--- license: cc-by-4.0 pretty_name: Model Merging & Capability Transfer Dataset tags: [model-merging, permutation-alignment, mergeability, language-models, negative-results] configs: - config_name: merged_models data_files: data/merged_models.parquet default: true - config_name: merges data_files: data/merges.parquet - config_name: evaluations data_files: data/evaluations.parquet - config_name: models data_files: data/models.parquet - config_name: summary data_files: data/summary.parquet --- # Model Merging & Capability Transfer Dataset A dataset of **merge experiments**, not just checkpoints. Every row says which two models were merged, how, under which alignment and configuration, and how the result scored on downstream tasks **next to both parents and the naive merge, measured under the same protocol**. Negative results, controls, unverified and incomplete runs are included, and their status is explicit. It contains 18,171 merge experiments, 64,180 evaluations of 18,507 checkpoints, and 59,087 rows in the flat `merged_models` table. ## Configurations `merged_models` is the default configuration: one long-format row per pair × method × alignment × benchmark × task × metric, carrying parent, naive and merged scores and the derived merge loss, gain and success. `merges`, `evaluations` and `models` are the linked tables it is built from. `summary` holds the derived statistics. ```python from datasets import load_dataset flat = load_dataset("Cross-Mergeability/model-merging-benchmark", "merged_models")["train"] evals = load_dataset("Cross-Mergeability/model-merging-benchmark", "evaluations")["train"] ``` ## Experiment families | experiment_family | merges | methods | unverified | |---|---|---|---| | beetle_controlled | 11364 | average, qmd, task_arithmetic, ties | 1996 | | beetle_published | 869 | average, csp, dare, opcm, other, qmd, svc, task_arithmetic, ties | 56 | | cross_architecture | 788 | average, dare, interpolation, ot_fusion, slerp, task_arithmetic, ties | 121 | | llama_forks | 18 | chat_vector | 0 | | mergebench | 72 | average, dare, other, task_arithmetic, ties | 72 | | polypythia | 4028 | average, interpolation, other, slerp, task_arithmetic, ties | 0 | | toksuite | 1032 | average, qmd, task_arithmetic, ties | 0 | ## How often a merge beats its better parent These counts are for comparisons where both parents and the merge were scored in the same experiment: | model_family | comparisons | beats_best_parent | |---|---|---| | beetle_controlled | 9368 | 1107 | | beetle_published | 378 | 2 | | cross_architecture | 1232 | 65 | | polypythia | 5460 | 0 | | toksuite | 5160 | 0 | ## Metrics All losses are signed so that **positive means worse than the better parent**: - **Merge loss.** For NLL, `merged − min(A, B)`. For accuracy, `max(A, B) − merged`. - **Merge gain.** `naive_merge_loss − method_merge_loss`. Positive means the method improved on plain averaging. It does **not** mean the result is useful. - **Merge success.** The merge strictly beats the better parent on that metric. - **Alignment gain.** Loss of the unaligned twin (same pair, method and configuration) minus loss of the aligned merge. NLL and accuracy are never mixed in one row. A parent is used as a baseline only when it was scored in the same `experiment_id`. ## Row status (`result_status`) | result_status | rows | |---|---| | parent_baseline_missing | 34537 | | evaluated | 21598 | | unverified | 2053 | | naive_baseline_missing | 809 | | naive_baseline_not_applicable | 90 | - **`evaluated`:** the merge and both parents were scored under one protocol. - **`parent_baseline_missing`:** the merge was scored but a parent was not, in that experiment. This happens, for example, for PolyPythia per-paradigm BLiMP, where only the parents' aggregate BLiMP was recorded, and for Beetle published NLL, where only the better-parent NLL was recorded. - **`naive_baseline_missing`:** there is no plain-average twin in the same experiment. - **`naive_baseline_not_applicable`:** the method has no plain-average twin by design (chat-vector transfer, OT fusion). - **`unverified`:** the source flags the value. Pair × method combinations that were never run have **no row**. ## Known limitations - **Copies a parent.** `copies_parent=True` marks rungs whose output is one parent's tensors, for example SVC/OPCM single-parent fills. They are not evidence of composition. - **Aligned equals naive.** In the published Beetle rungs, the aligned merges are byte-identical to the naive ones, because the aligner returned the identity; see `notes`. - **Calibration overlap.** - OT fusion is scored on sentences inside the set used to fit the transport plans, so it is `provisional`. - PolyPythia alignment is fitted on the same FLORES blocks it is scored on. - **Task arithmetic without a shared base.** Where the parents share no base, task arithmetic and TIES are parent interpolations, not conventional task vectors (see `merge_config`). - **MergeBench.** Rows are published scores, not re-evaluated, and the 5-expert merges have no `parent_a`/`parent_b`. - **Not recorded.** Parent checkpoint hashes, code commits, evaluation timestamps and most dataset revisions are absent from the historical result files and are left null. - **Wikitext-scored transport rungs.** The 56 Beetle transport rungs scored on wikitext are `unverified`. ## Provenance and reproduction Every row has a `source_file`, and `sources.json` lists every file each adapter read. Rebuild from the repository with `python -m merge_dataset.build_dataset`; the scripts are in `scripts/`. The tables are generated, never maintained by hand. ## Citation To be added by the authors.