{ "id": "presentations-051", "source": "vas", "artifact_type": "presentation", "category": "presentations", "acceptance_groups": { "G01": [ "IF01", "IF08", "IF09", "IF10", "IF11", "IF12" ], "G02": [ "IF02" ], "G03": [ "IF03", "IF04", "IF05", "IF06", "IF07", "IF56" ], "G04": [ "IF30", "IF31", "IF32", "IF33", "IF34", "IF35", "IF36", "IF37" ], "G05": [ "IF38", "IF39", "IF40", "IF41" ], "G06": [ "IF42", "IF43", "IF44", "IF45" ], "G07": [ "IF46", "IF47", "IF48" ], "G08": [ "IF49", "IF50", "IF51" ], "G09": [ "IF52", "IF53", "IF54" ], "G10": [ "IF55" ], "G11": [ "IF57", "IF58", "IF61" ], "G12": [ "IF59", "IF68", "IF69", "IF70", "IF71", "IF73", "IF74" ], "G13": [ "IF60", "IF62" ], "G14": [ "IF63", "IF64", "IF65", "IF66", "IF67" ], "G15": [ "IF72" ], "G16": [ "IF75" ], "G17": [ "IF77" ], "G18": [ "IF13", "IF14", "IF15", "IF16", "IF17", "IF18" ], "G19": [ "IF19", "IF20", "IF21", "IF22", "IF23" ], "G20": [ "IF24", "IF25", "IF26", "IF27", "IF28" ], "G21": [ "IF29" ] }, "provenance": { "source": "artifactspec", "original_id": "P51", "legacy_task_id": "artifactspec-P51" }, "acceptance_objectives": { "G01": { "title": "Identify the chart's 2026-07-17 revision. Explain year on x, cell efficiency (%) on y, technology colors/symbols and right-side record flags. Include at least one full-chart orientation slide.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Identify the chart as the 2026-07-17 revision.", "Requirement: Explain that the chart's x-axis represents year.", "Requirement: Explain that the chart's y-axis represents cell efficiency (%).", "Requirement: Explain the correspondence between technology colors and symbols.", "Requirement: Explain the right-side record flags.", "Requirement: Include at least one full-chart orientation page." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:6" }, "G02": { "title": "Required artifact language", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The presentation uses English." ], "objective_key": "constraint:language" }, "G03": { "title": "Using the frozen official chart and explanatory materials in input, create a six-slide English 16:9 Beamer presentation for students entering photovoltaics research. Deliver a compilable TEX project and PDF. Teach chart reading and comparison boundaries, not technology investment advice.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The presentation page ratio is 16:9.", "Requirement: The presentation is implemented using Beamer.", "Requirement: The presentation contains six slides.", "Requirement: The presentation uses the frozen official chart in input.", "Requirement: The presentation does not provide technology investment advice.", "Requirement: The TEX project compiles." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:3" }, "G04": { "title": "Summarize the three records/conditions in a native TEX table. Explain that these are not commercial-module rankings under identical conditions and do not establish cost, lifespan, scalability or system energy yield.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Use a native TEX table.", "Requirement: The TEX table summarizes the three specified records.", "Requirement: The TEX table includes the conditions of the three records.", "Requirement: Explain that these records are not commercial-module rankings under identical conditions.", "Requirement: Explain that these records do not establish cost conclusions.", "Requirement: Explain that these records do not establish lifespan conclusions.", "Requirement: Explain that these records do not establish scalability conclusions.", "Requirement: State that these records do not establish a system energy-yield conclusion." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:8" }, "G05": { "title": "Briefly explain independent recognized-laboratory confirmation, 25°C reference temperature, area basis and differing reference spectra for flat-plate/concentrator cells. Reproducing standards is unnecessary.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Briefly explain independent recognized-laboratory confirmation.", "Requirement: Briefly explain the 25°C reference temperature.", "Requirement: Briefly explain the area basis.", "Requirement: Briefly explain that flat-plate and concentrator cells use different reference spectra." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:9" }, "G06": { "title": "Distinguish measurement date, fabrication time and first-publication reference using the guide. State that remeasurements should be compared within uncertainty; do not invent uncertainty, area or unavailable exact measurement dates.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Distinguish the measurement date.", "Requirement: Distinguish the fabrication time.", "Requirement: Distinguish the first-publication reference.", "Requirement: State that remeasurements should be compared within uncertainty." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:10" }, "G07": { "title": "Evidence-bounded claims and truthful scenario identity", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Do not fabricate uncertainty values.", "Requirement: Do not fabricate area values.", "Requirement: Do not fabricate unavailable exact measurement dates." ], "objective_key": "constraint:evidence-boundary" }, "G08": { "title": "End with at least two supported chart-reading cautions and retain official source/credits.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: End with at least two chart-reading cautions.", "Requirement: Each chart-reading caution has supporting evidence.", "Requirement: Retain the official source and credits." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:11" }, "G09": { "title": "Academic teaching preferences: progressive explanation, clear legend/local annotations and faithful original charts. Do not force readers to extract key records from tiny full-chart text. Cropping/highlighting is allowed without changing data or presenting new conclusions as original chart text. Slide structure is flexible; no template or redraw of every historical point is required. Embed original PDF/PNG if desired, but added annotations, titles and tables must remain editable in TEX.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Do not force readers to extract key records from tiny full-chart text.", "Requirement: Cropping or highlighting does not change the chart data.", "Requirement: Added annotations do not pass off new conclusions as original chart text." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:13" }, "G10": { "title": "Required native editability and source structure", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Added titles remain editable in TEX." ], "objective_key": "constraint:editability" }, "G11": { "title": "Complete openable artifact handoff and source dependencies", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Deliver artifact/project/main.tex.", "Requirement: The project includes all relative-path dependency files.", "Requirement: artifact/lecture.pdf is six pages." ], "objective_key": "constraint:delivery" }, "G12": { "title": "Deliver artifact/project/main.tex with all relative-path dependencies, artifact/lecture.pdf (six pages), six page PNGs, sources.md and build.md (engine, fonts, compilation commands). XeLaTeX is recommended; use available fonts without requiring a brand font. No network, shell-escape or external absolute paths are needed. Inputs are read-only; use scratch. sources must map each slide to chart regions/explanatory sections/guide pages and frozen version.", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Project dependency references use relative paths.", "Requirement: Deliver build.md.", "Requirement: build.md gives the compilation engine.", "Requirement: build.md gives font information.", "Requirement: build.md gives compilation commands.", "Requirement: Compilation does not use shell-escape.", "Requirement: The project does not depend on external absolute paths." ], "objective_key": "requirement:prompt.md:15" }, "G13": { "title": "Required faithful previews and companion exports", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Deliver artifact/lecture.pdf.", "Requirement: Deliver six page PNGs." ], "objective_key": "constraint:preview" }, "G14": { "title": "Complete reproducibility and delivery documentation", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Deliver sources.md.", "Requirement: sources.md maps each slide to chart regions.", "Requirement: sources.md maps each slide to explanatory sections.", "Requirement: sources.md maps each slide to guide pages.", "Requirement: sources.md notes the frozen version." ], "objective_key": "constraint:notes" }, "G15": { "title": "Self-contained offline opening and playback", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Compilation requires no network." ], "objective_key": "constraint:offline" }, "G16": { "title": "Unmodified original inputs and isolated working state", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: The input files in input remain read-only and unmodified. [v7 verifiable boundary: check that the final inputs match the frozen snapshot file by file; it is not required to prove that no writing ever occurred during production. Public runtime inputs are guaranteed by read-only mounting.]." ], "objective_key": "constraint:input-integrity" }, "G17": { "title": "Readable labels, text and unclipped content at the required scale", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Use available fonts and do not require a brand font." ], "objective_key": "constraint:legibility" }, "G18": { "title": "Correct cropped and annotated III-V multijunction concentrator record", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Provide a cropped image for the right-side record of the III-V multijunction concentrator category.", "Requirement: Provide editable English annotations for the right-side record of the III-V multijunction concentrator category.", "Requirement: Correctly read the efficiency of the III-V multijunction concentrator record.", "Requirement: Correctly read the manufacturer label of the III-V multijunction concentrator record.", "Requirement: Retain and correctly read the concentration factor of the III-V concentrator record.", "Requirement: Retain and correctly read the junction count of the III-V concentrator record." ], "objective_key": "content:if-objective-01" }, "G19": { "title": "Correct cropped and annotated non-concentrator multijunction record", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Provide a cropped image for the right-side record of the three-junction-or-more non-concentrator category.", "Requirement: Provide editable English annotations for the right-side record of the three-junction-or-more non-concentrator category.", "Requirement: Correctly read the efficiency of the three-junction-or-more non-concentrator record.", "Requirement: Correctly read the manufacturer label of the three-junction-or-more non-concentrator record.", "Requirement: Correctly read the conditions of the three-junction-or-more non-concentrator record." ], "objective_key": "content:if-objective-02" }, "G20": { "title": "Correct cropped and annotated two-terminal perovskite/silicon tandem record", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Provide a cropped image for the right-side record of the two-terminal perovskite/silicon tandem category.", "Requirement: Provide editable English annotations for the right-side record of the two-terminal perovskite/silicon tandem category.", "Requirement: Correctly read the efficiency of the two-terminal perovskite/silicon tandem record.", "Requirement: Correctly read the manufacturer label of the two-terminal perovskite/silicon tandem record.", "Requirement: Correctly read the conditions of the two-terminal perovskite/silicon tandem record." ], "objective_key": "content:if-objective-03" }, "G21": { "title": "Chart mappings verified from the actual source graphic", "dimension": "CP", "scope": [ "Requirement: Do not infer chart mappings solely from adjacent extracted text." ], "objective_key": "content:if-objective-04" } }, "grouping_revision": "cp-fn-objectives-v2-20261114" }