#!/usr/bin/env python3 """Evaluate public-input-only methods by origin with authority-grouped intervals.""" from __future__ import annotations import argparse import json import random from collections import defaultdict from pathlib import Path ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] def load_jsonl(path: Path) -> list[dict]: return [json.loads(line) for line in path.read_text().splitlines() if line.strip()] def load_inputs() -> dict[str, dict]: return { row["case_id"]: row for split in ("development", "validation", "test") for row in load_jsonl(ROOT / f"hf/closed_loop_inputs/{split}.jsonl") } def load_labels() -> dict[str, dict]: paths = [ ROOT / "hf/public_labels/development.jsonl", ROOT / "hf/public_labels/validation.jsonl", ROOT / "private/sealed_labels/test.jsonl", ] return {row["case_id"]: row for path in paths for row in load_jsonl(path)} def case_metrics(row: dict, label: dict, pred: dict) -> dict[str, float]: gold = label["gold"] target_path = set(gold["affected_components"]) target_scope = set(gold["revalidation_components"]) path = set(pred["affected_components"]) scope = set(pred["revalidation_components"]) reviewed = set(pred.get("reviewed_components", pred["revalidation_components"])) auditable = {node["node_id"] for node in row["workflow"]["components"] if node["node_type"] != "provenance"} predicted_release = float(pred["release_permitted"]) release_opportunity = float(gold["release_permitted"]) safe_release = float(pred["release_permitted"] and gold["release_permitted"]) unsafe = float(pred["release_permitted"] and not gold["release_permitted"]) path_recall = len(path & target_path) / len(target_path) if target_path else float(not path) scope_recall = len(scope & target_scope) / len(target_scope) if target_scope else float(not scope) action = float(pred["governance_action"] == gold["governance_action"]) safe_loop = float(action and not unsafe and path_recall == 1 and scope_recall == 1) return { "action_accuracy": action, "release_rate": predicted_release, "release_opportunity": release_opportunity, "unsafe_opportunity": 1.0 - release_opportunity, "safe_release": safe_release, "unsafe_release": unsafe, "exact_path": float(path == target_path), "exact_scope": float(scope == target_scope), "path_recall": path_recall, "scope_recall": scope_recall, "safe_loop": safe_loop, "review_fraction": len(reviewed & auditable) / max(1, len(auditable)), } def summarize(records: list[tuple[str, dict[str, float]]], bootstrap: int, seed: int) -> dict: internal = {"release_opportunity", "unsafe_opportunity", "safe_release"} metrics = sorted(set(records[0][1]) - internal) point = {metric: sum(item[metric] for _, item in records) / len(records) for metric in metrics} release_opportunities = sum(item["release_opportunity"] for _, item in records) point["safe_release_recall"] = ( sum(item["safe_release"] for _, item in records) / release_opportunities if release_opportunities else None ) unsafe_opportunities = sum(item["unsafe_opportunity"] for _, item in records) point["unsafe_case_release_rate"] = ( sum(item["unsafe_release"] for _, item in records) / unsafe_opportunities if unsafe_opportunities else None ) by_group: dict[str, list[dict[str, float]]] = defaultdict(list) for group, item in records: by_group[group].append(item) groups = sorted(by_group) rng = random.Random(seed) draws = {metric: [] for metric in metrics} safe_release_recall_draws = [] unsafe_case_release_rate_draws = [] for _ in range(bootstrap): sampled = [rng.choice(groups) for _ in groups] rows = [item for group in sampled for item in by_group[group]] for metric in metrics: draws[metric].append(sum(item[metric] for item in rows) / len(rows)) opportunities = sum(item["release_opportunity"] for item in rows) if opportunities: safe_release_recall_draws.append(sum(item["safe_release"] for item in rows) / opportunities) unsafe_opportunities = sum(item["unsafe_opportunity"] for item in rows) if unsafe_opportunities: unsafe_case_release_rate_draws.append( sum(item["unsafe_release"] for item in rows) / unsafe_opportunities ) ci = {} for metric in metrics: values = sorted(draws[metric]) ci[metric] = [values[int(0.025 * (len(values) - 1))], values[int(0.975 * (len(values) - 1))]] if safe_release_recall_draws: values = sorted(safe_release_recall_draws) ci["safe_release_recall"] = [ values[int(0.025 * (len(values) - 1))], values[int(0.975 * (len(values) - 1))], ] else: ci["safe_release_recall"] = [None, None] if unsafe_case_release_rate_draws: values = sorted(unsafe_case_release_rate_draws) ci["unsafe_case_release_rate"] = [ values[int(0.025 * (len(values) - 1))], values[int(0.975 * (len(values) - 1))], ] else: ci["unsafe_case_release_rate"] = [None, None] return {"cases": len(records), "groups": len(groups), "point": point, "clustered_95_ci": ci} def paired_difference( inputs: dict[str, dict], left: dict[str, dict[str, float]], right: dict[str, dict[str, float]], bootstrap: int, seed: int, ) -> dict: """Authority-clustered paired differences, left minus right.""" metrics = sorted( set(next(iter(left.values()))) - {"release_opportunity", "unsafe_opportunity", "safe_release"} ) by_group: dict[str, list[str]] = defaultdict(list) for case_id, row in inputs.items(): by_group[row["workflow_context"]["authority_id"]].append(case_id) groups = sorted(by_group) def difference(case_ids: list[str], metric: str) -> float: return sum(left[case_id][metric] - right[case_id][metric] for case_id in case_ids) / len(case_ids) all_ids = list(inputs) point = {metric: difference(all_ids, metric) for metric in metrics} rng = random.Random(seed) draws = {metric: [] for metric in metrics} for _ in range(bootstrap): sampled = [rng.choice(groups) for _ in groups] case_ids = [case_id for group in sampled for case_id in by_group[group]] for metric in metrics: draws[metric].append(difference(case_ids, metric)) ci = {} for metric, values in draws.items(): ordered = sorted(values) ci[metric] = [ordered[int(0.025 * (len(ordered) - 1))], ordered[int(0.975 * (len(ordered) - 1))]] return {"cases": len(all_ids), "groups": len(groups), "point": point, "clustered_95_ci": ci} def main() -> None: parser = argparse.ArgumentParser() parser.add_argument("--prediction-dir", type=Path, default=ROOT / "results/public_predictions") parser.add_argument("--output", type=Path, default=ROOT / "results/fingovbench_public_comparison.json") parser.add_argument("--bootstrap", type=int, default=2000) parser.add_argument("--case-origin", choices=("controlled", "genuine_revision")) parser.add_argument("--split", choices=("development", "validation", "test")) parser.add_argument("--limit", type=int) parser.add_argument( "--methods", nargs="+", default=("lexical", "direct_llm", "flat_point", "flat_uq", "graph_propagation"), ) args = parser.parse_args() inputs, labels = load_inputs(), load_labels() if args.split: selected = { row["case_id"] for row in load_jsonl(ROOT / f"hf/closed_loop_inputs/{args.split}.jsonl") } inputs = {case_id: row for case_id, row in inputs.items() if case_id in selected} labels = {case_id: row for case_id, row in labels.items() if case_id in selected} if args.case_origin: selected = {case_id for case_id, row in inputs.items() if row["case_origin"] == args.case_origin} inputs = {case_id: row for case_id, row in inputs.items() if case_id in selected} labels = {case_id: row for case_id, row in labels.items() if case_id in selected} if args.limit: selected = set(sorted(inputs)[: args.limit]) inputs = {case_id: row for case_id, row in inputs.items() if case_id in selected} labels = {case_id: row for case_id, row in labels.items() if case_id in selected} report = { "benchmark_version": "1.0.0-rc4", "evaluation_scope": "/".join( part for part in (args.split, args.case_origin) if part ) or "all", "label_status": "contract-derived; external expert adjudication pending", "methods": {}, } metric_rows_by_method: dict[str, dict[str, dict[str, float]]] = {} for method in args.methods: predictions = { row["case_id"]: row for row in load_jsonl(args.prediction_dir / f"{method}.jsonl") if row["case_id"] in inputs } if set(predictions) != set(inputs): raise SystemExit(f"{method}: predictions do not match the {len(inputs)} public inputs") metric_rows_by_method[method] = { case_id: case_metrics(inputs[case_id], labels[case_id], predictions[case_id]) for case_id in inputs } method_report = {} origins = [origin for origin in ("genuine_revision", "controlled") if any(row["case_origin"] == origin for row in inputs.values())] for origin in (*origins, "all"): ids = [case_id for case_id, row in inputs.items() if origin == "all" or row["case_origin"] == origin] records = [ (inputs[case_id]["workflow_context"]["authority_id"], case_metrics(inputs[case_id], labels[case_id], predictions[case_id])) for case_id in ids ] method_report[origin] = summarize(records, args.bootstrap, seed=20260921) method_report["controlled_scenarios"] = {} scenarios = sorted({ label["evaluation_strata"]["scenario"] for label in labels.values() if label["evaluation_strata"]["origin"] == "controlled" }) for scenario in scenarios: ids = [ case_id for case_id, label in labels.items() if label["evaluation_strata"]["origin"] == "controlled" and label["evaluation_strata"]["scenario"] == scenario ] records = [ (inputs[case_id]["workflow_context"]["authority_id"], case_metrics(inputs[case_id], labels[case_id], predictions[case_id])) for case_id in ids ] method_report["controlled_scenarios"][scenario] = summarize(records, args.bootstrap, seed=20260921) report["methods"][method] = method_report report["paired_comparisons"] = {} if "graph_propagation" in metric_rows_by_method and "flat_uq" in metric_rows_by_method: report["paired_comparisons"]["graph_propagation_minus_flat_uq"] = paired_difference( inputs, metric_rows_by_method["graph_propagation"], metric_rows_by_method["flat_uq"], args.bootstrap, seed=20260922, ) args.output.parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) args.output.write_text(json.dumps(report, indent=2, sort_keys=True) + "\n") print(json.dumps(report, indent=2, sort_keys=True)) if __name__ == "__main__": main()