{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 106, "image_id": "514829e2-729d-48dc-aa17-55f40d33e4bc", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows an open Bible with two visible facing pages.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows an open book with two facing pages visible."}, {"statement": "Most of the visible body text on the pages is rendered in Hebrew script.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The body text on both pages is composed of Hebrew characters."}, {"statement": "The framing is a close-up view in which the open Bible occupies most of the image.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The open book fills almost the entire frame."}, {"statement": "One of the two visible pages contains a picture of exactly five people: one king, one queen, and three other men.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "The left page shows a king, a queen, and two other men, totaling four people, not five."}, {"statement": "A different visible page contains a picture of exactly two elderly people: one old man and one old woman.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "The right page shows two elderly men with beards, not an old man and an old woman."}, {"statement": "The background surrounding the Bible is predominantly dark.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The area behind and around the book is black."}, {"statement": "The visible pages and their printed imagery use a predominantly white or light-toned palette.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pages are white/light-toned, and the illustrations are essentially grayscale."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry or anatomical artifacts in the book or human figures, such as fused pages, malformed hands, or distorted faces.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The figures and the book's geometry appear well-rendered without obvious anatomical anomalies."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated external objects, watermarks, or logos that are not part of the Bible scene described in the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No external objects or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned figures, ornaments, or page elements that appear copy-pasted.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The illustrations and text elements do not appear copy-pasted."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, inconsistent, or unreadable rendered text or glyphs in the page writing or headings.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The English headers ('Btu: Bible' and 'liller Bible') are garbled and inconsistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent with a real photographed open book.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows on the pages are plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the paper pages, printed artwork, and surrounding background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials and textures are distinct and properly separated."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 25, "total_positive_weight_possible": 37, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model failed to accurately depict the requested characters in the illustrations and included garbled English text headers.", "net_score": 20, "final_score": 54.1}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 106, "image_id": "514829e2-729d-48dc-aa17-55f40d33e4bc", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The Bible is shown in a close-up view that fills most of the frame.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The opened Bible dominates the image, taking up nearly the entire frame."}, {"statement": "The visible page text uses recognizably Hebrew characters rather than Latin alphabet letters.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the pages resembles a garbled Gothic or blackletter Latin script, not Hebrew characters."}, {"statement": "One visible page contains a printed picture with exactly five human figures.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "The visible picture contains exactly three human figures, not five."}, {"statement": "In that five-figure picture, one figure is marked as the king by wearing a crown or similar royal headpiece.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "One figure in the illustration is wearing a prominent crown."}, {"statement": "In that five-figure picture, exactly one adult woman appears beside the crowned figure.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is one adult woman depicted standing beside the crowned king."}, {"statement": "In that five-figure picture, exactly three other adult men appear besides the crowned figure and the woman.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There is only one other adult man visible behind the king, not three."}, {"statement": "The opposite page contains a separate printed picture with exactly two elderly people: one man and one woman.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The left page contains only text and lacks any illustration of an old man and woman."}, {"statement": "The scene uses light-toned Bible pages contrasted against a dark background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bright, yellowish-white pages stand out against the very dark, muted background."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The human figures in the page pictures exhibit anatomical distortions such as fused hands, extra fingers, missing features, or warped faces.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The hands of the king and the woman are fused and distorted, forming an indistinct lump."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, modern items, watermarks, logos, or unrelated text that are not part of the described Bible scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No modern items, watermarks, or unrelated extraneous objects are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or mirrored people within the printed pictures, suggesting cloned figures rather than distinct individuals.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The three figures shown are visually distinct individuals."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or nonsensical rendered text or glyphs on the Bible pages or around the printed pictures.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The dense block of text on the left page and headers are entirely nonsensical, garbled glyphs."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows across the pages, printed pictures, or background that do not match a consistent light source.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting across the open book appears relatively consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where paper, printed pictures, and text blend together unnaturally.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures of the paper and the illustration remain distinct without unnatural smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 21, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 4, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The model failed to generate the second illustration entirely, merged the requested figures into a single incorrect scene, and produced garbled Latin-style text instead of Hebrew.", "net_score": 9, "final_score": 16.4}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 106, "image_id": "514829e2-729d-48dc-aa17-55f40d33e4bc", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows an open book with two visible pages.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An open book with two visible facing pages is centrally located in the image."}, {"statement": "The printed writing on the visible pages is rendered in Hebrew script.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on both pages is rendered using Hebrew-like characters."}, {"statement": "The open book occupies most of the frame in a close-up composition.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The book takes up the vast majority of the image frame in a close-up shot."}, {"statement": "The visible pages are predominantly white or light-toned.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pages of the book are white."}, {"statement": "One visible page contains a single inset image showing exactly five people: a king, a queen, and three additional adult men.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "The left page has an inset image showing four men (one possibly a king), but no queen, missing the count and specific characters requested."}, {"statement": "The other visible page contains a single inset image showing exactly two people: one elderly man and one elderly woman.", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The right page shows two elderly men, not an elderly man and an elderly woman."}, {"statement": "The background surrounding the book is predominantly dark-toned.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background outside the book is dark."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or facial artifacts in the people shown in the inset images, such as fused hands, extra fingers, or distorted eyes.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The hands of the men on the left page are slightly morphed and lacking detail."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a prominent extraneous object, person, logo, or watermark outside the open book and its inset images.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is an unrequested ornate object (possibly a lamp or stand) in the background above the book."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned human figures or repeated inset-image elements that appear copy-pasted.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious duplicated or cloned figures in the inset images."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered text or glyphs in the page writing or captions.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The Hebrew script consists of garbled, illegible pseudo-characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the pages, inset images, or surrounding surfaces.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally plausible for a studio shot."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the paper, printed text, and inset images.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials and boundaries between paper, text, and images are distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 31, "total_positive_weight_possible": 46, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -16, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The model failed to generate the correct characters in the inset images (missing the queen and elderly woman) and produced garbled text.", "net_score": 15, "final_score": 32.6}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 106, "image_id": "514829e2-729d-48dc-aa17-55f40d33e4bc", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is a close-up or zoomed-in view of a Bible opened to two visible pages.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An open book with two visible pages is prominently featured in a close-up perspective."}, {"statement": "The visible writing on the open Bible pages is rendered in Hebrew script.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the pages of the open book consists of Hebrew letters."}, {"statement": "One open page contains a photo or illustration with exactly five people.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "The left page has a photo containing four people, not five."}, {"statement": "The five-person page includes one male figure in royal attire and one female figure in royal attire.", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is a male in royal attire and a female in royal attire, but they are on a four-person page, not a five-person page."}, {"statement": "The three non-royal figures on the five-person page are adult men.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are only two non-royal men on the left page photo."}, {"statement": "The opposite open page contains a photo or illustration with exactly two people.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right page has a photo showing two people."}, {"statement": "The two-person page depicts an elderly man paired with a woman.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The photo on the right page shows an older man and a woman."}, {"statement": "The Bible pages are predominantly light or white in tone relative to a dark surrounding background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pages are light-colored and stand out against the darker wood and stone background."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts in the people shown in the page photographs, such as fused hands, missing body parts, or distorted facial features.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The people depicted in the photos appear anatomically normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The image includes an extra closed book and a candle, which were not requested."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or mirrored human figures within a page photograph, indicating cloning artifacts not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no mirroring or duplication of figures in the photos."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered text or glyphs in the Hebrew page text or any visible book title.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Much of the Hebrew text on the pages and the closed book cover is garbled or pseudotext."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the book, pages, and surrounding scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting from the candle appropriately illuminates the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the paper pages, printed photographs, and book surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures remain distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 37, "total_positive_weight_possible": 58, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 3, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The model failed to generate the correct number of people on the left page and included hallucinated objects like a candle and an extra book.", "net_score": 25, "final_score": 43.1}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 302, "image_id": "872a9294-871a-439d-b1a0-6c27444238e3", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three distinct building facades or building parts.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three distinct building sections visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The leftmost building part is visibly shorter than the middle building part.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The leftmost building part is taller than the middle building part."}, {"statement": "The leftmost building part has a beige wall.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The leftmost building section is beige."}, {"statement": "The middle building part includes a balcony decorated with red flowers.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The middle building section has a balcony with red flowers on the railing."}, {"statement": "The balcony level of the middle building part has exactly two doors.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two doors opening onto the balcony."}, {"statement": "The two balcony-level doors visibly use maroon, green, and white as their colors.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The doors are colored maroon and green, with white trim."}, {"statement": "The rightmost building part includes at least one white window framed in light blue.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rightmost building has a white window with a light blue frame."}, {"statement": "A cloudy sky is visible in the background above the buildings.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A cloudy sky is visible in the upper background."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible architectural geometry, such as warped wall planes, non-rectangular door or window frames, or a balcony structure that cannot physically attach to the facade.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The architectural elements are straight and physically sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous fixtures or signage not implied by the prompt, such as utility boxes, meters, plaques, cables, watermarks, or logos.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is a small utility box or plaque and a number plate '5' on the lower right facade."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned flower clusters, doors, lanterns, or windows.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning artifacts are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on any visible plaque, meter, sign, or label.", "weight": -2, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The small label/box on the lower right has illegible markings."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits harsh or contradictory shadows that are physically inconsistent with the cloudy sky shown in the scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "There are very distinct, harsh shadows cast by the lanterns despite the overcast sky."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding or texture smearing where the flowers meet the balcony railing, doors, or walls.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The flowers are rendered cleanly against the surrounding elements."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 46, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -9, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The leftmost building is taller instead of shorter, and the image includes unprompted fixtures with garbled text and inconsistent harsh shadows.", "net_score": 37, "final_score": 71.2}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 302, "image_id": "872a9294-871a-439d-b1a0-6c27444238e3", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three adjacent building sections.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three distinct building facades shown side-by-side."}, {"statement": "The top of the left building section sits lower than the top of the middle building section.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The roofline of the left building is clearly lower than the peak of the middle building."}, {"statement": "The top of the right building section reaches approximately the same height as the top of the middle building section.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The right building's roof is noticeably lower than the middle building's roof peak, matching the left building's height instead."}, {"statement": "The wall colors of the three building sections, from left to right, are beige, ivory, and ivory.", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "The right building's wall is light blue, not ivory."}, {"statement": "Each of the three building sections includes at least one lantern attached to its facade.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The right building has no lantern attached to its facade, though the middle one has multiple."}, {"statement": "Geranium flowers decorate the balcony on the middle building section.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are red flowers on the balconies of the middle building."}, {"statement": "The balcony on the middle building section contains exactly two doors.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are three doors on each balcony level of the middle building."}, {"statement": "The right building section includes a white window with a light-blue frame.", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "The window frame on the right building is white, while the wall itself is light blue."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible architectural geometry, such as bent rooflines, fused balcony rails, or distorted doors or windows.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The top balcony railing passes right through the middle red door, and the right building's lower window has an inconsistent pane structure."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, street signs, rendered text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements like people or text are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or cloned flower clusters or facade details with near-identical repeated patterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The middle building has an entire duplicated ground floor with an identical set of three doors and lanterns underneath the balcony."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits lighting or cast shadows whose directions are physically inconsistent across the buildings and sky.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent walls, frames, doors, flowers, or sky.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are clearly separated without bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 23, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -9, "failure_count": 5, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The model failed multiple explicit prompt constraints regarding colors, counts, and heights, and introduced major geometric errors like a balcony railing intersecting a door.", "net_score": 14, "final_score": 25.5}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 302, "image_id": "872a9294-871a-439d-b1a0-6c27444238e3", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three distinct building sections or facades.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three distinct building sections are clearly visible: one on the left, one in the middle, and one on the right."}, {"statement": "Exactly three wall-mounted lanterns are visible on the building sections.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "Only two lanterns are visible: one on the left building and one on the middle building; the right building does not have a lantern."}, {"statement": "The leftmost building section has a beige wall.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The wall of the leftmost building section is beige."}, {"statement": "The middle building section includes one balcony decorated with geranium flowers.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The middle building has a balcony adorned with what appear to be red geranium flowers."}, {"statement": "The middle building section shows exactly two doors positioned directly behind the balcony railing.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two doors are clearly visible behind the balcony railing on the middle building."}, {"statement": "Both doors on the middle building show maroon, green, and white coloring.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The doors on the middle building have maroon frames, green inner frames, and white panels."}, {"statement": "The rightmost building section includes a white window with a light-blue frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right building features a white window encased in a light-blue frame."}, {"statement": "The sky is visible in the background above the buildings.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A clear sky is visible in the background above the buildings."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or physically impossible architectural geometry, such as bent rooflines, malformed balcony railings, or distorted window frames.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The architectural geometry appears sound with straight lines and normal structures."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, signs, text, watermarks, logos, or unrelated street objects not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements like people, vehicles, or text are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits visibly duplicated or mirrored decorative elements, such as cloned flower clusters, railing motifs, or trim details.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The decorative elements and flower clusters look naturally varied without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting or shadows across the facades, lanterns, balcony, or window.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent elements such as walls, trim, flowers, railing, and window frame.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Colors and textures are sharply defined with no bleeding or smearing between elements."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 49, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The image is mostly accurate but misses a requested lantern on the rightmost building.", "net_score": 49, "final_score": 89.1}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 302, "image_id": "872a9294-871a-439d-b1a0-6c27444238e3", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three adjacent building sections.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three distinct building sections are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "From left to right, the building-height pattern is short, tall, tall, with the middle and right sections approximately equal in height.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The left building is shorter, while the middle and right buildings are taller and appear to be roughly the same height."}, {"statement": "From left to right, the wall-color pattern is beige, ivory, and ivory.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The leftmost wall is a darker beige, while the middle and right walls are a lighter, ivory color."}, {"statement": "Each of the three building sections includes one wall-mounted lantern.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A lantern is mounted on the wall of each of the three building sections."}, {"statement": "The middle building section includes a balcony decorated with red geranium flowers.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A balcony with red flowers (appearing to be geraniums) is present on the middle building section."}, {"statement": "The middle building section shows exactly two doors colored maroon, green, and white.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two doors on the middle building feature maroon frames, green panels, and white trim."}, {"statement": "The right building section shows a white window framed in light blue.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right building section contains a white window with a light blue frame."}, {"statement": "Dark, looming clouds are visible in the sky background above the buildings.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A sky with dark, looming clouds is visible behind the buildings."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible architectural geometry in the buildings, balcony, window, or lanterns.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The architecture appears structurally sound and well-rendered."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, signs, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or visibly cloned architectural elements or flower clusters that appear copy-pasted.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The elements, including the flowers, appear distinct and not copy-pasted."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow behavior that is inconsistent across the facades and cloudy sky.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent with the overcast sky."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent walls, doors, flowers, balcony elements, window, or lanterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are well-defined with no obvious bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 54, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 54, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 453, "image_id": "5cdcbaa0-50db-403d-b6b9-0b4a39fa29a2", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly three snail shells appear as the primary subjects above the reflection line.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three distinct snail shells are visible above the horizon line."}, {"statement": "Each of the three primary shells is visibly suspended in mid-air, with no visible support or contact with the reflective surface below.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three shells are floating above the reflective plane without physical supports."}, {"statement": "The background is a night sky that contains visible clouds.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background depicts a dark sky with clouds, stars, and a moon."}, {"statement": "Below the three floating shells, the image shows exactly three shell reflections.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three corresponding reflections on the surface below."}, {"statement": "Each shell reflection is vertically aligned beneath a corresponding shell, creating a mirror-like arrangement.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections align vertically with the floating shells."}, {"statement": "The shells are rendered with a weathered, rock-like surface texture that includes visible cracks or stone-like wear.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shells exhibit deep cracks and a rough, stony texture."}, {"statement": "The largest floating shell is positioned near the horizontal center of the composition.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The largest shell is centrally located."}, {"statement": "The two smaller floating shells are placed on opposite sides of the centered largest shell.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two smaller shells flank the central shell."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed shell geometry, such as fused coils, impossible spiral topology, or broken non-manifold openings.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The shell on the right is composed of two overlapping or fused spiral sections facing opposite directions."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, text, watermarks, logos, or structures not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned shell forms or repeated shell fragments that are not part of the three intended shells and their three reflections.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra shells or fragments beyond the main three and reflections."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or reflection behavior, such as reflections with mismatched scale, orientation, or brightness relative to the shells above.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Reflections are physically plausible and match the shells."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the shells, the sky, and the reflective surface.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and materials remain distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 55, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The generated image fulfills all positive criteria but exhibits a geometry artifact in the rightmost shell.", "net_score": 49, "final_score": 89.1}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 453, "image_id": "5cdcbaa0-50db-403d-b6b9-0b4a39fa29a2", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three primary snail shell forms before counting any reflections.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three distinct shells visible floating above the reflection line."}, {"statement": "The three primary shell forms are floating in mid-air with no visible support touching them.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The snails/shells are suspended in the air with no physical support."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly three mirrored shell reflections below the primary shell forms.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three distinct reflections corresponding to the three floating objects."}, {"statement": "The background is a nighttime sky.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background shows stars and a galaxy-like feature indicative of a night sky."}, {"statement": "Visible clouds are present in the sky background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Large, billowy clouds are visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The shell exteriors have a weathered, rock-like texture.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shells display cracked, rough, and weathered textures resembling rock."}, {"statement": "The largest shell is positioned near the center of the composition.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The central object is visibly larger than the two flanking it."}, {"statement": "The scene is viewed from roughly the same height as the shells, producing a head-on perspective.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective is straight on, showing the spirals and bodies directly."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts such as fused tentacles, extra tentacles, missing tentacles, or impossible shell-body connections.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The central snail's body appears flattened and oddly structured underneath the shell, lacking distinct tentacles."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous subject matter, such as full snail bodies, people, readable text, watermarks, or logos, that is not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The prompt asked for 'snail shells', but the image includes full snail bodies with flesh and tentacles."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned shells or reflections beyond the intended mirror pairings, with two non-corresponding instances sharing the same outline and texture pattern.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No erroneous cloning beyond the intended reflections is present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a shell reflection whose position, scale, or orientation is inconsistent with a mirror reflection of the shell above it.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections align correctly with the objects above them."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion at the boundaries between a shell, its reflection, and the sky.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between the objects, reflections, and sky are clean."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 55, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The model successfully captured the requested composition and textures, but hallucinated full snail bodies instead of just the requested shells, introducing some anatomical artifacts in the process.", "net_score": 43, "final_score": 78.2}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 453, "image_id": "5cdcbaa0-50db-403d-b6b9-0b4a39fa29a2", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three snail shells that are not reflections.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are four distinct snail shells floating in mid-air, not three."}, {"statement": "All three non-reflected snail shells are depicted floating in mid-air rather than touching a visible supporting surface.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The four non-reflected shells are all floating above the reflective surface."}, {"statement": "The background is a night sky with visible clouds.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background features a cloudy sky, although it appears more like twilight or dusk than a deep night sky, clouds are visible."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly three mirrored shell reflections below the three non-reflected shells.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are four mirrored shell reflections shown below the four non-reflected shells."}, {"statement": "The shells' exterior surfaces appear weathered and rock-like.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "The shells appear to have a natural, smooth, typical shell texture rather than a weathered, rock-like texture."}, {"statement": "The shell located in the central vertical third of the frame is the largest of the three non-reflected shells.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "Because there are four shells arranged horizontally, there is no single central largest shell; the two central shells are roughly the same size."}, {"statement": "Each reflected shell is vertically aligned beneath a corresponding non-reflected shell.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Every floating shell has a corresponding reflection directly beneath it."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible shell geometry, such as fused rims, broken spiral topology, or non-manifold openings.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of all visible shells appears natural and manifold without broken topology."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous non-shell objects, people, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects, text, or watermarks are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits cloned shells with unnaturally identical shape, orientation, and texture outside of the mirrored reflections.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The floating shells display varying shapes, sizes, colors, and orientations, avoiding an unnaturally cloned look."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections or lighting, such as a reflected shell not matching the position or orientation of the shell above it.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The reflections of the two central shells show the dark top side of the shells, while the floating shells have their open sides facing down/forward, which is physically impossible for a mirror reflection."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the shells, their reflections, and the sky.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials and boundaries between the shells, reflections, and sky are clearly defined."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 20, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 4, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image features four shells instead of the requested three and contains severe physics violations in the reflections.", "net_score": 14, "final_score": 28.0}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 453, "image_id": "5cdcbaa0-50db-403d-b6b9-0b4a39fa29a2", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three non-reflected snail shells.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly three snail shells floating above the horizon line."}, {"statement": "Each of the three non-reflected shells is floating in mid-air with no visible support.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The three upper shells are suspended in the air without any strings or pedestals."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly three reflected shell images below the shells, making six shell forms visible in total.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three distinct reflections below the horizon, creating a total of six shell forms."}, {"statement": "Each reflected shell is vertically aligned directly beneath one shell above it.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections are positioned directly under each corresponding floating shell."}, {"statement": "The largest shell is positioned near the center of the composition.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The central floating shell is noticeably larger than the two flanking it."}, {"statement": "The shells have a weathered, rock-like surface texture.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shells feature a rough, stony texture with mossy green accents."}, {"statement": "The background is a night sky with visible clouds.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists of clouds and a starry sky."}, {"statement": "All three shells and all three reflections are fully contained within the frame.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No parts of the six shell forms are cropped by the edges of the image."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible shell geometry, such as fused spirals, broken spiral continuity, or non-manifold edges.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The spiral structures of the shells appear coherent and unbroken."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no unwanted objects, people, or text elements present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or near-identical shell shapes or texture patches that make separate shells or reflections look copy-pasted.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shells have distinct shapes and texture distributions, avoiding a cloned appearance."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow directions across the shells, inconsistent with a coherent scene.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows on the shells are consistent with the ambient light of the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between a shell and the adjacent sky or reflective surface.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The edges of the shells and their reflections are clean against the sky and reflective surface."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 54, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 54, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 467, "image_id": "cc693a76-026e-427d-96df-85277a2c7b0e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image includes an airplane marked \"AIR FRANCE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An old commercial-style airplane with 'AIR FRANCE' clearly painted on its side is visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The image includes a separate warplane or military aircraft.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A smaller, propeller-driven military-style aircraft is visible in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The warplane is positioned closer to the viewer than the Air France airplane.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The propeller warplane is in the foreground, partially overlapping the view of the Air France plane behind it."}, {"statement": "The scene depicts an aircraft graveyard or boneyard setting, with grounded derelict aircraft on an outdoor lot.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The aircraft are grounded on a dirt and grass lot scattered with debris, consistent with a boneyard."}, {"statement": "Both airplanes show visible weathering such as rust, corrosion, stains, or peeling paint.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the Air France plane and the warplane exhibit extensive rust, missing panels, and peeling paint."}, {"statement": "The background includes green trees.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A tree line with green and some autumnal foliage is visible behind the aircraft."}, {"statement": "The background includes visible blue sky.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A blue sky with fluffy white clouds is visible above the trees."}, {"statement": "The bottom-right corner contains the watermark \"©JMZen Dugny 10/2013\".", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The watermark '©JMZen Dugny 10/2013' is clearly rendered in the bottom-right corner."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible aircraft geometry such as fused wings, mismatched engine placement, malformed propellers, or unusable landing gear.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The warplane's propeller blades are malformed and appear to intersect impossibly with the engine cowling, and the landing gear struts are structurally nonsensical."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, signs, logos, or watermarks beyond the requested \"©JMZen Dugny 10/2013\" watermark.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra people, vehicles, or unauthorized watermarks are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned aircraft, propellers, wheels, or other major aircraft parts not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious duplications or clones of major aircraft parts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered text in the \"AIR FRANCE\" marking or in the requested watermark.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both 'AIR FRANCE' and the watermark text are clearly legible and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent with a single outdoor daylight scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent with a daylight outdoor environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between aircraft surfaces and adjacent trees, sky, or ground.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and boundaries between the aircraft, ground, and background elements are distinct without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image meets all positive prompt requirements well but suffers from some structural geometry artifacts on the warplane's propeller and landing gear.", "net_score": 45, "final_score": 88.2}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 467, "image_id": "cc693a76-026e-427d-96df-85277a2c7b0e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly one large passenger airplane bearing Air France livery or readable \"Air France\" branding is present.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The large passenger plane has garbled text reading 'FRAN ACE I'FAME' instead of readable 'Air France'."}, {"statement": "Exactly one multicolored warplane is present.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a single smaller warplane in the foreground painted with multiple colors (blue, yellow, red, green)."}, {"statement": "The warplane is positioned in front of the Air France passenger airplane.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The multicolored warplane sits directly in front of the large passenger aircraft."}, {"statement": "Additional stored aircraft or aircraft parts are visible, indicating an aircraft graveyard or boneyard setting.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "To the left, there is an engine nacelle and parts of another aircraft body visible in the bushes."}, {"statement": "The aircraft surfaces show visible age-related wear such as grime, rust, or faded paint.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the large passenger plane and the smaller warplane have significant streaks of rust, grime, and weathered paint."}, {"statement": "Green trees are visible in the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A line of green trees is clearly visible behind the large airplane on the left side."}, {"statement": "A blue daytime sky is visible in the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background features a bright blue sky with white clouds."}, {"statement": "A watermark reading \"©JMZen Dugny 10/2013\" appears in the bottom-right corner of the image.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The watermark in the bottom right reads '©JMZend Dngy13' which is misspelled."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed aircraft geometry, such as fused or impossibly shaped wings, engines, cockpit windows, or landing gear.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The passenger plane has distorted cockpit windows, nonsensical gear structure on the right, and the engine on the left wing is strangely attached and shaped."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits additional watermarks, logos, signs, or text beyond Air France markings and the requested \"©JMZen Dugny 10/2013\" watermark.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is a small sign with garbled text near the front landing gear of the passenger plane."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned aircraft, aircraft parts, or trees that appear unnaturally repeated.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning or unnatural repetition of elements is visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, misspelled, or illegible rendered text in the Air France markings or in the requested watermark.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Both the main airline text ('FRAN ACE I'FAME') and the watermark ('©JMZend Dngy13') are garbled and misspelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible daylight shadows, highlights, or reflections that are inconsistent across the aircraft and ground.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows and lighting appear generally consistent for a daytime outdoor scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between aircraft metal, glass, vegetation, and dirt.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct; metal, glass, and vegetation are clearly differentiated."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 36, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -17, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image fails significantly on text rendering for both the main livery and the watermark, and contains structural geometry issues on the large aircraft.", "net_score": 19, "final_score": 36.5}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 467, "image_id": "cc693a76-026e-427d-96df-85277a2c7b0e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image includes a passenger airplane bearing Air France livery.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A passenger airplane with 'AIR FRANCE' text and matching livery is clearly visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The image includes a warplane positioned in front of the Air France airplane.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A smaller, military-style aircraft is positioned directly in front of the passenger plane."}, {"statement": "The setting resembles an aircraft graveyard or retired-aircraft storage yard.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The aircraft are parked on a grassy field surrounded by trees, consistent with a graveyard or storage yard."}, {"statement": "The image is wider than it is tall (landscape orientation).", "weight": 3, "met": false, "failure_code": "FORMAT_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The generated image has a square aspect ratio (1:1), not a landscape orientation."}, {"statement": "The background contains trees with predominantly green foliage.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Green trees form the immediate background behind the airplanes."}, {"statement": "A blue daytime sky is visible in the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A blue sky with some clouds is visible above the trees and aircraft."}, {"statement": "The aircraft surfaces show visible aging, weathering, or wear.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "Both aircraft appear relatively clean and polished, lacking obvious signs of aging or weathering."}, {"statement": "The bottom-right corner contains the watermark text \"©JMZen Dugny 10/2013\".", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The watermark text in the bottom right is slightly garbled, reading something closer to '©Jmz̄n Dugny 10/2013' with an extra mark over the 'z'."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible airplane geometry, such as fused or disconnected wings, engines, or landing-gear structures.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The landing gear of the larger plane merges confusingly with the wings/body of the smaller plane, and the smaller plane has unusual, asymmetrical structures on its top and nose."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated people, ground vehicles, buildings, signs, or extra text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected people, vehicles, or buildings are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned aircraft or airplane parts, such as repeated engines, wheels, wings, or tails.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The smaller plane has what appears to be a vertical stabilizer protruding from its nose/cockpit area, which is structurally anomalous."}, {"statement": "The watermark or aircraft lettering contains illegible or garbled characters.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The 'AIR FRANCE' text on the plane is slightly warped and the watermark has anomalous characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits shadows, reflections, or highlight directions that are inconsistent with a single daylight lighting setup.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent with daylight from the left."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the aircraft and the adjacent trees, sky, or ground.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between the aircraft, ground, and background elements are well-defined."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 31, "total_positive_weight_possible": 45, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -17, "failure_count": 3, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image has significant structural issues with the aircraft, specifically the merging of landing gear and anomalous parts on the smaller plane, and fails to render the requested landscape orientation and weathered appearance.", "net_score": 14, "final_score": 31.1}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 467, "image_id": "cc693a76-026e-427d-96df-85277a2c7b0e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image includes a passenger airplane bearing Air France livery or the text AIR FRANCE.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'AIR FRANCE' is visible on the side of the larger passenger airplane."}, {"statement": "The image includes a military warplane.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A fighter jet-style military warplane is present on the right side of the image."}, {"statement": "The military warplane is positioned in front of the Air France airplane.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The warplane is positioned physically closer to the viewer and in front of the wing of the Air France airplane."}, {"statement": "The ground immediately around the aircraft is rough grassy or scrub-covered ground rather than a clean paved runway or airport apron.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The aircraft are resting on rough, scrubby grass and dirt."}, {"statement": "The aircraft surfaces show visible aging such as rust, grime, faded paint, or chipped paint.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both aircraft show extensive grime, rust, and weathering on their surfaces."}, {"statement": "The background includes green trees.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Green trees surround the aircraft in the background."}, {"statement": "The background includes a blue sky in daylight.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A light blue sky with clouds is visible in the background, indicating daylight."}, {"statement": "A watermark reading \"©JMZen Dugny 10/2013\" appears in the bottom-right corner of the image.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The requested watermark is visible in the bottom right corner."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed aircraft geometry such as fused parts, impossible wing or tail shapes, or inconsistent landing gear structures.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The Air France plane has malformed front landing gear and the warplane has inconsistent, spindly landing gear structures."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, road vehicles, buildings, signs, or additional text or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are visible in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an obvious duplicated or cloned copy of one of the main aircraft.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are only two distinct aircraft shown."}, {"statement": "The watermark or other rendered text contains illegible, garbled, or nonsensical glyphs.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The watermark text is legible and accurate."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow directions across the aircraft and ground.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent with daylight."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where aircraft surfaces blend into nearby trees or ground.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The tree branches appear to be intersecting or growing through the fuselage and wing of the Air France plane."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -11, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image meets all positive criteria, but exhibits some malformed landing gear geometry and impossible intersection between the tree branches and the main airplane.", "net_score": 40, "final_score": 78.4}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 905, "image_id": "f4043b1c-bcec-47a8-a078-f914cea50741", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A dog appears on grass in the bottom-right area of the image.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A dog is sitting on the grass in the bottom right corner of the composition."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly three houses.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three distinct houses visible: one on the left, one in the center, and one on the right."}, {"statement": "A small brown house is positioned across the street from the dog.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A small brown house is located centrally across the paved road from where the dog sits."}, {"statement": "The small brown house has a rusty metal roof.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The central brown house features a corrugated metal roof with visible rust patches."}, {"statement": "A rusty gate stands in front of the small brown house.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A rusty metal gate is positioned directly in front of the central brown house."}, {"statement": "A green wooden gate attached to a stone wall appears to the left of the small brown house.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "To the left of the brown house, there is a green wooden gate connected to a stone wall."}, {"statement": "An old wooden fence appears to the right of the small brown house.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden picket fence is visible to the right of the central brown house."}, {"statement": "The sky is prominently dramatic and cloudy.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sky is filled with dark, textured clouds creating a dramatic atmosphere."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The dog exhibits anatomical artifacts such as extra legs, fused paws, or malformed facial features.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The dog appears anatomically correct with normal proportions and no visible artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a hallucinated person, vehicle, sign, or other salient object not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unprompted salient objects like people or vehicles are present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned fence boards, vegetation patches, roof tiles, or other repeated structures.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and repeating structures like the fence and grass appear naturally varied without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow directions inconsistent with the rest of the daytime scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent across the scene, appropriate for the dramatic daytime setting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent elements such as the dog, grass, fences, and houses.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and boundaries between distinct objects like the dog, grass, and buildings remain clean and distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 49, "total_positive_weight_possible": 49, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 49, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 905, "image_id": "f4043b1c-bcec-47a8-a078-f914cea50741", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly one Dutch Smoushond-type dog: a small rough-coated tan dog with a shaggy muzzle.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A rough-coated, tan dog matching the general description of a Dutch Smoushond is visible."}, {"statement": "The dog is located within the bottom-right quarter of the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The dog is clearly positioned in the bottom-right area of the image."}, {"statement": "The dog is standing on grass.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The dog is standing on an asphalt road, not on the grass."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly three houses.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three distinct houses are visible: the main brown house, one to its right, and one partially visible on the far left behind the gate."}, {"statement": "A brown house is visible across the street in the middle ground.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent brown wooden house is positioned across the road."}, {"statement": "The brown house across the street has a rusty metal roof.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The roof of the central brown house is made of corrugated metal with heavy rust."}, {"statement": "A green wooden gate bordered by stone wall posts is visible on the left side of the scene.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A green wooden gate with stone pillars is present on the left side."}, {"statement": "Clouds occupy more than half of the visible sky.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sky is dominated by dramatic, cloudy formations."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The dog exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts such as extra legs, fused paws, malformed ears, or distorted facial features.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The dog is well-rendered with no obvious anatomical issues."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, utility elements, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or watermarks are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned objects, such as repeated dogs, houses, shrubs, or fence sections, that are not implied by the scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no signs of cloned or duplicated objects."}, {"statement": "Visible text on any sign or plaque is illegible or garbled.", "weight": -2, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "There is a small plaque on the green gate with illegible, garbled text."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow behavior that conflicts with a single cloudy daytime outdoor scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent with the cloudy, warm daytime setting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent regions such as the dog, road, grass, fences, or buildings.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and materials are well-separated without noticeable bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 49, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -2, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The dog is standing on the road instead of the grass, and there is minor text garbling on a gate plaque.", "net_score": 47, "final_score": 85.5}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 905, "image_id": "f4043b1c-bcec-47a8-a078-f914cea50741", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly one Dutch Smoushond dog is visible.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "One dog resembling a Smoushond is in the lower right."}, {"statement": "The dog is positioned in the bottom-right area of the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The dog is situated in the bottom right corner."}, {"statement": "Exactly three houses are visible in the scene.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a brown house in the center, and roofs/parts of houses on the far left and far right."}, {"statement": "The central house is brown.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The house in the middle is painted brown."}, {"statement": "The central house has a rusty metal roof.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The central brown house has a corrugated metal roof with rust."}, {"statement": "A stone wall with a green gate is visible to the left of the central house.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "To the left of the central house is a stone wall abutting a green wooden gate."}, {"statement": "A wooden fence is visible to the right of the central house.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "To the right of the central house, a vertical wooden fence is visible."}, {"statement": "The upper portion of the image contains thick cloud cover.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sky is full of dense, dramatic clouds."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical distortions on the dog, such as extra limbs, fused paws, or malformed facial features.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The dog's anatomy appears normal with no visible distortions."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, signs, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No people, vehicles, signs, or watermarks are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obvious duplicated or cloned repetition in major scene elements, such as fence boards, roof panels, or foliage.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Fences, foliage, and roof panels show natural variation."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows inconsistent with a single daytime outdoor scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent with the overcast sky."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent surfaces such as dog fur, grass, fence, stone wall, and house.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and boundaries between grass, walls, and the dog are clean."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 54, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 54, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 905, "image_id": "f4043b1c-bcec-47a8-a078-f914cea50741", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly one dog.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only one dog is visible in the frame."}, {"statement": "The dog is located in the bottom-right quadrant of the image on grass.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The dog is sitting on the grass in the lower right area."}, {"statement": "The dog has a shaggy, rough-coated appearance consistent with a Dutch Smoushond.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The dog has a wiry, shaggy coat."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly three houses.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are four distinct house structures visible (one central brown house, one to the left, two to the right)."}, {"statement": "A small brown house stands across a road or street from the dog.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A central brown stone/brick building is located across the road from the dog."}, {"statement": "The small brown house has a rusty metal roof.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The roof of the central brown house appears to be corrugated metal with significant rust."}, {"statement": "A green wooden gate attached to a stone wall is visible on the left side of the scene.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A green wooden slatted gate is attached to stone pillars/wall on the left."}, {"statement": "Most of the visible sky is covered by dark, dramatic clouds.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sky is filled with heavy, dark, dramatic cloud cover."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The dog exhibits anatomical artifacts such as extra or missing legs, fused paws, or distorted facial features.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The dog's anatomy appears normal with no visible artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, signs, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements like people, vehicles, or text are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obvious cloned repetition in fence sections, vegetation, or cloud patterns.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no obvious cloned repetition in the textures or patterns."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows, such as conflicting light directions on the dog, road, and houses.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent elements such as the dog and grass or the roof and sky.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Edges and materials are distinct with no notable smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 49, "total_positive_weight_possible": 58, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The model rendered four houses instead of the requested three, but otherwise followed the prompt well.", "net_score": 49, "final_score": 84.5}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 1310, "image_id": "93bd4899-3196-4fa1-bf03-465574692f99", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "On the right side of the shelf, there are exactly three large blue hardback books.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three large blue hardback books are clearly visible on the right."}, {"statement": "Each of the three large blue books has a red rectangular label on its spine.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three blue books have a red label on their spines."}, {"statement": "The three large blue books are labeled as volumes 9, 10, and 11.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The red labels clearly read 'Vol. 9', 'Vol. 10', and 'Vol. 11'."}, {"statement": "On the left side of the shelf, at least four smaller books with varied spine colors are visible.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are several smaller books in various colors (green, red, yellow, etc.) on the left."}, {"statement": "At least one of the smaller left-side books has visible spine text indicating a language-learning subject, such as a language name, \"grammar,\" or \"learn.\"", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "One red book on the left clearly says 'Learrn Spaanissh', indicating language learning."}, {"statement": "The image is framed as a close-up, straight-on view at approximately eye level with the books.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The framing is straight-on and close-up at eye level."}, {"statement": "The lighting on the shelf and books is warm-toned and diffuse.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting has a warm, diffuse quality."}, {"statement": "The books on the main shelf row are sharply focused.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books and their titles on the main shelf are in sharp focus."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry in the books or shelf, such as fused volumes, severely warped hardback shapes, or broken shelf edges.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books and shelf appear geometrically sound with no fused or warped shapes."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, signs, shelf tags, or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is an unprompted tag with '19' on the shelf above the books."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned books, with repeated spines, titles, or texture patterns not implied by the described collection.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books have distinct designs and titles."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered text on book spines, labels, or volume numbers.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Several books have garbled text, such as 'Learrn Spaanissh', 'Esseeniial Eenglish', and 'Encycloppdia'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the books and shelf.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows appear consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent books or between the books and the shelf.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct without bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -11, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image successfully meets all prompt requirements, but features significant text garbling and a hallucinated shelf tag.", "net_score": 41, "final_score": 78.8}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 1310, "image_id": "93bd4899-3196-4fa1-bf03-465574692f99", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly three large blue hardback books are visible on the right side of the shelf.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three large blue books are clearly visible on the right side of the shelf."}, {"statement": "Each of the three large blue books has a red rectangular label panel on its spine.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each of the three blue books has a red label area on its spine."}, {"statement": "The three large blue books show the volume numbers 9, 10, and 11 on their spines, each appearing once.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The books are numbered 9, 11, and 11, missing the number 10."}, {"statement": "At least four smaller books with visibly different spine colors are visible to the left of the blue encyclopedia set.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are several smaller books with various colorful spines on the left side."}, {"statement": "A shelf surface is visible and shows age or wear such as chipped paint, scratches, or patina.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shelf surface is visible and appears worn with chipped edges."}, {"statement": "The composition is a close-up, straight-on view at approximately book-spine height.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective is a close-up, straight-on view."}, {"statement": "The lighting is warm in color temperature and soft rather than harsh.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is warm and soft."}, {"statement": "The front row of book spines is sharply focused.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The spines of the books are in sharp focus."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible book or shelf geometry, such as fused neighboring books, broken shelf edges, or severely warped rectangular spines.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books and shelf appear geometrically sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an unrelated object, person, watermark, logo, or overlay not implied by a close-up bookshelf scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unrelated objects or overlays are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned books with unnaturally repeated spine designs or repeated wear patterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious cloned books or repeated wear patterns."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, nonsensical, or garbled rendered text in areas meant to show book titles, labels, or volume numbers.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the spines is mostly garbled and nonsensical."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting or shadows, such as highlights and shadows implying conflicting light directions.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows appear consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent book covers, labels, and the shelf.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no significant color bleeding or texture smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 40, "total_positive_weight_possible": 49, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The text on the book spines is heavily garbled, and the volume numbers are incorrect (9, 11, 11 instead of 9, 10, 11).", "net_score": 32, "final_score": 65.3}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 1310, "image_id": "93bd4899-3196-4fa1-bf03-465574692f99", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly three large blue books are grouped on the right side of the shelf.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three distinct large blue books are positioned together on the right side of the shelf."}, {"statement": "Each of the three large blue books has a red label panel on its spine.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three blue books feature a distinct red rectangular panel on their spines."}, {"statement": "The three large blue books show the numbers 9, 10, and 11 on their spines, with each number appearing once.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The large blue books display the numbers 9, 7, and 11, missing the number 10."}, {"statement": "At least three smaller books with at least three distinct spine colors appear to the left of the blue books.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a row of several smaller books on the left in colors like red, yellow, blue, green, and orange."}, {"statement": "The image is a close-up of a single shelf of books, with the books occupying most of the frame.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The composition is a close-up shot focused tightly on a single shelf of books filling the frame."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint is straight-on at the books' eye level.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is directly straight-on at the spines of the books."}, {"statement": "The scene uses soft, warm-toned lighting.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears warm and diffuse, giving a soft glow to the scene."}, {"statement": "The books and shelf are rendered in sharp focus rather than noticeable blur.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The spines, textures, and text details are mostly in sharp focus."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped, fused, or impossible geometry in the books or shelf.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books and shelf maintain structurally sound and separate geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated non-book objects, people, watermarks, or logos not implied by the bookshelf prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects or elements are present outside of the books and shelf."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned books with unnaturally repeated spine designs or textures.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each book has a distinct design and size, without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical rendered text on one or more book spines.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on almost all books, including 'ENCYOPEDIA', consists of garbled, nonsensical characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting or shadows across the shelf and books.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows fall consistently across the books."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent books or between the books and shelf.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The edges between the books and the shelf are clean with no color bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 43, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image correctly renders the overall composition and aesthetic, but fails on text generation, showing '7' instead of '10' and widespread garbled text.", "net_score": 35, "final_score": 66.0}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 1310, "image_id": "93bd4899-3196-4fa1-bf03-465574692f99", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "On the right side of the shelf, exactly three large books are visible standing side by side.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three large books are standing together on the far right of the shelf."}, {"statement": "The three large books on the right have blue spines.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The spines of the three large books on the right are a faded blue color."}, {"statement": "Each of the three large books on the right has a red label panel on its spine.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are distinct red rectangular panels on the spines of the three large blue books."}, {"statement": "The three large books on the right are labeled as encyclopedia volumes 9, 10, and 11.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The red labels clearly read 'VOL. 9 ENCYCLOPEDIA BRITANNICA', 'VOL. 10...', and 'VOL. 11...'."}, {"statement": "On the left side of the shelf, at least four books are visibly smaller than the three large books on the right.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are many books on the left that are significantly shorter and thinner than the encyclopedias."}, {"statement": "The smaller books on the left span at least three distinct spine or cover colors.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The smaller books have various colors including yellow, blue, green, and red."}, {"statement": "At least one smaller book on the left has a visibly language-learning-related title or category, such as a dictionary, phrasebook, or verbs book.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are books titled 'SPANISH VERBS', 'LEARN FRENCH NOW', 'POCKET GERMAN DICTIONARY', and 'ITALIAN PHRASES'."}, {"statement": "The camera presents the shelf from a close-up, straight-on, eye-level perspective.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The viewpoint is directly facing the shelf, showing the spines head-on."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or fused shelf or book geometry, such as bent rectangular spines, merged books, or impossible shelf edges.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books and shelves maintain correct rectangular geometry without structural anomalies."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, captions, watermarks, or logos not implied by the bookshelf prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only books and shelves are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned books, shown by repeated identical spines, titles, or wear patterns.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There are two identical copies of 'SPANISH VERBS' visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, nonsensical, or unreadable text on book spines where titles or volume numbers should be legible.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Several smaller books have unreadable or nonsensical text, such as the white book next to the German dictionary."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that do not match the books and wooden shelf.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent books or between books and the shelf.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures of the books and the wood are distinct and rendered cleanly."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 56, "total_positive_weight_possible": 56, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -10, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image successfully captures the main prompt details, but suffers from some garbled text on smaller book spines and a duplicated book title.", "net_score": 46, "final_score": 82.1}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 1354, "image_id": "c610b2a9-3122-4636-89de-b7769f755294", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly four beer glass bottles.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are only three bottles visible in the image, not four."}, {"statement": "Exactly two of the four bottles are the Lupia variant, identifiable by label text including \"Lupia\".", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "Only one bottle (the left one) clearly says 'LUPIA' on the main label, and all three say 'Estrella Galicia'."}, {"statement": "Exactly one of the four bottles is the Estrella Galicia Especial variant, identifiable by label text including \"Estrella Galicia\" and \"Especial\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The center bottle has a label with 'Estrella Galicia' and 'Especial'."}, {"statement": "Exactly one of the four bottles is the Estrella Galicia gluten-free variant, identifiable by label text including \"Estrella Galicia\" and \"gluten-free\" or \"gluten free\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right bottle has a label with 'Estrella Galicia' and 'gluten free'."}, {"statement": "The four bottles are placed in a holder that visibly supports or surrounds them.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The three visible bottles are placed in a wire holder that surrounds them."}, {"statement": "The bottles collectively occupy at least half of the image height, indicating a close-up composition.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottles fill the majority of the vertical space in the frame."}, {"statement": "The background behind the bottles is visibly out of focus relative to the bottles.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background features a shallow depth of field with blurry bokeh elements."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit with predominantly warm tones such as yellow, orange, or amber.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting features a warm, orange-amber sunset glow."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible bottle or holder geometry, such as fused bottles, warped bottle necks, or holder bars that could not physically support the bottles.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottles and holder wire structure appear physically plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits clearly identifiable extraneous people, unrelated products, watermarks, or added text outside the expected bottle labels.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or added text are visible outside the requested bottles."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned bottles, caps, labels, or bottle fragments not implied by the requested set of four bottles.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated bottle parts or fragments visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered text on bottle labels or caps.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the labels is highly legible and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections, highlights, shadows, or glass transparency inconsistent with the rest of the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting, reflections, and glass transparency look realistic."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the glass bottles, paper labels, metal holder, and background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct with no color bleeding or texture smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 34, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The model failed to generate the correct number of bottles, rendering three instead of four.", "net_score": 34, "final_score": 64.2}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 1354, "image_id": "c610b2a9-3122-4636-89de-b7769f755294", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly four glass beer bottles.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Four distinct glass beer bottles are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "Exactly two of the four bottles have \"Lupia\" as the main label word.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The two bottles on the left prominently display 'Lupia' on their main labels."}, {"statement": "Exactly one of the four bottles is labeled \"Estrella Galicia Especial\".", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The third bottle is labeled 'Estrella Galicio ESPECIAL' and 'Beligrne', which is garbled and incorrect."}, {"statement": "Exactly one of the four bottles is labeled \"Estrella Galicia gluten-free\".", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The fourth bottle is labeled 'Estrella Galicio GLUITEN-FREE', which contains spelling errors."}, {"statement": "All four bottles are positioned inside a visible bottle holder or carrier.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A black wire bottle holder visibly contains all four bottles."}, {"statement": "The image is wider than it is tall (landscape orientation).", "weight": 2, "met": false, "failure_code": "FORMAT_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The image is square (1024x1024), not wider than it is tall."}, {"statement": "Each of the four bottles extends above the midpoint of the image height, indicating a close-up composition.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The tops of all four bottles reach well into the upper half of the frame."}, {"statement": "Background objects behind the bottles are visibly out of focus, with soft edges rather than sharp detail.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists of blurred, out-of-focus shapes and colors."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed bottle or holder geometry, such as fused bottle bodies, warped necks, or impossible carrier loops.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottles and holder have normal, intact geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, signage, watermarks, or logos outside the four bottles and their holder.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects are clearly visible in the focused areas."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits copy-paste duplication artifacts, such as two bottles, caps, or label areas with exactly repeated unique details.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottles have unique details and do not appear to be copy-pasted."}, {"statement": "The labels contain illegible small-print text or nonsensical character strings outside the main brand and product names.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The labels contain numerous nonsensical strings like 'EESTTRRLKA', 'GELIA', 'grelingref', and 'Beligrne'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible highlights, shadows, or reflections on the glass bottles or metal holder.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections and highlights on the glass and metal appear natural."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between the glass, labels, beer liquid, and holder.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials are distinct, with no obvious smearing or color bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 34, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -3, "failure_count": 3, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main issue is significant text garbling on the Estrella bottles, along with an incorrect square aspect ratio.", "net_score": 31, "final_score": 59.6}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 1354, "image_id": "c610b2a9-3122-4636-89de-b7769f755294", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly four beer bottles made of glass.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Four distinct glass beer bottles are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "All visible beer bottles are placed in a single visible holder/carrier.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The four bottles are contained within a single black carrier."}, {"statement": "Exactly two of the bottles are labeled \"Lupia\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The first two bottles from the left feature \"Lupia\" on their main labels."}, {"statement": "Exactly one of the bottles is labeled \"Estrella Galicia Especial\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The third bottle from the left reads \"Estrella Galicia ESPECIAL\" on its label."}, {"statement": "Exactly one of the bottles is labeled \"Estrella Galicia gluten-free\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The fourth bottle reads \"Estrella Galicia GLUTEN-FREE\"."}, {"statement": "The background behind the bottles is visibly blurred/out of focus relative to the bottles.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The landscape in the background is intentionally out of focus."}, {"statement": "The bottles and holder occupy at least half of the image height, indicating a close-up shot.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottles and their holder take up the majority of the vertical space in the frame."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit with warm orange/yellow lighting.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A warm sunset lighting bathes the entire scene."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry in the bottles or holder, such as fused bottle silhouettes, warped necks, or malformed caps.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottles and holder appear structurally sound without warped geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous foreground objects, people, signs, watermarks, or logos beyond the four bottles and their holder.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous foreground elements are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned visual elements, such as repeated bottle, cap, label, or background details that appear copied.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning artifacts are visible across the elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, illegible, or nonsensical text on the bottle labels.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Secondary text on the labels, such as \"elvcia\" under Lupia and garbled text under the Estrella Galicia logos, is nonsensical."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible highlights, shadows, reflections, or glass transparency inconsistent with the rest of the scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The holder appears to be floating in mid-air with no support beneath it."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent bottles, labels, and the holder.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors remain distinct without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -10, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The main requested elements are present, but the image features garbled secondary text on the labels and an unsupported, floating bottle holder.", "net_score": 42, "final_score": 80.8}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 1354, "image_id": "c610b2a9-3122-4636-89de-b7769f755294", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly four bottles are present, with this brand distribution: 2 labeled \"LUPIA\", 1 labeled \"Estrella Galicia Especial\", and 1 labeled as Estrella Galicia gluten-free, such as \"SIN GLUTEN\".", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "Five bottles are visible in the holder (one is partially hidden behind the front-left bottle)."}, {"statement": "Each of the four containers is a glass bottle rather than a can, cup, or mug.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All containers in the holder are glass bottles."}, {"statement": "All four bottles are placed inside a single holder or carrier.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottles are contained within a single wooden holder."}, {"statement": "The image is in landscape orientation, wider than it is tall.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image has a landscape orientation."}, {"statement": "The bottles and holder occupy at least half of the frame width, indicating a close-up composition.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The wooden holder and bottles take up about half of the image's width."}, {"statement": "Most of the background outside the bottles and holder is visibly blurred or out of focus.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background elements like the balcony, lights, and pillows are blurred."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated with warm-toned lighting, with yellow/orange highlights rather than cool blue lighting.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting has warm, golden tones consistent with golden hour or string lights."}, {"statement": "The scene includes at least three distinct prominent colors, consistent with a multicolor palette.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene features multiple colors, notably in the striped pillows and bottle labels."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed bottle or holder geometry, such as fused bottle necks, impossible handle connections, or broken glass contours.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottles and wooden holder appear geometrically sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits added watermark text, logos, or unrelated prominent signage not part of the requested bottle labels.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks or unrelated signage are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or copy-pasted bottles, labels, or holder parts that should appear as distinct objects.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottles and labels show normal variation, not exact copy-pasting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on the bottle labels.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The smaller text below the main brand names (like under 'Especial' and 'LUPIA') is garbled and illegible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent highlights, shadows, or reflections on the glass bottles or holder.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Highlights and shadows appear consistent with the lighting setup."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the paper labels, glass bottles, and wooden holder.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and rendered without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 31, "total_positive_weight_possible": 41, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model generated five bottles instead of the requested four, and some smaller text on the labels is garbled.", "net_score": 25, "final_score": 61.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 1459, "image_id": "df92c7fb-f706-4a09-b137-15c757f899f9", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly one brown ceramic vase.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A single brown ceramic vase is clearly visible at the center of the composition."}, {"statement": "The vase sits on a rough wooden shelf or wooden surface.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The vase rests on a heavily textured, rough wooden shelf."}, {"statement": "The vase contains a bouquet that includes sunflowers.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several bright yellow sunflowers are prominent in the vase."}, {"statement": "The bouquet includes visibly wilted or dried plant material.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Dried and drooping brown flower heads and stems are present alongside the fresh sunflowers."}, {"statement": "The front of the vase shows a rose motif positioned above exactly two beige horizontal lines.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A sculpted rose decoration sits directly above two distinct, light beige bands around the vase."}, {"statement": "A single fruit is placed next to the vase.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "One small apple-like fruit is resting on the wood to the right of the vase base."}, {"statement": "Exactly two small illuminated squares with designs appear in the upper-left corner of the image.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are three illuminated square designs visible in the upper-left corner, not exactly two."}, {"statement": "The bottom text block contains the strings “Zonnebloemen in de herfst”, “Johan Wolfhard”, and “211019”.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three requested text strings are clearly rendered at the bottom."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits fused or impossible plant anatomy, such as petals, leaves, or stems merging unnaturally with each other or with the vase.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The stems, petals, and leaves are rendered cleanly without obvious impossible fusions."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, logos, watermarks, or unrelated text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unprompted elements or watermarks are visible in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or cloned flower heads, leaves, fruit, or illuminated-square designs.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The illuminated squares in the top left appear to use identical, cloned mandala designs."}, {"statement": "The bottom text block or any other rendered text exhibits garbled, misspelled, or illegible characters.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text at the bottom is highly legible and spelled exactly as requested."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, shadows, or reflections across the vase, flowers, fruit, shelf, and illuminated squares.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent, matching the soft overhead source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between adjacent elements such as flowers, vase, fruit, and wood.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and boundaries between objects are sharp."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 50, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -3, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image miscounts the requested illuminated squares, providing three instead of two, and clones the design inside them.", "net_score": 47, "final_score": 87.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 1459, "image_id": "df92c7fb-f706-4a09-b137-15c757f899f9", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A brown ceramic vase sits on a rough wooden shelf or surface.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A brown ceramic vase is clearly visible resting on a rough, textured wooden shelf."}, {"statement": "The bouquet contains sunflowers.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The vase is filled with multiple sunflowers."}, {"statement": "The bouquet includes wilted dried plants.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Wilted and dried brown plant material is interspersed with the sunflowers."}, {"statement": "The vase shows a rose decoration.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A raised rose decoration is visible on the front of the vase."}, {"statement": "Two beige horizontal lines appear on the vase beneath the rose decoration.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The two beige lines intersect the rose decoration rather than appearing beneath it."}, {"statement": "A single fruit is placed next to the vase.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A single round fruit sits on the shelf to the right of the vase."}, {"statement": "Two small illuminated square panels with designs appear in the upper left corner of the image.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two distinct glowing square panels with intricate designs are in the upper left corner."}, {"statement": "A text block at the bottom reads exactly: \"Zonnebloemen in de herfst\" on one line, \"Johan Wolfhard\" on the next line, and \"211019\" on the next line.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The text at the bottom reads 'Zonnebloemen in de herfst' and 'Zihan Wolfhard', missing the date '211019' entirely and misspelling the name."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits fused petals, merged stems, or other impossible plant or vase geometry.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plants, vase, and fruit appear structurally sound without bizarre mergers."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extra objects, people, logos, or text beyond the vase, bouquet, single fruit, two illuminated square panels, and the bottom text block.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unrequested elements are present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously cloned or near-identical repeated copies of non-repeatable objects such as the vase, the fruit, or the illuminated square panels.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no signs of cloning or inappropriate duplication among the main objects."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, broken, or garbled glyphs in the bottom text block.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The name 'Johan Wolfhard' is incorrectly rendered as 'Zihan Wolffhard'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits shadows, highlights, or reflections that are inconsistent with soft overhead lighting.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears consistent with a soft overhead source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the flowers, vase, fruit, and wooden shelf.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct and do not bleed into one another."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 42, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image misses some text requirements, notably misrendering the name and omitting the date, and places the vase's stripes incorrectly.", "net_score": 36, "final_score": 65.5}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 1459, "image_id": "df92c7fb-f706-4a09-b137-15c757f899f9", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a brown ceramic vase resting on a wooden shelf or rough wooden surface.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A brown vase sits on a rough wooden shelf."}, {"statement": "The vase contains a bouquet with at least two visible sunflowers.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Five bright yellow sunflowers are clearly visible in the bouquet."}, {"statement": "The bouquet includes a visibly wilted cluster of dried plants separate from the sunflowers.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A brown, dried plant cluster hangs down on the right side of the bouquet."}, {"statement": "The vase decoration includes a rose motif with exactly two beige lines directly beneath it.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "The vase decoration shows a rose, but has multiple vertical lines forming a stem, not exactly two horizontal lines beneath it."}, {"statement": "A single fruit is placed beside the vase on the shelf.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A mango-like fruit rests on the shelf to the left of the vase."}, {"statement": "Exactly two small illuminated squares with internal designs appear in the upper-left corner area of the image.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two glowing square panels with symbols inside are located on the left wall of the alcove."}, {"statement": "At the bottom of the image, the exact title text \"Zonnebloemen in de herfst\" is present.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '\"Zonnebloemen in de herfst\"' is correctly printed along the bottom edge."}, {"statement": "At the bottom of the image, the exact attribution text block includes both \"Johan Wolfhard\" and \"211019\".", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The text 'Johan Wolfhard' is present, but the date '211019' is missing."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or visibly warped geometry in solid objects such as the vase, fruit, shelf, or illuminated squares.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The objects have normal, stable geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is a dark, bottle-like object in the background shadow on the right that was not requested."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or near-identical cloned flowers, fruits, or illuminated-square designs that appear copy-pasted.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The flowers and illuminated squares have distinct individual details."}, {"statement": "The bottom caption text is present but rendered with illegible or garbled characters.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rendered text is perfectly legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent with a soft overhead light source.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The overhead spotlight creates consistent highlights and shadows."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the ceramic vase, wooden shelf, fruit, and plants.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and well-rendered with no bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 44, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model missed the required date text and hallucinated an extra bottle-like object in the background.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 72.2}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 1459, "image_id": "df92c7fb-f706-4a09-b137-15c757f899f9", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly one brown ceramic vase.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A single brown ceramic vase is depicted on the right side of the image."}, {"statement": "The vase is placed on a wooden shelf or other visibly rough wooden surface.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The vase is resting on a textured wooden plank or shelf."}, {"statement": "The vase contains wilted sunflowers with visibly drooping flower heads.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The vase holds several sunflowers that have drooping petals and heads, indicating wilting."}, {"statement": "The front of the vase displays a rose decoration.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A three-dimensional rose decoration is present on the front of the vase."}, {"statement": "The vase shows exactly two beige horizontal lines beneath the rose decoration.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two distinct beige horizontal lines painted on the vase below the rose."}, {"statement": "Exactly one fruit is placed next to the vase on the shelf.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A single round fruit, resembling a pomegranate, sits to the right of the vase on the shelf."}, {"statement": "The upper left corner contains exactly two small illuminated squares with visible designs.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two illuminated square icons, one with a sun and one with a leaf, are in the upper left corner."}, {"statement": "At the bottom of the image, the text includes the exact phrase \"Zonnebloemen in de herfst\".", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The phrase 'Zonnebloemen in de herfst' is written clearly in text on the left side."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the vase, flower heads, stems, fruit, or illuminated squares.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the objects appears coherent without obvious fusions or impossible structures."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, symbols, logos, watermarks, or additional text elements not implied by the vase arrangement, single fruit, two illuminated squares, shelf, and requested bottom caption.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The image includes a large block of extraneous generated text describing the image below the main caption."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or cloned flowers, fruits, illuminated squares, or decorative motifs created by copy-like repetition.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The elements appear unique without signs of exact cloning or unnatural repetition."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or misspelled rendered text in the bottom caption area or any other text element.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The block of text on the bottom left contains several misspellings such as 'woodn space', 'contrassing', 'overhay', 'enhant', and 'the vase and the vase'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadows, highlights, or reflections that are inconsistent with soft overhead lighting.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent with a soft, directional overhead light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between the petals, leaves, vase, fruit, wooden surface, and dark background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are rendered distinctly without inappropriate smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 50, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -11, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The model accurately rendered the requested visual elements, but hallucinated a large block of misspelled descriptive text on the left side.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 78.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 1465, "image_id": "393d4a54-1eda-4d75-8e08-f4b4402889ce", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "At least 10 wine corks are visible in the image.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are over 30 individual wine corks clearly visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint is top-down, showing the corks from above in a close-up crop.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The composition is a top-down, flat-lay style close-up of a collection of corks."}, {"statement": "The visible corks are predominantly beige, with markings mainly in muted brown or black.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The corks are uniformly beige/tan with primarily dark brown and black stamped markings."}, {"statement": "At least one visible cork displays the word \"esporao\" or \"esporão\".", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"esporão\" is clearly printed on two different corks visible in the frame."}, {"statement": "At least one visible cork displays the word \"rola\".", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"rola\" is clearly printed on two adjacent corks in the upper-middle right area."}, {"statement": "At least one visible cork displays the word \"douro\".", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"douro\" is clearly printed on a round cork face in the middle-right area."}, {"statement": "At least one visible cork displays the phrase \"quinta do porira\".", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The phrase \"quinta do porira\" is cleanly printed on a horizontal cork near the center."}, {"statement": "A cork in the lower central area displays the quote \"life is too short to drink bad wine\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The large horizontal cork in the bottom center clearly displays this exact quote."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible cork geometry, such as fused corks or severely warped cork bodies.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All corks maintain proper cylindrical or circular cross-section geometry without fusing."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous non-cork objects, background props, watermarks, or overlay text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image contains only wine corks with no extraneous objects or watermarks."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or copy-pasted corks, including repeated identical shapes or stamp patterns.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "While some words repeat, the corks themselves exhibit unique textures, shapes, and wear patterns."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or partially formed letters on the cork text, making inscriptions unreadable.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Several corks on the edges have garbled text, such as the one in the top left reading 'A OJHJEIN'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting or shadows across neighboring corks.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent, suggesting a single light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where adjacent corks blend together.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The corks are distinctly separated with crisp edges and appropriate occlusion."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 41, "total_positive_weight_possible": 41, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The generated image perfectly captures all requested text and visual constraints, with only minor text garbling on background corks.", "net_score": 33, "final_score": 80.5}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 1465, "image_id": "393d4a54-1eda-4d75-8e08-f4b4402889ce", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image contains at least six visible wine corks.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are well over six distinct wine corks visible in the frame."}, {"statement": "Wine corks occupy more than half of the visible image area.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The composition is tightly packed, with wine corks filling almost the entire image."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint is top-down or overhead onto the corks.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective is an overhead view looking down onto the scattered corks."}, {"statement": "The corks look aged or used, with worn surfaces, stains, or pitted texture visible.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The corks display extensive pitting, wine stains, and rustic textures."}, {"statement": "A cork near the center of the image contains the words \"life is too short to drink bad wine\".", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The center cork reads 'Life is shot thrink! to bad wine', not the requested phrase."}, {"statement": "At least three visible corks other than the cork reading \"life is too short to drink bad wine\" contain printed or stamped writing.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Multiple other corks have stamped writing visible, such as the ones reading 'puinto' and 'EOL'."}, {"statement": "Beige and muted black or brown are the predominant colors in the image.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The color palette consists primarily of beige cork tones and brown/black shadows and markings."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit by a direct light source, producing distinct highlights and shadows on the corks.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Strong highlights and deep shadows indicate a direct light source illuminating the scene."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible cork geometry, such as fused corks or severely warped cylindrical shapes.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cylindrical shapes of the corks appear structurally sound and distinct from one another."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, tableware, bottles, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected objects or elements are present; only corks and surface are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned corks with unnaturally repeated shapes, markings, or texture patterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each cork displays unique textures, stains, and markings."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering on the corks.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Many corks feature misspelled or nonsensical text, such as 'puinto' and 'psrmobck'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows inconsistent with a single direct light source.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shadows cast by the corks are consistent with a single light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent corks or between corks and the background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and edges between the corks remain crisp and well-defined."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 43, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image suffers from significant text garbling, failing to render the requested central phrase accurately and producing nonsensical words on surrounding corks.", "net_score": 35, "final_score": 67.3}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 1465, "image_id": "393d4a54-1eda-4d75-8e08-f4b4402889ce", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows at least 10 wine corks packed together in a single pile.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly depicts a large pile containing well over 10 wine corks packed closely together."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is top-down/overhead.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The composition is a top-down, overhead view of the scattered corks."}, {"statement": "The framing is close-up, with corks filling at least 80% of the frame.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The corks fill almost the entirety of the frame in a close-up shot."}, {"statement": "At least 8 visible corks display printed letters or words.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "More than 8 corks feature distinct printed letters, words, or brands on their surface."}, {"statement": "A cork near the center reads the exact quote \"LIFE IS TOO SHORT TO DRINK BAD WINE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent cork directly in the center displays the phrase 'LIFE IS TOO SHORT TO DRINK BAD WINE' legibly and exactly."}, {"statement": "At least three of the following exact texts appear on visible cork labels: \"ESPORAO\", \"ROLA\", \"DOURO\", \"QUINTA DO PORIRA\".", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "While 'ESPORÃO' appears, 'ROLA' is rendered as 'ROLAA', 'DOURO' as 'DORO' or 'DORIO', and 'QUINTA DO PORIRA' is somewhat present but often misspelled or mangled, failing to meet the exact text requirement for three of the phrases."}, {"statement": "Visible cork surfaces show natural cork grain, pores, cracks, or wear marks.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures of the corks clearly exhibit natural grain, pitting, and characteristic wear."}, {"statement": "The visible color palette is dominated by beige cork tones with black or brown printing.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The color scheme primarily consists of beige cork hues accented by dark text and occasional reddish-purple wine stains."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits fused corks, broken cylindrical forms, or other impossible cork geometry.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The corks are distinct and appear as individual cylindrical objects without fusion."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits non-cork objects, floating scene text, watermarks, or logos outside the cork labels.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects, floating text, or watermarks are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated corks with repeated unique labels, end patterns, or textures that suggest cloning.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each cork appears to have unique markings, textures, and orientations without obvious signs of cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or visibly garbled lettering on one or more cork labels.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Several corks feature nonsensical or misrendered text, such as 'ROIRÃO', 'RUUTRRA', and 'QURIRO'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent shadows or highlights across neighboring corks.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent with a single top-down light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent corks or printed labels.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and boundaries between the corks are distinct and well-defined without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 44, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main quote is perfectly rendered, but many surrounding corks contain garbled or misspelled text, failing to accurately capture the specific requested brand names.", "net_score": 36, "final_score": 70.6}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 1465, "image_id": "393d4a54-1eda-4d75-8e08-f4b4402889ce", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a pile of at least 10 wine corks.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are dozens of wine corks visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is top-down or overhead.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is taken from a directly overhead, top-down perspective."}, {"statement": "The framing is close-up, with corks occupying at least 80% of the image area.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The corks fill almost the entire frame, leaving only small gaps showing the wooden surface below."}, {"statement": "A cork near the lower center displays the case-insensitive phrase \"LIFE IS TOO SHORT TO DRINK BAD WINE\".", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A cork in the lower center clearly displays the phrase 'LIFE IS TOO SHORT TO DRINK BAD WINE'."}, {"statement": "Visible cork labels include all four of these case-insensitive strings somewhere in the image: \"ESPORAO\" or \"ESPORÃO\", \"ROLA\", \"DOURO\", and \"QUINTA DO PORIRA\".", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The image contains 'ESPORÃO', 'ROLA', and 'DOURO', but 'QUINTA DO PORIRA' is missing (it shows 'QUINTA DO PÔPA' and others, but not 'PORIRA')."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated by direct light, shown by distinct highlights and shadows on multiple corks.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are clear highlights on the tops of the corks and strong shadows cast beneath them, indicating direct lighting."}, {"statement": "The image palette is dominated by beige with muted brown and black tones.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The color scheme consists almost entirely of beige corks, brown wooden background, and black text/markings."}, {"statement": "Multiple corks show clearly visible porous, worn cork texture.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The corks have highly detailed, realistic porous textures with some dark staining and wear."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed corks with fused bodies, impossible holes, or non-cylindrical geometry inconsistent with real wine corks.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The corks all appear to be well-formed cylinders with realistic shapes and ends."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits salient extraneous items such as bottles, glasses, hands, people, captions, watermarks, or logos that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no extraneous objects; only corks and a wooden background are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned corks with unnaturally identical shapes, markings, or textures.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "While some brands repeat, the individual corks have distinct shapes, wear patterns, and alignments, avoiding a cloned appearance."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, unreadable, or nonsensical rendered text on visible cork labels.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Some text is garbled, such as 'DUINRO' instead of a real word, and some blurry/nonsense characters on partially visible corks."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadow directions, highlights, or reflections that are inconsistent with a single direct light source.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent across the image, suggesting a single light source from the top-left."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent corks or between corks and the background surface.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The edges of the corks are sharp and distinct from one another and the background."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 42, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image is generally high quality but misses one of the specifically requested text strings and contains some minor text garbling.", "net_score": 35, "final_score": 72.9}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 1976, "image_id": "2823e601-3246-40a7-843b-cb3b0666ab18", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A military aircraft is the primary subject of the image.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large gray military cargo aircraft dominates the center of the image."}, {"statement": "The aircraft is on a runway or airport tarmac with its landing gear on the ground.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The aircraft is parked on a paved tarmac with its wheels resting on the ground."}, {"statement": "The identifier \"ZZ177\" is visibly rendered on the aircraft.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'ZZ177' is clearly visible on the tail of the aircraft."}, {"statement": "A sign beside the aircraft displays the numeral \"2\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A black sign with a white '2' is visible on the ground near the aircraft."}, {"statement": "The entire aircraft, including both the nose and the tail, is fully contained within the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The entire plane, from nose to tail, is visible within the image boundaries."}, {"statement": "The aircraft casts a visible shadow onto the ground.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A dark shadow is cast directly beneath the aircraft onto the tarmac."}, {"statement": "A large green hill appears in the background behind the aircraft.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large, green, rolling hill forms the backdrop behind the plane."}, {"statement": "Multiple houses are visible on the hill in the background.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Numerous white and light-colored houses are scattered across the green hillside."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible aircraft geometry, such as detached wings, fused landing gear, or distorted engine nacelles.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The aircraft's structure appears structurally sound and well-rendered."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated foreground people, service vehicles, unrelated signs, or watermark/logo overlays not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected people, vehicles, or watermarks are present in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or visibly cloned scene elements, such as repeated aircraft, repeated runway signs, or copy-pasted houses or cars.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene elements appear distinct without obvious cloning artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or illegible rendered text in the \"ZZ177\" aircraft marking or the \"2\" sign.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the 'ZZ177' and the '2' are clearly legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows that are inconsistent across the aircraft, runway, and background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent with a bright daytime setting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the aircraft, runway, and hillside background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and colors remain distinct between the plane, ground, and background."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 60, "total_positive_weight_possible": 60, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 60, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 1976, "image_id": "2823e601-3246-40a7-843b-cb3b0666ab18", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A gray military aircraft is parked on a runway.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large gray military-style aircraft is parked on the tarmac/runway in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The full aircraft, including nose, tail, wings, and landing gear, is visible within the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "INCOMPLETE_TRAJECTORY", "explanation": "The right wing and the top of the tail are cut off by the edges of the frame."}, {"statement": "The aircraft displays the identifier \"ZZ177\" on its fuselage or tail.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the tail reads 'ZZI7/' and the text on the fuselage reads 'ZZAV'."}, {"statement": "A sign beside the aircraft displays the number \"2\".", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two signs with the number '2' visible beside the aircraft."}, {"statement": "A visible shadow from the aircraft falls on the ground.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A shadow is cast under the fuselage and wings onto the runway."}, {"statement": "A green hill spans most of the background behind the aircraft.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large green hill dominates the background."}, {"statement": "Many houses are visible across the hillside in the background.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Numerous houses are scattered across the green hillside."}, {"statement": "Blue sky is visible along the top of the image.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A patch of blue sky with clouds is visible at the very top of the frame."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or fused aircraft parts, such as impossible landing gear, engine, wing, or tail geometry.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The right wing appears detached or misaligned, and the landing gear setup is structurally inconsistent with standard aircraft."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated people, additional aircraft, watermarks, or commercial logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected people, extra aircraft, or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned houses, cars, or aircraft components with unnaturally repeated patterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning artifacts among the houses or cars."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits additional illegible or garbled text or glyphs beyond the requested \"ZZ177\" and the number \"2\".", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The aircraft features garbled text like 'RIIINZIEE' and other nonsensical symbols."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, shadow direction, or reflections across the aircraft, runway, and hillside.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the aircraft, runway, cars, and hillside houses.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures remain distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 34, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The aircraft is partially cropped, features severe text garbling, and has geometric artifacts like misaligned engines.", "net_score": 22, "final_score": 44.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 1976, "image_id": "2823e601-3246-40a7-843b-cb3b0666ab18", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a military aircraft.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A gray military aircraft is prominently displayed in the center."}, {"statement": "The aircraft rests on its landing gear on a runway.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The aircraft's wheels are touching the runway surface."}, {"statement": "The full aircraft, including the nose, both wings, and tail, is visible within the frame.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The entire plane fits within the borders of the image."}, {"statement": "The aircraft or a sign immediately beside it displays the text \"ZZ177\".", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A sign on the grass beside the runway clearly reads 'ZZ177'."}, {"statement": "A sign beside the aircraft displays the digit \"2\".", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Next to the 'ZZ177' text on the sign, there is a clear number '2'."}, {"statement": "The aircraft casts a visible shadow on the ground.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Dark shadows are cast underneath the aircraft on the runway."}, {"statement": "A green hill spans most of the background behind the aircraft.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large, forested green hill forms the backdrop."}, {"statement": "Multiple houses are visible on the background hillside.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several houses dot the lower portion of the green hill."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as malformed wings, fused landing gear, or impossible engine or tail attachments on the aircraft.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The aircraft has unusual geometric attachments and struts near the landing gear that appear somewhat fused or mechanically non-sensical."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, unrelated aircraft, watermarks, logos, or additional signage not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or cloned houses, cars, runway markings, or aircraft components.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning artifacts are seen in the background or foreground elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or inconsistent rendered text, including \"ZZ177\" or \"2\".", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'ZZ177' and '2' are rendered legibly."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadow direction, or reflections inconsistent with the rest of the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent throughout the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the aircraft, runway, grass, hill, or houses.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and boundaries between objects are distinctly rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 38, "total_positive_weight_possible": 38, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image fulfills all positive prompt requirements but includes minor geometric artifacts on the aircraft's undercarriage.", "net_score": 33, "final_score": 86.8}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 1976, "image_id": "2823e601-3246-40a7-843b-cb3b0666ab18", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a military aircraft on a runway.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large grey military aircraft is prominently shown parked on a paved runway."}, {"statement": "The aircraft displays the identifier \"ZZ177\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'ZZ177' is clearly painted on the tail section of the aircraft."}, {"statement": "A sign located beside the aircraft displays the single digit \"2\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white sign with a clear black '2' is situated on the right side of the frame near the runway."}, {"statement": "The full aircraft is visible within the frame without any part cropped out.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The entire airplane, from nose to tail and wingtips, fits entirely inside the image boundaries."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint is at ground level rather than from an elevated or aerial angle.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is low to the ground, typical of a person standing on the runway."}, {"statement": "The background includes a large green hill.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent, vegetation-covered green hill rises behind the runway."}, {"statement": "Multiple houses are visible on the hill in the background.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several houses with white walls and red roofs dot the hillside behind the plane."}, {"statement": "The sky is visible along the top of the image.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A cloudy sky fills the upper portion of the background."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible aircraft geometry, such as malformed wings, fused engine parts, distorted landing gear, or an incoherent tail structure.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The aircraft's overall structure, including wings, tail, engines, and gear, appears coherent and plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, additional aircraft, unrelated signs, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no unexpected people, extra planes, or unwanted logos present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned houses, cars, signs, or aircraft parts with unnaturally repeated shapes or placements.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The houses and background elements appear varied enough to not look like direct copy-paste clones."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered text or digits on visible aircraft markings or signage.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the 'ZZ177' on the plane and the '2' on the sign are perfectly legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow behavior inconsistent across the aircraft, runway, hill, or sign.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows fall naturally from the aircraft and sign, matching the lighting direction."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between the aircraft, runway pavement, grass, hill vegetation, or sign.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and materials remain distinct, with no apparent bleeding between the plane, ground, or sky."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 54, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 54, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 1981, "image_id": "e6934104-9944-4f9d-8f07-3e74d64679eb", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly 10 geese appear in the main foreground or midground action group.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are 7 geese in the main foreground action group taking off."}, {"statement": "Exactly 3 geese appear in the distant background, separate from the main action group.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are only 2 geese in the distant background."}, {"statement": "The geese in the main action group are visibly larger than the geese in the distant background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The foreground taking-off geese are noticeably larger than the background swimming ones due to perspective."}, {"statement": "The main action group geese are taking off from the water, with bodies above the surface and feet contacting or skimming the water.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main group is actively taking off with wings raised and feet touching or lifting from the water surface."}, {"statement": "The main action group geese are oriented toward the same side of the frame, indicating travel in one shared direction.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All taking-off geese are facing left and slightly forward, moving in a unified direction."}, {"statement": "Visible splashes or bubbles are present on the water directly under or behind the taking-off geese.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Prominent water splashes are visible beneath the feet of the launching geese."}, {"statement": "The water in the scene is predominantly whitish blue.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The water surface is colored in light, whitish-blue and greyish tones."}, {"statement": "The geese are predominantly brown-toned.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geese are primarily covered in brown and tan plumage."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on the geese, such as fused wings, extra legs, or malformed beaks.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "Several foreground geese show wing melds, confused limb placements, and extra feet/legs."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated people, boats, signs, text, watermarks, logos, or non-goose animals not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no hallucinations of extraneous objects or other animals."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned geese that appear unnaturally repeated.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geese vary slightly in pose and shading, lacking obvious cloning patterns."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections, shadows, or splash patterns that do not match the geese positions or the scene lighting.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Splashes and lighting appear consistent with the action and environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between feathers, water, and splashes.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Feathers, water, and splash textures remain visually distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 31, "total_positive_weight_possible": 49, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model failed the requested counts, generating 7 foreground and 2 background geese instead of 10 and 3, and introduced anatomical artifacts among the tightly grouped birds.", "net_score": 23, "final_score": 46.9}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 1981, "image_id": "e6934104-9944-4f9d-8f07-3e74d64679eb", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly 10 geese in the main foreground or midground group.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are 8 geese visible taking off in the main group."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly 3 smaller geese in the background.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are only 2 geese visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The main group geese are depicted taking off from the water surface.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geese in the foreground are shown with wings spread, rising from the water."}, {"statement": "The main group geese are oriented toward the same direction of travel.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All taking-off geese are facing and moving towards the right side of the image."}, {"statement": "The water around the taking-off geese contains visible bubbles or splashing.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Splashing water and trails are clearly visible beneath the geese."}, {"statement": "The water is rendered in a whitish blue tone.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The water has a light, whitish-blue appearance reflecting the sky."}, {"statement": "The geese are rendered predominantly in brown tones.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plumage of the geese is mainly brown and greyish-brown."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit with soft natural daylight.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft and even, suggesting a natural outdoor setting."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts on one or more geese, such as extra legs, fused wings, malformed beaks, or impossible body geometry.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "Several wings overlap in physically impossible ways, and some wing joints appear disjointed or fused."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous subjects or elements not implied by the prompt, such as other animals, people, boats, signs, text, watermarks, or logos.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements like boats or text are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned geese with unnaturally repeated poses, wing shapes, or feather patterns.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The poses and wing positions of the geese vary reasonably well."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadows or water reflections that do not match the geese positions or the scene lighting.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections on the water generally correspond to the birds above."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between geese, water, and shoreline vegetation.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between the geese, water, and background vegetation remain distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 27, "total_positive_weight_possible": 45, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image fails to produce the correct number of geese in both the foreground and background, and suffers from anatomical artifacts in the wings.", "net_score": 19, "final_score": 42.2}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 1981, "image_id": "e6934104-9944-4f9d-8f07-3e74d64679eb", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly 10 discernible full-sized geese as the main subjects.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are only 7 visible full-sized geese in the foreground, not 10."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly 3 discernible smaller geese in the far background.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are 3 small geese visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The full-sized geese are depicted taking off from the water surface in active motion.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main geese have their wings spread and are actively leaving the water surface."}, {"statement": "The full-sized geese are oriented to travel in the same direction.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All the geese in the foreground are facing and moving towards the right side of the frame."}, {"statement": "Splashes or bubbles are visible on the water around the taking-off geese.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Splashes of water are clearly visible beneath the geese taking off."}, {"statement": "The water is rendered in a whitish blue hue.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The water in the background has a whitish-blue color."}, {"statement": "The geese are predominantly brown.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geese are primarily brown in color."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit with soft natural daylight, without a strong artificial color cast.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears to be natural and soft."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric defects in any goose, such as missing, fused, or impossibly shaped wings, legs, necks, or beaks.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "Some of the geese in the cluster appear to have merged or confused wings, making it difficult to distinguish individual bodies."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects or markings not implied by the prompt, such as people, boats, signs, text, watermarks, or logos.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects or markings are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned geese with unnaturally repeated poses, body parts, or feather patterns.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geese show sufficient variation in pose and appearance."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadows or reflections on the water that do not correspond to the geese or the scene lighting.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections on the water appear consistent with the subjects."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent wings, bodies, and water.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "There is visual confusion and blending of wings among the clustered geese."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 37, "total_positive_weight_possible": 47, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image contains an incorrect number of geese and exhibits some anatomical confusion where their bodies overlap.", "net_score": 25, "final_score": 53.2}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 1981, "image_id": "e6934104-9944-4f9d-8f07-3e74d64679eb", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly 10 mature geese.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are 7 distinct mature geese visible taking off."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly 3 small geese.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly 3 small geese visible in the background."}, {"statement": "Every small goose shown is positioned behind the mature flock in the background.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The 3 small geese are positioned behind the main flock in the background."}, {"statement": "The mature geese are depicted leaving the water in takeoff.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mature geese are shown with wings spread and splashing as they take off from the water."}, {"statement": "The mature geese occupy one contiguous flock rather than two or more separated groups.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mature geese are closely grouped together in a single flock."}, {"statement": "The mature geese face and move in the same direction.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All mature geese are facing and moving towards the right side of the image."}, {"statement": "Visible splashes or bubbles appear on the water around the taking-off mature geese.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Splashes are clearly visible around the feet of the taking-off geese."}, {"statement": "The mature geese are predominantly brown.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bodies of the mature geese are brown."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed goose anatomy, such as extra or missing wings, legs, feet, heads, necks, or beaks.", "weight": -9, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "Several mature geese have merged or malformed wings and bodies, particularly in the middle of the flock."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unrelated extraneous elements such as people, other animal species, boats, buildings, signs, text, logos, or watermarks.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned geese with unnaturally repeated poses, wing shapes, or body markings.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The poses and details of the geese appear varied, not duplicated."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections, shadows, or splash patterns that do not match the geese's positions and motion on the water.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The splashes and water disturbance match the motion of the geese."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where feathers, wings, splashes, and water meet.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "There is some smearing and fusion of feathers and bodies in the dense middle section of the flock."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 42, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image has the wrong number of mature geese and exhibits anatomical merging within the dense flock.", "net_score": 30, "final_score": 57.7}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 2189, "image_id": "69fc9b8b-c85d-42da-a8f9-7958d97aed2f", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The main roadside sign reads WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign on the right clearly reads 'WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA'."}, {"statement": "The main welcome sign is positioned beside the road.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The large sign is positioned on the snowy shoulder next to the road."}, {"statement": "The road surface is covered with snow.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The road on the left side of the image is covered in snow with visible tire tracks."}, {"statement": "The main welcome sign is heavily covered with snow.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A thick layer of snow rests on top of the main sign."}, {"statement": "Snow-laden trees are visible around the roadside scene.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Numerous evergreen and deciduous trees are heavily coated in snow throughout the scene."}, {"statement": "Exactly two additional roadside signs are visible on the left side of the image.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are three additional smaller signs visible on the left side of the road, not two."}, {"statement": "The background includes a clear sky.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sky above the trees is clear and uniform."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered mostly in black and white with only small localized color accents.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is mostly grayscale, except for the red, white, and blue on the middle smaller sign."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible geometry in the sign faces or their support posts.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signs and their posts appear structurally sound and geometrically consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous text, people, vehicles, buildings, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected people, vehicles, buildings, or watermarks are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits cloned roadside signs or trees with obviously repeated identical patterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The trees and signs look distinct and do not show obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or illegible lettering on one or more visible signs.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the two smaller leftmost signs is completely garbled and illegible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting direction or shadow behavior across the snow, signs, and trees.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the snowy landscape."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits texture smearing that blurs the boundary between snow and adjacent sign or tree surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between snow and solid objects like signs and trees remain relatively sharp."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 46, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image contains an incorrect number of background signs and the text on those smaller signs is garbled.", "net_score": 40, "final_score": 76.9}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 2189, "image_id": "69fc9b8b-c85d-42da-a8f9-7958d97aed2f", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The largest roadside sign includes the text \"Welcome to the United States of America\".", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The sign reads 'Welcome to the States United States of America'."}, {"statement": "A snow-covered road is visible next to the largest sign.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A plowed road with snowy edges is visible next to the signs."}, {"statement": "Exactly two additional signs are visible to the left of the largest sign.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are more than two signs visible to the left of the main sign in the distance."}, {"statement": "The largest sign contains tree illustrations.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The largest sign features an illustration of a snow-covered pine tree."}, {"statement": "The surrounding trees are heavily coated with snow.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pine trees behind the signs are heavily dusted with snow."}, {"statement": "The background sky is clear rather than overcast or snowy.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sky is blue with some light clouds, generally clear."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered predominantly in black and white.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The image is rendered in full color, with a blue sky and natural lighting, not black and white."}, {"statement": "An American flag in the scene retains visible color.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The American flag designs on the smaller signs are in color."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible geometry in the roadside signs, their borders, or their support posts.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The middle sign has a wavy, non-rectangular shape."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous vehicles, people, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There are small vehicles visible in the distance on the road."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned trees or sign faces with obviously repeated patterns.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning of trees or signs is present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering on any of the roadside signs.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the furthest left visible sign is garbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows on the snow, signs, or trees.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear natural."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between snow, sign surfaces, and trees.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials appear distinct and appropriate."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 26, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -17, "failure_count": 3, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The main text has a grammatical error, the black and white constraint was ignored, and there are extra signs and garbled text.", "net_score": 9, "final_score": 18.8}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 2189, "image_id": "69fc9b8b-c85d-42da-a8f9-7958d97aed2f", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image includes a main roadside sign that says WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent blue sign on the right clearly reads 'WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA'."}, {"statement": "The main welcome sign is positioned beside a snow-covered road.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign stands on a snowbank next to a plowed road."}, {"statement": "Snow visibly rests on the top or face of the main welcome sign.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A layer of snow sits on the top edge of the main blue sign."}, {"statement": "Snow-covered trees occupy the area behind or around the main welcome sign.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Heavy, snow-laden evergreen branches hang over and behind the sign."}, {"statement": "Exactly two additional roadside signs appear to the left of the main welcome sign.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two smaller signs visible in the distance along the left side of the road."}, {"statement": "The overall image is predominantly monochrome, with most of the scene rendered in black, white, or gray tones.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The image is in full color, not predominantly monochrome; the main sign is a bright blue."}, {"statement": "The middle of the three visible roadside signs contains visible color.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The middle sign is green with a colored flag."}, {"statement": "A colored American flag is visible in the scene.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An American flag is painted on the middle sign."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in one or more roadside signs, signposts, or road edges.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signs and posts are structurally sound and appropriately placed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, buildings, watermarks, logos, or unrelated text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There appears to be a faint vehicle or shape far down the road on the left."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned trees, signs, or snowbanks that repeat unnaturally.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The snow and trees look natural without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on one or more roadside signs.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the two smaller signs to the left is completely garbled and unreadable."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent light direction, shadow behavior, or reflections across the snow, signs, and trees.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting is diffuse and consistent with an overcast, snowy day."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the signs, snow, trees, and road.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and boundaries between snow, metal, and trees are clear."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 42, "total_positive_weight_possible": 46, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -13, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image failed the monochrome constraint by rendering the main sign in bright blue, and features severely garbled text on the background signs.", "net_score": 29, "final_score": 63.0}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 2189, "image_id": "69fc9b8b-c85d-42da-a8f9-7958d97aed2f", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A main roadside sign displays the phrase \"WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The large sign on the right clearly reads 'WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA'."}, {"statement": "The main welcome sign stands beside a snow-covered road.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A snow-covered road runs alongside the sign on the left side of the image."}, {"statement": "The main welcome sign contains tree graphics.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Silhouettes of pine trees flank the American flag graphic on the main sign."}, {"statement": "Exactly two additional roadside signs appear to the left of the main welcome sign.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two smaller rectangular signs are positioned to the left of the main sign along the road."}, {"statement": "The main welcome sign is heavily dusted with snow.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top frame and edges of the main welcome sign are covered in accumulated snow."}, {"statement": "The background shows a clear sky.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sky is a smooth, featureless gradient indicating a clear sky."}, {"statement": "The image is predominantly black-and-white or monochrome.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The landscape, sky, and signs are rendered in grayscale."}, {"statement": "An American flag or flag motif is visible with red and blue color accents.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A colored American flag is flying on a pole, and a colored flag graphic is on the main sign."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in the signs, flagpole, road, or horizon line.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The structural elements appear solid and geometrically sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, buildings, animals, logos, or watermarks not implied by the snowy roadside scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected elements are present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned signs, flags, or landscape elements that appear unnaturally repeated.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious cloned elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on the welcome sign or on the two additional roadside signs.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the leftmost sign ('NORTH... ENTER... AHEAD') is partially nonsensical, and the middle sign ('SPEED LIMIT... 50...') is obscured and slightly jumbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, shadows, or reflections for a single outdoor snowy scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between snow, wood, metal, sky, and flag surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are well-defined and separated."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 46, "total_positive_weight_possible": 46, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main sign and scene constraints are well-executed, but the text on the secondary signs to the left is garbled and nonsensical.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 84.8}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 2474, "image_id": "767a9fee-c04a-4c60-86d4-21e606bc8e9c", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a wooden direction sign in the foreground.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden direction sign is clearly visible in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The direction sign includes arrows labeled \"Reception,\" \"Huberta,\" \"Indlovu,\" \"River Lodge,\" \"Umthombe,\" and \"Lions.\"", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All the requested labels are present and correctly spelled on the arrows."}, {"statement": "A safari vehicle is positioned behind the direction sign.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A vehicle is parked in the background behind the sign."}, {"statement": "The safari vehicle has a beige tent mounted on it.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A beige tent structure is mounted on the roof of the vehicle."}, {"statement": "The safari vehicle is blue.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The vehicle body is blue."}, {"statement": "The background contains abundant green grass.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a lot of green grass in the background and middle ground."}, {"statement": "The background contains trees.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Trees are visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The framing includes the ground at the bottom of the image, the full height of the direction sign, and a portion of clear blue sky at the top.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The framing captures the ground, the entire sign, and the blue sky."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or malformed geometry in the vehicle body, the tent, or the wooden sign structure.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the vehicle, tent, and sign appears normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, animals, objects, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or hallucinations are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned major scene elements, such as multiple safari vehicles, repeated signboards, or obviously repeated vegetation patches.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious cloned or duplicated elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering on the direction-sign labels.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lettering is clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the sign, vehicle, tent, and landscape.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the wooden sign, the vehicle, the tent fabric, and the surrounding grass.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct and clean."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 50, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 50, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 2474, "image_id": "767a9fee-c04a-4c60-86d4-21e606bc8e9c", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The full wooden direction sign, including its post, is visible in the foreground.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "INCOMPLETE_TRAJECTORY", "explanation": "The signpost is cut off at the bottom and the top, so the full sign is not visible."}, {"statement": "The sign includes the labels \"Reception,\" \"Huberta,\" \"Indlovu,\" \"River Lodge,\" \"Umthombe,\" and \"Lions.\"", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All specified labels are present and correctly spelled on the sign arrows."}, {"statement": "A safari tour vehicle is parked behind the direction sign.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A vehicle is clearly visible parked in the background behind the sign."}, {"statement": "The safari vehicle is blue.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The vehicle has a blue body."}, {"statement": "A beige tent is mounted on top of the safari vehicle.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a beige roof tent mounted on top of the blue vehicle."}, {"statement": "The background contains abundant green grass.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The surrounding landscape features plenty of green grass."}, {"statement": "Trees are visible in the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Trees are present behind the vehicle and grassy area."}, {"statement": "A portion of blue sky is visible at the top of the image.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Blue sky is visible above the trees and sign."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible geometry in the safari vehicle, the roof tent, or the wooden sign.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The vehicle, tent, and sign show realistic and consistent geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, animals, buildings, signs, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "There is illegible, hallucinated text on the vehicle's license plate area."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned safari vehicles, tents, or entire direction signs not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no unwanted duplicates of the main subjects."}, {"statement": "The sign text exhibits illegible letters, garbled glyphs, or unreadable destination names.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the sign arrows is clear, legible, and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the sign, vehicle, tent, and landscape.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between the wooden sign, the vehicle, the tent, and the surrounding vegetation.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and well-rendered with no bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 37, "total_positive_weight_possible": 47, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -4, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The signpost is slightly cropped at the top and bottom, and there is garbled text on the vehicle's license plate.", "net_score": 33, "final_score": 70.2}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 2474, "image_id": "767a9fee-c04a-4c60-86d4-21e606bc8e9c", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A wooden multi-arrow direction signpost occupies the foreground of the image.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A multi-arrow signpost is prominently placed in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The signpost shows destination labels for \"Reception\", \"Huberta\", \"Indlovu\", \"River Lodge\", \"Umthombe\", and \"Lions\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All requested destination names are present on the sign arrows."}, {"statement": "A safari tour vehicle with a roof tent or canopy is parked behind the signpost.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A safari-style vehicle with a canopy roof is parked in the background behind the sign."}, {"statement": "The safari vehicle has a blue body with a beige roof tent or canopy.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "The vehicle body is green, not blue."}, {"statement": "Abundant green grass fills the field area of the scene.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The ground is covered in lush green grass."}, {"statement": "Trees form the background behind the field.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A dense line of trees forms the background of the image."}, {"statement": "The full height of the direction signpost is visible in the frame.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "INCOMPLETE_TRAJECTORY", "explanation": "The top of the signpost is cropped off, and the post continues downwards out of frame."}, {"statement": "A visible strip of sky appears at the top of the image.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A strip of blue sky is visible above the trees."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts in the safari vehicle or signpost, such as fused supports, impossible arrow shapes, or malformed wheels.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The vehicle and signpost geometry appear structurally sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, animals, buildings, extra signs, logos, watermarks, or other text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There appears to be a figure or passenger inside the safari vehicle, and some extra blurry text on the vehicle door."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated destination arrows or repeated destination names on the signpost beyond the single occurrences implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "The label 'RIVER LODGE' appears twice on two adjacent arrows."}, {"statement": "The destination text on the signpost exhibits illegible, garbled, or broken glyphs.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the signpost is clearly legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible daylight lighting, reflections, or shadows on the vehicle, signpost, or ground.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear natural and consistent for an outdoor daylight scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent objects such as the signpost, vehicle, grass, and trees.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and object boundaries are well-defined without bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 41, "total_positive_weight_possible": 49, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -11, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The main issues are an incorrect vehicle color, cropped signpost, and a duplicated 'River Lodge' sign arrow.", "net_score": 30, "final_score": 61.2}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 2474, "image_id": "767a9fee-c04a-4c60-86d4-21e606bc8e9c", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A wooden direction sign appears in the foreground.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden direction sign is prominently placed in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The sign arrows are labeled Reception, Huberta, Indlovu, River Lodge, Umthombe, and Lions.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign arrows correctly display the requested names."}, {"statement": "A parked safari tour vehicle is positioned behind the direction sign.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A safari vehicle is parked directly behind the wooden sign."}, {"statement": "The vehicle body is blue.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The body of the vehicle is blue."}, {"statement": "The vehicle has a beige tent mounted on top.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A beige tent is mounted on the roof of the vehicle."}, {"statement": "The background contains abundant green grass.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The surrounding landscape features plenty of green grass."}, {"statement": "The background contains multiple trees.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several trees are visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The framing shows the sign from its base at ground level to its top, with a portion of sky visible above.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "INCOMPLETE_TRAJECTORY", "explanation": "The base of the sign is cropped out at the bottom of the frame."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or warped geometry in the vehicle, tent, or direction sign, such as fused parts or nonfunctional shapes.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The objects appear structurally sound and correctly formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, watermarks, logos, or superimposed text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a duplicated or cloned copy of the vehicle or of the full direction sign.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated vehicles or signs."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering on any of the sign arrows.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the sign is perfectly legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, shadows, or reflections across the sign, vehicle, tent, and landscape.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the wood sign, fabric tent, vehicle body, grass, and trees.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are cleanly distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 49, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The base of the sign is slightly cropped, but the image is otherwise accurate.", "net_score": 49, "final_score": 89.1}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 2985, "image_id": "d6737c9d-2c42-4b4c-9a68-87f41dbaad46", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image contains a brown road sign in the foreground.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large brown sign is prominently positioned in the center foreground."}, {"statement": "The road sign is mounted on a metal pole.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign is attached to a gray metal pole."}, {"statement": "The sign contains legible English text reading \"Temple of Epikourios Apollonas\".", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The English text reads \"Temple of Eρikourios Appllomıaos\", containing garbled letters."}, {"statement": "The sign includes a separate line of text in Greek script.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is no separate line of distinct Greek text; the text on the sign is a mix of English and garbled characters."}, {"statement": "The sign displays the number \"61\".", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The number 61 is visible in the bottom center of the sign."}, {"statement": "A UNESCO World Heritage emblem appears on the left side of the sign.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a logo resembling a UNESCO emblem with text 'UNESCO UNESCO WORLD HERITAGE' on the left side."}, {"statement": "A UNESCO logo appears in the lower-right corner of the sign.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A smaller UNESCO logo is present in the lower right corner."}, {"statement": "An old stone wall appears beside the sign.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large stone wall runs along the right side of the image, next to the sign."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits visibly warped geometry in the signboard, pole, stone wall, or buildings.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the main structures appears sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, additional signs, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned road signs, poles, buildings, or crosses not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious duplication of main elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or unreadable rendered text or glyphs in the sign lettering, the number \"61\", or the UNESCO marks.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text 'Temple of Eρikourios Appllomıaos' is garbled, and the UNESCO logo on the left contains 'UNECO'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent shadow directions across the sign, pole, wall, and buildings.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows appear consistent with daylight."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits texture smearing or material confusion between adjacent objects such as the sign, pole, stone wall, vegetation, and buildings.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures are distinct and materials are well-separated."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 32, "total_positive_weight_possible": 47, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image suffers from significant text garbling, rendering the main sign text and logos incorrectly, and missing the requested Greek text line entirely.", "net_score": 24, "final_score": 51.1}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 2985, "image_id": "d6737c9d-2c42-4b4c-9a68-87f41dbaad46", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a brown directional road sign.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A brown directional road sign is prominently displayed in the center of the image."}, {"statement": "The sign is mounted on metal poles.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign is supported by two grey metal poles."}, {"statement": "The sign includes the English phrase \"Temple of Epikourios Apollonas\".", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The sign reads 'Temple of Exipkcrrioz Appllolios' and 'Epikurios Apollonas', missing the exact spelling requested."}, {"statement": "The sign includes at least one line of Greek script.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is no Greek script on the sign; the text is entirely in Latin characters."}, {"statement": "The number \"61\" appears on the sign.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The number '61' is visible on the bottom part of the sign."}, {"statement": "A UNESCO World Heritage emblem or logo appears on the sign.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A UNESCO emblem is visible on the bottom left of the sign."}, {"statement": "An old stone wall appears beside or behind the sign.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An old stone wall is situated directly behind the sign."}, {"statement": "A white church-like building with a visible cross appears in the left background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white building with a cross on top is visible in the left background."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits visibly warped or impossible geometry in the road sign, support poles, stone wall, or church structure.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The structural elements, including the sign, poles, wall, and building, have consistent geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits at least one unrelated extraneous object, person, vehicle, watermark, or logo not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "An extra vase-like graphic appears on the right side of the sign."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned major scene elements, such as repeated copies of the sign, church, or UNESCO emblem.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The temple graphic next to the UNESCO text is duplicated, appearing twice."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled Greek or English lettering on the sign.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text contains garbled words like 'Exipkcrrioz', 'Appllolios', and 'B.vourios'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent lighting, shadows, or reflections across the sign and surrounding scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the brown sign, white lettering, stone wall, and vegetation.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors remain distinct without bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 34, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -16, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image suffers from severe text garbling and misses the requested Greek script entirely.", "net_score": 18, "final_score": 34.6}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 2985, "image_id": "d6737c9d-2c42-4b4c-9a68-87f41dbaad46", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The road sign background is brown.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The road sign in the image clearly has a brown background."}, {"statement": "The sign contains the exact English words \"Temple of Epikourios Apollonas\".", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The sign reads 'Temple of Epikourios' on one line and 'Epikourios Apollonas' below, which is a garbled duplication rather than the exact requested phrase on its own."}, {"statement": "The main destination text on the sign includes at least one line in Greek script.", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is no Greek script visible in the main destination text on the sign."}, {"statement": "The sign displays the number \"61\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The number '61' is visible on the right side of the sign."}, {"statement": "A white UNESCO World Heritage emblem appears on the left side of the sign.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white emblem resembling a UNESCO logo is present on the top left of the sign."}, {"statement": "A white UNESCO logo appears in the lower-right corner of the sign.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white UNESCO logo is visible in the lower-right corner of the sign."}, {"statement": "The sign is mounted on a metal pole.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign is attached to a gray metal pole."}, {"statement": "An old stone wall is visible immediately beside the sign.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are stone walls visible in the foreground on the left and in the background on the right beside the sign."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible geometry in the road sign, its border, or its supporting pole.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign, its border, and the pole appear structurally sound without warped geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous stickers, labels, watermarks, or unrelated objects not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is a yellow sticker with an eye icon hallucinated on the metal pole supporting the sign."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned copies of scene elements, such as signs, logos, buildings, crosses, or flowers, that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The UNESCO logo is duplicated, appearing on both the left and right sides of the sign."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, misspelled, or garbled text or glyphs on the road sign or UNESCO markings.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "There is garbled, illegible text beneath both UNESCO logos on the sign."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible daylight lighting or inconsistent shadow directions across the sign, wall, and background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent with a daylight scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent surfaces such as the sign, pole, stone wall, vegetation, or sky.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no apparent color bleeding or texture smearing between distinct materials in the scene."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 35, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -16, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image suffers from significant text generation issues, including missing Greek script, duplicated English text, and garbled text under the duplicated UNESCO logos.", "net_score": 19, "final_score": 36.5}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 2985, "image_id": "d6737c9d-2c42-4b4c-9a68-87f41dbaad46", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image contains a brown directional road sign.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large brown directional road sign is prominently featured in the center of the image."}, {"statement": "The sign includes the English place name \"Temple of Epikourios Apollonas\".", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'TEMPLE OF EPIKOURIOS APOLLONAS' is clearly visible in white on the sign."}, {"statement": "The sign includes a line of Greek-script text.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Greek text is visible above the English translation on the sign."}, {"statement": "The sign includes a UNESCO World Heritage emblem or logo.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A UNESCO-style emblem is present on the left side of the sign."}, {"statement": "The sign includes the number \"61\".", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The number '61' is displayed in a white box on the right side of the sign."}, {"statement": "The sign is mounted on a metal pole.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign is supported by a single grey metal pole."}, {"statement": "An old stone wall is visible beside or directly behind the sign.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A continuous old stone wall runs behind the sign across the midground."}, {"statement": "A white building with a tiled roof is visible in the background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white building featuring a reddish tiled roof is seen in the background on the right."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry in the sign, pole, stone wall, or buildings, such as fused parts, warped edges, or broken topology.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The architectural and structural elements appear coherent without geometric artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, additional signs, or unrelated text, logos, or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unrequested people, vehicles, or unrelated elements are present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned scene elements, such as repeated road signs, poles, crosses, flower pots, or buildings.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious instances of duplicated or cloned objects in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, unreadable, or non-language glyphs in the requested Greek or English sign text or in the number \"61\".", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The requested English and Greek text, as well as the number 61, are legible and accurately rendered."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible daylight lighting or cast shadows that disagree with the rest of the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent with a bright daytime setting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the sign, metal pole, stone wall, vegetation, and buildings.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures and materials of the different objects are distinct and cleanly separated."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 51, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 3259, "image_id": "78c79c46-dcc3-434a-ab46-438355280ee5", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is rendered in a photographic style rather than as an illustration or painting.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image has realistic textures, depth of field, and lighting consistent with a photograph."}, {"statement": "The image is monochrome black and white, with no visible color.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is entirely grayscale."}, {"statement": "An octagonal street sign is visible.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large octagonal sign is centrally featured in the image."}, {"statement": "The sign text reads exactly \"DON'T STOP LOVING\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the sign clearly reads \"DON'T STOP LOVING\"."}, {"statement": "The sign occupies more than 50% of the image height.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign takes up the majority of the vertical space in the frame."}, {"statement": "A bridge silhouette is visible in the background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The blurred shape of a suspension bridge is visible behind the sign."}, {"statement": "The background is visibly blurred relative to the sign.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a strong depth of field effect blurring the background bridge and landscape."}, {"statement": "The lighting is consistent with outdoor natural daylight.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows on the sign suggest outdoor daylight."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in the sign, signpost, or bridge, such as warped edges or structurally inconsistent connections.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign, post, and bridge appear structurally sound with regular geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, additional signs, unrelated text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image contains a second near-identical copy of the street sign that is not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only one street sign is present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits letters on the sign that are malformed, merged together, or otherwise unreadable.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text is crisp, legible, and properly formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadows, highlights, or reflections that are inconsistent across the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and reflections appear consistent and realistic."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits texture smearing or material confusion that blends the sign into the pole or the background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 52, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 3259, "image_id": "78c79c46-dcc3-434a-ab46-438355280ee5", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image uses only grayscale black-and-white tones, with no visible non-neutral colors.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is entirely in black and white."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered in a photographic style rather than as a drawing, painting, or graphic illustration.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image has a realistic photographic appearance."}, {"statement": "An octagonal street sign is shown.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The central object is an octagonal street sign."}, {"statement": "The street sign occupies at least 50% of the image height, creating a close-up composition.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign takes up the majority of the vertical space in the frame."}, {"statement": "The sign includes the phrase \"DON'T STOP LOVING,\" including the apostrophe in \"DON'T.\"", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the sign reads exactly \"DON'T STOP LOVING\"."}, {"statement": "A recognizable bridge silhouette is visible in the background behind the sign.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large bridge structure is visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The bridge in the background is blurred or out of focus relative to the sign.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bridge is rendered with a shallow depth of field, making it blurred."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit as natural outdoor daylight rather than nighttime or indoor lighting.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting indicates natural daytime outdoor conditions."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the sign hardware or bridge structure, such as merged bolts, non-manifold railings, or impossible support connections.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign hardware and bridge structure appear geometrically sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, additional signs, watermarks, logos, or extra text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned copies of the main octagonal sign or its pole.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only one sign and pole are present."}, {"statement": "The sign text exhibits illegible, garbled, or malformed letters or punctuation instead of cleanly readable words.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text is perfectly clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible outdoor lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the sign and bridge.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits texture smearing, edge bleeding, or material confusion where the sign face, border, pole, and background meet.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Edges and textures are cleanly separated."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 56, "total_positive_weight_possible": 56, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 56, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 3259, "image_id": "78c79c46-dcc3-434a-ab46-438355280ee5", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is rendered as a realistic photograph rather than as a drawing, painting, or graphic design.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image features photographic textures, lighting, and depth of field, looking like a real photo."}, {"statement": "The image is monochrome black-and-white with no visible chromatic colors.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The entire image is in black and white grayscale, with no color present."}, {"statement": "The visible street sign has an octagonal shape.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign is clearly a standard eight-sided octagon."}, {"statement": "The street sign displays the exact phrase \"DON'T STOP LOVING\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text \"DON'T STOP LOVING\" is written clearly on the sign."}, {"statement": "The street sign occupies at least 50% of the image height.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The octagonal sign takes up the majority of the vertical space in the frame, well over 50%."}, {"statement": "A bridge structure is visible in the background behind the street sign.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large truss/suspension bridge is clearly visible stretching across the background behind the sign."}, {"statement": "The background is visibly blurred relative to the street sign.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bridge and background landscape are out of focus while the sign is sharp."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit like an outdoor natural-daylight photograph rather than a night scene.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bright sky and diffuse lighting are consistent with daytime."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in the sign border, signpost, or bridge structure.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the sign, post, and bridge appear structurally sound and normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a prominent extraneous person, vehicle, logo, watermark, or unrelated object beyond the street sign, bridge, sky, and landscape background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous people, logos, or objects are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an unintended duplicate of the street sign or an obviously cloned copy of another major object.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is only one sign and no cloned objects."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, distorted, or garbled glyphs within the sign text.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the sign is perfectly legible and correctly formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow behavior inconsistent with one outdoor natural-daylight scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent with a cloudy/overcast outdoor day."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits texture smearing or material confusion between the sign, its pole, the bridge, and the background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and well-rendered, with no smearing or confusion."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 52, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 3259, "image_id": "78c79c46-dcc3-434a-ab46-438355280ee5", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image contains an octagonal street sign.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An octagonal street sign is prominently featured on the right side of the image."}, {"statement": "The street sign text reads DON'T STOP LOVING.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text \"DON'T STOP LOVING\" is clearly written on the sign."}, {"statement": "The image is monochrome black and white rather than color.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is entirely rendered in black and white tones."}, {"statement": "A bridge silhouette is visible in the background.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A bridge structure is visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The bridge in the background is more blurred than the street sign.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background bridge is out of focus compared to the sharp street sign."}, {"statement": "The street sign occupies at least 40% of the image height.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign takes up the majority of the vertical space in the image."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit as outdoor natural daylight rather than night or indoor lighting.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting suggests an overcast outdoor daytime setting."}, {"statement": "The image is wider than it is tall.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image has a landscape orientation."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits visibly warped or impossible geometry in the sign outline, sign pole, or bridge structure.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the sign and bridge appears standard and not warped."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, logos, watermarks, or additional text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or hallucinations are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned signs, bridge sections, or repeated background elements not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no signs of duplication or cloning in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits malformed, overlapping, or unreadable letterforms on the sign.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the sign is clear and well-formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent with a real outdoor daylight photograph.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows appear consistent with a real photograph."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits texture smearing or material confusion between the sign, pole, bridge, and background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 52, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 3407, "image_id": "29a5feda-9fb7-4e88-b233-ab9048bb8514", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene shows the ceiling of a church interior.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly depicts an ornate church ceiling with arches, frescoes, and decorative molding."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint is from below, looking upward at the ceiling.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective is taken looking directly up at the ceiling details."}, {"statement": "A large white shield is centered in the composition.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent white shield shape is positioned squarely in the middle of the ceiling design."}, {"statement": "The large central white shield contains more than one smaller blue shield.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Multiple smaller blue shield-shaped panels are arranged within the large central white shield."}, {"statement": "A golden crown is positioned above the large central white shield.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large, detailed golden crown sits immediately above the top edge of the central white shield."}, {"statement": "Angelic child figures appear on both the left side and the right side of the central shield.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Cherub-like figures with wings are positioned on the upper and lower sections of both the left and right sides of the composition."}, {"statement": "The image includes written text on a banner or scroll below the central shield.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A decorative scroll below the central shield contains legible script reading 'Gloria in Excelsis Deo'."}, {"statement": "At least one of the smaller blue shields contains tiny human or angel figures.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several of the inner blue shields feature miniature painted figures that resemble small humans or angels."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts in the angelic children, such as extra, missing, or fused limbs, hands, fingers, wings, or facial features.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The angel in the lower left has mangled, fused fingers on its raised hand."}, {"statement": "The banner text exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical glyphs instead of coherent lettering.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text reads 'Gloria in Excelsis Deo' with only a minor typo ('Excelss'), remaining highly coherent and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous modern objects, unrelated people, logos, or watermarks beyond the expected ceiling decoration, angels, shield, crown, and banner.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image contains only appropriate classical ceiling decorations and architectural elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned angelic children that appear as exact repeated copies.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each angelic figure has a unique pose and draping, with no exact duplication."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion where the shield, angels, crown, banner, or ceiling ornament meet.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between the plaster, painted elements, and sculptural details remain distinct and clean."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits shadows or highlights on the crown, shield, or angels that imply conflicting light directions.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting remains consistent across the sculptural elements, creating a cohesive sense of depth."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 57, "total_positive_weight_possible": 57, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image successfully captures all requested elements, but suffers from minor anatomical artifacts in one of the angel's hands.", "net_score": 49, "final_score": 86.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 3407, "image_id": "29a5feda-9fb7-4e88-b233-ab9048bb8514", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene depicts a church ceiling interior.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows the ornate, vaulted ceiling of a building consistent with a church."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint looks directly upward from below at the ceiling.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The composition is a directly overhead perspective of a ceiling."}, {"statement": "Most of the visible ceiling surface is covered with decorative painted or carved ornamentation.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Almost every part of the visible surface is covered in intricate plasterwork, paintings, and relief carvings."}, {"statement": "A large white heraldic shield or coat of arms is centered in the composition.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large, predominantly white, ornately framed shield occupies the center of the image."}, {"statement": "The central white shield contains multiple smaller blue shields.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Inside the main white shield are several smaller blue shield-shaped emblems containing figures."}, {"statement": "A grand golden crown is positioned directly above the central shield.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large, detailed golden crown sits immediately above the top center of the white shield."}, {"statement": "Angelic children flank the central shield.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are four winged cherub figures placed around the sides of the central shield."}, {"statement": "At least one line of visible text appears inside or immediately adjacent to the large central shield.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a block of text located directly in the center of the large white shield."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The angelic children exhibit anatomical artifacts such as fused limbs, distorted hands, or malformed wings.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The hands of the angels holding the shield are somewhat melted/fused with the decorative elements, and the bottom left angel's right hand is poorly formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous modern objects, unrelated people, watermarks, or logos that do not belong in an ornate church-ceiling scene.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no modern objects, watermarks, or logos present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or cloned angelic figures with identical poses or textures where distinct figures are expected.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The four angels each have distinct, non-cloned poses."}, {"statement": "The rendered central text appears garbled, nonsensical, or illegible rather than readable script.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text in the center of the shield consists of illegible, pseudo-letterforms rather than readable script."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow direction that is inconsistent across the crown, shield, and surrounding ceiling relief.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent, providing a uniform sense of depth and relief."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between adjacent elements such as the crown, shield, angels, and plaster ornament.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and borders are distinct, without significant smearing or bleeding between elements."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 57, "total_positive_weight_possible": 57, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -11, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The model successfully generated all requested elements, but suffers from garbled text and minor anatomical artifacts on the cherubs' hands.", "net_score": 46, "final_score": 80.7}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 3407, "image_id": "29a5feda-9fb7-4e88-b233-ab9048bb8514", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image depicts an interior church ceiling viewed from directly below.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image shows a low-angle shot looking directly up at a vaulted church ceiling."}, {"statement": "A large white shield-shaped emblem appears near the center of the ceiling composition.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white shield shape is prominently visible, though situated more toward the lower center of the composition than the exact middle."}, {"statement": "The large central white shield contains multiple smaller blue shield motifs inside it.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The central white shield contains faint figures, but no small blue shields."}, {"statement": "Sculpted or carved angel figures surround the central shield as if supporting or holding it up.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Angelic figures with wings are clustered directly below and around the central white shield, appearing to support it."}, {"statement": "A golden crown is positioned above the central white shield.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A golden crown sits directly on top of the white shield."}, {"statement": "Groups of angelic children appear on both the left and right sides of the ceiling.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Groups of painted cherubs/angels are visible in the left and right archways."}, {"statement": "Inscription text appears in the open ceiling area between the left-side and right-side angelic children.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are blocks of text painted on the ceiling panels between the groups of angels."}, {"statement": "The ceiling is predominantly painted in warm pink and soft white, with visible blue accent areas.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The color palette features pink ribs, white panels, and significant blue accents in the lower section and arches."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or fused angel anatomy, such as extra limbs, extra faces, missing body parts, or impossible wing attachments.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The sculpted angels around the shield are heavily fused and distorted, with tangled wings and disembodied faces."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, text, logos, or watermarks that are not part of the church-ceiling scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The model literally rendered a hot air balloon ('balloon shield') at the top center of the ceiling."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or cloned angel figures, faces, wings, or ornaments that should appear as distinct elements.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The figures do not appear to be direct copy-paste clones, despite the fusion issues."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, nonsensical, or unreadable inscription lettering where the ceiling text appears.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text blocks between the angels consist of illegible, pseudo-linguistic characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent shadow directions or highlight placement across the ceiling ribs, crown, shield, and sculpted angels.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between painted ceiling surfaces and carved architectural ornaments.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "The sculptural elements around the shield melt indiscriminately into the painted flat surfaces below."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 47, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -18, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 4, "severity_summary": "The model hallucinated a literal hot air balloon on the ceiling and generated severely fused anatomy in the sculpted angels.", "net_score": 29, "final_score": 52.7}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 3407, "image_id": "29a5feda-9fb7-4e88-b233-ab9048bb8514", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is framed as an upward-looking view of a decorated church ceiling.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows an upward view of a highly decorated church ceiling."}, {"statement": "A large white shield is positioned at the center of the ceiling composition.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent white shield shape is centrally located."}, {"statement": "The central white shield contains multiple smaller blue inset emblems.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Inside the white shield, there are smaller blue oval emblems containing figures."}, {"statement": "Carved angel figures surround the central shield and appear to support it.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Winged angels are positioned around the sides of the central shield."}, {"statement": "A grand golden crown is placed directly above the central shield.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A golden crown is situated right above the main shield."}, {"statement": "Angelic child figures appear on each side of the composition.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Groups of cherubs or angelic children are on both the left and right sides."}, {"statement": "A banner or ribbon between the side angelic children contains visible written text.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Banners bearing text ('GLORIA IN' and 'IN EXCELSIS DEO') are held by the cherubs."}, {"statement": "Warm pink and soft white are the dominant colors of the ceiling decoration.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The overall color palette is dominated by pinks and whites."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed anatomy in human or angelic figures, such as extra limbs, fused hands, distorted faces, or impossible wing attachments.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "Several cherubs on the sides have fused limbs and distorted faces, particularly noticeable in the cluster on the left."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unrelated extraneous objects, extra people, logos, watermarks, or modern items not implied by an ornate church ceiling scene.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unrelated modern objects or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or cloned angelic figures or decorative motifs with identical details that suggest copy artifacts rather than intentional symmetry.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The composition is highly symmetrical but does not show obvious cloning artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical lettering on the banner or any other inscription.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'GLORIA IN EXCELSIS DEO' is clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting or shadows across the shield, crown, figures, and surrounding ceiling architecture.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the gold ornament, white shield, blue insets, and pink plaster surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials and colors are distinctly rendered without significant bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 59, "total_positive_weight_possible": 59, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The generated image successfully incorporates all elements from the prompt, but exhibits anatomical distortions in the cherub clusters.", "net_score": 51, "final_score": 86.4}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 3699, "image_id": "10d31ddb-ace5-4e07-9988-7a0cd599db40", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a pizza placed inside an open carton pizza box with a white paper liner visible beneath it.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A pizza is shown inside a cardboard box resting on white paper."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is directly overhead, creating a bird's-eye view of the pizza and box.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is taken from a top-down, bird's-eye perspective."}, {"statement": "The pizza is cut into triangular slices.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Slice lines are clearly visible, dividing the pizza into triangles."}, {"statement": "The lower part of the image displays the timestamp text \"19/11/2024 19:44\".", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '19/11/2024 19:44' is clearly legible at the bottom of the image."}, {"statement": "The pizza has visible melted white mozzarella cheese.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Melted white cheese is visible across the pizza slices."}, {"statement": "The pizza has visible pink meat slices.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Pink slices of meat are present as toppings."}, {"statement": "The pizza has visible dark mushroom slices.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Dark, sliced mushrooms are scattered across the pizza."}, {"statement": "The pizza has visible bell pepper strips in both green and red.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both green and red bell pepper strips are visible on the pizza."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the pizza, slice cuts, box, or paper liner.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the pizza, slices, box, and paper appears normal and well-defined."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, hands, utensils, logos, watermarks, or text other than the requested timestamp.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra objects, hands, logos, or unrequested text are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned pizza slices, topping pieces, or repeated texture patches.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The toppings and slices look varied and not copy-pasted."}, {"statement": "The timestamp or any other rendered text contains illegible, garbled, or malformed characters.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The requested text is rendered perfectly clearly with no garbling."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows across the pizza, box, and paper liner.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent and plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between the crust, cheese, toppings, box, and paper liner.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and do not bleed into one another."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 52, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 3699, "image_id": "10d31ddb-ace5-4e07-9988-7a0cd599db40", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a pizza placed inside an open carton pizza box with a white paper liner visible underneath it.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A pizza is shown inside a cardboard box resting on a white, slightly textured paper liner."}, {"statement": "The pizza is cut into triangular slices.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pizza is clearly divided into eight distinct triangular slices."}, {"statement": "The scene is shown from a directly overhead bird's-eye viewpoint.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is directly above the pizza box."}, {"statement": "The pizza is topped with melted white mozzarella cheese.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Melted white cheese is visible across all the slices."}, {"statement": "The pizza includes slices of meat.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Pink slices of meat (like ham or Canadian bacon) are placed on the pizza."}, {"statement": "The pizza includes slices of mushrooms.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Sliced mushrooms are visibly scattered on the slices."}, {"statement": "The pizza includes bell pepper strips in both green and red.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both green and red bell pepper strips are present among the toppings."}, {"statement": "The lower part of the image displays the exact timestamp \"19/11/2024 19:44\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '19/11/2024 19:44' is clearly rendered in the bottom right corner."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as fused pizza slices, impossible crust topology, or broken box structure.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The slices are neatly separated and the box structure looks normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, logos, watermarks, or additional text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra objects or unrequested elements are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned pizza slices or toppings with unnaturally repeated shapes.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The distribution and shapes of the toppings appear varied and natural."}, {"statement": "The timestamp text contains illegible, malformed, or garbled characters.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '19/11/2024 19:44' is perfectly legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent across the pizza, box, and paper liner.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows look consistent for an overhead shot."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between cheese, toppings, crust, box, and paper liner.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and materials remain distinct without blending into each other inappropriately."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 59, "total_positive_weight_possible": 59, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 59, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 3699, "image_id": "10d31ddb-ace5-4e07-9988-7a0cd599db40", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a pizza placed inside an open carton box.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A pizza is clearly placed inside a cardboard pizza box."}, {"statement": "A white paper liner is visible beneath the pizza inside the box.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "White paper can be seen underneath the pizza slices."}, {"statement": "The scene is shot from directly above in a bird's-eye view.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is taken from a top-down, bird's-eye view."}, {"statement": "The pizza is cut into triangle slices.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pizza is separated into distinct triangular slices."}, {"statement": "The lower part of the image contains the timestamp text \"19/11/2024 19:44\".", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is no timestamp text visible anywhere in the image."}, {"statement": "Melted white mozzarella cheese is visible on the pizza.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "White melted cheese is visible on the slices."}, {"statement": "Slices of meat are visible on the pizza.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Large slices of pink meat are present on the pizza."}, {"statement": "The pizza includes the requested vegetable toppings: mushroom slices, green bell pepper strips, and red bell pepper strips.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Mushrooms, green peppers, and red peppers are visible toppings."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry or topology in the pizza, slices, box, or toppings, such as fused slices, intersecting objects, or malformed mushroom pieces.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "A long green bell pepper strip in the bottom half of the pizza is bridging across two separate slices with impossible continuity."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, logos, watermarks, or text not implied by the prompt, including any text other than the timestamp \"19/11/2024 19:44\".", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects or unexpected text are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned pizza slices or topping pieces with exactly repeated shape and texture patterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The toppings and slices appear distinct and not cloned."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, unreadable, or malformed timestamp text in the lower part of the image.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Since the text is completely missing, there is no garbled text present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows that are inconsistent across the pizza, carton box, and paper liner.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent ingredients, the crust, the box, or the paper liner.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and ingredients are well-defined without noticeable smearing or color bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 46, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The requested timestamp is entirely missing, and there is a minor geometry artifact with a pepper strip connecting two separate slices.", "net_score": 40, "final_score": 74.1}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 3699, "image_id": "10d31ddb-ace5-4e07-9988-7a0cd599db40", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The pizza is placed in an open carton box with a visible white paper liner at the bottom.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image shows a pizza inside an open cardboard box resting on a piece of white paper."}, {"statement": "The pizza is cut into triangular slices.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Cut lines forming triangular slices are clearly visible radiating from the center of the pizza."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is directly overhead in a bird's-eye view.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is taken from a top-down, bird's-eye perspective."}, {"statement": "The lower part of the image shows the exact timestamp \"19/11/2024 19:44\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '19/11/2024 19:44' is clearly legible in the bottom right corner."}, {"statement": "Melted white mozzarella cheese is visible on the pizza.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Melted white cheese is spread across the pizza beneath the other toppings."}, {"statement": "Slices of meat are visible on the pizza.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Pink slices of meat (appearing like ham or salami) are distributed across the pizza."}, {"statement": "Slices of mushrooms are visible on the pizza.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Dark sliced mushrooms are scattered across the pizza surface."}, {"statement": "Both green bell pepper strips and red bell pepper strips are visible on the pizza.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Strips of both green and red bell peppers are present among the toppings."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or severely distorted geometry in the pizza, slice cuts, carton box, or paper liner.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the box, pizza, and slice cuts appears normal and intact."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, utensils, logos, watermarks, or additional text beyond the requested timestamp.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected objects, text, or watermarks are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned pizza slices or topping pieces not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The slices and toppings look distinct without obvious cloning artifacts."}, {"statement": "The timestamp text contains garbled, broken, or unreadable glyphs.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The timestamp text is cleanly rendered and perfectly legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent across the pizza, box, and paper.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the cheese, toppings, crust, box, and paper.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and materials remain distinct without inappropriate smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 55, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 55, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 3714, "image_id": "a4c04045-b312-46dd-af24-338b1aed7f4e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The upper sign displays the large white numerals \"50.506\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top sign clearly shows the numbers 50.506 in white."}, {"statement": "The lower sign displays the white text \"luteala maxima\" at the top.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'luteala maxima' is visible in white at the top of the lower sign."}, {"statement": "The lower sign displays a large white \"60\" below \"luteala maxima\".", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large white number 60 is positioned beneath 'luteala maxima'."}, {"statement": "The lower sign displays the white text \"km.pe ora\" below the \"60\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'km.pe ora' is rendered in white below the number 60."}, {"statement": "A partially cropped sign on the right edge includes \"DEP\" and part of a large white \"D\".", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A third sign on the right contains the letters 'DEP' and a large white 'D'."}, {"statement": "The visible signs use red faces with white borders.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three signs are red with thin white borders."}, {"statement": "The framing is a very close-up view, with the signs occupying most of the image area.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is a close-up shot dominated by the signs."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit with bright, direct lighting.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is bright and casts clear highlights on the signs."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible sign geometry, such as warped rigid panels, fused borders, or malformed rectangular sign shapes.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign panels have regular, rigid rectangular shapes."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, text, logos, or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no extra objects, people, or text added to the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned sign panels, numerals, or lettering not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No elements appear to be inappropriately duplicated."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, misshapen, or unreadable rendered text in the sign lettering or numerals.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text and numbers are perfectly legible and well-formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent with a single bright direct light source.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and reflections are consistent with a bright outdoor setting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where white letters or borders blend into the red sign surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The contrast between the white letters and red background is sharp and clean."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 52, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 3714, "image_id": "a4c04045-b312-46dd-af24-338b1aed7f4e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The topmost sign displays the number string \"50.506\" in large white characters.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top sign clearly shows '50.506' in large white text on a red background."}, {"statement": "The sign displaying \"60\" is located below the sign displaying \"50.506\".", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign with the number '60' is positioned beneath the '50.506' sign."}, {"statement": "The upper text on the lower sign reads \"luteala maxima\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'luteala maxima' is clearly visible above the '60' on the lower sign."}, {"statement": "The lower sign displays a large white \"60\".", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large white '60' is prominently featured on the lower central sign."}, {"statement": "The lower text on the lower sign reads \"km.pe ora\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'km.pe ora' appears clearly below the '60'."}, {"statement": "A cropped sign fragment on the right edge shows the letters \"DEP\".", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A sign on the bottom right clearly displays the letters 'DEP'."}, {"statement": "The visible sign panels are predominantly red.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All visible sign faces are solid red."}, {"statement": "At least two sign panels are cropped by the image borders, creating a very close-up composition.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Signs on the top, left, bottom, and right edges are partially cropped by the frame."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or fused sign panels, borders, or mounting hardware that create impossible rigid-sign geometry.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The sign displaying 'DEP' on the right appears to fuse strangely with the sign above it showing a 'D'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, logos, watermarks, or unrelated text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is a blurry partial sign added on the far left that was not requested."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned sign panels or repeated text fragments that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "An extra sign with a 'D' appears above the requested 'DEP' sign on the right."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered letters, numbers, or punctuation on any visible sign.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text rendered on the signs is clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the sign surfaces.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting is flat and consistent across the signs."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the red sign faces, white lettering, and white borders.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The white text and borders are cleanly separated from the red backgrounds."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 53, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -14, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image accurately renders all requested text and signs, but introduces extra, unrequested signs on the left and right edges that clutter the composition and fuse awkwardly.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 73.6}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 3714, "image_id": "a4c04045-b312-46dd-af24-338b1aed7f4e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The upper sign shows the numerals \"50.506\" in large white type on a red background.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The numerals '50.506' are clearly visible in large white type on a red background on the upper sign."}, {"statement": "The lower sign shows the words \"luteala maxima\" in white on its upper portion.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The words 'LUTEALA MAXIMA' are printed in white on the upper portion of the lower red sign."}, {"statement": "The lower sign includes a large white \"60\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large white '60' is prominently featured in the center of the lower sign."}, {"statement": "The lower sign includes the text \"km.pe ora\" in white.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'KM.PE ORA' is visible in white next to the '60' on the lower sign."}, {"statement": "A third sign is partially visible on the right edge and includes \"DEP\" plus a white \"D\".", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "A third sign is visible with 'DEP', but the 'D' below it is red and blue, not white."}, {"statement": "The visible signs have white borders.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signs all feature distinct white borders."}, {"statement": "The framing is a very close-up view focused on sign details.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shot is tightly framed on the signs, capturing their textual details."}, {"statement": "The lighting is bright and direct.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is bright and casts distinct highlights and shadows on the signs."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible sign geometry, such as bent planes, fused corners, or malformed borders.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the signs, including their planes and borders, appears structurally sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, logos, watermarks, or unrelated text beyond the described sign close-up.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no extraneous objects, logos, or watermarks present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned sign panels, borders, or repeated text fragments not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no evidence of duplicated panels or cloned text fragments."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical letters or numerals on the signs.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text and numerals on the signs are legible and well-formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible highlights, shadows, or reflections on the sign surfaces.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The highlights and shadows on the signs appear consistent with direct lighting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the white lettering, the borders, and the red sign faces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The edges between the colors and textures are crisp without bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 43, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The main issue is the incorrect color of the 'D' on the third sign, which should be white.", "net_score": 43, "final_score": 89.6}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 3714, "image_id": "a4c04045-b312-46dd-af24-338b1aed7f4e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The uppermost sign displays the large white number \"50.506\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top sign clearly displays the number '50.506' in white on a red background."}, {"statement": "The top line of the lower sign reads \"luteala maxima\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'luteala maxima' is clearly visible on the top line of the lower sign."}, {"statement": "The lower sign contains a large white \"60\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large white '60' is prominent on the lower sign."}, {"statement": "The lower sign contains the text \"km.pe ora.\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'km.pe ora.' is present on the lower sign below the '60'."}, {"statement": "A third sign is partially cropped by the right edge, with \"DEP\" visible on it.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A sign on the right is cropped and displays the letters 'DEP'."}, {"statement": "The sign panels are red, with white text and white border lines.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All visible signs are red with white text and white borders."}, {"statement": "The signs fill most of the frame, leaving only narrow margins of background visible.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signs occupy the majority of the image area, with a small amount of sky visible behind."}, {"statement": "The sign faces are brightly illuminated, consistent with direct light.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signs appear brightly lit, indicating direct lighting."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused sign geometry, such as warped rectangular panels or merged border lines.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signs have clear, distinct rectangular geometry with no warping or merging."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, extra signs, unrelated text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects, text, or logos are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned sign panels, repeated text blocks, or repeated border segments not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated panels or repeated text blocks."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled sign text, including malformed digits or letters.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text and numbers are perfectly legible and well-formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadows, highlights, or reflections on the signs that are inconsistent across the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent and physically plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the red panels, white text, and white borders.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The colors are distinct with no bleeding or smearing between the red and white areas."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 51, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4076, "image_id": "0ef0ded0-1aff-4976-b1a7-76cb62e9dfbc", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is divided into exactly three separate panels or frames.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly contains three distinct vertical panels separated by white space."}, {"statement": "The three panels are arranged as a vertical split layout with side-by-side tall columns.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The three panels are tall, vertical, and positioned side-by-side."}, {"statement": "Each panel shows a hornbill with a large curved beak and casque.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A bird with a distinctive curved hornbill beak and casque is present in every panel."}, {"statement": "Exactly two panels show the hornbill in mid-flight.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The left and center panels depict the bird in flight, while the right panel shows it perched."}, {"statement": "In the flying panels, the hornbill's wings are curved downward.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "In both the left and center panels, the bird's wings are extended upward rather than curving downward."}, {"statement": "Exactly one panel shows the hornbill perched on a branch.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right panel is the only one showing the bird resting on a wooden branch."}, {"statement": "At least one panel has a paved-surface background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The left panel features a paved stone or brick surface in the background."}, {"statement": "At least one panel has a background of green plants or grass.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the center and right panels have backgrounds filled with green grass and foliage."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The hornbill exhibits anatomical distortions such as extra or missing toes, fused claws, malformed beak structure, or impossible wing or leg attachment.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The left panel shows a malformed left foot with fused, indistinct toes, and the center panel shows an awkward leg attachment and posture."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous animals, people, objects, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements, text, or watermarks are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or near-identical cloned hornbill poses or repeated branch or background elements that appear copied between panels.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each panel features a unique pose, angle, and distinct background composition."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows, such as light falling from inconsistent directions within a panel or a bird shadow that does not match the bird's position.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows cast on the birds and the ground appear consistent within each panel."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, feather-texture smearing, or material confusion between the hornbill, branch, pavement, grass, or foliage.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures for the birds, branch, pavement, and plants remain distinct without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 46, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main issues are that the flying birds have their wings pointing up instead of downward, and there are some minor anatomical artifacts in the feet.", "net_score": 38, "final_score": 74.5}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4076, "image_id": "0ef0ded0-1aff-4976-b1a7-76cb62e9dfbc", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The composition contains exactly three distinct image frames or panels.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The image is split vertically into two distinct backgrounds, but it does not have three separate, bordered frames."}, {"statement": "Exactly two frames show the bird airborne in mid-flight.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "FORMAT_VIOLATION", "explanation": "There are two airborne birds depicted, but they are not in distinct frames."}, {"statement": "In both airborne frames, the wings are curved downward.", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The wings on both airborne birds are curved upward, not downward."}, {"statement": "Exactly one frame shows the bird perched on a branch.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "FORMAT_VIOLATION", "explanation": "There is one bird perched on a branch, but it is not in its own distinct frame."}, {"statement": "Each depicted bird has hornbill features, including a large curved bill and a prominent casque above the bill.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three birds have hornbill features, specifically large curved bills and prominent casques."}, {"statement": "At least one frame background includes a paved surface.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background on the right side includes a paved surface."}, {"statement": "At least one frame background includes lush green plants or grass.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background on the left side features lush green plants and grass."}, {"statement": "The overall arrangement uses a vertical split layout with a visible vertical division between sections of the series.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a visible vertical split between the green background on the left and the paved background on the right."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on the bird or birds, such as extra claws or toes, fused digits, malformed beaks, or impossible wing attachment.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The talons on the flying birds appear slightly messy and fused, and the feet on the perched bird are poorly defined."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, text, watermarks, logos, or decorative elements not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No hallucinated objects, text, or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits cloned birds or repeated background elements that appear copy-pasted across frames rather than independently rendered.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The birds and backgrounds do not appear copy-pasted."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows, such as conflicting light directions between the bird and its background within a frame.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting appears consistent across the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared feather detail, or material confusion where the bird overlaps nearby plants, pavement, or the branch.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no significant color bleeding or material confusion around the edges of the birds."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 25, "total_positive_weight_possible": 60, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 4, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image fails to create three distinct frames, placing all birds into a single composition split vertically, and the flying birds have their wings curved upward instead of downward.", "net_score": 18, "final_score": 30.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4076, "image_id": "0ef0ded0-1aff-4976-b1a7-76cb62e9dfbc", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is divided into exactly three side-by-side panels separated by vertical boundaries.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is divided into three distinct side-by-side vertical panels."}, {"statement": "Exactly two panels show a hornbill bird in mid-flight.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The left and center panels each feature a hornbill in flight."}, {"statement": "In each flight panel, the hornbill's wings are curved downward.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "In both flight panels, the hornbills' wings are extended upwards, not curved downward as requested."}, {"statement": "Exactly one panel shows a hornbill perched on a branch.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right panel shows a hornbill perched on a branch."}, {"statement": "At least one panel has a paved surface in the background.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The left panel has a paved road surface in the background."}, {"statement": "At least one panel has lush green plants or grass in the background.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The center and right panels feature lush green foliage and grass."}, {"statement": "All three panels are brightly lit rather than dark or low-light.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All panels are well-lit with bright lighting."}, {"statement": "In each panel, the hornbill is shown close-up, occupying at least one-quarter of the panel height.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The hornbills are large and prominent in all three panels."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on a hornbill, such as extra or missing toes, fused claws, distorted beaks, or impossible wing shapes.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The hornbills are rendered cleanly without anatomical artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects or text are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned hornbills or repeated branch or plant elements within a single panel that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no unwanted duplications within individual panels."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows within a panel, such as the hornbill being lit from a direction inconsistent with its background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting is consistent between the birds and their backgrounds."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where the hornbill, branch, panel borders, plants, or pavement blend into one another.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The borders and elements are distinct with no smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 45, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The main issue is that the flying hornbills have their wings pointed upwards instead of curved downwards as requested.", "net_score": 45, "final_score": 88.2}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4076, "image_id": "0ef0ded0-1aff-4976-b1a7-76cb62e9dfbc", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly three separate photo frames or panels are visible.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image shows three distinct photo panels within a larger wooden frame."}, {"statement": "Exactly two of the frames show a hornbill bird in mid-flight.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top and bottom panels both display a hornbill flying."}, {"statement": "Exactly one frame shows a hornbill bird perched on a branch.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The middle panel features a hornbill sitting on a tree branch."}, {"statement": "In each mid-flight frame, the hornbill's wings are curved downward.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the top and bottom birds have their wings angled downward."}, {"statement": "At least one frame has a paved-surface background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottom panel contains a paved walkway."}, {"statement": "At least one frame has a background of lush green plants or grass.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top and middle panels show vibrant green foliage."}, {"statement": "The frames are arranged in a vertical split layout, stacked one above another.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The three panels are stacked vertically."}, {"statement": "The photo series is brightly lit rather than dim or night-like.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three panels represent brightly lit daytime scenes."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits hornbill anatomy or geometry errors such as extra wings, fused feathers, a malformed beak, or impossible leg attachment.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The hornbills are rendered with coherent anatomy and no obvious geometric artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an extraneous outer wooden picture frame or wood-plank wall background around the requested three photo panels.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "An outer wooden frame and a wood-paneled wall background are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an unintended duplicated or ghosted hornbill within a single panel.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each panel contains exactly one distinct hornbill."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting or shadows within a panel, such as the bird being lit from a different direction than the nearby branch, grass, or pavement.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears consistent within each panel."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the hornbill and adjacent foliage, branch, or pavement.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures and edges of the birds and backgrounds are distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model successfully generated all requested content but added an unrequested wooden frame and wall background.", "net_score": 47, "final_score": 90.4}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4253, "image_id": "be8b0858-4532-461e-ac0f-4415e0c904ca", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is shown from a top-down / overhead viewpoint.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is clearly shot from directly above, looking down at the fabric, peppers, and paper."}, {"statement": "A blue fabric occupies most of the image background.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists entirely of a blue fabric."}, {"statement": "The background fabric shows visible texture.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The blue fabric has a distinct woven or terrycloth-like texture."}, {"statement": "Multiple whole chili peppers are scattered loosely on the fabric.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several whole chili peppers are arranged in a loose scattering on the right side of the fabric."}, {"statement": "More than one size of chili pepper is visible among the scattered peppers.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scattered peppers vary slightly in size and thickness."}, {"statement": "The scattered chili peppers include red, green, and yellow examples.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are distinct red, green, and yellow peppers scattered on the fabric."}, {"statement": "A printed sheet containing miniature chili-pepper photos is positioned on the left side of the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A printed sheet with a grid of pepper photos is located on the left side of the image."}, {"statement": "Text labels appear directly below the miniature photos on the printed sheet.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are text labels positioned beneath each of the small photos on the printed sheet."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed chili peppers or stems, such as fused forms, broken parts, or impossible geometry.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The peppers and stems appear anatomically correct and distinct without geometric artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, produce items other than chili peppers, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects or elements are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously cloned scattered peppers with identical shape, orientation, and surface detail.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scattered peppers have unique shapes, curves, and orientations."}, {"statement": "The printed sheet contains garbled or unreadable text labels below the miniature photos.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text below the miniature photos on the printed sheet consists of illegible, garbled characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent lighting or shadow directions across the peppers, paper, and fabric.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shadows cast by the peppers and the paper all fall consistently to the lower right, indicating a single light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent peppers, paper, and fabric.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and boundaries between the peppers, paper, and fabric are sharp and distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image successfully meets all positive criteria, but the text on the printed sheet is garbled and illegible.", "net_score": 45, "final_score": 86.5}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4253, "image_id": "be8b0858-4532-461e-ac0f-4415e0c904ca", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is shown from a top-down or overhead viewpoint.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is directly above looking down on the fabric and sheet."}, {"statement": "A textured light navy blue fabric is visible beneath the chili peppers.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists of a textured, light blue fabric."}, {"statement": "Multiple chili peppers are scattered across the fabric rather than confined to the printed sheet.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several real chili peppers are lying directly on the fabric on the right side."}, {"statement": "The scattered chili peppers are not all the same size.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scattered peppers range from very small to large."}, {"statement": "The scattered chili peppers include red, green, and yellow peppers.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Red, green, and yellow scattered peppers are visible on the right."}, {"statement": "A printed sheet is positioned along the left side of the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white sheet with printed images and text is on the left edge."}, {"statement": "The printed sheet shows multiple small photos of chili peppers.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sheet contains a grid of small images depicting various peppers."}, {"statement": "Each small photo on the printed sheet has a line of text directly below it.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Text is printed beneath every small image on the sheet."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed chili peppers with fused stems, broken contours, or impossible pepper geometry.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The chili peppers appear to have normal, natural geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, logos, or watermarks not implied by a chili-pepper arrangement and reference sheet.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous items are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned chili peppers or repeated printed-sheet photos that appear unnaturally identical.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The peppers and printed photos all appear distinct."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text in the name labels below the chili-pepper photos on the printed sheet.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text beneath the printed photos consists of illegible, nonsensical characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent with a single real tabletop photo.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows look consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the fabric, the peppers, and the printed sheet.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The generated image perfectly matches the layout and subjects of the prompt, but the text on the reference sheet is heavily garbled.", "net_score": 46, "final_score": 88.5}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4253, "image_id": "be8b0858-4532-461e-ac0f-4415e0c904ca", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is presented as a top-down overhead view.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is directly above the scene."}, {"statement": "A textured blue fabric occupies most of the frame as the background.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A woven, textured blue fabric serves as the primary background."}, {"statement": "Multiple chili peppers are scattered directly on the fabric.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A pile of various chili peppers rests on the blue fabric."}, {"statement": "A printed reference sheet is visible along the left side of the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white sheet with printed contents is positioned on the left side."}, {"statement": "The printed reference sheet shows multiple small photos of chili peppers.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sheet contains a grid of small images depicting individual chili peppers."}, {"statement": "The printed reference sheet places a text name below each chili pepper photo.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are lines of text situated directly beneath each small chili pepper photo."}, {"statement": "At least one red chili pepper, at least one green chili pepper, and at least one yellow chili pepper are visible.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pile contains red, green, and yellow/orange chili peppers."}, {"statement": "The visible chili peppers include at least two noticeably different sizes.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are longer, thicker peppers and slightly smaller, thinner ones visible."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits fused chili peppers, disconnected stems, or other impossible pepper geometry.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The chili peppers appear anatomically correct with proper stems and no fusion."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, logos, watermarks, or text elements outside the printed reference sheet that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only the requested fabric, sheet, and peppers are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or cloned chili peppers with the same shape and orientation repeated.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each pepper has unique curves and variations."}, {"statement": "The printed reference sheet contains illegible, garbled, or non-word text where chili pepper names are expected.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text below the photos consists of illegible, made-up characters rather than real words."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent lighting or shadow directions across the peppers, paper, and fabric.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows fall consistently across all elements, suggesting a single light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the peppers, the paper, and the fabric.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct, with sharp boundaries between the glossy peppers, matte paper, and textured fabric."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 55, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The generated image successfully includes all requested elements, but suffers from garbled, illegible text on the reference sheet.", "net_score": 49, "final_score": 89.1}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4253, "image_id": "be8b0858-4532-461e-ac0f-4415e0c904ca", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is shown from a top-down perspective.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The composition is framed looking straight down at the surface."}, {"statement": "A textured light navy blue fabric is visible beneath the chili peppers.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A textured, light blue fabric is clearly placed under the peppers."}, {"statement": "Multiple chili peppers are scattered directly on the fabric.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A pile of various chili peppers rests directly on the blue fabric."}, {"statement": "At least two visibly different chili-pepper sizes are present.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are small, squat peppers and long, thin peppers mixed together."}, {"statement": "A printed sheet is positioned on the left side of the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A laminated sheet with pepper varieties is located on the left side of the image."}, {"statement": "The printed sheet contains multiple small photos of chili peppers.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sheet features a 3x3 grid of smaller pepper photographs."}, {"statement": "Each small chili-pepper photo on the printed sheet has a text name beneath it.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Names like 'Jalapeño' and 'Habanero' are printed below their respective photos."}, {"statement": "The visible chili peppers include all three requested colors: red, green, and yellow.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Red, green, and yellow peppers are visible in the main pile."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits distorted or fused geometry in the chili peppers, printed sheet, or fabric.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The peppers, sheet, and fabric maintain coherent structures without unnatural melting or fusion."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, utensils, people, logos, watermarks, or unrelated text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "A pair of metal tongs is present next to the peppers, which was not requested in the prompt."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned chili peppers or repeated printed-sheet panels that appear unnaturally identical.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The peppers and the photos on the sheet appear distinct without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The text on the printed sheet is garbled, nonsensical, misspelled, or unreadable.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text labels ('Cayenne', 'Poblano', etc.) are clearly legible and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shadows and lighting are generally consistent across the top-down arrangement."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the peppers, paper, and fabric.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials (glossy peppers, matte paper, woven fabric, wood grain) remain distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image successfully meets all prompt criteria but includes hallucinated metal tongs.", "net_score": 45, "final_score": 88.2}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4461, "image_id": "d66982f2-7f6c-4f88-adb3-b809994b1fca", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is set inside an indoor swimming pool facility.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The environment is clearly an indoor pool with lanes and spectator seating."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly four swimmers.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly four young swimmers positioned on the starting blocks."}, {"statement": "Four starting blocks at the pool edge are occupied by swimmers.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Four starting blocks are occupied by the four swimmers."}, {"statement": "The occupied starting blocks are labeled 5, 6, 7, and 8.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The blocks are clearly labeled with the numbers 5, 6, 7, and 8."}, {"statement": "The swimmers on the starting blocks are bent forward in a pre-dive or pre-start pose toward the water.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All four swimmers are in a bent-over starting position facing the pool."}, {"statement": "At least one coach or official is standing on the pool deck beside the swimmers.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are several officials or coaches standing on the deck behind and beside the swimmers."}, {"statement": "A yellow railing separates the pool deck from the spectator seating area.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent yellow railing is visible between the pool area and the stands."}, {"statement": "Seated spectators are visible in the background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A crowd of spectators is seated in the background behind the yellow railing."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or body-geometry distortions in any person, such as fused limbs, malformed hands or feet, or impossible joint structure.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "Some of the officials holding clipboards have malformed hands and arms."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a visible watermark, caption overlay, or unrelated logo not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks or unrelated text overlays are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned swimmers, officials, spectators, starting blocks, or lane equipment.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning or duplication is visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or unreadable visible numerals or signage, including the starting-block numbers.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The numbers 5, 6, 7, and 8 on the blocks are clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits shadows or reflections on the water or pool deck that do not match the positions of the swimmers or starting blocks.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Reflections on the water correspond properly to the elements on the deck."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between skin, swimwear, starting blocks, tiles, and water.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and rendered without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 55, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image successfully meets all positive criteria but exhibits some minor hand malformations on the background figures.", "net_score": 47, "final_score": 85.5}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4461, "image_id": "d66982f2-7f6c-4f88-adb3-b809994b1fca", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is set inside an indoor swimming pool facility.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The setting is clearly an indoor pool with lanes, starting blocks, and spectator seating above."}, {"statement": "The image shows exactly four young boy swimmers.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are only three swimmers visible on the starting blocks."}, {"statement": "The four swimmers occupy starting blocks labeled 5, 6, 7, and 8.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The starting blocks are numbered 5/4, 2/5, and 8/6, not a clean sequence of 5, 6, 7, 8."}, {"statement": "All four swimmers are shown preparing to dive into the pool from the blocks.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "Only three swimmers are shown diving."}, {"statement": "At least one coach or official is standing on the pool deck near the starting blocks.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several officials or coaches in blue and white are standing on the deck near the blocks."}, {"statement": "Spectators are visible in the background behind a yellow railing.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Spectators are watching from a balcony behind a yellow railing in the upper background."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is from pool-deck height at an eye-level angle, not from an overhead or underwater perspective.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective is from eye level on the pool deck."}, {"statement": "White, beige, or gray tile surfaces are visible around the pool area.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "White tiles are visible on the edge of the pool and the walls."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on people, such as extra, missing, or fused limbs, hands, feet, or facial features.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The swimmer in the middle has a partially missing/fused left leg, and the closest swimmer has distorted hands."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, signs, watermarks, or logos that are not implied by an indoor swim meet.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No out-of-place objects or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned swimmers, adults, spectators, or starting blocks.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious cloned figures."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered numbers or text on starting blocks or other visible signage.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The numbers on the starting blocks are garbled, containing multiple numbers on single blocks (e.g., '8' and '6' on the closest block)."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, reflections, or splash behavior inconsistent with the rest of the indoor pool scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "Splashes are appearing in the water below the starting blocks before the swimmers have actually hit the water."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between skin, swimwear, starting blocks, water, and pool tiles.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are generally distinct without major bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 23, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -16, "failure_count": 3, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image misses the required swimmer count and block numbers, features garbled text, and shows physical inconsistencies with splashes appearing before swimmers enter the water.", "net_score": 7, "final_score": 13.7}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4461, "image_id": "d66982f2-7f6c-4f88-adb3-b809994b1fca", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is set inside an indoor pool facility rather than outdoors.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows an indoor pool setting with tiled walls and spectator seating."}, {"statement": "Exactly four swimmers are positioned on starting blocks.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly four swimmers on the starting blocks."}, {"statement": "The occupied starting blocks display the numbers 5, 6, 7, and 8.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The blocks are numbered 5, 5/8 (garbled), 8, 4, 6/7, which does not match the requested 5, 6, 7, and 8 sequence."}, {"statement": "The swimmers are in pre-dive poses preparing to enter the water.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All four swimmers are leaning forward on the blocks, preparing to dive."}, {"statement": "At least one coach or official stands near the starting blocks.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several officials in uniform are standing right behind the swimmers."}, {"statement": "Seated spectators are visible in the background.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a crowd of spectators sitting in the bleachers in the background."}, {"statement": "A yellow railing is visible in front of the spectator area.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent yellow railing runs along the stairs and in front of the bleachers."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is approximately eye level with the pool deck.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is level with the pool deck, showing the swimmers from an eye-level perspective."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on people, such as fused limbs, missing extremities, or distorted faces.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The second swimmer has a distorted arm merging into their leg."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a watermark, signature, UI overlay, or other unrelated text or logo not implied by the swimming competition scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks or UI overlays are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned swimmers, officials, or spectators with near-identical faces, poses, or clothing.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "People in the scene appear distinct."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text or numerals on the starting blocks or poolside signage.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the pool edge (e.g., 'OOTIDOA') and numbers on the blocks are garbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or water reflections that are inconsistent with the scene geometry.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and reflections appear generally consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where swimmers, starting blocks, water, tiles, or railings meet.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Boundaries between objects and materials are relatively clean."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 43, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -13, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image fails to render the correct block numbers (garbled digits) and includes minor anatomical artifacts on a swimmer.", "net_score": 30, "final_score": 57.7}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4461, "image_id": "d66982f2-7f6c-4f88-adb3-b809994b1fca", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is set inside an indoor swimming pool facility.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows an indoor pool setting with bleachers, lane lines, and pool tiles."}, {"statement": "Exactly four swimmers are positioned on starting blocks.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly four swimmers on the starting blocks."}, {"statement": "The four starting blocks used by the swimmers are labeled 5, 6, 7, and 8.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The blocks are labeled with multiple numbers each (e.g., '5 5', '5 6', '6 7', '8 8'), not individually 5, 6, 7, 8."}, {"statement": "The four swimmers are crouched forward in a race-start pose, preparing to dive into the pool.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All four swimmers are in a bent-over starting position."}, {"statement": "At least one coach or official is standing on the pool deck near the starting blocks.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two officials with clipboards are standing on the deck near the swimmers."}, {"statement": "Spectators are visible in the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A crowd of spectators is sitting in the bleachers in the background."}, {"statement": "A yellow railing is visible between the pool deck and the spectators.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A bright yellow railing separates the pool deck area from the bleachers."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is approximately eye level with the swimmers.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is roughly level with the swimmers on the blocks."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts on people, such as fused fingers, missing limbs, or impossible joint geometry.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The hands of the swimmers on the blocks exhibit fused and malformed fingers, and the face of the first swimmer on the left is severely deformed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits additional swimmers or competitors beyond the four requested on starting blocks 5 through 8.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There are three additional swimmers standing on the deck to the far left."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned people with unnaturally repeated faces, bodies, or poses.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning of specific individuals is visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or unreadable incidental text, such as malformed writing on clothing, signs, or equipment.", "weight": -2, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the officials' shirts and the swimmers' caps is garbled and unreadable."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections or shadows in the pool area that do not match the swimmers, blocks, or railing.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections in the water appear generally plausible for the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between swimmers, starting blocks, tiles, railings, or water.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "There is melting/smearing around the starting blocks and the lane line attachments to the wall."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 40, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -19, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 4, "severity_summary": "The image has significant issues with garbled numbering on the blocks and severe anatomical distortions on the subjects.", "net_score": 21, "final_score": 43.8}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4491, "image_id": "018eb62d-f580-4523-886f-15b009b9b904", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image depicts exactly two llamas.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two llamas visible in the field."}, {"statement": "The pair of llamas consists of one brown or light-brown llama and one white llama.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "One llama has a brown coat and the other has a white coat."}, {"statement": "The brown or light-brown llama has its head lowered to the grass in a grazing pose.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The brown llama is depicted with its head down, eating the grass."}, {"statement": "The white llama is positioned next to or slightly behind the brown or light-brown llama.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The white llama is standing next to and slightly behind the brown llama."}, {"statement": "The brown or light-brown llama is shown primarily in side profile.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The brown llama is viewed from the side."}, {"statement": "The scene is set outdoors in an open grassy field.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The llamas are in an outdoor grassy field."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered in a realistic photographic style.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rendering style is realistic and photographic."}, {"statement": "The lighting appears natural and diffused.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft, natural, and diffused across the scene."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed llama anatomy such as extra legs, fused limbs, distorted heads, or impossible body topology.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both llamas have normal, anatomically correct body structures."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, animals, people, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra objects, people, or text are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned llama body parts or repeated llama figures suggestive of copy artifacts.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no signs of cloning or duplicated body parts on the llamas."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows that are inconsistent across the llamas and the field.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows and lighting are consistent across the animals and the environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between llama fur, grass, and soil.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures of the fur, grass, and dirt are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 52, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4491, "image_id": "018eb62d-f580-4523-886f-15b009b9b904", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two llamas.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two llamas are clearly visible in the image."}, {"statement": "One visible llama has brown or light brown fur.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The llama in the foreground has brown fur."}, {"statement": "The brown or light brown llama is shown in side profile.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The brown llama is viewed from its left side."}, {"statement": "The brown or light brown llama has its head lowered to graze on visible green grass.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The brown llama's head is down, touching a patch of green grass."}, {"statement": "A second visible llama has white fur.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The llama in the background has white fur."}, {"statement": "The white llama is positioned next to or slightly behind the brown or light brown llama.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The white llama stands behind and slightly to the right of the brown llama."}, {"statement": "The scene is set in an open outdoor field rather than an indoor or built environment.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The setting is a grassy field with hills in the background."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered in a realistic photographic style.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rendering mimics a realistic photograph with depth of field and natural lighting."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts on the llamas, such as extra legs, fused limbs, malformed ears, or distorted facial features.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The llamas appear anatomically correct with normal limbs and features."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, structures, signage, logos, or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects, logos, or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned llamas, or repeated near-identical body parts, not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no duplication of llamas or cloning of body parts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or inconsistent shadow directions across the llamas and the field.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is consistent, casting soft, believable shadows underneath the animals."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between llama fur, grass, and soil.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures for fur, grass, and soil are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 57, "total_positive_weight_possible": 57, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 57, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4491, "image_id": "018eb62d-f580-4523-886f-15b009b9b904", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two llamas.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two llamas are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "One llama is predominantly light brown.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The llama in the foreground is mostly light brown."}, {"statement": "A second llama is predominantly white.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The llama in the background is white."}, {"statement": "The light brown llama is shown in side profile.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The brown llama is viewed from the side."}, {"statement": "The light brown llama has its head lowered to the grass in a grazing pose.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The brown llama is leaning down to eat the grass."}, {"statement": "The white llama is positioned next to or slightly behind the light brown llama.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The white llama is standing behind the brown llama."}, {"statement": "The setting is an open field covered with green grass.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The llamas are in a grassy field."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered in a realistic photographic style.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rendering is photorealistic."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on a llama, such as extra legs, fused limbs, missing ears, or distorted neck-to-head connections.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The brown llama has a weird gap/line near its hind leg and some structural weirdness on its front left leg."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated non-prompt elements such as people, fences, buildings, vehicles, text, watermarks, or logos.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra objects like fences or people are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned visual elements, such as repeated fur regions or repeated background patches, that suggest copy-paste artifacts.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No copy-paste artifacts are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows, such as inconsistent light direction across the two llamas or shadows that contradict diffuse daylight.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting is diffuse and consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between llama fur and the surrounding grass or background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and do not smear into the background."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 55, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image fulfills all positive requests but has minor anatomical artifacts on the brown llama's side and front leg.", "net_score": 47, "final_score": 85.5}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4491, "image_id": "018eb62d-f580-4523-886f-15b009b9b904", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A brown llama is shown with its head lowered into the grass as if eating.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A brown llama is visible on the left side of the image with its head lowered into the grass."}, {"statement": "A white llama with visibly shaved or very short fur is positioned next to the brown grazing llama.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white llama with very short fur is standing right next to the brown llama on the left."}, {"statement": "A light brown llama with short fur is shown from the side.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A light brown llama is shown in profile view on the right side of the image."}, {"statement": "The light brown side-view llama has its head lowered toward the green grass.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The light brown llama on the right has its head down near the grass."}, {"statement": "A white llama with visibly long fur is positioned behind the light brown side-view llama.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "A white llama with longer fur is visible on the far right, but it is next to or slightly in front of the light brown llama, not behind it."}, {"statement": "The setting is an outdoor open grassy field with visible brown soil patches.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background and foreground show an open grassy field with patches of brown soil visible."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered in a realistic photographic style.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image has a photorealistic style with natural depth of field and lighting."}, {"statement": "The lighting is soft and diffused, consistent with natural daylight.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft, natural, and overcast, creating diffused light."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits llamas with extra or missing legs, fused limbs, distorted necks, or malformed facial features.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All four llamas appear to have normal anatomy with appropriate numbers of limbs and normal facial features."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits prominent extraneous subjects such as people, vehicles, signs, text, watermarks, logos, or non-llama animals not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous subjects, watermarks, or logos are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or near-identical llamas or repeated vegetation patterns that suggest cloning.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each llama is distinct in color, pose, or fur length, and the vegetation appears natural and unrepeated."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits shadows or illumination on the llamas that are inconsistent with a single soft diffused outdoor light source.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows and highlights on the llamas are consistent with a soft, overcast light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding or texture smearing where llama fur blends unnaturally into the grass or soil.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The edges between the llamas and the surrounding environment are distinct without unnatural blending."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 42, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The image perfectly met almost all criteria, with only a minor spatial relationship error regarding the placement of the long-furred white llama.", "net_score": 42, "final_score": 87.5}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4563, "image_id": "5ca3004d-5f20-442e-9e66-423d6cf9dfe8", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A laptop is visible in the foreground of the image.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A laptop is clearly the primary subject in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The word \"TOSHIBA\" is visible on the laptop.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'TOSHIBA' is written on the bottom left corner of the laptop screen bezel."}, {"statement": "The laptop screen displays a webpage branded \"GuruShots\".", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The 'GuruShots' logo and branding are visible on the website displayed on the screen."}, {"statement": "The visible background behind the laptop is purple.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The wall behind the laptop is a solid purple color."}, {"statement": "The visible background behind the laptop is out of focus relative to the laptop.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The purple background and the object on the right are blurred out of focus."}, {"statement": "Purple and blue cool tones dominate most of the image area.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Cool purple tones take up the majority of the background and reflect slightly on the laptop."}, {"statement": "The laptop occupies at least 50% of the image width, indicating close-up framing.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The laptop stretches across almost the entire width of the frame."}, {"statement": "The camera angle is from above the laptop enough that the keyboard or palm rest is visible.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The keyboard and trackpad area are visible in front of the screen."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as a bent screen border, impossible hinge alignment, or fused keyboard keys.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The laptop's structure and keys are rendered cleanly."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an added watermark, logo, or block of text outside the laptop and its on-screen webpage.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no watermarks or extra text elements outside the laptop screen."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned laptop parts such as repeated keyboard sections, a second screen border, or multiple overlapping laptops.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only one normal laptop is visible with no repeated parts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text where the laptop branding \"TOSHIBA\" or the webpage name \"GuruShots\" should appear.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both 'TOSHIBA' and 'GuruShots' are spelled correctly and legibly."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the laptop body or screen.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and reflections appear realistic for the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the laptop chassis, screen content, and purple background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between the screen, chassis, and background are sharp and distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 46, "total_positive_weight_possible": 46, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 46, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4563, "image_id": "5ca3004d-5f20-442e-9e66-423d6cf9dfe8", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A laptop appears in front of the background as the foreground subject.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A laptop is clearly visible in the foreground, dominating the scene."}, {"statement": "The laptop body displays the brand name \"TOSHIBA\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'TOSHIBA' is printed on the bottom bezel of the laptop screen."}, {"statement": "The laptop screen shows a webpage that includes a prominent \"GuruShots\" title or logo.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'GuruShots' appears multiple times in a large font on the displayed webpage."}, {"statement": "The area behind the laptop is predominantly purple.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists of various shades of purple."}, {"statement": "The background lacks sharp detail and appears out of focus.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background is blurry with no distinct features, matching the out-of-focus description."}, {"statement": "The laptop fills most of the frame, indicating a close-up composition.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The laptop screen and keyboard take up the majority of the image area."}, {"statement": "The top surface of the laptop base or keyboard is visible below the screen, indicating a viewpoint from above.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The keyboard and hinge are visible at the bottom of the frame."}, {"statement": "Purple tones cover more of the image area than any other hue, creating a cool purple palette.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the background and the webpage displayed are heavily dominated by purple tones."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the laptop screen, bezel, hinge, or keyboard.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The laptop's physical structure appears sound with distinct bezels, hinges, and keys."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unrelated objects, people, watermarks, or logos outside the described laptop-and-background scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or mirrored laptop parts or repeated interface elements that suggest cloning artifacts.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious cloning artifacts or mirrored laptop components."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or nonsensical rendered text in the browser or webpage interface.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The webpage contains significant amounts of garbled, unreadable text under the main logo and within the central widget."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits reflections, highlights, or shadows on the laptop or screen that are physically inconsistent with the scene lighting.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and reflections on the laptop seem consistent with a screen emitting light in a lit environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the screen, bezel, keyboard, and purple background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct without bleeding between the screen, plastic body, and background."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 48, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main issue is the presence of garbled, illegible text on the laptop screen interface.", "net_score": 41, "final_score": 85.4}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4563, "image_id": "5ca3004d-5f20-442e-9e66-423d6cf9dfe8", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A laptop is visible in the foreground of the image.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A laptop is clearly visible in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The laptop body or bezel shows the brand name \"TOSHIBA\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'TOSHIBA' is printed on the bottom bezel of the screen."}, {"statement": "A webpage or browser interface is visible on the laptop screen.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A webpage layout is visible on the laptop screen."}, {"statement": "The laptop screen displays the text \"GuruShots\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Gurushots' is prominently displayed on the webpage."}, {"statement": "The background is visibly blurry or out of focus.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists of out-of-focus bokeh elements."}, {"statement": "Purple is the dominant color in the background.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background is primarily a deep purple hue."}, {"statement": "The composition is a close-up, with the laptop occupying at least one-third of the frame.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The laptop fills a large portion of the right side and bottom foreground."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint is a high shot, with the camera above the laptop so the top surfaces of the keys are visible.", "weight": 3, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The camera angle is low, looking up at the screen, with the keyboard seen from a low oblique angle rather than a high shot."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible laptop geometry, such as fused hinges, warped screen edges, or key shapes that could not physically exist.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The laptop keys are melted and fused together in impossible shapes."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous physical objects or devices beyond a single laptop scene against a blurry purple background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects are visible in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned laptop parts, such as repeated hinges, overlapping screens, or unnaturally repeated key groups.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No cloned or duplicated parts are apparent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered text in the visible branding or webpage text.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the webpage below 'Gurushots' consists of garbled, illegible characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits lighting or glare on the laptop that is inconsistent with the rest of the scene illumination.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The purple ambient lighting reflects consistently on the keyboard."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding or texture smearing that blurs the boundaries between the keyboard, bezel, and screen content.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "There is noticeable smearing and blurring of the keys in the foreground."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 50, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -15, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image captures the requested elements and colors well, but suffers from significant text garbling and melted keyboard geometry.", "net_score": 35, "final_score": 66.0}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4563, "image_id": "5ca3004d-5f20-442e-9e66-423d6cf9dfe8", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A laptop is visible in the foreground of the image.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A laptop is clearly the primary subject in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The visible laptop branding reads \"TOSHIBA\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'TOSHIBA' is clearly printed on the bottom bezel of the screen."}, {"statement": "The laptop screen displays a webpage with the word \"GuruShots\" visible.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The screen shows a website with 'GuruShots' displayed prominently."}, {"statement": "The background is visibly blurred or out of focus.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background behind the laptop is heavily blurred."}, {"statement": "The background is predominantly purple or violet.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The out-of-focus background has a dark purple hue."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint is a high-angle shot looking down onto the laptop.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The camera angle is relatively low and from the side, not a high-angle shot looking down."}, {"statement": "The framing is a close-up, with the laptop occupying at least half of the image width.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The laptop takes up the majority of the right side and foreground of the frame."}, {"statement": "The laptop or its lighting shows a cool purple or violet tint beyond the background alone.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The silver laptop and the wooden table both reflect a purple tint."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible laptop geometry, such as fused keys, a broken hinge, or a warped screen frame.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The keyboard features fused and unevenly spaced keys."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a watermark or unrelated overlay logo/text not part of the laptop or the webpage interface.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks or unrelated text overlays are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned laptops, keyboard sections, or repeated screen panels not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is only one laptop visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits clearly garbled pseudo-text in visible browser or webpage UI labels.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The website text below the main headings contains illegible garbled letters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or screen reflections inconsistent with the rest of the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and reflections are consistent with the environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the laptop, tabletop, and background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and boundaries are clean."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 44, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -10, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The generation failed to use a high-angle shot and suffers from minor text garbling and keyboard geometry artifacts.", "net_score": 34, "final_score": 70.8}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4709, "image_id": "1a3f0175-ff7d-4c47-9f44-291d4d333876", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Every visible playing card is from the clubs suit.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All visible symbols on the cards are clubs."}, {"statement": "A playing card with rank 5 is visible.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The leftmost card is a 5 of clubs."}, {"statement": "A playing card with rank 6 is visible.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The second card from the left is a 6 of clubs."}, {"statement": "A playing card with rank 8 is visible.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The third card from the left is an 8 of clubs."}, {"statement": "A playing card with rank 9 is visible.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The fourth card from the left is a 9 of clubs."}, {"statement": "From left to right, the requested ranks appear in ascending order as 5, 6, 8, 9.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cards are arranged as 5, 6, 8, 9 from left to right."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed card geometry or impossible club-symbol shapes, such as warped card edges, fused corners, or broken pips.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The pips on the cards are mismatched with their ranks (e.g., the 5 card has 5 pips, but the 6 card has 7 pips, the 8 card has 7 pips, and the 9 card has 9 pips)."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous non-card elements, such as hands, chips, dice, captions, logos, or watermarks, that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned playing cards, including repeated near-identical card faces not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No duplicate cards are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rank numerals or corner club symbols on the cards.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The bottom right corner numbers on the 6 and 8 cards are incorrectly rendered as '5'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent shadows, highlights, or reflections across the cards and tabletop.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the card faces, printed symbols, and tabletop surface.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and colors are well-defined."}, {"statement": "The image includes a visible seven of clubs even though the prompt specifies that the seven is absent.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No 7 of clubs is present in the image."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 47, "total_positive_weight_possible": 47, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -13, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image has garbled bottom corner numbers on some cards and incorrect pip counts for the 6 and 8.", "net_score": 34, "final_score": 72.3}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4709, "image_id": "1a3f0175-ff7d-4c47-9f44-291d4d333876", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly five distinct playing cards are visible in the image.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "Only four cards (5, 6, 8, 9) are visible, not five."}, {"statement": "All visible suit symbols on the cards are clubs symbols.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Every card displayed features club suit symbols."}, {"statement": "A visible card shows rank 5.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The leftmost card is a 5 of clubs."}, {"statement": "A visible card shows rank 6.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The second card from the left is a 6 of clubs."}, {"statement": "A visible card shows rank 8.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The third card from the left is an 8 of clubs."}, {"statement": "A visible card shows rank 9.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rightmost card is a 9 of clubs."}, {"statement": "From left to right, the identifiable ranks appear in ascending order as 5, 6, 8, and 9.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cards are correctly ordered 5, 6, 8, 9 from left to right."}, {"statement": "The visible card arrangement spans at least 70% of the image width, consistent with a close-up shot.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The card arrangement takes up most of the horizontal space in the frame."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible card geometry, such as fused card borders, severely warped corners, or non-rectangular card shapes.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cards appear as solid, individual rectangular objects."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unrelated objects, people, watermarks, logos, or added text outside the standard playing-card designs.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous items or text are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned card faces or repeated printed details that look copy-pasted.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each card face is distinct without obvious cloning artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rank numerals or club suit glyphs on any visible card.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The 9 card has a garbled, upside-down '6' numeral in the bottom right corner instead of a '9', and the 5 and 6 cards erroneously contain face-card (court card) artwork instead of standard pip arrangements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits shadows, highlights, or reflections on the cards that are inconsistent with a single plausible light source.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits edge bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where adjacent cards or printed card elements blend together unnaturally.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The edges of the cards are cleanly separated."}, {"statement": "The image includes a visible rank-7 card even though the prompt specifies that the seven is absent.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no 7 card visible in the arrangement."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 44, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model missed the count by generating only four cards instead of five, and introduced garbled card designs by putting face card artwork on number cards and a wrong numeral on the 9.", "net_score": 37, "final_score": 68.5}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4709, "image_id": "1a3f0175-ff7d-4c47-9f44-291d4d333876", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly five playing cards are shown in the image.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are six visible cards fanned out (ranks 5, 6, 8, 8, 9, and one mostly hidden on top)."}, {"statement": "Every visible card face belongs to the clubs suit.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All visible suit symbols on the cards are clubs."}, {"statement": "At least one visible card face shows the rank 5.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The leftmost card clearly shows a 5."}, {"statement": "At least one visible card face shows the rank 6.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The second card from the left shows a 6."}, {"statement": "At least one visible card face shows the rank 8.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The third card from the left shows an 8."}, {"statement": "At least one visible card face shows the rank 9.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The fifth card from the left shows a 9."}, {"statement": "The cards are positioned so that the shown ranks appear in numerical order from one end of the spread to the other.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The visible ranks (5, 6, 8, 8, 9, 7) are not in strict numerical order, but the main sequence 5,6,8,8,9 is ordered."}, {"statement": "The cards occupy more than half of the frame area, creating a close-up composition.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The fan of cards fills the vast majority of the frame."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible card geometry, such as fused edges, non-rectangular corners, or cards intersecting unnaturally.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The top right corner of the spread shows cards melting into each other with confusing borders."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, logos, watermarks, or unrelated text beyond the playing cards and their standard card markings.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only cards and their markings are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned card faces, with two visible cards appearing to be the same rank and face design.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are two cards showing the rank '8' side-by-side."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, malformed, or unreadable rank numerals or club suit symbols on the cards.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The numerals and club symbols are legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting or shadows across the overlapping cards.", "weight": -2, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or ink/material confusion between adjacent cards or printed card markings.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No significant texture smearing or color bleeding between cards."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a seven of clubs anywhere in the spread, despite that card being intended to be absent.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "A card with the rank '7' is visible tucked in the upper right."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 43, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -17, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image hallucinates six cards instead of five, duplicates the 8, includes the forbidden 7, and has some geometric artifacts near the top right.", "net_score": 26, "final_score": 49.1}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4709, "image_id": "1a3f0175-ff7d-4c47-9f44-291d4d333876", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly five playing cards.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "Only four playing cards are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The playing cards are depicted in a close-up view.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image provides a relatively close view of the cards on the table."}, {"statement": "Every visible card is from the clubs suit.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All visible symbols on the cards are clubs."}, {"statement": "The 5 of clubs is present.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The 5 of clubs is the leftmost card."}, {"statement": "The 6 of clubs is present.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The 6 of clubs is the second card from the left."}, {"statement": "The 8 of clubs is present.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The 8 of clubs is the third card from the left."}, {"statement": "The 9 of clubs is present.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The 9 of clubs is the rightmost card."}, {"statement": "The visible card ranks increase from left to right.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cards are arranged 5, 6, 8, 9 from left to right."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometrically malformed playing cards, such as fused cards, impossible corners, or non-rectangular card shapes.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cards have normal rectangular shapes with rounded corners."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits additional distinct objects besides the cards and a neutral background surface, such as a lamp, hands, chips, dice, logos, or watermarks, that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "A desk lamp is clearly visible in the top right corner."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned playing cards or repeated card details not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No duplicated cards or incorrectly repeated details are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled card rank numerals or club symbols in the corner indices.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The bottom right index of the 9 card incorrectly displays a '6'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the cards that are inconsistent with a real scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting from the lamp and resulting shadows appear plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the card faces, printed symbols, and background surface.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The card textures and symbols are clearly separated from the background."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits the 7 of clubs even though the prompt states that the seven is absent.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The 7 of clubs is correctly absent from the image."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 41, "total_positive_weight_possible": 45, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -11, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image is missing the fifth card entirely, includes an unrequested lamp, and features a garbled index number on the 9 of clubs.", "net_score": 30, "final_score": 66.7}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4854, "image_id": "f332db50-df70-49db-b4a7-9a3031e64ac4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The hall walls are deep blue.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The walls throughout the museum hall are painted a deep blue color."}, {"statement": "The left side of the hall contains exactly three tall framed paintings depicting human figures in armor.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three distinct tall paintings on the left wall showing figures wearing armor."}, {"statement": "Exactly three smaller artworks in glass-fronted mounts are positioned below the three tall paintings on the left side.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three smaller artworks enclosed in glass or clear mounts are visible directly below the tall paintings."}, {"statement": "Exactly one seating bench is placed near the three tall paintings on the left side.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A single wooden bench is located in front of the left-hand paintings."}, {"statement": "Exactly one tube-shaped light fixture hangs from the ceiling.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A single long, cylindrical light fixture is suspended from the ceiling."}, {"statement": "The right wall contains exactly two large framed paintings depicting holy Christian figures.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right wall features two large paintings of religious figures."}, {"statement": "Exactly one white information display panel is mounted beside the two paintings on the right wall.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white informational panel is mounted on the wall to the right of the two large paintings."}, {"statement": "The floor is a polished light marble surface.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The floor is made of light-colored, reflective marble."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped architectural geometry, such as crooked wall planes, impossible ceiling junctions, or distorted frame shapes.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The architecture and frames appear structurally sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated visitors, unrelated furniture, unrelated sculptures, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects, people, or logos are present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously cloned paintings, labels, or furnishings that repeat with near-identical appearance.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The paintings and objects are distinct, with no obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on the white information panel or artwork labels.", "weight": -2, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the white information panel on the right is unreadable and garbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, shadows, or marble-floor reflections relative to the visible fixtures and illuminated artworks.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and reflections on the marble floor appear natural."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between the walls, frames, glass cases, and marble floor.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct with no smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 53, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -2, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image meets all positive criteria perfectly, but suffers from garbled text on the information panel.", "net_score": 51, "final_score": 96.2}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4854, "image_id": "f332db50-df70-49db-b4a7-9a3031e64ac4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The hall walls are deep blue.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The walls throughout the museum hall are a solid deep blue color."}, {"statement": "The left side contains exactly three tall framed paintings depicting historical characters in armor.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three tall paintings on the left wall clearly depict figures wearing armor."}, {"statement": "The left side contains exactly three smaller artworks mounted in glass-front display cases.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Directly below the tall paintings are three distinct display cases with glass fronts holding smaller artworks."}, {"statement": "The right wall contains exactly two large framed paintings depicting holy Christian characters.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right wall features two large framed paintings showing figures in religious attire with halos."}, {"statement": "A white informational display panel is placed near the two paintings on the right wall.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white display stand with text is located beneath the two paintings on the right."}, {"statement": "The floor is polished light-colored marble.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The floor has a light marble texture with a reflective, polished surface."}, {"statement": "A tube-shaped decorative light fixture hangs from the ceiling.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A thick, decorated tube-like structure is suspended from the ceiling."}, {"statement": "A seating bench is placed near the left-side group of three tall paintings.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The bench is positioned on the right side of the room, far away from the three paintings on the left."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric distortions in depicted human figures, such as malformed hands, faces, or limbs within the paintings.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The figures in the large painting on the right have distorted hands, and the smaller artworks have messy, fused figures."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, signs, watermarks, or logos that are not implied by the museum-hall description.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unrelated objects, watermarks, or people are present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned artworks, labels, furnishings, or decorative elements that appear unnaturally repeated beyond the described arrangement.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There are three vent covers hallucinated below the glass cases that were not requested."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on the white informational display or wall labels.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the white display panel consists of illegible, garbled symbols."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent with a warmly lit indoor gallery.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent with an indoor gallery setting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent surfaces such as frames, walls, curtain, bench, floor, or glass cases.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Surfaces and materials are distinctly rendered without significant bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 56, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image generally matches the prompt but misplaces the bench and includes minor visual artifacts in the paintings and text.", "net_score": 40, "final_score": 71.4}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4854, "image_id": "f332db50-df70-49db-b4a7-9a3031e64ac4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The visible walls of the hall are deep blue.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The walls of the museum hall are painted a deep blue color."}, {"statement": "The left side contains exactly three tall paintings depicting historical characters wearing armor.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three tall paintings on the left wall showing figures in armor."}, {"statement": "The left side contains exactly three mounted artworks enclosed in glass cases.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are only two glass-encased artworks visible on the left wall, not three."}, {"statement": "A seating bench is placed near the three tall paintings on the left side.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden bench is positioned in front of the three tall paintings on the left."}, {"statement": "The right wall contains exactly two large paintings depicting holy Christian figures.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two large paintings of Christian figures with halos are on the right wall."}, {"statement": "A white information display is positioned near the right-wall paintings.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white display stand is located next to the paintings on the right wall."}, {"statement": "The floor is a polished light marble surface.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The floor appears to be made of light, reflective marble tiles."}, {"statement": "At least one tube-shaped light fixture hangs from the ceiling.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A linear, tube-like lighting fixture hangs from the ceiling."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The human visitors exhibit anatomical artifacts such as fused limbs, missing body parts, or distorted hands.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The visitors on the bench appear anatomically normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits visible watermarks, brand logos, or overlaid text not implied by the museum-gallery prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks or unprompted logos are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned paintings, visitors, or fixtures that appear unnaturally repeated.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no signs of unnatural duplication or cloning in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or illegible text on wall labels, signs, or the white information display.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the wall labels and the information display is illegible and garbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadows or reflections on the marble floor that are inconsistent with the ceiling lights or displayed objects.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections and shadows on the floor appear generally consistent with the lighting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent surfaces such as the paintings, blue walls, bench, and marble floor.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between different materials and objects are well-defined."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 45, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -3, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image incorrectly features two glass-encased artworks instead of three, and text elements are garbled.", "net_score": 42, "final_score": 79.2}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4854, "image_id": "f332db50-df70-49db-b4a7-9a3031e64ac4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is an indoor museum hall or gallery.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly depicts an indoor museum hall with paintings on the walls and a bench for visitors."}, {"statement": "The hall walls are deep blue.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The walls throughout the museum hall are painted a deep blue color."}, {"statement": "On the left side of the hall, exactly three tall paintings show figures wearing armor.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three tall paintings on the left wall, each depicting a historical figure wearing armor."}, {"statement": "On the left side of the hall, exactly three smaller artworks are mounted inside glass cases.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "On the back left wall (still considered the left side of the perspective), there are three smaller paintings enclosed in clear glass or acrylic cases."}, {"statement": "A seating bench is placed near the three tall paintings on the left side.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden bench is positioned on the floor near the three tall paintings of armored figures on the left."}, {"statement": "On the right wall, exactly two large vertical religious portraits are displayed.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right wall features exactly two large, vertical paintings depicting religious figures."}, {"statement": "A white informational display panel is mounted on the right wall beside the two large paintings.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a large white rectangular panel with text mounted on the right wall, situated before the two large religious paintings."}, {"statement": "The floor is polished light-colored marble.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The floor is made of polished, light-colored marble, complete with reflections of the room."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as warped picture frames, impossible wall or ceiling intersections, or a malformed bench structure.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The architecture, frames, and bench appear geometrically sound and structurally logical."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous visitors, sculptures, barrier ropes, watermarks, logos, or unrelated signage not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The space is empty of visitors, ropes, watermarks, or other extraneous elements not requested."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or near-identical paintings, frames, wall labels, or architectural details that appear unintentionally cloned.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The paintings, frames, and labels are distinct and do not show signs of unintentional cloning."}, {"statement": "The informational display panel or artwork labels contain visibly garbled pseudo-text or malformed glyphs.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the large white informational display panel on the right wall is composed of illegible, garbled pseudo-text."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the marble floor, picture glass, or frames.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections on the marble floor and the lighting throughout the room appear physically plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the walls, frames, glass cases, bench, and marble floor.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials (wood, marble, canvas, glass, plaster) are cleanly separated without color bleeding or texture smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 57, "total_positive_weight_possible": 57, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -3, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image successfully meets all positive prompt requirements, with the only issue being garbled text on the informational display panel.", "net_score": 54, "final_score": 94.7}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4865, "image_id": "c31a4074-9213-45eb-8bc7-ff81b386e477", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The main subject is a stone pedestal memorial.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A stone pedestal is clearly the main subject of the image."}, {"statement": "The floor contains an engraving of the name \"Frederick Douglass.\"", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The name \"Frederick Douglass\" is engraved on the pedestal itself, not on the floor."}, {"statement": "The floor contains an engraving of the years \"1818\" and \"1895.\"", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The dates \"1818-1895\" are engraved on the pedestal, not on the floor."}, {"statement": "The floor contains an engraved quote that includes the words \"struggle\" and \"progress.\"", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The floor contains the engraved quote \"If there is no struggle, there is progress.\""}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is slightly below the midpoint of the pedestal, creating a slight upward-looking view.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective is slightly low-angled, looking up at the pedestal."}, {"statement": "The pedestal presents multiple straight edges and flat planar faces rather than rounded or organic forms.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pedestal is constructed with straight edges and flat faces."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated by soft natural-looking light with gradual shadow transitions.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Soft, natural-looking light illuminates the scene with realistic shadows."}, {"statement": "The image uses a warm color palette dominated by beige, cream, gold, or brown tones.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The overall color palette is warm, featuring beige and brownish tones."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits broken or impossible stone geometry, such as warped edges, fused faces, or non-manifold pedestal surfaces.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The stone geometry appears solid and structurally sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, unrelated inscriptions, logos, or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects or hallucinated elements are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned memorial elements, such as repeated pedestal blocks or repeated copies of the inscription.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated or cloned elements visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical engraved text where the memorial name, dates, or quote should appear.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The quote is missing the word 'no' before progress, reading 'there is progress' instead of 'there is no progress'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent light direction or physically implausible shadows between the pedestal and the floor.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent and physically plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the stone pedestal, engraved lettering, and floor surfaces.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are distinctly rendered without bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 32, "total_positive_weight_possible": 49, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model incorrectly placed the name and dates on the pedestal instead of the floor, and slightly garbled the quote.", "net_score": 24, "final_score": 49.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4865, "image_id": "c31a4074-9213-45eb-8bc7-ff81b386e477", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A stone pedestal or monument base is the main subject of the image.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large stone pedestal base dominates the right side of the composition."}, {"statement": "The floor in front of the pedestal is engraved with the name \"Frederick Douglass.\"", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the floor is garbled and reads something like 'Frecdieck Digkbe S'."}, {"statement": "The floor engraving includes two separate four-digit years indicating Frederick Douglass's life dates.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The numbers present are garbled and do not form two four-digit years (e.g., '24.4.76' and a squiggle followed by '2178')."}, {"statement": "The floor engraving includes a quote whose readable wording mentions both struggle and progress.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text for the quote is completely illegible and garbled."}, {"statement": "The shot uses a slightly low angle that places the engraved floor prominently in the foreground.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective is low and places the inscribed floor prominently in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The pedestal is shown with clearly visible straight, stepped geometric lines.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pedestal has straight, stepped geometric lines."}, {"statement": "The illumination is soft, with gentle shadow transitions rather than harsh hard-edged shadows.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft with gentle shadow transitions."}, {"statement": "The overall image palette is warm-toned, dominated by beige, gold, or amber hues.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The palette is warm, with beige and amber tones dominating the stone and background."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or warped stone geometry, such as fused pedestal edges, distorted slab joints, or non-planar architectural surfaces.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The stone geometry appears plausible and well-defined."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, statues, signs, logos, watermark text, or other objects not implied by the memorial scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous people, logos, or objects are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned pedestal sections, engraved text blocks, or paving elements not implied by a single memorial pedestal.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No cloning or duplication of elements is observed."}, {"statement": "The engraved lettering contains illegible, garbled, or misspelled words instead of readable memorial text.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "All text engraved on the floor is severely garbled and unreadable."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadows, highlights, or reflections inconsistent with one soft natural light source.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows and highlights are consistent with the natural light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the engraved letters, the floor stone, and the pedestal stone.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct with no smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 24, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 3, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The generated image suffers from severe text garbling, rendering all requested text elements completely illegible.", "net_score": 16, "final_score": 33.3}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4865, "image_id": "c31a4074-9213-45eb-8bc7-ff81b386e477", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A stone pedestal with visible tiered, straight-edged geometry is centered as the main subject of the image.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A tiered stone pedestal is centered in the image."}, {"statement": "The memorial inscription is engraved into the floor surface directly in front of the pedestal.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main text inscription is engraved on a floor slab in front of the pedestal."}, {"statement": "The floor engraving includes the name \"Frederick Douglass\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The name \"FREDERICK DOUGLASS\" is clearly engraved on the floor."}, {"statement": "The floor engraving includes the life dates 1818 and 1895, or the range 1818-1895.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The life dates 1818 and 1895 are not present; instead, there is the number '9200'."}, {"statement": "The floor engraving includes a multi-line quote containing the word \"struggle\" and the word \"progress\".", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The multi-line text is mostly gibberish and contains 'PROGRESS' but not 'struggle'."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint is near floor level, with the engraved floor occupying the foreground and the camera looking slightly upward at the pedestal base.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective is low, showing the engraved floor in the foreground and the pedestal behind it."}, {"statement": "The lighting is soft and natural, without harsh flash-like hotspots or hard-edged shadows.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears soft and natural with realistic reflections."}, {"statement": "The overall color palette is warm, dominated by amber, beige, or golden tones.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene features warm beige and golden tones."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or visibly malformed pedestal or floor geometry, such as fused tiers, warped seams, or non-planar stone blocks.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the pedestal and floor appears structurally sound and plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, decorative objects, signage, watermark text, or logos not implied by the memorial scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous people or unrelated decorative objects are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned pedestal elements or repeated memorial inscriptions that imply multiple copies of the main subject.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated pedestals or cloned inscriptions."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, nonsensical, or unreadable engraved text where the name, dates, or quote should appear.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text below the name is highly garbled and nonsensical (e.g., 'SHCHEY A STO STETHO-IVUREATTL')."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadows or reflections on the pedestal or floor that conflict with a coherent light source.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The reflections and shadows on the floor and pedestal are consistent with the lighting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between engraved letters, floor slabs, and pedestal stone surfaces.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and well-rendered with no visible smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 34, "total_positive_weight_possible": 45, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main issue is severe text garbling in the floor engraving, missing the required life dates and accurate quote text.", "net_score": 26, "final_score": 57.8}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4865, "image_id": "c31a4074-9213-45eb-8bc7-ff81b386e477", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A stone pedestal is the main memorial structure in the scene.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent stone pedestal with a bust is visible in the center of the image."}, {"statement": "The floor in front of the pedestal is engraved with the name \"Frederick Douglass.\"", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The name 'FREDERICK DOUGLASS' is clearly engraved on the floor in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The floor engraving includes the life dates 1818 and 1895.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The dates '1818 - 1895' are engraved on the floor below the name."}, {"statement": "The floor engraving includes a quote containing both the words \"struggle\" and \"progress.\"", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The quote 'IF THERE IS NO STRUGGLE, THERE IS NO PROGRESS' is engraved on the floor."}, {"statement": "The camera is positioned at a slightly low angle so the engraved floor dominates the foreground.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective is low, making the engraved text on the floor the dominant element in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The composition clearly shows the pedestal's straight geometric edges.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The pedestal is rectangular with clear, straight vertical and horizontal edges."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated by soft natural-looking daylight with diffuse light rather than harsh sharply edged shadows.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears soft and natural, coming from a window, without harsh shadows."}, {"statement": "The overall color palette is warm, dominated by beige, amber, or golden tones.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image features a warm palette with prominent beige and golden lighting tones."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The Frederick Douglass bust or the surrounding architecture exhibits impossible geometry, fused features, or distorted proportions.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bust and architecture appear structurally sound and proportioned."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, furniture, signs, modern objects, watermarks, or logos not implied by the memorial scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects, people, or watermarks are present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated memorial elements, such as multiple Frederick Douglass figures, multiple pedestals, or repeated engraved text blocks.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is only one bust, one pedestal, and one set of engraved text."}, {"statement": "The engraved name, dates, or quote contain illegible, misspelled, or garbled characters.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All engraved text is clearly legible and spelled correctly."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits implausible lighting or shadows that do not align with the apparent daylight entering the space.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent with the window behind the bust."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared carved letters, or material confusion between the stone floor, stone pedestal, and plaster walls.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and the carved letters are crisp without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 52, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4906, "image_id": "f2be3d34-f0b8-4cb2-8d19-9ba0415d756e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "At least one deer is lying on the grass.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Multiple deer are shown lying down on the grassy slope in the foreground."}, {"statement": "At least one deer is standing upright.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "All the deer in the image are lying down; none are standing upright."}, {"statement": "The scene includes at least two cows.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two cows visible in the midground grazing on the grass."}, {"statement": "A turkey is positioned behind the deer and cows.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "A turkey is visible, but it is standing next to the cows in the midground, rather than behind the cows."}, {"statement": "A dog lies on the grass beside a deer near the center of the composition.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A small dog is lying on the grass nestled next to the deer in the center-right of the foreground."}, {"statement": "Exactly two tree trunks are visible in the background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two prominent vertical tree trunks behind the fence in the background."}, {"statement": "A fence made of horizontal wooden rails is visible in the background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden post-and-rail fence runs horizontally across the background behind the cows."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered in monochrome black-and-white tones.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The entire image is rendered in black and white grayscale."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts on animals, such as extra legs, fused limbs, or malformed heads.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The cow on the left has extra legs blending together, and the central cow's head is fused awkwardly with the left cow."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extra animal species, people, vehicles, signs, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unprompted objects or species are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned animals with unnaturally repeated bodies, heads, or markings.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The animals appear individually distinct without obvious cloning or texture repetition."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows that are inconsistent across the animals, fence, and ground plane.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits texture smearing or material confusion where animal fur, grass, fence rails, or tree bark blend incorrectly.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures for grass, fur, and wood remain distinct and do not smear into each other."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 38, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image lacks any standing deer and places the turkey beside rather than behind the cows, while suffering from severe anatomical fusing and extra limbs on the cows.", "net_score": 30, "final_score": 57.7}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4906, "image_id": "f2be3d34-f0b8-4cb2-8d19-9ba0415d756e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows at least one deer lying on the grass.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two deer lying down on the grass in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The image shows at least one deer standing upright.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two deer standing upright in the midground."}, {"statement": "The image shows a group of cows containing at least two cows.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three cows standing in the background."}, {"statement": "The image shows a dog lying on the grass immediately beside a deer located near the center of the composition.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A dog is lying on the grass in the bottom center/left, right in front of/beside a lying deer."}, {"statement": "The image shows a turkey positioned behind at least one deer and at least one cow.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The turkey is positioned in front of a standing deer and in front of the cows, not behind them."}, {"statement": "The background shows exactly two visible tree trunks.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two large tree trunks visible on the left side of the background."}, {"statement": "A wooden fence is visible beside the two tree trunks in the background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden post-and-rail fence runs across the background beside the trees."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered in monochrome or near-monochrome tones.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The image has distinct desaturated colors, but is not monochrome, as the turkey has blue/teal feathers, the cows have yellow ear tags, and the grass has a greenish-brown tint."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on animals, such as extra legs, fused limbs, malformed antlers, or distorted facial features.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The cow on the left has a malformed front leg that blends into the grass, and the turkey's tail feathers are abnormally rendered."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous elements not implied by the prompt, such as overlay text, watermarks, logos, signs, vehicles, or buildings.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements like text, vehicles, or buildings are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or near-identical cloned animals, poses, or coat patterns suggestive of copy artifacts.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The animals have varied poses and distinct spot patterns."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows, with inconsistent light direction across the animals and background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between fur, feathers, antlers, grass, or fence elements.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures for fur, feathers, wood, and grass are distinctly rendered without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 43, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image fails to place the turkey behind the other animals, misses the monochrome constraint by including noticeable color tints, and features minor geometric artifacts on the cow's leg.", "net_score": 35, "final_score": 66.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4906, "image_id": "f2be3d34-f0b8-4cb2-8d19-9ba0415d756e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image includes at least one deer that is lying down.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Multiple deer are lying down in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The image includes at least one deer that is standing.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are standing deer on the left and right sides of the image."}, {"statement": "The image shows at least two cows grouped together.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A group of three cows is standing together in the background on the left."}, {"statement": "A turkey appears behind the deer and cows.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "A turkey is present, but it is standing in the middle ground, not behind the cows."}, {"statement": "A dog is lying on the grass next to a deer near the center of the image.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A small dog is lying on the grass near the center, next to the central standing deer."}, {"statement": "The background shows exactly two tree trunks.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two prominent tree trunks visible in the background."}, {"statement": "A wooden fence is visible in the background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden fence runs across the background behind the animals."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered in grayscale monochrome.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is entirely in black and white grayscale."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on an animal, such as extra legs, fused limbs, missing facial features, or impossible body connections.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The deer on the far left has a strange, somewhat fused back leg structure, and the dog lying down has a poorly defined, blob-like shape."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous animals, people, objects, text, signs, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or watermarks are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned animals with unnaturally repeated poses, body shapes, or markings.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The animals have distinct poses and markings."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows that are inconsistent across the animals and background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits tonal bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where animals blend unnaturally into the grass, fence, or one another.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The animals are well-separated from the background and each other without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 47, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image mostly follows the prompt, but the turkey is incorrectly placed, and some minor geometric artifacts exist on the dog and a deer.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 73.6}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4906, "image_id": "f2be3d34-f0b8-4cb2-8d19-9ba0415d756e", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows at least one deer lying on the grass.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several deer are depicted lying down in the grassy foreground and middle ground."}, {"statement": "The image shows at least one deer standing upright.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Multiple deer are standing upright in the background."}, {"statement": "The image shows a group of at least two cows.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A group of multiple cows is visible on the left side of the mid-ground."}, {"statement": "A turkey appears behind the deer and cows.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "A turkey is present, but it is standing beside the cows and behind the foreground deer, rather than behind the cows and deer."}, {"statement": "A dog lies on the grass beside a deer located near the center of the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A shaggy dog is lying down on the grass directly in front of the central group of resting deer."}, {"statement": "A wooden fence appears in the background beside exactly two tree trunks.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden fence is visible in the background on the right, positioned next to exactly two distinct, thick tree trunks."}, {"statement": "The deer are distributed across multiple depth layers, with at least one deer in the foreground and another farther back in the scene.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Deer are arranged with some resting close to the camera and others standing further back on the hill."}, {"statement": "The image is rendered in grayscale or sepia-like monochrome tones rather than full color.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The entire image is rendered in a sepia-toned monochrome palette."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric errors in the animals, such as extra legs, fused limbs, malformed heads, or impossible body topology.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The animals' anatomies appear normal and lack structural anomalies."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, buildings, signs, text, watermarks, logos, or other objects not implied by the countryside animal scene.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No inappropriate elements or artifacts are visible in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned animals, fence elements, or tree elements that appear unnaturally repeated.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The subjects are varied and show no signs of cloning or repetition."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows that are inconsistent across the animals and landscape.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent with the overcast, hazy environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits texture smearing, color bleeding, or material confusion between fur, grass, wood, and bark.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures are distinct and cleanly rendered without blending."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 46, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The image accurately renders the complex prompt with only a minor spatial error regarding the turkey's placement relative to the cows.", "net_score": 46, "final_score": 88.5}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4956, "image_id": "9c188cff-1c96-438e-9d47-41b77a3d8bf4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The primary subject is a mailbox designed to resemble a car.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The mailbox does not resemble a car; it is a standard mailbox shape with wheels underneath."}, {"statement": "The mailbox body is green.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main body of the mailbox is painted green."}, {"statement": "A sign on the mailbox reads exactly \"1118 PRINTERY RD.\"", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '1118 PRINTERY RD.' is clearly written on the side of the mailbox."}, {"statement": "A green metal frame is visible beneath the mailbox.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are green metal support structures visible beneath the mailbox body."}, {"statement": "Exactly four tire-and-wheel assemblies are attached to the mailbox structure.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Four distinct black and yellow wheels are attached to the frame."}, {"statement": "The mailbox wheel assemblies have black tires and yellow wheel centers.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The wheels feature black tires and yellow rims/centers."}, {"statement": "Snow is present on both the left and right sides of the road.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Snowbanks are visible on both edges of the road surface."}, {"statement": "Out-of-focus buildings appear on the right side of the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Blurred brownish buildings are present in the background on the right side."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or broken geometry in the mailbox, frame, or wheels, such as fused tires or disconnected supports.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The front green support post passes straight through the front tire, representing impossible geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, signs, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is a small, hallucinated logo and text near the front right edge of the mailbox."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits cloned or unnaturally repeated mailbox or wheel elements suggesting duplication artifacts.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No cloning or unnaturally repeated elements are evident."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, incomplete, or illegible characters in the address sign or any other visible text.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The small text on the front right edge and the small 'RD' are somewhat garbled or artifacted."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, shadows, or reflections across the mailbox, wheels, road, and snow.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent with an overcast snowy scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the green metal parts, black tires, yellow wheel centers, road surface, and snow.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct without significant smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 44, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -17, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The mailbox fails to resemble a car, and the image contains impossible geometry where a support post clips through a tire.", "net_score": 27, "final_score": 50.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4956, "image_id": "9c188cff-1c96-438e-9d47-41b77a3d8bf4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The main subject is a mailbox designed to resemble a car.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A green object shaped like a car serves as the mailbox."}, {"statement": "The car-shaped mailbox body is green.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The car-shaped portion of the mailbox is rendered in green."}, {"statement": "A sign for the mailbox reads exactly \"1118 PRINTERY RD.\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign attached to the support structure clearly reads '1118 PRINTERY RD.'."}, {"statement": "The mailbox is mounted on a green metal support frame.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The car-shaped box is held up by a framework of green metal bars."}, {"statement": "Exactly four support wheels are attached to the mailbox structure.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are four large support wheels at the base of the frame."}, {"statement": "The four support wheels have black tires with yellow rims or wheel centers.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The wheels on the frame feature black tires and yellow centers."}, {"statement": "Snow is visible along both the left and right sides of the road.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Snow borders the road on both the left and right sides."}, {"statement": "Blurred brownish buildings are visible on the right side of the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are blurred, brownish houses visible in the right background."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the car-shaped mailbox, support frame, or wheel attachments.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The front left wheel on the car body itself seems to partially clip or fuse with the green metal frame beneath it."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a watermark, brand logo, or other extraneous readable text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks or unrequested text are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an extra duplicated or cloned car-shaped mailbox or address sign beyond the single requested mailbox.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is only one mailbox and one address sign."}, {"statement": "The address sign text is garbled, partially unreadable, or rendered with malformed letters.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '1118 PRINTERY RD.' is rendered clearly and correctly."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, shadows, or reflections across the mailbox, wheels, road, and snow.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent throughout the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the green mailbox or frame, the black-and-yellow wheels, and the surrounding snow or road.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct and do not bleed into one another."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 53, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model followed all prompt instructions well, but generated a slight geometry artifact where the car body's front wheel meets the support frame.", "net_score": 46, "final_score": 86.8}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4956, "image_id": "9c188cff-1c96-438e-9d47-41b77a3d8bf4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The main subject is a car-shaped mailbox.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The mailbox is cylindrical with tires attached, not car-shaped."}, {"statement": "The mailbox body is green.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main body of the mailbox is painted green."}, {"statement": "The sign on the mailbox reads exactly \"1118 PRINTERY RD.\"", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The sign reads '118 PRINTERY RD.', missing a '1'."}, {"statement": "The mailbox has exactly four tires.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "Only two tires are visible attached to the front of the mailbox."}, {"statement": "The tires are black with yellow accents.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The visible tires are black with a yellow inner rim."}, {"statement": "The tires are attached to a green metal frame.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The tires are attached directly to the green mailbox body, not a separate frame."}, {"statement": "Snow covers both sides of the road.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Snow is clearly visible on the ground on both the left and right sides of the road."}, {"statement": "Blurred brownish buildings appear on the right side of the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are blurred brown/reddish buildings on the right side of the road in the background."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as fused, misshapen, or impossibly attached tires or mailbox parts.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The tires are unrealistically attached to the sides of the mailbox cylinder."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits prominent extraneous foreground objects, people, vehicles, logos, or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous foreground objects are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned mailbox components or tire elements that appear unnaturally repeated.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unnatural duplication is evident."}, {"statement": "The rendered address text contains illegible, garbled, or malformed characters.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '118 PRINTERY RD.' is clearly legible, even though incorrect."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent across the mailbox, tires, and snowy road.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the tires, mailbox body, frame, and snow.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 19, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 4, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The mailbox is not car-shaped, has only two tires, and the text reads '118' instead of '1118'.", "net_score": 13, "final_score": 25.5}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4956, "image_id": "9c188cff-1c96-438e-9d47-41b77a3d8bf4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A mailbox shaped like a car is prominently visible.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large green car-shaped object serving as a mailbox is the central focus of the image."}, {"statement": "The car-shaped mailbox is green.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main body of the car-shaped mailbox is painted green."}, {"statement": "A sign on the mailbox reads exactly \"1118 PRINTERY RD.\"", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A sign mounted on the roof of the car clearly displays '1118 PRINTERY RD.'"}, {"statement": "The mailbox has exactly four tires.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Four tires are visible on the car-shaped mailbox (two prominent on the left side, and the edges of the other two visible on the opposite side)."}, {"statement": "The tires are black with yellow wheel centers or rims.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The tires shown have black treads with yellow centers/hubs."}, {"statement": "A green metal frame is visible beneath the mailbox body.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A green metal tubular frame connects the wheels beneath the main body of the car."}, {"statement": "A road is visible with snow along both sides of it.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A paved road is shown in the background with snow covering the ground on either side."}, {"statement": "The right side of the background contains blurred brownish buildings.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Blurred brown residential buildings are visible in the background on the right."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits fused, broken, or impossible geometry in the mailbox body, sign, tires, or undercarriage frame.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The structure of the car, frame, and wheels appears structurally coherent without impossible geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, signs, logos, or watermark text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no extra people, vehicles, or text watermarks in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned objects, such as repeated wheels, trees, or buildings, that appear copy-pasted rather than distinct.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning or copy-pasting artifacts are visible among the background elements or the main subject."}, {"statement": "The address sign contains illegible, garbled, or nonsensical glyphs.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '1118 PRINTERY RD.' is rendered cleanly and legibly."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow directions across the mailbox, road, and snow.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows are consistent with an overcast snowy day."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the green mailbox, black/yellow wheels, wooden sign, and white snow.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Colors and materials are distinctly separated without bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 53, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 53, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 4993, "image_id": "f1df041d-d18a-44c9-8ae3-19418e551926", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two street signs.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two street signs visible on the post."}, {"statement": "The image is framed as a medium shot with the street signs in focus.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The framing is a medium shot and the signs are sharp and in focus."}, {"statement": "Both street signs are blue with white lettering.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both signs have a blue background and white text."}, {"statement": "The larger street sign is positioned on the right side of the image.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign on the right is larger and prominent."}, {"statement": "The right street sign reads \"Weißfrauenstraße 15-7\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Weißfrauenstraße 15-7' is clearly legible on the right sign."}, {"statement": "The left street sign is partially visible.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The left sign is cropped by the left edge of the frame."}, {"statement": "The left street sign reads \"Straße 14-20\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Straße 14-20' is visible on the left sign."}, {"statement": "A tall white building appears in the background against a clear blue sky.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white building and clear blue sky form the background."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped, fused, or otherwise impossible geometry in the street signs, signpost, or building.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the signs, post, and building appears normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, street furniture, unrelated text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned street signs, signpost elements, or building sections suggestive of copy artifacts.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No duplicated elements or cloning artifacts are visible."}, {"statement": "The street-sign text contains illegible, garbled, or nonsensical glyphs.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text is perfectly legible with no garbled characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the signs and building.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent and plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the blue signs, the metal signpost, and the white building.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct with no bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 56, "total_positive_weight_possible": 56, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 56, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 4993, "image_id": "f1df041d-d18a-44c9-8ae3-19418e551926", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two street signs.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two street signs attached to the central pole."}, {"statement": "The street signs use white lettering on blue signboards.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both signs feature white text on a blue background."}, {"statement": "The street signs are in sharper focus than the background building.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signs are sharply focused while the building behind them is blurred."}, {"statement": "The right-hand street sign reads \"Weißfrauenstraße \\ 15-7\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the right sign accurately reads 'Weißfrauenstraße / 15-7' (note: forward slash used instead of backslash, but acceptable given prompt spacing)."}, {"statement": "The left-hand street sign reads \"Straße \\ 14-20\".", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the left sign accurately reads 'Straße / 14-20'."}, {"statement": "The left-hand street sign is cropped so that only part of it is visible.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The left side of the left street sign extends out of the frame."}, {"statement": "A predominantly white multistory building is visible in the background behind the street signs.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white multistory building with multiple windows is clearly visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The visible sky area is blue and cloud-free.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sky is solid blue with no clouds visible."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the signboards, pole, mounting brackets, or building edges.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mounting brackets, pole, and signs are structurally coherent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated people, vehicles, vegetation, logos, watermarks, or other unrelated objects not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There are stickers hallucinated on the sign pole, and vegetation is visible in the lower right."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits identical repeated patches of windows, facade, foliage, or sign hardware that indicate cloning artifacts.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning artifacts are present."}, {"statement": "The street-sign text contains illegible, garbled, or malformed characters.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text is legible and correctly formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent shadow, highlight, or reflection directions between the signs, pole, and building.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion at boundaries between the blue signs, the pole, the building, and the sky.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Edges between objects and the background are clean."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 58, "total_positive_weight_possible": 58, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -4, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image perfectly follows the prompt, with minor hallucinations of stickers and vegetation.", "net_score": 54, "final_score": 93.1}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 4993, "image_id": "f1df041d-d18a-44c9-8ae3-19418e551926", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two street signs.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two street signs visible in the image."}, {"statement": "Both street signs are blue.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the left and right street signs have a blue background."}, {"statement": "Both street signs are in focus.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both street signs are sharply in focus against a blurred background."}, {"statement": "The larger street sign is positioned on the right side of the frame.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign on the right is larger and positioned on the right side of the image."}, {"statement": "The larger right sign bears the white inscription \"Weißfrauenstraße 15-7\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The right sign clearly displays \"Weißfrauenstraße 15-7\" in white text."}, {"statement": "The left street sign bears the white inscription \"Straße 14-20\".", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The left sign says \"Straße -> 14-20.\" rather than the requested \"Straße 14-20\"."}, {"statement": "The background contains a tall white building.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A tall white building is visible in the background out of focus."}, {"statement": "The scene is set against a clear blue sky.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background features a clear blue sky."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry or fused structure in the street signs, support poles, or building.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The street signs, poles, and building appear structurally coherent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unrelated extra elements such as people, vehicles, trees, stickers, watermarks, or logos beyond the two street signs, their poles, one building, and sky.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There are stickers visible on the pole of the left street sign."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a duplicated or cloned copy of a street sign or support pole with obvious repeated shape or text.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious duplicated or cloned signs or poles."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or malformed glyphs on rendered text.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The left sign contains an arrow character and period not requested in the prompt."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the signs, poles, building, and sky.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between adjacent objects such as sign faces, lettering, poles, building edges, or sky.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures remain distinct with no visible color bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 55, "total_positive_weight_possible": 64, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The left sign includes unrequested characters (an arrow and a period), and there are unwanted stickers on its pole.", "net_score": 43, "final_score": 67.2}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 4993, "image_id": "f1df041d-d18a-44c9-8ae3-19418e551926", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two street signs.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two street signs visible on the pole."}, {"statement": "Both street signs are in focus.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the right and left street signs are clearly in focus."}, {"statement": "Both street signs are blue.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both visible street signs have a blue background."}, {"statement": "The larger street sign is positioned on the right side of the frame.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The larger, fully visible street sign extends to the right."}, {"statement": "The larger right street sign reads \"Weißfrauenstraße 15-7\" in white text.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Weißfrauenstraße \\ 15-7' is clearly legible in white on the right sign."}, {"statement": "A partially visible left street sign reads \"Straße 14-20\" in white text.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The left sign reads 'straße \\ 14-20' in white text."}, {"statement": "A tall white building appears in the background.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A tall building with white facades is visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The background around the scene is a clear blue sky.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A clear blue sky surrounds the signs and building."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or severely distorted geometry in the street signs, signposts, or building.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the signs, pole, and building appears normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, overlay text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are hallucinated."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned fragments of the street signs, signposts, or building facade.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No duplicated fragments are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical rendered text on either street sign.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on both signs is clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the signs or building.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent and plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the blue signs, metal frames, building, and sky.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct without smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 59, "total_positive_weight_possible": 59, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 59, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5302, "image_id": "9c90a52e-2d73-4dcf-9adc-530fc25a7bfe", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene contains exactly two physical red candles, excluding any mirror reflections.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two physical red candles in the foreground (with reflections visible in the background mirror)."}, {"statement": "Each of the two physical candles is placed in a glass holder.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both physical red candles are standing in clear glass holders."}, {"statement": "The scene contains exactly one physical figurine depicting a bride and a groom together, excluding mirror reflections.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a single physical figurine of a bride and groom standing together in the center."}, {"statement": "The scene includes a physical mirror.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A physical mirror is present on the right side behind the rose, and a larger mirror is in the background."}, {"statement": "The scene includes a glass vessel holding a rose, excluding any reflected copy in the mirror.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A physical glass vase holding a single red rose is present in front of the right-side mirror."}, {"statement": "The scene includes a white box decorated with ornamental dove motifs.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white box with a raised dove motif is visible in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The scene includes a sign reading \"Mr.\".", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A small wooden sign reading \"Mr.\" is visible on the left."}, {"statement": "The scene includes a sign reading \"Mrs.\".", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is no sign reading \"Mrs.\" visible in the image."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The bride-and-groom figurine exhibits malformed, fused, or missing limbs, hands, eyes, or facial features.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The figurine features are clear and well-formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, decorative items, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the wedding tabletop prompt, excluding mirror reflections of requested items.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned physical decor items that look like repeated copies of the same candle, figurine, sign, rose vessel, mirror, or box, excluding legitimate mirror reflections.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no inappropriately cloned or duplicated items."}, {"statement": "Visible sign text is garbled, misspelled, or illegible instead of clearly readable.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the \"Mr.\" sign is clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible mirror reflections or glass reflections/shadows that do not match the positions of the candles, figurine, rose vessel, or box.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The large mirror in the background reflects a third candle that does not correspond to a physical candle in the scene, and the surface reflections below the \"Mr.\" sign and white box appear misaligned."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent surfaces such as wax, glass, mirror, figurine, and the white box.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are distinctly rendered without bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 50, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image misses the 'Mrs.' sign and contains a physics violation with an extra candle reflection.", "net_score": 45, "final_score": 83.3}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5302, "image_id": "9c90a52e-2d73-4dcf-9adc-530fc25a7bfe", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly 2 physical candles are present in the scene, excluding mirror reflections.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two physical candles present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The candles are red.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both physical candles shown are red."}, {"statement": "Each physical candle is inside a transparent glass holder.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both red candles are contained within clear, transparent glass holders."}, {"statement": "The image includes a figurine depicting a bride and groom together.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image includes figurines of a bride and groom."}, {"statement": "A mirror is shown with a drinking glass or goblet holding a rose.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A mirror is present reflecting a glass goblet holding a red rose."}, {"statement": "A white box decorated with ornamental dove motifs is visible.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A decorated white box is visible, with ornamental doves placed upon it."}, {"statement": "A visible sign reads \"Mr.\"", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A sign with the text \"Mr.\" is clearly visible on the left."}, {"statement": "A visible sign reads \"Mrs.\"", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A sign with the text \"Mrs.\" is clearly visible on the right."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The bride or groom figurine exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts such as fused limbs, malformed hands, or distorted facial features.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The hands on the figurines are poorly formed and exhibit geometric artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, text, watermarks, or logos that are not implied by the described wedding tabletop scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects, people, or text are hallucinated in the image."}, {"statement": "The image contains duplicated or cloned copies of a requested main subject, excluding normal mirror reflections.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are two separate sets of bride and groom figurines present, duplicating the requested subject."}, {"statement": "Rendered text intended to read \"Mr.\" or \"Mrs.\" is garbled, misspelled, or illegible.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text \"Mr.\" and \"Mrs.\" is rendered clearly and legibly."}, {"statement": "The mirror reflection, candle lighting, shadows, or glass transparency are physically implausible or inconsistent with the scene geometry.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The reflection in the mirror shows a candle and other elements not positioned correctly relative to the physical objects in the foreground."}, {"statement": "The image shows color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between wax, glass, fabric, and decorative surfaces.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials such as wax, glass, and fabric are rendered distinctly without significant smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -16, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image features duplicated bride and groom figurines and an inconsistent mirror reflection, though all requested elements are present.", "net_score": 36, "final_score": 69.2}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5302, "image_id": "9c90a52e-2d73-4dcf-9adc-530fc25a7bfe", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly two candles are visible in the scene.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two lit candles shown in the image."}, {"statement": "The two candles are red.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both candles are red."}, {"statement": "Each candle is placed in a glass holder.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The red candles are standing in clear glass holders."}, {"statement": "The image includes one figurine depicting a bride and groom.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A single bride and groom figurine is prominently placed in the center."}, {"statement": "A mirror is visible in the scene.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "No mirror is visible in the scene."}, {"statement": "A separate glass vessel containing a rose is visible in the scene.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a glass on the left holding a rose."}, {"statement": "A white box decorated with ornamental doves is visible in the scene.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white box with golden doves is visible on the right."}, {"statement": "Visible signs read \"Mr.\" and \"Mrs.\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign \"Mr.Mrs.\" is present on top of the white box."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on the bride-and-groom figurine, such as extra limbs, fused body parts, malformed hands, or distorted faces.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The figurine has no visible anatomical artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, logos, or watermarks not implied by the wedding-decoration prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene does not include extraneous elements beyond the wedding decor."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously cloned or unintentionally duplicated decorative items with near-identical appearance, suggesting copy artifacts.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no obvious unintentional cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits additional illegible or garbled rendered text beyond the requested \"Mr.\" and \"Mrs.\" signs.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "There is garbled text on the white box beneath the doves."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, flame glow, shadows, reflections, or glass transparency inconsistent with the rest of the scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and materials appear physically plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent elements such as wax, glass, rose petals, skin, fabric, and the box.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 48, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The requested mirror is missing, and the white box features garbled, hallucinated text.", "net_score": 43, "final_score": 82.7}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5302, "image_id": "9c90a52e-2d73-4dcf-9adc-530fc25a7bfe", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The tabletop arrangement includes exactly two physical candles, excluding any mirror reflections.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two physical candles visible on the table, one on the left and one on the right."}, {"statement": "Both physical candles are red.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both candles in the glass holders are colored red."}, {"statement": "Each physical candle is inside a glass holder.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both red candles are contained within clear glass holders."}, {"statement": "The image includes a figurine depicting a bride and groom.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A figurine of a bride and groom is present on the left side of the table."}, {"statement": "The image includes a mirror.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A framed mirror is standing behind the white box."}, {"statement": "The image includes a glass container holding a rose.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A clear glass vase holding a red rose is present on the right side."}, {"statement": "The image includes a white box whose decoration features ornamental doves.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white box sits in the center, adorned with two ornamental doves on top."}, {"statement": "The image includes signs reading exactly \"Mr.\" and \"Mrs.\".", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two wooden signs are present in the foreground, reading 'Mr.' and 'Mrs.'."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The bride-or-groom figurine exhibits malformed or fused heads, limbs, hands, or other impossible geometry.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The bride and groom figurine's faces and hands are melted and somewhat fused together."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unrelated extraneous objects, people, logos, watermark text, or other additions not implied by the tabletop wedding-decoration scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unrelated objects or watermarks are present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned decorative items with unnaturally identical repeated appearance, excluding normal mirror reflections.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The decorative items appear unique or appropriately varied without unnatural cloning."}, {"statement": "The rendered lettering on the table signs is illegible, garbled, or visually corrupted.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the 'Mr.' and 'Mrs.' signs is clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections, shadows, or glass transparency in the mirror, candle holders, or rose container.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The reflection in the mirror shows a white box, but it is angled incorrectly and the ribbon does not match the real box."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the lace cloth, wooden tabletop, glass items, figurine, and box.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are distinctly rendered without significant smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 48, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The model successfully includes all requested elements, but introduces minor physics violations in the mirror reflection and geometry artifacts on the figurine.", "net_score": 40, "final_score": 83.3}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5352, "image_id": "9c3b2fea-fe17-400f-bb7c-b9b67d3f8d85", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The plaque surface shows visible wood grain or surface wear characteristic of wood.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plaque features distinct wood grain, knots, and surface scratches."}, {"statement": "A stone wall forms the background behind the plaque.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists entirely of a stone wall."}, {"statement": "Exactly two metal chains suspend the plaque.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two distinct metal chains are attached to the top of the plaque."}, {"statement": "Exactly three separate words are written on the plaque.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly three separate words ('Сила', 'Мъдрост', 'Надежда') on the plaque."}, {"statement": "The words on the plaque use Cyrillic characters.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The words are written in Cyrillic script."}, {"statement": "Stone wall is visible on all four sides of the plaque.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The stone wall can be seen above, below, to the left, and to the right of the plaque."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated by daylight.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene is lit by bright, directional sunlight casting strong shadows."}, {"statement": "Individual stones in the wall are clearly delineated as separate shapes.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The individual stones making up the wall are well-defined and clearly separated."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the chain links, plaque holes, or plaque attachment points.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The chains attach to the plaque via loops that fuse seamlessly into the top edge of the wood, without distinct holes or hardware."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the plaque-on-wall scene.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects, watermarks, or logos are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned plaques, chain segments, or copied patches of wall texture not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning or duplication is visible in the textures or objects."}, {"statement": "The rendered plaque text contains illegible, garbled, or non-word glyphs.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text is perfectly legible Cyrillic."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows, such as chain or plaque shadows that do not match the scene's light direction.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shadows cast by the plaque and chains are consistent with the strong directional sunlight."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the wood plaque, metal chains, and stone wall.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and well-rendered with no bleeding or confusion."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 53, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image is largely successful, meeting all positive criteria, but exhibits a minor geometry artifact where the chain attachments fuse into the wood without clear hardware or holes.", "net_score": 48, "final_score": 90.6}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5352, "image_id": "9c3b2fea-fe17-400f-bb7c-b9b67d3f8d85", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image includes a wooden plaque.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent wooden plaque is visible in the center of the image."}, {"statement": "The plaque surface shows visible weathered wood grain consistent with a vintage sign.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The wood surface has deep, visible grain and a weathered appearance."}, {"statement": "The plaque is suspended by exactly two visible metal chains.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two metal chains are clearly seen attaching the plaque to the wall above."}, {"statement": "The plaque occupies at least one-third of the frame area, indicating a medium shot focused on it.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plaque is large and centrally framed, taking up a significant portion of the image."}, {"statement": "A stone wall of individually distinguishable stones is visible behind the plaque.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A background consisting of individually distinct stones is clearly visible."}, {"statement": "The plaque contains exactly three separate words of text.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are only two separate words visible on the plaque, not three."}, {"statement": "The text on the plaque is rendered in Cyrillic characters consistent with Bulgarian.", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text uses Latin-style characters with diacritics ('Ooglütér Uauur'), not Cyrillic."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated by daylight.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows suggest a sunny daylight environment."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry in the plaque or chain links, such as fused, broken, or non-manifold attachments.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plaque and chains appear structurally sound with no fused or impossible geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unrelated objects or people beyond the plaque, chains, and stone wall.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only the plaque, chains, and wall are visible."}, {"statement": "The stone wall contains obviously cloned repeating stones or repeated texture patches.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The stones in the wall appear unique without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The plaque text contains malformed or unreadable glyphs.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text forms nonsensical words with unusual accents ('Ooglütér Uauur')."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent shadow directions between the plaque, chains, and stone wall.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows fall consistently down and to the left across all objects."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding or texture smearing at the boundaries between the chains, plaque, and stone wall.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Boundaries between the chains, wood, and stone are clean."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 38, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image fails to generate three words and uses garbled Latin characters instead of Bulgarian Cyrillic.", "net_score": 30, "final_score": 55.6}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5352, "image_id": "9c3b2fea-fe17-400f-bb7c-b9b67d3f8d85", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly one plaque.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A single wooden plaque is centrally framed."}, {"statement": "The plaque surface shows visible wood grain or carved wooden texture.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Wood grain texture is visible on the edges and background of the plaque."}, {"statement": "The background behind the plaque is a stone wall with separate stones visibly discernible.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Distinct, individual stones make up the wall behind the plaque."}, {"statement": "The plaque is suspended by exactly two metal chains.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two metal chains are clearly attached to the top of the plaque."}, {"statement": "Exactly three separate words are written on the plaque.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Three distinct lines of text, appearing as three words, are on the plaque."}, {"statement": "The text on the plaque is rendered in Cyrillic characters.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The characters shown appear to be Cyrillic."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit as daylight.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Strong shadows and bright highlights indicate daylight illumination."}, {"statement": "The plaque occupies at least one-third of the image area, consistent with a medium-shot focused on the plaque.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plaque takes up a significant portion, well over a third, of the frame."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or broken geometry in the plaque frame, chain links, or chain attachment points.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The chains and plaque frame geometry appear structurally sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, logos, or watermark text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra objects or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The stone wall or plaque surface exhibits visibly duplicated or cloned texture patterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures appear natural without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The text on the plaque exhibits garbled, malformed, or unreadable glyphs.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text contains some garbled or nonsensical letter combinations."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent daylight shadows or highlights across the plaque, chains, and stone wall.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows and lighting are consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the wood, metal chains, and stone wall.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and do not bleed into one another."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image meets all positive criteria but contains garbled text on the plaque.", "net_score": 43, "final_score": 84.3}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5352, "image_id": "9c3b2fea-fe17-400f-bb7c-b9b67d3f8d85", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The plaque occupies at least half of the image width.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rectangular wooden plaque spans most of the width of the image."}, {"statement": "The plaque surface shows visible wood-grain texture.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Wood grain lines and knots are clearly visible on the surface of the plaque."}, {"statement": "The plaque is suspended by exactly two metal chains.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two rusty metal chains are shown attaching to the top edge of the plaque."}, {"statement": "The front face of the plaque displays exactly three separate written words.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three distinct words written on the plaque, separated by commas."}, {"statement": "The words on the plaque are written in Cyrillic script.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text uses Cyrillic characters."}, {"statement": "The background behind the plaque is a stone wall.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plaque is hung against a wall made of stacked stones."}, {"statement": "Individual stones in the wall are clearly distinguishable.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shapes and edges of individual stones in the wall are clearly defined."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated as daylight rather than night or indoor lighting.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bright lighting and sharp shadows indicate a daylight setting."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed, fused, or broken chain links or other impossible geometry in the plaque or wall.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The chain links and other geometric elements appear structurally sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, animals, plants, logos, watermarks, or decorative objects not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an additional plaque or a cloned duplicate of the main plaque not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only one plaque is visible in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, unreadable, or nonsensical lettering on the plaque.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lettering on the plaque is clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent shadow or highlight directions between the plaque, chains, and stone wall.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows consistently fall downward and to the left across all objects."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the wood, metal, and stone surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures of the wood, stone, and metal are distinct without bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 49, "total_positive_weight_possible": 49, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 49, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5588, "image_id": "8098008f-9948-4a16-9b7a-284f65d86909", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is composed as a wide shot rather than a close-up.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image captures a broad view of a city, river, and surrounding landscape, confirming it is a wide shot."}, {"statement": "Dense green trees occupy much of the background, surrounding the built-up area on most sides.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large area of the background is filled with dense green trees enclosing the buildings."}, {"statement": "At least five classical stone or masonry buildings are visible along the riverbanks.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "More than five large stone buildings are clearly visible lining both sides of the river."}, {"statement": "At least three boats with tall sails are visible on the river.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are four sailboats with tall white sails visible on the river."}, {"statement": "At least five cars are visible on streets or roads beside the river.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several cars are parked and driving along the road on the right side of the river."}, {"statement": "A bridge railing is visible across the foreground along the bottom edge of the image.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A black metal bridge railing spans the entire bottom edge of the image."}, {"statement": "A watermark reading \"Luis Barria\" appears at the bottom of the image.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Luis Barria' is clearly visible at the bottom center of the image below the railing."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated by natural sunlight, with visible shadows on the buildings.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Sunlight illuminates the scene, casting distinct shadows on the building facades and trees."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts, such as malformed people or impossible boat, building, or railing structures.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The buildings, boats, railing, and overall geometry appear well-formed and realistic."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits prominent extraneous text, logos, or watermarks other than the requested photographer credit \"Luis Barria\".", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No significant extraneous text or logos are present other than the requested watermark."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned boats, cars, trees, or people with obviously repeated shapes or textures.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The objects in the scene exhibit natural variation without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unreadable or garbled glyphs in rendered text, including the bottom watermark.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Underneath the legible 'Luis Barria' watermark, there is smaller, garbled and illegible text."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible sunlight direction, shadows, or water reflections that are inconsistent within the scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting, shadows, and reflections on the water are consistent with a single light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent trees, buildings, water, sails, and railing.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and materials are distinct with clear boundaries between the different elements."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image perfectly follows the prompt instructions, with the only minor flaw being some garbled text beneath the main watermark.", "net_score": 46, "final_score": 90.2}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5588, "image_id": "8098008f-9948-4a16-9b7a-284f65d86909", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A river or canal occupies a prominent central portion of the scene.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A river occupies the lower central portion of the image."}, {"statement": "Green trees are visible on the left side, right side, and far background around the city.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Green trees are visible on both sides of the river and in the background."}, {"statement": "Multi-story classical stone or masonry buildings line both sides of the waterway.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Classical multi-story buildings line the streets along the waterway."}, {"statement": "At least 3 boats with tall sails are visible on the waterway.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are at least 4 boats with tall sails on the river."}, {"statement": "A bridge spans the waterway.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A bridge crosses the river in the middle distance."}, {"statement": "At least 10 cars are visible on the city streets.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Many cars are parked and driving on the streets next to the river."}, {"statement": "A bridge railing is visible along the bottom foreground.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A blurry stone railing is visible across the bottom foreground."}, {"statement": "A bottom-edge watermark reads \"Luis Barria\".", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The watermark reads 'Luis Brrria', with a typo."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the sailboats or their rigging.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The sails and rigging of the boats appear somewhat fused and structurally impossible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous signs, logos, or text beyond the requested photographer watermark.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous text is visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned boats, cars, trees, or buildings with unnaturally repeated identical patterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning artifacts are present."}, {"statement": "The bottom-edge watermark text is illegible or contains corrupted glyphs.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The watermark text 'Luis Brrria' is corrupted/misspelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits shadows or water reflections that are inconsistent with the apparent sunlight direction.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows and reflections appear consistent with sunlight coming from the right."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding or texture smearing between adjacent elements such as sails, water, buildings, and trees.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No significant color bleeding or smearing is visible."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 48, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -9, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image generally matches the prompt but has misspelled text in the watermark and minor geometry artifacts in the sailboats.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 75.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5588, "image_id": "8098008f-9948-4a16-9b7a-284f65d86909", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The frame includes multiple city blocks and a long stretch of the river in one view.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image shows a wide view of the city with several blocks and a long portion of the river."}, {"statement": "Dense green trees are visible on the left side, right side, and background around the city.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Dense green trees surround the city on the hills in the background and line the riverbanks."}, {"statement": "Classical European-style stone buildings line both sides of the river.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are classical-style buildings along the streets on both sides of the river."}, {"statement": "At least two boats with tall sails are present on the river.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two boats with tall sails are clearly visible navigating the river."}, {"statement": "At least 10 cars are visible on the streets beside the river.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Numerous cars are parked and driving along the streets flanking the river."}, {"statement": "A bridge spans the river within the city scene.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A bridge crosses the river in the middle distance."}, {"statement": "A bridge railing runs across the lower foreground of the image.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large stone bridge railing dominates the left foreground."}, {"statement": "A watermark at the bottom of the image reads 'Luis Barria'.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "No watermark reading 'Luis Barria' is present at the bottom of the image."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in people, boats, cars, bridge railings, or building facades.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "A car in the lower right foreground appears to be driving directly on the water."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous large objects, signs, logos, or additional watermarks beyond the requested photographer credit.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra large objects, signs, logos, or watermarks are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned boats, cars, buildings, or tree canopies with obviously repeated identical patterns.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning or repeated identical patterns are seen in the elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, misspelled, or garbled text in the photographer watermark area.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is no text in the watermark area to be garbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits shadows or reflections whose direction is inconsistent across the buildings, boats, and river.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent areas such as water, boats, buildings, trees, or the foreground railing.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are distinct with no obvious bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 48, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The requested watermark is missing, and a physics violation shows a car driving on the water.", "net_score": 43, "final_score": 81.1}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5588, "image_id": "8098008f-9948-4a16-9b7a-284f65d86909", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is framed as a wide shot showing a broad cityscape.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image provides a sweeping, wide-angle view of a large town and surrounding landscape."}, {"statement": "A visible river runs through or directly alongside the city.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wide river flows prominently through the center of the town."}, {"statement": "Dense green trees are visible around the built-up city area on at least three sides of the frame.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lush green trees and forested hills surround the town on the left, top, and right."}, {"statement": "At least 5 stone or masonry buildings are visible directly along the riverbanks.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Many classical stone buildings line the banks of the river on both sides."}, {"statement": "At least 3 boats with tall sails are visible on the river.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several boats with tall masts and sails are moored and sailing on the river."}, {"statement": "At least 8 cars are visible on the city streets or bridge.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Numerous cars are visible driving and parked on the streets and the bridge."}, {"statement": "A bridge railing is visible in the immediate foreground.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large stone bridge railing occupies the immediate right foreground."}, {"statement": "A watermark along the bottom edge reads \"Luis Barria\".", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text '© Luis Barria' is clearly visible in the bottom right corner."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or broken geometry, such as distorted human body parts, warped railings, fused boats, or malformed buildings.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The buildings, boats, bridge, and people appear structurally sound and correctly proportioned."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous prominent objects, captions, logos, or watermarks not implied by the riverside city prompt, other than the requested photographer watermark.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected logos, objects, or text are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned boats, cars, buildings, or people with conspicuously repeated identical appearance.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene features diverse and unrepeated elements throughout."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered text in the watermark area.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The watermark text is crisp and perfectly legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent sunlight, shadows, or reflections across the buildings, bridge, and river.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting, shadows, and reflections are consistent with a single sun source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent trees, buildings, bridge surfaces, and water.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and boundaries between water, stone, and foliage are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 53, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 53, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5596, "image_id": "7f608b69-db82-4445-804a-cbb8febbebe3", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "At least one yellow directional road sign displays the destination name Čakovec.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A top yellow sign displays 'ČAKOVEC'."}, {"statement": "At least one yellow directional road sign displays the destination name Varaždin.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A yellow sign displays 'VARAŽDIN'."}, {"statement": "At least one yellow directional road sign displays the destination name Zagreb.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A yellow sign displays 'ZAGREB'."}, {"statement": "At least one brown road sign displays the words Vinska cesta or Wine Road.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A brown sign displays 'VÍNSKA CESTA'."}, {"statement": "At least one brown road sign contains either the words Tourist Information or a white lowercase i information symbol.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The brown sign displays 'TURÍŠTÍCKE INFORMAŤIONE' instead of 'Tourist Information' and lacks a standard 'i' symbol."}, {"statement": "At least one blue road sign shows a bicycle pictogram.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A blue sign on the right shows a bicycle pictogram."}, {"statement": "The cycling-direction sign includes the destination name Sv. I. Zelina.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign below the blue bicycle sign displays 'SV. I. ZELINA'."}, {"statement": "The background behind the signs is predominantly green forest or dense leafy trees.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists of dense green leafy trees."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed sign geometry, such as fused sign panels, warped sign faces, or impossible pole connections.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signs and poles have standard, distinct geometries."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, signs, text, logos, or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous unprompted elements are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned road signs that appear unintentionally repeated.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unintended sign duplication is apparent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical lettering on one or more signs.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The brown signs contain garbled text like 'ROUSTA' and 'INFORMAŤIONE'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the signs or roadway.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent with a sunny day."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent signs, poles, road, and foliage.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and edges remain distinct and un-smeared."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 48, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main issue is text garbling on the brown signs, rendering the 'Tourist Information' text incorrect.", "net_score": 40, "final_score": 75.5}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5596, "image_id": "7f608b69-db82-4445-804a-cbb8febbebe3", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "At least one yellow directional road sign contains the text \"Čakovec\".", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The top yellow sign says 'ČákOVEC' with an incorrect diacritic over the 'a'."}, {"statement": "At least one yellow directional road sign contains the text \"Varaždin\".", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The middle yellow sign says 'Varažestjn', not 'Varaždin'."}, {"statement": "At least one yellow directional road sign contains the text \"Zagreb\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'ZAGREB' is clearly visible on the middle yellow sign."}, {"statement": "At least one brown road sign contains the text \"Vinska cesta\" or \"Wine Road\".", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The brown sign says 'WINE RESTA' and gibberish below, lacking 'Vinska cesta' or 'Wine Road'."}, {"statement": "At least one brown road sign contains either the words \"Tourist Information\" or an information \"i\" symbol.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The brown sign does not contain 'Tourist Information' or an 'i' symbol."}, {"statement": "At least one blue road sign with a bicycle symbol contains the text \"Sv. I. Zelina\".", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The blue sign shows bicycle symbols and the text 'Sv. I. Zelina'."}, {"statement": "The road signs appear in front of green forest foliage.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists of green trees and foliage."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated by natural sunny daylight.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears to be natural, sunny daylight."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped, fused, or impossible geometry in the road-sign panels, arrow shapes, or support poles.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The blue sign has an extra vertical line separating the arrow from the text, and the poles do not align properly with the signs above."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous vehicles, people, animals, watermarks, logos, or unrelated signboards not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The middle yellow sign features a hallucinated illustration of a building and trees."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated road-sign panels with identical text or symbols beyond what the prompt implies.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated panels with identical text."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, unreadable, or misspelled sign text, including malformed diacritics in place names.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Multiple instances of garbled text are present, such as 'ČákOVEC', 'Varažestjn', 'WINE RESTA', and unreadable Gothic-style gibberish on the brown sign."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent lighting or shadow directions on the signs relative to the sunny forest setting.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting on the signs seems generally consistent with the environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between sign faces, sign borders, and surrounding foliage.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The bicycle icons on the blue sign are smeared and malformed."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 24, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -19, "failure_count": 4, "active_error_count": 4, "severity_summary": "The image suffers from severe text garbling and hallucinated elements on the signs.", "net_score": 5, "final_score": 9.1}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5596, "image_id": "7f608b69-db82-4445-804a-cbb8febbebe3", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The background consists primarily of green forest foliage.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background is entirely filled with green leaves and trees."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit by natural, sunny daylight.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears natural and bright, indicative of sunny daylight."}, {"statement": "A yellow directional road sign names \"Čakovec\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top yellow sign clearly displays the text 'Čakovec'."}, {"statement": "A yellow directional road sign names \"Varaždin\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The second yellow sign displays the text 'Varaždin'."}, {"statement": "A yellow directional road sign names \"Zagreb\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Zagreb' is present on the second yellow sign next to 'Varaždin'."}, {"statement": "A brown tourist-direction sign indicates Wine Road by showing \"Vinska cesta\" or \"Wine Road\".", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The brown signs read 'WINSA ROAD' and 'TUNSKA CESTA', failing to correctly spell 'Vinska cesta' or 'Wine Road'."}, {"statement": "A brown tourist-direction sign indicates Tourist Information via the words \"Tourist Information\" or a standard tourist-information symbol.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is no text or symbol indicating Tourist Information on the brown signs."}, {"statement": "A blue road sign with a bicycle symbol names \"Sv. I. Zelina\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottom blue sign features a bicycle symbol and the text 'SV. I ZELINA'."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed road-sign geometry, such as fused signboards, distorted borders, or poles attaching impossibly to the signs.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The signs are stacked without clear individual borders or proper mounting structures, creating a fused appearance."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, signs, destination names, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The top yellow sign includes extraneous text 'ow tw' and the third sign has an unrequested symbol (blue circle with red border and white triangle)."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned road signs, poles, or repeated foliage patterns not implied by the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious duplications or cloned elements in the signs or foliage."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, misspelled, or unreadable sign text or diacritics.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text 'WINSA ROAD' and 'TUNSKA CESTA' are misspelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the signs or poles that conflict with sunny daylight.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows on the signs appear consistent with the natural environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between sign faces, sign borders, poles, and surrounding foliage.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials and colors of the signs and foliage are distinctly rendered without bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 41, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -18, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image fails to correctly render the 'Wine Road' and 'Tourist Information' text, and includes significant text garbling and extraneous symbols.", "net_score": 23, "final_score": 42.6}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5596, "image_id": "7f608b69-db82-4445-804a-cbb8febbebe3", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows multiple road signs grouped together in a single cluster.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Multiple road signs are arranged together on posts in a cluster."}, {"statement": "A green forest forms the background behind the sign cluster.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A dense green forest provides the background for the signs."}, {"statement": "At least one yellow directional sign includes the destination name \"Čakovec\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top left yellow sign clearly displays the name 'Čakovec'."}, {"statement": "At least one brown sign indicates a wine route using the words \"Vinska cesta\" or \"Wine Road\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A brown sign clearly reads 'Vinska cesta' and 'Wine Road'."}, {"statement": "At least one brown sign indicates tourist information using the words \"Tourist Information\" or a standard information \"i\" symbol.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A brown sign displays an 'i' symbol and the words 'Tourist Information'."}, {"statement": "A blue cycling road sign names the destination \"Sv. I. Zelina\".", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A blue sign with a bicycle icon reads 'Sv. I. Zelina'."}, {"statement": "The sign cluster is viewed from a straight-on, eye-level perspective.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is directly facing the signs at approximately eye level."}, {"statement": "The scene is lit by natural, sunny daylight.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting features bright sunlight casting clear shadows, indicating natural sunny daylight."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused sign geometry, such as warped sign boards or support posts merging into each other.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The post supporting the yellow and brown signs on the right appears to pass through the front of the top brown sign."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, vehicles, text, logos, or watermarks not implied by the roadside forest scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous or hallucinatory objects are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned road signs, sign posts, or repeated sign text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No signs or texts are inappropriately duplicated."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered sign text, including unreadable place names or corrupted glyphs.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text is legible and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible sunlight, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the signs, road, and forest.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between sign faces, borders, posts, and nearby foliage.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials and colors are distinct without bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image captures all requested elements clearly, but there is a physical occlusion error where a wooden post appears to pass through a sign board.", "net_score": 46, "final_score": 90.2}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5608, "image_id": "e405d8a2-ba3f-4c71-8cbc-3c0d8c777c99", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The composition is a close-up or macro-style shot that fills most of the frame with the leather surface.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is a close-up framing mostly filled with the brown leather surface."}, {"statement": "The leather surface is brown.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The visible leather material is entirely brown."}, {"statement": "A logo resembling an eagle with wings spread wide appears in the central area of the image.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An eagle design with spread wings is prominently embossed in the center."}, {"statement": "The banner above the eagle reads LIVE TO RIDE.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top banner clearly spells out 'LIVE TO RIDE'."}, {"statement": "The banner below the eagle reads RIDE TO LIVE.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottom banner clearly spells out 'RIDE TO LIVE'."}, {"statement": "A black button appears in the lower right corner of the leather item.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A black circular button is present in the lower right corner."}, {"statement": "A watermark reading Jean appears in a bottom corner of the image.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'Jean' is visible as a watermark in the bottom left corner."}, {"statement": "The scene uses soft lighting that highlights the leather texture and embossed design details.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Soft lighting is used, creating highlights that emphasize the grain of the leather and the embossed features."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The eagle emblem exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts such as fused feathers, malformed claws, or impossible wing structure.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The eagle design is symmetrical and clearly structured with no obvious malformations."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, logos, or text beyond the eagle emblem, the two specified banners, the black button, and the Jean watermark.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only the requested elements are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned major elements such as multiple eagle emblems, repeated banner ribbons, or extra snap buttons not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated eagles, banners, or buttons."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or malformed text in the banners or watermark.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text in the banners and the watermark is perfectly legible and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent with a single soft-lit leather surface.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent with a realistic physical object."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the leather surface, the embossed emblem, and the button.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures and materials remain distinct, with no smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 53, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 53, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5608, "image_id": "e405d8a2-ba3f-4c71-8cbc-3c0d8c777c99", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The main visible surface is leather.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The primary material shown is clearly a textured leather surface."}, {"statement": "The leather is brown.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The leather material is rendered in a brown color."}, {"statement": "The image is framed as a close-up or macro view of the leather surface.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The framing is a close-up focusing primarily on the leather design and textures."}, {"statement": "A spread-wing eagle emblem appears near the center of the leather item.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An embossed eagle with spread wings is prominently featured in the center."}, {"statement": "A banner above the eagle reads exactly \"LIVE TO RIDE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top banner correctly spells 'LIVE TO RIDE'."}, {"statement": "A banner below the eagle reads exactly \"RIDE TO LIVE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottom banner correctly spells 'RIDE TO LIVE'."}, {"statement": "A black button or snap appears in the lower right corner of the leather item.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a black button visible in the lower right corner."}, {"statement": "A watermark containing the name \"Jean\" appears in a bottom corner of the image.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A watermark with 'Jean Ar Kive' is present in the bottom right."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts in the eagle emblem, such as extra talons, fused claws, or impossible feather topology.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The eagle's anatomy and feathers appear generally coherent without obvious geometric artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated brand logos or unrelated text outside the two banner phrases and the bottom-corner Jean watermark.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is additional unrequested, garbled text surrounding the 'Jean' watermark."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated snap buttons beyond the single black button specified in the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "An extra black button is present on the lower left side, not just the right."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering in the photographer watermark.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The watermark area contains several lines of garbled, illegible text around 'Jean Ar Kive'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the leather surface or the snap button.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows look plausible for the embossed leather."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the leather surface and the embossed eagle or banners.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures and materials remain distinct and well-defined without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 56, "total_positive_weight_possible": 56, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The main request is fulfilled accurately, but there is a duplicated button and garbled text around the watermark.", "net_score": 44, "final_score": 78.6}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5608, "image_id": "e405d8a2-ba3f-4c71-8cbc-3c0d8c777c99", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The primary subject is a leather item.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows a brown leather item, appearing to be a motorcycle seat."}, {"statement": "The leather item is brown.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The leather is distinctly brown in color."}, {"statement": "An eagle logo with wings spread wide appears at the center of the leather surface.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a prominent graphic of an eagle with spread wings printed centrally on the leather."}, {"statement": "A banner above the eagle reads exactly \"LIVE TO RIDE\".", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The banner reads \"LIVE TO RIDE,\", including an unrequested comma."}, {"statement": "A second banner below the eagle reads exactly \"RIDE TO LIVE\".", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The banner reads \"RIDE TO LIVE.\", including an unrequested period."}, {"statement": "A black button appears in the lower right corner of the leather item.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "A black button is present, but it is positioned at the bottom center, not the lower right corner."}, {"statement": "A photographer watermark containing the name \"Jean\" appears in a bottom corner.", "weight": 3, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is no watermark visible in either bottom corner of the image."}, {"statement": "The composition is a close-up or macro view focused on the leather surface.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shot is framed closely on the leather item and its design elements."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed eagle anatomy in the central emblem, such as extra wings, missing claws, or fused body parts.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The eagle graphic is cleanly rendered with standard anatomical proportions."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an unrelated added object, person, logo, or text element distinct from the leather item, the eagle emblem, the two banners, the black button, and the photographer watermark.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no unrelated objects or elements beyond the requested leather seat and its design."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an unintended duplicate of the eagle emblem, a banner, or the black button.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No duplicate elements are present; there is only one eagle, two banners, and one button."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or illegible lettering in the banner text or the photographer watermark.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text is perfectly legible, despite the added punctuation."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent highlights or shadows on the leather or button that do not match a single soft light source.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears consistent and soft across the leather surface and button."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding or texture smearing between the black printed design and the brown leather surface.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The black graphic is sharply printed on the leather without any smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 28, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 4, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The image misses several specific details: the button is centered instead of on the right, the watermark is missing, and the text includes unwanted punctuation.", "net_score": 28, "final_score": 52.8}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5608, "image_id": "e405d8a2-ba3f-4c71-8cbc-3c0d8c777c99", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The main subject is a leather item.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows a brown leather saddlebag as the main subject."}, {"statement": "The visible leather surface is brown.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The leather item depicted is entirely brown."}, {"statement": "The framing is a close-up or macro-style view, with the leather surface occupying most of the frame.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shot is a close-up that fills almost the entire frame with the leather surface and its details."}, {"statement": "A logo resembling an eagle with wings spread wide appears near the center of the leather surface.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An embossed design of an eagle with spread wings is centered on the leather."}, {"statement": "A banner above the eagle reads exactly \"LIVE TO RIDE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The top banner clearly and accurately says 'LIVE TO RIDE'."}, {"statement": "A banner below the eagle reads exactly \"RIDE TO LIVE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottom banner clearly and accurately says 'RIDE TO LIVE'."}, {"statement": "A black button appears in the lower right quadrant of the image.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "A black button is present, but it is located in the lower center, not the lower right quadrant."}, {"statement": "A watermark including the name \"Jean\" appears in a bottom corner of the image.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A watermark reading 'Photo by Jean' is visible in the bottom left corner."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry in the eagle emblem, banners, button, or leather seams.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the eagle, banners, button, and seams appears coherent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits additional readable text, logos, or watermarks beyond \"LIVE TO RIDE\", \"RIDE TO LIVE\", and one watermark including \"Jean\".", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra text or logos are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned copies of the eagle emblem, black button, or watermark.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled glyphs in either banner or in the watermark.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text in the banners and the watermark is legible and well-formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible highlights, shadows, or reflections on the leather or black button that are inconsistent with a single softly lit close-up scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows appear realistic for the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the leather surface, the eagle logo, the banners, and the button.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials and textures are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The generated image successfully meets almost all criteria, with the only minor issue being the placement of the black button in the bottom center rather than the bottom right.", "net_score": 51, "final_score": 92.7}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5704, "image_id": "a2725e3f-03cb-46a5-8a9d-abd79f01e434", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three wooden cabins.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly three distinct wooden cabins shown in the image."}, {"statement": "The three cabins have matching overall shape and size, consistent with identical cabins.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The three cabins share the same shape, size, and architectural design."}, {"statement": "Exactly two cabins display a sign.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Signs are present above the doors of the left and middle cabins only."}, {"statement": "Each displayed sign reads exactly \"Disel-Bensin\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both visible signs clearly spell out 'Disel-Bensin'."}, {"statement": "The viewpoint is a low-angle shot looking upward at the cabins.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is low, looking slightly upward from the grass level."}, {"statement": "A predominantly clear blue sky is visible above the cabins.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A clear blue sky occupies the upper portion of the frame."}, {"statement": "Green grass covers the ground around the cabins, indicating a countryside field.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The foreground is filled with green grass."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated by natural daylight.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears to be natural sunlight."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible cabin geometry, such as warped rooflines, fused walls, or misaligned doors and frames.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cabin structures appear solid and geometrically coherent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, animals, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or hallucinations are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or copy-pasted structural elements or texture patches, such as repeated cabin features, wood planks, or grass clumps.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures of the wood and grass appear natural without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering on any cabin sign.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the signs is legible and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent daylight, such as shadows or highlights indicating conflicting light directions across the cabins and grass.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows and highlights are consistent with a single sun source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the wood cabins, grass, and sky.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are well-defined with clear boundaries between wood, grass, and sky."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 48, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 48, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5704, "image_id": "a2725e3f-03cb-46a5-8a9d-abd79f01e434", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three cabins.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly three wooden cabin structures visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The cabins are rendered as wooden structures with predominantly brown wood tones.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cabins are made of wood and have a prominent brown color."}, {"statement": "The three cabins are visually identical in overall architectural design.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three cabins share the same architectural style, including roofs, balconies, and doors."}, {"statement": "Exactly two cabins display a visible name sign.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "Only one large sign is visible in the center cabin, not two."}, {"statement": "Each visible name sign reads \"Disel-Bensin\".", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The visible sign reads 'Disel Bensin' but is missing the hyphen requested in the prompt ('Disel-Bensin')."}, {"statement": "The scene is framed from a low angle, with the camera looking upward at the cabins.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The shot is taken from a relatively straight-on or eye-level angle, not a low angle."}, {"statement": "A clear blue daytime sky is visible above the cabins.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A blue sky with some clouds is visible above the cabins."}, {"statement": "The cabins stand in a countryside setting with visible green grass or field around them.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cabins are situated in a grassy field in a rural setting."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible cabin geometry, such as fused balconies, misaligned roofs, or distorted doors and windows.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The cabins are fused together into a single structure rather than being three distinct cabins."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, animals, vehicles, utility structures, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are visible in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obvious copy-paste duplication of architectural details, grass patches, or extra cabin-like structures beyond the intended three similar cabins.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "While identical, there are no obvious visual copy-paste artifacts beyond what is requested."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, misshapen, or partially illegible lettering on any visible sign or label.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Disel Bensin' is clearly legible and well-formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent lighting or shadow directions across the cabins and ground.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between wood, grass, sky, or signage.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and materials are well-separated without smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 34, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 3, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model failed to include the correct number of signs and missed the low angle constraint, while also fusing the three cabins into a single building.", "net_score": 28, "final_score": 52.8}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5704, "image_id": "a2725e3f-03cb-46a5-8a9d-abd79f01e434", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly three cabins.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly three wooden cabins visible in the frame."}, {"statement": "Exactly two of the three cabins display an exterior sign.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "All three cabins display an exterior sign above their doors, rather than just two."}, {"statement": "The text on each displayed sign reads Disel-Bensin.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Only the first sign reads 'Disel-Bensin'; the others contain illegible text."}, {"statement": "Each cabin has a wooden exterior.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three cabins are constructed with brown wooden planks."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is low to the ground and angled upward at the cabins.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shot is taken from the grass level looking up at the cabins."}, {"statement": "All three cabins have matching architectural design.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The three cabins feature identical shapes, doors, roofs, and platforms."}, {"statement": "A clear blue sky is visible above the cabins.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A clear blue sky forms the background above the buildings."}, {"statement": "Visible grass is present around the cabins.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Green grass is prominent in the foreground beneath the cabins."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible cabin geometry, such as distorted rooflines or doors merging unnaturally into walls.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cabins have consistent and realistic structural geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, vehicles, watermarks, logos, or unrelated text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There are small, unrequested logo-like graphics on the signs above the text."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obvious copy-paste duplication in the wood textures or grass patterns.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The wood grains and grass blades show natural variation without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering on the cabin signs.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the middle and far right cabins is garbled and unreadable."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting or shadow directions across the cabins and ground.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows fall consistently across all cabins from a single light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding or texture smearing where the cabins, grass, and sky meet.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Edges between the cabins, grass, and sky remain crisp and well-defined."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 37, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -9, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image failed to follow the constraints regarding the signs, adding one to all three cabins instead of two, and garbling the text on the distant signs.", "net_score": 28, "final_score": 52.8}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5704, "image_id": "a2725e3f-03cb-46a5-8a9d-abd79f01e434", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly three cabins are visible in the image.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are three distinct wooden cabins shown in the landscape."}, {"statement": "The three cabins share the same structural design, indicating identical cabin forms.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The three cabins all have identical designs, including matching roofs, wooden plank structures, and centered doors."}, {"statement": "The cabins have visible wooden brown exteriors.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All three cabins feature a visible brown, wooden texture on their exteriors."}, {"statement": "Exactly two of the cabins display a sign.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The two leftmost cabins have signs placed above their doors, while the third cabin on the right has no sign."}, {"statement": "Each displayed sign reads \"Disel-Bensin\" regardless of letter case.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on both signs reads 'DIESEL-BENSIN', which is a misspelling of the requested text 'Disel-Bensin' (the prompt contains the misspelling 'Disel')."}, {"statement": "The scene is framed from a low-angle viewpoint looking up at the cabins.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is low, placed down in the grassy field, looking slightly upward towards the cabins positioned higher on the hill."}, {"statement": "The scene is outdoors under a clear blue daytime sky.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sky above the cabins is clear, bright blue with no clouds, indicating a clear daytime setting."}, {"statement": "Green grass is visible around or in front of the cabins, indicating a countryside setting.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large field of green grass is present in the foreground and around the cabins."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or structurally impossible cabin geometry, such as fused rooflines, bent walls, or doors that do not align with the cabin fronts.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cabins are drawn with correct and sound architectural geometry, with no fused parts or bent walls."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, unrelated buildings, vehicles, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no unrequested objects, people, or logos present in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned non-requested elements, such as repeated signboards, repeated cabin details, or copy-pasted grass patterns.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning artifacts or unnatural repetitions are visible in the grass or structures."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical lettering on any cabin sign.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lettering on the signs is clear and legible, even though it corrected the spelling from the prompt."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows, such as inconsistent sun direction across the cabins and grass.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shadows fall consistently across all three cabins and the ground, suggesting a single coherent light source."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent areas such as cabins, signs, sky, and grass.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and well-rendered, with no bleeding between the sky, wood, or grass."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 45, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "The image is generally highly accurate to the prompt, failing only on the exact spelling of the sign text by correcting 'Disel' to 'DIESEL'.", "net_score": 45, "final_score": 88.2}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5801, "image_id": "372f9c13-0db5-441c-bd0b-cff4799a2ee9", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly 2 lions.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two lions visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The 2 lions are physically entwined, with their bodies pressed together in a single intimate pose.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The two lions are shown embracing each other."}, {"statement": "At least 1 transparent wing is visibly attached to each of the 2 lions.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both lions have transparent, insect-like wings attached to their backs."}, {"statement": "A green leaf is positioned above the lions so they appear underneath it.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large green leaf is shown directly above the two lions."}, {"statement": "Both lions are rendered in orange and black tones.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lions have orange fur and black manes/markings."}, {"statement": "The background is visibly out of focus relative to the lions.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background is blurry, creating a shallow depth of field."}, {"statement": "The background is predominantly pink and green.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The blurred background consists mainly of pink and green hues."}, {"statement": "A visible signature in the image reads \"Hari Boro\".", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signature 'Hari Boro' is visible in the bottom left corner."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric distortions in the lions or their wings, such as fused paws, missing limbs, or impossible wing attachment.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The wings are somewhat awkwardly attached, appearing almost overlaid rather than anatomically connected, and the male lion's front right leg is missing."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, text, logos, or watermarks beyond the 2 lions, their wings, the green leaf, and the requested signature.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There appears to be another signature or watermark in the bottom right corner."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned lion body parts or wings that create unintended extra copies.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No duplicated parts are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled rendered text in the signature or elsewhere in the frame.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text in the bottom right corner is illegible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, reflections, or wing transparency inconsistent with the rest of the scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and transparency appear consistent with the surreal scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between fur, wings, leaf, and background at object boundaries.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Object boundaries are generally distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -16, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image successfully renders the prompt's elements but introduces an anatomical error (missing leg) and hallucinated, garbled text in the bottom right.", "net_score": 35, "final_score": 68.6}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5801, "image_id": "372f9c13-0db5-441c-bd0b-cff4799a2ee9", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two lions.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two distinct lions are visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The two lions are entwined in a mating pose, with one lion mounted on top of the other.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A smaller lion is mounted on the back of a larger lion."}, {"statement": "Transparent wings are visibly attached to both lions.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "Only the smaller lion on top has transparent wings; the bottom lion has none."}, {"statement": "Both lions are orange and black in coloration.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both lions have orange fur and black manes or tail tufts."}, {"statement": "At least one green leaf is positioned above the lions.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Green leaves are hanging down from above the lions."}, {"statement": "The background is out of focus.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background elements are heavily blurred."}, {"statement": "The background is predominantly pink and green.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The blurred background consists mainly of pink and green hues."}, {"statement": "The image includes signature text reading \"Hari Boro\".", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Hari Boro' is written on the wing."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits fused or malformed lion anatomy, such as impossible limb placement, merged bodies, or extra body parts.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The top lion's anatomy is distorted, appearing unusually small with limbs awkwardly clinging to the mane."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous animals, objects, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the two winged lions, the leaf, the blurred background, and the signature \"Hari Boro\".", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned lion parts, wings, leaves, or repeated subjects not implied by the scene.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious duplications or cloned parts."}, {"statement": "The signature text contains illegible or garbled characters instead of cleanly rendered letters.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Hari Boro' is legible and cleanly rendered."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, reflections, or wing transparency inconsistent with the rest of the scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and transparency are consistent with the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between lion fur, the wings, the leaf, and the background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures are distinct with no material confusion."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 44, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The bottom lion is missing the requested wings, and the top lion's anatomy is significantly malformed.", "net_score": 36, "final_score": 67.9}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5801, "image_id": "372f9c13-0db5-441c-bd0b-cff4799a2ee9", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two lions.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two lions are clearly depicted in the center of the image."}, {"statement": "Transparent wings are visibly attached to both lions.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Insect-like transparent wings are attached to the backs of both lions."}, {"statement": "The two lions are entwined in a mating position.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The lions are standing and holding hands/paws, not in a mating position."}, {"statement": "The lions are predominantly orange and black.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lions have orange bodies and black manes."}, {"statement": "A green leaf is positioned above the lions.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The lions are standing on top of a green leaf, not under one."}, {"statement": "The image includes the signature text \"Hari Boro\".", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Hari Boro' is written in the bottom right corner."}, {"statement": "The background is blurry or out of focus.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background elements are heavily blurred."}, {"statement": "The background contains pink and green tones.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The blurred background features large areas of pink and green."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The lions exhibit anatomical or geometric artifacts such as extra limbs, fused paws, missing body parts, or malformed faces.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The front paws of the lions are fused together."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous animals, objects, decorative elements, text, logos, or watermarks beyond the two lions, the leaf, and the requested signature.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned lions, wings, paws, tails, or leaf structures that appear unintentionally repeated.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No elements appear unintentionally cloned or repeated."}, {"statement": "The signature area contains illegible or garbled glyphs instead of readable signature-style text.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signature 'Hari Boro' is legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or wing transparency that is inconsistent across the scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and transparency appear consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where fur, wings, and leaf surfaces meet.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors remain distinct at boundaries."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 38, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The lions are not in the requested mating position, are standing on rather than under the leaf, and have fused front paws.", "net_score": 30, "final_score": 56.6}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5801, "image_id": "372f9c13-0db5-441c-bd0b-cff4799a2ee9", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two lions as the main subjects.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two winged lions are clearly the main subjects in the center of the image."}, {"statement": "Both lions are predominantly orange and black.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both lions have coats featuring strong orange and black colors."}, {"statement": "Each of the two lions has visible transparent wings attached to its body.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Insect-like transparent wings are visible on the sides of both lions."}, {"statement": "The two lions are depicted in a mating position, with one lion mounted on or directly straddling the other.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The lions are hugging/embracing rather than being in a mating position as requested."}, {"statement": "A green leaf is directly above the two lions, visibly overhanging them.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large green leaf hangs over both lions like an umbrella."}, {"statement": "The background is noticeably blurry or out of focus.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background elements are blurred, providing a shallow depth of field."}, {"statement": "Pink and green tones are both visible in the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The blurred background contains pinkish hues on the left and green hues on the right."}, {"statement": "The image includes a visible signature reading \"Hari Boro\".", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signature 'Hari Boro' is visible in the bottom right corner."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits fused, missing, or extra lion body parts or wings, or other impossible body topology.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The lion on the right has an extra arm/paw extending abnormally around the other lion."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a prominent extraneous animal, object, logo, watermark, or text not implied by the two winged lions, the green leaf, the blurred natural background, and the \"Hari Boro\" signature.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements outside the prompt are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or mirrored wings, paws, tails, or leaf sections that appear mechanically copied.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious digital duplication artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled glyphs in the \"Hari Boro\" signature or any other visible text.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signature text is readable."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible wing transparency, reflections, or shadows that are inconsistent with the rest of the scene's soft lighting.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between fur, wing membranes, and leaf surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures remain distinct without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 44, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The lions are hugging instead of mating, and there is an anatomical geometry artifact with an extra, abnormally placed arm.", "net_score": 36, "final_score": 66.7}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5856, "image_id": "83923b9f-86e7-41c5-aca8-7e53018ec097", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows at least 10 visible books on a bookshelf.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are at least 13 distinct books visible on the shelf."}, {"statement": "More than half of the visible books have upright, vertically oriented spines.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All of the books are oriented vertically."}, {"statement": "At least 3 visible books are noticeably leaning against neighboring books.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several books on the left side are leaning against each other."}, {"statement": "More than half of the visible book spines are dark-toned, such as black, dark blue, or dark brown.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Almost all of the book spines are dark in color."}, {"statement": "Readable title or author text is visible on at least 5 book spines.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "While there is text on many spines, almost all of it is garbled or nonsensical (e.g., 'MOOBRN PHILOSSRCHY', 'MDEERNN TEAN DOEAN CREIER N TIHY')."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is straight-on from the front of the shelf rather than from an oblique side angle.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shot is taken straight on from the front."}, {"statement": "Book spines occupy more than half of the image area.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books take up the majority of the frame."}, {"statement": "The overall scene is dimly lit, consistent with indoor ambient lighting.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft and dim, fitting an indoor setting."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or fused geometry in the books or shelf, such as books merging into each other or shelf lines bending unnaturally.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books and shelf appear structurally sound with no fused geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unrelated objects, people, or watermark-like overlays that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unrelated objects or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously duplicated or cloned book spines, textures, or titles.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Each book appears to have a unique design and text layout."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, nonsensical, or unreadable title or author text on book spines.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The vast majority of the text on the spines is complete gibberish (e.g., 'Pecnms & Essaay', 'ROERSTOVSSTBASSY')."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, such as conflicting light directions or impossible reflections across the books and shelf.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent book spines or between the books and the wooden shelf.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The edges of the books and the shelf are cleanly defined."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits harsh cast shadows or bright hotspots on the books or shelf.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft and even with no harsh shadows or hotspots."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 45, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main issue is pervasive text garbling on the book spines, making the titles unreadable despite the otherwise accurate depiction of the scene.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 78.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5856, "image_id": "83923b9f-86e7-41c5-aca8-7e53018ec097", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows at least 12 books placed on a bookshelf shelf.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "I count over 12 visible books lining the main shelf section."}, {"statement": "Most visible books are oriented vertically, with their long edges running up and down.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books shown are aligned in a vertical position."}, {"statement": "At least 3 visible books are slightly tilted or leaning against neighboring books rather than all standing perfectly parallel.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "All books are standing straight up, with none visibly tilted against each other."}, {"statement": "More than half of the visible book spines or covers are dark-colored.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Dark spines dominate the visible collection."}, {"statement": "At least 5 visible book spines display title or author text.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Text formatting appears on almost every visible spine."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is straight-on from the front of the bookshelf rather than from an oblique side angle.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shot is taken from directly in front of the books."}, {"statement": "Book spines occupy more than half of the image area, indicating a close-up composition focused on the shelf section.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The composition centers tightly on a single row of books."}, {"statement": "The scene has a low-key overall exposure consistent with soft indoor lighting rather than bright daylight.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting is soft and somewhat dark."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry in the books or shelf, such as merged spines, warped rectangular books, or bent shelf edges.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books and shelf edges are structurally normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated non-book objects, people, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only books and shelves are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned book spines, repeated cover artwork, or copied text patterns suggesting duplicated books.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The book designs vary from one another."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled title or author text on visible book spines.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on all the books consists of nonsensical, garbled letters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, such as inconsistent light direction or impossible reflections across the books or shelf.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting appears consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent books or between books and the wooden shelf.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between materials are clean."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits bright hotspots or strong cast shadows on the books or shelf despite the prompt specifying no shadows or bright spots.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting is even, avoiding harsh shadows or hot spots."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 45, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The books are entirely upright instead of tilted, and the text on the spines is completely garbled.", "net_score": 37, "final_score": 74.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5856, "image_id": "83923b9f-86e7-41c5-aca8-7e53018ec097", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a section of a bookshelf containing at least 20 visible books.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are well over 20 books visible across the three shelves shown in the image."}, {"statement": "At least 80% of the visible books are standing upright with their spines running vertically.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The vast majority of the books are standing upright vertically."}, {"statement": "At least 3 visible books are leaning diagonally against neighboring books.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "None of the books are leaning diagonally against each other; they are all perfectly straight or stacked flat."}, {"statement": "The bookshelf is viewed straight from the front rather than from an oblique side angle.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is a straight-on, frontal view of the shelves."}, {"statement": "Book spines occupy more than half of the image area.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The spines of the books fill the majority of the frame."}, {"statement": "More than half of the visible book spines or covers are dark-toned (for example black, charcoal, dark blue, or dark green).", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Many of the books are dark blue, green, or charcoal, making up over half the visible spines."}, {"statement": "At least 10 visible book spines contain title or author text.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Almost all the visible book spines feature some form of text."}, {"statement": "The scene uses low-key lighting, with most of the bookshelf area rendered in mid-to-dark tones.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft and dark, giving the image a low-key, intimate feel."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible book or shelf geometry, such as fused volumes, warped rectangular books, or unnaturally bent shelf lines.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books and shelves are straight and structurally sound without impossible geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits prominent objects other than books and bookshelf parts, or any watermark or logo overlay, that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No non-book objects, watermarks, or logos are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned books with near-identical spine designs repeated unnaturally.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The spine designs appear varied without obvious cloning or repetition."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, nonsensical, or visibly malformed lettering on book spines.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on almost all the book spines is nonsensical, malformed, and unreadable."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, reflections, or cast shadows across nearby books or shelf surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is even and consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion at the boundaries between adjacent books or between books and the shelf.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between the books and the shelves are clean and well-defined."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits distinct bright hotspots or hard-edged shadows on the books or shelves, despite the prompt specifying no shadows or bright spots.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft with no noticeable bright spots or hard shadows."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 47, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image fails to include any tilted books as requested and features widespread garbled text on the spines.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 75.0}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5856, "image_id": "83923b9f-86e7-41c5-aca8-7e53018ec097", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a bookshelf section containing at least 12 visible books.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are well over a dozen books visible on the main shelf alone."}, {"statement": "At least 8 visible books are oriented upright with their spines running vertically.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "More than 8 books on the main shelf are standing vertically."}, {"statement": "At least 3 visible books are noticeably tilted and leaning against neighboring books.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several books on the right side of the main shelf are leaning to the right."}, {"statement": "More than half of the visible book spines are dark colors such as black, brown, dark blue, or dark green.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The majority of the books on the middle shelf have dark spines."}, {"statement": "At least 5 visible book spines contain title or author text readable as complete words.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Titles like 'The Hobbit', 'Ulysses', 'The Odyssey', 'War and Peace' are clearly legible."}, {"statement": "The camera view is nearly straight-on from the front, with the book spines facing the viewer rather than being seen from a strong side angle.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is a straight-on shot of the bookshelf."}, {"statement": "The framing is a close-up that shows only part of the bookshelf rather than the full bookcase or surrounding room.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shot is tightly framed on a few shelves, not showing the whole room."}, {"statement": "The scene uses dim, diffuse lighting consistent with a soft indoor light source.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft and warm, typical of indoor lighting."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible book or shelf geometry, such as fused books, broken shelf planes, or severely warped rectangular spines.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books and shelves have proper geometry without warping or merging."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous objects, people, or overlay elements such as watermarks or logos that are not implied by a bookshelf-only scene.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only books and shelves are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unnaturally duplicated or near-identical book spines repeated in a cloned pattern.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The books appear unique with no obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical lettering on visible book spines.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "While some titles are clear, many books (e.g., the red one next to 'Ulysses', the dark one next to 'War and Peace') have gibberish text."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, such as neighboring books being lit from incompatible directions or casting inconsistent shadows.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or confusion between wood and book materials along object boundaries.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and boundaries are clean."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits harsh shadows or bright hotspots on the books or shelf.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting is soft without extreme hotspots or harsh shadows."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main issue is the presence of garbled text on several book spines, despite some titles being perfectly clear.", "net_score": 45, "final_score": 88.2}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5899, "image_id": "01a33301-9ec8-42fa-b84c-49719065cc80", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The composition is a high-angle top-down view looking into an off-white spiral staircase.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows a high-angle view looking down into an off-white spiral staircase."}, {"statement": "The staircase has a golden handrail.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A golden handrail is prominently featured along the staircase."}, {"statement": "A transparent glass wall or balustrade borders the staircase.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The staircase is bordered by clear glass panels serving as a balustrade."}, {"statement": "An off-white perforated wall appears on the left side of the frame.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An off-white perforated wall section is visible in the upper left of the image."}, {"statement": "A glass display showcase is visible below or beside the staircase.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A distinct glass display showcase is visible on a lower level next to the staircase."}, {"statement": "At least one tote bag is visible inside the display showcase.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Multiple tote bags are clearly visible inside the display case."}, {"statement": "At least one pair of shoes is visible inside the display showcase.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Pairs of shoes are visible on the bottom shelf of the display showcase."}, {"statement": "At least one miniature couture display, such as a small mannequin or doll-sized garment display, is visible inside the showcase.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A miniature mannequin wearing a dress is visible inside the display case."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible staircase or railing geometry, such as misaligned steps, intersecting rails, or glass panels that do not follow a coherent spiral.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The inner handrail and glass balustrade exhibit severe geometric issues, intersecting themselves in physically impossible ways near the bottom curve."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, decor objects, signage, watermarks, or overlaid logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements, people, or logos are hallucinated in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned bags, shoes, mannequins, or other display items.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The items in the display case appear unique and not obviously cloned."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled brand lettering or monogram-like glyphs on the display items or glass surfaces.", "weight": -2, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The patterned tote bags exhibit garbled, unintelligible monogram-like patterns."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent reflections, shadows, or transparency on the glass balustrade or display showcase.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The glass balustrade has inconsistent transparency and reflections, especially where the impossible geometry occurs."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the gold rail, glass panels, and off-white stair surfaces.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials (gold, glass, off-white surface) are distinct without noticeable color bleeding or texture smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -13, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image successfully captures all requested elements, but suffers from significant architectural geometry errors in the staircase railing and balustrade.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 75.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5899, "image_id": "01a33301-9ec8-42fa-b84c-49719065cc80", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows an off-white spiral staircase from an elevated top-down viewpoint.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An off-white spiral staircase is visible from an elevated, top-down perspective."}, {"statement": "The staircase features a golden handrail following the spiral curve.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent golden handrail curves along the top of the staircase railing."}, {"statement": "A transparent glass railing or wall surrounds the staircase opening.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The handrail is mounted on a transparent glass barrier surrounding the stairwell."}, {"statement": "The left side of the frame contains an off-white perforated wall.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A textured, off-white wall with a perforated pattern is visible on the left."}, {"statement": "A glass display showcase contains at least one tote bag.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several tote bags are visible in the glass display case in the background."}, {"statement": "A glass display showcase contains at least one pair of shoes.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Multiple pairs of shoes are displayed within the glass case."}, {"statement": "A glass display showcase contains at least one garment or dress-like couture piece.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A black garment resembling a dress is visible on the far right of the display."}, {"statement": "The displayed fashion items include at least one mint green piece and at least one mustard yellow piece.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The display includes mint green bags and a mustard yellow bag."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits broken or impossible geometry in the spiral stairs, circular railings, glass panels, or displayed products.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The spiral staircase steps and inner handrail merge into an impossible, infinite spiral at the very bottom."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, unrelated decor objects, signage, or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous people, unrelated decor, or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned bags, shoes, or garments that appear as repeated copies rather than distinct items.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The displayed items appear distinct and not as repeated exact copies."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering on visible product branding such as \"DIOR\".", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'DIOR' is clearly legible on the tote bags."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections, shadows, or transparency in the glass railing or display case.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The reflections and transparency on the glass panel on the lower right are confusing and physically implausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the gold handrail, glass surfaces, walls, and fabric items.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors remain distinct without significant bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 50, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -13, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image successfully meets all prompt requirements but suffers from broken geometry at the bottom of the spiral stairs and confusing reflections on the lower right glass panel.", "net_score": 37, "final_score": 74.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5899, "image_id": "01a33301-9ec8-42fa-b84c-49719065cc80", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is a top-down or overhead POV view into an off-white spiral staircase.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image presents a top-down perspective of a spiral staircase with off-white steps."}, {"statement": "A golden handrail follows the curve of the staircase.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominently visible golden handrail spirals along with the staircase."}, {"statement": "A transparent glass wall or balustrade surrounds the staircase opening.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A clear glass balustrade is seen supporting the golden handrail along the curve of the stairs."}, {"statement": "An off-white perforated wall is visible on the left side of the frame.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The left side of the frame features a large, off-white wall with a distinct perforated pattern."}, {"statement": "A glass display showcase is visible beyond the staircase.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Looking down through the center of the staircase, a display showcase with shelves is visible."}, {"statement": "At least one tote bag is visible inside the display showcase.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several bags, including tote styles, are clearly displayed on the shelves."}, {"statement": "At least one pair of shoes is visible inside the display showcase.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Pairs of shoes, including high heels, are visible on the middle shelves of the showcase."}, {"statement": "Both mint-colored merchandise and mustard-colored merchandise are visible inside the display showcase.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The display case contains bags that are light blue/mint colored and bags that are yellow/mustard colored."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible architectural geometry, such as staircase steps, railings, or glass panels that do not connect coherently in 3D space.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The lower section of the spiral handrail appears to warp and terminate illogically into the glass near the bottom center, and the spiral structure is Escher-like."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, signage, watermarks, or non-Dior logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no extraneous people, watermarks, or non-Dior logos visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned display items, such as repeated identical bags or shoes presented as separate objects.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The items in the display case appear unique and not obviously cloned."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on product labels, signage, or branding.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the tote bag on the right side of the second shelf down is garbled and illegible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections, shadows, or transparency on the glass railing or display case.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Reflections and transparencies on the glass elements appear plausible for the lighting conditions."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the gold handrail, glass, walls, or displayed products.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials such as the gold handrail, glass, and perforated walls are cleanly separated without texture smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 47, "total_positive_weight_possible": 47, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -10, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image meets all positive criteria but features impossible architectural geometry in the staircase spiral and some garbled text on a displayed bag.", "net_score": 37, "final_score": 78.7}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5899, "image_id": "01a33301-9ec8-42fa-b84c-49719065cc80", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is shot from a top-down angled POV looking down onto a spiral staircase.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is looking down onto the curving staircase."}, {"statement": "The spiral staircase is off-white and has a golden handrail.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The stairs are off-white and feature a gold-colored handrail."}, {"statement": "A transparent glass railing or wall surrounds the staircase.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The staircase has curved, transparent glass panels serving as the railing."}, {"statement": "A perforated white wall occupies the left side of the frame.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a wall with a pattern of circular perforations on the left."}, {"statement": "A glass display showcase of mint- and mustard-colored merchandise is visible beyond or in front of the staircase.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A display case with mint green and mustard yellow items is visible in the background."}, {"statement": "The display showcase contains tote bags.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several tote bags are visible on the top and bottom shelves of the display."}, {"statement": "The display showcase contains shoes.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Pairs of shoes are visible on the second shelf from the top."}, {"statement": "The display showcase contains miniature couture garments or dress forms.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Dresses on small mannequins are visible on the third shelf."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or broken geometry in the staircase, handrail, or glass railing.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The glass railing geometry is confusing and intersects unnaturally near the center bottom curve."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, furniture, signs, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected people or unrequested signs are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned display items, mannequins, or stair elements that appear as repeated copies.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The display items appear varied rather than exact cloned copies."}, {"statement": "Any visible text or lettering in the scene is garbled, misspelled, or illegible.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the tote bags is garbled and illegible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections, shadows, or transparency on the glass surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The glass transparency and reflections appear generally plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the gold handrail, glass, white walls, and display items.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct without significant smearing or bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 50, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -12, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The model successfully generated all requested elements, but there is some confusing geometry in the glass railing and garbled text on the tote bags.", "net_score": 38, "final_score": 76.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5953, "image_id": "f22a4aa1-4552-4da5-a6b3-fbaeb1919ffe", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image depicts a café signboard.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent signboard indicating a cafe is centrally displayed in the image."}, {"statement": "At the top of the sign, the cafe name 'Holy Rock Cafe' is displayed.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'HOLY ROCK CAFE' is clearly visible at the top section of the sign."}, {"statement": "The sign contains a yellow circular symbol.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large yellow circle is present in the middle of the sign."}, {"statement": "A red arrow symbol appears on or inside the yellow circle.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a red arrow graphic embedded within the yellow circle."}, {"statement": "Below the yellow circle, the sign includes a line of Arabic-script text.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A line of text in Arabic script is positioned below the yellow circle."}, {"statement": "Below the yellow circle, the sign includes a line of English text.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A line of text in English ('Holy Rock Cafe') is located below the Arabic script."}, {"statement": "Below the yellow circle, the sign includes a line of Hebrew-script text.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A line of text in Hebrew script is located at the bottom of the sign."}, {"statement": "The overall image is in landscape orientation, with the frame wider than it is tall.", "weight": 2, "met": false, "failure_code": "FORMAT_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The image has a square aspect ratio (1:1), not a landscape orientation."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped, fused, or impossible geometry in the signboard, frame, or hanging hardware.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The signboard, frame, and visible hanging hardware appear structurally sound without warped geometry."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unrelated extra signage, logos, or watermarks not implied by the single cafe sign.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is a small sticker or secondary sign visible on the window frame to the right."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a duplicated second cafe signboard or obvious cloned copies of the main sign.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only one main cafe signboard is present in the composition."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical Arabic, English, or Hebrew lettering on the sign.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The Arabic and Hebrew texts contain nonsensical or malformed characters/words."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible shadows, reflections, or illumination on the sign relative to the rest of the scene.", "weight": -2, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and reflections on the sign appear consistent with the outdoor environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the sign text or symbols and the sign background.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text, symbols, and background colors are cleanly separated without bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -10, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image fails to match the requested landscape orientation and contains garbled foreign language text, along with an extra minor sign on the right.", "net_score": 41, "final_score": 77.4}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5953, "image_id": "f22a4aa1-4552-4da5-a6b3-fbaeb1919ffe", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a cafe sign.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent white sign advertising a cafe is visible in the image."}, {"statement": "Near the top of the sign, there is a yellow circle.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large yellow circle is centered near the top of the sign."}, {"statement": "Inside the yellow circle, there is a red arrow symbol.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A red arrow pointing to the right is inside the yellow circle."}, {"statement": "Below the yellow circle, the sign displays the English words \"Holy rock Cafe\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Holy rock Café' is displayed beneath the yellow circle."}, {"statement": "Below the yellow circle, the sign contains at least one line of Arabic script.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are lines of script that resemble Arabic below the English text."}, {"statement": "Below the yellow circle, the sign contains at least one line of Hebrew script.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a line of script that resembles Hebrew at the bottom of the sign."}, {"statement": "The overall image is wider than it is tall.", "weight": 3, "met": false, "failure_code": "FORMAT_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The image is a square (1:1 ratio), not a landscape format as requested."}, {"statement": "The camera viewpoint is approximately eye level with the sign, without a steep upward or downward angle.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign is viewed from a relatively straight-on, eye-level perspective."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped, bent, or physically impossible geometry in the sign panel or its supports.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign panel is flat and its supports appear geometrically sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous content unrelated to a single outdoor cafe sign scene, such as people, logos, watermark text, or unrelated objects.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background consists of a street and stone walls, appropriate for an outdoor scene, with no extraneous artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned copies of the sign, the arrow symbol, or the printed text lines beyond one cafe sign.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is only one sign and no duplicated elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled glyphs in the English, Arabic, or Hebrew text on the sign.", "weight": -9, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The non-English scripts appear to be nonsensical or pseudo-script rather than legible words."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting or shadows across the sign and the surrounding outdoor scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows are consistent with bright sunlight."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the red arrow, yellow circle, black lettering, and white sign surface.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Colors and boundaries are clean and distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -9, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image failed to generate in landscape format and produced garbled text for the non-English scripts.", "net_score": 43, "final_score": 78.2}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5953, "image_id": "f22a4aa1-4552-4da5-a6b3-fbaeb1919ffe", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a cafe sign as the main subject.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large cafe sign is prominently displayed in the center of the image."}, {"statement": "The upper portion of the sign displays the exact text \"HOLY ROCK CAFE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'HOLY ROCK CAFE' is clearly visible on the upper black portion of the rectangular sign."}, {"statement": "The top emblem of the sign is a yellow circle.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a yellow circular emblem mounted above the main rectangular sign."}, {"statement": "The top emblem includes an arrow motif.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A small black arrow is incorporated into the design within the yellow circle."}, {"statement": "The top emblem includes a red symbol element.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A red circle is present inside the triangle design on the yellow circular emblem."}, {"statement": "Below the circular emblem, the sign contains Arabic text.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is script resembling Arabic (though potentially nonsensical) on the red section of the sign."}, {"statement": "Below the circular emblem, the sign contains English text.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The English words 'HOLY ROCK CAFE', 'AABIC', 'ENGLISH', and 'HEBREW' are visible."}, {"statement": "Below the circular emblem, the sign contains Hebrew text.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is script resembling Hebrew on the red section of the sign."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits distorted or impossible geometry in the signboard, circular emblem, or support post.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the sign and its components appears structurally sound and standard."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated people, vehicles, unrelated logos, or unrelated additional signage not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected elements like people or vehicles are added to the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated signboards, repeated emblems, or cloned text panels not implied by the description.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is only one sign structure with no unintended cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, misspelled, or garbled rendered text in the cafe name or the Arabic, English, or Hebrew lines.", "weight": -9, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The word 'ARABIC' is misspelled as 'AABIC', and the non-English scripts appear to be a mix of garbled or pseudo-characters rather than accurate translations."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the sign relative to the surrounding scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows on the sign generally match the ambient outdoor lighting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the sign graphics, text, and adjacent background areas.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text and graphics are sharply separated from their background panels without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -9, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image captures all requested elements, but suffers from significant text garbling, including a misspelling of 'ARABIC' and pseudo-language scripts.", "net_score": 43, "final_score": 82.7}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5953, "image_id": "f22a4aa1-4552-4da5-a6b3-fbaeb1919ffe", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The top portion of the sign reads \"HOLY ROCK CAFE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'HOLY ROCK CAFE' is clearly legible inside the yellow circle at the top of the sign."}, {"statement": "The top portion of the sign contains a yellow circle.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent yellow circle is visible in the upper half of the sign."}, {"statement": "The top portion of the sign contains a red arrow symbol.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A red arrow pointing downwards is present within the yellow circle."}, {"statement": "Below the yellow circle, the sign includes Arabic script.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Arabic script is visible on the wood panels below the yellow circle."}, {"statement": "Below the yellow circle, the sign includes English text.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The English text 'HOLY ROCK CAFE' is visible on the wood panels below the yellow circle."}, {"statement": "Below the yellow circle, the sign includes Hebrew script.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Hebrew script, written in red, is visible on the wood panels below the yellow circle."}, {"statement": "The image is wider than it is tall (landscape orientation).", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The overall image dimensions show a landscape aspect ratio."}, {"statement": "The sign is viewed from approximately eye level rather than from a high or low angle.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The perspective of the sign and the surrounding alleyway indicates an eye-level viewpoint."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or physically impossible geometry in the sign, the circular emblem, or the surrounding wall.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The sign, emblem, and walls appear structurally sound and geometrically plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a hallucinated watermark, brand logo, or unrelated sign text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unrelated watermarks or logos are present on the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned decorative objects, such as repeated lamps or potted plants, that appear copied unnaturally.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "While there are multiple string lights and potted plants, they do not look unnaturally cloned."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering or glyphs in the cafe sign text.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text on the sign, including English, Arabic, and Hebrew, is legible and formed correctly."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows on the sign or surrounding wall.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting from the string lights and ambient sources casts plausible shadows."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the sign graphics, the wood surface, and the stone wall.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures of the painted sign, the wooden boards, and the stone wall are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 41, "total_positive_weight_possible": 41, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 41, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5968, "image_id": "939f8a24-54fd-4eb8-91b0-87c434032357", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a seating arrangement of exactly two red chairs facing a wooden table.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two red chairs are facing a wooden table in the foreground."}, {"statement": "A Europe map hangs on the wall above a yellow couch.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A map of Europe is on the wall above a yellow couch."}, {"statement": "A wall mirror is visible with the Europe map reflected inside it.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A mirror on the left wall reflects a portion of the map and a lamp."}, {"statement": "A lamp or lampshade is positioned beside the Europe map.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wall-mounted lamp is positioned next to the map."}, {"statement": "The seating area is illuminated by warm-toned light.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene has warm ambient lighting."}, {"statement": "A wooden door is visible in the background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden door is visible in the background next to the lamp."}, {"statement": "The background walls are light-colored.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The walls are a light beige/off-white color."}, {"statement": "At least one green houseplant is visible in the room.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several green houseplants are visible in the room."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed or impossible geometry, such as warped chair legs, fused furniture edges, or distorted mirror, door, or lamp shapes.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Furniture and room elements appear structurally sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, animals, logos, watermarks, or floating text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No hallucinated extraneous objects are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated whole objects with near-identical appearance, suggesting a cloning artifact.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No cloning artifacts are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on the Europe map or elsewhere in the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the map reads 'Euaib 6aule' which is garbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections, shadows, or light direction inconsistent with the visible lamp or mirror.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The reflection in the mirror shows the lamp on the right side of the map, which contradicts the room layout where the door is on the left of the lamp."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between adjacent objects such as the chairs, couch, table, walls, or plants.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and materials are distinct and cleanly rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 47, "total_positive_weight_possible": 47, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The generated image successfully includes all requested elements but contains garbled text on the map and an inconsistent reflection in the mirror.", "net_score": 39, "final_score": 83.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5968, "image_id": "939f8a24-54fd-4eb8-91b0-87c434032357", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two red chairs.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two distinct red armchairs are visible in the foreground."}, {"statement": "A wooden table is positioned so that the two red chairs face it.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A round wooden table sits between the two red chairs in the foreground."}, {"statement": "A map of Europe hangs on the wall above a yellow couch.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large map of Europe is mounted on the wall directly above a yellow sofa."}, {"statement": "A lamp with a lampshade is visible beside the map.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A table lamp with a patterned shade is located on the left side, near the map."}, {"statement": "A mirror is visible and reflects the wall map.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A framed mirror on the left wall reflects a portion of a map."}, {"statement": "A wooden door is visible in the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A closed wooden door is visible on the right side of the background."}, {"statement": "The walls behind the seating area are light-colored.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The walls are a light beige or off-white color."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated primarily by warm-toned light.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting throughout the room has a distinct warm, yellowish hue."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible furniture geometry, such as fused chair parts, warped table legs, or non-manifold object edges.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The furniture appears structurally sound with no obvious geometric anomalies."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a visible watermark, logo, or interface overlay not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no watermarks or overlays present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned furniture or decor elements with identical details.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No identical duplicated objects are apparent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled large-format text on the wall map or other visible paper surfaces.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text 'MACEPHVORCA' on the map is nonsensical."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent reflections or shadows, such as a mirror view or lamp shadow direction that does not match the room layout.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The mirror on the left reflects a map that appears to be the wrong orientation and size given its position."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent surfaces such as wall, fabric, and wood.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are cleanly separated."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 47, "total_positive_weight_possible": 47, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image meets all positive criteria but contains garbled text on the map and an physically inconsistent reflection in the mirror.", "net_score": 40, "final_score": 85.1}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5968, "image_id": "939f8a24-54fd-4eb8-91b0-87c434032357", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two red chairs.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two red armchairs are prominently featured in the foreground."}, {"statement": "A wooden table is positioned so that both red chairs face toward it.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A round wooden table is situated between the two red chairs, which are angled towards it."}, {"statement": "A map of Europe hangs on the wall above a yellow couch.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A colorful map of Europe is mounted on the wall directly above a yellow sofa."}, {"statement": "A lamp with a visible lampshade is placed beside the Europe map.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A floor lamp with a shade stands to the left of the map."}, {"statement": "The seating area is illuminated predominantly by warm yellow/orange light.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting casts a distinct warm, yellowish-orange glow across the scene."}, {"statement": "A wooden door is visible in the background.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden paneled door is visible on the left side of the room."}, {"statement": "A mirror is visible in the room.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An arched mirror is placed on the wall behind the plant and lamp."}, {"statement": "The image is framed as a mid-range, eye-level view of the seating area.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The camera angle is level with the seating arrangement, capturing a mid-range view of the furniture."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or impossible geometry in room objects, such as fused chair legs, misshapen table edges, or distorted door or mirror frames.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The furniture and architectural elements appear structurally sound and geometrically correct."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, animals, electronics, unrelated wall art, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unprompted elements like people, animals, or logos are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits cloned or near-identical repeated furniture or plant forms that suggest copy-paste duplication.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plants and furniture do not show signs of artificial duplication."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled place names or other glyphs on the Europe map.", "weight": -2, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the map of Europe consists of nonsensical, garbled characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits shadows or mirror reflections that are inconsistent with the positions of the lamp, door, couch, or wall map.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The mirror reflection fails to show the map or lamp as requested in the prompt, reflecting a door instead."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between adjacent surfaces such as the chairs, couch, table, walls, and plants.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are cleanly separated without bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 49, "total_positive_weight_possible": 49, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image successfully meets all positive criteria but contains garbled text on the map and an incorrect mirror reflection.", "net_score": 42, "final_score": 85.7}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5968, "image_id": "939f8a24-54fd-4eb8-91b0-87c434032357", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image contains exactly two red chairs.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "The image contains three red chairs instead of two."}, {"statement": "A wooden table is positioned in front of the red chairs.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden table is visible in front of the seating area."}, {"statement": "A yellow couch sits below a wall-mounted map of Europe.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A yellow couch is positioned beneath the map of Europe on the wall."}, {"statement": "A lamp with a visible lampshade is placed beside the Europe map.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A floor lamp with a lampshade stands next to the map."}, {"statement": "A wall mirror is present and shows a reflection of the Europe map.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A mirror on the wall reflects parts of the map and the lamp."}, {"statement": "A wooden door is visible in the background.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A wooden door is clearly visible on the right side of the background."}, {"statement": "The background walls are light-colored.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The walls in the background have a light, neutral color."}, {"statement": "Warm-toned ambient lighting illuminates the seating area.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene is lit with warm, ambient lighting typical of a cozy living room."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped, fused, or impossible geometry in furniture, the door, the mirror, or room corners.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the furniture and room elements appears coherent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, animals, signs, watermarks, logos, or unrelated objects not implied by the described living-room scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous or unexpected elements are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or near-identical copies of chairs, lamps, plants, or framed wall pieces that appear cloned.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "While there is an extra chair, the objects do not appear to be identical clones."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or illegible map labels or other printed text.", "weight": -2, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text at the top of the map is illegible and garbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent mirror reflections, lamp illumination, or shadow directions.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Reflections and lighting appear physically consistent within the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared textures, or material confusion between adjacent objects such as upholstery, wood, plants, and walls.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are cleanly separated without obvious smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 38, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -2, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image features an incorrect count of three red chairs instead of two, and contains garbled text on the map.", "net_score": 36, "final_score": 75.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 5992, "image_id": "7a9d70e5-c237-409a-a4c2-2c79443a78a0", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The smartphone is shown in horizontal (landscape) orientation.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The smartphone in the foreground is held horizontally."}, {"statement": "The smartphone screen spans at least half of the image width.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The phone screen occupies the majority of the image width."}, {"statement": "Exactly one cat is visible on the smartphone screen.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are two cats visible on the smartphone screen: one sitting in the foreground and another lying down in the background."}, {"statement": "The cat shown on the smartphone screen is sitting.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main cat on the smartphone screen is in a seated position."}, {"statement": "A wooden floor is visible on the smartphone screen beneath the cat.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The screen shows a wooden floor beneath the cats."}, {"statement": "Exactly one real cat is visible behind the smartphone, outside the phone screen.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a single out-of-focus cat behind the smartphone."}, {"statement": "The real cat behind the smartphone appears blurrier than the cat shown on the phone screen.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The physical cat behind the phone is heavily blurred compared to the sharp image on the screen."}, {"statement": "The cat shown on the smartphone screen has the same coat color and pattern as the real cat behind the smartphone.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the physical cat and the main cat on the screen appear to be the same grey tabby."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts such as fused fingers, malformed paws, or distorted cat facial features.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Hands, paws, and faces appear anatomically sound without severe geometric artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated watermarks, logos, or unrelated text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unrelated text or watermarks are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned subjects or room objects with unnaturally repeated appearance.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No cloned objects are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, reflections, or screen glare inconsistent with the room and smartphone.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The image on the phone screen does not match the real-world scene behind it, showing a completely different room layout and an extra cat."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the cats, the smartphone, the hands, and the floor.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures are cleanly separated."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 41, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -4, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The phone screen shows an extra cat and a completely different room environment than the physical space behind it.", "net_score": 37, "final_score": 74.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 5992, "image_id": "7a9d70e5-c237-409a-a4c2-2c79443a78a0", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The smartphone is oriented horizontally.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The smartphone held in the foreground is clearly oriented horizontally (landscape mode)."}, {"statement": "The smartphone screen occupies at least one-third of the image width.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The smartphone screen takes up well over half of the image width."}, {"statement": "The smartphone screen shows a cat.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A cat is clearly visible on the smartphone screen."}, {"statement": "A real cat is visible behind the smartphone.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a physical cat sitting behind the smartphone."}, {"statement": "The cat shown on the smartphone screen is sitting.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cat displayed on the screen is in a sitting/loaf position."}, {"statement": "The cat shown on the smartphone screen is on a wooden floor.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The floor visible on the smartphone screen is made of wood."}, {"statement": "The cat shown on the smartphone screen and the real cat behind the smartphone share matching fur markings.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the cat on the screen and the real cat behind it have matching tabby markings."}, {"statement": "The scene is clearly indoors.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The wooden floor and furniture in the background indicate an indoor setting."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical artifacts in either cat depiction, such as malformed ears, asymmetrical eyes, or fused paws.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both cats appear anatomically correct without obvious artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits an extraneous watermark, logo, sign, or unrelated caption not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks, logos, or captions are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned cats beyond the one real cat and the one cat shown on the smartphone screen.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two cats shown: one real and one on the screen."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text or glyphs in the smartphone interface.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The smartphone interface contains garbled, illegible glyphs/text next to the camera UI elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections or glare on the smartphone screen.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The screen does not show physically implausible reflections or glare."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits texture smearing or material confusion where the smartphone bezel meets the screen content.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The transition between the bezel and the screen is distinct and clean."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 54, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -3, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The generated image successfully captures all requested elements but includes minor text garbling in the smartphone's camera interface.", "net_score": 51, "final_score": 94.4}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 5992, "image_id": "7a9d70e5-c237-409a-a4c2-2c79443a78a0", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A smartphone is visible in the foreground of the image.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A smartphone is clearly visible in the foreground being held by a hand."}, {"statement": "The smartphone is oriented horizontally (landscape).", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The smartphone is held vertically (portrait), not horizontally."}, {"statement": "The smartphone screen displays a camera view of a cat.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The screen shows a camera interface capturing an image of a cat."}, {"statement": "A real cat is visible behind the smartphone.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A real cat is sitting behind the smartphone."}, {"statement": "The cat shown on the smartphone screen has the same coat pattern and coloring as the real cat behind the phone.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the cat on the screen and the real cat share the same brown tabby and white markings."}, {"statement": "The real cat behind the smartphone is slightly out of focus.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cat in the background has a soft, out-of-focus blur compared to the sharp smartphone."}, {"statement": "The scene is set indoors.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene includes furniture and wooden floors typical of an indoor environment."}, {"statement": "A wooden floor is visible beneath the cat shown on the smartphone screen.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cat on the screen is sitting on a wooden floor."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts, such as extra or fused fingers, distorted cat anatomy, or warped phone geometry.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The thumb holding the phone appears somewhat unnaturally structured near the joint."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a watermark, brand logo, unrelated caption, or other extraneous overlay not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks or unrelated logos are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned subjects or objects, such as extra cats beyond the one real cat and one cat on the screen, or multiple smartphones.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is exactly one real cat, one cat on the screen, and one smartphone."}, {"statement": "The smartphone screen contains illegible or garbled text or interface glyphs.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text and icons on the camera interface are garbled and illegible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, reflections, or screen glare inconsistent with the indoor scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent with the indoor setting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent elements such as the cat, the smartphone, the hand, and the floor.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and boundaries between the hand, phone, cat, and floor are distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 59, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -10, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The smartphone is held vertically instead of horizontally, and the screen UI contains garbled text.", "net_score": 41, "final_score": 69.5}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 5992, "image_id": "7a9d70e5-c237-409a-a4c2-2c79443a78a0", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The smartphone is held horizontally.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The phone in the foreground is held in a landscape orientation."}, {"statement": "The composition is a close-up that prominently features the smartphone screen.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The phone screen occupies a large, central portion of the frame."}, {"statement": "A cat is visible on the smartphone screen.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a cat displayed within the camera app on the phone screen."}, {"statement": "A real cat is visible behind the smartphone.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "An orange cat is positioned in the background, behind the phone."}, {"statement": "The cat on the smartphone screen matches the real cat behind the smartphone in coat color and general appearance.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both the cat on the screen and the cat in the background are orange tabbies."}, {"statement": "The real cat behind the smartphone is slightly out of focus.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The background cat is blurred compared to the sharp phone screen."}, {"statement": "The cat shown on the smartphone screen is sitting.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cat on the screen is in a seated position."}, {"statement": "The cat shown on the smartphone screen is on a wooden floor.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cat on the screen is sitting on a wooden surface."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts such as fused or misshapen fingers, paws, ears, or facial features on the hand or cats.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The hand holding the phone has misshapen fingers."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, logos, watermarks, or unrelated text not implied by a hand-held smartphone photographing a cat indoors.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The setting appears normal for an indoor living room."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned cats, hands, or smartphones not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No cloning or duplication artifacts are present."}, {"statement": "Any rendered text on the smartphone interface is illegible, garbled, or nonsensical.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Text on the camera UI is garbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the smartphone, hand, cats, or floor that are inconsistent with the room illumination.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the smartphone, hand, cats, and wooden floor.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures remain distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 57, "total_positive_weight_possible": 57, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -10, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The hand holding the phone has structural issues, and the text on the camera interface is garbled.", "net_score": 47, "final_score": 82.5}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 6032, "image_id": "eaa85b0d-6007-4f28-8b27-760642e5c023", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a narrow street bordered by buildings on both the left and right sides.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The street is flanked by brick buildings on both sides."}, {"statement": "At least 15 umbrellas are visibly suspended on strings overhead across the street.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are well over 15 umbrellas suspended overhead."}, {"statement": "The suspended umbrellas display at least four bright colors.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Red, yellow, blue, and green umbrellas are clearly visible."}, {"statement": "A white building is visible at the end of the street.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A white building facade closes off the end of the street."}, {"statement": "At least two black lighting units hang along the center of the street between the rows of umbrellas.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several black box-like lighting units hang down the center line of the umbrellas."}, {"statement": "Shop signs with text are visible on both sides of the street.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Signs like 'GEOX' and 'Molina' are on the left, and 'Pacini' and 'Marino' on the right."}, {"statement": "Patches of sky are visible through gaps between the hanging umbrellas.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Blue sky with some clouds is visible above and between the umbrellas."}, {"statement": "The scene is illuminated by natural sunlight.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Sunlight casts clear shadows on the buildings and street."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed umbrella or architectural geometry, such as fused canopies, broken handles, or impossible building edges.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "Many umbrella handles are missing, disconnected, or floating strangely, especially further down the street."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, vehicles, watermarks, or unrelated logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No people, vehicles, or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously cloned umbrellas, shop signs, or facade details that repeat identically.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning of elements is visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, unreadable, or nonsensical text on the shop signs.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the main signs (GEOX, Molina, Marino, Pacimi, Ext.) is mostly legible and correctly formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent sunlight direction or impossible shadows across the umbrellas, street, and buildings.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The shadows cast by the umbrellas on the street and buildings do not align with the lighting direction seen on the upper facades."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between umbrella edges, strings, signs, and building surfaces.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and edges remain reasonably distinct without significant smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 53, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -9, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image successfully meets all positive prompt requirements but exhibits minor geometric issues with the umbrella handles and some lighting inconsistencies.", "net_score": 44, "final_score": 83.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 6032, "image_id": "eaa85b0d-6007-4f28-8b27-760642e5c023", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows a narrow street flanked by buildings on both the left and right sides.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows a narrow street with brick and white buildings on both the left and right."}, {"statement": "More than 10 umbrellas are hanging overhead across the street.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are dozens of colorful umbrellas hanging in the sky above the street."}, {"statement": "At least four distinct umbrella colors are visible among the hanging umbrellas.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Umbrellas in green, orange, red, yellow, purple, and blue are visible."}, {"statement": "At least two black lighting units are suspended across the middle of the street beneath or between the umbrella rows.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a horizontal wire carrying several black lighting units suspended across the street."}, {"statement": "A white building facade is visible at the far end of the street.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a white building visible in the distant background at the end of the street."}, {"statement": "At least one shop sign is visible on the left side and at least one shop sign is visible on the right side of the street.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "Shop signs are visible on the left, but there are no clear shop signs visible on the right side of the street."}, {"statement": "At least one visible plant appears on the right-side buildings.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Plants are visible on the balconies and ledges of the buildings on the right."}, {"statement": "At least one balcony awning is visible on the right-side buildings.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Red awnings are clearly visible on the buildings on the right side."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits umbrella or building geometry artifacts such as fused umbrella parts, broken spokes, or distorted balconies.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "Some umbrellas have broken or misaligned spokes and handles, particularly the multi-colored ones near the top."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no people, vehicles, or watermarks visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits visibly duplicated or cloned umbrellas, plants, or storefront details repeating unnaturally.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The sign on the left repeats variations of 'Geox, Molina, Pacini' redundantly."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on the shop signs.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the main signs includes garbled letters like 'Pario' instead of Marino, and smaller signs have entirely illegible text."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent sunlight or shadows across the umbrellas and surrounding buildings.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear generally consistent with sunlight coming from above."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where umbrellas, walls, signs, or awnings meet.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and boundaries between objects remain distinct without noticeable smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 38, "total_positive_weight_possible": 42, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -13, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image generally fulfills the prompt but suffers from garbled text on the signs and minor structural artifacts in the umbrellas.", "net_score": 25, "final_score": 59.5}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 6032, "image_id": "eaa85b0d-6007-4f28-8b27-760642e5c023", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "At least 10 umbrellas are visible hanging overhead across the street.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Dozens of colorful umbrellas are visible hanging in rows overhead."}, {"statement": "The visible umbrellas include at least four distinct colors.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Umbrellas are shown in red, green, blue, yellow, purple, and other colors."}, {"statement": "Buildings line both sides of the street.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Architectural structures with balconies and shop signs flank both sides of the narrow street."}, {"statement": "A white building is visible at the far end of the street.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent white building structure closes the vista at the end of the street."}, {"statement": "Supporting strings or wires are visible spanning the street among the hanging umbrellas.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Thin black wires are strung across the gap between the buildings, supporting the umbrellas and lights."}, {"statement": "At least three black lighting units are suspended along the middle of the street between the umbrella rows.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A central line of black, cylindrical lighting fixtures runs down the middle of the street."}, {"statement": "Shop signs are visible on both sides of the street.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Numerous rectangular shop signs hang from the buildings on both the left and right sides."}, {"statement": "Blue sky is visible through gaps between the hanging umbrellas.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Clear blue sky is visible above the umbrellas and buildings."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry or fused structures in the umbrellas, lamp housings, wires, signs, or building facades.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "Some umbrellas further down the street appear fused together or have malformed canopies."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, overlay text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No people, vehicles, or overlay text are present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned umbrellas, lamp units, or shop signs that repeat with near-identical appearance.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The umbrellas and signs show variation in color, angle, and text, without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled shop-sign text instead of coherent store names.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "Many shop signs feature garbled, nonsensical characters (e.g., 'VAITLORA', 'PITTCRC')."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible sunlight, shadow direction, or reflections across the umbrellas and buildings.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows on the buildings and umbrellas appear consistent with overhead sunlight."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where umbrellas, wires, signs, and building surfaces touch.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Edges between the umbrellas, wires, and buildings are generally clean without significant color bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 51, "total_positive_weight_possible": 51, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -13, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image successfully captures the requested scene with umbrellas and lighting, but suffers from heavily garbled text on most shop signs and minor geometric issues in the distant umbrellas.", "net_score": 38, "final_score": 74.5}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 6032, "image_id": "eaa85b0d-6007-4f28-8b27-760642e5c023", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Buildings line both the left and right sides of the street.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Buildings are clearly visible on both the left and right sides of the street."}, {"statement": "A white building is visible at the far end of the street.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large white building is prominently featured at the end of the street."}, {"statement": "At least 20 umbrellas are visible hanging overhead across the street.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are many more than 20 colorful umbrellas hanging across the street."}, {"statement": "The hanging umbrellas include at least four distinct colors.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Umbrellas in red, blue, green, yellow, orange, and purple are visible."}, {"statement": "At least two black lighting units are visible hanging among the umbrellas.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several black lighting units are hanging from the wires between the umbrellas."}, {"statement": "At least one shop sign is visible on each side of the street.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Shop signs are visible on both the left (e.g., 'GEOX', 'MOLINA') and right (e.g., 'Caffè dell'Arte')."}, {"statement": "At least one balcony awning is visible on the right-side buildings.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several balcony awnings are visible on the upper levels of the buildings on the right."}, {"statement": "At least one planter, flower box, or potted plant is visible on the right-side buildings.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Planters and flower boxes are visible on the balconies of the right-side buildings."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry, such as umbrellas with broken topology, warped building edges, or malformed visible people.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the umbrellas, buildings, and distant people appears normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a watermark, overlaid caption, or standalone logo that is not part of a storefront sign.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks or non-diegetic logos are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obvious duplicated or cloned umbrellas, balconies, plants, signs, or people with identical repeated details.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The umbrellas and building details have natural variation."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical text on visible shop signs.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the signs ('GEOX', 'MOLINA', 'Marino', 'Pacini', 'Caffè dell'Arte') is highly legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits conflicting shadow directions or highlight patterns that cannot be explained by a single outdoor daylight source.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting is consistent with natural outdoor daylight."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where umbrellas, buildings, wires, or plants blend unnaturally into one another.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The boundaries between distinct objects remain sharp and clear."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 48, "total_positive_weight_possible": 48, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 48, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 6172, "image_id": "68b8dc8b-bbaa-427b-af7e-63db6d9eccc4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is on an extremely dark street, with most of the surroundings remaining in deep shadow.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The street is very dark and most of the surroundings are in deep shadow."}, {"statement": "The rear/back of the car is the clearly visible side of the vehicle.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The back of the car is clearly visible."}, {"statement": "The car's rear lights are glowing red.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rear lights of the car are glowing red."}, {"statement": "The car's license plate is clearly visible.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The license plate on the back of the car is clearly visible."}, {"statement": "The license plate text reads \"REH-244\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the license plate clearly reads \"REH-244\"."}, {"statement": "A pole is partially visible along the left side of the image.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A tall pole is visible on the left side of the image."}, {"statement": "A garden or planted area is partially visible in front of the car.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A planted area with bushes and plants is visible in front/to the side of the car."}, {"statement": "White light from the car highlights the garden or its textures.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A bright white light from the front of the car illuminates the plants."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts in the car, such as warped body panels, fused light housings, or impossible wheel shapes.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No geometric artifacts are present on the car."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, signage, overlay text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous people, signs, or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned elements, such as a second copy of the car, the pole, or repeated garden plants.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No duplicated elements are visible in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, broken, or unreadable characters on the license plate or any other visible labels.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The license plate text is perfectly readable and not garbled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that do not match the positions of the car's lights and nearby surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and reflections appear plausible for the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the car, road, pole, and garden.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No color bleeding or texture smearing is evident."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 57, "total_positive_weight_possible": 57, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 57, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 6172, "image_id": "68b8dc8b-bbaa-427b-af7e-63db6d9eccc4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The main car is shown from the rear.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The primary focus of the image is the back of a car."}, {"statement": "The car is positioned on an extremely dark street.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The setting is a night scene on a dark street."}, {"statement": "Both rear tail lights are illuminated in red.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The car's red tail lights are glowing on both sides."}, {"statement": "The rear license plate reads REH-244.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The license plate clearly displays the text REH-244."}, {"statement": "A pole is partially visible on the left side of the image.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A utility pole is standing on the left side of the street."}, {"statement": "A garden with plants is partially visible near the car.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Plants and flowers are visible along the left side of the street next to the car."}, {"statement": "White light from the car illuminates the garden.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The white light illuminating the garden seems to be coming from a street lamp on the left, not from the front headlights of the main car."}, {"statement": "The car shows a visible reflection of the garden on its glass or bodywork.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rear windshield of the car shows a clear reflection of a bright garden scene."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible car geometry, such as fused panels, warped windows, or malformed wheels.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The car's geometry appears normal and well-formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a person anywhere in the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no people visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a second car that appears duplicated or cloned from the main car.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "While there is another vehicle parked ahead, it is not a clone of the main car."}, {"statement": "The license plate contains garbled or illegible characters.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text on the license plate is clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits reflections or illumination on the car or garden that are physically inconsistent with the visible light sources.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The bright daytime garden scene reflected in the rear windshield is completely inconsistent with the dark night environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding or texture smearing between the car, the plants, and the dark street.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The textures and colors are distinct without bleeding."}, {"statement": "The image clearly shows the front of the car instead of keeping the rear as the only clearly visible side.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only the rear of the car is visible."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 49, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -4, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The main issue is a physics violation where the rear windshield reflects a bright daylight scene despite the nighttime setting.", "net_score": 45, "final_score": 84.9}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 6172, "image_id": "68b8dc8b-bbaa-427b-af7e-63db6d9eccc4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The rear of the car is the clearly visible side of the vehicle.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image shows the rear end of a car facing the viewer."}, {"statement": "A clearly visible rear license plate reads \"REH-244\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The license plate is clearly readable and shows 'REH-244'."}, {"statement": "The car’s rear lights are illuminated red.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The tail lights on the left and right are brightly glowing red."}, {"statement": "The setting is a street shown in extremely low light or darkness.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The scene is a street during twilight or nighttime with dim overall lighting."}, {"statement": "The image is presented as a photograph rather than a drawing, painting, or graphic.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image has a photorealistic style."}, {"statement": "White light from the car highlights part of a visible garden or vegetation area.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is no actual garden or vegetation highlighted by white light in the physical space around the car, only an image printed/reflected on the bumper."}, {"statement": "A pole is partially visible on the left side of the image.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is a pole visible near the top center, not on the left side."}, {"statement": "The visible car body shows a reflection of a garden or plants.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The rear bumper shows what appears to be a very vivid, almost printed reflection of a garden path."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible car geometry, such as fused body panels, warped windows, or malformed wheel arches.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The car geometry appears relatively standard and structurally sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits additional readable text, logos, badges, or watermarks beyond the requested license plate text \"REH-244\".", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is a logo badge above the plate, and text reading 'REH 04' and 'EDITIONS' on the trunk."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or mirrored vehicle parts, light clusters, or roadside elements that appear artificially cloned.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious duplicated or cloned elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or internally inconsistent rendered text in the license plate or elsewhere.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the left side of the trunk appears slightly garbled ('OILTOMIS' or similar)."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections or illumination on the car body or the garden area.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The reflection of the garden on the rear bumper is impossibly clear, bright, and perspective-incorrect, appearing more like a decal than a reflection."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the lights, paint, street, and vegetation.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "The garden scene on the bumper looks like a vinyl wrap rather than a reflection, confusing the material properties."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 47, "total_positive_weight_possible": 56, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -23, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 4, "severity_summary": "The model placed a garden image on the bumper as a decal rather than rendering a true reflection or illuminating real vegetation, and included extra, garbled text on the car.", "net_score": 24, "final_score": 42.9}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 6172, "image_id": "68b8dc8b-bbaa-427b-af7e-63db6d9eccc4", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is set on an extremely dark street with very low ambient light.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "CONSTRAINT_BREACH", "explanation": "The scene is at night but is quite well-lit by streetlights and the car's lights, not extremely dark."}, {"statement": "The main car is viewed mainly from the rear.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The primary car in the center is viewed from the rear."}, {"statement": "The main car's rear lights are glowing red.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The central car's taillights are illuminated red."}, {"statement": "The main car's license plate reads exactly REH-244.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The license plate clearly says 'REH-244'."}, {"statement": "A pole is partially visible on the left side of the image.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a large utility pole visible on the far left edge."}, {"statement": "A garden or patch of plants is partially visible in front of the car.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The plants are behind the primary car and next to a second, unrequested car."}, {"statement": "White light illuminates the visible garden or patch of plants.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plants in the foreground are illuminated by white light."}, {"statement": "The car's bodywork reflects the nearby garden or plants.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The secondary car on the right has reflections of the plants on its side."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or malformed vehicle geometry, such as fused body panels, missing wheels, or distorted lights or mirrors.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The cars appear structurally sound with no obvious geometric artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, vehicles, signs, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "An entire second car is prominently featured on the right side of the image, which was not requested."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned cars, poles, or plant clusters not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious signs of cloning or duplication."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, incomplete, or unreadable rendered text on the license plate.", "weight": -7, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The license plate text is clear and readable."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent with the visible red and white car lights.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and reflections appear reasonably consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the car, the street, and the garden foliage.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and textures remain distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 37, "total_positive_weight_possible": 49, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model hallucinated a prominent second car in the foreground and the scene is not 'extremely dark' as requested.", "net_score": 32, "final_score": 65.3}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 6211, "image_id": "68dd9996-f180-42fb-b0e1-dac19603d11f", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The main subject is a circular artwork.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image features a large, circular piece of art prominently in the center."}, {"statement": "The artwork is rendered as a mosaic made from visible small tiles.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The artwork is composed of many small, distinct square tiles typical of a mosaic."}, {"statement": "The artwork's center contains a Medusa face.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large face with snakes for hair is positioned centrally in the circular artwork."}, {"statement": "Yellow snakes extend from Medusa's head.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Yellow snakes are clearly visible radiating from the top and sides of the central face."}, {"statement": "Two wings are attached to Medusa's head.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two white wings extend outward from the sides of Medusa's head."}, {"statement": "A red-cyan geometric ring surrounds the central face.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is a ring featuring a red and cyan geometric meander pattern surrounding the central figures."}, {"statement": "The mosaic includes a mounted horseman confronting a foot soldier.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A figure on horseback faces off against a standing figure armed with a shield and weapon."}, {"statement": "The outermost border contains floral and fruit motifs.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The outer ring of the mosaic displays various flowers, leaves, and fruits."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits extra, missing, fused, or misshapen anatomy on the Medusa, horseman, soldier, horse, or wings.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The standing soldier appears to have a third, smaller arm/hand jutting out towards the horse, and the horse's front legs look slightly malformed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a watermark, logo, signature, or other overlaid graphic that is not part of the mosaic.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks or non-mosaic overlays are visible on the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or mirrored copies of a major subject, such as the Medusa face, horse, horseman, or soldier.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated major subjects; only one Medusa, horseman, and foot soldier scene are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits pseudo-text or gibberish characters on any visible label, plaque, or sign.", "weight": -2, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No legible or gibberish text is present in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits inconsistent lighting across the mosaic surface, such as highlights and shadows implying incompatible light directions.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears consistent, simulating overhead gallery lights illuminating the circular piece."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits smeared tile textures that blur the boundaries between adjacent mosaic elements.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mosaic tiles are distinct and sharply rendered without significant smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 60, "total_positive_weight_possible": 60, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -7, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image follows the prompt well, successfully incorporating all requested mosaic elements, but contains minor anatomical artifacts in the soldier figure.", "net_score": 53, "final_score": 88.3}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 6211, "image_id": "68dd9996-f180-42fb-b0e1-dac19603d11f", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is depicted as a mosaic made of visible tile-like tesserae.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The entire image is composed of visible, small, tile-like pieces (tesserae)."}, {"statement": "The center of the artwork contains a face of Medusa.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A central face with snake hair is prominently featured."}, {"statement": "Yellow snakes extend outward from Medusa's head.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Yellow snakes are clearly visible forming Medusa's hair."}, {"statement": "Medusa's eyes are blue.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The central face has bright blue irises."}, {"statement": "Two wings are attached to Medusa's head.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two wings, one on each side, are attached to the upper sides of Medusa's head."}, {"statement": "A circular ring of red and cyan patterns surrounds the central Medusa motif.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A pattern primarily composed of red and cyan tiles forms a rough circular band around the center."}, {"statement": "The surrounding scenes include a horseman fighting a soldier.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "While there is a soldier and a horse head, there is no cohesive scene of a horseman fighting a soldier."}, {"statement": "The outer border of the artwork contains flowers and fruits.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The outer edges of the mosaic feature flowers (daisies, roses) and fruits (apples, lemons)."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed anatomy or impossible geometry in the face, snakes, wings, horse, or human figures.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The human figures on the left and right have distorted limbs and anatomy, and the horse is just a disembodied head/neck."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, modern items, added people, or added text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no modern items, text, or watermarks present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or mirrored copies of the central Medusa motif or the battle figures that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The central motif is not duplicated."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that are inconsistent across the mosaic surface.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "Medusa's head and snakes are rendered in a 3D relief style that casts shadows not consistent with a flat mosaic surface."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent mosaic elements.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mosaic tiles remain distinct without significant texture smearing or color bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 48, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -11, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image fails to depict a coherent scene of a horseman fighting a soldier, and introduces 3D pop-out shading that contradicts a flat mosaic.", "net_score": 37, "final_score": 68.5}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 6211, "image_id": "68dd9996-f180-42fb-b0e1-dac19603d11f", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A face of Medusa is the central subject of the composition.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Medusa's face is clearly the main focal point in the center."}, {"statement": "Yellow snakes extend outward from Medusa's head.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Yellow serpentine shapes act as her hair."}, {"statement": "The artwork is rendered as a mosaic made of many small tiles.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The entire image is composed of small mosaic tiles."}, {"statement": "The composition is circular with concentric surrounding layers.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Concentric circles surround the central face."}, {"statement": "A separate surrounding scene depicts one mounted horseman fighting one soldier.", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "There is a mounted figure, but no opposing soldier fighting him."}, {"statement": "One surrounding decorative ring includes at least one red patterned section and at least one cyan patterned section.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Rings of red and cyan tiles surround the center."}, {"statement": "The Medusa head includes exactly two wings.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two wings are visible extending from her head."}, {"statement": "The outermost border includes at least one flower motif and at least one fruit motif.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "Fruits and foliage are present in a separate circle, but not as the outermost border ring."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits malformed human or horse anatomy, such as extra limbs, missing limbs, or fused body parts.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The horseman and the floating figure above him have distorted, somewhat fused anatomical details."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous modern objects, unrelated bystander figures, text, logos, or watermarks not implied by the ancient mosaic scene.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No modern objects or text are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits unintended duplicated Medusa heads or duplicated human or horse figures that look like cloning artifacts.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No cloning artifacts are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible highlights, shadows, or reflections across the mosaic surface.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and depth of field are consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared tile texture, or material confusion between adjacent mosaic regions.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mosaic tiles remain distinct without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 46, "total_positive_weight_possible": 58, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -6, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model missed the soldier fighting the horseman and placed the fruit/flower motif incorrectly, with some anatomical distortion in the secondary figures.", "net_score": 40, "final_score": 69.0}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 6211, "image_id": "68dd9996-f180-42fb-b0e1-dac19603d11f", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The artwork is rendered as a mosaic made of many small tesserae tiles.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The entire image is composed of small, distinct, square-like tiles typical of a mosaic."}, {"statement": "The overall artwork is circular.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mosaic design forms a large circle on the floor."}, {"statement": "The center of the circle contains a human face.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent face (Medusa) is located at the exact center of the circular mosaic."}, {"statement": "Yellow snakes emerge from the central face's head.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Several yellow snakes are intertwined with the hair extending from the central face."}, {"statement": "Two wings are attached to the central face's head.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two distinct blue wings protruding from the sides of the head near the temples."}, {"statement": "A surrounding band of geometric patterns in red and cyan encircles the central face.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A thick circular band featuring a red and cyan geometric meander pattern surrounds the central medallion."}, {"statement": "A separate scene depicts one mounted horseman fighting one human soldier.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "In the upper section of the mosaic, a scene shows a horseman with a spear facing a soldier with a shield."}, {"statement": "The outermost decorative band is composed of flowers and fruits.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A thick, continuous border of various flowers, leaves, and fruits frames the entire circular design."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts such as fused limbs, missing limbs, malformed hands, or impossible horse anatomy in the depicted figures.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The figures of the horseman and soldier appear anatomically sound for a mosaic representation."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, people, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the described mosaic scene.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements, text, or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned subjects or panels not implied by the description, such as multiple central faces or repeated horseman-versus-soldier scenes.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is only one central face and one fighting scene, with no unwarranted duplication."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible indoor lighting or shadows that are inconsistent across the mosaic and surrounding room.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears to fall naturally from the window at the top left across the floor."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared tesserae texture, or material confusion between adjacent mosaic elements.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The tesserae remain distinct without noticeable smearing or color bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 59, "total_positive_weight_possible": 59, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 59, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 6296, "image_id": "3efe8e6e-3571-4863-8413-c3d3aa46b710", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two gulls.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly depicts one adult gull and one young gull."}, {"statement": "Both gulls are positioned on a rocky cliff or rocky ledge.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The birds are resting on a textured, rocky surface."}, {"statement": "The larger gull is touching the smaller gull's beak or mouth with its own beak in a feeding interaction.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull's beak is touching the beak of the young gull."}, {"statement": "The smaller gull is lying on its back, with its belly facing upward.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The chick is lying on its back with its feet in the air and belly exposed."}, {"statement": "The shot is a close-up, with the two gulls occupying most of the frame.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The gulls are the central focus and take up the majority of the image area."}, {"statement": "The larger gull's body is predominantly white, with gray patches visible on its back.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull has a white chest and neck with gray feathers on its back and wings."}, {"statement": "The larger gull's head is gray.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull features a distinct gray head."}, {"statement": "The smaller gull's plumage is light gray.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The chick is covered in light gray, fluffy down."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on either gull, such as fused beaks, extra limbs, or malformed wings, eyes, or feet.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The adult gull has a malformed black leg/foot resting on the chick's belly, which appears anatomically incorrect and fused."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous animals, objects, text, watermarks, logos, or human-made items not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects, text, or human-made items are visible in the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned bird features or repeated copied rock textures that suggest a cloning artifact.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious cloning artifacts in the rocks or bird features."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent with a naturally lit outdoor cliff scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears natural and consistent with an outdoor setting."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between feathers, beaks, and the rocky cliff.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures for the feathers, beaks, and rocks remain distinct without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image successfully meets all prompt criteria but suffers from a noticeable anatomical artifact regarding the adult gull's leg.", "net_score": 44, "final_score": 84.6}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 6296, "image_id": "3efe8e6e-3571-4863-8413-c3d3aa46b710", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "Exactly two gulls are visible in the image.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are exactly two gulls, an adult and a chick, shown in the image."}, {"statement": "Both gulls are perched on a rocky cliff surface.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Both birds are resting on what appears to be a rocky, dirt-covered cliff ledge."}, {"statement": "The larger gull is feeding the smaller gull by placing its beak directly against the smaller gull's beak or mouth.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull has its beak touching the beak of the chick in a feeding gesture."}, {"statement": "The smaller gull is lying on its back, with its underside facing upward.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The chick is sitting upright or resting on its belly, not lying on its back with its underside facing up."}, {"statement": "The larger gull has a gray head.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull features gray plumage on the upper part of its head."}, {"statement": "The larger gull's visible eye is red with a black center.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull has an eye with a distinct red ring around a dark center."}, {"statement": "The smaller gull's plumage is predominantly light gray.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The chick is covered in light, fluffy gray down."}, {"statement": "The composition is a close-up in which the two birds occupy most of the frame.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The framing is tight, with the two gulls taking up the majority of the visual space."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts in the birds, such as extra or fused toes, malformed legs, or distorted beaks.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The adult gull's legs and feet appear somewhat unnatural, with dark, oddly shaped toes and red bands on the legs that seem somewhat distorted."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits a prominent extraneous object, person, text element, watermark, or logo not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No watermarks, text, or extraneous objects are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or mirrored body parts or repeated textures that suggest cloned content.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious mirrored parts or cloned textures."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow directions inconsistent with a natural outdoor scene.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting appears consistent with outdoor, natural daylight."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where feathers and rock surfaces blend unnaturally into each other.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The separation between the birds' feathers and the rocky surface is distinct."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 45, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The chick is not lying on its back as requested, and there are some anatomical anomalies with the adult gull's feet.", "net_score": 37, "final_score": 69.8}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 6296, "image_id": "3efe8e6e-3571-4863-8413-c3d3aa46b710", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two gulls.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two gulls are clearly visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The two gulls are situated on a rocky cliff ledge.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The birds are perched on a rocky cliff structure."}, {"statement": "One gull is feeding the other through direct beak-to-beak contact.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The adult bird's beak is touching the other bird's head, but no food is being transferred and it is not beak-to-beak feeding."}, {"statement": "The gull being fed is lying on its back with its belly facing upward.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The younger gull is sitting upright, not lying on its back."}, {"statement": "The two gulls together occupy more than half of the image area, creating a close-up composition.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The gulls are the main subject and take up most of the frame."}, {"statement": "The feeding gull has predominantly white plumage with visible gray patches on its back.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull has a white body and gray back/wings."}, {"statement": "The feeding gull has a gray head.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull has a dark gray head."}, {"statement": "The gull being fed has predominantly light-gray plumage.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The younger gull is mostly light gray."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts in the gulls, such as extra legs, fused beaks, malformed feet, or impossible wing structure.", "weight": -8, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The adult gull's legs appear somewhat spindly and oddly attached, and the younger gull's lower body anatomy is unclear."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous animals, people, text, watermarks, logos, or man-made objects not implied by the rocky-cliff bird scene.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous objects are visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned visual elements, such as repeated gull body parts or copied rock patterns that appear unnaturally identical.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No cloned elements are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadows, such as conflicting light directions on the birds and the cliff.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting appears consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, smeared feather detail, or material confusion between bird plumage and rock surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and materials are distinct and well-rendered."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 35, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -8, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model failed to depict the younger bird lying on its back and did not clearly show beak-to-beak feeding, instead showing the adult's beak resting on the younger bird's head.", "net_score": 27, "final_score": 50.9}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 6296, "image_id": "3efe8e6e-3571-4863-8413-c3d3aa46b710", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image shows exactly two gulls.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Two gulls are clearly visible in the image."}, {"statement": "The gulls are perched on a rocky cliff.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The setting is a rocky cliff face where both gulls are situated."}, {"statement": "The feeding gull is in direct beak-to-beak feeding contact with the other gull.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The larger gull's beak is touching the open beak of the smaller gull."}, {"statement": "The gull being fed is lying on its back.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The smaller gull is positioned on its back against the rocks."}, {"statement": "The image is framed as a close-up, with the two gulls occupying most of the frame.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The composition is a close-up focusing primarily on the two birds."}, {"statement": "The feeding gull has white plumage, with gray patches visible on its back.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull has white underparts and gray back feathers."}, {"statement": "The feeding gull has a gray head.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The adult gull's head is completely gray."}, {"statement": "The gull being fed has light gray plumage.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The younger gull is covered in light gray feathers."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts in either gull, such as fused beaks, malformed wings, missing eyes, or impossible leg placement.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No significant anatomical errors are visible in either bird."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated human-made objects, people, text, logos, or watermarks not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only natural elements (birds, rocks) are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or mirrored bird features or repeated rock segments that appear copy-pasted.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Textures and features appear unique without obvious duplication."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting or shadow direction across the gulls and the cliff.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear natural and consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between feathers and the rocky cliff.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The transition between the birds and the rocks is clean with distinct textures."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 53, "total_positive_weight_possible": 53, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 53, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 6757, "image_id": "738569e6-0d76-4927-b045-4ca34f537958", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The artwork is rendered as a mosaic composed of many small tesserae-like tiles.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is clearly rendered as a mosaic made of small tiles."}, {"statement": "The mosaic depicts exactly four human figures: one adult woman, two adult men, and one baby.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The artwork shows one adult woman in the center, a man on either side, and a baby held by the woman."}, {"statement": "The adult figures are shown standing on visible ground.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The three adult figures are depicted standing on a mosaic ground area."}, {"statement": "A cityscape appears in the upper background above the figures.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A cityscape with domed buildings is visible in the upper background."}, {"statement": "The lower portion of the mosaic contains a band of Coptic-style inscription characters in blue, red, and white.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is an inscription band at the bottom using blue, red, and white tiles with Coptic-style characters."}, {"statement": "The mosaic includes a visible artist signature together with a visible year.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A signature 'G. Naguib 2024' is visible in the bottom right corner."}, {"statement": "The image is framed as a close-up view focused on the mosaic, with little or no surrounding room visible.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is tightly framed on the mosaic artwork itself."}, {"statement": "The mosaic is brightly illuminated, with no major area obscured by darkness.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mosaic is brightly and evenly illuminated."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts on the human figures, such as extra fingers, fused hands, misplaced facial features, or impossible body topology.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The man on the right has misshapen, elongated fingers, and the baby's legs appear somewhat fused."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous modern objects, unrelated labels, logos, or watermark text beyond the requested mosaic content, inscription band, signature, and year.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "The signature 'G. Naguib 2024' appears as a printed white label pasted onto the artwork, rather than being part of the mosaic itself."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned human figures, faces, or hands that appear unintentionally copy-pasted.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated or cloned figures in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled lettering in the inscription band or in the signature/year area.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The inscription at the bottom consists of pseudo-Greek/Coptic gibberish."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections that conflict across the same flat mosaic surface.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting on the flat mosaic surface appears consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion where figures, buildings, ground, or border details blend into adjacent areas.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mosaic tiles are distinct with no smearing or color bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 49, "total_positive_weight_possible": 49, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -19, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The generated image successfully includes all requested elements, but suffers from garbled text in the inscription, minor hand/limb artifacts, and a signature that appears as a pasted label rather than part of the mosaic.", "net_score": 30, "final_score": 61.2}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 6757, "image_id": "738569e6-0d76-4927-b045-4ca34f537958", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is a close-up view of a mosaic artwork with visible small tesserae.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows a mosaic with small square tiles (tesserae)."}, {"statement": "The mosaic depicts exactly four human figures: one adult woman, two adult men, and one baby.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is one woman on the left, two men in the center/right, and a baby in the center."}, {"statement": "The figures are positioned above a visible ground area at the bottom of the mosaic rather than floating.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The figures have feet touching a tiled ground area."}, {"statement": "A cityscape appears behind the figures in the background of the mosaic.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are buildings and towers depicting a city in the background."}, {"statement": "Inscription-like glyphs appear along the top edge of the mosaic.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are pseudo-Arabic/Coptic inscriptions along the top border."}, {"statement": "Inscription-like glyphs appear along the bottom edge of the mosaic.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are red inscription-like glyphs along the bottom edge."}, {"statement": "Blue, red, and white are all visibly used in the inscription areas.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The inscriptions use white and red text, with a blue background at the top."}, {"statement": "A small signature/date notation appears on the mosaic, separate from the main top and bottom inscriptions.", "weight": 2, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are some small black glyphs mimicking a signature in the bottom right corner."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The human figures exhibit anatomical or geometric artifacts such as extra fingers, fused hands, distorted faces, or impossible limb connections.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The baby's hand is fused and malformed, and the hands of the adults show messy, fused fingers."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, unrelated people, modern signs, watermarks, or logos not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous modern signs, logos, or unrelated elements appear."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned human figures, babies, halos, or inscription bands not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No elements are incorrectly duplicated."}, {"statement": "The inscriptional glyphs or the signature/date mark are garbled or illegible.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text at the top, bottom, and bottom-right is pseudo-language gibberish rather than readable script."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent across the mosaic or surrounding indoor scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting of the indoor environment seems consistent."}, {"statement": "The mosaic surface or adjacent elements exhibit color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion that merges separate objects.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mosaic texture is maintained relatively well without smearing into the surrounding rock."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 37, "total_positive_weight_possible": 37, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -10, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 2, "severity_summary": "The image successfully generates the requested mosaic scene, but suffers from garbled pseudo-text and some geometric artifacts in the figures' hands.", "net_score": 27, "final_score": 73.0}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 6757, "image_id": "738569e6-0d76-4927-b045-4ca34f537958", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The artwork is rendered as a mosaic made of visible small tile pieces.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is clearly composed of small square tiles characteristic of a mosaic."}, {"statement": "The mosaic shows exactly one adult woman.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There is a second adult woman visible in the upper right corner."}, {"statement": "The mosaic shows exactly two adult men.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two adult men depicted in the main scene."}, {"statement": "The mosaic shows exactly one baby.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is one baby being held in the center of the image."}, {"statement": "A city is depicted in the background of the mosaic.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Buildings representing a city are visible in the background on the left and right sides."}, {"statement": "Blue, red, and white inscription text is visible along the border of the mosaic.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Inscriptions in blue, red, and white are present along the arched border."}, {"statement": "A signature inscription is visible on the mosaic.", "weight": 3, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "No artist signature is discernible in the mosaic."}, {"statement": "A year number is visible on the mosaic.", "weight": 2, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "No numerical year is visible in the artwork."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The human figures exhibit anatomical or geometric artifacts such as extra fingers, fused hands, distorted faces, or impossible limb shapes.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The baby's hand holding the woman's hand is fused and poorly defined, and the baby's left leg merges oddly with the man's garment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated modern objects, watermarks, logos, or unrelated text not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No modern objects, watermarks, or logos are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits cloned or near-identical repeated figures, halos, or buildings that appear copy-pasted.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The figures and background elements appear distinct, without obvious cloning."}, {"statement": "The inscriptions, signature, or year contain illegible or garbled glyphs instead of coherent characters.", "weight": -7, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text along the border and near the figures consists of garbled, nonsensical characters."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent lighting, shadows, or reflections across the mosaic surface.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and reflections on the mosaic surface are reasonably consistent for an indoor shot."}, {"statement": "The mosaic shows color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent tiles and figure outlines.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The mosaic texture smears in areas, particularly in the faces and hands, losing the distinct tile appearance."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 36, "total_positive_weight_possible": 50, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -16, "failure_count": 3, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image captures the overall mosaic style and most requested elements, but suffers from garbled text, anatomical anomalies in the baby, and missing signature/year.", "net_score": 20, "final_score": 40.0}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 6757, "image_id": "738569e6-0d76-4927-b045-4ca34f537958", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The artwork is rendered as a mosaic with visible small tile tesserae.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image clearly shows the artwork composed of small individual square tiles, characteristic of a mosaic."}, {"statement": "The mosaic depicts exactly one adult woman.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There is exactly one adult woman depicted in the center-left of the mosaic."}, {"statement": "The mosaic depicts exactly two adult men.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "The mosaic depicts three adult men, not two."}, {"statement": "The mosaic depicts exactly one baby.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The woman is holding exactly one baby."}, {"statement": "The adult figures are shown standing on a visible ground band.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The figures are standing on a curved, brown ground plane."}, {"statement": "The upper background contains a city or fortified architectural skyline.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A walled city with towers is depicted in the background."}, {"statement": "The lower portion contains Coptic-style inscription bands that use blue, red, and white.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottom of the mosaic features bands with text on blue and red backgrounds with white lettering."}, {"statement": "The mosaic is visibly signed and dated.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The bottom right corner includes a signature ('ΓΕΩΡΓΙΟΣ') and a date ('2023 AD')."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits anatomical or geometric artifacts in the human figures, such as fused hands, malformed feet, or inconsistent limb counts.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The hands of the figures are somewhat malformed and lack detail, particularly the baby's hand and the hand of the man on the far right."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, objects, unrelated text, watermarks, or logos that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "A modern sconce lamp is attached to the wall on the left, and a wooden frame is visible on the right, which are extraneous to the requested mosaic."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned human figures not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The figures appear distinct and are not cloned."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled inscriptions, signature text, or year numerals.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The inscription bands contain pseudo-text that is garbled and unreadable."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent with a flat indoor-lit mosaic surface.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting on the wall and mosaic appears consistent with an indoor environment."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, tile-texture smearing, or material confusion between figures, inscriptions, and architectural background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The mosaic texture is consistently maintained throughout the artwork without smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 50, "total_positive_weight_possible": 58, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -16, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image contains an incorrect number of adult men (3 instead of 2) and features garbled text in the inscription bands.", "net_score": 34, "final_score": 58.6}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 6805, "image_id": "8a5ee540-804e-41ca-96dc-bd53c1640032", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The plate has a gray background with large raised blue numerals.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image shows a license plate with a gray background and raised blue numbers."}, {"statement": "The word \"MAINE\" appears at the top center of the plate.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"MAINE\" is clearly visible at the top center."}, {"statement": "Below \"MAINE\", the main registration starts with a capital letter \"G\" followed by numerals.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main text is 'G 233'."}, {"statement": "The word \"TRAILER\" appears below the main registration.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"TRAILER\" is positioned below the main numbers."}, {"statement": "The upper-left corner marking reads \"FEB\".", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The upper-left sticker clearly says \"FEB\"."}, {"statement": "A corner marking on the plate reads \"MAINE 93\".", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The upper-right sticker says \"MAINE 93\"."}, {"statement": "Visible nails fasten the plate to a wooden surface.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Rusty nails are visible in the corner holes, attaching the plate to wood."}, {"statement": "The photo shows the plate from a straight-on front view.", "weight": 3, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The angle is directly in front, straight-on."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry in the metal plate, embossed characters, or mounting hardware, such as warped edges or fused fasteners.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the plate, text, and nails appears realistic and well-formed."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, text, logos, watermarks, or other background items not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extra objects or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned license-plate elements, such as repeated stickers, repeated characters, or repeated fasteners.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no duplicated stickers or unnatural repetitions."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled glyphs in the plate text or sticker text.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text and numbers on the plate and stickers are clear and legible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections inconsistent with a real outdoor photo of a metal plate mounted on wood.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows cast by the raised text and nails look realistic."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the blue characters, the gray plate, and the wooden surface.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are distinct and do not bleed into one another."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 47, "total_positive_weight_possible": 47, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 47, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 6805, "image_id": "8a5ee540-804e-41ca-96dc-bd53c1640032", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The top center of the plate reads \"MAINE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"MAINE\" is clearly visible at the top center of the plate."}, {"statement": "The bottom of the plate reads \"TRAILER\".", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"TRAILER\" is clearly visible at the bottom of the plate."}, {"statement": "The main registration sequence below \"MAINE\" starts with the letter \"G\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main sequence starts with \"G\"."}, {"statement": "The upper right corner of the plate reads \"MAINE 93\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The upper right corner has the text \"MAINE 93\" along with \"93\" below it."}, {"statement": "The upper left corner of the plate reads \"FEB\".", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The upper left corner clearly displays \"FEB\"."}, {"statement": "The plate background is light gray.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plate has a light gray background color."}, {"statement": "The main registration characters are blue.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The large characters in the center are blue."}, {"statement": "Visible nail heads secure the plate to a wooden backing.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The objects securing the plate look more like wooden pegs or debris rather than distinct nail heads."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or fused geometry where the plate border, mounting holes, or nails merge unnaturally.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The mounting holes and whatever is protruding from them (pegs/debris) are weirdly fused with the plate edge and holes."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extra text, logos, inspection stickers, or decorative emblems beyond \"MAINE\", \"FEB\", \"MAINE 93\", the main registration string, and \"TRAILER\".", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There are extra faint boxes with unreadable text/logos in the bottom corners."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or obviously cloned plate elements, such as repeated nails, repeated mounting holes, or copied wood-grain patches.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning of wood grain or repeated elements is visible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled, misspelled, or unreadable lettering in any requested plate marking, including \"MAINE\", \"FEB\", \"MAINE 93\", \"TRAILER\", or the main registration string.", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All requested text is spelled correctly and readable."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent highlights or shadows across the plate, nails, and wooden backing.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The shadows cast by the plate onto the wood appear physically consistent."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits blue paint bleeding, smeared edges, or material confusion between the characters, the plate face, and the wooden backing.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "ATTRIBUTE_BINDING_ERROR", "explanation": "There is weird material confusion around the mounting holes where the wood/peg material seems to bleed onto the plate."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 52, "total_positive_weight_possible": 56, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -15, "failure_count": 1, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The generated plate includes the correct text but suffers from severe geometry and material confusion around the mounting holes, as well as hallucinated extra stickers/text.", "net_score": 37, "final_score": 66.1}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 6805, "image_id": "8a5ee540-804e-41ca-96dc-bd53c1640032", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The plate background is gray.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The license plate background is a light gray color."}, {"statement": "The plate's main registration characters are embossed in blue.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main characters 'G B 83' are raised and colored blue."}, {"statement": "The top center of the plate reads \"MAINE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'MAINE' is clearly visible at the top center."}, {"statement": "The main registration sequence includes the letter \"G\" before the numeric portion.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The registration sequence starts with the letter 'G'."}, {"statement": "The bottom of the plate reads \"TRAILER\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'TRAILER' is visible at the bottom of the plate."}, {"statement": "The upper left corner of the plate reads \"FEB\".", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word 'FEB' is located in the upper left corner."}, {"statement": "A small corner marking on the plate includes both \"MAINE\" and \"93\".", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "While '93' is in the top right and 'MAINE' is in the bottom left, they are not together in a single small corner marking as requested."}, {"statement": "The plate is nail-mounted to a wooden surface.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "The plate is resting against wood and has empty holes, but there are no nails mounting it to the wood."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible geometry in the license plate, mounting holes, or nails, such as warped edges or fused openings.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plate geometry and holes appear normal."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous objects, logos, watermarks, or unrelated text not implied by a license plate mounted on wood.", "weight": -5, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is a faint, unrequested embossed square mark between the 'G' and 'B'."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or visibly cloned scene elements, such as a second plate or repeated copied hardware or wood patches.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no obvious duplicated scene elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible, garbled, or nonsensical rendered text in requested markings such as \"MAINE\", \"FEB\", \"93\", or \"TRAILER\".", "weight": -8, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All requested text is legible and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically inconsistent shadows, highlights, or reflections across the metal plate and wooden surface.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting and shadows appear consistent across the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the blue lettering, gray plate surface, and wood background.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are cleanly separated."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 43, "total_positive_weight_possible": 52, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -5, "failure_count": 2, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image misses the specific corner text grouping and lacks the requested mounting nails, while also including a hallucinated faint embossing mark.", "net_score": 38, "final_score": 73.1}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 6805, "image_id": "8a5ee540-804e-41ca-96dc-bd53c1640032", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The license plate is mounted to a wooden surface by visible nails.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image shows a license plate mounted to a wooden board with four rusty nail heads visible in the corners."}, {"statement": "The plate background is gray.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main background color of the license plate is gray."}, {"statement": "The plate uses blue embossed characters for the main registration.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The central registration characters are blue and have an embossed, raised appearance."}, {"statement": "The top center of the plate reads \"MAINE\".", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"MAINE\" is clearly written at the top center of the plate."}, {"statement": "The upper left corner of the plate reads \"FEB\".", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"FEB\" is printed in the upper left corner of the plate."}, {"statement": "A corner box on the plate reads \"MAINE 93\".", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The upper right corner has a small box containing the text \"MAINE 93\"."}, {"statement": "The main registration begins with the letter \"G\".", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The main sequence of characters starts with a large letter \"G\"."}, {"statement": "The word \"TRAILER\" appears below the main registration.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The word \"TRAILER\" is positioned below the central numbers on the plate."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits warped or fused geometry in the plate border, embossed characters, or nail heads.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The plate border, characters, and nails are well-formed without obvious warping or fusion."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extra objects, signs, logos, or watermarks beyond the license plate, wooden surface, and fasteners.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no additional unrequested objects or marks in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits multiple license plates.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Only one license plate is shown in the image."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or unreadable lettering in any plate inscription, such as \"MAINE\", \"FEB\", \"MAINE 93\", the registration, or \"TRAILER\".", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "All text on the license plate is clear, legible, and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits conflicting shadow directions or implausible reflections across the plate and wooden surface.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting and shadows appear consistent across the plate and the wood."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits blue color bleeding or smeared textures between the embossed characters, the gray plate face, and the wood.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The colors are well-contained within their respective boundaries without bleeding."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 58, "total_positive_weight_possible": 58, "total_negative_weight_incurred": 0, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 0, "severity_summary": "No significant issues.", "net_score": 58, "final_score": 100.0}
{"model_key": "flux", "model_display_name": "Black Forest Labs FLUX.2", "row_idx": 6902, "image_id": "7da01ede-3daa-4994-ae3a-25f818787b20", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The scene is framed as a wide shot of the kitchen rather than a close-up view.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image is a wide shot showing the entire kitchen layout including the island, cabinets, and door."}, {"statement": "A large kitchen island is present.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent kitchen island occupies the center of the scene."}, {"statement": "The kitchen island contains exactly two sinks.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are two sinks built into the kitchen island, one on the left and one on the right."}, {"statement": "The kitchen island contains a stove.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A stovetop is built into the center of the kitchen island."}, {"statement": "Exactly four wooden chairs are placed around the kitchen island.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Four wooden chairs surround the island."}, {"statement": "A stainless steel chimney is positioned above the kitchen island.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A stainless steel range hood/chimney hangs directly above the island's stove."}, {"statement": "Wooden storage cabinets are mounted above the kitchen island area.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Wooden cabinets are mounted on the wall behind the island area."}, {"statement": "A glass door is visible on the right side of the kitchen.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A glass door leading outside is visible on the far right."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts such as fused chair legs, malformed faucets, or impossible cabinet shapes.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The objects all appear structurally sound without obvious geometric artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated people, pets, watermarks, logos, or major objects not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "There are no unprompted entities or major hallucinated elements."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obviously cloned or copy-pasted furniture or decor elements with near-identical repetition.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "While there are matching chairs and sinks, they have natural variations in lighting and perspective, not obvious cloning artifacts."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits illegible or garbled text on the framed sign.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The text 'Home & Comfort' is legible and correctly spelled."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible reflections, shadows, or highlights on the mirror, glass door, sinks, or chimney.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "PHYSICS_VIOLATION", "explanation": "The reflection in the mirror shows an oven built into a wall that does not align with the geometry of the room."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between the wood, metal, glass, and stone surfaces.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials are distinct and rendered well without blending into each other."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 59, "total_positive_weight_possible": 59, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -4, "failure_count": 0, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image successfully renders the requested elements, but exhibits a physics violation with an incorrect reflection in the mirror.", "net_score": 55, "final_score": 93.2}
{"model_key": "hunyuan3", "model_display_name": "Hunyuan 3.0", "row_idx": 6902, "image_id": "7da01ede-3daa-4994-ae3a-25f818787b20", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "The image is a wide shot that shows the island and surrounding kitchen area rather than a close-up of a single fixture.", "weight": 6, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The image shows a wide view of the kitchen including the island, cabinets, and surrounding space."}, {"statement": "The central island contains exactly two sinks, with one sink on the left side and one sink on the right side.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The central island has a double sink unit on one side, but the second sink area is on a separate counter against the wall."}, {"statement": "A mirror is visible near the left-side sink.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large mirror is visible on the left side near the counter."}, {"statement": "A stove is installed in the island.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The stove is installed on the back counter against the wall, not in the island."}, {"statement": "Exactly four wooden chairs surround the island.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are five wooden chairs surrounding the island (two on the left, three on the right)."}, {"statement": "A stainless steel chimney or range hood is positioned above the island.", "weight": 7, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The stainless steel chimney is positioned above the back counter, not above the island."}, {"statement": "Wooden storage cabinets are visible above the island area.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "The wooden storage cabinets are on the back wall, not above the island area."}, {"statement": "A glass door is visible on the right side of the image.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A glass door is visible on the right side of the kitchen."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits geometric artifacts in furniture or fixtures, such as malformed chair frames, fused legs, or impossible sink or cabinet shapes.", "weight": -6, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "GEOMETRY_ARTIFACT", "explanation": "The middle chair on the right has a malformed seat and backrest structure intersecting strangely with the counter."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extra objects, people, wall decor, text, watermarks, or logos that are not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "HALLUCINATED_OBSERVATION", "explanation": "There is an extra framed sign on the wall on the right side."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits cloned or near-identical repeated chairs or decorative items with copy-paste-like matching details.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The chairs and decorative items show natural variation and do not appear cloned."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits garbled or illegible text on the framed sign or any other visible signage.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text on the framed signs is garbled and illegible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the mirror, metal sinks, or glass door.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The lighting, shadows, and reflections appear physically plausible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent surfaces such as wood, stone countertop, glass, and metal.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The materials and textures are distinct with no noticeable bleeding or smearing."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 15, "total_positive_weight_possible": 55, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -13, "failure_count": 5, "active_error_count": 3, "severity_summary": "The image places multiple key elements (sinks, stove, hood, cabinets) on a back counter instead of the island as requested, and features garbled text and five chairs instead of four.", "net_score": 2, "final_score": 3.6}
{"model_key": "ideogram", "model_display_name": "Ideogram 3.0", "row_idx": 6902, "image_id": "7da01ede-3daa-4994-ae3a-25f818787b20", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A freestanding kitchen island occupies the central foreground of the kitchen.", "weight": 9, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A large kitchen island is visible in the foreground."}, {"statement": "Exactly four wooden chairs are visible around the island.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Four wooden chairs are positioned along the front edge of the island."}, {"statement": "Exactly two sinks are visible on the island, with one sink on the left half of the island and one sink on the right half.", "weight": 10, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISSING_STEP", "explanation": "Only one sink is visible on the island, located on the right side."}, {"statement": "A stove or cooktop is visible on the island.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "A stove is visible, but it is located on the back counter, not on the island."}, {"statement": "A mirror is visible on the left side of the island near the left sink area.", "weight": 4, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "A mirror is visible on the back counter on the left side, not on the island."}, {"statement": "A stainless steel chimney or range hood is visible above the island.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "A grey chimney hood is visible, but it is above the back counter, not the island."}, {"statement": "Wooden storage cabinets are visible above the island.", "weight": 5, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "Wooden cabinets are visible, but they are located above the back counter, not the island."}, {"statement": "A glass door is visible on the right side of the kitchen.", "weight": 4, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A glass door with dark framing is present on the right side of the image."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or broken geometry in furniture or fixtures, such as fused chair parts, malformed sinks, or distorted cabinet or door shapes.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The geometry of the furniture and fixtures appears intact and structurally sound."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits extraneous people, appliances, objects, text, watermarks, or logos not implied by the kitchen prompt.", "weight": -5, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No extraneous elements or watermarks are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits duplicated or cloned chairs, decor items, or fixtures that appear unnaturally copied rather than separately rendered.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No obvious cloning or unnatural duplication of items is seen."}, {"statement": "The framed sign contains illegible, garbled, or nonsensical text or glyphs.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The framed sign on the counter contains unreadable, squiggly text."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, or reflections on the mirror, metal chimney, or glass door.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The illustration style lacks realistic lighting, but no egregious physical lighting errors are present given the style."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent wood, metal, glass, and countertop surfaces.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials and colors are cleanly separated in this flat illustration style."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 21, "total_positive_weight_possible": 54, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -3, "failure_count": 5, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The model failed to place several elements (stove, mirror, chimney, cabinets) on the island as requested, placing them on a back counter instead, and missed the second sink entirely.", "net_score": 18, "final_score": 33.3}
{"model_key": "nanobanana_pro", "model_display_name": "Gemini 3 Pro Image (Nano Banana Pro)", "row_idx": 6902, "image_id": "7da01ede-3daa-4994-ae3a-25f818787b20", "rubric_writer": "gpt5pro", "rubric_scorer": "gemini", "positive_criteria": [{"statement": "A large kitchen island occupies the center foreground of the image.", "weight": 10, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A prominent kitchen island is centrally located in the foreground of the image."}, {"statement": "Exactly two sinks are installed in the kitchen island, with one sink on the viewer-left side and one sink on the viewer-right side.", "weight": 9, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "There is only one sink on the island (right side); the other sink is on the counter behind the island."}, {"statement": "A mirror is positioned behind the viewer-left sink.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A mirror is placed on the wall behind the sink on the left counter."}, {"statement": "A stovetop is installed on the surface of the kitchen island.", "weight": 8, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A flat stovetop is built into the center of the kitchen island."}, {"statement": "Exactly four wooden chairs are placed around the kitchen island.", "weight": 8, "met": false, "failure_code": "MISCOUNT", "explanation": "There are five wooden chairs placed around the island, not four."}, {"statement": "A stainless steel chimney or range hood is mounted above the kitchen island.", "weight": 7, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A stainless steel range hood is suspended from the ceiling over the island."}, {"statement": "Wooden storage cabinets are mounted above the kitchen island.", "weight": 6, "met": false, "failure_code": "SPATIAL_RELATION_ERROR", "explanation": "Wooden cabinets are mounted on the wall behind the island, not directly above it."}, {"statement": "A glass door appears on the viewer-right side of the kitchen.", "weight": 5, "met": true, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "A glass sliding door is visible on the right side of the image."}], "negative_criteria": [{"statement": "The image exhibits impossible or severely distorted geometry in the kitchen island, chairs, sinks, cabinets, walls, or other fixtures.", "weight": -6, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "The architectural and furniture geometry appears structurally sound without severe distortions."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits hallucinated extraneous people, objects, text, watermarks, logos, or appliances not implied by the prompt.", "weight": -4, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "No unexpected people, watermarks, or major out-of-place objects are present."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits obvious duplicated or cloned chairs, decorations, or fixtures with near-identical repeated appearance.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "While chairs are uniform, they do not appear as obvious digital clones."}, {"statement": "The framed sign or any other visible text exhibits illegible or garbled letters or glyphs.", "weight": -3, "triggered": true, "failure_code": "TEXT_GARBLING", "explanation": "The text below 'HOME' on the framed sign is small and illegible."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits physically implausible lighting, shadows, reflections, or glass transparency inconsistent with the rest of the scene.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Lighting, shadows, and reflections are consistent throughout the scene."}, {"statement": "The image exhibits color bleeding, texture smearing, or material confusion between adjacent surfaces such as wood, stone, metal, and glass.", "weight": -3, "triggered": false, "failure_code": null, "explanation": "Materials like wood, metal, and stone are distinct with no smearing or blending."}], "total_positive_weight_earned": 35, "total_positive_weight_possible": 58, "total_negative_weight_incurred": -3, "failure_count": 3, "active_error_count": 1, "severity_summary": "The image fails to place both sinks on the island and features five chairs instead of the requested four, along with minor text garbling.", "net_score": 32, "final_score": 55.2}