{ "resamples": 10000, "seed": 20261110, "ours": "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut", "iou": 0.5, "subsets": { "unfiltered": { "pages": 2871, "faults": { "clean": 487, "swap-navbar": 148, "swap-button": 108, "swap-chip": 51, "common-type": 77, "common-low_contrast": 55, "swap-listrow": 143, "swap-fab": 17, "swap-search": 42, "common-overflow": 43, "common-overlap": 63, "swap-tabbar": 12, "swap-segmented": 28, "common-small_target": 46, "common-drop": 44, "common-reorder": 65, "local-icon": 188, "local-radius": 86, "local-material": 123, "local-colour": 160, "swap-switch": 77, "swap-slider": 17, "swap-dialog": 15, "swap-sheet": 4, "multi-display-missing_image": 108, "multi-display-ellipsis": 32, "multi-display-cropped": 147, "multi-display-null_value": 60, "negative-selection": 111, "common-two_selected": 111, "negative-badge": 40, "common-badge_overlap": 40, "negative-placeholder": 44, "negative-primary": 19, "local-primary_colour": 19, "negative-fab": 12, "common-fab_overlap": 12, "multi-common-low_contrast": 11, "multi-common-overflow": 4, "multi-common-small_target": 2 }, "models": { "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": { "f1": 0.4777464788732394, "precision": 0.6091954022988506, "recall": 0.39295644114921224, "false_alarm": 0.08976157082748948, "clean": 713, "errors": 0, "matched": 848, "boxes": 1392, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 539, "kind_known": 848, "aspect_right": 267, "aspect_known": 304, "normalized_kind_right": 839 }, "gemini-4-argon": { "f1": 0.3598396962666104, "precision": 0.3302361595044522, "recall": 0.39527340129749766, "false_alarm": 0.30014025245441794, "clean": 713, "errors": 0, "matched": 853, "boxes": 2583, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 342, "kind_known": 853, "aspect_right": 282, "aspect_known": 504, "normalized_kind_right": 709 }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "f1": 0.29770565193060994, "precision": 0.21322645290581163, "recall": 0.49304911955514363, "false_alarm": 0.8036465638148668, "clean": 713, "errors": 0, "matched": 1064, "boxes": 4990, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 420, "kind_known": 1064, "aspect_right": 283, "aspect_known": 611, "normalized_kind_right": 898 }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "f1": 0.2901423679942332, "precision": 0.23739309938071365, "recall": 0.3730305838739574, "false_alarm": 0.4600280504908836, "clean": 713, "errors": 3, "matched": 805, "boxes": 3391, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 393, "kind_known": 805, "aspect_right": 196, "aspect_known": 395, "normalized_kind_right": 710 }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "f1": 0.44859020563917745, "precision": 0.4134427510746385, "recall": 0.4902687673772011, "false_alarm": 0.5301542776998598, "clean": 713, "errors": 0, "matched": 1058, "boxes": 2559, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 605, "kind_known": 1058, "aspect_right": 385, "aspect_known": 443, "normalized_kind_right": 1038 }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "f1": 0.40351906158357775, "precision": 0.549520766773163, "recall": 0.31881371640407785, "false_alarm": 0.07433380084151472, "clean": 713, "errors": 0, "matched": 688, "boxes": 1252, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 463, "kind_known": 688, "aspect_right": 182, "aspect_known": 223, "normalized_kind_right": 679 }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "f1": 0.04166954598852878, "precision": 0.022513440860215055, "recall": 0.2794253938832252, "false_alarm": 0.8821879382889201, "clean": 713, "errors": 292, "matched": 603, "boxes": 26784, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 20, "kind_known": 603, "aspect_right": 214, "aspect_known": 408, "normalized_kind_right": 428 } }, "base_bootstrap": { "clusters": 486, "min_size": 1, "max_size": 25, "vs": { "gemini-4-argon": { "delta": 0.11790678260662901, "ci95": [ 0.08761223765461952, 0.1484526149519525 ] }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "delta": 0.18004082694262946, "ci95": [ 0.157066158146166, 0.202959339556883 ] }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "delta": 0.1876041108790062, "ci95": [ 0.15698316298091203, 0.21914929600029698 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "delta": 0.029156273234061947, "ci95": [ 0.014235602965603904, 0.043825377089743746 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "delta": 0.07422741728966165, "ci95": [ 0.05516100139367012, 0.09392536015620727 ] }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "delta": 0.4360769328847106, "ci95": [ 0.4122818415353857, 0.46004061519641287 ] } } } }, "published": { "pages": 2765, "faults": { "swap-navbar": 148, "swap-button": 108, "swap-chip": 51, "common-type": 77, "common-low_contrast": 55, "clean": 426, "swap-listrow": 143, "swap-fab": 17, "swap-search": 42, "common-overflow": 43, "common-overlap": 63, "swap-tabbar": 12, "swap-segmented": 28, "common-small_target": 46, "common-drop": 44, "common-reorder": 65, "local-icon": 188, "local-radius": 86, "local-material": 123, "local-colour": 160, "swap-switch": 77, "swap-slider": 17, "swap-dialog": 15, "swap-sheet": 4, "multi-display-missing_image": 108, "multi-display-ellipsis": 32, "multi-display-cropped": 147, "multi-display-null_value": 60, "negative-selection": 94, "common-two_selected": 111, "negative-badge": 32, "common-badge_overlap": 40, "negative-placeholder": 39, "local-primary_colour": 19, "negative-fab": 9, "common-fab_overlap": 12, "negative-primary": 7, "multi-common-low_contrast": 11, "multi-common-overflow": 4, "multi-common-small_target": 2 }, "models": { "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": { "f1": 0.48058940209691137, "precision": 0.6185266229029905, "recall": 0.39295644114921224, "false_alarm": 0.07413509060955518, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 848, "boxes": 1371, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 539, "kind_known": 848, "aspect_right": 267, "aspect_known": 304, "normalized_kind_right": 839 }, "gemini-4-argon": { "f1": 0.3715966020474841, "precision": 0.3505959720509659, "recall": 0.39527340129749766, "false_alarm": 0.17792421746293247, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 853, "boxes": 2433, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 342, "kind_known": 853, "aspect_right": 282, "aspect_known": 504, "normalized_kind_right": 709 }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "f1": 0.3075588957941899, "precision": 0.22348246166771688, "recall": 0.49304911955514363, "false_alarm": 0.7825370675453048, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 1064, "boxes": 4761, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 420, "kind_known": 1064, "aspect_right": 283, "aspect_known": 611, "normalized_kind_right": 898 }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "f1": 0.2997579594116552, "precision": 0.25054466230936817, "recall": 0.3730305838739574, "false_alarm": 0.3657331136738056, "clean": 607, "errors": 3, "matched": 805, "boxes": 3213, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 393, "kind_known": 805, "aspect_right": 196, "aspect_known": 395, "normalized_kind_right": 710 }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "f1": 0.4554455445544554, "precision": 0.4252411575562701, "recall": 0.4902687673772011, "false_alarm": 0.515650741350906, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 1058, "boxes": 2488, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 605, "kind_known": 1058, "aspect_right": 385, "aspect_known": 443, "normalized_kind_right": 1038 }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "f1": 0.4048249485142689, "precision": 0.5543916196615633, "recall": 0.31881371640407785, "false_alarm": 0.06919275123558484, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 688, "boxes": 1241, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 463, "kind_known": 688, "aspect_right": 182, "aspect_known": 223, "normalized_kind_right": 679 }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "f1": 0.04301919098237854, "precision": 0.023303447209769672, "recall": 0.2794253938832252, "false_alarm": 0.8780889621087314, "clean": 607, "errors": 282, "matched": 603, "boxes": 25876, "truths": 2158, "kind_right": 20, "kind_known": 603, "aspect_right": 214, "aspect_known": 408, "normalized_kind_right": 428 } }, "base_bootstrap": { "clusters": 469, "min_size": 1, "max_size": 25, "vs": { "gemini-4-argon": { "delta": 0.10899280004942724, "ci95": [ 0.07861130987305658, 0.13977227007512993 ] }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "delta": 0.1730305063027215, "ci95": [ 0.14973295382964544, 0.1955147349765577 ] }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "delta": 0.1808314426852562, "ci95": [ 0.14836676575593857, 0.2131133582931496 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "delta": 0.02514385754245596, "ci95": [ 0.010260478680406186, 0.03943047502601561 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "delta": 0.07576445358264244, "ci95": [ 0.05604748796387334, 0.09492340873975616 ] }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "delta": 0.4375702111145328, "ci95": [ 0.4129719697091177, 0.4613580982021184 ] } } }, "requirement_bootstrap": { "clusters": 121, "min_size": 1, "max_size": 414, "vs": { "gemini-4-argon": { "delta": 0.10899280004942724, "ci95": [ 0.04467793849992695, 0.17696848361181572 ] }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "delta": 0.1730305063027215, "ci95": [ 0.14083593515714832, 0.20652628574165327 ] }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "delta": 0.1808314426852562, "ci95": [ 0.13080445467071503, 0.22946292326254902 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "delta": 0.02514385754245596, "ci95": [ 0.005967370588310595, 0.04313225869484571 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "delta": 0.07576445358264244, "ci95": [ 0.03961699314203121, 0.10928092511103336 ] }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "delta": 0.4375702111145328, "ci95": [ 0.3703972864951111, 0.4854255803273521 ] } } } }, "audit_excluded": { "pages": 2680, "faults": { "swap-button": 100, "swap-chip": 50, "common-type": 72, "common-low_contrast": 55, "clean": 394, "swap-listrow": 138, "swap-fab": 16, "swap-search": 38, "swap-navbar": 142, "common-overflow": 42, "common-overlap": 63, "common-small_target": 46, "swap-segmented": 26, "common-drop": 41, "common-reorder": 58, "swap-tabbar": 11, "local-icon": 188, "local-radius": 86, "local-material": 123, "local-colour": 160, "swap-switch": 76, "swap-slider": 15, "swap-dialog": 14, "swap-sheet": 1, "multi-display-missing_image": 108, "multi-display-ellipsis": 32, "multi-display-cropped": 147, "multi-display-null_value": 60, "negative-selection": 94, "common-two_selected": 111, "negative-badge": 32, "common-badge_overlap": 40, "negative-placeholder": 39, "local-primary_colour": 19, "negative-fab": 8, "common-fab_overlap": 12, "negative-primary": 6, "multi-common-low_contrast": 11, "multi-common-overflow": 4, "multi-common-small_target": 2 }, "models": { "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": { "f1": 0.4885672937771346, "precision": 0.6261127596439169, "recall": 0.40056953013763646, "false_alarm": 0.07329842931937172, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 844, "boxes": 1348, "truths": 2107, "kind_right": 538, "kind_known": 844, "aspect_right": 264, "aspect_known": 301, "normalized_kind_right": 835 }, "gemini-4-argon": { "f1": 0.3774258309167968, "precision": 0.3560606060606061, "recall": 0.4015187470336972, "false_alarm": 0.17975567190226877, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 846, "boxes": 2376, "truths": 2107, "kind_right": 342, "kind_known": 846, "aspect_right": 277, "aspect_known": 497, "normalized_kind_right": 704 }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "f1": 0.31506644766313274, "precision": 0.2298474945533769, "recall": 0.5007119126720455, "false_alarm": 0.787085514834206, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 1055, "boxes": 4590, "truths": 2107, "kind_right": 419, "kind_known": 1055, "aspect_right": 279, "aspect_known": 603, "normalized_kind_right": 890 }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "f1": 0.3095927427137618, "precision": 0.2608978529603123, "recall": 0.3806359753203607, "false_alarm": 0.35951134380453753, "clean": 573, "errors": 2, "matched": 802, "boxes": 3074, "truths": 2107, "kind_right": 392, "kind_known": 802, "aspect_right": 194, "aspect_known": 393, "normalized_kind_right": 707 }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "f1": 0.46457041629760853, "precision": 0.43545039435450394, "recall": 0.4978642619838633, "false_alarm": 0.5043630017452007, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 1049, "boxes": 2409, "truths": 2107, "kind_right": 603, "kind_known": 1049, "aspect_right": 378, "aspect_known": 436, "normalized_kind_right": 1029 }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "f1": 0.4106714628297362, "precision": 0.5573637103336045, "recall": 0.32510678690080685, "false_alarm": 0.06806282722513089, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 685, "boxes": 1229, "truths": 2107, "kind_right": 462, "kind_known": 685, "aspect_right": 181, "aspect_known": 221, "normalized_kind_right": 676 }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "f1": 0.043282103950408976, "precision": 0.023453649228812212, "recall": 0.2800189843379212, "false_alarm": 0.8778359511343804, "clean": 573, "errors": 274, "matched": 590, "boxes": 25156, "truths": 2107, "kind_right": 19, "kind_known": 590, "aspect_right": 205, "aspect_known": 396, "normalized_kind_right": 415 } }, "base_bootstrap": { "clusters": 460, "min_size": 1, "max_size": 25, "vs": { "gemini-4-argon": { "delta": 0.11114146286033777, "ci95": [ 0.07967464664486199, 0.1414465221686127 ] }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "delta": 0.17350084611400185, "ci95": [ 0.15042032661224217, 0.19584024539229442 ] }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "delta": 0.1789745510633728, "ci95": [ 0.14750714475477159, 0.21097993264872794 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "delta": 0.023996877479526058, "ci95": [ 0.008922994780452742, 0.03875636995415016 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "delta": 0.07789583094739838, "ci95": [ 0.05877179782683998, 0.09737202460231702 ] }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "delta": 0.4452851898267256, "ci95": [ 0.42122242693278383, 0.4679879361780612 ] } } } }, "structural_quarantine": { "pages": 2581, "faults": { "swap-button": 100, "swap-chip": 50, "common-type": 72, "common-low_contrast": 55, "clean": 394, "swap-listrow": 138, "swap-fab": 16, "swap-search": 38, "swap-navbar": 142, "common-overflow": 42, "common-overlap": 63, "common-small_target": 46, "swap-segmented": 26, "swap-tabbar": 11, "local-icon": 188, "local-radius": 86, "local-material": 123, "local-colour": 160, "swap-switch": 76, "swap-slider": 15, "swap-dialog": 14, "swap-sheet": 1, "multi-display-missing_image": 108, "multi-display-ellipsis": 32, "multi-display-cropped": 147, "multi-display-null_value": 60, "negative-selection": 94, "common-two_selected": 111, "negative-badge": 32, "common-badge_overlap": 40, "negative-placeholder": 39, "local-primary_colour": 19, "negative-fab": 8, "common-fab_overlap": 12, "negative-primary": 6, "multi-common-low_contrast": 11, "multi-common-overflow": 4, "multi-common-small_target": 2 }, "models": { "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": { "f1": 0.5063063063063064, "precision": 0.6376701966717095, "recall": 0.4198207171314741, "false_alarm": 0.07329842931937172, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 843, "boxes": 1322, "truths": 2008, "kind_right": 537, "kind_known": 843, "aspect_right": 264, "aspect_known": 301, "normalized_kind_right": 834 }, "gemini-4-argon": { "f1": 0.3954194905351718, "precision": 0.3725231175693527, "recall": 0.4213147410358566, "false_alarm": 0.17975567190226877, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 846, "boxes": 2271, "truths": 2008, "kind_right": 342, "kind_known": 846, "aspect_right": 277, "aspect_known": 497, "normalized_kind_right": 704 }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "f1": 0.3270186335403727, "precision": 0.23759025270758122, "recall": 0.524402390438247, "false_alarm": 0.787085514834206, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 1053, "boxes": 4432, "truths": 2008, "kind_right": 419, "kind_known": 1053, "aspect_right": 279, "aspect_known": 603, "normalized_kind_right": 890 }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "f1": 0.3208, "precision": 0.268048128342246, "recall": 0.399402390438247, "false_alarm": 0.35951134380453753, "clean": 573, "errors": 2, "matched": 802, "boxes": 2992, "truths": 2008, "kind_right": 392, "kind_known": 802, "aspect_right": 194, "aspect_known": 393, "normalized_kind_right": 707 }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "f1": 0.48302932348187483, "precision": 0.45027981058975464, "recall": 0.5209163346613546, "false_alarm": 0.5043630017452007, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 1046, "boxes": 2323, "truths": 2008, "kind_right": 601, "kind_known": 1046, "aspect_right": 378, "aspect_known": 436, "normalized_kind_right": 1027 }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "f1": 0.4256378344741754, "precision": 0.5671641791044776, "recall": 0.34063745019920316, "false_alarm": 0.06806282722513089, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 684, "boxes": 1206, "truths": 2008, "kind_right": 461, "kind_known": 684, "aspect_right": 181, "aspect_known": 221, "normalized_kind_right": 675 }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "f1": 0.04460431654676259, "precision": 0.02413736578968937, "recall": 0.29332669322709165, "false_alarm": 0.8778359511343804, "clean": 573, "errors": 258, "matched": 589, "boxes": 24402, "truths": 2008, "kind_right": 19, "kind_known": 589, "aspect_right": 205, "aspect_known": 396, "normalized_kind_right": 415 } }, "base_bootstrap": { "clusters": 460, "min_size": 1, "max_size": 25, "vs": { "gemini-4-argon": { "delta": 0.11088681577113457, "ci95": [ 0.07835602317984597, 0.14297294615854736 ] }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "delta": 0.17928767276593366, "ci95": [ 0.155562028072719, 0.20235313618042142 ] }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "delta": 0.18550630630630638, "ci95": [ 0.152888992870874, 0.21850935906801486 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "delta": 0.023276982824431525, "ci95": [ 0.007806048472150712, 0.038494405152895116 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "delta": 0.08066847183213094, "ci95": [ 0.06095831107520356, 0.10061037665436738 ] }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "delta": 0.46170198975954374, "ci95": [ 0.4376583170445951, 0.4847600033817072 ] } } } }, "convention_sensitivity": { "pages": 1766, "faults": { "common-type": 72, "common-low_contrast": 55, "clean": 394, "common-overflow": 42, "common-overlap": 63, "common-small_target": 46, "local-radius": 86, "local-material": 123, "local-colour": 160, "multi-display-missing_image": 108, "multi-display-ellipsis": 32, "multi-display-cropped": 147, "multi-display-null_value": 60, "negative-selection": 94, "common-two_selected": 111, "negative-badge": 32, "common-badge_overlap": 40, "negative-placeholder": 39, "local-primary_colour": 19, "negative-fab": 8, "common-fab_overlap": 12, "negative-primary": 6, "multi-common-low_contrast": 11, "multi-common-overflow": 4, "multi-common-small_target": 2 }, "models": { "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": { "f1": 0.6268922528940338, "precision": 0.6685660018993352, "recall": 0.5901089689857502, "false_alarm": 0.07329842931937172, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 704, "boxes": 1053, "truths": 1193, "kind_right": 537, "kind_known": 704, "aspect_right": 146, "aspect_known": 162, "normalized_kind_right": 698 }, "gemini-4-argon": { "f1": 0.39705340699815844, "precision": 0.35413929040735875, "recall": 0.451802179379715, "false_alarm": 0.17975567190226877, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 539, "boxes": 1522, "truths": 1193, "kind_right": 342, "kind_known": 539, "aspect_right": 146, "aspect_known": 190, "normalized_kind_right": 515 }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "f1": 0.34983986203498396, "precision": 0.2477320307048151, "recall": 0.595138306789606, "false_alarm": 0.787085514834206, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 710, "boxes": 2866, "truths": 1193, "kind_right": 419, "kind_known": 710, "aspect_right": 186, "aspect_known": 260, "normalized_kind_right": 658 }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "f1": 0.35065710872162487, "precision": 0.27238979118329465, "recall": 0.4920368818105616, "false_alarm": 0.35951134380453753, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 587, "boxes": 2155, "truths": 1193, "kind_right": 392, "kind_known": 587, "aspect_right": 123, "aspect_known": 178, "normalized_kind_right": 560 }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "f1": 0.5824136703453185, "precision": 0.5061881188118812, "recall": 0.6856663872590109, "false_alarm": 0.5043630017452007, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 818, "boxes": 1616, "truths": 1193, "kind_right": 601, "kind_known": 818, "aspect_right": 181, "aspect_known": 208, "normalized_kind_right": 806 }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "f1": 0.5400183992640295, "precision": 0.5983690112130479, "recall": 0.4920368818105616, "false_alarm": 0.06806282722513089, "clean": 573, "errors": 0, "matched": 587, "boxes": 981, "truths": 1193, "kind_right": 461, "kind_known": 587, "aspect_right": 104, "aspect_known": 124, "normalized_kind_right": 585 }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "f1": 0.03922224079335896, "precision": 0.021007400334208642, "recall": 0.2950544844928751, "false_alarm": 0.8778359511343804, "clean": 573, "errors": 191, "matched": 352, "boxes": 16756, "truths": 1193, "kind_right": 19, "kind_known": 352, "aspect_right": 51, "aspect_known": 159, "normalized_kind_right": 178 } }, "base_bootstrap": { "clusters": 457, "min_size": 1, "max_size": 21, "vs": { "gemini-4-argon": { "delta": 0.2298388458958754, "ci95": [ 0.18724555288083433, 0.27145427894908847 ] }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "delta": 0.27705239085904987, "ci95": [ 0.24710773133780767, 0.3071044790862251 ] }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "delta": 0.27623514417240896, "ci95": [ 0.23588166680019326, 0.31661125390467615 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "delta": 0.044478582548715284, "ci95": [ 0.027595375186851175, 0.06107735972514386 ] }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "delta": 0.08687385363000433, "ci95": [ 0.06199426792543952, 0.11109210298681961 ] }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "delta": 0.5876700121006748, "ci95": [ 0.5605721021443575, 0.6132586220645458 ] } } } } }, "exclusions": { "disputed": 106, "human": 86, "structural": 109, "convention": 850 }, "common_parseable": { "pages": 2762, "models": { "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": { "f1": 0.4812712826333712, "precision": 0.6194302410518627, "recall": 0.39350348027842225, "false_alarm": 0.07413509060955518, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 848, "boxes": 1369, "truths": 2155, "kind_right": 539, "kind_known": 848, "aspect_right": 267, "aspect_known": 304, "normalized_kind_right": 839 }, "gemini-4-argon": { "f1": 0.37192064530194024, "precision": 0.35074013157894735, "recall": 0.39582366589327145, "false_alarm": 0.17792421746293247, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 853, "boxes": 2432, "truths": 2155, "kind_right": 342, "kind_known": 853, "aspect_right": 282, "aspect_known": 504, "normalized_kind_right": 709 }, "claude-opus-5-5-medium": { "f1": 0.30795947901591897, "precision": 0.2237644584647739, "recall": 0.4937354988399072, "false_alarm": 0.7825370675453048, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 1064, "boxes": 4755, "truths": 2155, "kind_right": 420, "kind_known": 1064, "aspect_right": 283, "aspect_known": 611, "normalized_kind_right": 898 }, "gpt-6.1-sol": { "f1": 0.29992548435171384, "precision": 0.25054466230936817, "recall": 0.37354988399071926, "false_alarm": 0.3657331136738056, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 805, "boxes": 3213, "truths": 2155, "kind_right": 393, "kind_known": 805, "aspect_right": 196, "aspect_known": 395, "normalized_kind_right": 710 }, "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": { "f1": 0.4560344827586207, "precision": 0.42575452716297785, "recall": 0.49095127610208816, "false_alarm": 0.515650741350906, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 1058, "boxes": 2485, "truths": 2155, "kind_right": 605, "kind_known": 1058, "aspect_right": 385, "aspect_known": 443, "normalized_kind_right": 1038 }, "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": { "f1": 0.40530191458026504, "precision": 0.5548387096774193, "recall": 0.31925754060324824, "false_alarm": 0.06919275123558484, "clean": 607, "errors": 0, "matched": 688, "boxes": 1240, "truths": 2155, "kind_right": 463, "kind_known": 688, "aspect_right": 182, "aspect_known": 223, "normalized_kind_right": 679 }, "qwen3.5-9b-base": { "f1": 0.043006143734819265, "precision": 0.023296312062226696, "recall": 0.27935034802784225, "false_alarm": 0.8780889621087314, "clean": 607, "errors": 282, "matched": 602, "boxes": 25841, "truths": 2155, "kind_right": 20, "kind_known": 602, "aspect_right": 213, "aspect_known": 407, "normalized_kind_right": 427 } } }, "input_sha256": { "data/defect-consistency-runs/rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut.jsonl": "fb2924a4e3d141953bfc1c7e41df629fbede1dc97157602b147605011d50681b", "data/defect-consistency-runs/gemini-4-argon.jsonl": "24960309c022ee6f78ee4d15f4f17e3dca83f672a3d7e3d7d72fa4fbcfc3e8fe", "data/defect-consistency-runs/claude-opus-5-5-medium.jsonl": "0f2c61f77a2108f8f264cc8f543d4a5da55136a97b42deae14858884a5097a87", "data/defect-consistency-runs/gpt-6.1-sol.jsonl": "d56adb3a103d6c9cda47a10e01abd42f5ae58c3c16261a67327fd2b17fcec59d", "data/defect-consistency-runs/rolejudge-v7f-r128soup.jsonl": "f68ccd7ccfcde3a56d288bc035d3940ec81260b2c57dbf267ae4370d226549b6", "data/defect-consistency-runs/rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut.jsonl": "a004c12c1d8ee4afc5624a1dce6918b046fdf34dc72a913d3ce9f33f5a3bde5c", "data/defect-consistency-runs/qwen3.5-9b-base.jsonl": "a1e0c18d01f9c4199d96250ed45733a0246f74eacb9e38338c3082393aba8ccc", "data/human-eval/label-check/answers.json": "0bd37470f31f3f03ad94ae82cb1a51fa72cfe7a99651d5fc7ba7ac8059e27d3f" }, "rows_sha256": "84ee979babd205e986e26971a04306d6697b8c8ef47307d6d63177b097a65dc4" }