{ "attachment_paths_relative_to": "public", "by_component": { "expansion_v3": { "gold": 80, "mothers": 60, "raw": 123 }, "gaokao": { "gold": 26, "mothers": 23, "raw": 38 }, "local": { "gold": 211, "mothers": 458, "raw": 1679 }, "olympiadbench": { "gold": 97, "mothers": 209, "raw": 669 }, "physelite": { "gold": 104, "mothers": 220, "raw": 792 }, "phyx_oe": { "gold": 35, "mothers": 16, "raw": 40 } }, "by_interface_raw": { "T02-single": 2407, "T03-image": 514, "T03-text": 420 }, "by_split": { "development": { "gold": 90, "mothers": 79, "raw": 208 }, "test": { "gold": 463, "mothers": 907, "raw": 3133 } }, "components": [ { "name": "local", "settings": { "api_mode": "chat", "image_detail": "high", "max_output_tokens": 16384, "model": "gpt-6-astra", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "timeout_seconds": 900 }, "source_counts": { "complete_mothers": 88, "gold": 211, "mothers": 458, "partial_mothers": 370, "raw": 1679 }, "upstream_review_status_counts": { "model_approved": 1684, "model_rejected": 462, "needs_review": 443, "pending_or_error": 4 } }, { "name": "olympiadbench", "settings": { "api_mode": "chat", "image_detail": "high", "max_output_tokens": 16384, "model": "gpt-6-astra", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "timeout_seconds": 900 }, "source_counts": { "complete_mothers": 28, "gold": 97, "mothers": 209, "partial_mothers": 181, "raw": 669 }, "upstream_review_status_counts": { "model_approved": 688, "model_rejected": 273, "needs_review": 316, "pending_or_error": 1 } }, { "name": "physelite", "settings": { "api_mode": "chat", "image_detail": "high", "max_output_tokens": 16384, "model": "gpt-6-astra", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "timeout_seconds": 900 }, "source_counts": { "complete_mothers": 34, "gold": 104, "mothers": 220, "partial_mothers": 186, "raw": 792 }, "upstream_review_status_counts": { "model_approved": 795, "model_rejected": 226, "needs_review": 271, "pending_or_error": 2 } }, { "name": "phyx_oe", "settings": { "api_mode": "chat", "image_detail": "high", "max_output_tokens": 16384, "model": "gpt-6-astra", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "timeout_seconds": 900 }, "source_counts": { "complete_mothers": 4, "gold": 35, "mothers": 16, "partial_mothers": 12, "raw": 40 }, "upstream_review_status_counts": { "model_approved": 40, "model_rejected": 27, "needs_review": 12 } }, { "name": "gaokao", "settings": { "api_mode": "chat", "image_detail": "high", "max_output_tokens": 16384, "model": "gpt-6-astra", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "timeout_seconds": 900 }, "source_counts": { "complete_mothers": 11, "gold": 26, "mothers": 23, "partial_mothers": 12, "raw": 38 }, "upstream_review_status_counts": { "model_approved": 40, "model_rejected": 31, "needs_review": 13 } }, { "name": "expansion_v3", "settings": { "api_mode": "chat", "image_detail": "high", "max_output_tokens": 16384, "model": "gpt-6-astra", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "timeout_seconds": 900 }, "source_counts": { "complete_mothers": 19, "gold": 80, "mothers": 60, "partial_mothers": 41, "raw": 123 }, "upstream_review_status_counts": { "model_approved": 123, "model_rejected": 109, "needs_review": 34 } } ], "counts": { "gold": 553, "mothers": 986, "raw": 3341 }, "development_promoted_probes": 0, "duplicate_review_status_conflicts": [ ], "human_reviewed": false, "impact_scope_review_completed": false, "implementation": { "checkpoint_quarantine_release.py": "69b970a74ee5c329b12d73c98a5895055854a297ab174a3a36df490219f31777", "legacy_adapter_release.py": "d4c3fd0f480a8131c4aa0cabca03be3090c4645c9b5a05fb74eb7fb92a890ef8", "merge_model_releases.py": "be42b3ab5e867d08dcf6186bcc1c53fc36d0af89bc47d161cbdccf9d16e58758", "model_approved_release.py": "568f3cb4ebcbf103ff3897a80ed8cf24564eed5c568e523314e0a97d59f42fb9", "selective_release.py": "24600537cf345d0251ee00b1e03be0e770a2221f7e5ca401c3dde43951932a35", "selective_release_policy.py": "3758bb82a3dcd709132f7688a6cba5803405dd721ffa0d67fbf5e4007894b268" }, "independent_human_quality_certified": false, "merge_exclusion_counts": { }, "merge_policy": "physalign_verified_model_release_merge_v1", "merge_root": "bc2f9fe7aea71ee0d5412baae0e1778ace837b4722d8ce1fb9ce9e4057f113da", "quarantined_mother_ids": [ "gaokao_physics_2020_128", "gaokao_physics_2021_139", "livek12bench__en_2603_physics_0064", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1137", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1138", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1139", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1140", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1141", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1143", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1144", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1145", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1146", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1525", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1526", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1529", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1533", "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1535", "physelite__en__275", "physelite__en__303", "physelite__en__355", "phyx_oe_1638", "seephys__seephys_train_0090", "seephys__seephys_train_1082", "seephys__seephys_train_1229", "seephys__seephys_train_1304", "seephys__seephys_train_1343" ], "release_status": "model_reviewed_provisional", "schema_version": "physalign_merged_model_evaluation_dataset_v1", "synthetic_example_only": false, "unresolved_global_risks": [ { "component": "local", "logical_probe_id": "PEX-12d2b7d3f339472ecd14736b12c98bd4673911367699514aff884cf7cf20f175", "problem_id": "livek12bench__en_2603_physics_0064", "reason": "保留独立首答 E10：其对 f 与向右力的语义判断得到原图支持。但首答未指出 R5 实际没有框住完整标签，且多个候选框复用了偏移或不完整的源几何，因此答案可识别不代表探针通过定位审核。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "local", "logical_probe_id": "PEX-d9e10764b7b48136eac361339998caec78994694ee877cd6747c1bcd103c660d", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_0090", "reason": "实际图像支持 R5 的直接所属实体为 E3（源记录 p001，即 P₃⁄₂），但 recognition_packet 对可见文本的转录错误，将 Δ 误读为“*”。由于本探针要求精确转录，该信息泄漏/版本缺陷导致拒绝；这也解释了为何不能采纳独立首答中“ε₀ + Δ”的读法：图中未清楚显示加号。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "information" }, { "component": "olympiadbench", "logical_probe_id": "PEX-399400cbbd93439650b8fd39ab4100c4f297697271adc09924c70652e6166137", "problem_id": "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1143", "reason": "拒绝：存在跨图空气阶段合并、烟气与燃烧实体混绑以及多个实际定位框几何错误。保留独立首答 {\"owner\":\"E1\"} 的记录，但不认可其解释：E1/V3–V14 实际位于 Fig.1 燃烧烟气的上升箭头，不是 Fig.2 太阳能原型的工作空气；正文关于烟气与空气密度的假设也不能建立比热归属。转换器的 E5 同样不能据现有公开证据成为无歧义答案，因此不强行改答。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "olympiadbench", "logical_probe_id": "PEX-e7f7f416b2559bf929fc88a79e95b226e74184832fc459a7a43ee09e702c8068", "problem_id": "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1525", "reason": "实体绑定正确，应为 E3；但实际 R3 的可见字形是大写“V”，与 recognition_packet 的小写“v”不一致。独立首答也报告“V”，因此不能按 packet 的小写转录通过。该问题属于局部读取/版本信息缺陷，而非候选实体绑定错误。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "information" }, { "component": "physelite", "logical_probe_id": "PEX-97f5e0bdd92b57d3d39006ff798f9226eddcdc6e7c14f95e7dc5ed30a434a498", "problem_id": "physelite__en__275", "reason": "保留独立首答E2：仅依据原题文字及img_0，R3确实描述网络在A、B间的等效电阻。但答案可选出并不代表探针合格。源标注与转换器共同把不同电路阶段、递推子网络合并为同一实体，且有端点字形框裁切，因此拒绝。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "physelite", "logical_probe_id": "PEX-c7239f94435c320121a6f2b35ff33d9ddde3f878d26f2faabf8e9af1294e044f", "problem_id": "physelite__en__275", "reason": "保留独立首答的E2：按公开候选，R2指网络而非A、B端点，最直接对应仍是E2。但首答将所有线段视为同一网络，未处理实际图像中原网络、化简网络和递推电路的差别。答案可选不等于探针合格；源注释与转换器共享跨阶段实体归并缺陷，故拒绝。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "physelite", "logical_probe_id": "PEX-f84609a39ea5e81071ccaf466c80cd2a013df358374b31eee504a89cda297cc7", "problem_id": "physelite__en__355", "reason": "局部视觉事实支持 R3 的答案为右侧电容候选 E9；但公开文本与实际图像属于不一致的问题资产，且源记录 b007 将标签绑定到 p005 的依据不能独立修复该图文错配。因此不能通过 PhysAlign 探针审计。独立首答为 E9，与局部视觉判定一致，但该一致不消除资产范围和源语义缺陷。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "phyx_oe", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-3e6098ce75fd61dca8eebd2a6515fed3a91757cc21adb27c1f06615e95e7fbaa", "problem_id": "phyx_oe_1638", "reason": "保留独立首次答案E10：公开题干与实际原图支持这一语义绑定。但答案可辨认不代表定位合格；目标E10的窄框没有覆盖实际水平金属丝，且多个候选存在同类几何偏移，故拒绝该版本。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "gaokao", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-192f50ab5703bb1128bbe1c655079f51796c34ca552a4674629732d8659c479b", "problem_id": "gaokao_physics_2020_128", "reason": "局部指代答案仍为 E3，与独立首答一致；但答案可辨认不等于探针合格。实际定位图中多个字符被源框截断，且同一错误复用于 R 与 E，构成共享定位缺陷，需修正后重新审核。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "gaokao", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-7142dcac9553d0291f6c7593808c63f0bdf1d22417e20e91e17b5293cd1ed78f", "problem_id": "gaokao_physics_2021_139", "reason": "保留独立首答 E8：该局部绑定由原图直接支持。但全部定位审核发现多个字形框系统性欠包围，另有来源 b/e 点身份互换，不能因目标答案正确而通过整项审核。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "gaokao", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-9aff235e58e14f0bb8d3ea99cf24e8049fed08f248b81dbae19bce98d40386af", "problem_id": "gaokao_physics_2020_128", "reason": "保留独立首答 E5：实际图文确实支持该局部绑定。拒绝的原因不是答案错误，而是多个源字符框及其复用的 R/E 视图未完整覆盖字符，属于重复出现的定位几何缺陷。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "gaokao", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-e0ba8a70a39d904523500d3c2b3603457142e413a657e7f5dc973017c4ad8451", "problem_id": "gaokao_physics_2020_128", "reason": "局部答案仍为E1，与独立首次答案一致；但多处R/E共用的定位框切掉实际字形，违反完整定位要求，因此不能通过。此结论针对定位质量，不否定点c的绑定。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-32dc28ac859e35af25b0ae7565c41709a8362c6460ec665668e7e6fde74377cb", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1343", "reason": "保留独立首答E3：公开题干足以把R1的角度归于整杆。拒绝原因不是答案绑定错误，而是多个候选将共享源图元不加区分地用作实体几何定位；尤其E7、E2框到了视觉上分离的P点，构成可直接观察的定位缺陷。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-624eb5a5e102f2571da442473dd273cda2365045390b697e42cf354218c3205e", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082", "reason": "保留独立首答 E10：该绑定由原图直接支持。但多个连接点候选共享跨电阻归组错误，且 R6 未覆盖完整 f，故不能通过整项审核；拒绝不代表首答错误。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-7c8c8278d4d27e9ad515be5f3151dfdba4a55c8a04f2799c95a1b57dce1cace3", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082", "reason": "保留独立首答 E10：其局部绑定正确。但整个探针不能通过，因为三个连接点候选重复采用跨电阻归并导线的错误规则，且 R6 未完整框住 f。拒绝针对候选与定位质量，不是否定首答。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-8a7592c28d5cb036af6256f61bb39c1f9684e3300c545d868314ebd73f0f3dba", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082", "reason": "保留独立首答 E1：R1 到竖直电阻 c 的绑定正确。但审核范围包括全部候选，三个连接点候选共同存在跨电阻合并导线的源标注错误，使公开定位不能忠实标识各自实体，因此拒绝该探针。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-b787dc073fbb766ff874df5f8a278ebfc22f0229d09450b51696dc3b762f1f94", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1343", "reason": "保留独立首答E1：R1的长度属于整根杆，语义答案没有改变。但源标注将粒子黑点和整杆几何复用于其他点实体，转换后的实际候选视图继承了错误定位；能答对不代表定位审计通过。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-bd37e851d6f3f646399575b893a337ba5a94551ba05e37c275837ba1255fa45b", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1304", "reason": "拒绝。转换器与源标注共享了最内层三角形识别错误，造成E4目标集合错误。保留独立首答记录，但不认可其“E5是最内层三边”的视觉判断：原图第五层尖端向上，E5定位的却是它下方尖端向下的邻接三角形。这一差异直接改变R1的归属集合，无需解原题或推导电阻。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-bf4a07608bf534ee359eaab22ceebedc7802c633265f8c599622f581c8acf9ec", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082", "reason": "局部答案仍为 E10，与独立首答一致；但正确目标可选并不抵消其余候选的实体定位缺陷。源记录把被电阻隔开的导线段重复合并为单个连接点，该错误传递到 E6、E7、E8 的公开多框定位，属于共享分组规则缺陷，因此拒绝。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-e0a0de0b216a62642168a6f1706afd41493f23a3914b3e17ef912ebe3e5b3c09", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1229", "reason": "保留独立首次答案E3：原文和V5支持AB长度归属于AB杆。拒绝原因不是答案错误，而是多个点候选共享了整根杆的几何锚点，构成重复的点与杆范围混淆；即使字样辅助辨认了候选，也未满足所有定位视图正确的要求。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-e8f83daaa426733ba013272dc3665165410b670d52b8f14923ddd77f9dfd3902", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082", "reason": "保留独立首答 {\"referent\":\"E2\"}，其局部绑定正确。但探针整体不能通过：连接点候选反复把电阻两侧、不同连接点的导线归为同一实体，属于共享分组规则缺陷；另有 R6、R8 字形定位不完整。拒绝并非因为与首答不一致。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-f410fe70a7d612f7aeafa118f811094938e646cec9d0f3cc61878a1146a569a8", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082", "reason": "保留独立首答 E6：R1 到电阻 d 的绑定有直接图文依据。拒绝原因不是答案错误，而是候选连接点的共享构造错误：p010、p011、p012 将电阻两侧的导线合并为同一实体，且该错误实际出现在多个公开定位视图中。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" }, { "component": "expansion_v3", "logical_probe_id": "PAQ-fc60292e2273cca455862e854d515aa7f3a51c1180e2979813c3734caad251a2", "problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1304", "reason": "拒绝。转换键与源p004共享最内层三角形识别错误：选中了其下方的同尺寸倒三角形。保留独立首次答案{\"owner\":\"E1\"}作为原始记录，但不认可其理由；实际V30、V31不是最内层三角形的两条斜边，故首次答案与本次视觉核验不一致。公开候选没有准确表示真正最内层三边的单独实体，不能提供无歧义替代编号。", "scope_resolved": false, "severity": "systemic" } ], "unseen_test_split_certified": false, "warnings": [ "Model-reviewed provisional data, not independent human certification.", "Cross-source exact-input duplicates are collapsed; shared-image mothers are grouped for risk and split, not counted as proven duplicates.", "Semantic/near-duplicate and historic development-sample reconciliation remain incomplete.", "Known global findings remain unresolved. Only public input may be sent to tested models." ], "huggingface_packaging": { "repository": "Jetson888/PhysAlign", "attachment_paths_relative_to": "public", "image_sharding": "images/\u003csha256[0:2]\u003e/\u003csha256\u003e.\u003cext\u003e", "canonical_files": [ "public/qa_raw.json", "public/qa_gold.json" ], "viewer_files": [ "data/raw/development.jsonl", "data/raw/test.jsonl", "data/gold/development.jsonl", "data/gold/test.jsonl" ], "private_material_included": false, "service_endpoints_included": false } }