# Negative-experiment appendix: tool trajectory learning and contract regression Author: Chonghao Ju. **Local release candidate; not published or approved for publication.** Neither experiment replaces the released AlignTune ownership gate or its 23/30 shopping workflow. Paid iteration is stopped. | Experiment | Base | Ownership adapter | Trajectory adapter | |---|---:|---:|---:| | Original trajectory experiment | 0/72 direct tools | 34/72 with a deterministic controller | 39/72 direct tools | | Expanded contract, all direct tools | 0/72 | 1/72 | 0/72 | These rows use different prompts and, for ownership, different architectures. They are not one ranking. The 72 tasks are exposed synthetic cases, not a new independent test. ## Offline reproduction Python 3.9+; no packages, network, GPU, credentials or inference: ```sh python3 -I -B replay.py ``` The script verifies hashes, 196 teacher trajectories, every executed tool call in both experiments, exact metrics and family-bootstrap intervals. It copies records to a temporary directory for re-scoring; packaged records are never overwritten. Expected output ends in APPENDIX_PASS. Offline replay recomputes scores from saved answers; it does not regenerate model predictions. ## Contents - `data/`: 304 source-matched synthetic tasks (196 training, 36 development, 72 held-out/exposed), exact teacher calls, literal-value overrides and simulated replies. - `recorded/distillation/`: 216 evaluation trajectories, original local metrics, and training-mask receipt. - `recorded/regression/`: 234 trajectories (18 development and 216 regression), exact summary, paired changes and separately labeled post-hoc format diagnosis. - `code/`: historical environment, prompts, training loss checks and scoring; portable inference helpers. - `adapter/`: **non-adopted** trajectory LoRA, 30.7 MB; no base weights. Only the saved base-path metadata is normalized. Weight bytes unchanged. - `config/`, `provenance.json`: versions, settings, criteria and transformations. - `INFERENCE.md`: optional fresh-inference/training instructions. They require separate compute and are never invoked by replay. No private profile/reserve/library texts, authentication files, billing/account receipts, cloud launchers, private Hub addresses or cloud logs are included. Source task text matches the already-public authored component dataset exactly. New model outputs, compiled traces, overrides and the trajectory adapter are still proposed exports awaiting user confirmation. See REPORT.md for findings and limitations, LICENSE-SCOPE.md for the distinct code/data/model permissions, and FILES.csv for the exact proposed publication list.