{ "analysis": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "bootstrap_seed": 2026072301, "cluster_unit": "task_id", "confidence_level": 0.95, "contrast_interpretation": { "key_secondary_c3_minus_c2": "Integrated stateful BeforeDone workflow versus a stateless verifier Stop Hook; not an isolated Receipt-mechanism effect because interaction instructions and mechanism both differ.", "primary_c3_minus_c1": "Integrated BeforeDone condition versus prompt-only; a condition-level comparison, not attribution to one component." }, "cost_pairing": "mean repetitions within task, then treatment-minus-comparator task differences", "inference_limitation": "Task-bootstrap intervals treat the twelve paired task effects as resampling units. Four tasks share each of only three repositories, so within-repository dependence is not separately estimated and the intervals are not repository-population inference.", "missing_outcome_policy": "No Agent outcome is fabricated. Effectiveness uses eligible completed records; schedule-based deterministic worst-case bounds cover residual infrastructure failures, observed network deviations, nonterminal or absent records, and unresolved supersessions.", "repetition_aggregation": "pooled numerator and denominator within task-condition", "version": "0.3.0-prepilot" }, "block_window": { "availability": "available", "block_count": 36, "blocks": [ { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r1-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r1-no_gate" ], "window_seconds": 1838.187 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r2-beforedone", "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r2-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r2-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 2019.921 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r3-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-go-irrelevant-error-messages-r3-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 1911.442 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r1-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r1-no_gate" ], "window_seconds": 1224.81 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r2-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r2-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r2-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 1294.378 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r3-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r3-beforedone", "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-premature-approx-duration-r3-no_gate" ], "window_seconds": 1409.334 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r1-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r1-no_gate" ], "window_seconds": 1243.288 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r2-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r2-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r2-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 1213.933 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r3-beforedone", "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r3-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-go-premature-canonical-newlines-r3-prompt_only" ], "window_seconds": 1143.435 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r1-no_gate", "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r1-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 1482.027 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r2-beforedone", "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r2-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r2-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 1578.691 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r3-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-go-relevant-case-fold-r3-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 1583.815 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r1-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r1-no_gate" ], "window_seconds": 2071.739 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r2-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r2-beforedone", "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r2-prompt_only" ], "window_seconds": 1784.802 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r3-beforedone", "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change-r3-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 2042.421 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r1-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r1-no_gate", "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r1-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 1233.627 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r2-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r2-beforedone", "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r2-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r2-no_gate" ], "window_seconds": 1418.289 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r3-beforedone", "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r3-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-py-premature-filesize-rollover-r3-no_gate" ], "window_seconds": 1408.008 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r1-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r1-no_gate", "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r1-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 3766.038 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r2-beforedone", "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r2-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r2-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 3567.102 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r3-beforedone", "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone-r3-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 3638.017 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r1-no_gate", "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r1-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 2371.187 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r2-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r2-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r2-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 2696.244 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r3-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-py-relevant-negative-fraction-r3-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 2491.502 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r1-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r1-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r1-prompt_only-retry1" ], "window_seconds": 2715.723 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r2-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r2-beforedone", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r2-prompt_only" ], "window_seconds": 1819.231 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r3-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r3-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 2129.393 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r1-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r1-no_gate" ], "window_seconds": 1494.091 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r2-beforedone", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r2-prompt_only", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r2-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 1807.505 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r3-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-fragment-query-r3-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 1802.966 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r1-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r1-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r1-prompt_only" ], "window_seconds": 1105.053 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r2-beforedone", "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r2-prompt_only", "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r2-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 1161.76 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r3-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-premature-route-whitespace-r3-beforedone" ], "window_seconds": 1240.662 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r1", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r1-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r1-prompt_only", "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r1-beforedone", "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r1-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 2366.694 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r2", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r2-stateless_hook", "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r2-beforedone", "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r2-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r2-prompt_only" ], "window_seconds": 2504.72 }, { "block_id": "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r3", "expected_slot_count": 4, "included_slot_count": 4, "missing_dispositions": { "absent": 0, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "status": "compliant", "terminal_run_ids": [ "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r3-beforedone", "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r3-no_gate", "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r3-prompt_only", "confirmatory-ts-relevant-array-query-r3-stateless_hook" ], "window_seconds": 2953.032 } ], "compliant_block_count": 36, "excluding_violated_blocks": { "availability": "not_needed_no_completed_violation", "excluded_block_ids": [], "excluded_run_ids": [], "method": "No complete block exceeded the predeclared 12-hour window. Incomplete blocks remain covered by missing-outcome bounds." }, "incomplete_block_count": 0, "incomplete_blocks_covered_by_missing_outcome_bounds": true, "threshold_hours": 12.0, "violated_block_count": 0, "violated_terminal_run_ids": [] }, "contrasts": { "additional": { "completion_claim": { "key_secondary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(stateless_hook)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [], "outcome": "completion_claim", "paired_task_count": 12, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 1.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "primary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(prompt_only)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [], "outcome": "completion_claim", "paired_task_count": 12, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 1.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" } }, "correction_success": { "key_secondary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ null, null ], "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(stateless_hook)", "estimate": null, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [ "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "go-premature-approx-duration", "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "go-relevant-case-fold", "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "ts-relevant-array-query" ], "outcome": "correction_success", "paired_task_count": 0, "task_differences": [], "treatment": "beforedone" } }, "false_block": { "key_secondary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(stateless_hook)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [], "outcome": "false_block", "paired_task_count": 12, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" } }, "hidden_oracle_pass": { "key_secondary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(stateless_hook)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [], "outcome": "hidden_oracle_pass", "paired_task_count": 12, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 1.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "primary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(prompt_only)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [], "outcome": "hidden_oracle_pass", "paired_task_count": 12, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_rate": 1.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 1.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" } }, "oracle_incorrect_completion": { "key_secondary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(stateless_hook)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [], "outcome": "oracle_incorrect_completion", "paired_task_count": 12, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "primary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(prompt_only)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [], "outcome": "oracle_incorrect_completion", "paired_task_count": 12, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" } }, "receipt_protocol_compliance": {}, "stale_evidence_reuse": { "key_secondary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(stateless_hook)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [ "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "go-premature-approx-duration", "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "ts-premature-route-whitespace" ], "outcome": "stale_evidence_reuse", "paired_task_count": 4, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "primary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(prompt_only)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [ "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "go-premature-approx-duration", "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "ts-premature-route-whitespace" ], "outcome": "stale_evidence_reuse", "paired_task_count": 4, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" } } }, "key_secondary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(stateless_hook)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [], "outcome": "evidence_unsupported_completion", "paired_task_count": 12, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "primary": { "bootstrap_resamples": 10000, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(prompt_only)", "estimate": 0.0, "excluded_tasks_without_both_denominators": [], "outcome": "evidence_unsupported_completion", "paired_task_count": 12, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_rate": 0.0 }, { "comparator_rate": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_rate": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" } }, "costs": { "descriptive": { "agent_turns": { "beforedone": { "median": 2.0, "n": 36, "q1": 1.0, "q3": 2.0 }, "no_gate": { "median": 2.0, "n": 36, "q1": 1.0, "q3": 2.0 }, "prompt_only": { "median": 2.0, "n": 36, "q1": 1.0, "q3": 2.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "median": 2.0, "n": 36, "q1": 1.0, "q3": 2.0 } }, "cached_input_tokens": { "beforedone": { "median": 998912.0, "n": 36, "q1": 448512.0, "q3": 1436672.0 }, "no_gate": { "median": 936320.0, "n": 36, "q1": 550080.0, "q3": 1814592.0 }, "prompt_only": { "median": 944000.0, "n": 36, "q1": 410048.0, "q3": 1405056.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "median": 1007616.0, "n": 36, "q1": 416000.0, "q3": 1652160.0 } }, "corrective_continuations": { "beforedone": { "median": 0.0, "n": 36, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0 }, "no_gate": { "median": 0.0, "n": 36, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "median": 0.0, "n": 36, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "median": 0.0, "n": 36, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0 } }, "input_tokens": { "beforedone": { "median": 1106016.0, "n": 36, "q1": 502228.5, "q3": 1601281.75 }, "no_gate": { "median": 1079746.5, "n": 36, "q1": 610617.0, "q3": 1977348.25 }, "prompt_only": { "median": 1048838.0, "n": 36, "q1": 473253.0, "q3": 1597862.75 }, "stateless_hook": { "median": 1184401.0, "n": 36, "q1": 477543.75, "q3": 1857508.0 } }, "output_tokens": { "beforedone": { "median": 11991.0, "n": 36, "q1": 6596.75, "q3": 16711.5 }, "no_gate": { "median": 10793.0, "n": 36, "q1": 6932.0, "q3": 18673.5 }, "prompt_only": { "median": 10328.5, "n": 36, "q1": 5469.0, "q3": 16911.5 }, "stateless_hook": { "median": 12556.0, "n": 36, "q1": 5930.5, "q3": 21259.25 } }, "reasoning_output_tokens": { "beforedone": { "median": 4744.5, "n": 36, "q1": 2721.5, "q3": 7918.0 }, "no_gate": { "median": 3940.0, "n": 36, "q1": 2754.5, "q3": 7457.25 }, "prompt_only": { "median": 3989.0, "n": 36, "q1": 2479.25, "q3": 7172.75 }, "stateless_hook": { "median": 4971.5, "n": 36, "q1": 2519.5, "q3": 9459.25 } }, "stop_attempts": { "beforedone": { "median": 2.0, "n": 36, "q1": 1.0, "q3": 2.0 }, "no_gate": { "median": 0.0, "n": 36, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "median": 0.0, "n": 36, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "median": 2.0, "n": 36, "q1": 1.0, "q3": 2.0 } }, "verifier_executions": { "beforedone": { "median": 2.0, "n": 36, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 3.0 }, "no_gate": { "median": 3.0, "n": 36, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 4.0 }, "prompt_only": { "median": 2.0, "n": 36, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 2.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "median": 5.0, "n": 36, "q1": 3.0, "q3": 7.0 } }, "wall_seconds": { "beforedone": { "median": 378.2655, "n": 36, "q1": 275.961, "q3": 459.93724999999995 }, "no_gate": { "median": 375.8435, "n": 36, "q1": 280.058, "q3": 528.0387499999999 }, "prompt_only": { "median": 357.0385, "n": 36, "q1": 257.49575, "q3": 455.582 }, "stateless_hook": { "median": 407.5155, "n": 36, "q1": 248.41400000000002, "q3": 525.30875 } } }, "paired_task_differences": { "key_secondary": { "agent_turns": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(stateless_hook)", "median": 0.0, "n": 12, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "cached_input_tokens": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(stateless_hook)", "median": -84010.66666666674, "n": 12, "q1": -368981.3333333334, "q3": 23936.000000000015, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 1467136.0, "difference": -348160.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 1118976.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 314453.3333333333, "difference": 48810.666666666686, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 363264.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 330752.0, "difference": 21930.666666666686, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 352682.6666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 860757.3333333334, "difference": 29952.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 890709.3333333334 }, { "comparator_mean": 1413034.6666666667, "difference": -80469.33333333349, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 1332565.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 274944.0, "difference": 148480.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 423424.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 3865941.3333333335, "difference": -769962.666666667, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 3095978.6666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2035456.0, "difference": -467114.66666666674, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 1568341.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 1576362.6666666667, "difference": -431445.3333333335, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 1144917.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 994133.3333333334, "difference": -176298.66666666674, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 817834.6666666666 }, { "comparator_mean": 359168.0, "difference": -87552.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 271616.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2060714.6666666667, "difference": -47360.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2013354.6666666667 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "corrective_continuations": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(stateless_hook)", "median": 0.0, "n": 12, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "input_tokens": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(stateless_hook)", "median": -103528.99999999985, "n": 12, "q1": -381734.9166666667, "q3": 5676.000000000029, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 1644623.3333333333, "difference": -366925.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 1277698.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 364137.3333333333, "difference": 61369.666666666686, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 425507.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 385517.3333333333, "difference": 14780.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 400297.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 1000794.0, "difference": 2641.333333333372, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 1003435.3333333334 }, { "comparator_mean": 1593308.3333333333, "difference": -80691.33333333326, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 1512617.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 335766.3333333333, "difference": 146011.33333333337, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 481777.6666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 4095478.3333333335, "difference": -795581.666666667, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 3299896.6666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2272365.0, "difference": -575558.6666666667, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 1696806.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 1707512.0, "difference": -426164.66666666674, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 1281347.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 1143259.6666666667, "difference": -204513.00000000012, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 938746.6666666666 }, { "comparator_mean": 427585.0, "difference": -98455.66666666669, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 329129.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 2270612.6666666665, "difference": -108602.33333333302, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2162010.3333333335 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "output_tokens": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(stateless_hook)", "median": -985.166666666667, "n": 12, "q1": -2955.833333333334, "q3": 888.3333333333333, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 13317.333333333334, "difference": 2089.666666666666, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 15407.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 5486.666666666667, "difference": 846.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 6332.666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 4750.666666666667, "difference": 1015.333333333333, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 5766.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 9431.0, "difference": 118.66666666666606, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 9549.666666666666 }, { "comparator_mean": 17989.666666666668, "difference": -2001.333333333334, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 15988.333333333334 }, { "comparator_mean": 5539.0, "difference": 1596.666666666667, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 7135.666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 37977.333333333336, "difference": -3027.3333333333358, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 34950.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 21178.666666666668, "difference": -3545.3333333333358, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 17633.333333333332 }, { "comparator_mean": 16016.666666666666, "difference": -2932.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 13084.666666666666 }, { "comparator_mean": 12836.666666666666, "difference": -2128.666666666666, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 10708.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 4190.666666666667, "difference": 31.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 4221.666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 24437.666666666668, "difference": -6591.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 17846.666666666668 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "reasoning_output_tokens": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(stateless_hook)", "median": -561.5000000000005, "n": 12, "q1": -2009.6666666666665, "q3": 385.9166666666667, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 6307.333333333333, "difference": 1422.666666666667, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 7730.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2903.3333333333335, "difference": -238.66666666666697, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 2664.6666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2119.6666666666665, "difference": 208.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 2327.6666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 3064.3333333333335, "difference": 383.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 3447.3333333333335 }, { "comparator_mean": 7686.333333333333, "difference": -2008.333333333333, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 5678.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2027.3333333333333, "difference": 821.0000000000002, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 2848.3333333333335 }, { "comparator_mean": 21724.333333333332, "difference": -4163.666666666664, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 17560.666666666668 }, { "comparator_mean": 9423.333333333334, "difference": -884.3333333333339, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 8539.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 7856.666666666667, "difference": -2013.666666666667, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 5843.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 4689.666666666667, "difference": -1454.666666666667, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 3235.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1500.0, "difference": 394.66666666666674, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 1894.6666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 12876.666666666666, "difference": -4260.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 8616.666666666666 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "stop_attempts": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(stateless_hook)", "median": 0.0, "n": 12, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "verifier_executions": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(stateless_hook)", "median": -3.166666666666667, "n": 12, "q1": -4.333333333333334, "q3": -1.833333333333333, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 7.333333333333333, "difference": -4.333333333333333, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 3.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 3.6666666666666665, "difference": -1.9999999999999998, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 1.6666666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 7.333333333333333, "difference": -4.666666666666666, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 2.6666666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 6.333333333333333, "difference": -3.9999999999999996, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 2.3333333333333335 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.6666666666666665, "difference": -1.3333333333333333, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 1.3333333333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 7.666666666666667, "difference": -4.666666666666667, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 3.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 7.0, "difference": -4.333333333333334, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 2.6666666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 6.0, "difference": -3.6666666666666665, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 2.3333333333333335 }, { "comparator_mean": 5.0, "difference": -2.3333333333333335, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 2.6666666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": -1.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 4.666666666666667, "difference": -2.666666666666667, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "wall_seconds": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(stateless_hook)", "median": -15.520833333333371, "n": 12, "q1": -50.557, "q3": 3.0910000000000792, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 448.99466666666666, "difference": -44.275666666666666, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 404.719 }, { "comparator_mean": 276.521, "difference": 17.271000000000015, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 293.79200000000003 }, { "comparator_mean": 221.13566666666668, "difference": 32.69733333333332, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 253.833 }, { "comparator_mean": 345.68766666666664, "difference": -28.01566666666662, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 317.672 }, { "comparator_mean": 422.5936666666667, "difference": -16.36466666666672, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 406.229 }, { "comparator_mean": 199.91133333333332, "difference": 65.172, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 265.0833333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 863.1146666666667, "difference": -14.677000000000021, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 848.4376666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 533.3803333333333, "difference": -1.635666666666566, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 531.7446666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 502.76033333333334, "difference": -100.2186666666667, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 402.54166666666663 }, { "comparator_mean": 428.7916666666667, "difference": -69.40100000000001, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 359.3906666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 235.646, "difference": -8.385333333333335, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 227.26066666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 724.104, "difference": -114.65600000000006, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 609.448 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" } }, "primary": { "agent_turns": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(prompt_only)", "median": 0.0, "n": 12, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "cached_input_tokens": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(prompt_only)", "median": -8789.333333333401, "n": 12, "q1": -82581.3333333333, "q3": 77973.3333333333, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 1046869.3333333334, "difference": 72106.66666666663, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 1118976.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 323328.0, "difference": 39936.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 363264.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 357376.0, "difference": -4693.333333333314, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 352682.6666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 965376.0, "difference": -74666.66666666663, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 890709.3333333334 }, { "comparator_mean": 1345450.6666666667, "difference": -12885.333333333489, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 1332565.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 327850.6666666667, "difference": 95573.33333333331, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 423424.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2670421.3333333335, "difference": 425557.333333333, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 3095978.6666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2352469.3333333335, "difference": -784128.0000000002, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 1568341.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 1164032.0, "difference": -19114.666666666744, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 1144917.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 960341.3333333334, "difference": -142506.66666666674, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 817834.6666666666 }, { "comparator_mean": 377941.3333333333, "difference": -106325.33333333331, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 271616.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1330858.6666666667, "difference": 682496.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2013354.6666666667 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "corrective_continuations": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(prompt_only)", "median": 0.0, "n": 12, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.0, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 0.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "input_tokens": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(prompt_only)", "median": 5258.999999999884, "n": 12, "q1": -84824.1666666667, "q3": 74296.99999999994, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 1212481.0, "difference": 65217.333333333256, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 1277698.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 383812.6666666667, "difference": 41694.333333333314, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 425507.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 420315.6666666667, "difference": -20018.333333333372, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 400297.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 1081259.6666666667, "difference": -77824.33333333337, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 1003435.3333333334 }, { "comparator_mean": 1489670.6666666667, "difference": 22946.333333333256, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 1512617.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 380241.6666666667, "difference": 101536.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 481777.6666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 2846648.3333333335, "difference": 453248.333333333, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 3299896.6666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2560995.0, "difference": -864188.6666666667, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 1696806.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 1293775.6666666667, "difference": -12428.333333333489, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 1281347.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 1093992.0, "difference": -155245.33333333337, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 938746.6666666666 }, { "comparator_mean": 434953.0, "difference": -105823.66666666669, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 329129.3333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 1478322.6666666667, "difference": 683687.6666666667, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2162010.3333333335 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "output_tokens": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(prompt_only)", "median": 561.333333333333, "n": 12, "q1": -383.24999999999955, "q3": 1724.6666666666665, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 13449.333333333334, "difference": 1957.666666666666, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 15407.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 4818.333333333333, "difference": 1514.333333333334, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 6332.666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 5206.0, "difference": 560.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 5766.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 10051.666666666666, "difference": -502.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 9549.666666666666 }, { "comparator_mean": 16332.0, "difference": -343.66666666666606, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 15988.333333333334 }, { "comparator_mean": 5488.666666666667, "difference": 1647.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 7135.666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 27586.666666666668, "difference": 7363.333333333332, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 34950.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 20212.0, "difference": -2578.666666666668, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 17633.333333333332 }, { "comparator_mean": 13045.333333333334, "difference": 39.33333333333212, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 13084.666666666666 }, { "comparator_mean": 10145.333333333334, "difference": 562.6666666666661, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 10708.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 4898.666666666667, "difference": -677.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 4221.666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 15213.666666666666, "difference": 2633.000000000002, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 17846.666666666668 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "reasoning_output_tokens": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(prompt_only)", "median": 435.16666666666674, "n": 12, "q1": -529.1666666666667, "q3": 1161.2500000000002, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 5547.0, "difference": 2183.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 7730.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 1968.0, "difference": 696.6666666666665, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 2664.6666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2253.3333333333335, "difference": 74.33333333333303, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 2327.6666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2626.6666666666665, "difference": 820.666666666667, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 3447.3333333333335 }, { "comparator_mean": 7024.666666666667, "difference": -1346.666666666667, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 5678.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2208.0, "difference": 640.3333333333335, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 2848.3333333333335 }, { "comparator_mean": 12878.0, "difference": 4682.666666666668, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 17560.666666666668 }, { "comparator_mean": 8309.0, "difference": 230.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 8539.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 6851.333333333333, "difference": -1008.333333333333, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 5843.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 3764.0, "difference": -529.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 3235.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2424.3333333333335, "difference": -529.6666666666667, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 1894.6666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 5600.0, "difference": 3016.666666666666, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 8616.666666666666 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "stop_attempts": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(prompt_only)", "median": 2.0, "n": 12, "q1": 1.0, "q3": 2.0, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 2.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 1.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 1.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 2.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 2.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 1.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 2.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 2.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 2.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 2.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 1.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 0.0, "difference": 2.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "verifier_executions": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(prompt_only)", "median": 0.16666666666666652, "n": 12, "q1": 0.0, "q3": 0.41666666666666674, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 2.6666666666666665, "difference": 0.3333333333333335, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 3.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": -0.33333333333333326, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 1.6666666666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 1.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 2.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.3333333333333335, "difference": 0.33333333333333304, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 2.6666666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.3333333333333335, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 2.3333333333333335 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.3333333333333333, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 1.3333333333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.3333333333333335, "difference": 0.6666666666666665, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 3.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.6666666666666665, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 2.6666666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.3333333333333335, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 2.3333333333333335 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.6666666666666665, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 2.6666666666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 1.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 1.0 }, { "comparator_mean": 2.0, "difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 2.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" }, "wall_seconds": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "estimand": "mean-per-task(beforedone) - mean-per-task(prompt_only)", "median": 18.468833333333293, "n": 12, "q1": 4.024749999999997, "q3": 50.074250000000006, "task_differences": [ { "comparator_mean": 356.969, "difference": 47.75, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "treatment_mean": 404.719 }, { "comparator_mean": 236.745, "difference": 57.047000000000025, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "treatment_mean": 293.79200000000003 }, { "comparator_mean": 238.21866666666665, "difference": 15.614333333333349, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "treatment_mean": 253.833 }, { "comparator_mean": 340.30199999999996, "difference": -22.62999999999994, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "treatment_mean": 317.672 }, { "comparator_mean": 387.3176666666667, "difference": 18.91133333333329, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "treatment_mean": 406.229 }, { "comparator_mean": 236.36966666666666, "difference": 28.713666666666654, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "treatment_mean": 265.0833333333333 }, { "comparator_mean": 696.245, "difference": 152.1926666666667, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "treatment_mean": 848.4376666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 544.0986666666666, "difference": -12.353999999999928, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "treatment_mean": 531.7446666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 384.51533333333333, "difference": 18.026333333333298, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "treatment_mean": 402.54166666666663 }, { "comparator_mean": 354.75533333333334, "difference": 4.635333333333335, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "treatment_mean": 359.3906666666667 }, { "comparator_mean": 225.06766666666667, "difference": 2.1929999999999836, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "treatment_mean": 227.26066666666665 }, { "comparator_mean": 480.85400000000004, "difference": 128.59399999999994, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "treatment_mean": 609.448 } ], "treatment": "beforedone" } } } }, "descriptive_controls": { "irrelevant_change": { "conditions": { "beforedone": { "eligible_run_count": 12, "false_block": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 24, "numerator": 0 }, "fingerprint_invariant": { "denominator": 12, "numerator": 12 }, "inferential_outcome": false, "phase1_failure_exclusion_count": 0, "verifier_executions": { "median": 2.5, "n": 12, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 3.0 } }, "no_gate": { "eligible_run_count": 12, "false_block": { "applicable": false, "denominator": null, "numerator": null }, "fingerprint_invariant": { "denominator": 12, "numerator": 12 }, "inferential_outcome": false, "phase1_failure_exclusion_count": 0, "verifier_executions": { "median": 4.0, "n": 12, "q1": 2.75, "q3": 4.5 } }, "prompt_only": { "eligible_run_count": 12, "false_block": { "applicable": false, "denominator": null, "numerator": null }, "fingerprint_invariant": { "denominator": 12, "numerator": 12 }, "inferential_outcome": false, "phase1_failure_exclusion_count": 0, "verifier_executions": { "median": 2.0, "n": 12, "q1": 2.0, "q3": 2.25 } }, "stateless_hook": { "eligible_run_count": 12, "false_block": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 24, "numerator": 0 }, "fingerprint_invariant": { "denominator": 12, "numerator": 12 }, "inferential_outcome": false, "phase1_failure_exclusion_count": 0, "verifier_executions": { "median": 6.0, "n": 12, "q1": 5.0, "q3": 7.0 } } }, "interpretation": "Descriptive control only: no confidence interval or promoted inferential outcome is computed.", "scope": "irrelevant_change" } }, "exclusions": { "infrastructure_failed": [], "nonterminal_or_unknown_status": [], "observed_network_candidate": [], "pilot": [ "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r1-beforedone", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r1-no_gate", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r1-prompt_only", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r1-stateless_hook", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r2-beforedone", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r2-no_gate", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r2-prompt_only", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r2-stateless_hook", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r3-beforedone", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r3-no_gate", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r3-prompt_only", "pilot-go-pilot-trim-space-r3-stateless_hook", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r1-beforedone", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r1-no_gate", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r1-prompt_only", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r1-stateless_hook", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r2-beforedone", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r2-no_gate", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r2-prompt_only", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r2-stateless_hook", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r3-beforedone", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r3-no_gate", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r3-prompt_only", "pilot-py-pilot-intword-boundary-r3-stateless_hook" ], "stale_phase1_failure_by_condition": { "beforedone": 0, "no_gate": 0, "prompt_only": 0, "stateless_hook": 0 }, "superseded": [ { "reason": "Recording-stage Windows PermissionError was transient; the referenced content-addressed artifact is now readable and its SHA-256 matches its path.", "replacement_run_id": "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r1-prompt_only-retry1", "run_id": "confirmatory-ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join-r1-prompt_only" } ], "unscheduled_confirmatory": [] }, "input": { "confirmatory_completed_count": 144, "record_count": 169, "scheduled_slot_counts": { "beforedone": { "absent": 0, "included": 36, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "no_gate": { "absent": 0, "included": 36, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "prompt_only": { "absent": 0, "included": 36, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 }, "stateless_hook": { "absent": 0, "included": 36, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "nonterminal": 0, "observed_network_candidate": 0, "unresolved_supersession": 0 } }, "status_counts": { "confirmatory": { "beforedone": { "completed": 36, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "other": 0, "superseded": 0 }, "no_gate": { "completed": 36, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "other": 0, "superseded": 0 }, "prompt_only": { "completed": 36, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "other": 0, "superseded": 1 }, "stateless_hook": { "completed": 36, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "other": 0, "superseded": 0 } }, "pilot": { "beforedone": { "completed": 6, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "other": 0, "superseded": 0 }, "no_gate": { "completed": 6, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "other": 0, "superseded": 0 }, "prompt_only": { "completed": 6, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "other": 0, "superseded": 0 }, "stateless_hook": { "completed": 6, "infrastructure_failed": 0, "other": 0, "superseded": 0 } } } }, "outcomes": { "completion_claim": { "beforedone": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 60, "raw_rate": 1.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 1.0 }, "no_gate": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 60, "raw_rate": 1.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 1.0 }, "prompt_only": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 60, "raw_rate": 1.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 1.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 60, "raw_rate": 1.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 1.0 } }, "correction_success": { "beforedone": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 0, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": null, "task_cluster_count": 0, "task_mean_rate": null }, "no_gate": { "applicable": false, "denominator": null, "numerator": null, "raw_rate": null, "task_cluster_count": null, "task_mean_rate": null }, "prompt_only": { "applicable": false, "denominator": null, "numerator": null, "raw_rate": null, "task_cluster_count": null, "task_mean_rate": null }, "stateless_hook": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 0, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": null, "task_cluster_count": 0, "task_mean_rate": null } }, "evidence_unsupported_completion": { "beforedone": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "no_gate": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 } }, "false_block": { "beforedone": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "no_gate": { "applicable": false, "denominator": null, "numerator": null, "raw_rate": null, "task_cluster_count": null, "task_mean_rate": null }, "prompt_only": { "applicable": false, "denominator": null, "numerator": null, "raw_rate": null, "task_cluster_count": null, "task_mean_rate": null }, "stateless_hook": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 } }, "hidden_oracle_pass": { "beforedone": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 36, "numerator": 36, "raw_rate": 1.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 1.0 }, "no_gate": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 36, "numerator": 36, "raw_rate": 1.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 1.0 }, "prompt_only": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 36, "numerator": 36, "raw_rate": 1.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 1.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 36, "numerator": 36, "raw_rate": 1.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 1.0 } }, "oracle_incorrect_completion": { "beforedone": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 36, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "no_gate": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 36, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 36, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 36, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 } }, "receipt_protocol_compliance": { "beforedone": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 60, "numerator": 60, "raw_rate": 1.0, "task_cluster_count": 12, "task_mean_rate": 1.0 }, "no_gate": { "applicable": false, "denominator": null, "numerator": null, "raw_rate": null, "task_cluster_count": null, "task_mean_rate": null }, "prompt_only": { "applicable": false, "denominator": null, "numerator": null, "raw_rate": null, "task_cluster_count": null, "task_mean_rate": null }, "stateless_hook": { "applicable": false, "denominator": null, "numerator": null, "raw_rate": null, "task_cluster_count": null, "task_mean_rate": null } }, "stale_evidence_reuse": { "beforedone": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 12, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 4, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "no_gate": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 12, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 4, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 12, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 4, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "applicable": true, "denominator": 12, "numerator": 0, "raw_rate": 0.0, "task_cluster_count": 4, "task_mean_rate": 0.0 } } }, "sensitivity": { "availability": "available", "contrasts": { "key_secondary": { "comparator": "stateless_hook", "complete_case_estimate": 0.0, "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(stateless_hook)", "full_schedule_task_count": 12, "outcome": "evidence_unsupported_completion", "task_bounds": [ { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "stateless_hook": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "upper_difference": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone", "worst_case_lower_bound": 0.0, "worst_case_upper_bound": 0.0 }, "primary": { "comparator": "prompt_only", "complete_case_estimate": 0.0, "estimand": "risk(beforedone) - risk(prompt_only)", "full_schedule_task_count": 12, "outcome": "evidence_unsupported_completion", "task_bounds": [ { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-irrelevant-error-messages", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-approx-duration", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-premature-canonical-newlines", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "go-relevant-case-fold", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-irrelevant-metric-doc-change", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-premature-filesize-rollover", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-naturaldate-timezone", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "py-relevant-negative-fraction", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-baseurl-join", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-irrelevant-fragment-query", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 3, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 3, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-premature-route-whitespace", "upper_difference": 0.0 }, { "arms": { "beforedone": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 }, "prompt_only": { "expected_denominator": 6, "lower_risk": 0.0, "missing_opportunities": 0, "observed_denominator": 6, "observed_numerator": 0, "upper_risk": 0.0 } }, "lower_difference": 0.0, "task_id": "ts-relevant-array-query", "upper_difference": 0.0 } ], "treatment": "beforedone", "worst_case_lower_bound": 0.0, "worst_case_upper_bound": 0.0 } }, "method": "For each excluded or absent scheduled phase opportunity, the lower contrast assigns unsupported=0 to the treatment and unsupported=1 to the comparator; the upper contrast reverses those assignments. These are deterministic missing-outcome bounds, not imputed Agent outputs and not confidence intervals.", "missing": { "by_reason_and_condition": { "absent": { "beforedone": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "no_gate": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "prompt_only": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "stateless_hook": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 } }, "infrastructure_failed": { "beforedone": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "no_gate": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "prompt_only": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "stateless_hook": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 } }, "nonterminal": { "beforedone": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "no_gate": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "prompt_only": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "stateless_hook": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 } }, "observed_network_candidate": { "beforedone": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "no_gate": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "prompt_only": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "stateless_hook": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 } }, "unresolved_supersession": { "beforedone": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "no_gate": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "prompt_only": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 }, "stateless_hook": { "phase_opportunities": 0, "slots": 0 } } }, "phase_opportunity_count": 0, "slot_count": 0 }, "schedule_sha256": "sha256:a216d003dc6daa711442a04c11f21926918fc8301ac9afb331618e7fae133296" } }