is consistently stable across regions.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nJudge negative visual grades by substantive harm and extent within this criterion, not a prerequisite of functional unusability. Harmless style differences are not defects; retain the original concrete defect examples.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: This criterion’s visual goal is severely impaired. Specific manifestation: key table bodies or notes have excessively small font size / overly dense line spacing and cannot be read in normal viewing. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple places of text are hard to make out at projection scale, affecting understanding. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: individual notes or table bodies are somewhat small and require leaning in to read. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: The text is readable, and the font-size hierarchy is discernible; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: the font sizes of table bodies and notes are clear, and line spacing is comfortable. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the font size, spacing, or line breaking of a class of necessary text reduces reading burden, and cannot be based merely on being legible. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the font-size system corresponds to information importance, and long labels break lines reasonably. Quality improvement must be reflected in: font size, line spacing, contrast, and semantic line breaking are coordinated, so dense content remains comfortably readable at the scale defined by the prompt. the typographic scale precisely matches projection viewing, and notes also remain comfortably readable. The longest necessary labels, small qualifiers, or complex symbols remain complete and easy to read, and typographic quality is consistently stable across regions. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: The font sizes and line spacing of titles, headers, table bodies, and notes are readable at normal 1280×720 viewing distance, and table labels and uncertainty notes are not compressed to illegibility. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the longest necessary labels, small qualifiers, or complex symbols remain complete and easy to read, and typographic quality is consistently stable across regions. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. Typographic structure makes a difficult meaning or relationship apparent as it is read, reducing parsing beyond fully refined legibility, spacing and hierarchy. Identify the specific semantic contribution at the required viewing scale; a distinctive font or decorative lettering is not sufficient. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: The font sizes and line spacing of titles, headers, table bodies, and notes are readable at normal 1280×720 viewing distance, and table labels and uncertainty notes are not compressed to illegibility. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the longest necessary labels, small qualifiers, or complex symbols remain complete and easy to read, and typographic quality is consistently stable across regions. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 7, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "V4", "dimension": "Visuals", "criterion": "Decoding of graphics, arrows, and table symbols.\nWhat is measured: The linear diameter vs collecting area diagram, table symbols (m², µm, arcsec, multiplier), and any arrows/annotations can be correctly decoded and do not imply a wrong area-diameter ratio.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Check whether the area diagram is scaled by area rather than diameter or is clearly labeled not to scale. Check whether arrows and figure captions point to the correct objects. Check whether the m²/µm/arcsec symbols are consistent and unambiguous.\nScoring boundary: The legibility and semantic correspondence of graphic markers, lines, arrows, symbols, and dynamic states; evaluates accurate decoding and reliable comparison.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most complex connections, states, or scale relationships can still be reliably decoded, and the legend and actual content have no ambiguity or misleading elements.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nJudge negative visual grades by substantive harm and extent within this criterion, not a prerequisite of functional unusability. Harmless style differences are not defects; retain the original concrete defect examples.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: This criterion’s visual goal is severely impaired. Specific manifestation: diagrams or symbols directly mislead (e.g., area drawn in proportion to diameter), distorting the core concept. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple places of graphic annotation or symbols are ambiguous, and readers must guess their meaning. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: individual symbols or figure captions are imprecise but correctable. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: Graphics and table symbols are readable, and their meaning is discernible; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: the diagram has clear labels and a not-to-scale note, and symbols are consistent. Quality improvement must be reflected in: a set of markers, connections, or comparisons makes object relationships more directly decodable, reducing guesswork about the figure. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the graphics accurately distinguish linear diameter from area, and the labels echo the table values. Quality improvement must be reflected in: graphic encoding, labels, and actual relationships support one another; complex comparisons do not require extra explanation to correct the figure's meaning. the graphic language is precise and restrained, and symbols and labels form a self-explanatory comparison. The most complex connections, states, or scale relationships can still be reliably decoded, and the legend and actual content have no ambiguity or misleading elements. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: The linear diameter vs collecting area diagram, table symbols (m², µm, arcsec, multiplier), and any arrows/annotations can be correctly decoded and do not imply a wrong area-diameter ratio. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most complex connections, states, or scale relationships can still be reliably decoded, and the legend and actual content have no ambiguity or misleading elements. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. A visual encoding makes a difficult relationship directly perceptible instead of requiring mental reconstruction from fully correct labels and marks. Show what becomes easier to understand and verify fidelity to the source or required state; novelty and additional diagrams are not requirements. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: The linear diameter vs collecting area diagram, table symbols (m², µm, arcsec, multiplier), and any arrows/annotations can be correctly decoded and do not imply a wrong area-diameter ratio. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most complex connections, states, or scale relationships can still be reliably decoded, and the legend and actual content have no ambiguity or misleading elements. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 5, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "V5", "dimension": "Visuals", "criterion": "Graphic and typographic tone for the astronomy science-communication scenario.\nWhat is measured: The visual language (graphic abstraction, typographic tone, table and component style) is integrated into a restrained and consistent comparative explanatory language that serves comparison and explanation, rather than applying news cards or decorative graphics; color harmony alone does not support this item, nor does it impose a fixed aesthetic.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Check whether news cards/navigation-style components are used. Check whether the diagrams and tables share the same graphic language. Check whether the typographic tone matches astronomy-club science communication.\nScoring boundary: Audience, purpose, medium temperament, and the integration of graphic abstraction, typography, images, and component surface language; purely color aesthetics are deferred to V9.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the most difficult content to integrate is coordinated with the overall visual language; when information is complete, there is still a clear, restrained scenario expression.\nScenario reference · visual language (no new thresholds): A restrained scientific-institution style, stable title/body hierarchy and color scheme, unified graphic language, avoiding news cards and navigation-style decoration.\nScenario reference · design constraints (no new thresholds): A's Mirrors narrative (Webb 6.5m, area \"more than six times\") and B's table (6.6m, 25.37/4.55 m², 5.6 times) have inconsistent values; resolution entries correspond to different wavelengths and are easily misread as a same-wavelength showdown; and within the limited six pages there is a need to balance the complementarity explanation with the presentation of differences.\nScenario reference · design goal (no new thresholds): Readers can accurately distinguish linear diameter from collecting area, correctly understand that resolution varies jointly with wavelength and mirror diameter, clearly see the differences between the two sources and the conclusion that \"the available sources cannot adjudicate,\" and all claims can be traced back to specific sections of A/B.\nScoring boundary: V9 independently evaluates the aesthetic harmony and refinement of the color scheme; reading impairment caused by text contrast belongs to V3, mismatches between color and object meaning belong to V4, and cross-page color-code identity drift belongs to V7. Attribute across items only when different functional impairments are demonstrated. V5 must not merely repeat V9's color-quality judgment, and V9 must not award a professional tier directly on the grounds of \"fitting the scenario.\"\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nJudge negative visual grades by substantive harm and extent within this criterion, not a prerequisite of functional unusability. Harmless style differences are not defects; retain the original concrete defect examples.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: This criterion’s visual goal is severely impaired. Specific manifestation: the visual language conflicts with the science-communication purpose, or a large amount of news-card-style decoration steals the show. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: graphic and typographic styles are split apart, and comparison information is weakened by decoration. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: the overall result is acceptable, but the style of local components is jarring. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: The style is restrained and unified, and can carry science-communication content; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: the tone of graphics, typography, and tables is coordinated and serves comparison. Quality improvement must be reflected in: specific choices in graphic abstraction, typography, or image treatment improve audience understanding and the overall look. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the component language is unified and can express differences in scale and conditions. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the coordinated service of typography, graphics, images, or component language to this task's purpose, not substituting good-looking colors for analysis. the visual language is maturely integrated, restrained, and serves comparative explanation, and does not replace content with decoration or color harmony. Even the most difficult content to integrate is coordinated with the overall visual language; when information is complete, there is still a clear, restrained scenario expression. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: The visual language (graphic abstraction, typographic tone, table and component style) is integrated into a restrained and consistent comparative explanatory language that serves comparison and explanation, rather than applying news cards or decorative graphics; color harmony alone does not support this item, nor does it impose a fixed aesthetic. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the most difficult content to integrate is coordinated with the overall visual language; when information is complete, there is still a clear, restrained scenario expression. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. A distinctive but appropriate visual language makes the subject or purpose intrinsic to the graphic form, beyond flawless stylistic integration. Identify a non-color design contribution and its communication benefit; personal taste, modernity and impressive decoration are not evidence. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: The visual language (graphic abstraction, typographic tone, table and component style) is integrated into a restrained and consistent comparative explanatory language that serves comparison and explanation, rather than applying news cards or decorative graphics; color harmony alone does not support this item, nor does it impose a fixed aesthetic. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; even the most difficult content to integrate is coordinated with the overall visual language; when information is complete, there is still a clear, restrained scenario expression. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 7, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "V6", "dimension": "Visuals", "criterion": "Local geometry, endpoints, line weights, and optical alignment.\nWhat is measured: Diagram endpoints, arrows, table lines, annotation leader lines, and cropping are locally precise; line thickness and endpoints do not create ambiguity; and there is optical alignment visually.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Zoom in and check whether arrow endpoints and annotation leader lines land in the correct positions. Check the consistency of table lines and figure frame line weights. Check whether graphics are unintentionally cropped.\nScoring boundary: Graphic outlines, line weights, endpoints, image proportions and cropping, geometry and optical alignment within components; evaluates local construction precision.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the finest connections, complex intersections, or irregular outlines are still handled sufficiently, and local workmanship does not undermine the overall effect.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nJudge negative visual grades by substantive harm and extent within this criterion, not a prerequisite of functional unusability. Harmless style differences are not defects; retain the original concrete defect examples.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: This criterion’s visual goal is severely impaired. Specific manifestation: graphic endpoints/arrows/leader lines point to the wrong place or are clearly cropped, causing misreading. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple places of rough local geometry that affect diagram decoding. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: One clearly visible workmanship defect in an endpoint, boundary, cropping, proportion, or alignment substantively reduces local construction quality. Provide actual-impact evidence in the relevant parts of this task regarding local geometry, endpoints, line weights, and optical alignment; ordinary performance, harmless small differences, or pure personal preference do not trigger a negative tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: Local geometry is orderly and readable; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: endpoints, leader lines, and table lines are precise, and line weights have hierarchy. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the handling of a class of endpoints, line weights, cropping, or optical alignment is more precise than ordinary neatness. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: local workmanship is meticulous, and the alignment of graphics and tables holds up under close inspection. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the geometry, boundaries, and image proportions of different components are coordinated, and are stable both up close and in overall viewing. local geometry and line language are precise and consistent, and remain rigorous under close inspection. The finest connections, complex intersections, or irregular outlines are still handled sufficiently, and local workmanship does not undermine the overall effect. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: Diagram endpoints, arrows, table lines, annotation leader lines, and cropping are locally precise; line thickness and endpoints do not create ambiguity; and there is optical alignment visually. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the finest connections, complex intersections, or irregular outlines are still handled sufficiently, and local workmanship does not undermine the overall effect. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. Fine construction resolves a real perceptual ambiguity at the task’s most demanding local junction or component, beyond spotless alignment and uniform polish. Identify the optical or geometric benefit visible at the intended scale; more detail or tiny changes with no perceptible benefit do not qualify. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: Diagram endpoints, arrows, table lines, annotation leader lines, and cropping are locally precise; line thickness and endpoints do not create ambiguity; and there is optical alignment visually. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the finest connections, complex intersections, or irregular outlines are still handled sufficiently, and local workmanship does not undermine the overall effect. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 6, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "V7", "dimension": "Visuals", "criterion": "Cross-page visible identity and content consistency.\nWhat is measured: The six pages share consistent title/footer/color semantics and source-annotation styles; the same comparison object maintains the same visual identity across different pages, with no inter-page style breaks or inconsistent value presentation.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Compare the title/footer/source-annotation styles of each page. Check whether the same object's color or icon is consistent. Check whether the presentation format of the same value is unified across pages.\nScoring boundary: The stable correspondence of the same object, identity, markers, styles, and content across pages, states, and carriers; evaluates visual inheritance.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; complex states or the most dense content remain consistent across all required carriers; identity, layout, and qualifiers are all stably traceable.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nCheck recurring objects in the actual slides and required exports; do not demand additional export formats.\nJudge negative visual grades by substantive harm and extent within this criterion, not a prerequisite of functional unusability. Harmless style differences are not defects; retain the original concrete defect examples.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: This criterion’s visual goal is severely impaired. Specific manifestation: an obvious break in style or value presentation across pages, so readers mistakenly think the object has changed. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple cross-page inconsistencies in style or annotation method that weaken overall credibility. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: individual pages have missing elements or style drift. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: Cross-page consistency, and it is recognizable as the same set of slides; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: titles, source annotations, and color semantics are stable across pages. Quality improvement must be reflected in: repeated objects or corresponding carriers follow clear visual rules, reducing the burden of re-identification. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: cross-page identity is unified, and value/source annotation methods are consistent. Quality improvement must be reflected in: state changes, repeated components, and necessary exports correspond to one another, with content changes distinguished but identity not drifting. cross-page consistency becomes part of credibility and is also unified in the details. Complex states or the most dense content remain consistent across all required carriers; identity, layout, and qualifiers are all stably traceable. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: The six pages share consistent title/footer/color semantics and source-annotation styles; the same comparison object maintains the same visual identity across different pages, with no inter-page style breaks or inconsistent value presentation. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; complex states or the most dense content remain consistent across all required carriers; identity, layout, and qualifiers are all stably traceable. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. A deliberately designed recurring visible identity enables recognition across the task’s genuinely different views or presentations with materially less re-identification effort than fully refined consistency alone. Name the recognition benefit and verify it across actual delivered contexts, without requiring nonexistent extra versions. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: The six pages share consistent title/footer/color semantics and source-annotation styles; the same comparison object maintains the same visual identity across different pages, with no inter-page style breaks or inconsistent value presentation. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; complex states or the most dense content remain consistent across all required carriers; identity, layout, and qualifiers are all stably traceable. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 3, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "V8", "dimension": "Visuals", "criterion": "Static reading path and dwell.\nWhat is measured: As a static presentation, each page's information density, visual scanning path, and reading rhythm allow readers to complete the visual reading of that page within a normal dwell time; tables and notes do not require repeated look-backs. Static only evaluates visual scanning/attention shifts/reading rhythm; whether semantics carry across pages belongs to O3, and dynamic motion experience is not assessed in this task.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Simulate a normal presentation dwell time and read page by page. Check whether tables + notes require back-and-forth look-backs. Check whether each page's amount of information exceeds a single purpose.\nScoring boundary: The movement of the eye between information units, and content reveal, dwell, motion, and transitions; evaluates scanning and temporal rhythm.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most dense content or the most complex handoffs can still be followed calmly, and the overall and detailed rhythm of a complete reading or playback cycle is consistent.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): footers, page numbers, icons, animations, or transitions are not required.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all relevant items apply; no new scoring items): do not use current news cards, navigation items, or unbundled external images as evidence.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nFor static slides, assess scanning and backtracking at presentation scale, not motion effects.\nJudge negative visual grades by substantive harm and extent within this criterion, not a prerequisite of functional unusability. Harmless style differences are not defects; retain the original concrete defect examples.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: This criterion’s visual goal is severely impaired. Specific manifestation: page information overload or a broken visual path, so that the visual reading of that page cannot be completed within normal dwell time. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple pages require repeated look-backs to assemble the visual focus. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: This item has clear localized substantive defects. Specific manifestation: individual pages have somewhat high information density, and the visual reading rhythm is interrupted. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: Each page allows the necessary visual reading to be completed within normal dwell time; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: the visual scanning path is clear, and density matches purpose. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the arrangement of a class of scanning paths, dwell points, or handoffs makes necessary information easier to finish viewing and follow. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: each page's visual dwell rhythm is well arranged, with key points reached first and notes available afterward. Quality improvement must be reflected in: the gaze or timing arrangement is coordinated with content difficulty, with no unnecessary jumps back or waiting between entry, understanding, and exit. the static visual reading experience is mature, and attention shifts and information release rhythm naturally serve the explanation. The most dense content or the most complex handoffs can still be followed calmly, and the overall and detailed rhythm of a complete reading or playback cycle is consistent. Verify the complex parts relevant to this item: side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram. Task-specific object: As a static presentation, each page's information density, visual scanning path, and reading rhythm allow readers to complete the visual reading of that page within a normal dwell time; tables and notes do not require repeated look-backs. Static only evaluates visual scanning/attention shifts/reading rhythm; whether semantics carry across pages belongs to O3, and dynamic motion experience is not assessed in this task. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most dense content or the most complex handoffs can still be followed calmly, and the overall and detailed rhythm of a complete reading or playback cycle is consistent. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. A non-obvious reading or temporal organization lets the audience orient, inspect and continue with unusually little backtracking or missed understanding. Identify the timing or scanning tension solved beyond consistently smooth ordinary presentation; add no motion or interaction to a static task. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: As a static presentation, each page's information density, visual scanning path, and reading rhythm allow readers to complete the visual reading of that page within a normal dwell time; tables and notes do not require repeated look-backs. Static only evaluates visual scanning/attention shifts/reading rhythm; whether semantics carry across pages belongs to O3, and dynamic motion experience is not assessed in this task. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; the most dense content or the most complex handoffs can still be followed calmly, and the overall and detailed rhythm of a complete reading or playback cycle is consistent. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 3, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "V9", "dimension": "Visuals", "criterion": "Independent color-scheme aesthetics and image/background-ground integration.\nWhat is measured: The color scheme (hue/lightness/saturation × area / accent color / graphics-background and text-background contrast) is itself restrained and harmonious, the accent colors of the two telescopes have stable semantics across pages, and the contrast between text and background is readable; color is not used to explain concepts such as linear diameter/area, nor does it impose a fixed aesthetic.\nObservation scope: 6-page 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, astronomy club two-source comparison.\nObservation basis: Check whether the accent colors of the two telescopes are stable across pages. Check the contrast between large-area backgrounds and text. Check whether color alone is used to distinguish linear diameter/area.\nScoring boundary: The aesthetic relationships of hue, lightness, saturation × area, accent color, and image/background color; quality goals are demonstrated separately with V3/V4/V5/V7.\nObservation elements: Hue pairing and warm/cool relationships. Lightness hierarchy and color center of gravity. Saturation × area ratio. The number, weight, and restraint of accent colors. Integration of images, graphics, panels, and background color.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; in the most difficult-to-match images, dense regions, or changing states, the relationships among lightness, hue, and area remain unified, clear, and restrained.\nScoring boundary: V9 independently evaluates the aesthetic harmony and refinement of the color scheme; reading impairment caused by text contrast belongs to V3, mismatches between color and object meaning belong to V4, and cross-page color-code identity drift belongs to V7. Attribute across items only when different functional impairments are demonstrated. V5 must not merely repeat V9's color-quality judgment, and V9 must not award a professional tier directly on the grounds of \"fitting the scenario.\"\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.\nJudge negative visual grades by substantive harm and extent within this criterion, not a prerequisite of functional unusability. Harmless style differences are not defects; retain the original concrete defect examples.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: This criterion’s visual goal is severely impaired. Specific manifestation: the color scheme is glaring or chaotic, and conflicts between graphics/text and background colors affect viewing. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: The main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: the color scheme's lightness/saturation is unbalanced or the semantics of accent colors clearly drift. Judged by the above actual impact; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: one clear conflict in hue, lightness/darkness, saturation, or area relationship materially undermines local color harmony. In the relevant parts of this task on independent color-palette aesthetics and integration of graphics and text with background colors, provide evidence of actual impact; ordinary performance, harmless minor differences, or pure personal preference do not trigger the negative tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: the color palette is restrained and the whole is presentable; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: the color palette is harmonious, accent colors are used sparingly, and text/background contrast is readable. Quality improvement must be shown as: pointing out how specific hue, lightness/darkness or saturation, and area relationships improve harmony, rather than merely listing color names. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the color palette integrates well with the text and background colors, and the lightness/darkness and area relationships and the semantics of accent colors are stable. Quality improvement must be shown as: the relationships among the subject, background, images, and accent colors are coordinated, and the color focus and area control serve the actual content. the color palette is mature and restrained, with lightness/darkness, saturation, and area relationships serving the comparative explanatory tone, and color alone does not bear conceptual distinctions. In the most difficult image, dense area, or changing-state combinations, the lightness/darkness, hue, and area relationships remain unified, clear, and restrained. In the complex parts relevant to this item, verify: side-by-side conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and diameter/area diagrams. Task-specific object: The color scheme (hue/lightness/saturation × area / accent color / graphics-background and text-background contrast) is itself restrained and harmonious, the accent colors of the two telescopes have stable semantics across pages, and the contrast between text and background is readable; color is not used to explain concepts such as linear diameter/area, nor does it impose a fixed aesthetic. Difficult-case and inspection basis: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; in the most difficult-to-match images, dense regions, or changing states, the relationships among lightness, hue, and area remain unified, clear, and restrained. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. Subtle hue, lightness, saturation and area relationships reconcile the hardest color-balance conflict with a distinctive, highly resolved visual character. Explain the perceptual gain beyond a flawlessly harmonious palette; semantic color correctness, fashion and personal liking do not establish exceptional color design. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: The color scheme (hue/lightness/saturation × area / accent color / graphics-background and text-background contrast) is itself restrained and harmonious, the accent colors of the two telescopes have stable semantics across pages, and the contrast between text and background is readable; color is not used to explain concepts such as linear diameter/area, nor does it impose a fixed aesthetic. In-task verification cases for that benefit: Only within this item's applicable scope, check side-by-side presentation of conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and the diameter/area diagram; in the most difficult-to-match images, dense regions, or changing states, the relationships among lightness, hue, and area remain unified, clear, and restrained. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 6, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "D1", "dimension": "Delivery", "criterion": "Deliverables can be opened and located.\nTarget of measurement: artifact/telescopes.pptx opens normally, the six pages correspond one-to-one with artifact/preview/01.png–06.png and are 1280×720, and sources.md can be located and used.\nScope of observation: 6 pages of 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, comparing two sources for the astronomy club.\nBasis of observation: open telescopes.pptx and check the six pages and 16:9. Verify the number of preview/01–06.png files and the 1280×720 dimensions. Check whether sources.md is readable and locatable.\nScoring boundary: opening, locating, and direct use of the required files; V7 evaluates the consistency of the actually visible content, and file existence does not substitute for quality.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: check the complete viewing flow from locating the main product to the necessary supporting materials according to the actual delivery scope of this task; if one item is missing, rate the tier only by the actual impact, and do not require out-of-scope formats or extra files.\nScenario reference · media (no additional threshold): six-page English PPTX (including cover, 16:9, native editable text and comparison table), with per-page PNG previews and sources.md.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all related items apply; no new scoring items): the input files and prompt.md, workspace/README.md, workspace/sources/, and workspace/source.json are read-only and must not be modified; the final deliverables are written to artifact/.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: A core required deliverable is missing or, because of its own defects, cannot be opened/used as a whole, making the task's core use objective impossible to achieve; first rule out evaluation-tool and environment failures.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: Required content is missing on a large scale, or key opening/locating processes are persistently obstructed, requiring substantial remediation of the main use workflow; judge according to actual impact, not by mechanically assigning a tier based solely on a single discrepancy in file count.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: There is a clear, localized issue involving a missing deliverable, version identification, file correspondence, or opening instructions that affects necessary use under this criterion, while the remaining core content is usable.", "0": "Basically acceptable: all three types of deliverables are present and correspond; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: within the task-specified files and entry points, explicit role, sequence, or location cues eliminate one actual search or trial-and-error step; complete files and filenames that comply with the task statement alone qualify only for tier 0. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the roles, sequence, and necessary usage instructions of required files are coordinated, and the viewing path from the main artifact to corresponding previews/supporting materials is streamlined and unambiguous; assess only the files actually required by the task statement. even the required files, versions, or states most likely to be confused can be located accurately, and the complete viewing workflow is smooth; actual opening and required correspondence verification support the judgment, without requiring additional navigation pages or explanatory documents. Task-specific object: Deliverables can be opened and located. Difficult-case and inspection basis: check the complete viewing flow from locating the main product to the necessary supporting materials according to the actual delivery scope of this task; if one item is missing, rate the tier only by the actual impact, and do not require out-of-scope formats or extra files. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. Within the required deliverables and entry points, an economical handoff removes a real selection, opening or first-use ambiguity that persists in a conventionally flawless delivery. Identify the materially reduced effort; extra files, packaging or software are not required. If no additional benefit is observable, +2 is the ceiling. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: Deliverables can be opened and located. In-task verification cases for that benefit: check the complete viewing flow from locating the main product to the necessary supporting materials according to the actual delivery scope of this task; if one item is missing, rate the tier only by the actual impact, and do not require out-of-scope formats or extra files. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 4, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "D2", "dimension": "Delivery", "criterion": "Native editable structure and offline resources.\nTarget of measurement: the text, comparison table, and simple diameter/area diagram required by the prompt remain natively editable; qualitative and not to scale is allowed, and no additional calculations or external images are required.\nScope of observation: 6 pages of 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, comparing two sources for the astronomy club.\nBasis of observation: in the PPTX, select text and tables to confirm editability. Check whether the diagram uses native shapes or local resources. Check for externally linked images/fonts.\nScoring boundary: the editable structure, resources, and material organization of the objects required by the prompt; no engineering scripts or additional tests are required.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: verify the structure, resources, and editing entry points of native text, comparison tables, and editable simple diagrams in the side-by-side conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and diameter/area diagrams; do not modify the submitted files, and do not require unrequested generation scripts or extra documents.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: the core understanding or usage goal of this item cannot be completed. Specific manifestation: key text/tables are images and cannot be edited, violating the delivery requirements. Judge by the actual impact above; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: the main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: multiple key objects are not editable or depend on missing external resources. Judge by the actual impact above; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: this item has a clear local substantive defect. Specific manifestation: individual objects have insufficient editability or have external dependencies. Judge by the actual impact above; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: native text, comparison tables, and editable simple diagrams are complete and editable as required by the prompt, necessary resources can be parsed; the boundary between native content and allowed raster assets is correct and does not depend on the author's private missing paths; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: in the native text, comparison tables, and editable simple diagrams, object naming, grouping, or data relationships have specific arrangements, making locating/local maintenance of one type of necessary content more direct than ordinary editability; mere existence of objects is not enough for a positive score. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: the semantic grouping, resources, and editing entry points of native text, comparison tables, and editable simple diagrams are coordinated, complex objects can be located, and maintaining a local part does not affect unrelated content; no additional general-purpose engine or refactoring is required. among the required objects for side-by-side conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and diameter/area diagrams, both complex structures and simple parts are clearly maintainable, and resource relationships and originally correct content are stable; based on native structure and task-defined construction checks, do not modify the submission or add out-of-scope experiments. Task-specific object: Native editable structure and offline resources. Difficult-case and inspection basis: verify the structure, resources, and editing entry points of native text, comparison tables, and editable simple diagrams in the side-by-side conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and diameter/area diagrams; do not modify the submitted files, and do not require unrequested generation scripts or extra documents. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. The native editable organization reveals a meaningful relationship among task objects so directly that a targeted maintenance step requires materially less structural reconstruction than in a flawlessly editable conventional artifact. Show this through native evidence, without requiring an extra refactoring, unrequested source code or speculative editing claims. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: Native editable structure and offline resources. In-task verification cases for that benefit: verify the structure, resources, and editing entry points of native text, comparison tables, and editable simple diagrams in the side-by-side conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and diameter/area diagrams; do not modify the submitted files, and do not require unrequested generation scripts or extra documents. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 3, "benchmark_source": "vas" }, { "id": "D3", "dimension": "Delivery", "criterion": "sources.md traceability, derivation, and unresolved-difference explanation.\nTarget of measurement: sources.md maps claims to A/B and to sections/tables page by page, marks any derived calculations and their sources, and describes the unresolved diameter and light-gathering-area difference; snapshots are traceable, but modification dates must not be used to decide factual priority.\nScope of observation: 6 pages of 16:9 native English PPTX and 1280×720 PNG, comparing two sources for the astronomy club.\nBasis of observation: check the A/B section mapping in sources.md page by page. Check whether derivations such as 25.37/4.55≈5.576 are marked. Check whether it explicitly states that the difference is unresolved and includes snapshot metadata.\nScoring boundary: the verifiability of the required sources, calculations/changes/captures, or usage instructions; select according to the actual requirements of this task, and do not require all document types.\nOriginal full refinement inspection basis: check side-by-side conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and diameter/area diagrams only within the applicable scope of this item; the most confusing sources, conditions, or changes can also be verified along the explanation, and the complete verification path is concise with no gaps or overclaims.\nApplicable boundary for this task (all related items apply; no new scoring items): fixed delivery paths: artifact/telescopes.pptx, artifact/preview/01.png–06.png, artifact/sources.md.\nRevised grade boundary: the original high-grade descriptions are +2 quality obligations, not sufficient evidence for +3. +2 covers the entire applicable scope; +3 additionally requires the exceptional benefit specified in answers[\"3\"]. Levels inherit quality obligations, not the shortcomings explaining lower grades.", "answers": { "-3": "Severe failure: the core understanding or usage goal of this item cannot be completed. Specific manifestation: no traceability or incorrect mapping, and derivations and unresolved differences are missing. Judge by the actual impact above; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-2": "Clearly unacceptable: the main area or key process of this item is persistently impaired. Specific manifestation: traceability is largely vague or key conflict explanations are omitted. Judge by the actual impact above; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "-1": "Below basic requirements: this item has a clear local substantive defect. Specific manifestation: traceability basically exists but individual pages or derivations are unmarked. Judge by the actual impact above; harmless minor differences do not trigger this tier.", "0": "Basically acceptable: page-by-page mapping and the unresolved-difference explanation are complete; the necessary requirements of this item are fully met, with no substantive defects and ordinary performance.", "1": "Accomplished but not yet fully refined: meets tier 0 and shows a substantive observed benefit beyond ordinary correctness, completeness or readability through the following: mapping to specific sections/tables, and derived calculations indicate their sources. Quality improvement must be shown as: at least one type of key evidence has a precise location and corresponds to the actual object, reducing the need to search through vague sources. In reason explain the concrete benefit and the observable limitation keeping it below +2. Do not invent a defect to force this grade; missing required observation must be acquired first.", "2": "Fully refined within scope: meets tier 0 and achieves complete quality in every applicable part, not only an attractive local example. Retain and jointly verify these quality obligations: each page is verifiable, and derivations and conflict explanations are clearly distinguished. Quality improvement must be shown as: claims, materials, and the explanations required by the prompt correspond to each other, so one can both trace the evidence and know where that evidence is used. traceability is mature and can serve as a basis for review, and snapshots are traceable. The most confusing sources, conditions, or changes can also be verified along the explanation, and the complete verification path is concise with no gaps or overclaims. In the complex parts relevant to this item, verify: side-by-side conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and diameter/area diagrams. Task-specific object: sources.md traceability, derivation, and unresolved-difference explanation. Difficult-case and inspection basis: check side-by-side conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and diameter/area diagrams only within the applicable scope of this item; the most confusing sources, conditions, or changes can also be verified along the explanation, and the complete verification path is concise with no gaps or overclaims. Within this criterion and the stated use conditions, there is no identifiable substantive weakness or feasible task-relevant improvement of material benefit. Establish full applicable coverage and actively inspect the strongest plausible shortcoming; finding no error, a single successful example or an author assertion does not prove full refinement.", "3": "Exceptional beyond conventional full refinement: first fully meet +2. An economical provenance/handoff organization makes a difficult fact, calculation or asset relationship directly auditable, reducing reconstruction beyond a complete accurate conventional source list. Identify the actual trace and saved ambiguity, without requiring new evidence or new documentation beyond the task. Apply the exceptional benefit specifically to: sources.md traceability, derivation, and unresolved-difference explanation. In-task verification cases for that benefit: check side-by-side conflicting sources, resolution corresponding to wavelength, and diameter/area diagrams only within the applicable scope of this item; the most confusing sources, conditions, or changes can also be verified along the explanation, and the complete verification path is concise with no gaps or overclaims. Correct completion of these cases is only a foundation, not evidence of exceptional benefit. In reason identify the non-obvious choice, real difficulty and substantial benefit beyond an equally correct, complete and polished conventional solution, with actual evidence. No comparison artifact or unique design is required. Complexity, extra features, ornament, praise or repetition of +2 strengths is insufficient. Without demonstrated extra benefit the ceiling is +2; no score quota applies." }, "weight": 3, "benchmark_source": "vas" } ]