{ "scope": "Independent direct proof audit plus numerical adversarial probes; no formal proof assistant or hardware certification.", "theorem_review": "No blocking derivation error remaining after stated corrections; weighted geometry, graph realizability, covariance martingale, channel bounds, OU identities, radial envelopes and finite-cutoff diagnostics reviewed.", "resolved_findings": [ { "id": "R1", "severity": "blocking", "original_issue": "Arbitrary H(x)>700 infinity shortcut created zero positive-time risk upper bound below positive endpoint lower bound.", "resolution": "Reject unsupported beta>650; keep finite supported positive Poisson evaluation." }, { "id": "R2", "severity": "substantive numerical", "original_issue": "FV beta50 produced negative decay eigenvalue, clipped zero exits and mean exit error of five orders.", "resolution": "Restrict FV to beta<=15 and cells<=2000; reject nonpositive decay; mark under-resolved exit values NaN." }, { "id": "R3", "severity": "blocking input validation", "original_issue": "NaN restoring rate or horizon erased drift tube allowance and returned a positive robust margin.", "resolution": "Finite-value validation added to calibration API." }, { "id": "R4", "severity": "mathematical hypothesis", "original_issue": "Girsanov marginal-path KL equality unjustified for hidden exogenous adapted disturbance.", "resolution": "Use energy inequality and explain augmented-space/data-processing distinction." }, { "id": "R5", "severity": "mathematical hypothesis", "original_issue": "Centered OU tracking comparison omitted zero initial condition.", "resolution": "Explicitly require Z0=0; general initial error remains covered separately." }, { "id": "R6", "severity": "numerical bound", "original_issue": "Positive Laplace upper bound could underflow to false zero.", "resolution": "Positive smallest-float upward underflow rounding plus log_upper and underflow flag." } ], "numerical_probes": [ { "function": "mean_exit_upper", "status": "rejected", "details": "dimensionless beta exceeds supported range (beta<=650)" }, { "function": "mean_exit_upper", "status": "rejected", "details": "dimensionless beta exceeds supported range (beta<=650)" }, { "function": "survival_fv", "status": "rejected", "details": "validated FV support: 00" }, { "function": "drift_tube", "status": "rejected", "details": "all scalar parameters must be finite" }, { "function": "drift_tube", "status": "rejected", "details": "all scalar parameters must be finite" }, { "function": "robust_margin", "status": "rejected", "details": "all scalar parameters must be finite" }, { "function": "laplace_chernoff_upper", "status": "positive underflow rounding verified", "result": { "upper": 5e-324, "log_upper": -3122.8359746001997, "s": 3124499.9929559845, "underflow_rounded_up": true } }, { "function": "FV range edge", "beta": 12.5, "status": "convergence checked", "values": [ { "cells": 200, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.490443374381333e-05, "mean_relative_error": -0.0001364085863825304 }, { "cells": 400, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.489574726730994e-05, "mean_relative_error": -3.410503409517762e-05 }, { "cells": 800, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.489357628752046e-05, "mean_relative_error": -8.525187564112358e-06 }, { "cells": 1600, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.489302728264858e-05, "mean_relative_error": -2.1302833549396993e-06 }, { "cells": 2000, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.489296355165827e-05, "mean_relative_error": -1.3661838982326202e-06 } ] }, { "function": "FV range edge", "beta": 15, "status": "convergence checked", "values": [ { "cells": 200, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.51419700912485e-06, "mean_relative_error": -0.0002028768802967429 }, { "cells": 400, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.512902544710432e-06, "mean_relative_error": -5.072161935526509e-05 }, { "cells": 800, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.512576721020274e-06, "mean_relative_error": -1.267598048282359e-05 }, { "cells": 1600, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.512492562596715e-06, "mean_relative_error": -3.1518842026345695e-06 }, { "cells": 2000, "principal_eigenvalue": 8.512488279738732e-06, "mean_relative_error": -2.0560617690623673e-06 } ] } ], "checks_run": { "risk_unit_checks": 16, "calibration_checks": 5, "quantum_algebra_checks": "all passed independently" }, "limits": [ "Double precision analytic results are not outward-rounded interval certificates.", "FV is a spatially approximate solver with an explicit finite support range.", "No experiments, quantum advantage or AI capability gain certified." ] }