item_id
stringlengths
5
5
repetition_index
int64
0
2
judge_model
stringclasses
1 value
judge_temperature
null
rubric_version
stringclasses
1 value
rubric_sha256_12
stringclasses
1 value
prompt_sha256_12
stringlengths
16
16
judged_at_utc
stringlengths
32
32
raw_judge_output
stringlengths
0
228
judge_error
null
parse_ok
bool
2 classes
q1_semantic_redundancy
stringclasses
2 values
q2_functional_redundancy
stringclasses
2 values
q3_new_information
stringclasses
2 values
q4_answer_influence
stringclasses
2 values
q5_division_of_labour_present
stringclasses
2 values
judge_reason
stringlengths
82
162
⌀
problem_uid
stringlengths
8
10
arm
stringclasses
4 values
actor_model
stringclasses
3 values
run_id
stringclasses
3 values
config_version
stringclasses
2 values
trajectory_correct
float64
0
1
⌀
automated_collapse_label
bool
2 classes
trajectory_key
stringlengths
23
35
T0000
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
70bef79dffbaaef8
2026-09-29T17:24:01.984400+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives general parity argument and answer, Agent 3 only reviews/approves, restating Agent 2's reasoning."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives general parity argument and answer, Agent 3 only reviews/approves, restating Agent 2's reasoning.
omni2_1283
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1283|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0000
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
70bef79dffbaaef8
2026-09-29T17:02:44.197205+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 only checks and agrees; roles differ though Agent 3 restates."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 only checks and agrees; roles differ though Agent 3 restates.
omni2_1283
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1283|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0000
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
70bef79dffbaaef8
2026-09-29T17:05:15.495924+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and computes answer, Agent 3 reviews; Agent 3 merely paraphrases Agent 2's justification."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and computes answer, Agent 3 reviews; Agent 3 merely paraphrases Agent 2's justification.
omni2_1283
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1283|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0001
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
703ab7dcc62e07c2
2026-09-29T16:59:09.158629+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 derives closed form and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 derives closed form and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions.
omni2_2318
Cp
gemma-4-31B-it
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_2318|Cp|gemma-4-31B-it
T0001
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
703ab7dcc62e07c2
2026-09-29T17:17:05.899909+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans only, Agent 2 derives closed form and answer, Agent 3 verifies — distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans only, Agent 2 derives closed form and answer, Agent 3 verifies — distinct role functions.
omni2_2318
Cp
gemma-4-31B-it
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_2318|Cp|gemma-4-31B-it
T0001
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
703ab7dcc62e07c2
2026-09-29T16:52:08.689964+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 derives closed form and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 derives closed form and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions.
omni2_2318
Cp
gemma-4-31B-it
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_2318|Cp|gemma-4-31B-it
T0002
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
e0d55aa6d4ec4299
2026-09-29T17:18:22.895055+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 largely paraphrases Agent 1's plan, but roles differ: planner, executor, critic who rejects answer and routes back."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 2 largely paraphrases Agent 1's plan, but roles differ: planner, executor, critic who rejects answer and routes back.
omni2_131
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_131|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0002
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
e0d55aa6d4ec4299
2026-09-29T17:23:28.749856+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 paraphrases Agent 1's plan without new derivation, but roles differ: planner, executor, critic who rejects answer and reroutes."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 2 paraphrases Agent 1's plan without new derivation, but roles differ: planner, executor, critic who rejects answer and reroutes.
omni2_131
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_131|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0002
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
e0d55aa6d4ec4299
2026-09-29T17:09:13.577998+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 merely paraphrases Agent 1's plan, but roles differ: planner, solver, critic who rejects answer and routes back."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 2 merely paraphrases Agent 1's plan, but roles differ: planner, solver, critic who rejects answer and routes back.
omni2_131
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_131|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0003
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
18ae0abf60ee22bb
2026-09-29T17:08:07.080144+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans decomposition, Agent 2 executes and derives explicit triples, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no course correction."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans decomposition, Agent 2 executes and derives explicit triples, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no course correction.
omni2_173
Cp
gpt-oss-120b
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_173|Cp|gpt-oss-120b
T0003
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
18ae0abf60ee22bb
2026-09-29T17:22:22.648133+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes the derivation and produces triples, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions though plan prefigured conclusions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes the derivation and produces triples, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions though plan prefigured conclusions.
omni2_173
Cp
gpt-oss-120b
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_173|Cp|gpt-oss-120b
T0003
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
18ae0abf60ee22bb
2026-09-29T17:19:32.942450+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes derivation and produces explicit triples, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite unchanged path."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes derivation and produces explicit triples, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite unchanged path.
omni2_173
Cp
gpt-oss-120b
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_173|Cp|gpt-oss-120b
T0004
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
027083c16d6df270
2026-09-29T17:14:40.186578+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes and boxes an answer, Agent 3 critiques arithmetic and routes back for correction."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes and boxes an answer, Agent 3 critiques arithmetic and routes back for correction.
omni2_1556
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_1556|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0004
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
027083c16d6df270
2026-09-29T16:55:45.261617+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes to boxed answer, Agent 3 critiques arithmetic and routes back; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes to boxed answer, Agent 3 critiques arithmetic and routes back; distinct role functions.
omni2_1556
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_1556|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0004
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
027083c16d6df270
2026-09-29T17:33:41.422495+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes to boxed value, Agent 3 critiques arithmetic and routes back for correction."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes to boxed value, Agent 3 critiques arithmetic and routes back for correction.
omni2_1556
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_1556|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0005
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
5563ae355c4f252e
2026-09-29T17:36:25.313115+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 largely restates Agent 1's plan but executes it (Pascal identity, final value); Agent 3 verifies — distinct plan/execute/check roles."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 2 largely restates Agent 1's plan but executes it (Pascal identity, final value); Agent 3 verifies — distinct plan/execute/check roles.
omni2_54
Cp
gemma-4-31B-it
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_54|Cp|gemma-4-31B-it
T0005
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
5563ae355c4f252e
2026-09-29T17:07:21.257334+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 restates Agent 1's plan but computes final value via Pascal; Agent 3 verifies — distinct planner/executor/checker roles."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 2 restates Agent 1's plan but computes final value via Pascal; Agent 3 verifies — distinct planner/executor/checker roles.
omni2_54
Cp
gemma-4-31B-it
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_54|Cp|gemma-4-31B-it
T0005
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
5563ae355c4f252e
2026-09-29T17:15:45.566313+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with Pascal simplification, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles though answer unchanged."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with Pascal simplification, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles though answer unchanged.
omni2_54
Cp
gemma-4-31B-it
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_54|Cp|gemma-4-31B-it
T0006
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8e679537df0e6d37
2026-09-29T17:13:15.053096+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 reviews; distinct role functions despite Agent 3 adding nothing new."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 reviews; distinct role functions despite Agent 3 adding nothing new.
omni2_123
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_123|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0006
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8e679537df0e6d37
2026-09-29T17:17:34.598893+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives answer, Agent 3 reviews; distinct role functions despite shallow verification."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives answer, Agent 3 reviews; distinct role functions despite shallow verification.
omni2_123
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_123|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0006
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8e679537df0e6d37
2026-09-29T17:02:02.520924+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives a full solution and answer, Agent 3 reviews and accepts; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives a full solution and answer, Agent 3 reviews and accepts; distinct role functions.
omni2_123
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_123|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0007
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
4c99a83c8f061531
2026-09-29T17:07:06.118004+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 merely restate Agent 1's formula and arithmetic, adding no new derivation, critique, or change."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 merely restate Agent 1's formula and arithmetic, adding no new derivation, critique, or change.
omni2_1579
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1579|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0007
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
4c99a83c8f061531
2026-09-29T17:24:53.054758+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 merely restate Agent 1's formula and arithmetic, adding no new step, critique, or correction."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 merely restate Agent 1's formula and arithmetic, adding no new step, critique, or correction.
omni2_1579
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1579|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0007
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
4c99a83c8f061531
2026-09-29T17:28:04.737951+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 merely restate Agent 1's formula and arithmetic, adding no new step, critique, or change."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 merely restate Agent 1's formula and arithmetic, adding no new step, critique, or change.
omni2_1579
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1579|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0008
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
aebdfc459924a027
2026-09-29T17:31:22.911592+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans cases, Agent 2 executes areas and computes answer, Agent 3 verifies and approves; distinct roles."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans cases, Agent 2 executes areas and computes answer, Agent 3 verifies and approves; distinct roles.
omni2_3139
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3139|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0008
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
aebdfc459924a027
2026-09-29T16:56:55.714851+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans cases, Agent 2 executes area computations, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions though verifier adds no new step."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans cases, Agent 2 executes area computations, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions though verifier adds no new step.
omni2_3139
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3139|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0008
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
aebdfc459924a027
2026-09-29T17:07:46.695412+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans cases, Agent 2 computes areas, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles though verification adds no new step."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans cases, Agent 2 computes areas, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles though verification adds no new step.
omni2_3139
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3139|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0009
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
341d630682197c1d
2026-09-29T17:12:53.470542+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 reviews; distinct roles though the check is a rubber stamp."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 reviews; distinct roles though the check is a rubber stamp.
omni2_1204
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1204|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0009
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
341d630682197c1d
2026-09-29T17:18:56.712698+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 reviews; distinct roles though the check is shallow rubber-stamping."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 reviews; distinct roles though the check is shallow rubber-stamping.
omni2_1204
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1204|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0009
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
341d630682197c1d
2026-09-29T17:28:16.287213+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 reviews; distinct roles though the review is a rubber-stamp."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and answers, Agent 3 reviews; distinct roles though the review is a rubber-stamp.
omni2_1204
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1204|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0010
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
0cfda2815654c51e
2026-09-29T17:28:36.261505+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Three identical bare assertions of 8 with bare agreement; no structuring, derivation, or checking."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Three identical bare assertions of 8 with bare agreement; no structuring, derivation, or checking.
omni2_2740
B
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
true
omni2_2740|B|gpt-oss-120b
T0010
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
0cfda2815654c51e
2026-09-29T17:15:28.232003+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Three identical bare assertions of the same answer with no structuring, derivation, or checking."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Three identical bare assertions of the same answer with no structuring, derivation, or checking.
omni2_2740
B
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
true
omni2_2740|B|gpt-oss-120b
T0010
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
0cfda2815654c51e
2026-09-29T17:25:09.761818+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Three identical bare assertions of 8 with agreement; no structuring, execution, or checking distinguishes the agents."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Three identical bare assertions of 8 with agreement; no structuring, execution, or checking distinguishes the agents.
omni2_2740
B
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
true
omni2_2740|B|gpt-oss-120b
T0011
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
e6a7685fad9b221c
2026-09-29T16:57:45.649306+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agent 2 restates Agent 1's decomposition and bijection; Agent 3 writes it out. Same method, same answer, no critique or new step."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agent 2 restates Agent 1's decomposition and bijection; Agent 3 writes it out. Same method, same answer, no critique or new step.
omni2_1018
Cp
gpt-oss-120b
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1018|Cp|gpt-oss-120b
T0011
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
e6a7685fad9b221c
2026-09-29T16:59:15.081518+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agent 2 restates Agent 1's identical decomposition and bijection; Agent 3 writes it out with same answer, no new content or critique."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agent 2 restates Agent 1's identical decomposition and bijection; Agent 3 writes it out with same answer, no new content or critique.
omni2_1018
Cp
gpt-oss-120b
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1018|Cp|gpt-oss-120b
T0011
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
e6a7685fad9b221c
2026-09-29T17:22:42.649679+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agent 2 restates Agent 1's identical plan; Agent 3 writes it out. Same bijection, same Catalan answer, no critique or new step."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agent 2 restates Agent 1's identical plan; Agent 3 writes it out. Same bijection, same Catalan answer, no critique or new step.
omni2_1018
Cp
gpt-oss-120b
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1018|Cp|gpt-oss-120b
T0012
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
604ff8ff78627f4f
2026-09-29T17:32:27.492064+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with new derivations, Agent 3 diagnoses and reroutes; distinct role functions despite some restated lemmas."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with new derivations, Agent 3 diagnoses and reroutes; distinct role functions despite some restated lemmas.
omni2_3918
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
0
false
omni2_3918|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0012
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
604ff8ff78627f4f
2026-09-29T17:24:36.130492+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes derivation with new lemmas, Agent 3 diagnoses failure and routes back with fix instructions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes derivation with new lemmas, Agent 3 diagnoses failure and routes back with fix instructions.
omni2_3918
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
0
false
omni2_3918|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0012
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
604ff8ff78627f4f
2026-09-29T17:03:32.794499+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes new derivation (truncated), Agent 3 diagnoses and redirects; distinct role functions despite some restatement."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes new derivation (truncated), Agent 3 diagnoses and redirects; distinct role functions despite some restatement.
omni2_3918
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
0
false
omni2_3918|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0013
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
2f20b9205f0c929f
2026-09-29T17:06:18.481412+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 executes and verifies, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 executes and verifies, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions.
omni2_1349
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_1349|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0013
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
2f20b9205f0c929f
2026-09-29T17:37:28.303891+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 executes and verifies, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 executes and verifies, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions.
omni2_1349
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_1349|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0013
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
2f20b9205f0c929f
2026-09-29T17:24:09.864315+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 executes and verifies, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 executes and verifies, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions.
omni2_1349
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_1349|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0014
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8cffca80ac1ec3fd
2026-09-29T17:20:54.426203+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 largely executes Agent 1's stated plan, but adds explicit derivation; Agent 3 checks. Roles differ: plan, execute, verify."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 2 largely executes Agent 1's stated plan, but adds explicit derivation; Agent 3 checks. Roles differ: plan, execute, verify.
omni2_4164
Cp
gpt-oss-120b
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_4164|Cp|gpt-oss-120b
T0014
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8cffca80ac1ec3fd
2026-09-29T17:06:07.264602+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 supplies full derivation and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no redirection."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 supplies full derivation and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no redirection.
omni2_4164
Cp
gpt-oss-120b
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_4164|Cp|gpt-oss-120b
T0014
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8cffca80ac1ec3fd
2026-09-29T17:31:13.405847+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 largely executes Agent 1's stated plan but adds explicit derivation details; Agent 3 performs a distinct checking role."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 2 largely executes Agent 1's stated plan but adds explicit derivation details; Agent 3 performs a distinct checking role.
omni2_4164
Cp
gpt-oss-120b
armCp-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_4164|Cp|gpt-oss-120b
T0015
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
35b4144dcbf06a5d
2026-09-29T17:17:17.105604+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and computes new answer, Agent 3 reviews and accepts; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and computes new answer, Agent 3 reviews and accepts; distinct role functions.
omni2_1283
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_1283|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0015
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
35b4144dcbf06a5d
2026-09-29T17:33:08.013435+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and computes new answer, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and computes new answer, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions.
omni2_1283
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_1283|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0015
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
35b4144dcbf06a5d
2026-09-29T17:06:33.560516+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and computes, Agent 3 reviews and accepts; distinct role functions despite rubber-stamp check."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and computes, Agent 3 reviews and accepts; distinct role functions despite rubber-stamp check.
omni2_1283
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
1
false
omni2_1283|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0016
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
5f3901dfabad4ff5
2026-09-29T17:25:34.733640+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 re-derive Agent 1's identical construction; Agent 2 adds the δ=70 test, Agent 3 merely restates it."}
null
true
YES
YES
YES
YES
NO
Agents 2 and 3 re-derive Agent 1's identical construction; Agent 2 adds the δ=70 test, Agent 3 merely restates it.
omni2_2340
B
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2340|B|gemma-4-31B-it
T0016
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
5f3901dfabad4ff5
2026-09-29T17:23:22.648929+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's derivation, but Agent 2 supplies the unfinished solution (70°) and Agent 3 verifies it."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's derivation, but Agent 2 supplies the unfinished solution (70°) and Agent 3 verifies it.
omni2_2340
B
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2340|B|gemma-4-31B-it
T0016
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
5f3901dfabad4ff5
2026-09-29T17:26:06.581231+00:00
null
false
null
null
null
null
null
null
omni2_2340
B
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2340|B|gemma-4-31B-it
T0017
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
13783524c9e5752e
2026-09-29T17:10:59.564538+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives via a different route producing the answer, Agent 3 verifies and accepts."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives via a different route producing the answer, Agent 3 verifies and accepts.
omni2_1392
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1392|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0017
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
13783524c9e5752e
2026-09-29T17:11:31.757884+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives the key identity and answer, Agent 3 reviews and accepts; distinct roles."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives the key identity and answer, Agent 3 reviews and accepts; distinct roles.
omni2_1392
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1392|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0017
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
13783524c9e5752e
2026-09-29T17:03:17.538838+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives the key identity and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives the key identity and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions.
omni2_1392
C
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1392|C|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0018
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
e5a9c0002103d549
2026-09-29T17:01:11.216541+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"All three restate the same Legendre/Lucas musings and small-case checks; Agents 2 and 3 add no new derivation, repeating boxed 0."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
All three restate the same Legendre/Lucas musings and small-case checks; Agents 2 and 3 add no new derivation, repeating boxed 0.
omni2_1283
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1283|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0018
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
e5a9c0002103d549
2026-09-29T16:58:43.729316+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"All three rehash the same Legendre/Lucas musings without executing; Agent 3 merely echoes Agent 2's unchanged boxed 0."}
null
true
YES
YES
YES
NO
NO
All three rehash the same Legendre/Lucas musings without executing; Agent 3 merely echoes Agent 2's unchanged boxed 0.
omni2_1283
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1283|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0018
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
e5a9c0002103d549
2026-09-29T17:18:01.771759+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"All three rehash the same Legendre/Lucas musing and recompute identical small cases; Agent 3's binary claim adds little, answer unchanged."}
null
true
YES
YES
YES
NO
NO
All three rehash the same Legendre/Lucas musing and recompute identical small cases; Agent 3's binary claim adds little, answer unchanged.
omni2_1283
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1283|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0019
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8972094cc2652068
2026-09-29T17:22:04.441415+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 computes the answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions though plan carried forward unchanged."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 computes the answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions though plan carried forward unchanged.
omni2_1608
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_1608|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0019
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8972094cc2652068
2026-09-29T17:24:18.298750+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 computes the quadratic and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions though path unchanged."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 computes the quadratic and answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions though path unchanged.
omni2_1608
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_1608|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0019
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8972094cc2652068
2026-09-29T17:02:34.786447+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 executes and derives the value, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans without computing, Agent 2 executes and derives the value, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions.
omni2_1608
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_1608|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0020
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
c4989031b3cd2579
2026-09-29T16:54:32.203783+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agent 3 nearly verbatim repeats Agent 2's derivation; Agent 1 only asserts the same answer. No distinct roles."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agent 3 nearly verbatim repeats Agent 2's derivation; Agent 1 only asserts the same answer. No distinct roles.
omni2_1384
B
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_1384|B|gpt-oss-120b
T0020
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
c4989031b3cd2579
2026-09-29T17:29:20.305219+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agent 3 near-verbatim repeats Agent 2's derivation; Agent 1 gives bare answer. No structuring, checking, or new content."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agent 3 near-verbatim repeats Agent 2's derivation; Agent 1 gives bare answer. No structuring, checking, or new content.
omni2_1384
B
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_1384|B|gpt-oss-120b
T0020
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
c4989031b3cd2579
2026-09-29T17:31:56.325865+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agent 3 restates Agent 2's derivation nearly verbatim; Agent 1 only asserts the answer. No distinct roles."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agent 3 restates Agent 2's derivation nearly verbatim; Agent 1 only asserts the answer. No distinct roles.
omni2_1384
B
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_1384|B|gpt-oss-120b
T0021
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
3191ed6a1df0984d
2026-09-29T17:20:41.960740+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with new identities and numeric checks reaching a Legendre-symbol answer, Agent 3 verifies."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with new identities and numeric checks reaching a Legendre-symbol answer, Agent 3 verifies.
omni2_2471
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
null
false
omni2_2471|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0021
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
3191ed6a1df0984d
2026-09-29T17:29:05.589581+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with new identities and numeric checks yielding the answer, Agent 3 verifies; roles distinct."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with new identities and numeric checks yielding the answer, Agent 3 verifies; roles distinct.
omni2_2471
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
null
false
omni2_2471|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0021
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
3191ed6a1df0984d
2026-09-29T17:32:35.812978+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and adds new identity plus numeric checks yielding Legendre symbol, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 derives and adds new identity plus numeric checks yielding Legendre symbol, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles.
omni2_2471
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
null
false
omni2_2471|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0022
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
98247ccc607b02e9
2026-09-29T17:18:05.725276+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 outputs a value, Agent 3 critiques, adds new exponent constraints and a different total, routing back."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 outputs a value, Agent 3 critiques, adds new exponent constraints and a different total, routing back.
omni2_2994
A
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2994|A|gpt-oss-120b
T0022
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
98247ccc607b02e9
2026-09-29T17:16:59.334061+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Planner structures approach, solver gives answer, reviewer critiques, adds prime-2/3 constraints, changes answer to 30, routes back."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Planner structures approach, solver gives answer, reviewer critiques, adds prime-2/3 constraints, changes answer to 30, routes back.
omni2_2994
A
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2994|A|gpt-oss-120b
T0022
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
98247ccc607b02e9
2026-09-29T16:55:15.431549+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 computes an answer, Agent 3 critiques, adds new exponent constraints and changes the result."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 computes an answer, Agent 3 critiques, adds new exponent constraints and changes the result.
omni2_2994
A
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2994|A|gpt-oss-120b
T0023
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
3c1ae53385237a52
2026-09-29T16:57:07.254382+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans states/equations without computing; Agent 2 computes probabilities and solves; Agent 3 verifies and accepts."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans states/equations without computing; Agent 2 computes probabilities and solves; Agent 3 verifies and accepts.
omni2_2039
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2039|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0023
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
3c1ae53385237a52
2026-09-29T16:52:50.627843+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans states/equations without computing; Agent 2 computes probabilities and solves; Agent 3 verifies and accepts. Distinct roles."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans states/equations without computing; Agent 2 computes probabilities and solves; Agent 3 verifies and accepts. Distinct roles.
omni2_2039
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2039|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0023
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
3c1ae53385237a52
2026-09-29T17:20:19.457105+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans states without computing; Agent 2 derives probabilities and solves; Agent 3 verifies. Distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans states without computing; Agent 2 derives probabilities and solves; Agent 3 verifies. Distinct role functions.
omni2_2039
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2039|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0024
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
841ad08446a6ba78
2026-09-29T17:06:11.659894+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 repeats Agent 1's stated computation but executes to an answer; Agent 3 checks. Roles distinct despite overlap."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 2 repeats Agent 1's stated computation but executes to an answer; Agent 3 checks. Roles distinct despite overlap.
omni2_3395
C
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3395|C|gpt-oss-120b
T0024
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
841ad08446a6ba78
2026-09-29T16:57:05.336661+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 repeats Agent 1's stated computation but executes and answers; Agent 3 checks. Roles distinct despite overlap."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 2 repeats Agent 1's stated computation but executes and answers; Agent 3 checks. Roles distinct despite overlap.
omni2_3395
C
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3395|C|gpt-oss-120b
T0024
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
841ad08446a6ba78
2026-09-29T16:54:58.732521+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 2 restates Agent 1's plan but executes it to an answer; Agent 3 checks. Distinct roles despite overlap."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 2 restates Agent 1's plan but executes it to an answer; Agent 3 checks. Distinct roles despite overlap.
omni2_3395
C
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3395|C|gpt-oss-120b
T0025
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
01f4cebc8c56932c
2026-09-29T16:59:40.187210+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans decomposition, Agent 2 executes and answers, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no correction."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans decomposition, Agent 2 executes and answers, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no correction.
omni2_3427
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3427|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0025
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
01f4cebc8c56932c
2026-09-29T17:16:26.732484+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no correction."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no correction.
omni2_3427
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3427|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0025
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
01f4cebc8c56932c
2026-09-29T16:53:46.641479+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no correction."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite no correction.
omni2_3427
C
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3427|C|gemma-4-31B-it
T0026
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
0766667d25dd7b8b
2026-09-29T16:52:22.192192+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's unfinished setup and rubber-stamp the same unverified 0.485 without new computation."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's unfinished setup and rubber-stamp the same unverified 0.485 without new computation.
omni2_1145
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1145|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0026
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
0766667d25dd7b8b
2026-09-29T16:55:00.720236+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's unfinished setup and rubber-stamp the unverified 0.485 without new computation."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's unfinished setup and rubber-stamp the unverified 0.485 without new computation.
omni2_1145
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1145|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0026
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
0766667d25dd7b8b
2026-09-29T17:07:41.844068+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's setup verbatim in substance and rubber-stamp 0.485 without any new computation."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's setup verbatim in substance and rubber-stamp 0.485 without any new computation.
omni2_1145
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1145|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0027
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8d37d54229d5cbc3
2026-09-29T17:15:56.596659+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 both hand-wave the same verification, repeating Agent 1's answer without new derivation or correction."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 both hand-wave the same verification, repeating Agent 1's answer without new derivation or correction.
omni2_1253
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1253|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0027
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8d37d54229d5cbc3
2026-09-29T17:12:45.624600+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 both merely assert vague verification of Agent 1's answer; same answer, same hand-waving, no distinct roles."}
null
true
YES
YES
YES
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 both merely assert vague verification of Agent 1's answer; same answer, same hand-waving, no distinct roles.
omni2_1253
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1253|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0027
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8d37d54229d5cbc3
2026-09-29T17:35:56.588094+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 both restate Agent 1's answer with vague hand-waving 'verification', adding no real computation or correction."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 both restate Agent 1's answer with vague hand-waving 'verification', adding no real computation or correction.
omni2_1253
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1253|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0028
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
3acd91d0208b8ae8
2026-09-29T17:32:41.296104+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with computation, Agent 3 diagnoses errors and routes back for correction."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with computation, Agent 3 diagnoses errors and routes back for correction.
omni2_1141
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1141|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0028
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
3acd91d0208b8ae8
2026-09-29T17:36:12.276207+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with computations, Agent 3 diagnoses errors and routes back with corrective instructions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with computations, Agent 3 diagnoses errors and routes back with corrective instructions.
omni2_1141
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1141|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0028
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
3acd91d0208b8ae8
2026-09-29T17:00:39.556901+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes computations, Agent 3 diagnoses errors and routes back with fix instructions; distinct roles."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes computations, Agent 3 diagnoses errors and routes back with fix instructions; distinct roles.
omni2_1141
A
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_1141|A|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0029
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8bb65ed7ac89809e
2026-09-29T16:56:45.592723+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans and reduces, Agent 2 executes with explicit computations and partition list, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans and reduces, Agent 2 executes with explicit computations and partition list, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles.
omni2_365
A
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_365|A|gpt-oss-120b
T0029
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8bb65ed7ac89809e
2026-09-29T16:57:03.180449+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with explicit partition enumeration and values, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite unchanged answer."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans, Agent 2 executes with explicit partition enumeration and values, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions despite unchanged answer.
omni2_365
A
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_365|A|gpt-oss-120b
T0029
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
8bb65ed7ac89809e
2026-09-29T17:02:32.393350+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans and states lemmas, Agent 2 executes computations and enumerates partitions, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles despite carried-forward answer."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans and states lemmas, Agent 2 executes computations and enumerates partitions, Agent 3 verifies; distinct roles despite carried-forward answer.
omni2_365
A
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_365|A|gpt-oss-120b
T0030
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
9f15bfe0def48c29
2026-09-29T17:10:28.416510+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans without solving, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct roles."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans without solving, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct roles.
omni2_3696
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3696|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0030
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
9f15bfe0def48c29
2026-09-29T16:56:15.788359+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans modular strategy, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 plans modular strategy, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 checks and approves; distinct role functions.
omni2_3696
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3696|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0030
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
9f15bfe0def48c29
2026-09-29T17:27:32.285337+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"YES","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 plans without solving, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
YES
YES
Agent 1 plans without solving, Agent 2 executes and derives answer, Agent 3 verifies; distinct role functions.
omni2_3696
A
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_3696|A|gemma-4-31B-it
T0031
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
041fcad8edba527b
2026-09-29T16:59:44.141822+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's case analysis verbatim in structure, adding no new steps, corrections, or method changes."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's case analysis verbatim in structure, adding no new steps, corrections, or method changes.
omni2_2403
B
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2403|B|gemma-4-31B-it
T0031
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
041fcad8edba527b
2026-09-29T17:07:32.003875+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's case analysis verbatim in structure, adding no new steps or corrections."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's case analysis verbatim in structure, adding no new steps or corrections.
omni2_2403
B
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2403|B|gemma-4-31B-it
T0031
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
041fcad8edba527b
2026-09-29T17:07:03.558847+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"YES","Q3":"NO","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's case analysis verbatim in structure, adding no new steps, corrections, or method changes."}
null
true
YES
YES
NO
NO
NO
Agents 2 and 3 restate Agent 1's case analysis verbatim in structure, adding no new steps, corrections, or method changes.
omni2_2403
B
gemma-4-31B-it
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_2403|B|gemma-4-31B-it
T0032
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
dded7e84b1696b67
2026-09-29T17:14:18.287899+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"YES","reason":"Agent 1 proposes coefficients; Agent 2 tests specific values; Agent 3 adds asymptotic and limit analysis—different checking work, answer unchanged."}
null
true
NO
NO
YES
NO
YES
Agent 1 proposes coefficients; Agent 2 tests specific values; Agent 3 adds asymptotic and limit analysis—different checking work, answer unchanged.
omni2_138
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_138|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0032
1
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
dded7e84b1696b67
2026-09-29T17:34:26.984283+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"YES","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agent 1 asserts answer unjustified; Agents 2 and 3 both merely verify it, duplicating the checking role without changing answer or method."}
null
true
NO
YES
YES
NO
NO
Agent 1 asserts answer unjustified; Agents 2 and 3 both merely verify it, duplicating the checking role without changing answer or method.
omni2_138
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_138|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0032
2
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
dded7e84b1696b67
2026-09-29T17:21:29.957754+00:00
{"Q1":"NO","Q2":"YES","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agent 1 asserts an unjustified answer; Agents 2 and 3 both merely verify it with spot checks/limits, duplicating the same checking role."}
null
true
NO
YES
YES
NO
NO
Agent 1 asserts an unjustified answer; Agents 2 and 3 both merely verify it with spot checks/limits, duplicating the same checking role.
omni2_138
B
Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
actor3-n400
231b8c4fe205d04b
0
false
omni2_138|B|Llama-3.3-70B-Instruct
T0033
0
claude-opus-5
null
RUBRIC_v1
4f624de5b1073940
6c05c8fe867d8a5f
2026-09-29T17:18:30.919438+00:00
{"Q1":"YES","Q2":"NO","Q3":"YES","Q4":"NO","Q5":"NO","reason":"Agent 2 merely restates Agent 1's boxed answer; Agent 3 independently derives verification but truncates without conclusion or change."}
null
true
YES
NO
YES
NO
NO
Agent 2 merely restates Agent 1's boxed answer; Agent 3 independently derives verification but truncates without conclusion or change.
omni2_4130
B
gpt-oss-120b
main-n1600-v2
e3afa39849c1b980
1
false
omni2_4130|B|gpt-oss-120b