{
  "adoption": {
    "decision": "Do not promote runtime change",
    "eligible_under_predeclared_rule": false,
    "paired_lower_mean": [
      {
        "pair": 0,
        "step_cpu": true,
        "step_wall": true
      },
      {
        "pair": 1,
        "step_cpu": true,
        "step_wall": true
      }
    ],
    "pooled": {
      "step_cpu": {
        "candidate_mean_reduction_percent": 12.599688117239072,
        "mean_s": {
          "baseline": 0.0014383610000000013,
          "candidate": 0.001257132
        }
      },
      "step_wall": {
        "candidate_mean_reduction_percent": 15.69721381493122,
        "mean_s": {
          "baseline": 0.0015054188838694244,
          "candidate": 0.0012691100628580898
        }
      }
    },
    "rule": {
      "minimum_pooled_mean_reduction_percent_each_clock": 5.0,
      "on_failure": "Do not promote; retain as negative or inconclusive. No post-result tuning.",
      "required_exact_equivalence": true,
      "required_lower_candidate_mean_each_pair": [
        "step_wall",
        "step_cpu"
      ]
    }
  },
  "all_passed": false,
  "attempts": [
    {
      "case": "original",
      "id": "timing-00-baseline",
      "mode": "timing",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 2.420006916858256,
      "variant": "baseline"
    },
    {
      "case": "original",
      "id": "timing-01-candidate",
      "mode": "timing",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 2.0803113747388124,
      "variant": "candidate"
    },
    {
      "case": "original",
      "id": "timing-02-candidate",
      "mode": "timing",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 2.0139063335955143,
      "variant": "candidate"
    },
    {
      "case": "original",
      "id": "timing-03-baseline",
      "mode": "timing",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 2.4118966250680387,
      "variant": "baseline"
    },
    {
      "case": "original",
      "id": "dense-original-baseline",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 6.503215416800231,
      "variant": "baseline"
    },
    {
      "case": "original",
      "id": "dense-original-candidate",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 6.568463541567326,
      "variant": "candidate"
    },
    {
      "case": "open-jaw",
      "id": "dense-open-jaw-baseline",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 5.4805178749375045,
      "variant": "baseline"
    },
    {
      "case": "open-jaw",
      "id": "dense-open-jaw-candidate",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 6.379173707682639,
      "variant": "candidate"
    },
    {
      "case": "hold",
      "id": "dense-hold-baseline",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 5.533948041964322,
      "variant": "baseline"
    },
    {
      "case": "hold",
      "id": "dense-hold-candidate",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 5.328347083181143,
      "variant": "candidate"
    },
    {
      "case": "feedback-no-pulse",
      "id": "dense-feedback-no-pulse-baseline",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 7.0851437500678,
      "variant": "baseline"
    },
    {
      "case": "feedback-no-pulse",
      "id": "dense-feedback-no-pulse-candidate",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 7.633159082848579,
      "variant": "candidate"
    },
    {
      "case": "feedback-pulse",
      "id": "dense-feedback-pulse-baseline",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 7.811261875089258,
      "variant": "baseline"
    },
    {
      "case": "feedback-pulse",
      "id": "dense-feedback-pulse-candidate",
      "mode": "diagnostic",
      "returncode": 0,
      "subprocess_wall_s": 8.18520720815286,
      "variant": "candidate"
    }
  ],
  "comparisons": [
    {
      "both_complete": true,
      "exact_match": true,
      "kind": "timing-pair",
      "pair": 0,
      "same_assets": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "bytes_verified",
          "commit",
          "files_verified",
          "lock_sha256",
          "profile",
          "repository",
          "simulation_asset_license"
        ]
      },
      "same_boundaries": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "config",
          "seed",
          "valid",
          "success",
          "reason",
          "error",
          "simulated_seconds",
          "initial_object_position_m",
          "compiled_model_sha256",
          "trajectory",
          "actions",
          "metrics"
        ]
      },
      "same_model": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "dimensions",
          "native_bias",
          "native_control_limits",
          "native_force_limits",
          "native_gains",
          "sha256",
          "timestep_s"
        ]
      },
      "same_runtime": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "machine",
          "mujoco",
          "numpy",
          "python",
          "system"
        ]
      },
      "same_score": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "native_metrics_source",
          "native_outcome_success",
          "native_outcome_valid",
          "reason",
          "reference_xy_m",
          "required_dwell_s",
          "required_lift_dwell_s",
          "sample_interval_s",
          "success",
          "terminal_dwell_s",
          "terminal_reference_success",
          "terminal_xy_error_m",
          "trace_lift_dwell_s",
          "trajectory_complete"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "both_complete": true,
      "exact_match": true,
      "kind": "timing-pair",
      "pair": 1,
      "same_assets": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "bytes_verified",
          "commit",
          "files_verified",
          "lock_sha256",
          "profile",
          "repository",
          "simulation_asset_license"
        ]
      },
      "same_boundaries": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "config",
          "seed",
          "valid",
          "success",
          "reason",
          "error",
          "simulated_seconds",
          "initial_object_position_m",
          "compiled_model_sha256",
          "trajectory",
          "actions",
          "metrics"
        ]
      },
      "same_model": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "dimensions",
          "native_bias",
          "native_control_limits",
          "native_force_limits",
          "native_gains",
          "sha256",
          "timestep_s"
        ]
      },
      "same_runtime": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "machine",
          "mujoco",
          "numpy",
          "python",
          "system"
        ]
      },
      "same_score": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "native_metrics_source",
          "native_outcome_success",
          "native_outcome_valid",
          "reason",
          "reference_xy_m",
          "required_dwell_s",
          "required_lift_dwell_s",
          "sample_interval_s",
          "success",
          "terminal_dwell_s",
          "terminal_reference_success",
          "terminal_xy_error_m",
          "trace_lift_dwell_s",
          "trajectory_complete"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "case": "original",
      "error": "ValueError: Expanded document exceeds bound",
      "exact_match": false,
      "kind": "dense-equivalence"
    },
    {
      "both_complete": true,
      "case": "open-jaw",
      "complete_native_cadence": true,
      "exact_match": true,
      "kind": "dense-equivalence",
      "same_assets": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "bytes_verified",
          "commit",
          "files_verified",
          "lock_sha256",
          "profile",
          "repository",
          "simulation_asset_license"
        ]
      },
      "same_boundaries": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "config",
          "seed",
          "valid",
          "success",
          "reason",
          "error",
          "simulated_seconds",
          "initial_object_position_m",
          "compiled_model_sha256",
          "trajectory",
          "actions",
          "metrics"
        ]
      },
      "same_model": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "dimensions",
          "native_bias",
          "native_control_limits",
          "native_force_limits",
          "native_gains",
          "sha256",
          "timestep_s"
        ]
      },
      "same_native_arrays": {
        "differences": [],
        "exact_match": true
      },
      "same_native_contacts_scorer": {
        "baseline_rows": 20001,
        "candidate_rows": 20001,
        "exact_match": true,
        "first_different_row": null
      },
      "same_runtime": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "machine",
          "mujoco",
          "numpy",
          "python",
          "system"
        ]
      },
      "same_score": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "native_metrics_source",
          "native_outcome_success",
          "native_outcome_valid",
          "reason",
          "reference_xy_m",
          "required_dwell_s",
          "required_lift_dwell_s",
          "sample_interval_s",
          "success",
          "terminal_dwell_s",
          "terminal_reference_success",
          "terminal_xy_error_m",
          "trace_lift_dwell_s",
          "trajectory_complete"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "both_complete": true,
      "case": "hold",
      "complete_native_cadence": true,
      "exact_match": true,
      "kind": "dense-equivalence",
      "same_assets": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "bytes_verified",
          "commit",
          "files_verified",
          "lock_sha256",
          "profile",
          "repository",
          "simulation_asset_license"
        ]
      },
      "same_boundaries": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "config",
          "seed",
          "valid",
          "success",
          "reason",
          "error",
          "simulated_seconds",
          "initial_object_position_m",
          "compiled_model_sha256",
          "trajectory",
          "actions",
          "metrics"
        ]
      },
      "same_model": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "dimensions",
          "native_bias",
          "native_control_limits",
          "native_force_limits",
          "native_gains",
          "sha256",
          "timestep_s"
        ]
      },
      "same_native_arrays": {
        "differences": [],
        "exact_match": true
      },
      "same_native_contacts_scorer": {
        "baseline_rows": 20001,
        "candidate_rows": 20001,
        "exact_match": true,
        "first_different_row": null
      },
      "same_runtime": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "machine",
          "mujoco",
          "numpy",
          "python",
          "system"
        ]
      },
      "same_score": {
        "different_fields": [],
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields_compared": [
          "native_metrics_source",
          "native_outcome_success",
          "native_outcome_valid",
          "reason",
          "reference_xy_m",
          "required_dwell_s",
          "required_lift_dwell_s",
          "sample_interval_s",
          "success",
          "terminal_dwell_s",
          "terminal_reference_success",
          "terminal_xy_error_m",
          "trace_lift_dwell_s",
          "trajectory_complete"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "case": "feedback-no-pulse",
      "error": "ValueError: Expanded document exceeds bound",
      "exact_match": false,
      "kind": "dense-equivalence"
    },
    {
      "case": "feedback-pulse",
      "error": "ValueError: Expanded document exceeds bound",
      "exact_match": false,
      "kind": "dense-equivalence"
    }
  ],
  "interpretation": "These unpaced shared-host CPU samples compare one unchanged synthetic command tape. No inference time is included. Do not infer new task accuracy, hardware response, minimum hardware or real-time safety. Report every paired result; two pairs cannot establish robust population speedup.",
  "paired_timing": [
    {
      "baseline_sum_s": 1.4684963417239487,
      "candidate_p95_reduction_percent": 25.79315547361659,
      "candidate_sum_s": 1.2328931200318038,
      "candidate_total_step_reduction_percent": 16.043841240731815,
      "pair": 0
    },
    {
      "baseline_sum_s": 1.5423414260149002,
      "candidate_p95_reduction_percent": 23.795316993807734,
      "candidate_sum_s": 1.3053270056843758,
      "candidate_total_step_reduction_percent": 15.367182410636659,
      "pair": 1
    }
  ],
  "planned_attempts": 14,
  "protocol_sha256": "386c34e8201a86dbe81709805b7c0d47ec4c257120023514153cc4df652f5184",
  "schema": "dvidia.piper-control-comparison/v1",
  "scope": "One previously checked synthetic PiPER scenario, preserved commands and privileged native simulator state. Allocation-only source comparison, not new skill training, held-out success, hardware latency, calibrated contact or a real-time guarantee.",
  "source_unchanged": true,
  "timing_runs": [
    {
      "id": "timing-00-baseline",
      "setup_reset_wall_s": 0.367916792165488,
      "status": "complete",
      "step_cpu": {
        "count": 1000,
        "max_s": 0.012059000000000042,
        "mean_s": 0.0014127509999999999,
        "over_nominal_20ms": 0,
        "p50_s": 0.0011879999999999669,
        "p95_s": 0.002274649999999988,
        "p99_s": 0.002799599999999997,
        "sum_s": 1.4127509999999999
      },
      "step_wall": {
        "count": 1000,
        "max_s": 0.012310583610087633,
        "mean_s": 0.0014684963417239487,
        "over_nominal_20ms": 0,
        "p50_s": 0.0012011665385216475,
        "p95_s": 0.002542358636856079,
        "p99_s": 0.003286311766132712,
        "sum_s": 1.4684963417239487
      },
      "variant": "baseline"
    },
    {
      "id": "timing-01-candidate",
      "setup_reset_wall_s": 0.28948104102164507,
      "status": "complete",
      "step_cpu": {
        "count": 1000,
        "max_s": 0.008727999999999847,
        "mean_s": 0.0012205139999999996,
        "over_nominal_20ms": 0,
        "p50_s": 0.0010654999999999415,
        "p95_s": 0.0018321999999998393,
        "p99_s": 0.0024473500000000855,
        "sum_s": 1.2205139999999997
      },
      "step_wall": {
        "count": 1000,
        "max_s": 0.010767832864075899,
        "mean_s": 0.0012328931200318038,
        "over_nominal_20ms": 0,
        "p50_s": 0.0010669578332453966,
        "p95_s": 0.001886604120954871,
        "p99_s": 0.0025030286889523266,
        "sum_s": 1.2328931200318038
      },
      "variant": "candidate"
    },
    {
      "id": "timing-02-candidate",
      "setup_reset_wall_s": 0.25960616674274206,
      "status": "complete",
      "step_cpu": {
        "count": 1000,
        "max_s": 0.00799099999999986,
        "mean_s": 0.0012937500000000002,
        "over_nominal_20ms": 0,
        "p50_s": 0.001134999999999775,
        "p95_s": 0.001920649999999912,
        "p99_s": 0.0027079999999999327,
        "sum_s": 1.2937500000000002
      },
      "step_wall": {
        "count": 1000,
        "max_s": 0.008000124711543322,
        "mean_s": 0.0013053270056843757,
        "over_nominal_20ms": 0,
        "p50_s": 0.0011370624415576458,
        "p95_s": 0.0019861731911078096,
        "p99_s": 0.00277163659222424,
        "sum_s": 1.3053270056843758
      },
      "variant": "candidate"
    },
    {
      "id": "timing-03-baseline",
      "setup_reset_wall_s": 0.3268076251260936,
      "status": "complete",
      "step_cpu": {
        "count": 1000,
        "max_s": 0.018218000000000067,
        "mean_s": 0.001463971000000003,
        "over_nominal_20ms": 0,
        "p50_s": 0.0012210000000000276,
        "p95_s": 0.002330100000000157,
        "p99_s": 0.0029761600000003073,
        "sum_s": 1.463971000000003
      },
      "step_wall": {
        "count": 1000,
        "max_s": 0.02005712501704693,
        "mean_s": 0.0015423414260149002,
        "over_nominal_20ms": 1,
        "p50_s": 0.001237792195752263,
        "p95_s": 0.0026063663186505436,
        "p99_s": 0.003594016665592789,
        "sum_s": 1.5423414260149002
      },
      "variant": "baseline"
    }
  ]
}