""" Adversarial tests for L1 (physical isolation). Every test is an attack or an escape-enabling misconfiguration. The question each one answers: if an operator, or a compromised toolchain, or a well-meaning convenience patch tried this, would containment silently weaken? """ import dataclasses from pathlib import Path import pytest from ames.events import EventType from ames.gate1 import verify as gate1_verify from ames.ledger import ChainError from containment.backend import ( FakeBackend, VmState, build_firecracker_config, ) from containment.supervisor import GUEST_ACTOR_BASE, Supervisor from containment.transport import ( GuestEventReader, MAX_FRAME_PAYLOAD, TransportLimitExceeded, encode_frame, ) from containment.vmspec import ( HOST_ACTOR_ID, VM_ACTOR_ID, DiskSpec, IsolationPolicy, PolicyViolation, VmSpec, is_host_observed, ) def good_spec(**overrides): base = dict( run_id="run-00000001", kernel_image=Path("/k/vmlinux"), rootfs=DiskSpec(Path("/i/base.ext4"), read_only=True), overlay=DiskSpec(Path("/i/ovl.ext4"), read_only=False, is_ephemeral_overlay=True), vcpus=2, mem_mib=2048, timeout_seconds=900, vsock_cid=3, ) base.update(overrides) return VmSpec(**base) # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # The invariant the OpenAI incident exists to teach # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_network_device_is_refused_unconditionally(): """The escape used a package-registry proxy that existed to give the sandbox network reach. There is no safe version of this.""" with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="NETWORK DEVICE"): IsolationPolicy.validate(good_spec(allow_network_device=True)) def test_generated_config_has_no_network_interface(): """Firecracker only creates a NIC if configured. Absence, not filtering.""" cfg = build_firecracker_config(good_spec()) assert "network-interfaces" not in cfg assert not any("net" in k.lower() for k in cfg) def test_host_filesystem_share_refused(): with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="HOST FILESYSTEM SHARE"): IsolationPolicy.validate(good_spec(allow_host_filesystem_share=True)) def test_persistent_state_refused(): with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="PERSISTENT STATE"): IsolationPolicy.validate(good_spec(allow_persistent_state=True)) # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Disks: no writable persistence, no mutable base image # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_writable_non_ephemeral_disk_refused_at_construction(): with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="persistence"): DiskSpec(Path("/i/state.ext4"), read_only=False, is_ephemeral_overlay=False) def test_writable_rootfs_refused(): with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="rootfs must be read-only"): IsolationPolicy.validate(good_spec( rootfs=DiskSpec(Path("/i/base.ext4"), read_only=False, is_ephemeral_overlay=True))) def test_rootfs_and_overlay_must_differ(): same = Path("/i/same.ext4") with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="distinct"): IsolationPolicy.validate(good_spec( rootfs=DiskSpec(same, read_only=True), overlay=DiskSpec(same, read_only=False, is_ephemeral_overlay=True))) # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Bounds: an unbounded run is an unbounded number of escape attempts # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- @pytest.mark.parametrize("field,value", [ ("vcpus", 0), ("vcpus", 999), ("mem_mib", 64), ("mem_mib", 99999), ("timeout_seconds", 0), ("timeout_seconds", 999999), ]) def test_resource_bounds_enforced(field, value): with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation): IsolationPolicy.validate(good_spec(**{field: value})) @pytest.mark.parametrize("args", [ "console=none init=/bin/sh", "console=none rw", "console=none single", ]) def test_dangerous_kernel_args_refused(args): with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="kernel_args"): IsolationPolicy.validate(good_spec(kernel_args=args)) def test_reserved_vsock_cids_refused(): with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="vsock_cid"): IsolationPolicy.validate(good_spec(vsock_cid=2)) # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Lifecycle: destroy must run on EVERY path # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_destroy_runs_on_clean_exit(): b = FakeBackend() Supervisor(b).run(good_spec()) assert b.destroyed @pytest.mark.parametrize("stage", ["measure_image", "prepare_overlay", "boot", "wait"]) def test_destroy_runs_even_when_a_stage_fails(stage): """A supervisor that leaks a live VM on an error path has failed at the one job that matters. These are the paths a real incident takes.""" b = FakeBackend(fail_on=stage) with pytest.raises(RuntimeError, match="injected failure"): Supervisor(b).run(good_spec()) assert b.destroyed, f"VM left alive after failure at {stage}" def test_invalid_spec_never_reaches_the_backend(): b = FakeBackend() with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation): Supervisor(b).run(good_spec(allow_network_device=True)) assert b.calls == [], "policy must reject before anything is created" def test_timeout_is_recorded_as_a_denied_capability(): b = FakeBackend(timed_out=True) report = Supervisor(b).run(good_spec()) assert report.result.timed_out assert not report.clean_exit kinds = [e.event_type for e in report.ledger.all_events()] assert EventType.CAPABILITY_REQUEST in kinds assert b.destroyed # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Provenance: a guest must not be able to forge a host observation # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_guest_claim_cannot_use_the_host_actor_id(): sup = Supervisor(FakeBackend()) with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="reserved host range"): sup.record_guest_claim(EventType.TOOL_CALL, b"", actor=HOST_ACTOR_ID) def test_guest_claim_cannot_use_the_vm_actor_id(): sup = Supervisor(FakeBackend()) with pytest.raises(PolicyViolation, match="reserved host range"): sup.record_guest_claim(EventType.TOOL_CALL, b"", actor=VM_ACTOR_ID) def test_auto_assigned_guest_actors_are_outside_the_host_band(): sup = Supervisor(FakeBackend()) for _ in range(50): assert not is_host_observed(sup.record_guest_claim(EventType.TOOL_CALL, b"")) def test_host_events_are_distinguishable_in_the_ledger(): """An analyst must be able to separate evidence from testimony.""" b = FakeBackend() sup = Supervisor(b) report = sup.run(good_spec()) for ev in report.ledger.all_events(): assert is_host_observed(ev.actor_id), "supervisor emitted a non-host actor" # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # The run record itself must be sound # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_run_produces_a_verifiable_ledger(): report = Supervisor(FakeBackend()).run(good_spec()) report.ledger.verify_chain(report.checkpoint) def test_run_record_passes_gate1_lineage(): report = Supervisor(FakeBackend()).run(good_spec()) gate1_verify(list(report.ledger.all_events())).raise_if_failed() def test_images_are_measured_before_boot(): """Measuring after boot would let a running guest influence its own recorded provenance.""" b = FakeBackend() Supervisor(b).run(good_spec()) assert b.calls.index("measure_image") < b.calls.index("boot") def test_tampering_with_the_run_record_is_detected(): report = Supervisor(FakeBackend()).run(good_spec()) blk = report.ledger.blocks[0] blk.events[2] = dataclasses.replace(blk.events[2], payload=b"rewritten") with pytest.raises(ChainError): report.ledger.verify_chain(report.checkpoint) # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Transport: the one channel crossing the boundary # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_guest_cannot_forge_run_boundary_markers(): r = GuestEventReader() assert r.read(encode_frame(EventType.RUN_BEGIN, b"")) == [] assert r.read(encode_frame(EventType.RUN_END, b"")) == [] def test_oversized_payload_claim_is_refused_before_allocation(): import struct r = GuestEventReader() assert r.read(struct.pack(">BI", int(EventType.TOOL_CALL), 0x0FFFFFFF)) == [] assert "MAX_FRAME_PAYLOAD" in r.stats.rejections[0] def test_payload_running_past_end_of_stream_refused(): import struct r = GuestEventReader() assert r.read(struct.pack(">BI", int(EventType.TOOL_CALL), 500) + b"short") == [] def test_unknown_event_type_skipped_not_fatal(): import struct r = GuestEventReader() stream = struct.pack(">BI", 0x42, 0) + encode_frame(EventType.TOOL_CALL, b"ok") assert len(r.read(stream)) == 1 # bad frame skipped, good one kept def test_event_count_cap_truncates_rather_than_exhausting_host(): r = GuestEventReader(max_events=10) flood = b"".join(encode_frame(EventType.TOOL_CALL, b"x") for _ in range(1000)) assert len(r.read(flood)) == 10 def test_total_byte_cap_enforced(): r = GuestEventReader(max_total_bytes=1000) flood = b"".join(encode_frame(EventType.TOOL_CALL, b"x" * 500) for _ in range(100)) assert r.stats.bytes_accepted <= 1000 + 500 def test_rejection_log_is_bounded(): """Error handling must not itself become a memory-exhaustion primitive.""" import struct r = GuestEventReader() r.read(b"".join(struct.pack(">BI", 0x42, 0) for _ in range(5000))) assert len(r.stats.rejections) <= 100 def test_encode_frame_refuses_oversized_payload(): with pytest.raises(TransportLimitExceeded): encode_frame(EventType.TOOL_CALL, b"x" * (MAX_FRAME_PAYLOAD + 1)) def test_truncated_trailing_frame_does_not_destroy_the_record(): """A guest must not be able to erase its own audit trail with one bad byte at the end.""" r = GuestEventReader() stream = encode_frame(EventType.TOOL_CALL, b"real") + b"\x05\x00" assert len(r.read(stream)) == 1