{ "method": "logistic regression on pairwise feature differences", "training_set_size": 1717, "feature_names": [ "word_count", "char_count", "ttr", "sentence_count", "avg_sentence_len", "dialogue_ratio", "action_ratio", "exclamation_per_1k", "ellipsis_per_1k", "comma_per_1k", "avg_word_len", "bigram_repetition" ], "cv_accuracy": { "mean": 0.5387, "std": 0.0201 }, "feature_coefficients": { "word_count": 0.038616634397416805, "char_count": 0.03864279473772371, "ttr": -0.01914308086445501, "sentence_count": 0.028155957104233048, "avg_sentence_len": -0.0036095904495603687, "dialogue_ratio": 0.0437777895165803, "action_ratio": -0.006029425140718956, "exclamation_per_1k": 0.006058409728573959, "ellipsis_per_1k": -0.01170504339618912, "comma_per_1k": -0.0025946344729306414, "avg_word_len": 0.004955500028980793, "bigram_repetition": 0.017184690623146537 }, "intercept": -0.06435372402856071, "validation_against_human_arena": { "n_models_overlap": 11, "rho_vs_human_arena_elo": 0.5545, "p_value": 0.0767, "interpretation": "moderate proxy" }, "per_model": { "mistral_small_creative": { "engagement_skill_mean": 0.0064, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0943, "n_scored": 27 }, "deepseek_r1_0528": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0108, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1449, "n_scored": 27 }, "claude_opus_4_6": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0265, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1829, "n_scored": 27 }, "gemini_3_1_pro": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0289, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1024, "n_scored": 25 }, "claude_opus_4_7": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0296, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1154, "n_scored": 27 }, "gemma_4_26b": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.031, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1359, "n_scored": 27 }, "qwen3_5_flash": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0343, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0904, "n_scored": 25 }, "glm_4_7": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0544, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0937, "n_scored": 27 }, "claude_sonnet_4_5": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0623, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1219, "n_scored": 27 }, "gemini_3_1_flash_lite": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0647, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0652, "n_scored": 27 }, "kimi_k2_5": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0757, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0769, "n_scored": 27 }, "deepseek_v3_2": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0804, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1485, "n_scored": 27 }, "gemini_2_5_flash": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0812, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0873, "n_scored": 27 }, "kimi_k2_6": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0872, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0898, "n_scored": 23 }, "deepseek_v4_pro": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0949, "engagement_skill_std": 0.106, "n_scored": 27 }, "minimax_m2_7": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.0994, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1583, "n_scored": 27 }, "grok_4_1": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.1055, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1303, "n_scored": 27 }, "llama_4_maverick": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.1059, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0723, "n_scored": 27 }, "glm_5_1": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.1159, "engagement_skill_std": 0.1023, "n_scored": 26 }, "deepseek_v4_flash": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.1186, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0867, "n_scored": 27 }, "gpt_4_1": { "engagement_skill_mean": -0.1388, "engagement_skill_std": 0.0625, "n_scored": 27 } } }