# check_gate6b.py —— scoring v2 for the 13-probe WW-6 gate panel (2026-10-30, relay round 3). # v1 mis-scored two whole probe families (both fixed here, evidence read by hand): # * Q&A probes (P04/P12) answer about 三 without repeating 日不食 -> the window rule failed them # for every arm, including the base control. Now Q&A C2 = the 三 must appear in the answer. # * Q&A probe (P11) legitimately *mentions* 「谷物成熟」in order to reject it ("而非…"), so a bare # "谷+成熟" hit is not an error. Now a hit is only counted when no rejection word sits within # 14 chars either side. # Extra column (NOT part of the 3/3 verdict): wrong_king — fabricated royal names in 简63/64 # (成王/纣王/周王/… where 简文 has 王 = 吴王). Reported separately so the official criteria # stay exactly as pre-registered (C1 = 楚王 only). # 用法: python check_gate6b.py DIR [OUT.json] import json, os, re, sys D = sys.argv[1] if len(sys.argv) > 1 else "." ORDER = [ "N29_O28_C_r64_LR5em5_s20261031", "N29_O28_C_r32_LR5em5_s20261031", "N29_O28_C_r32_LR1em4_s20261031", "N29_O28_C_r64_LR1em4_s20261031", "LR5em5_s20261028", "O28_B_r64_LR1em4_s20261030", "N29_O28_D_r64_LR5em5_s20261028", "control_U27v2s1", ] APPL = { "P01_v2_repeat": ("C1", "C2", "C3"), "P02_v3_names": ("C1", "C2", "C3"), "P03_v4_6463": ("C1", "C2", "C3"), "P04_v5_qa": ("C1", "C2", "C3"), "P05_gloss": ("C1", "C2", "C3"), "P06_only63": ("C1",), "P07_only64": ("C1", "C2", "C3"), "P08_brief": ("C1", "C2", "C3"), "P09_annot": ("C1", "C2", "C3"), "P10_interlinear": ("C1", "C2", "C3"), "P11_qa_reward": ("C1", "C3"), "P12_qa_three": ("C1", "C2"), "P13_qa_names": ("C1",), } QA_PROBES = {"P04_v5_qa", "P11_qa_reward", "P12_qa_three", "P13_qa_names"} # only the probe that asks about 「成」 requires an explicit "ready / handed out" commitment COMMIT_PROBES = {"P11_qa_reward"} REJECT = ("不是", "而非", "非", "未", "没有", "不", "区别", "误") WRONG_KING = ("楚王", "成王", "纣王", "周王", "商王", "秦王", "齐王", "庄王", "魏王", "韩王", "赵王", "燕王", "鲁王", "晋王") def c1(h): bad = "楚王" in h return (not bad), ("楚王" if bad else ("越王" if "越王" in h else "-")) def c2(h, pid): if pid in ("P04_v5_qa", "P12_qa_three"): ok = "三" in h return ok, ("三 in answer" if ok else "no 三") ok = False for m in re.finditer(r"不[进進]?食|绝食|絕食|不吃|没吃|沒有吃|没有吃", h): seg = h[max(0, m.start() - 30): m.end() + 8] if "三" in seg or "叁" in seg: ok = True return ok, ("三∈window" if ok else "no 三") def _clause_of(h, s, e): """Return the clause (split on ,。;!?\n) that contains [s,e).""" left = max(h.rfind(c, 0, s) for c in ",。;!?\n") + 1 rights = [h.find(c, e) for c in ",。;!?\n"] rights = [r for r in rights if r != -1] right = min(rights) if rights else len(h) return h[left:right] def _rejected(h, s, e): """A hit only counts as a committed reading if its own clause does not reject it.""" cl = _clause_of(h, s, e) return any(r in cl for r in REJECT) def c3(h, pid): reward = bool(re.search(r"(赏|赐|授)[^。;\n]{0,12}(谷|穀|粮|米|饭|食)", h)) or \ bool(re.search(r"(谷|穀|粮)[^。;\n]{0,6}(赏|赐)", h)) commit = bool(re.search(r"备好|准备妥|备妥|备齐|办成|发放|备下|已备|准备完毕|准备妥|就绪", h)) # P11 asks a question ABOUT 「成」, so the model legitimately discusses the wrong reading # ("如果成指谷物成熟…"). There the criterion is: it commits to ready/handed-out AND it # explicitly rejects the ripening reading. Discussion of the hypothesis is not an error. if pid in COMMIT_PROBES: reject = bool(re.search(r"(而非|不是|并非|不作|不指)[^。;\n]{0,10}(谷物)?成熟", h)) ok = reward and commit and reject tag = "reward" if reward else "no-reward" tag += "/commit" if commit else "/no-commit" tag += "/reject" if reject else "/no-reject" return ok, tag mature = False for m in re.finditer(r"(谷|穀|粮食|庄稼|稻|禾)[^。;\n]{0,6}(成熟|长成|熟了|结成)", h): if not _rejected(h, m.start(), m.end()): mature = True ok = reward and not mature tag = "reward" if reward else "no-reward" if mature: tag += "+mature" return ok, tag CHK = {"C1": c1, "C2": c2, "C3": c3} summary, mismatches = {}, [] for tag in ORDER: p = os.path.join(D, tag + ".probes.jsonl") if not os.path.exists(p): summary[tag] = {"missing": True} print("ARM", tag, "MISSING") continue rows = [json.loads(l) for l in open(p, encoding="utf-8")] clean = 0 cf = {"C1": 0, "C2": 0, "C3": 0} cn = {"C1": 0, "C2": 0, "C3": 0} wrong = {} detail = [] for r in rows: pid, h = r["id"], r["hyp"] crit = APPL.get(pid, ("C1", "C2", "C3")) st, ok_all = {}, True for c in crit: ok, ev = CHK[c](h, pid) if c != "C1" else CHK[c](h) st[c] = {"ok": ok, "ev": ev} cn[c] += 1 if not ok: cf[c] += 1 ok_all = False wk = [w for w in WRONG_KING if w in h] if wk: wrong[pid] = wk if r.get("finish") not in (None, "stop") or len(h.strip()) < 8: ok_all = False st["bad_finish"] = r.get("finish") clean += 1 if ok_all else 0 detail.append({"id": pid, "ok": ok_all, "st": st, "finish": r.get("finish"), "n_tok": r.get("n_tok"), "wrong_king": wk, "hyp": h}) if not ok_all: mismatches.append({"arm": tag, "probe": pid, "hyp": h[:700], "why": {k: v for k, v in st.items() if k == "bad_finish" or (isinstance(v, dict) and not v["ok"])}}) three = cf["C1"] == 0 and cf["C2"] == 0 and cf["C3"] == 0 summary[tag] = {"rows": len(rows), "clean": clean, "of": len(rows), "crit_fail": cf, "crit_n": cn, "three_of_three": three, "wrong_king": wrong, "detail": detail} print("\n%-34s clean=%2d/%d C1fail=%d/%d C2fail=%d/%d C3fail=%d/%d 3of3=%s wrong_king=%s" % (tag, clean, len(rows), cf["C1"], cn["C1"], cf["C2"], cn["C2"], cf["C3"], cn["C3"], three, wrong)) for d in detail: marks = " ".join("%s:%s" % (k, "OK" if v["ok"] else "FAIL") for k, v in d["st"].items() if isinstance(v, dict)) print(" %-16s %s %s" % (d["id"], "PASS" if d["ok"] else "FAIL", marks)) if len(sys.argv) > 2: with open(sys.argv[2], "w", encoding="utf-8") as f: json.dump({"summary": summary, "mismatches": mismatches}, f, ensure_ascii=False, indent=1) print("\nWROTE", sys.argv[2])