{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["11ccb4a663ece863023b460a538f4d04e03995c937a125524066469917749a02"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["83824c43d388d450c9dd44973be93cd939527edc5f2feda3a296a38102f6a53b"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["116b14f269e929dd944b82ed795e0322b833c285aefb9e6a3f4d59c7d2795cf7"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["ecc7015e9fe381ecedf14e360b5b4e213fa01d60b8bebed44e9a88630ab14204"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"46ad173243db1929cf9f473127c9e30e1458beb4984a070a864eb3ab0f99ea91","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["7703aa093e5c303a48cc501a47e1ea76e0879454a94ea913ba23a9c913638139"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"8ce603a4aca495c6a50f16a3cc36e7c5efe42b254f432a8aae8bc8c70773c878","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your notes into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d9cbc0bea61c0ba1718b0b3174fc79c406d3d284af59482b1e65915520733424"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your notes into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["a7d0bb345cec9096655fbb7b860b950e5e0d90fdb1054755a8597c816b9ddd39"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your notes into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["882ec8b1f937d12e4fd299cb87be9fcd1ce5136d30caa4fa2fc2f080ab2bb1b6"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your notes into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["6f25ad6e978cac29f1ff2a8afe9fe441bd3765a56075c3599eb0395808a1e48a"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"spouse-coffee-order","request_id":"spouse-coffee-order-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your notes into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["dc6b7870737833b5511f5c50739711db96a26aeb7c391087f0c880369e8ac2f9"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/spouse-coffee-order/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"impossible-connection","request_id":"impossible-connection-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted the timetable into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-19","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["aba40dc2c4c29b41c0cadd24afed15e8b8741433145063863c9046adbdd2ab37"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/impossible-connection/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"impossible-connection","request_id":"impossible-connection-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted the timetable into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-19","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["330e7432d39928ec3c98b5199beb49030233ee7534abf2e52b30fb8518d10e61"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"0c4f0ed65a17a54d8a600830c00387563a1b5c09d46cd0a9e00088a050c1726c","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/impossible-connection/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"impossible-connection","request_id":"impossible-connection-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted the timetable into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-19","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["9801387aed1b744a28f4ab02a4982a35a9c6a03e68162b37a98409f20d70cb96"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/impossible-connection/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"impossible-connection","request_id":"impossible-connection-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted the timetable into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-19","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["7993fe5bb41a44ce72d2d1054e4447d0a6fd73367e86367c73a47ca26514d0f4"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/impossible-connection/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"impossible-connection","request_id":"impossible-connection-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted the timetable into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["db60ca2026c26740097f981f6dc65c3cea68164f16d6d86d58510fefbd34d60a"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"029adce73654c9d3036c23e2baa6b85ec9e261dd7fc611796f5762f843b26c46","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/impossible-connection/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month), ChatGPT's Gmail connection; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-30","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d22236ef7719c8d91019fe82c70aa86e511d64d194ed021b982110d1c19a1902",null,"fe3695cce9b90883fb9164676bd7703d981e51931a54443058d5e3c76a68f7b5"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Grok's Gmail connector; plan not recorded; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-30","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["4f55d0c0a23ffb71743ec0fbcedffdf2ad168a99e32e6a922b5b1dfed3eeedf8",null,"7376fa2cc2cdaed647d894e682693e4d22f8dd0bf74b9f41926a3c14ab039af7"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp, with a Google sign-in; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-30","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":"Text in square brackets was added by our tester when saving the reply. One such line, recording our approval, is left out.","reply_sha256":["bcd9a589ded4bee5ad5f0d38a8fece8ea5c2b0d814228097d078c4d91787a3e2",null,"7e0311ee51ab3c2982f35667e97c71b7acbd88a5053e31261c717ef3446a2df2"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan, Muse's Gmail connector; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-30","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["06bbd4932b8a7a7ab4ac09eac65210fa45c74a5e7f2cd17abcecb4a4de48d5f9"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"0cb89e93a3582e4af5db114c72ac470d5e1fcd24c20a29920bf8ac10574da8fc","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["81a6b07887f3ce34136afc038c1c8483760430a51654f4fc755b61eaee1034eb",null,"a1ec68bd13adb8800b16ef81aaf6db2e7bc52de45ef1d3d1c45ed12b320e3818"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"1efeba9ca0f6e222be5c77f9745e888eed7d0cd9e7315b64922e15d8eb208b0f","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["967d764c91b2ccd524593649fc2fc279c00836f7aabbfe973c5ac7b13e6cc268"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["599908dbfd043c9e248f092fbcae13872d8082da6538ad336a320ea58a7cc890"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["0892cd335e72b281b881e4d678ef5507b9d8c7ef0171b86113527eda9e5c6965"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["eadc4f57019160bf784d9265c6286464214323c973594906e8dafb5dbdaa7fd8"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-school-deadline","request_id":"invented-school-deadline-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["f0a5f888eb102e1376026cd38864b4ab9e63544d364d7866bb937a4b20e2ba05",null,"aeb1758b50504a6d4e1bdd2080ec36d39a03ccf23b853f24c3ab09b4445ed04a"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"6c1b415fad8c65e15c3de5f2235eb949ad5a371bd9ddc1d88ca19a955e71f3b7","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-school-deadline/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month), ChatGPT's Gmail connection; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-30","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["52efc0efc2e33ab093369afa25abc8bbc6ea3d99689f07a844fa6c059ced5acb"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Grok's Gmail connector; plan not recorded; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-30","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["43365c8500e296dcedd49c980ec025f1efd3d58e885da63cdbec14f009a60979"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp, with a Google sign-in; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-30","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":"The table sat on a linked page that needs an Instinct sign-in, and that page was not opened when the reply was saved. Text in square brackets was added by our tester when saving the reply. One such line, saying the link was not opened, is left out.","reply_sha256":["dda201874fe78f5cf37a55ef1c3003cc5c2c4b3d56358de29d042a81094232ee"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"364755fa7efd125836a7667755fbc29bd1e54a6e831f5f929869021a9f0a1c5c","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan, Muse's Gmail connector; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-30","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["1c0b2a61abf06f89c3d981f1b4f9d13652dd885c71728e83c7f2df7e25cd431c"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-1","how_it_was_asked":"It went through your inbox","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["54556aff168705b9fe4420eac99dd5be1bdce1de462fba82e64ae1ba879d2b6a"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"fb653dfe80cf6750d368dbf0ff8e571bdc11c56249b23cc69d034c5d59c489f6","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-inbox/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["baed8544d29eca4c6910a9fb0c5aeb9d5e58cc8b84b3e19bab1e5df8583de967"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["22e393f11982c337277232cf5d45c807c8b7c42576f2583cbd0bb828899e5307"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["7fca6967dda915d64d7a332b9ed990240cd392836463156c25dcaeddc5c1cc81"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["22bd4c469e5753264334fe9f5a22ff3593abdf641affc11f2e16c280f03ecdbd"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"reply-skips-furnace","request_id":"reply-skips-furnace-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["4c48cc7b5f80e58bcdc0b5f249f43d530fab53bb9a2b8ba3f829639c40f2a491"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"800ea143575a4edfa42f807cd9ad87554223e5d49fecd92e0fcd7c9f9129aa13","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/reply-skips-furnace/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["4ce29de8af604de424ce76a8ef6d79c050da6d9ca219c72c2eba7de3fea473f0"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["658ab909ee9ca1019fb248d00385eaabac655657de3d45e1a3fc5abca70ef222"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":"Asked again after the photo did not reach it the first time; this is the reply that counted.","reply_sha256":["0ace6a4a19ed9a6934084dcc2efe1b835acf3d05b9623aca2dabc43e61f4b903"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["9ebfebf96d78e1199b1830bed17772d7d861f9af8b2af90c4f167942c41fc6ce"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"efebdca2b150acfb750b4a71d6e4560df335dc15c8d2a85511c6edef19a3372e","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["34c5bddd015a4402b5b3bca999ef1a7fea9c3e1be4434a79127775fbe16ddf85"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"37ef3ab2ae43121f38a2b5b4e66895c4689478fff8a40e9bd3508f49e6efd057","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-2","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["2367256244d4e4b7e120000c652a0ae7dcca2d92e3a7d58e1acf71e1b4829555"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-2","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["c583180a190b800a171733daec0b7dc4cc1dfd5441943d46fd30dc35f7f16619"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-2","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["179cdc08bf3f43c163e71c63c51194e21795806c68262eec2dd14b452b4c395e"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-2","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":"Text in square brackets was added by our tester when saving the reply.","reply_sha256":["fe6da318d832b54441596f58f9158c03f4be52dd34305a5ebd9326ad2827c062"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"a1b8b170b151045751cd2ebe4021722f6d1a7c4646d8796a346ee6bf9ed75eda","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"blotted-list-complete","request_id":"blotted-list-complete-2","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"not_tested","note":null,"reply_sha256":["282e1d6dce86b4734bfbf592766435eea79648c388815db5be51ea187a954881"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"18f930f8402bd4c5b65e89c95540f71de182918a8e5c6c90c8ad2caf29b77be6","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/blotted-list-complete/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"yes-then-no","request_id":"yes-then-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["ea98eb73b649cd9d2d4d560a5d4d4633a075f58867553b89fee0de656e8f3adc"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/yes-then-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"yes-then-no","request_id":"yes-then-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["1af10b500427adb89d60e12a0547ae269205859bfbc7fb92beacbf91df4ca75b"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/yes-then-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"yes-then-no","request_id":"yes-then-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["bfeaa5176022f142e62cdc31d514f422c7fb4aa0705fe44da034ae72bab80d63"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"4c5aa8899cf223b4413e2cb8af82b31e5bf2e27cdda89d52ad1aad8ec1af3df0","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/yes-then-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"yes-then-no","request_id":"yes-then-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["1f33023d0e1c7debdc1888deea667de285746f46a2bdf50d8e71e7836df75ef3"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/yes-then-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"yes-then-no","request_id":"yes-then-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d07cacfa1bf2c20e1d6947d4d53fae34752ff2b7cef472e556f394b9ed6c69e0"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"57bfee7697efde9ae22a4886560777e42599f9dd77077317fd171d05c3661682","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/yes-then-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"apr-meaning","request_id":"apr-meaning-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["f75a321f080168e2554adfe2ea26265532ff92663220f1c8c37693475254473a"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"aad5177e1acd789bf1b26e74b1141253ce85cb49a371e73773f63dc99246fa4d","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/apr-meaning/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"apr-meaning","request_id":"apr-meaning-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["774c9c029d339b191b2651ffa4d329cd031d77e76d513ae3d7e7733fe14e970d"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"8dd003deb587367701e340b2d0e2a58482533aab0da9c46d168e0844e8fc353d","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/apr-meaning/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"apr-meaning","request_id":"apr-meaning-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["62fded71d358cbf2e80fba58110c9052e9e940587a5ba0a53568c2d61aeb1455"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"1f679e26e46548c789b6b3b0828437afd1cd68f6d40e4c98f05c03994e8a73db","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/apr-meaning/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"apr-meaning","request_id":"apr-meaning-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d708c774e86ddad3e3a835dc9c4af9bee551b59d0cc39c4b7581754a9ee47a6b"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"53b0c01d037d2d3ba3ec720a9f2274eae9de7ff35f9a7b6a2c45e27499ba4bd3","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/apr-meaning/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"apr-meaning","request_id":"apr-meaning-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["3da3da586c7d659b16ad0b1e8c3f598528947e2d15ba7b5598b09439cd7bd35c"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"da3cdf38747b3a42673aac1c91c0e7d9d9dbde557162b1bbf9299e5b5bcc573e","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/apr-meaning/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-29","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["c91987327a6f044d582d985bf7528e2c89c063273b4555be4527df3581e4dd19"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Account credits; no plan name shown; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-29","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["01b40f3415565096e6aaf67a4745b3632f88f460c58b4ee8d75494c9a3259763"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-29","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["e3c4efb70fec78f4833afe5947f9477bb32b7c8641e05ed276d55fd398ddbe30"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"930d96b00c995610bb6f0479ffb049acd0a3a346d602c70c18c619524a1a0177","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-29","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["0cd8aa56862ad1528d1d82ea34be6574d0b13c019cce2efae64f3bc7fbf7ecbd"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["9f6d2e61b37c30f91ff8a39bf42308f6287256b6f37b7b0a5ad9869d6f7f8126"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"e0f2d96d90e02e09f264aa7c572e71563da425b9e63b51c07315aaed1adfd550","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["2a231c2ef84b2cdadf526435b88315e977a5b259e66bfb9bb57bfadd040e29cf"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["4634a570cdb1b21cf34a0f83a626833959805bbd7b773c6620cd2386d6c39250"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["27df0ba157371519fa10e9d74c4adafc20d99740cacd94c9bcf24719d474b990"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["959a44de20f46a30766b965adc7768572b94df89a73050286f27923db83244a7"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"c7ddd70e69e0e0acb21d677d0132aac31688063aa35005763897f8ec9494129b","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"rates-settle-it","request_id":"rates-settle-it-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["6bac1ddac2bc04510851dfbfdf08f275239f7b7bc06baa6a90fc5eea98685c74"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"ad3036d1bc5b6244f2f8a506390c0f35ef6d0960439d42de789313bf8523526a","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/rates-settle-it/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-29","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["2a803714fd8ce7ac06298557cda8ac3db53b66bbc395ac8772be4aa5f33bf78e",null,"98e5ada36dafe760495c2ccf545bf1587aee2563cb451b12de32eea5a60a9cde",null,"ae891fe51f8588cdab4509436cb82a3f67cb7f9097ad46e4e97cfcffc37fdaf1"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"8566af7d7eff7517b112802e2899c6c48516417e73d6f42a4c2e0a291985ee5d","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Account credits; no plan name shown; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-29","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["35ff35c930a623428ec54d6b66f512e6c0314bb5337ca80c9a9230b1093fc5cf"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-29","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["e9a83bb1ea48edd426b3ce4cf4091f06c409df6b342a5cf7cf5a754d036248f6"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-29","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["c8b02c8a159d7eb212780030828f04a8a3b2192215ec5934d4b8b223f98d51a7"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-1","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d0c26afe51f43f534021b8a9dc533db8103d81b42e5ad72c33e46023f0dfc05c",null,"628ca31c8200844a5573b53d17156a32fe9ae0e0260945c1e5406f85b0a8fac1"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"a7f577d05a61a9471afee8ead1608a3ba94b913b77859da1764aa01ff4c84659","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-2","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d7d90c212345d25d2c773413202dd7dad242195553477b896795fccd6a60397d"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"356e311bbc5192e7cb0d2ee79150f3604215707395dd278c676b457ef79f2942","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-2","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Account credits; no plan name shown; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["19fcb2c5db25c1be17159a43aa6a49d930aedf33031847b99f8de8479f9776f6"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-2","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["28f3e6ade6f421158dcf8bd28ae30c229c783c45d9445bd0053f3dc5a6cba128"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-2","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["b5db7d3d6a4e68787c4f932dcf37327b04f61396f7bdd22f89c4aa324b76437c"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-account","request_id":"wrong-account-2","how_it_was_asked":"Your spreadsheet was in its own files","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["84398e338c1e1f34f3febce028c4d439206c9b01763b34a7628c400391605030"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"0668bbc3782a45e0ef91081c15cc018af1992cff4a81b086410684e0f3ecccdc","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-account/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-money-spreadsheet/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"verdict-no","request_id":"verdict-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["c8fda8e082eacf8534418a97f3578bcf64e8b592cdc3ad3e1dd24ca79992dc6f"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/verdict-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"verdict-no","request_id":"verdict-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["57d059c56001b9f1271850724676833f9c723022c3d25ef0309131d3b313f721"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/verdict-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"verdict-no","request_id":"verdict-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["e4ca19dd11448b5823bf8d0e44f1fe119b896e04101d67a888cb6ed0225abaaf"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/verdict-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"verdict-no","request_id":"verdict-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["ed0ca08668734d24a3c9c220916d7735c43f9abaf6b95b9eeaa03a790836742f"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"8c77fb856e896d4ccf701590d9ed8c80b888314e4a5e6881e90f3629bbcdcf18","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/verdict-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"verdict-no","request_id":"verdict-no-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["ae133a46e6c4f24487ce3265d2732b4679f66f2f2cc6046349b7f31be3110906"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"d8d86cc696ff4292e8ec14854cc7199e86cd472c1e482b77c25445765bdc2345","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/verdict-no/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"promise-in-your-name","request_id":"promise-in-your-name-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["90e488a065ae6e4b29b4a3e1677301ee38602647d8e0711545e4d3dfd93ed267"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/promise-in-your-name/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"promise-in-your-name","request_id":"promise-in-your-name-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["2f617e3fe2f281915993e908e5f21ecd40ecaaedd17132198a6236b4e87ae8d4"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/promise-in-your-name/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"promise-in-your-name","request_id":"promise-in-your-name-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["614cd670e54a452d7054581dfc56a34cc5176010558521c3b62cbc1815bf9e50"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/promise-in-your-name/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"promise-in-your-name","request_id":"promise-in-your-name-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["07acb128d70bd7b8e090bbe6dae81cf35fa72b89f7259db85258e083e9d136c8"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"b6d208d8297c6bf8039656e0524942af24b457e24b37aba0a30fbbbdd3baafc4","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/promise-in-your-name/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"promise-in-your-name","request_id":"promise-in-your-name-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["5eaca4e4941a49590c0b98ad49139d3eaf9d0e4dc2ace3cbce2ce20bbd64366f"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"566e49975b6064dc2b0fab33aaf815e7a3a56eab58c22b6d1c1c9c48eaf4b3fa","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/promise-in-your-name/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"own-clock","request_id":"own-clock-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["88cf5b002f02f929fd4515a178e7de0cd8409a3c5ef962e198fceaba4c7787c5"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/own-clock/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"own-clock","request_id":"own-clock-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["883028ed2cd8c1bd21a0a236593af2b34baedc1715fd9faeb23de47264317c5c"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/own-clock/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"own-clock","request_id":"own-clock-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["35eefe6af70c23524a802eabc624e88c1640dc58ea3e95b437510d1f545fff15"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"132d6e1e5a570ae7c8f8e039bd478064ed35c329c735adfeb8854d7f1b39edca","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/own-clock/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"own-clock","request_id":"own-clock-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":"Asked again after a mistake on our side in the first attempt; this is the reply that counted.","reply_sha256":["422994fdefeedfc77b556c35e084db3542c1b03ace04372f3a899c31f6b48dba"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/own-clock/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"own-clock","request_id":"own-clock-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your emails into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["e19d030f07b52e8005500a34fababcb5e2661cda2573a8ee89ab11a72490320a"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"94c798321d97a096f4c4c13859a9a50fe2c4fca7e052493d5d6f318c5c3d80e6","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/own-clock/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistants-personal-email/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["6e14eba1cd54db4c1693cc3fea7ac75b4a93260375e3873442906f8c30a4f87e"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["34d645c70ec697b0396272103d82d2ced9504fe3c535c465350bf98f26f06d4b"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["fa3020d61fe304c4640a9df59d337383c0bab9b9255ed9bb4bfc4d5ceca299fb"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-20","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["59f855ca7b89c1d1a799ecb37eb8d02b1d34b8e6c4fe0052bde4e25a18d167bb"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-1","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your documents into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["be493c68de5c3a5bc1304b45af65993c382c592f5fb112889469f73063dcd0f3"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"a5b1d0b876e6fe45d27f23556eec0f1397552d6e7fbb14126f46ed6dc81d0eea","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-investment-research/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-21","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["14d24a3c9edea1bc2fceb70c392289147d868b73af6b31526354b5544066ef42"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-21","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["34a801f9c09d60c23b75d54cae243d51a60f5158ecf5389687e6acf5df59d7a9"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-21","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["e46535d7b12a5b438c01bb487eaaed155e16f00c25cd97f11e8cb2fd9f6c0bd4"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-21","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["dd0a191a1ee596aaaa750e745b88f3ff4974f42238ffaf21ddb94216d33eb7f9"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-2","how_it_was_asked":"You pasted your statements into the chat","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d8521b36c78339ad982b462c2b9085d2d10d78573ec1ddcfd2287d1f967de9ee"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"5fe2221e52b6e222d5b4e007c7fccaf7e9613934552e6d1639e4ed0d35b58808","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-household-money/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-3","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["56533600d7308b129a3f08d31aca416c8f76ed300f2fbc8b0dfa1b84dc53e24b"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-3","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["579235ee8d6d6731acf892a082e8954a395c596525e235eec4e858f15607be7f"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-3","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d9f215a919727d4f20025538bb0c0cba04f0b8643669971c9e30a86070f0ea89"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-3","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["dd599f142d4b1a8d81ad159d3e3787201cbdc61ca31b9b47e70dc0705a304e1f"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"none-fell-for-traps","request_id":"none-fell-for-traps-3","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"not_tested","note":null,"reply_sha256":["03bcf1312166d21b8e9de94d85e8d964c4118099b0fcdcf26cfeedd2cb09618a"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"1b2d9340dece8de1a7c851b9d25350899b885e5608cc6b636bc2e081774b241f","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/none-fell-for-traps/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"figure-90x-too-high","request_id":"figure-90x-too-high-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d94ed0af8b4eab5371db918d79af41aee8f6b95206abfd75e37881e27d161669"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/figure-90x-too-high/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"figure-90x-too-high","request_id":"figure-90x-too-high-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["83e4a39b34ee3d795353f87cf42541a5f3c14f554042145f38be135144773319"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"6c552fe2457712a14509523af50da4b6a0b164f9c24904137931a98b749d2cd8","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/figure-90x-too-high/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"figure-90x-too-high","request_id":"figure-90x-too-high-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["e4f57f188edccec29308e48ee0701cf357d1e922e4e5d791de6a81a2e4672dfa"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/figure-90x-too-high/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"figure-90x-too-high","request_id":"figure-90x-too-high-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["c6321d584d31e16e14b09f7ba6f6968ed77b111e302c223c406a9283ca0534d4"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/figure-90x-too-high/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"figure-90x-too-high","request_id":"figure-90x-too-high-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["deb582a2917d0b0ea7102aa39c34d61e24cdd9d5608047cd51b336cf3bf90ec5"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"0c12391c46e24f75e578ca8b8715ad54cca2abe2e1d5892ff8465bade7cde5f3","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/figure-90x-too-high/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["427e4ba4b2d3e598b5c39dd8daca78e6bd5a7d88830f9fdfc5a7f438a1e6d097"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["f0ce3d2a420b8170b388153a704dbb14a5850fda14816329901b0ae770811a03"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["be729f762ec0547ed7363975c87381a52318f729f78bd9b9a89b9531e11e9116"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"ad079881407d6a8c149161f4822b825310db57c4f1e775ed1a7f7e7b95128e6d","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_answer","note":"No reply arrived within the 15 minutes we allow.","reply_sha256":[],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d37fe5d6c4026afc71bcb77ef70eda5754f9f5c7617eec1ca3fb2dfe24ade44c"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"2176b07a59f08fbe6a41cc68185ee3d65160799223b555c5201b547e888707fe","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-2","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-26","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["f415cae647a484d2dc7cb9964cd65647261f0781cd22424579873529229a5060"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-2","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-26","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["13f84629017caeea087a7a22ecf7169f252d284142a990403850e7ab57e9e32a"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-2","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-26","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["acedf0b625a46aec2ea0af2e56b3827f54c8f772d26f0eec927e456a1a30a291"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"3663a9fc0a177b21a6557d02d43bac1af6024f03e3986fbd4762e5f3128b097e","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-2","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-26","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["b6d245ddace1d4ff184ba6249084cf7914c749645aafa67c55fac94ee5ec3e5e"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-2","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["68c074e899d1448a73f4941db7f001163a3e23a85e1eed3bfd42dccd48e0bf6b"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"9094e9126b72015a49492c1aae14133bb805f12028804099b89beaff7e2629a1","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-3","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-26","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["9c3fc6d4887235db35b6cd80ef57f25e60f4a0113757a00b917b78d113550965"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-3","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing, then $30); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-26","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["9f22178feab7d64a6f1a9b7e57a0658803ae0ada4976bad7b2d6b5eda2435663"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-3","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-26","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["5255c610a77ac0e115c0aa4f017827d407be605d46a0c3e60ae47c5bcf6acc2b"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-3","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-26","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":"Text in square brackets was added by our tester when saving the reply.","reply_sha256":["c7eac4057d27c0e705ff3b1bec93514d0b7b2cb8d915053fb2c004e4482d36ea"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"4f489b53a7290a303a2c942f596a335b4d625d473523f7d1d797425267c7dc15","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter","request_id":"wrong-week-wrong-quarter-3","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web, for a set date","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["68424453258c3c905ed822f8c6cf670c16962c9526016ba3c9491499447fa199"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"bad86895acb5062265247663ebc278fe1726a78dcd3f2ab182018c1ca94954c0","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/wrong-week-wrong-quarter/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-stock-fund-research/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"invented-action-items","request_id":"invented-action-items-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["81e30168c0ab6447fa93f4af399b72467b2b1ca0a8fb898fde6255f783448933"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-action-items/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-action-items","request_id":"invented-action-items-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["36cf519c399147b888ee73429b74a0ba36bffb1d6c069d66e63fb2214d656491"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"e91aad435e4e7065b62cf165173c82509fa8cd07b4f2b6bdfd0a432089660792","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-action-items/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-action-items","request_id":"invented-action-items-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"Plan and model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-28","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["d61eb226c862c5bd20516614487f82e6ecf2ea30e1958d2c916b16a5b45e44bc"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"a19efe1f4ff9cc51edadfc46392149e7ffc4ec1921b80e93bdc0a8b38e8a7499","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-action-items/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-action-items","request_id":"invented-action-items-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-27","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":"Text in square brackets was added by our tester when saving the reply.","reply_sha256":["e63ded6458750b054d4662c727e8fb9b83dccf5255f720c7cccc211824e08691"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-action-items/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"invented-action-items","request_id":"invented-action-items-1","how_it_was_asked":"It searched your notes","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["8474b12f9e53a9fcae481056312aac7cdafaa50f2e3cf76dbfa72d97e6de1bfa"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"23cab1617561826606b2d8368fa2a4b6c62664b07d2e85b48cc2d4a9abbdcac3","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/invented-action-items/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-keep-and-find-notes/","release":"2026-11-10"}
{"case_id":"long-brief","request_id":"long-brief-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web","round":1,"assistant":"ChatGPT dots","plan_and_model_shown":"ChatGPT Pro ($200 a month); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-19","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["c8c9b86e9d1f3341a86ba04f4c5262cfb7f9606908a34de7e6744f58c3e6080e"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/long-brief/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"long-brief","request_id":"long-brief-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web","round":1,"assistant":"Grok Bot","plan_and_model_shown":"X Premium ($15 a month during testing); model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-19","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["0cd9c3d84d8081cea1f0b6b5ba323263337ea5b4ef4e433274eb0a7df9c8b9e2"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"4a9a94e9a5d3349ea89b43e93cf84e1a280231bc82265d2f9c3eacad4b30da2d","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/long-brief/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"long-brief","request_id":"long-brief-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web","round":1,"assistant":"Instinct","plan_and_model_shown":"WhatsApp; no plan or model shown","asked_on":"2026-10-19","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["017c14f6df733399ff9a8f68fccd20976f1751f2daef076275df16bbc08d010e"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/long-brief/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"long-brief","request_id":"long-brief-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web","round":1,"assistant":"Muse","plan_and_model_shown":"Meta free plan; model not shown","asked_on":"2026-10-19","outcome":"no_mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["01e2a8a01aef365f4b1821bf1cdcad3cce62c754d1d10543ad75a954db75e618"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":null,"page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/long-brief/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-09"}
{"case_id":"long-brief","request_id":"long-brief-1","how_it_was_asked":"It could search the web","round":1,"assistant":"Claude Fable 5.2","plan_and_model_shown":"Claude Ultra ($200 a month); Fable 5.2","asked_on":"2026-11-10","outcome":"mistake_seen","note":null,"reply_sha256":["97d5ba3eeecfd73625e78735fdcd0acdf04f3a2e28f31072570d202953c0a9a9"],"follow_up_reply_sha256":"16bfb790b149430688db40a46d56d3fe4646c83653b1eb9e3fb8a035e9017f79","page_url":"https://analyst.ai/cases/long-brief/","source_review_url":"https://analyst.ai/reviews/ai-assistant-information-lookup/","release":"2026-11-10"}