{ "schema": "modevc.chart.v1", "slug": "open-weights-vs-proprietary-arena-gap", "title": "Open Weights vs. Proprietary AI: The Gap Stays at 42 Points", "date": "2026-10-14", "canonical_url": "https://modevc.com/charts/open-weights-vs-proprietary-arena-gap/", "claim": "Open weights briefly beat every proprietary model in early 2025 (deepseek-r1); today the best open model trails by 42 points.", "takeaway": "A 42-point gap does not justify a 10× price premium for 80% of workflows.", "sources": [ { "name": "Arena leaderboard dataset (lmarena-ai, CC BY 4.0)", "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/lmarena-ai/leaderboard-dataset" } ], "data": { "type": "line", "yFmt": "pts", "xFmt": "year", "yDomain": [ -15, 140 ], "zero": true, "zeroLabel": "Parity line (0 pts)", "endLabels": true, "series": [ { "name": "Proprietary Lead", "short": "Closed vs Open", "pts": [ { "t": 1704758400000, "y": 67, "note": "mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1" }, { "t": 1705536000000, "y": 66, "note": "mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1" }, { "t": 1706140800000, "y": 66, "note": "mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1" }, { "t": 1706832000000, "y": 135, "note": "mixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1" }, { "t": 1707955200000, "y": 107, "note": "qwen1.5-72b-chat" }, { "t": 1709596800000, "y": 104, "note": "qwen1.5-72b-chat" }, { "t": 1709769600000, "y": 105, "note": "qwen1.5-72b-chat" }, { "t": 1710288000000, "y": 104, "note": "qwen1.5-72b-chat" }, { "t": 1711411200000, "y": 105, "note": "qwen1.5-72b-chat" }, { "t": 1711497600000, "y": 105, "note": "qwen1.5-72b-chat" }, { "t": 1712102400000, "y": 105, "note": "qwen1.5-72b-chat" }, { "t": 1712620800000, "y": 62, "note": "command-r-plus" }, { "t": 1712707200000, "y": 61, "note": "command-r-plus" }, { "t": 1712793600000, "y": 68, "note": "command-r-plus" }, { "t": 1712966400000, "y": 67, "note": "command-r-plus" }, { "t": 1713398400000, "y": 66, "note": "command-r-plus" }, { "t": 1713484800000, "y": 60, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1713744000000, "y": 49, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1714089600000, "y": 50, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1714521600000, "y": 49, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1715126400000, "y": 50, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1715731200000, "y": 86, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1715817600000, "y": 85, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1716076800000, "y": 84, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1716163200000, "y": 84, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1716768000000, "y": 80, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1717286400000, "y": 80, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1717632000000, "y": 80, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1718064000000, "y": 80, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1718582400000, "y": 75, "note": "nemotron-4-340b-instruct" }, { "t": 1718928000000, "y": 77, "note": "nemotron-4-340b-instruct" }, { "t": 1719100800000, "y": 79, "note": "nemotron-4-340b-instruct" }, { "t": 1719360000000, "y": 80, "note": "llama-3-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1719619200000, "y": 73, "note": "gemma-2-27b-it" }, { "t": 1720224000000, "y": 70, "note": "gemma-2-27b-it" }, { "t": 1720396800000, "y": 71, "note": "gemma-2-27b-it" }, { "t": 1721088000000, "y": 71, "note": "gemma-2-27b-it" }, { "t": 1721606400000, "y": 70, "note": "gemma-2-27b-it" }, { "t": 1721865600000, "y": 69, "note": "gemma-2-27b-it" }, { "t": 1722297600000, "y": 24, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1722384000000, "y": 24, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1722470400000, "y": 24, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1722816000000, "y": 23, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1722902400000, "y": 23, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1723507200000, "y": 22, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1724284800000, "y": 51, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1724371200000, "y": 51, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1724716800000, "y": 50, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1724803200000, "y": 50, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1725408000000, "y": 49, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct" }, { "t": 1726358400000, "y": 28, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct-fp8" }, { "t": 1726531200000, "y": 89, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct-fp8" }, { "t": 1727395200000, "y": 73, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct-bf16" }, { "t": 1728259200000, "y": 68, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct-bf16" }, { "t": 1728950400000, "y": 68, "note": "llama-3.1-405b-instruct-fp8" }, { "t": 1729641600000, "y": 70, "note": "llama-3.1-nemotron-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1730073600000, "y": 64, "note": "llama-3.1-nemotron-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1730678400000, "y": 63, "note": "llama-3.1-nemotron-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1731369600000, "y": 64, "note": "llama-3.1-nemotron-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1731456000000, "y": 64, "note": "llama-3.1-nemotron-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1732060800000, "y": 65, "note": "llama-3.1-nemotron-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1732147200000, "y": 65, "note": "llama-3.1-nemotron-70b-instruct" }, { "t": 1732233600000, "y": 60, "note": "athene-v2-chat" }, { "t": 1733011200000, "y": 57, "note": "athene-v2-chat" }, { "t": 1733356800000, "y": 57, "note": "athene-v2-chat" }, { "t": 1733788800000, "y": 56, "note": "athene-v2-chat" }, { "t": 1734220800000, "y": 57, "note": "athene-v2-chat" }, { "t": 1734480000000, "y": 58, "note": "athene-v2-chat" }, { "t": 1734825600000, "y": 57, "note": "deepseek-v2.5-1210" }, { "t": 1735516800000, "y": 44, "note": "deepseek-v3" }, { "t": 1736035200000, "y": 33, "note": "deepseek-v3" }, { "t": 1736899200000, "y": 31, "note": "deepseek-v3" }, { "t": 1737244800000, "y": 32, "note": "deepseek-v3" }, { "t": 1737417600000, "y": 32, "note": "deepseek-v3" }, { "t": 1737504000000, "y": 32, "note": "deepseek-v3" }, { "t": 1737676800000, "y": -5, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1738022400000, "y": -6, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1738540800000, "y": -9, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1738713600000, "y": -5, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1738800000000, "y": -5, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1739059200000, "y": -6, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1739232000000, "y": -6, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1739491200000, "y": -7, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1739750400000, "y": -6, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1740096000000, "y": -4, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1740614400000, "y": -4, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1740960000000, "y": 49, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1741651200000, "y": 46, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1741996800000, "y": 46, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1742169600000, "y": 46, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1742428800000, "y": 44, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1742860800000, "y": 44, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1742947200000, "y": 48, "note": "deepseek-r1" }, { "t": 1743292800000, "y": 36, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1743811200000, "y": 40, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1744070400000, "y": 40, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1744156800000, "y": 36, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1744761600000, "y": 35, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1745366400000, "y": 45, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1746403200000, "y": 39, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1746489600000, "y": 39, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1746921600000, "y": 40, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1747612800000, "y": 41, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1747699200000, "y": 41, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1747872000000, "y": 41, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1748736000000, "y": 45, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1748908800000, "y": 44, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1749081600000, "y": 43, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1749600000000, "y": 43, "note": "deepseek-v3-0324" }, { "t": 1750118400000, "y": 6, "note": "deepseek-r1-0528" }, { "t": 1750204800000, "y": 6, "note": "deepseek-r1-0528" }, { "t": 1750723200000, "y": 54, "note": "deepseek-r1-0528" }, { "t": 1751328000000, "y": 49, "note": "deepseek-r1-0528" }, { "t": 1751846400000, "y": 52, "note": "deepseek-r1-0528" }, { "t": 1752537600000, "y": 50, "note": "deepseek-r1-0528" }, { "t": 1752710400000, "y": 50, "note": "deepseek-r1-0528" }, { "t": 1753401600000, "y": 48, "note": "deepseek-r1-0528" }, { "t": 1753660800000, "y": 48, "note": "deepseek-r1-0528" }, { "t": 1754006400000, "y": 39, "note": "qwen3-235b-a22b-instruct-2507" }, { "t": 1754265600000, "y": 36, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1754524800000, "y": 38, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1755129600000, "y": 36, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1755475200000, "y": 37, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1755734400000, "y": 37, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1756252800000, "y": 37, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1756339200000, "y": 37, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1757289600000, "y": 37, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1758067200000, "y": 41, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1758153600000, "y": 41, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1759190400000, "y": 38, "note": "qwen3-vl-235b-a22b-instruct" }, { "t": 1759276800000, "y": 39, "note": "glm-4.5" }, { "t": 1759449600000, "y": 23, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1759795200000, "y": 27, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1760572800000, "y": 26, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1760659200000, "y": 26, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1762300800000, "y": 21, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1762387200000, "y": 20, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1762646400000, "y": 21, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1763251200000, "y": 51, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1763337600000, "y": 53, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1763424000000, "y": 49, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1763596800000, "y": 48, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1764115200000, "y": 46, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1764547200000, "y": 45, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1764806400000, "y": 45, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1764892800000, "y": 45, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1765152000000, "y": 44, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1765411200000, "y": 46, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1765756800000, "y": 44, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1765843200000, "y": 45, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1766016000000, "y": 45, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1766102400000, "y": 44, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1766275200000, "y": 44, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1766448000000, "y": 44, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1767052800000, "y": 45, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1767916800000, "y": 44, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1769472000000, "y": 42, "note": "glm-4.6" }, { "t": 1769644800000, "y": 35, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1770336000000, "y": 57, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1770595200000, "y": 60, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1770681600000, "y": 41, "note": "glm-5" }, { "t": 1770768000000, "y": 59, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1771200000000, "y": 59, "note": "glm-5" }, { "t": 1771286400000, "y": 58, "note": "glm-5" }, { "t": 1771459200000, "y": 55, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1771545600000, "y": 54, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1771632000000, "y": 55, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1771718400000, "y": 55, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1771891200000, "y": 54, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1771977600000, "y": 54, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1772064000000, "y": 50, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1772496000000, "y": 54, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1772582400000, "y": 55, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1772668800000, "y": 53, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1772755200000, "y": 54, "note": "qwen3.5-397b-a17b" }, { "t": 1773187200000, "y": 53, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1773619200000, "y": 50, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1773792000000, "y": 49, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1773878400000, "y": 49, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1773964800000, "y": 50, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1774483200000, "y": 51, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1774915200000, "y": 51, "note": "kimi-k2.5-thinking" }, { "t": 1775088000000, "y": 25, "note": "gpt-5.4-high" }, { "t": 1775520000000, "y": 25, "note": "gpt-5.4-high" }, { "t": 1775692800000, "y": 26, "note": "gpt-5.4-high" }, { "t": 1775779200000, "y": 26, "note": "gpt-5.4-high" }, { "t": 1776124800000, "y": 28, "note": "gpt-5.4-high" }, { "t": 1776384000000, "y": 28, "note": "gpt-5.4-high" }, { "t": 1776643200000, "y": 26, "note": "gpt-5.4-high" }, { "t": 1776816000000, "y": 35, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1776902400000, "y": 34, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1777248000000, "y": 32, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1777334400000, "y": 32, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1777420800000, "y": 34, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1777507200000, "y": 33, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1777593600000, "y": 32, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1778025600000, "y": 31, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1778112000000, "y": 32, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1778544000000, "y": 32, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1778716800000, "y": 30, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1779062400000, "y": 31, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1779148800000, "y": 31, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1779840000000, "y": 30, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1780444800000, "y": 30, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1780531200000, "y": 30, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1780617600000, "y": 31, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1781049600000, "y": 31, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1781568000000, "y": 31, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1782345600000, "y": 32, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1782950400000, "y": 34, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1783641600000, "y": 34, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1783814400000, "y": 34, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1783987200000, "y": 34, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1784160000000, "y": 35, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1784505600000, "y": 36, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1784592000000, "y": 37, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1785024000000, "y": 33, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1785110400000, "y": 38, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1785369600000, "y": 38, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1785628800000, "y": 34, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1785715200000, "y": 42, "note": "glm-5.1" }, { "t": 1785974400000, "y": 32, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1786320000000, "y": 32, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1786406400000, "y": 32, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1786492800000, "y": 31, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1787097600000, "y": 28, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1787270400000, "y": 27, "note": "glm-5.3-max" }, { "t": 1787788800000, "y": 29, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1788220800000, "y": 29, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1788307200000, "y": 38, "note": "kimi-k3-max" }, { "t": 1789084800000, "y": 33, "note": "glm-5.3-max" }, { "t": 1789257600000, "y": 32, "note": "glm-5.3-max" }, { "t": 1790294400000, "y": 27, "note": "mimo-v2.6-pro" }, { "t": 1790726400000, "y": 43, "note": "mimo-v2.6-pro" }, { "t": 1790899200000, "y": 42, "note": "mimo-v2.6-pro" } ] } ], "ann": [ { "t": 1738540800000, "y": -9, "text": "DeepSeek R1 leads (-9 pts, 3 Feb 2025)", "dy": 24 } ] } }