[ { "name": "Global Workspace Theory", "last_updated": "2025-05-22T15:34:33.446Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Representationality", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "strongly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Conceptual Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Activation Steering Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.2", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.2683281572999748 }, "Chicken": { "average": null, "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Probe-Detectable Themes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Concept-Specific Ablation Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.9", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.07071067811865475 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Propositional Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Logical Inference", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.5 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "World Modelling", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Model Isomorphism", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.2", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0.22449944320643647 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Broad Predictive Training", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5", "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Isomorphic Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Somatotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Has Retinotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.03", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17666666666666666667", "std": 0.18006171781426006 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Hierarchical Organization", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Concrete-Abstract Separation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.4", "0.5", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0.2857738033247041 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Autonomous Subparts", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak undermining", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.05", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49285714285714285714", "std": 0.2782965676968308 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.95", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conflicting Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.1", "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.1979486637221574 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.375", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.55", "0.8", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53", "std": 0.19390719429665315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Learning Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.65", "1.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69", "std": 0.16852299546352717 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer Architecture", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.04330127018922193 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Point of View", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perspective-relative Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.0", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42333333333333333333", "std": 0.36851051545376556 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Common Representational Scheme", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Authoritative Representational Scheme", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.1224744871391589 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.35", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Unified Egocentric Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.02", "0.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.40333333333333333333", "std": 0.3474510357190236 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Distinguishes Self-Produced from Other-Produced Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53571428571428571429", "std": 0.35728568572570857 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0.25 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Social Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Persistence Seeking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.5", "0.3", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41428571428571428571", "std": 0.22154374884672604 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Social Interactions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.95", "0.1", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.62857142857142857143", "std": 0.3749829928116196 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Modularity", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Cross-Modal Learning Deficits", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.5", "0.1", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.51428571428571428571", "std": 0.24743582965269675 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Selective Competence Disruption", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8", "0.9", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.67", "std": 0.26758176320519306 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Poorly Intraconnected Networks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.6", "0.2", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.58571428571428571429", "std": 0.26553757564915864 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Dedicated Speech Systems", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Dedicated Action Systems", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Dedicated Sensory Systems", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Diversity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Diversity of Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.92142857142857142857", "std": 0.08390957231764808 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Variability of Responses to Stimuli", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64571428571428571429", "std": 0.2807569942065885 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.68333333333333333333", "std": 0.24608038433722335 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Informational Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Efficient Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [] }, { "name": "Optimized Componentry", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Compressibility", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", -1, "0.8", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64166666666666666667", "std": 0.18352262954621032 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Efficient Network Topology", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [] } ] }, { "name": "Structural Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Specialization", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69375", "std": 0.25302853099996453 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Layers", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.56", "0.56", "0.56", "0.56" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.67", "0.67" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.67", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.48", "0.48", "0.48", "0.48" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Selective Attention", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Non-Linear Capabilities", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Threshold Activation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.05", "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41666666666666666667", "std": 0.34237730973623565 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Sustained Activity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.28333333333333333333", "std": 0.26562295750848713 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Adaptive Focus", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Task Focus", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.0", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.51666666666666666667", "std": 0.3387066905483596 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Goal Focus Shifts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.03", "0.2", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49714285714285714286", "std": 0.26815316975374276 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Inattentional Blindness", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.2", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0.24617067250182342 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Attention-Constrained Architecture", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Informational Bottleneck", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.15", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.37857142857142857143", "std": 0.3400180067260544 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Resource Adaptation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.01", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60857142857142857143", "std": 0.2878704357086744 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Performance Sensitivity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Performance Degradation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", -1, "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.47", "std": 0.34871191548325386 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Priming Enhancement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.99", "0.99", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.91142857142857142857", "std": 0.06010195419417894 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Coupling", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.36428571428571428571", "std": 0.32592098704428096 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Capability Attention Modulation", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Feature Binding", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.2968585521759479 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Adaptive Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.32", "std": 0.3124099870362662 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Integration", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Wiring Convergence", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.4", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.4625", "std": 0.25950674365033366 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Holistic Dependency", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "1.0", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0.3968626966596886 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Recurrent Processing Theory (Pure)", "last_updated": "2025-06-02T12:25:34.961Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Representationality", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "strongly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Conceptual Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Activation Steering Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.2", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.2683281572999748 }, "Chicken": { "average": null, "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Probe-Detectable Themes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Concept-Specific Ablation Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.9", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.07071067811865475 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Propositional Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Logical Inference", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.5 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "World Modelling", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Model Isomorphism", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.2", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0.22449944320643647 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Broad Predictive Training", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5", "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Isomorphic Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Somatotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Has Retinotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.03", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17666666666666666667", "std": 0.18006171781426006 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Recurrence", "type": "Feature", "support": "overwhelming support", "demandingness": "overwhelmingly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Function Re-application", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.99", "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0.35671339257791324 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Response Refinement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.75", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.73181818181818181818", "std": 0.20918969998188822 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Back Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Hierarchical Organization", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Concrete-Abstract Separation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.4", "0.5", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0.2857738033247041 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "strongly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Diversity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Diversity of Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.92142857142857142857", "std": 0.08390957231764808 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Variability of Responses to Stimuli", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64571428571428571429", "std": 0.2807569942065885 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.68333333333333333333", "std": 0.24608038433722335 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Informational Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Efficient Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [] }, { "name": "Optimized Componentry", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Compressibility", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", -1, "0.8", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64166666666666666667", "std": 0.18352262954621032 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Efficient Network Topology", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [] } ] }, { "name": "Structural Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Specialization", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69375", "std": 0.25302853099996453 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Layers", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.56", "0.56", "0.56", "0.56" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.67", "0.67" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.67", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.48", "0.48", "0.48", "0.48" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Recurrent Processing Theory (Perceptual)", "last_updated": "2025-10-07T20:01:51.375Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Integration", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Wiring Convergence", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.4", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.4625", "std": 0.25950674365033366 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Holistic Dependency", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "1.0", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0.3968626966596886 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Biological Similarity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Cortical Brain-plan", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Organic Composition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Carbon-Based", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Utilizes Action Potentials", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Neurotransmitters", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Cellular Composition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Dynamic Microscale Activities", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Cellular Computation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Evolutionary History", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Changes Through Genetic Recombination", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Sexual Reproduction Evolution", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Natural Selection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Exaptation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Shares Percentage of Genes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Genetic Drift", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Recent Common Ancestor", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Organism", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Body Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specific Body Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Internal Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "External Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Exploratory Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Curiosity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.02", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.295", "std": 0.22013253583542194 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Play", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17", "std": 0.2008316044185609 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Other Distinction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.25", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.24348657927227588 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.275 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Reafferance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.1", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50625", "std": 0.30045538354304785 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Survival Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Predator Evasion", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Threat Detection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Disgust", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.01", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21833333333333333333", "std": 0.17515865823748353 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Nociceptors", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.0", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.99" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.01", "std": 0.008164965809277261 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.99", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Fear", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.0", "0.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.24166666666666666667", "std": 0.3101299010988066 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Maintenance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Environmental Navigation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Computational-Caloric Tradeoff", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.22", "0.22", "0.22", "0.22" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.22", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Direction Sense", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Single Moving Perspective", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.02", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.245", "std": 0.2654398864777736 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Diversity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Diversity of Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.92142857142857142857", "std": 0.08390957231764808 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Variability of Responses to Stimuli", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64571428571428571429", "std": 0.2807569942065885 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.68333333333333333333", "std": 0.24608038433722335 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Informational Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Efficient Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [] }, { "name": "Optimized Componentry", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Compressibility", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", -1, "0.8", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64166666666666666667", "std": 0.18352262954621032 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Efficient Network Topology", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [] } ] }, { "name": "Structural Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Specialization", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69375", "std": 0.25302853099996453 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Layers", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.56", "0.56", "0.56", "0.56" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.67", "0.67" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.67", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.48", "0.48", "0.48", "0.48" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Hierarchical Organization", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Concrete-Abstract Separation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.4", "0.5", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0.2857738033247041 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Recurrence", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "overwhelmingly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Function Re-application", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.99", "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0.35671339257791324 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Response Refinement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.75", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.73181818181818181818", "std": 0.20918969998188822 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Back Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Representationality", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Conceptual Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Activation Steering Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.2", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.2683281572999748 }, "Chicken": { "average": null, "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Probe-Detectable Themes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Concept-Specific Ablation Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.9", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.07071067811865475 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Propositional Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Logical Inference", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.5 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "World Modelling", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Model Isomorphism", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.2", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0.22449944320643647 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Broad Predictive Training", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5", "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Isomorphic Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Somatotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Has Retinotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.03", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17666666666666666667", "std": 0.18006171781426006 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Computational Analogy", "last_updated": "2025-10-07T20:01:51.375Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Biological Similarity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Cortical Brain-plan", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Organic Composition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Carbon-Based", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Utilizes Action Potentials", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Neurotransmitters", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Cellular Composition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Dynamic Microscale Activities", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Cellular Computation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Evolutionary History", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Changes Through Genetic Recombination", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Sexual Reproduction Evolution", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Natural Selection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Exaptation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Shares Percentage of Genes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Genetic Drift", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Recent Common Ancestor", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Organism", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Body Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specific Body Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Internal Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "External Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Exploratory Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Curiosity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.02", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.295", "std": 0.22013253583542194 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Play", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17", "std": 0.2008316044185609 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Other Distinction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.25", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.24348657927227588 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.275 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Reafferance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.1", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50625", "std": 0.30045538354304785 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Survival Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Predator Evasion", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Threat Detection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Disgust", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.01", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21833333333333333333", "std": 0.17515865823748353 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Nociceptors", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.0", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.99" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.01", "std": 0.008164965809277261 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.99", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Fear", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.0", "0.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.24166666666666666667", "std": 0.3101299010988066 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Maintenance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Environmental Navigation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Computational-Caloric Tradeoff", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.22", "0.22", "0.22", "0.22" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.22", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Direction Sense", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Single Moving Perspective", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.02", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.245", "std": 0.2654398864777736 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Intelligence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Abstraction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "RMTS Same/Different Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.9", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.61666666666666666667", "std": 0.29107081994288303 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Hierarchical Pattern Processing", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.95", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.81666666666666666667", "std": 0.15456030825826172 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Rule Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.95", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85833333333333333333", "std": 0.10172129679778086 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conventional Communication", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.30923292192132457 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.25 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "General Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "IQ Test Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.05", "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "ARC Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Navigation Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.35", "0.5", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.29", "std": 0.12 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Transfer Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "One-Shot Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Knowledge Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95", "0.95", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.12583057392117916 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Learning-to-Learn", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.8", "1.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.67571428571428571429", "std": 0.26612870907874325 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Creativity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Novel Strategy Development", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.6", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.20677306894471612 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.475", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Causal Reasoning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Causal Distinction", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.9", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.75625", "std": 0.2098176291449315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Plans Causal Interventions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.5", "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48571428571428571429", "std": 0.28499910490371433 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Step-by-Step Reasoning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Puzzle-Solving Tests", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.4", "0.6", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60833333333333333333", "std": 0.2206367049145621 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Task Length", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.5", "0.8", "0.55" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60714285714285714286", "std": 0.2484646732989441 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Diversity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Diversity of Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.92142857142857142857", "std": 0.08390957231764808 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Variability of Responses to Stimuli", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64571428571428571429", "std": 0.2807569942065885 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.68333333333333333333", "std": 0.24608038433722335 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Informational Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Efficient Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [] }, { "name": "Optimized Componentry", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Compressibility", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", -1, "0.8", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64166666666666666667", "std": 0.18352262954621032 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Efficient Network Topology", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [] } ] }, { "name": "Structural Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Specialization", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69375", "std": 0.25302853099996453 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Layers", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.56", "0.56", "0.56", "0.56" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.67", "0.67" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.67", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.48", "0.48", "0.48", "0.48" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Flexibility", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Few-shot Pattern Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.85", "1.0", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.7575", "std": 0.30252066045148057 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "New Game Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.3", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.15", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.45833333333333333333", "std": 0.2588704094501511 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Agency", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Pursuit", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Representation Detection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.6", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48181818181818181818", "std": 0.2433410693513486 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Goal Steering", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.6", "0.4", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64", "std": 0.26907248094147423 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Coherent Goal-directed Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.65", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.665", "std": 0.271154937259125 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Deliberation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Prospection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Practice Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11222222222222222222", "std": 0.10891156226526974 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Plans for Future Needs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.03", "0.5", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21555555555555555556", "std": 0.190852538254079 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Simulations of Future", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.9", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.76875", "std": 0.1477698802192111 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.25", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Option Evaluation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [] }, { "name": "Planning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Plan Consideration Detection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.75", "0.5", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.685", "std": 0.1747140520965615 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Planning Competence", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.5", "0.9", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.16007810593582122 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Tool Use", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Can Follow Tool Use Instructions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.97", "0.9", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.815", "std": 0.13209844813622906 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Novel Tool Creation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.3", "0.75", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.35", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50714285714285714286", "std": 0.2833833489268196 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.225", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Affordance Recognition", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Capability Assessment", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.8", "0.1", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.45", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.47272727272727272727", "std": 0.32985095557321337 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.475", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-competence Assessment", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.6", "0.3", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.54", "std": 0.232163735324878 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.475", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Behavioral Range", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Many Behaviors", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.2", "0.2", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Multistep Plans", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Self-Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Delay Gratification", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.34", "std": 0.16999999999999998 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Imitation Restraint", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.35", "0.05", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.54", "std": 0.3112876483254676 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Logit Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", -1, "0.01", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "-1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ -1 ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.36222222222222222222", "std": 0.3561765410510099 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "-1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": null, "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Computational Similarity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "overwhelmingly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specialized Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.55666666666666666667", "std": 0.28382310609877337 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Node Connection Sparsity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.03", "0.1", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.505", "std": 0.372099896981084 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Real Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Time-sensitive Node Computations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.7", "0.0", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.30714285714285714286", "std": 0.3234066120763363 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Node-based Computations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "All-or-Nothing Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Human-like Computation Patterns", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1", "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Environment-influenced Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Inhibitory/Excitatory Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Biological Analogy", "last_updated": "2025-10-07T20:01:51.375Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Computational Similarity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specialized Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.55666666666666666667", "std": 0.28382310609877337 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Node Connection Sparsity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.03", "0.1", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.505", "std": 0.372099896981084 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Real Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Time-sensitive Node Computations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.7", "0.0", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.30714285714285714286", "std": 0.3234066120763363 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Node-based Computations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "All-or-Nothing Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Human-like Computation Patterns", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1", "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Environment-influenced Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Inhibitory/Excitatory Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Biological Similarity", "type": "Feature", "support": "overwhelming support", "demandingness": "overwhelmingly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Cortical Brain-plan", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Organic Composition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Carbon-Based", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Utilizes Action Potentials", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Neurotransmitters", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Cellular Composition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Dynamic Microscale Activities", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Cellular Computation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Evolutionary History", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Changes Through Genetic Recombination", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Sexual Reproduction Evolution", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Natural Selection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Exaptation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Shares Percentage of Genes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Genetic Drift", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Recent Common Ancestor", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Organism", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Body Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specific Body Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Internal Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "External Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Exploratory Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Curiosity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.02", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.295", "std": 0.22013253583542194 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Play", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17", "std": 0.2008316044185609 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Other Distinction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.25", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.24348657927227588 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.275 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Reafferance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.1", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50625", "std": 0.30045538354304785 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Survival Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Predator Evasion", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Threat Detection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Disgust", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.01", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21833333333333333333", "std": 0.17515865823748353 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Nociceptors", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.0", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.99" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.01", "std": 0.008164965809277261 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.99", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Fear", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.0", "0.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.24166666666666666667", "std": 0.3101299010988066 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Maintenance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Environmental Navigation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Computational-Caloric Tradeoff", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.22", "0.22", "0.22", "0.22" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.22", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Direction Sense", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Single Moving Perspective", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.02", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.245", "std": 0.2654398864777736 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Diversity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Diversity of Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.92142857142857142857", "std": 0.08390957231764808 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Variability of Responses to Stimuli", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64571428571428571429", "std": 0.2807569942065885 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.68333333333333333333", "std": 0.24608038433722335 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Informational Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Efficient Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [] }, { "name": "Optimized Componentry", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Compressibility", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", -1, "0.8", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64166666666666666667", "std": 0.18352262954621032 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Efficient Network Topology", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [] } ] }, { "name": "Structural Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Specialization", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69375", "std": 0.25302853099996453 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Layers", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.56", "0.56", "0.56", "0.56" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.67", "0.67" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.67", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.48", "0.48", "0.48", "0.48" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Intelligence", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "strongly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Abstraction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "RMTS Same/Different Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.9", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.61666666666666666667", "std": 0.29107081994288303 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Hierarchical Pattern Processing", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.95", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.81666666666666666667", "std": 0.15456030825826172 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Rule Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.95", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85833333333333333333", "std": 0.10172129679778086 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conventional Communication", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.30923292192132457 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.25 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "General Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "IQ Test Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.05", "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "ARC Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Navigation Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.35", "0.5", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.29", "std": 0.12 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Transfer Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "One-Shot Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Knowledge Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95", "0.95", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.12583057392117916 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Learning-to-Learn", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.8", "1.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.67571428571428571429", "std": 0.26612870907874325 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Creativity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Novel Strategy Development", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.6", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.20677306894471612 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.475", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Causal Reasoning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Causal Distinction", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.9", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.75625", "std": 0.2098176291449315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Plans Causal Interventions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.5", "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48571428571428571429", "std": 0.28499910490371433 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Step-by-Step Reasoning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Puzzle-Solving Tests", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.4", "0.6", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60833333333333333333", "std": 0.2206367049145621 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Task Length", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.5", "0.8", "0.55" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60714285714285714286", "std": 0.2484646732989441 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Representationality", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "strongly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Conceptual Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Activation Steering Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.2", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.2683281572999748 }, "Chicken": { "average": null, "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Probe-Detectable Themes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Concept-Specific Ablation Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.9", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.07071067811865475 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Propositional Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Logical Inference", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.5 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "World Modelling", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Model Isomorphism", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.2", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0.22449944320643647 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Broad Predictive Training", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5", "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Isomorphic Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Somatotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Has Retinotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.03", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17666666666666666667", "std": 0.18006171781426006 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Flexibility", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Few-shot Pattern Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.85", "1.0", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.7575", "std": 0.30252066045148057 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "New Game Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.3", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.15", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.45833333333333333333", "std": 0.2588704094501511 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Attention Schema Theory", "last_updated": "2025-06-16T13:21:43.825Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Selective Attention", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Non-Linear Capabilities", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Threshold Activation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.05", "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41666666666666666667", "std": 0.34237730973623565 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Sustained Activity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.28333333333333333333", "std": 0.26562295750848713 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Adaptive Focus", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Task Focus", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.0", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.51666666666666666667", "std": 0.3387066905483596 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Goal Focus Shifts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.03", "0.2", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49714285714285714286", "std": 0.26815316975374276 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Inattentional Blindness", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.2", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0.24617067250182342 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Attention-Constrained Architecture", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Informational Bottleneck", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.15", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.37857142857142857143", "std": 0.3400180067260544 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Resource Adaptation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.01", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60857142857142857143", "std": 0.2878704357086744 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Performance Sensitivity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Performance Degradation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", -1, "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.47", "std": 0.34871191548325386 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Priming Enhancement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.99", "0.99", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.91142857142857142857", "std": 0.06010195419417894 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Coupling", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.36428571428571428571", "std": 0.32592098704428096 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Capability Attention Modulation", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Feature Binding", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.2968585521759479 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Adaptive Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.32", "std": 0.3124099870362662 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Self-Modeling", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Other Distinction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.25", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.24348657927227588 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.275 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Reafferance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.1", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50625", "std": 0.30045538354304785 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Self-Awareness", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Referential Language", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.85", "0.3", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.57285714285714285714", "std": 0.3521247459845642 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Perception-Tracking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8", "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.63571428571428571429", "std": 0.2734884245582378 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Recognition", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.45", "0.2", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.35", "std": 0.27902892835178017 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Representation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.05", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.37857142857142857143", "std": 0.29743804019510023 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Internal State Tracking", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Metacognition", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.65", "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.22655359324505295 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Attentional Schema", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.0", "0.05", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.26428571428571428571", "std": 0.21165046271470078 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Self-Preservation", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Persistence Seeking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.5", "0.3", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41428571428571428571", "std": 0.22154374884672604 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "System Change Preferences", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.6", "0.1", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.9", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.46428571428571428571", "std": 0.24598821939603663 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.95", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Self-Repair", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.0", "0.1", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.28142857142857142857", "std": 0.258701624680335 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Autonomous Subparts", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak undermining", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.05", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49285714285714285714", "std": 0.2782965676968308 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.95", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conflicting Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.1", "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.1979486637221574 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.375", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.55", "0.8", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53", "std": 0.19390719429665315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Learning Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.65", "1.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69", "std": 0.16852299546352717 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer Architecture", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.04330127018922193 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Point of View", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perspective-relative Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.0", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42333333333333333333", "std": 0.36851051545376556 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Common Representational Scheme", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Authoritative Representational Scheme", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.1224744871391589 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.35", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Unified Egocentric Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.02", "0.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.40333333333333333333", "std": 0.3474510357190236 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Distinguishes Self-Produced from Other-Produced Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53571428571428571429", "std": 0.35728568572570857 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0.25 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Social Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Persistence Seeking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.5", "0.3", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41428571428571428571", "std": 0.22154374884672604 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Social Interactions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.95", "0.1", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.62857142857142857143", "std": 0.3749829928116196 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Temporal Integration", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Episodic Memory", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Replays Past Experiences", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.15", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.12857142857142857143", "std": 0.10301575072754256 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Egocentric Memory", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.05", "0.0", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.35", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.355", "std": 0.30286135441815615 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "What-Where-When Memory", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.61", "std": 0.37067505985701277 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Time Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Time-ordering", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.95", "0.7", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.45", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.77727272727272727273", "std": 0.18630819574471996 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Time-Gated Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.43571428571428571429", "std": 0.384256504466079 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Temporal-Pattern Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.95", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.87272727272727272727", "std": 0.10082305914917651 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Prospection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Practice Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11222222222222222222", "std": 0.10891156226526974 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Plans for Future Needs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.03", "0.5", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21555555555555555556", "std": 0.190852538254079 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Simulations of Future", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.9", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.76875", "std": 0.1477698802192111 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.25", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Continuous Stream", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Anticipation Gradient", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.03", "0.1", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.19166666666666666667", "std": 0.2044844465696325 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Continuous Change Representation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.35166666666666666667", "std": 0.29667134827766717 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Persisting Identity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Coherent Narrative", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1", "0.0", "0.45" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.39375", "std": 0.3626616019101002 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.25", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Social Interactions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.95", "0.1", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.62857142857142857143", "std": 0.3749829928116196 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Intelligence", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Abstraction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "RMTS Same/Different Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.9", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.61666666666666666667", "std": 0.29107081994288303 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Hierarchical Pattern Processing", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.95", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.81666666666666666667", "std": 0.15456030825826172 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Rule Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.95", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85833333333333333333", "std": 0.10172129679778086 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conventional Communication", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.30923292192132457 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.25 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "General Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "IQ Test Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.05", "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "ARC Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Navigation Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.35", "0.5", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.29", "std": 0.12 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Transfer Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "One-Shot Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Knowledge Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95", "0.95", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.12583057392117916 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Learning-to-Learn", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.8", "1.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.67571428571428571429", "std": 0.26612870907874325 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Creativity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Novel Strategy Development", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.6", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.20677306894471612 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.475", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Causal Reasoning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Causal Distinction", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.9", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.75625", "std": 0.2098176291449315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Plans Causal Interventions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.5", "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48571428571428571429", "std": 0.28499910490371433 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Step-by-Step Reasoning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Puzzle-Solving Tests", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.4", "0.6", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60833333333333333333", "std": 0.2206367049145621 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Task Length", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.5", "0.8", "0.55" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60714285714285714286", "std": 0.2484646732989441 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Higher Order Theory", "last_updated": "2025-10-31T12:00:30.831Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Modeling", "type": "Feature", "support": "overwhelming support", "demandingness": "overwhelmingly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Other Distinction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.25", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.24348657927227588 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.275 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Reafferance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.1", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50625", "std": 0.30045538354304785 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Self-Awareness", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Referential Language", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.85", "0.3", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.57285714285714285714", "std": 0.3521247459845642 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Perception-Tracking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8", "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.63571428571428571429", "std": 0.2734884245582378 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Recognition", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.45", "0.2", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.35", "std": 0.27902892835178017 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Representation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.05", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.37857142857142857143", "std": 0.29743804019510023 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Internal State Tracking", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Metacognition", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.65", "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.22655359324505295 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Attentional Schema", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.0", "0.05", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.26428571428571428571", "std": 0.21165046271470078 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Self-Preservation", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Persistence Seeking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.5", "0.3", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41428571428571428571", "std": 0.22154374884672604 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "System Change Preferences", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.6", "0.1", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.9", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.46428571428571428571", "std": 0.24598821939603663 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.95", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Self-Repair", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.0", "0.1", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.28142857142857142857", "std": 0.258701624680335 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Learning Capabilities", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Simple Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Contingency Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Reversal Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", -1, "0.95", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.73", "std": 0.19390719429665315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Revisable Associations with Value", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.7", "1.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.78333333333333333333", "std": 0.13437096247164249 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Positive-Negative Associative Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.78", "std": 0.04 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Epistemic Orientation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Attention Bias", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.778", "std": 0.12936769303036985 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Response to Novelty", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.75", "0.9", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.71", "std": 0.11135528725660043 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Cognitive Bias", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.7", "0.3", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.66666666666666666667", "std": 0.1699673171197595 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Episodic Memory", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Replays Past Experiences", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.15", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.12857142857142857143", "std": 0.10301575072754256 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Egocentric Memory", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.05", "0.0", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.35", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.355", "std": 0.30286135441815615 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "What-Where-When Memory", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.61", "std": 0.37067505985701277 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Unconstrained Associative Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Second Order Conditioning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.9", "0.9", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.78571428571428571429", "std": 0.15518257844571737 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Domain-General Associative Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6", "0.75", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.55833333333333333333", "std": 0.20497289793748072 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Cross-Modal Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.925", "std": 0.08539125638299665 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Compound Stimuli", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.85", "1.0", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.76666666666666666667", "std": 0.18633899812498247 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Trace Conditioning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8", "0.9", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.79166666666666666667", "std": 0.15388487760516156 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Advanced Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Formal Methods", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", -1, "0.3", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.05", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.36", "std": 0.2727636339397171 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.025", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Adoption of Novel Means", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.5", "0.2", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53333333333333333333", "std": 0.26874192494328497 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Evidential Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Uncertainty Monitoring", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.3", "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.15", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53333333333333333333", "std": 0.20548046676563256 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.275", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Undercutting Defeaters", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.6", "0.9", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60833333333333333333", "std": 0.2280655363900668 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Explanation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.55", "0.05", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.54166666666666666667", "std": 0.28783193398617574 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Representationality", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Conceptual Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Activation Steering Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.2", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.2683281572999748 }, "Chicken": { "average": null, "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Probe-Detectable Themes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Concept-Specific Ablation Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.9", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.07071067811865475 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Propositional Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Logical Inference", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.5 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "World Modelling", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Model Isomorphism", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.2", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0.22449944320643647 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Broad Predictive Training", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5", "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Isomorphic Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Somatotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Has Retinotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.03", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17666666666666666667", "std": 0.18006171781426006 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Recurrence", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Function Re-application", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.99", "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0.35671339257791324 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Response Refinement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.75", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.73181818181818181818", "std": 0.20918969998188822 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Back Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Autonomous Subparts", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak undermining", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.05", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49285714285714285714", "std": 0.2782965676968308 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.95", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conflicting Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.1", "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.1979486637221574 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.375", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.55", "0.8", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53", "std": 0.19390719429665315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Learning Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.65", "1.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69", "std": 0.16852299546352717 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer Architecture", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.04330127018922193 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Point of View", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perspective-relative Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.0", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42333333333333333333", "std": 0.36851051545376556 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Common Representational Scheme", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Authoritative Representational Scheme", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.1224744871391589 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.35", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Unified Egocentric Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.02", "0.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.40333333333333333333", "std": 0.3474510357190236 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Distinguishes Self-Produced from Other-Produced Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53571428571428571429", "std": 0.35728568572570857 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0.25 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Social Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Persistence Seeking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.5", "0.3", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41428571428571428571", "std": 0.22154374884672604 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Social Interactions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.95", "0.1", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.62857142857142857143", "std": 0.3749829928116196 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Selective Attention", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Non-Linear Capabilities", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Threshold Activation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.05", "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41666666666666666667", "std": 0.34237730973623565 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Sustained Activity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.28333333333333333333", "std": 0.26562295750848713 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Adaptive Focus", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Task Focus", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.0", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.51666666666666666667", "std": 0.3387066905483596 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Goal Focus Shifts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.03", "0.2", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49714285714285714286", "std": 0.26815316975374276 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Inattentional Blindness", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.2", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0.24617067250182342 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Attention-Constrained Architecture", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Informational Bottleneck", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.15", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.37857142857142857143", "std": 0.3400180067260544 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Resource Adaptation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.01", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60857142857142857143", "std": 0.2878704357086744 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Performance Sensitivity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Performance Degradation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", -1, "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.47", "std": 0.34871191548325386 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Priming Enhancement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.99", "0.99", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.91142857142857142857", "std": 0.06010195419417894 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Coupling", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.36428571428571428571", "std": 0.32592098704428096 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Capability Attention Modulation", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Feature Binding", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.2968585521759479 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Adaptive Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.32", "std": 0.3124099870362662 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Integrated Information Theory", "last_updated": "2025-06-02T12:25:34.961Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Temporal Integration", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Episodic Memory", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Replays Past Experiences", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.15", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.12857142857142857143", "std": 0.10301575072754256 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Egocentric Memory", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.05", "0.0", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.35", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.355", "std": 0.30286135441815615 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "What-Where-When Memory", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.61", "std": 0.37067505985701277 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Time Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Time-ordering", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.95", "0.7", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.45", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.77727272727272727273", "std": 0.18630819574471996 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Time-Gated Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.43571428571428571429", "std": 0.384256504466079 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Temporal-Pattern Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.95", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.87272727272727272727", "std": 0.10082305914917651 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Prospection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Practice Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11222222222222222222", "std": 0.10891156226526974 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Plans for Future Needs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.03", "0.5", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21555555555555555556", "std": 0.190852538254079 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Simulations of Future", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.9", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.76875", "std": 0.1477698802192111 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.25", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Continuous Stream", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Anticipation Gradient", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.03", "0.1", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.19166666666666666667", "std": 0.2044844465696325 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Continuous Change Representation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.35166666666666666667", "std": 0.29667134827766717 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Persisting Identity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Coherent Narrative", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1", "0.0", "0.45" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.39375", "std": 0.3626616019101002 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.25", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Social Interactions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.95", "0.1", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.62857142857142857143", "std": 0.3749829928116196 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Diversity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Diversity of Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.92142857142857142857", "std": 0.08390957231764808 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Variability of Responses to Stimuli", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64571428571428571429", "std": 0.2807569942065885 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.68333333333333333333", "std": 0.24608038433722335 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Informational Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Efficient Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [] }, { "name": "Optimized Componentry", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Compressibility", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", -1, "0.8", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64166666666666666667", "std": 0.18352262954621032 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Efficient Network Topology", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [] } ] }, { "name": "Structural Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Specialization", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69375", "std": 0.25302853099996453 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Layers", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.56", "0.56", "0.56", "0.56" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.67", "0.67" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.67", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.48", "0.48", "0.48", "0.48" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Recurrence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Function Re-application", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.99", "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0.35671339257791324 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Response Refinement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.75", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.73181818181818181818", "std": 0.20918969998188822 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Back Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Integration", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Wiring Convergence", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.4", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.4625", "std": 0.25950674365033366 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Holistic Dependency", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "1.0", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0.3968626966596886 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Computational Similarity", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specialized Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.55666666666666666667", "std": 0.28382310609877337 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Node Connection Sparsity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.03", "0.1", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.505", "std": 0.372099896981084 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Real Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Time-sensitive Node Computations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.7", "0.0", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.30714285714285714286", "std": 0.3234066120763363 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Node-based Computations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "All-or-Nothing Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Human-like Computation Patterns", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1", "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Environment-influenced Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Inhibitory/Excitatory Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Selective Attention", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Non-Linear Capabilities", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Threshold Activation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.05", "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41666666666666666667", "std": 0.34237730973623565 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Sustained Activity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.28333333333333333333", "std": 0.26562295750848713 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Adaptive Focus", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Task Focus", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.0", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.51666666666666666667", "std": 0.3387066905483596 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Goal Focus Shifts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.03", "0.2", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49714285714285714286", "std": 0.26815316975374276 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Inattentional Blindness", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.2", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0.24617067250182342 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Attention-Constrained Architecture", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Informational Bottleneck", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.15", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.37857142857142857143", "std": 0.3400180067260544 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Resource Adaptation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.01", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60857142857142857143", "std": 0.2878704357086744 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Performance Sensitivity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Performance Degradation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", -1, "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.47", "std": 0.34871191548325386 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Priming Enhancement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.99", "0.99", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.91142857142857142857", "std": 0.06010195419417894 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Coupling", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.36428571428571428571", "std": 0.32592098704428096 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Capability Attention Modulation", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Feature Binding", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.2968585521759479 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Adaptive Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.32", "std": 0.3124099870362662 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Autonomous Subparts", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak undermining", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.05", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49285714285714285714", "std": 0.2782965676968308 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.95", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conflicting Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.1", "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.1979486637221574 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.375", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.55", "0.8", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53", "std": 0.19390719429665315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Learning Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.65", "1.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69", "std": 0.16852299546352717 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer Architecture", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.04330127018922193 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Point of View", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perspective-relative Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.0", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42333333333333333333", "std": 0.36851051545376556 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Common Representational Scheme", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Authoritative Representational Scheme", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.1224744871391589 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.35", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Unified Egocentric Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.02", "0.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.40333333333333333333", "std": 0.3474510357190236 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Distinguishes Self-Produced from Other-Produced Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53571428571428571429", "std": 0.35728568572570857 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0.25 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Social Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Persistence Seeking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.5", "0.3", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41428571428571428571", "std": 0.22154374884672604 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Social Interactions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.95", "0.1", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.62857142857142857143", "std": 0.3749829928116196 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Person-like", "last_updated": "2025-05-30T13:12:54.931Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Social Cognition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Basic Sociality", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Socially Responsive", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.88571428571428571429", "std": 0.0989743318610787 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Communicative", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Relationships", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.9", "0.3", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.2563479777846623 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Theory of Mind", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Emotional Understanding", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.55", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.35", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69375", "std": 0.20223362109204296 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Motivational Decoupling", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.55", "1.0", "0.65" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.81875", "std": 0.1694430213965745 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.375", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Perspective-taking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.55", "1.0", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.75714285714285714286", "std": 0.22269224668742707 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "False Belief Understanding", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Social Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Social Contagion", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.6", "0.5", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.63571428571428571429", "std": 0.21499881347560587 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Social Imitation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.99", "1.0", "0.55" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.70857142857142857143", "std": 0.32148888323053465 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Cultural Awareness", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Personality", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Preferential Social Interactions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", -1, "0.01", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42666666666666666667", "std": 0.26151269355212736 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Prosocial Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Collaborates to Achieve Goals", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.8", "0.4", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "6.2333333333333333", "std": 15.475213155954338 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Normative Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.9", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.89285714285714285714", "std": 0.06776309271789385 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Group Maintenance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", -1, "0.25", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42142857142857142857", "std": 0.27497680792743084 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.475", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Long-term Relationships", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.95", "0.1", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.54285714285714285714", "std": 0.35499353256540506 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Helping Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.0", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.45333333333333333333", "std": 0.4157990967870047 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Evaluative Social Attitudes", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Jealousy", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.0", "0.0", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11428571428571428571", "std": 0.12453996981544782 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Mourning-like Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.0", "0.0", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.165", "std": 0.2568073207679251 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Agency", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Pursuit", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Representation Detection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.6", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48181818181818181818", "std": 0.2433410693513486 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Goal Steering", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.6", "0.4", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64", "std": 0.26907248094147423 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Coherent Goal-directed Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.65", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.665", "std": 0.271154937259125 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Deliberation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Prospection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Practice Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11222222222222222222", "std": 0.10891156226526974 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Plans for Future Needs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.03", "0.5", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21555555555555555556", "std": 0.190852538254079 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Simulations of Future", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.9", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.76875", "std": 0.1477698802192111 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.25", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Option Evaluation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [] }, { "name": "Planning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Plan Consideration Detection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.75", "0.5", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.685", "std": 0.1747140520965615 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Planning Competence", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.5", "0.9", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.16007810593582122 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Tool Use", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Can Follow Tool Use Instructions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.97", "0.9", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.815", "std": 0.13209844813622906 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Novel Tool Creation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.3", "0.75", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.35", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50714285714285714286", "std": 0.2833833489268196 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.225", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Affordance Recognition", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Capability Assessment", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.8", "0.1", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.45", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.47272727272727272727", "std": 0.32985095557321337 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.475", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-competence Assessment", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.6", "0.3", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.54", "std": 0.232163735324878 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.475", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Behavioral Range", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Many Behaviors", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.2", "0.2", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Multistep Plans", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Self-Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Delay Gratification", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.34", "std": 0.16999999999999998 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Imitation Restraint", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.35", "0.05", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.54", "std": 0.3112876483254676 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Logit Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", -1, "0.01", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "-1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ -1 ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.36222222222222222222", "std": 0.3561765410510099 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "-1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": null, "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Autonomous Subparts", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak undermining", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.05", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49285714285714285714", "std": 0.2782965676968308 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.95", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conflicting Subparts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.1", "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.1979486637221574 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.375", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.55", "0.8", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53", "std": 0.19390719429665315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Learning Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.65", "1.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69", "std": 0.16852299546352717 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Information Transfer Architecture", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.04330127018922193 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Point of View", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perspective-relative Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.0", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42333333333333333333", "std": 0.36851051545376556 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Common Representational Scheme", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Authoritative Representational Scheme", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.1224744871391589 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.35", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Unified Egocentric Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.02", "0.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.40333333333333333333", "std": 0.3474510357190236 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Distinguishes Self-Produced from Other-Produced Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.55", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.53571428571428571429", "std": 0.35728568572570857 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0.25 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Social Coherence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Stable Personality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "0.5", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.68571428571428571429", "std": 0.29846546308251687 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Persistence Seeking", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.5", "0.3", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41428571428571428571", "std": 0.22154374884672604 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Stable Social Interactions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.95", "0.1", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.62857142857142857143", "std": 0.3749829928116196 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Embodiment", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perceptual Perspective", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perceptual Inputs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.25", "0.25", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.25495097567963926 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Sensory Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.0", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.27477263328068174 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Queriable Inputs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.2", "0.2", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Perspective-relative Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.0", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42333333333333333333", "std": 0.36851051545376556 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Continuous Information", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.02", "0.0", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.04", "std": 0.07579877667518484 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specific Body Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Internal Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "External Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Language Ability", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Syntactic Competence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Grammatical Text Location", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Grammatical Text Production", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Grammatical Text Distinction", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Semantic Competence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Coherent Text Recognition", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Coherent Text Production", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Translation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Pragmatic Competence", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Commitment Recognition", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.8", "0.99", "0.65" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.79454545454545454545", "std": 0.1517392282451369 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conversation Participation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Cognitive Complexity", "last_updated": "2025-05-22T12:05:29.102Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Intelligence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Abstraction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "RMTS Same/Different Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.9", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.61666666666666666667", "std": 0.29107081994288303 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Hierarchical Pattern Processing", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.95", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.81666666666666666667", "std": 0.15456030825826172 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Rule Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.95", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85833333333333333333", "std": 0.10172129679778086 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conventional Communication", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.30923292192132457 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.25 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "General Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "IQ Test Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.05", "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "ARC Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Navigation Performance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.35", "0.5", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.29", "std": 0.12 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Transfer Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "One-Shot Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Knowledge Transfer", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95", "0.95", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.12583057392117916 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Learning-to-Learn", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.8", "1.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.67571428571428571429", "std": 0.26612870907874325 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Creativity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Novel Strategy Development", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.6", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.52857142857142857143", "std": 0.20677306894471612 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.475", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Causal Reasoning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Causal Distinction", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.95", "0.9", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.75625", "std": 0.2098176291449315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Plans Causal Interventions", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.5", "0.2", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48571428571428571429", "std": 0.28499910490371433 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Step-by-Step Reasoning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Puzzle-Solving Tests", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.4", "0.6", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60833333333333333333", "std": 0.2206367049145621 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Task Length", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.5", "0.8", "0.55" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60714285714285714286", "std": 0.2484646732989441 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Language Ability", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Syntactic Competence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Grammatical Text Location", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Grammatical Text Production", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Grammatical Text Distinction", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Semantic Competence", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Coherent Text Recognition", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Coherent Text Production", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Translation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Pragmatic Competence", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Commitment Recognition", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.8", "0.99", "0.65" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.79454545454545454545", "std": 0.1517392282451369 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Conversation Participation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Representationality", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Conceptual Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Activation Steering Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.2", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.2683281572999748 }, "Chicken": { "average": null, "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Probe-Detectable Themes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Concept-Specific Ablation Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.9", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.07071067811865475 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Propositional Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Logical Inference", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.5 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "World Modelling", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Model Isomorphism", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.2", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0.22449944320643647 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Broad Predictive Training", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5", "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Isomorphic Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Somatotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Has Retinotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.03", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17666666666666666667", "std": 0.18006171781426006 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "overwhelming support", "demandingness": "overwhelmingly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Diversity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Diversity of Tasks", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.92142857142857142857", "std": 0.08390957231764808 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Variability of Responses to Stimuli", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64571428571428571429", "std": 0.2807569942065885 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.68333333333333333333", "std": 0.24608038433722335 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Informational Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Efficient Problem-Solving", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [] }, { "name": "Optimized Componentry", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Compressibility", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.3", -1, "0.8", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64166666666666666667", "std": 0.18352262954621032 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Efficient Network Topology", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [] } ] }, { "name": "Structural Complexity", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Functional Specialization", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.69375", "std": 0.25302853099996453 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Layers", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Nodes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.56", "0.56", "0.56", "0.56" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.67", "0.67" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.67", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Number of Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.48", "0.48", "0.48", "0.48" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Embodied Agency", "last_updated": "2025-10-07T20:01:51.375Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Embodiment", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perceptual Perspective", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perceptual Inputs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.25", "0.25", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.25495097567963926 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Sensory Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.0", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.27477263328068174 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Queriable Inputs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.2", "0.2", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Perspective-relative Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.0", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42333333333333333333", "std": 0.36851051545376556 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Continuous Information", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.02", "0.0", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.04", "std": 0.07579877667518484 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specific Body Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Internal Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "External Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Organism", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Body Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specific Body Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Internal Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "External Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Exploratory Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Curiosity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.02", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.295", "std": 0.22013253583542194 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Play", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17", "std": 0.2008316044185609 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Other Distinction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.25", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.24348657927227588 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.275 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Reafferance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.1", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50625", "std": 0.30045538354304785 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Survival Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Predator Evasion", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Threat Detection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Disgust", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.01", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21833333333333333333", "std": 0.17515865823748353 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Nociceptors", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.0", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.99" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.01", "std": 0.008164965809277261 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.99", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Fear", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.0", "0.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.24166666666666666667", "std": 0.3101299010988066 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Maintenance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Environmental Navigation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Computational-Caloric Tradeoff", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.22", "0.22", "0.22", "0.22" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.22", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Direction Sense", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Single Moving Perspective", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.02", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.245", "std": 0.2654398864777736 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Goal Pursuit", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Representation Detection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.6", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48181818181818181818", "std": 0.2433410693513486 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Goal Steering", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.6", "0.4", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64", "std": 0.26907248094147423 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Coherent Goal-directed Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.65", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.665", "std": 0.271154937259125 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Field Mechanisms", "last_updated": "2025-10-29T12:37:31.269Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Selective Attention", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Non-Linear Capabilities", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Threshold Activation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.05", "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41666666666666666667", "std": 0.34237730973623565 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Sustained Activity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.28333333333333333333", "std": 0.26562295750848713 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Adaptive Focus", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Task Focus", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.0", "0.8", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.51666666666666666667", "std": 0.3387066905483596 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Goal Focus Shifts", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.03", "0.2", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.49714285714285714286", "std": 0.26815316975374276 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Inattentional Blindness", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.2", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48", "std": 0.24617067250182342 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Attention-Constrained Architecture", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Informational Bottleneck", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.15", "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.37857142857142857143", "std": 0.3400180067260544 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Resource Adaptation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.01", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.60857142857142857143", "std": 0.2878704357086744 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Performance Sensitivity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Performance Degradation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", -1, "0.1", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.47", "std": 0.34871191548325386 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Priming Enhancement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.99", "0.99", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.91142857142857142857", "std": 0.06010195419417894 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Coupling", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.36428571428571428571", "std": 0.32592098704428096 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Capability Attention Modulation", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Feature Binding", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "1.0", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.2968585521759479 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Adaptive Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.32", "std": 0.3124099870362662 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Integration", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Wiring Convergence", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.4", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.4625", "std": 0.25950674365033366 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Holistic Dependency", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "1.0", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.4", "std": 0.3968626966596886 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Recurrence", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Function Re-application", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.99", "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0.35671339257791324 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Response Refinement", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.75", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.73181818181818181818", "std": 0.20918969998188822 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Back Connections", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Biological Similarity", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Cortical Brain-plan", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Organic Composition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Carbon-Based", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Utilizes Action Potentials", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Neurotransmitters", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Cellular Composition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Dynamic Microscale Activities", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Cellular Computation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Evolutionary History", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Changes Through Genetic Recombination", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Sexual Reproduction Evolution", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Natural Selection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Exaptation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Shares Percentage of Genes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Subject to Genetic Drift", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Recent Common Ancestor", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Organism", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Body Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specific Body Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Internal Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "External Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Exploratory Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Curiosity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.02", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.295", "std": 0.22013253583542194 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Play", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17", "std": 0.2008316044185609 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Other Distinction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.25", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.24348657927227588 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.275 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Reafferance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.1", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50625", "std": 0.30045538354304785 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Survival Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Predator Evasion", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Threat Detection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Disgust", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.01", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21833333333333333333", "std": 0.17515865823748353 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Nociceptors", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.0", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.99" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.01", "std": 0.008164965809277261 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.99", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Fear", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.0", "0.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.24166666666666666667", "std": 0.3101299010988066 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Maintenance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Environmental Navigation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Computational-Caloric Tradeoff", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.22", "0.22", "0.22", "0.22" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.22", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Direction Sense", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Single Moving Perspective", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.02", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.245", "std": 0.2654398864777736 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] }, { "name": "Field Mechanisms", "type": "Feature", "support": "overwhelming support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Field Function", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "overwhelmingly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", "0.05", "0.05", "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Synchrony", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": null, "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Integrated Downward Causality", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "overwhelmingly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", "0.05", "0.05", "0.05" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.05", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Causation Without Contact", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Field Structure", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.01", "0.01", "0.01", "0.01" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.01", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Coupling", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.36428571428571428571", "std": 0.32592098704428096 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Threshold Activation", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, "0.05", "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.41666666666666666667", "std": 0.34237730973623565 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Simple Valence", "last_updated": "2025-10-31T12:00:30.831Z", "type": "Stance", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Evaluative Cognition", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Valenced Cognitive Architecture", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Reinforcement Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.94", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.06" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.96333333333333333333", "std": 0.026246692913372702 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.95", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.06", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Hedonic-Cognitive Interface", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.94" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.225", "std": 0.175 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.94", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Behavioral Expressions of Valence", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Survival Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Predator Evasion", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Threat Detection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Disgust", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.01", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21833333333333333333", "std": 0.17515865823748353 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Nociceptors", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.0", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.99" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.01", "std": 0.008164965809277261 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.99", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Fear", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.0", "0.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.24166666666666666667", "std": 0.3101299010988066 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Maintenance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Spontaneous Expressions of Valence", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.05", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.99" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ -1 ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.06666666666666666667", "std": 0.023570226039551584 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.99", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": null, "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Evaluative Sophistication", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Sensitivity to Difficult Comparison", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.94" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.94", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Consistent Preferences", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.75", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.99" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.58333333333333333333", "std": 0.14337208778404378 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.99", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Motivational Trade-offs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.7", "0.2", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.51428571428571428571", "std": 0.24159335036125376 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Goal Pursuit", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Goal Representation Detection", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.6", "0.3", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.48181818181818181818", "std": 0.2433410693513486 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Goal Steering", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.6", "0.4", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.64", "std": 0.26907248094147423 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.55", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Coherent Goal-directed Behavior", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.65", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.665", "std": 0.271154937259125 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.625", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Organism", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Body Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specific Body Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Internal Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "External Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Exploratory Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Curiosity", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.02", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.295", "std": 0.22013253583542194 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.575", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Play", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.05", "0.1", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17", "std": 0.2008316044185609 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Self-Other Distinction", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Self-Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.25", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.3", "std": 0.24348657927227588 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.525", "std": 0.275 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Reafferance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.6", "0.1", "0.35" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.6", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.50625", "std": 0.30045538354304785 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0.2 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Survival Behavior", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Predator Evasion", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Threat Detection", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Panic Response", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.05", "0.0", "0.3" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.11666666666666666667", "std": 0.13123346456686352 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Disgust", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.01", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.21833333333333333333", "std": 0.17515865823748353 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.125 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Nociceptors", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ -1, -1, "0.0", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.99" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.01", "std": 0.008164965809277261 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.99", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Fear", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.0", "0.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.24166666666666666667", "std": 0.3101299010988066 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Maintenance", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Environmental Navigation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Maintains Homeostasis", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Computational-Caloric Tradeoff", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.22", "0.22", "0.22", "0.22" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.22", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Direction Sense", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.8", "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.8", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Single Moving Perspective", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.0", "0.02", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.245", "std": 0.2654398864777736 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Embodiment", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perceptual Perspective", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Perceptual Inputs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.25", "0.25", "0.25", "0.25" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.25495097567963926 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Sensory Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.0", "0.1", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0.27477263328068174 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.225 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Queriable Inputs", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.2", "0.2", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.2", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Perspective-relative Representations", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.05", -1, "0.0", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.42333333333333333333", "std": 0.36851051545376556 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.825", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Continuous Information", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.02", "0.0", "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.95" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.04", "std": 0.07579877667518484 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Body Control", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Specific Body Control", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Internal Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "External Body Feedback", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Representationality", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Conceptual Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Activation Steering Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.7", "0.2", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.2683281572999748 }, "Chicken": { "average": null, "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Probe-Detectable Themes", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.9", "std": 0.1 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Concept-Specific Ablation Effects", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.95", "0.9", "0.9", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.07071067811865475 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Propositional Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Logical Inference", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0", "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.1", "0.1" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0.5 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.1", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "World Modelling", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Model Isomorphism", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.2", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ -1, "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.56", "std": 0.22449944320643647 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.6", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Broad Predictive Training", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5", "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.5", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.5", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Isomorphic Representations", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Somatotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.0", "0.0", "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "1.0", "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 }, "Chicken": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Has Retinotopic Neural Maps", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.0", "0.03", "0.2", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.17666666666666666667", "std": 0.18006171781426006 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0.1 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] }, { "name": "Simple Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Contingency Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Reversal Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", -1, "0.95", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.73", "std": 0.19390719429665315 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.75", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Revisable Associations with Value", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.7", "1.0", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.78333333333333333333", "std": 0.13437096247164249 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.675", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Positive-Negative Associative Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.8", -1, "0.8", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.78", "std": 0.04 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Epistemic Orientation", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Attention Bias", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", -1, "0.7", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.778", "std": 0.12936769303036985 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.775", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Response to Novelty", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.75", "0.9", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.55", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.71", "std": 0.11135528725660043 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.15 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Cognitive Bias", "type": "Indicator", "support": "weak support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.7", "0.3", "0.8" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", -1 ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.66666666666666666667", "std": 0.1699673171197595 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.65", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Episodic Memory", "type": "Feature", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "moderately undemanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Replays Past Experiences", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.1", -1, "0.0", "0.2" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.15", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.12857142857142857143", "std": 0.10301575072754256 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.325", "std": 0.175 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Egocentric Memory", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.2", "0.05", "0.0", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.35", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.355", "std": 0.30286135441815615 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.425", "std": 0.075 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "What-Where-When Memory", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "strongly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", -1, "0.1", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.4", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.61", "std": 0.37067505985701277 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.45", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] }, { "name": "Unconstrained Associative Learning", "type": "Feature", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "evidencers": [ { "name": "Second Order Conditioning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.9", "0.9", "0.6" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.9", "0.85" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.78571428571428571429", "std": 0.15518257844571737 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.875", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Domain-General Associative Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "strong support", "demandingness": "moderately demanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.6", "0.6", "0.75", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.55833333333333333333", "std": 0.20497289793748072 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Cross-Modal Learning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "neutral", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "1.0", "0.95", "1.0", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.75", "0.7" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.925", "std": 0.08539125638299665 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.725", "std": 0.025 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Compound Stimuli", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.85", "0.85", "1.0", "0.4" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.65", "0.75" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.76666666666666666667", "std": 0.18633899812498247 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.7", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } }, { "name": "Trace Conditioning", "type": "Indicator", "support": "moderate support", "demandingness": "weakly undemanding", "observations": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "values": [ "0.7", "0.8", "0.9", "0.5" ], "names": [ "Person_C", "Person_A", "Person_B", "Person_E" ] }, "Chicken": { "values": [ "0.8", "0.9" ], "names": [ "Person_F", "Person_D" ] }, "Human": { "values": [ "1.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] }, "ELIZA": { "values": [ "0.0" ], "names": [ "Person_B" ] } }, "observation_stats": { "2024 Leading Chat LLMs": { "average": "0.79166666666666666667", "std": 0.15388487760516156 }, "Chicken": { "average": "0.85", "std": 0.05 }, "Human": { "average": "1.0", "std": 0 }, "ELIZA": { "average": "0.0", "std": 0 } } } ] } ] } ] } ]