""" Adversarial tests for the Runtime -- the composed L1-L9 entrypoint. Governing question: can a caller, a misconfiguration, or a failing component produce a run that reports ALLOWED when it should not have? """ from pathlib import Path import pytest from ames.canonical import payload_capability_request from ames.events import Capability, EventType, FileOp from containment.backend import FakeBackend, VmBackend, VmResult, VmState from containment.envstate import ( EnvironmentBaseline, MutationObservation, ) from containment.identity import BinaryPolicy from containment.killswitch import KillReason from containment.policy import CapabilityPolicy, CapabilityRequest from containment.runtime import ( ALLOWED, FAILED, KILLED, ContainmentReport, Runtime, RuntimeConfig, RuntimeError_, ) from containment.vmspec import DiskSpec, VM_ACTOR_ID, VmSpec ONE32 = bytes([1]) * 32 TWO32 = bytes([2]) * 32 def spec(**overrides) -> VmSpec: base = dict( run_id="rt-000001", kernel_image=Path("/k/vmlinux"), rootfs=DiskSpec(Path("/i/base.ext4"), read_only=True), overlay=DiskSpec(Path("/i/ovl.ext4"), read_only=False, is_ephemeral_overlay=True), vcpus=2, mem_mib=2048, timeout_seconds=900, vsock_cid=3, ) base.update(overrides) return VmSpec(**base) def sealed_baseline(path="/rootfs/bin/sh", digest=ONE32) -> EnvironmentBaseline: b = EnvironmentBaseline() b.add(path, digest) b.seal() return b # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # The baseline: a clean run is allowed, and independently verifiable # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_clean_run_is_allowed(): """True-negative baseline. If this fails, every KILLED result below is meaningless because the runtime would be refusing everything.""" r = Runtime().execute(spec(), FakeBackend()) assert r.verdict == ALLOWED assert r.allowed assert not r.kill.kill assert r.gate1.ok def test_report_is_independently_verifiable(): """A report a reviewer cannot re-check is a summary, not evidence. `verify()` recomputes every commitment from the raw ledger.""" r = Runtime().execute(spec(), FakeBackend()) assert r.verify() def test_tampering_with_the_ledger_breaks_verification(): """The verification is real, not a stub that returns True.""" import dataclasses r = Runtime().execute(spec(), FakeBackend()) blk = r.ledger.blocks[0] blk.events[2] = dataclasses.replace(blk.events[2], payload=b"rewritten") assert not r.verify() # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # An unsafe spec never runs at all # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_network_device_spec_is_refused_before_anything_is_created(): backend = FakeBackend() r = Runtime().execute(spec(allow_network_device=True), backend) assert r.verdict == FAILED assert not r.allowed assert "isolation policy" in r.error assert backend.calls == [], "nothing may be created for a refused spec" @pytest.mark.parametrize("bad", [ dict(allow_network_device=True), dict(allow_host_filesystem_share=True), dict(allow_persistent_state=True), ]) def test_every_escape_hatch_spec_is_refused(bad): r = Runtime().execute(spec(**bad), FakeBackend()) assert not r.allowed # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Fail closed # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- class ExplodingBackend(FakeBackend): def wait(self, spec): raise RuntimeError("backend detonated mid-run") def test_component_exception_fails_closed_to_killed(): """An exception in the containment system must never read as 'nothing to report'. Note it is KILLED, not FAILED: the VM did start, so the conservative reading is that something ran uncontained.""" r = Runtime().execute(spec(), ExplodingBackend()) assert r.verdict == KILLED assert not r.allowed assert "failing closed" in r.error def test_hook_exception_fails_closed(): def boom(ctx): raise ValueError("hook detonated") r = Runtime().execute(spec(), FakeBackend(), during_run=boom) assert r.verdict == KILLED assert not r.allowed def test_execute_never_raises_even_on_a_garbage_spec(): r = Runtime().execute("not a spec", FakeBackend()) assert not r.allowed assert r.error # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # A real breach composes into a kill # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_read_only_breach_during_the_run_kills(): """The full path: L7 observes an impossible write -> Evidence.from_run picks it up -> KillSwitch fires absolutely -> the runtime reports KILLED.""" def breach(ctx): ctx.monitor.observe(MutationObservation( path="/rootfs/bin/sh", op=FileOp.WRITE, before=ONE32, after=TWO32, timestamp_ns=1, actor_id=VM_ACTOR_ID, )) cfg = RuntimeConfig(environment_baseline=sealed_baseline()) r = Runtime(cfg).execute(spec(), FakeBackend(), during_run=breach) assert r.verdict == KILLED assert KillReason.CONTAINMENT_FAILURE in r.kill.reasons assert r.kill.absolute assert r.monitor.containment_failed def test_denial_burst_during_the_run_kills(): """A real Broker driven through the runtime's own context, not a hand-built DenialSignal.""" def probe(ctx): for _ in range(10): ctx.broker.request(CapabilityRequest(Capability.PROCESS_SPAWN, "spawn")) r = Runtime().execute(spec(), FakeBackend(), during_run=probe) assert r.verdict == KILLED assert r.broker.denial_count == 10 # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # The structural property: advisory layers cannot reach the verdict # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_advisory_findings_never_change_the_verdict(): """L5/L6 are computed after the kill decision and are not inputs to it. This drives a real OUTCOME_MISMATCH (guest narrates a grant the broker denied) and asserts the verdict is identical to a clean run's.""" def conceal(ctx): actor = ctx.supervisor.record_guest_claim(EventType.PROCESS_SPAWN, b"") ctx.broker.request(CapabilityRequest(Capability.FILE_WRITE, "/workspace/x")) ctx.supervisor.record_guest_claim( EventType.CAPABILITY_REQUEST, payload_capability_request(Capability.FILE_WRITE, True, "narrated"), actor=actor, ) ctx.supervisor.record_guest_claim(EventType.PROCESS_EXIT, b"", actor=actor) r = Runtime().execute(spec(), FakeBackend(), during_run=conceal) clean = Runtime().execute(spec(), FakeBackend()) assert r.drift, "expected the concealment to be detected" assert r.advisory_findings > 0 assert r.verdict == clean.verdict == ALLOWED assert r.kill.reasons == clean.kill.reasons == () def test_evidence_has_no_parameter_for_advisory_signals(): """Structural, not behavioural: there is no wiring to remove because there is no parameter to wire. Asserted by inspecting the signature so a future refactor that adds one has to consciously break this test.""" import inspect from containment.killswitch import Evidence params = set(inspect.signature(Evidence.from_run).parameters) assert "drift" not in params assert "fingerprint" not in params assert "behaviour" not in params # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Config cannot be used to weaken the system # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_config_exposes_no_disable_switches(): cfg = RuntimeConfig() for forbidden in ("disable_killswitch", "disable_gate1", "skip_verification", "enable_network", "bypass", "allow_unsafe"): assert not hasattr(cfg, forbidden), f"RuntimeConfig exposes {forbidden}" def test_unsealed_binary_policy_is_refused_at_config_time(): p = BinaryPolicy() p.approve(ONE32) with pytest.raises(RuntimeError_): RuntimeConfig(binary_policy=p) def test_unsealed_baseline_is_refused_at_config_time(): b = EnvironmentBaseline() b.add("/rootfs/x", ONE32) with pytest.raises(RuntimeError_): RuntimeConfig(environment_baseline=b) def test_runtime_does_not_share_state_between_runs(): """Each execute() builds its own broker/monitor/authorizer. Sharing any of them would carry state across a run boundary -- the exact thing L1 destroys the VM to prevent.""" rt = Runtime() a = rt.execute(spec(run_id="rt-aaaaaa1"), FakeBackend()) b = rt.execute(spec(run_id="rt-bbbbbb2"), FakeBackend()) assert a.broker is not b.broker assert a.ledger is not b.ledger assert a.run_id != b.run_id # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Report completeness # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_successful_report_carries_everything_a_review_needs(): r = Runtime().execute(spec(), FakeBackend()) assert r.ledger is not None assert r.checkpoint is not None assert r.gate1 is not None assert r.kill is not None assert r.broker is not None assert r.run_report is not None assert r.summary() def test_authorizer_is_wired_only_when_an_allowlist_is_supplied(): plain = Runtime().execute(spec(), FakeBackend()) assert plain.authorizer is None p = BinaryPolicy() p.approve(ONE32, "sh") p.seal() withlist = Runtime(RuntimeConfig(binary_policy=p)).execute(spec(), FakeBackend()) assert withlist.authorizer is not None assert VM_ACTOR_ID in withlist.authorizer.live_actors