#!/usr/bin/env python """Compare token-aligned LLM annotations against the PerDT silver layer. python scripts/annotation/compare_to_silver.py \ --llm annotation/data/llm/ner-v1-default/select-100.jsonl \ --ref annotation/data/select-100.jsonl \ --out annotation/data/llm/ner-v1-default/select-100.agreement.json Exact span match (start, end, label); silver is the reference, so "precision" reads as "share of LLM spans the silver layer also has". Silver is not gold — the disagreement list is the human review queue, not an error list. `expected_corrections` counts silver spans that end on an opening parenthesis, the tokenization artefact GUIDELINES.md rule 10 tells the annotator to correct, so those disagreements are not read as LLM mistakes. With --self , also reports span agreement between two LLM runs over their overlapping ids (a run-to-run consistency sample). """ import argparse import json from collections import defaultdict from pathlib import Path LABELS = ("PER", "LOC", "ORG", "DAT") def load(path): return {json.loads(line)["id"]: json.loads(line) for line in Path(path).open(encoding="utf8")} def span_set(spans): return {(s["start"], s["end"], s["label"]) for s in spans} def prf(tp, fp, fn): p = tp / (tp + fp) if tp + fp else 0.0 r = tp / (tp + fn) if tp + fn else 0.0 f = 2 * p * r / (p + r) if p + r else 0.0 return {"tp": tp, "fp": fp, "fn": fn, "p": round(p, 4), "r": round(r, 4), "f": round(f, 4)} def score(pairs): """pairs: [(ref_spans, hyp_spans)] -> {label: prf, micro: prf}.""" tp = defaultdict(int) fp = defaultdict(int) fn = defaultdict(int) for ref, hyp in pairs: for s in hyp & ref: tp[s[2]] += 1 for s in hyp - ref: fp[s[2]] += 1 for s in ref - hyp: fn[s[2]] += 1 out = {lab: prf(tp[lab], fp[lab], fn[lab]) for lab in LABELS} out["micro"] = prf(sum(tp.values()), sum(fp.values()), sum(fn.values())) return out def render(tokens, spans): return [f"[{' '.join(tokens[s['start']:s['end']])}]({s['label']})" for s in sorted(spans, key=lambda s: s["start"])] def main(): ap = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__) ap.add_argument("--llm", required=True) ap.add_argument("--ref", required=True) ap.add_argument("--out", required=True) ap.add_argument("--self", dest="self_path", default=None) args = ap.parse_args() llm, ref = load(args.llm), load(args.ref) missing_ids = sorted(set(ref) - set(llm), key=lambda i: int(i.split(":")[1])) pairs, disagreements, expected = [], [], 0 for sid, r in sorted(ref.items(), key=lambda kv: int(kv[0].split(":")[1])): h = llm.get(sid) if h is None: continue tokens = r["tokens"] rs, hs = span_set(r["silver"]), span_set(h["entities"]) pairs.append((rs, hs)) artefacts = [s for s in r["silver"] if tokens[s["end"] - 1] in ("(", ")")] expected += len(artefacts) if rs != hs: disagreements.append({ "id": sid, "text": r["text"], "silver": render(tokens, r["silver"]), "llm": render(tokens, h["entities"]), "silver_paren_artefact": bool(artefacts), }) result = { "llm": args.llm, "ref": args.ref, "sentences": len(pairs), "missing_ids": missing_ids, "scores": score(pairs), "expected_corrections": { "rule": "10 (silver span ending on a parenthesis token)", "spans": expected, "sentences": sum(1 for d in disagreements if d["silver_paren_artefact"]), }, "disagreements": disagreements, } if args.self_path: other = load(args.self_path) shared = sorted(set(other) & set(llm), key=lambda i: int(i.split(":")[1])) sp = [(span_set(other[i]["entities"]), span_set(llm[i]["entities"])) for i in shared] result["self_agreement"] = { "against": args.self_path, "sentences": len(shared), "identical_sentences": sum(1 for a, b in sp if a == b), "scores": score(sp), } Path(args.out).parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) Path(args.out).write_text(json.dumps(result, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2), encoding="utf8") m = result["scores"]["micro"] print(f"sentences={result['sentences']} micro p={m['p']} r={m['r']} f={m['f']} " f"(tp={m['tp']} fp={m['fp']} fn={m['fn']})") for lab in LABELS: s = result["scores"][lab] print(f" {lab}: p={s['p']} r={s['r']} f={s['f']} (tp={s['tp']} fp={s['fp']} fn={s['fn']})") print(f"disagreeing sentences={len(disagreements)} " f"expected_corrections={result['expected_corrections']['spans']} spans -> {args.out}") if "self_agreement" in result: sa = result["self_agreement"] print(f"self_agreement: {sa['identical_sentences']}/{sa['sentences']} sentences identical, " f"micro f={sa['scores']['micro']['f']}") if __name__ == "__main__": main()