{"id": "v3_921379c0e530be54_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.05, 0.27, 0.57, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3927949ca4e9c71_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e5e44806cffbc0b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.74, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ccf40f8ad3cd4e0c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.4, 0.58, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49dcb68ae674c72_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.08, 0.26, 0.36, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b387e435a588e28_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c074a11b0185083_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.76, 0.23, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4c8fbbda40ca67b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.27, 0.5, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e47e7126a3eaa197_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dabc9bbe9c19aeda_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1d85e0de3af235a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.03, 0.55, 0.18], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_823ce5508f4970db_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.4, 0.56, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45d2feb2c1001c42_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.24, 0.31, 0.22, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d37906e56f857b0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9db6260186531ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.84, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_454af686cfb8bdaf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6e471102ff8ead2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.23, 0.28, 0.26, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb953ab3ef091e05_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_80ab91df51694c85_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17ca8ad52877a316_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5dcde1ceb257eea0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.02, 0.71, 0.19], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f14e64f4bd6bae8d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.13, 0.11, 0.37, 0.24, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bcf0c1173e7f629_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86890f39cc660dc8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_551b89dbfc52377f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aaef30c1ff9bbd68_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.07, 0.45, 0.45, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdca00d869c82efa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.27, 0.28, 0.3, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c24b2f86a1c336dd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.2, 0.36, 0.36, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b288b8b079cd0de0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.26, 0.7, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91ec7023a086dd8a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.08, 0.11, 0.48, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34bc65b940f184ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f00e7c5c7171462_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.17, 0.26, 0.34, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_668b7d184cd0aad3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d379257433b00be_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.71, 0.02, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cbe8cb75e5359acc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.48, 0.52, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12e4e4b55c055ebe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.08, 0.3, 0.42, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bda57529422533b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.49, 0.42, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_391de218a986c03e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.12, 0.01, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b00cfeb687d329d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.86, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cffcc2ba66c060cb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.13, 0.26, 0.46, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec724e4d0e10e0cb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.54, 0.44, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_874d779684283d80_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.32, 0.58, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b78ea3ed947dbc4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6837b018cb3f4c8c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.14, 0.12, 0.31, 0.38, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b37063d5f197ef0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.03, 0.7, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e10abef76b1c169_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.31, 0.64, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e524f32d0b2bd9f9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93dabed265c122f1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.73, 0.21, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8da0c9bd0322029c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.23, 0.11, 0.26, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2eacae7898cc8471_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_727df6fcf2155dd4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_188949afce8abc5f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.16, 0.24, 0.37, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2929e272de6497d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.35, 0.64, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c394c055af579d6c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cf25cf58581a4da7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.68, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f221e7505dfd0d11_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.35, 0.15, 0.25, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74cdcf04a4fda3ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.49, 0.5, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e35d01c5cdd2463_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.25, 0.49, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_933547979d8c63d7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bbee4b07ce71cf50_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.83, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b35b62d6c8ec711_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.25, 0.3, 0.2, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e5b1e8b399c29ec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_80c1c6da5808923f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.13, 0.35, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50d5a926fd031c5a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8379018e170dbfa3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6185f252539612d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.48, 0.31, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43a888ec41447ae5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcd5a633bfc1c857_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.57, 0.31, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_69c9f9c64368b6c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8761c8bc4b9a523_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.47, 0.05, 0.18], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dc5fa52c4efe6cb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ead4e334d514c361_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.48, 0.33, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b06ed2be4ef6b1c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.93, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1db87b833fed14e8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.1, 0.52, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f3c3c233971851de_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.18, 0.29, 0.32, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8341fdbab1805a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3333, 0.5455, 0.1111, 0.0101], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ecfae306bdef8d33_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.11, 0.38, 0.31, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b21fd1a1558e7fe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.22, 0.22, 0.27, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc6058933795f5f9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.73, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a6b105984c92e5d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.09, 0.21, 0.36, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e7914f96b93f3bf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.72, 0.14, 0.01, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc2e892acb163c5f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5d98e954df8dee6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.66, 0.29, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35923327e32c9527_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eab7303ea50c0db8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.53, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d78fbca79e7944bf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f819b236e4738c4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0254ef73eaf0baaf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2929e272de6497d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.1, 0.48, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29820e5e24e1fbc7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.38, 0.19, 0.13, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcaba9b3a072961e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.23, 0.13, 0.35, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44643d7118da6e5a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.4, 0.52, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d20a5f7cc326010b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.84, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4abcef60be92938f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_595e1e19ddeb36ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2736514b6bdcf013_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb5856c165d5bcb1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.18, 0.72, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_768c8fbb52c8f38c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.17, 0.49, 0.3, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_794ec1aa944f2239_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.16, 0.28, 0.33, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5debf4498610dd5a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90bf572a55d13153_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88684eb281547e56_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.22, 0.19, 0.37, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4e9096889813e1c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07db4980affc34fc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.1, 0.09, 0.31, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42d28d8f36309d35_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff929524452fbead_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.72, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58b9d937652d8923_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_397af398ef2629b8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.13, 0.23, 0.33, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cda41f8f6fa96b2a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.89, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86d184a6bb0b0218_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.71, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d48c67b908af469_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.79, 0.14, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_152dfc3c34363d36_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.26, 0.38, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb821e36fe7b3c7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.19, 0.25, 0.24, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8a8d8d45e57243a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9b9318248e6c799_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ccddd6169de5c7a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.75, 0.22, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c55b4a1f2e7e8cac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.12, 0.17, 0.43, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bdfaa088b3e48989_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.05, 0.06, 0.42, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9a3f944e239effe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5149b9a403327f12_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.96, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ce5c9e4dbf2f0a7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.19, 0.39, 0.2, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c1b29d7d28ec120_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.14, 0.39, 0.34, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b288b8b079cd0de0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_828e1cfb84055459_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.72, 0.19, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac85e127121c4999_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.06, 0.86, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cd98984134f1fe0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cedc4428541bc17_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.25, 0.63, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c97fc0e429d6b8d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e44df57367945d5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.12, 0.45, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57072c742b1a7232_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.14, 0.4, 0.34, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f469e638c8bf7660_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.79, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d705ff67005fa68_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.07, 0.18, 0.48, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b10cd6d9461d32f0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.74, 0.12, 0.01, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d5dfc0e7dddb3e2b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.37, 0.18, 0.19, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4c3bd5d43a7c268_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.07, 0.27, 0.46, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_958c36110a29d645_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f031dd1296a53f2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.54, 0.41, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e04a60682b804955_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.06, 0.54, 0.38, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2a66427f20ac0ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.18, 0.46, 0.24, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3291f9bc175628f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3741996dcb98caaa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0606, 0.1414, 0.2727, 0.404, 0.1111, 0.0101], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_370de51125f45b5e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.13, 0.34, 0.34, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee4413d41edc569f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.62, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d62ec8f3b3b0529_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6629c45f9cfba802_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.26, 0.59, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79d51f986929ad53_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.26, 0.09, 0.32, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4e3023e2e121a10_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.14, 0.26, 0.43, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d7024b0372e7a74_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4594ebe9afc46ab0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.05, 0.15, 0.55, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be80cfb3e7ffb835_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.37, 0.51, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_032fa1fab9507513_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.2, 0.76, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86974afdaed8e754_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe10a8b6d891f4ce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.45, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a31b497a6eccd212_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.05, 0.42, 0.5, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d6f723e3eb0067c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0663beaeebec89a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.45, 0.08, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec4804228b33e596_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.97, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3945bf0231c20f23_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.43, 0.18, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b66f50ddb5a4e8cd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.35, 0.38, 0.09, 0.1, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_727df6fcf2155dd4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.09, 0.29, 0.38, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82a4a31e4c6ff5f7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.63, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8aba9669cd219da1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b37e3c498aa80ab5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_705bbb659b81c168_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.12, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_358824d4f61be878_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8ebad6280793f9f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.87, 0.08, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_80d83f7b5b5a4928_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6598c831abb9d16_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.52, 0.42, 0.04, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9929e0623827c448_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_473b9056ad865a61_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb3e801e51772bf4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.12, 0.31, 0.39, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d21fc20b0a8ab7b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_062acd516f9a4475_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.75, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b431e7f81bc6fe51_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b20ac786ace3334a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7168aec5f1222e7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_481bd7485830d7bc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.44, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_035931080431b392_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0774ff6da0b8c75_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.17, 0.3, 0.32, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c222c4aeb5aae066_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e11d0937157876d3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.91, 0.0, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bdcab1a43c6971c4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87e35e1ce6c99c13_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.49, 0.41, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a30f1abaf564706d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.34, 0.57, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15f0ffe89f21a7e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.78, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d5e8080afca86f4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_19a41545024064ff_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fa7d3df4868ebb5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.56, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_178afd440fa0112e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.15, 0.34, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_727df6fcf2155dd4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.46, 0.19, 0.02, 0.33], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1c3235969200c92_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f6ef59afbdd8a2c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.83, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cae479533bf8461_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d4aef3fd47063a84_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.25, 0.61, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b1deb56a8ef0cdce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.49, 0.46, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c39e6ff11162f62f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb7967c1b2b191b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.78, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a970d6e235f4b475_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.14, 0.45, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88684eb281547e56_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8ba75ea1a4c1af2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_407665d089e970a6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb27aae97d5ac508_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.31, 0.62, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c489283c6d52de1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.14, 0.57, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_980e74dc6c9fda8a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae141c6f91ec3292_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.82, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79b07270c09f2521_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.34, 0.22, 0.2, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3291f9bc175628f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.82, 0.18, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3cccfe01bc81141_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.13, 0.21, 0.4, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0962b4d66a919133_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.97, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a17859a5966f0d1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.24, 0.37, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91c32bd058ca7b71_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1901208013bc1aab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a81285917fe7d23_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.19, 0.24, 0.3, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23ce4baf3279eb9a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3021df90a1060015_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.79, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac936dfec986746e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f80bfc46ebf31df_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.01, 0.72, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da428d9f6325f81b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.8, 0.15], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e99bb9b1e2ddf256_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb00cf2fdd62ccad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.44, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da8b61a6f750bab3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.2, 0.67, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d7eb78adb9010878_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66833285e552c844_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9772df5ab3935d9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.96, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b938cb25ed3b0725_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.48, 0.24, 0.12, 0.13, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7710978c7136c206_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfe4db10ae47cf37_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ec8467ef2bce89a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb31cb13c9e5652b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.21, 0.26, 0.27, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe1a2056819f757d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0bf8b6047c45465c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7fa254c60179fe3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.65, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a15fb0c49a3ce293_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.54, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f031dd1296a53f2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e614d1b026ccfaf0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.76, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a5bff151b19fddb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.88, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a647df04db78896_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.63, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b41724b81590ccb3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.58, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9373fabb1115421f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28bd64b4baf2b965_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb31cb13c9e5652b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71bbd91e370f9841_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d44ec4c5c2df9716_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.26, 0.27, 0.19, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79cdeb281651daaf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.97, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82c89e728b798d1f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.15, 0.14, 0.38, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c10ad26d97189c24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.75, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_693fb533ddc942c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07c04d38f804a97a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.75, 0.21], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4bca8f7ea703828_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.17, 0.73, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2653962c5ae07bc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.53, 0.37, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba67c8e13b79a94f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31246ae345df3c6b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cd98984134f1fe0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.47, 0.37, 0.08, 0.07, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f683487f579a0d92_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.28, 0.52, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2300ac29352f7f0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdcd382fdd257404_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da058bc14bf616db_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3434, 0.5354, 0.0101, 0.1111], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0aec4d77d858e5c3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c7a1e23786f4d4d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.84, 0.05, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24ba653f73385bf5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f81c7d1921d0bba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.02, 0.04, 0.3, 0.57, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2fb3898fa1925e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.12, 0.41, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b257fdb7758e32e7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.72, 0.2, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d63186d23d5563ef_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.39, 0.3, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef23a1d4491e228b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.12, 0.32, 0.38, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ef130e10c11831d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.81, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71bb4a8df2bad8e1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.09, 0.28, 0.42, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75aac9f3b816f254_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1fcdc4b14eaa0e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66818731370a2051_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.13, 0.23, 0.41, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d5a1653c52517115_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd9cdb632f2e0bad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.58, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6501a694665dcf6f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.92, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4279eeddda04721_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9d62ed2209aa9ec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c99769ae8100a0e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb9713d8bc3d0c0e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.31, 0.42, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d5a1653c52517115_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.14, 0.49, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05a8da665bb02b0f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.72, 0.21, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f8bea13351143a8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.18, 0.17, 0.4, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_df5bd6909b54ff5d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_abf8dce6f012c45f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.18, 0.56, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a2f0c6ba6910e67_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.34, 0.63, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_647be39395348e66_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_beefe3844a73d87d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1723dad366370e5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.36, 0.61, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cc02c936694a0f7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.1, 0.4, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42ea6d09f218e1bc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_431c692d9be8f0f5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.71, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d3b731c286627941_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.42, 0.47, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0917fd1d6baf4d5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.19, 0.12, 0.26, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acba33ccf6514d92_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.13, 0.3, 0.38, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b64bafeedf0e88c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.2, 0.28, 0.24, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_632409c3185cb567_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.39, 0.46, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34285c36c77cc644_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.23, 0.24, 0.35, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_570c1a1607865fe2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.08, 0.33, 0.39, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7c582f4264ead8a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d68ff673e1757c1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b2ee0e5f44b2113_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.63, 0.35, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2f9851c871f2bfe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.06, 0.08, 0.36, 0.39, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7228045a18f14ee0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.66, 0.09, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_359db6e590faabb3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8235c312515dc322_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.12, 0.54, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2602f6f2b89c8790_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3016b431f6819140_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.31, 0.52, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82f2f0222b46a77c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.01, 0.58, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1869908c7bac1e26_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.32, 0.4, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4a698d027c9e812_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94a81f3e6e47c88a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f90448befd5e2a57_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3da049fb535aa3af_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdedd4ba120c2618_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.17, 0.13, 0.24, 0.21, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1087462e712666c3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd12809924068cef_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7b9161483deed3d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.14, 0.39, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c331713541c7ceb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.34, 0.46, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50c0ab549b207522_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_671810a3f325714b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b222c9d9bb067923_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.52, 0.47, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17ae4171fd51ae51_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.15, 0.27, 0.43, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6091a53f7b082b9c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.27, 0.2, 0.32, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1826ae56c5bebff1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.17, 0.21, 0.34, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74556706d448c81c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eced87fe52755f68_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.36, 0.42, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07a646fc2a50472e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.2, 0.45, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25cfc5dc339fd927_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f58cf349047fb9b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.64, 0.33, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe5b9cd54af6b4fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.09, 0.04, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb27aae97d5ac508_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c20afb325785a4b7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.41, 0.58, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb19b94b3a804659_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.86, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e2199ddbe8e08c8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_887091147a280a8a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fffb1d9acc126e80_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.58, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8842684e253552a7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.95, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f2b1cf7f32916e6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.7, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97af7ee9f4fe0bd8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.7, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e72970b78583de0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.91, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60c19fad633f2aaf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd70e813590d52b8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9a4a905d783c7dd4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.22, 0.17, 0.16, 0.16, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12e4e4b55c055ebe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0038babd7f4be7f1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.17, 0.42, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d93f62b3566bb9d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.13, 0.25, 0.5, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_210e64324e573215_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73b667d44c368691_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66339b1f067715c6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.2, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d705ff67005fa68_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e47204a711628116_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.24, 0.31, 0.21, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0ef54bae31cf35b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5657, 0.3838, 0.0505, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8c878d7f77503ab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de85922d1bcd7c97_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.26, 0.35, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_577eb75e2c07918c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.89, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_630e3bf2d340f745_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.77, 0.01, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8c73476e0422649_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.15, 0.26, 0.44, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0b7aebbb1a27297_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.67, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01359542b9c74b2d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.23, 0.75, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00e2c5936982d693_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.62, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_834286add85b715f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.17, 0.5, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2131034fd58a2752_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.25, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a61b9ca82c9c90a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c40d5c0cab4e786_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d5ce8ae4befc497_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_081f72f3e515a197_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdd8c769b0183e18_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.11, 0.36, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff2c855c7e8effb4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.11, 0.15, 0.26, 0.32, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad822f4eb69ba64a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.22, 0.2, 0.29, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f7b71f691b5279d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.2, 0.23, 0.22, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e7b8de1e33e7a9c9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.1, 0.25, 0.37, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d656dde86ddff97_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.6, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ea144bb2adeb688_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.07, 0.67, 0.23, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25520cfa3fab30e5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.13, 0.33, 0.3, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e92a6134661bb736_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.98, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5288d4302a5f595b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.81, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e76d05b93d35070_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.42, 0.36, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af6a2433e64971e8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.92, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_551c8871fc94b48c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.14, 0.51, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00e829fda703cded_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.05, 0.37, 0.34, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47c5259fddbb2592_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.04, 0.77, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1ce311eb7018fb1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.68, 0.25, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d37906e56f857b0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.16, 0.37, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e15ed57b63133507_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.1, 0.32, 0.34, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13903f14fc1bc700_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.79, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15892e0af59af9b2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.7, 0.19, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76489ff9bcaca304_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1716427b4ea8a332_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06c7d8779b053473_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29a37a92424e7424_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.22, 0.32, 0.27, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4fadc1ac03180e47_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.18, 0.38, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a17859a5966f0d1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.55, 0.42, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d05b9875c2de6f7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.45, 0.24, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_18535c3ce887857a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.32, 0.17, 0.15, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6703c953e2dffcc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d7c4bdb9734f259_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.3, 0.24, 0.25, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b02380b7f691f96e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.06, 0.08, 0.52, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8c201e02b11bfb2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.08, 0.16, 0.26, 0.36, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97af7ee9f4fe0bd8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.16, 0.2, 0.44, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95ebf11983333d6a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bec4f01cda61ae44_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_677998e4f5581771_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.07, 0.43, 0.33, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e73add9e4eb4e0a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.92, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3fdc0c1c08176f1d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.25, 0.15, 0.23, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22fab628b8bc2aca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.75, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4785d783ac3f8563_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.28, 0.21, 0.24, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0764cbf9aba1e886_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.32, 0.21, 0.17, 0.22, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_998c7deeac9307cf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_437efcb8afc69293_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.09, 0.12, 0.35, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6f219dd9f0c436f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf839974c8f9039c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.07, 0.4, 0.5, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_577eb75e2c07918c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.14, 0.26, 0.33, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1adecccc931246f9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.59, 0.33, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c96cb4d31ada8eee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f126c69cd18672d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.86, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eee726f11d9216c1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.39, 0.3, 0.15, 0.13, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d38934c5dbf445a2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb5f3a160a6e7df6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.82, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48b8be86a3d382fc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.16, 0.35, 0.37, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_195b3b28bca3f6aa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.72, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17ca8ad52877a316_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.97, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5e6246ce1a00636_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.22, 0.26, 0.35, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7673c2a66246b95_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.03, 0.08, 0.45, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff38fc13fa0f3732_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.74, 0.17, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67318a0cce639427_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.6, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e7914f96b93f3bf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.34, 0.13, 0.32, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f63a6fa728ac806_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ac1700f285ba3d9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.98, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_30526f5697674e94_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.14, 0.2, 0.32, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b04127b132fd7660_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.47, 0.36, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eab7303ea50c0db8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.17, 0.23, 0.38, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be49d2379c3f8e20_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.06, 0.41, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bff97cd0dabcc53c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.63, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fff312a964c17fb0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.92, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdd88491ead2e6be_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.48, 0.45, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd3845eab6628cdf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc321cb407314bac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c516da54818bbee2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.52, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7b4009acc69b0ed_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.76, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_886556f5f8aff22e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.25, 0.21, 0.27, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99be52ee361e747c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.63, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8edb9802c78e3c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.63, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f1c6411338cc93e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.18, 0.47, 0.28, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81d6f399208a3529_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.29, 0.47, 0.21, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a59a6563c22fd75_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.75, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4e6fc9507774b93_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.12, 0.41, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55a030a4a98da730_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.03, 0.08, 0.51, 0.33, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_330038ab18de3c19_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7461d8922e7214a7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.06, 0.53, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f24d2b215cf9ed46_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1065aae764ec8126_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.86, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad13ef1f23849c58_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.13, 0.29, 0.4, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6cdc1821d7246578_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca9fb5129f88ab4e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1f858b27796f1ed_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.86, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f779fbe0cadd6aa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.97, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2b7cb609a9e1974_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_481bd7485830d7bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.17, 0.41, 0.27, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b6e42e75c87a3c0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.16, 0.25, 0.34, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6cb886531ff8db2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.12, 0.5, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f469e638c8bf7660_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_868c3bf23f527a11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.66, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66833285e552c844_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.49, 0.46, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f068121ec7f4f7e1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.42, 0.33, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f162c74a0074ce1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.24, 0.13, 0.23, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ae8b545774e2251_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.15, 0.32, 0.29, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e9710b399beeeb7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf2259322e435e3f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.65, 0.33, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb68605efc2c57e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.29, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a25ee6c93548556_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb4b4fc3bcce0931_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.48, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ede7d6ace13cdefd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c44f50ed38299512_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.78, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf839974c8f9039c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6dc3abf3a1f4e38e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34ee090563e4867f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.24, 0.18, 0.28, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a7a5af9f572c2fd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.2, 0.24, 0.27, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e3353f5527aede7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.81, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0789cc2c61f25417_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e411c7a1f7dc1d68_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9b6b7da431529f6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98a8b2fbad46a9da_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57119c6a88e78377_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca68e3cfc071c95c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.34, 0.39, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_993b680b41c20350_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.38, 0.36, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b43a8f4e04ed2f3d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.91, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2da40a06387f7329_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.52, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfc3f3a0b1e6c8c9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.51, 0.44, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8edfa71852a3aee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.67, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f2560ef2994428f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.08, 0.01, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb956f638039d6cd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.72, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_375cf576e7c776e9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7245f9cd31a3686c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_063fbb064db7fac9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb821e36fe7b3c7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_726ed6ebea64b7e7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f221e7505dfd0d11_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59dc00bd34a22b76_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.15, 0.26, 0.34, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4fb63829dd83c43_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c62d3d2ecc2590fd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81664d7c757f20bd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.11, 0.14, 0.21, 0.3, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_266a29d48bdfac69_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3799b1ed2bf34b57_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.12, 0.12, 0.22, 0.3, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_745d69e754e337b0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0202, 0.0505, 0.1111, 0.4646, 0.3434, 0.0101], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fc4f6ab949defd7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.12, 0.21, 0.26, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2f3ea8003e9bc5c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.17, 0.1, 0.21, 0.27, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf470dfa4f035fd5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c357efaaa7ce4472_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0101, 0.0404, 0.3131, 0.5657, 0.0707, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_64a63814dafcbb44_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.75, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26950359f5f105ba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.12, 0.65, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad7dda65f6a7e898_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.19, 0.16, 0.34, 0.18, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1dad20b866b4b3c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8235c312515dc322_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.12, 0.43, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e00642258a31152_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e550a6f718e9d071_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86af05bf58981268_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.17, 0.18, 0.28, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86dcffde18768f92_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.81, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fbcf9150d4f7890_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_18822a5cdee890d8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.14, 0.32, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_647be39395348e66_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.52, 0.16, 0.01, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48206536b070e71c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b5fe1c2c99295a6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a320a34ba263c809_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.16, 0.3, 0.42, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf6c9078916297bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.19, 0.23, 0.33, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb9571ada44676bb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28aa159d52c85e88_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.09, 0.35, 0.38, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_644d65a103cfbec0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c69465c5bc21ca80_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.12, 0.22, 0.33, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ee4741f596d4f8a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.13, 0.49, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd6f1df632da044e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf2259322e435e3f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a26b10153a77fac0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.11, 0.24, 0.38, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ceff4ea4c60301a4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.02, 0.07, 0.34, 0.5, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8bb0c3ea6e024e63_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3124efb71d486f6d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9ef23194f00e379_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b196f4907455911_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.13, 0.63, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da058bc14bf616db_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce84cdb5d95c6f1b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.39, 0.54, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d328c9d7076cf530_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.83, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06f2955c3a0f313e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9749dfb36ac1b233_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.34, 0.5, 0.15], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f8f63521a68bc61_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.65, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5515def22a05b87_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.72, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a87251d367dcf63_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.2, 0.11, 0.23, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44e93877a30cdb6d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0da9b4b81b5b270_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.43, 0.26, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66cc0191e6ed55da_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.86, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7906366c8a8183ea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.96, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15feb331a9a6404d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36b19b21ceffb5f6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e83a6ca1d3453c66_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.31, 0.17, 0.18, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_999d550e4ea76be6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.21, 0.27, 0.29, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33fe919b8dd847c4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.09, 0.27, 0.44, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7a4c1a5819589e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.32, 0.61, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_271df68c34c8472f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.5, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcdf5217c7b86a11_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.22, 0.08, 0.32, 0.15, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f91ef21d6968f82b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.08, 0.39, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_243d1666fe40b9e6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.53, 0.38, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99143c50846a5ec7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6da0acb085f16f9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e10ac529349da849_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.23, 0.22, 0.24, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50cc3d80ae4e40da_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.14, 0.12, 0.28, 0.26, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6a42d2d9cae7081_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.13, 0.37, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0990702cf66f5de_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24aaf87ea09ec7fc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.32, 0.28, 0.13, 0.18, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_20726cfb6746006c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.2, 0.48, 0.3], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8e56a3857dce606_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f7944dd1948a814_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ceabc4fc12044813_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.74, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3801056d6ff6712b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.64, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79dd719541484445_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.09, 0.24, 0.5, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd12809924068cef_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.09, 0.42, 0.25, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24232c89272d219c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.78, 0.2, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_accff5af23f86f4b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25812ef76d2e90db_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.3, 0.25, 0.19, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_359db6e590faabb3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.18, 0.1, 0.28, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d45aa02f84ceccef_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.47, 0.42, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a159f9c61d314e8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fb3138d76999487_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_872b3c32fa497836_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.27, 0.24, 0.23, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_baa07f246f7db63e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4a596b27dcdde16_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.59, 0.35, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8e7632ba7a9c7d2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.06, 0.14, 0.55, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d60e5df51153323a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.07, 0.1, 0.51, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af2ca37f7ea3c954_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.2, 0.48, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36f35842f7e0fb82_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f66febcfdf1366e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f9796147ed4297a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.38, 0.59, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_490700376b666127_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5e89b3cb8ffc155_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.76, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ce86aeb5ed42794_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.44, 0.41, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cbfbc20a11984572_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.21, 0.24, 0.28, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_510a492a02b47497_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.72, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23ffcac1cce6ec33_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.28, 0.13, 0.31, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da8f2e680adadd55_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.13, 0.17, 0.31, 0.25, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d1bde9b9584ee08_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.24, 0.7, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fc2a38b8ea4155d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.85, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa3f82b542f589fe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.74, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5fc00cae355aad9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.09, 0.84, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_183523c966791840_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa2b9955c4948032_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8e7632ba7a9c7d2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29fc28bb27ec59dd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8fb1019e724cf87f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.79, 0.2, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad7169e4eba1fcee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.25, 0.55, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7673c2a66246b95_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.03, 0.57, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_710eb4437590fbc1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.56, 0.29, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e83a6ca1d3453c66_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.9, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cec09d9ee4da8db5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d88421419165887_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.22, 0.33, 0.27, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b37e3c498aa80ab5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.25, 0.34, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8ad80b044104f2b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.2, 0.39, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9fbf246bf10ecff_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.75, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb821e36fe7b3c7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.94, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_738d61efddc39aa2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.14, 0.11, 0.26, 0.27, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7813c4d76c9d3a6f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.24, 0.68, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd8edfc073ac3341_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.74, 0.15, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93bffbe4515123b2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.37, 0.09, 0.3, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25ced7ee33b0f9dc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2fca18dffa8cb61_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.33, 0.41, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85973da56f484e17_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.79, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d21c8557969ce66_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cdefb510cfad6af_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.07, 0.01, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6215b1706b5704c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.06, 0.33, 0.52, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_237da6cb2d572d95_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34855173921f9e59_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.43, 0.21, 0.18, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f69c4384d940c19_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.11, 0.54, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6fc1300457bd0dc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.09, 0.34, 0.45, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8bee8210f240de1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8fb173b83ec3336_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43a888ec41447ae5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.87, 0.03, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_085ba6f426efe4d3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.19, 0.46, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c65bab6c9016d254_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.13, 0.46, 0.36, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_333ea078203307a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0faae41ca5484655_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.06, 0.39, 0.49, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e00642258a31152_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.15, 0.1, 0.43, 0.19, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97057f8bf7268362_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0101, 0.9394, 0.0505], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b70384fdeb34120_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c05ea3e601fb24df_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.15, 0.39, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c809855125cc15a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.18, 0.24, 0.33, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9021178d58805a70_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.05, 0.01, 0.17], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_721d94bff0eb74f4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ed7caff225e44c76_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5f3104fc5a329c1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.85, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_712e44acd5e64c57_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.25, 0.13, 0.27, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5ce52a7d70fe7cd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.29, 0.21, 0.28, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_27f9e92b3495ac11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.92, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d67900bbe1a5dfb1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.28, 0.65, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb09cc00d7749f2d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.73, 0.26, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d3d05628c9f54b9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.19, 0.25, 0.33, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90b982d080481a5e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.88, 0.06, 0.0, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26aff861307a2ff5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.07, 0.11, 0.41, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f376729b016cd0b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.69, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f33ac4479fbf7c86_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79b36a2462e33cc7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_964c82945fed01ae_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.07, 0.21, 0.56, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb276511e4b3a28f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.19, 0.23, 0.32, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58fa6ff32d1b15ea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.65, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_904a63b188e48e8d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.22, 0.69, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e2dcfa5e9d4c813_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.0, 0.1, 0.81, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c40d5c0cab4e786_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.15, 0.3, 0.35, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ac1ad0e0ac77f65_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cb246a0957e28a7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.18, 0.42, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d0988db92efb5d1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.13, 0.29, 0.42, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_868d306babf637ea_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63ae634682986406_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.21, 0.23, 0.25, 0.13, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55cdc36f5ecbe44e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_109db888eb447d6b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.76, 0.06, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0772cc6cf82fb59_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.17, 0.53, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5766cd4433f628fc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.25, 0.11, 0.33, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a18b4e38d544d04_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd3ee92f3059e5f7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d67900bbe1a5dfb1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43261ed2894b1d49_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.59, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29725a4f7edb45e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.92, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e9dc32ae2ac98f9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.91, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d0988db92efb5d1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.97, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_19a41545024064ff_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.13, 0.42, 0.29, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_348ec7f945569dfc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.8, 0.14], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50f14e09534bc297_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.06, 0.22, 0.54, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25ced7ee33b0f9dc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.04, 0.23, 0.56, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a30f1abaf564706d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_010d3cdb6e33b340_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1037b0b0349e014_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.34, 0.21, 0.16, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5fe741c97ae95422_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.28, 0.69, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d159ba4964323329_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d24566099b99dcc0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.51, 0.37, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_772bc2735d3fe0e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.41, 0.44, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_120ac157060b1f82_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.24, 0.22, 0.3, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f7cb434924533d5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.17, 0.28, 0.3, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_155e1d3f8d654924_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.16, 0.16, 0.34, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91c32bd058ca7b71_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.34, 0.11, 0.27, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66d82516df1f215d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.3, 0.26, 0.23, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_028c3814ad3113e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.27, 0.46, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6e0edb772b66af27_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.28, 0.41, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3c6f62d9b325559f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.03, 0.21, 0.65, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_09cf3eeb271ff65d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.13, 0.36, 0.38, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06dc600ccc591143_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.11, 0.43, 0.42, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f90a3a7483f8d00f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.14, 0.14, 0.29, 0.29, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ee3e548d3dfd5b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24a759a3c29882ce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1aefc29bf44fc10e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.08, 0.11, 0.41, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d58f03f0d6e01ce2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.49, 0.51, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85d0c8849a9197d4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.24, 0.21, 0.32, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b1a179d4d64d8ec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.09, 0.01, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_051df887f5488d6d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.18, 0.48, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c97fc0e429d6b8d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.22, 0.32, 0.25, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06d9a62c09359f5f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.75, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb0f04d6cb021321_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.07, 0.93, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf412ae6628d2989_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.1, 0.31, 0.4, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_840508fe083ddb01_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f661ac3e2aca0ed_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.1, 0.89, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_098dd74c92517ce7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d58f218228404af1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.32, 0.17, 0.2, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86af05bf58981268_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.85, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a53a4ab1fc3944be_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.58, 0.03, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d262f90ea672039_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95ebf11983333d6a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.08, 0.51, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d1b129a9ececae5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc1918048abf8a61_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.28, 0.36, 0.32, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fc23331e6ea00919_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.14, 0.66, 0.16], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_afbf025f3785dacb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.17, 0.42, 0.34, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d5aecbbbfc48753_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.85, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88afbc50d21b003e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.29, 0.08, 0.3, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac936dfec986746e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.18, 0.19, 0.32, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22c877d8e2fb8c7a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.17, 0.3, 0.19, 0.09, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_606b9a691f176b3e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.26, 0.18, 0.25, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8569afc62e08276a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.6, 0.19, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_375cf576e7c776e9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.18, 0.15, 0.32, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fee2f509f2634a6d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.56, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00f47dac6d9b44d5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.31, 0.15, 0.16, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57975f21aa1b6fb5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.04, 0.26, 0.48, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee7eddd9fc79aa87_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.2, 0.57, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6dfbe5148c4d89fe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.35, 0.39, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e64db7048c803631_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.14, 0.32, 0.39, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_69289eab656961b0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.59, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9030fd014f651fb2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.47, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5a2f976d93ad1a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.86, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7427e22bba99f6e3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26d9b614548b9019_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.06, 0.06, 0.42, 0.36, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db4c4a73a440e5ab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.1, 0.48, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c2fc7fe6f328017_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.61, 0.25, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_388faceb88fc122a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.18, 0.48, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03bc0d553aa33b95_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0809aef0ded86f2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a81285917fe7d23_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fb3d9413901b46b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.16, 0.16, 0.31, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b948e2f6a8e00f71_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.45, 0.45, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c23a5a94e680598c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a1e47e7f12a6b56_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.64, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_809f06afb9ed27fe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.13, 0.49, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6f192c347301ba6a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.19, 0.31, 0.25, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42bd318a5d3e9edc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d15e00a8fcf5ca33_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a42026caca16025_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.19, 0.09, 0.42, 0.21, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7fe201076c90ded9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1037b0b0349e014_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.87, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37c0b47b53758b18_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.17, 0.23, 0.33, 0.18, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73b667d44c368691_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.12, 0.19, 0.29, 0.29, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_206a681a98c3d7b3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.16, 0.24, 0.3, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7b9161483deed3d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_392174c204e0b2ed_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.71, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0febfe30f4f537c8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.05, 0.3, 0.53, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2273ae6d05637af1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.13, 0.38, 0.3, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b02544d83355d80_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.29, 0.31, 0.25, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cd88fdc49a249d6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.58, 0.29, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41bdb26f9b530ad8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.23, 0.3, 0.3, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ce8fabb7a83db6e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.49, 0.47, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a5f2b25c6fc0a41_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0984569104b23a45_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.96, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4bdc13370035f6ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.43, 0.4, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c8aaf810641d5ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.09, 0.4, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15e676a1899a10da_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b1a9035cd5e97bfb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a33371bd5d50a4dd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.99, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f9d22bbfc663ad2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.46, 0.31, 0.11, 0.1, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_647be39395348e66_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.4, 0.19, 0.11, 0.23, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_21c543b7b69598a1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.13, 0.26, 0.46, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_967eba7051edcbe8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_afdd086ed73405e5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.11, 0.55, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2869cf8c3b48d5bb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.61, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35804a677ab5c8de_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e72a9f110cb9344_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.91, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_efac05bb197b1ac8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.11, 0.37, 0.36, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdd88491ead2e6be_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.17, 0.46, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_750d507f2dc9dbfb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.12, 0.12, 0.3, 0.3, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c96cb4d31ada8eee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.07, 0.14, 0.33, 0.36, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af146c450c7311eb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b231790ccfaf542e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.34, 0.29, 0.18, 0.14, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16b77f4c64957668_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71bbd91e370f9841_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.16, 0.46, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cec09d9ee4da8db5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.24, 0.06, 0.31, 0.17, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcd54cd0949515bd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1636eee4b688c47b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.14, 0.22, 0.42, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e24373876ea934b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e92c0c7209f93271_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.31, 0.16, 0.19, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0b510700ccfa95_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.39, 0.01, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_218dd03f73e68be1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.39, 0.44, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b7ed55fbab9f494_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.93, 0.07, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b6fd0e38b070565_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_462cd72b15af52d6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.16, 0.44, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be470f70591b4e83_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.19, 0.51, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e3da9c6b163ad83_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.87, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a65650e1d6e4309f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.14, 0.32, 0.27, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_672e4828880fcdb2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.11, 0.38, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8761c8bc4b9a523_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_834bc0af8c72b28c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.44, 0.55, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b3f21f7abeae9fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.52, 0.13, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a74d2da620b13633_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.01, 0.85, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_431c692d9be8f0f5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c3a25895f2913ba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.21, 0.7, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d26a129709561014_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.13, 0.23, 0.42, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d62960fa8e49c09_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_170391cd941a5594_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.77, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58fa6ff32d1b15ea_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa5b601e2ab2379b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.17, 0.11, 0.35, 0.23, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_013644cde61732c3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.13, 0.38, 0.35, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c69bf85871288af2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.78, 0.18, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7279d10e97ee629f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c7284993ccee78f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fb7506d54b39918_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.24, 0.43, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c015f62bcac28445_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2dce35eaf99ff72_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c408e88c7b5cd5b3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99ed03fa649c5c99_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_990872f1b07b317a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.28, 0.33, 0.25, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4e444ddbaeb07bb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.64, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51e92ac653245ed0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a3d88cd12c11dc2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.17, 0.16, 0.3, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23b32508e247ad7e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9021178d58805a70_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_832746248178573b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8ba75ea1a4c1af2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.3, 0.15, 0.3, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91ba8cf2066423b4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.19, 0.13, 0.32, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca9fb5129f88ab4e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.23, 0.19, 0.31, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5097b471cd65c307_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.68, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38afb067b9ab2dcb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28aa159d52c85e88_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5c8038d0438afde_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5a53945828c6240_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.25, 0.24, 0.49, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5a7263d073f96d3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.04, 0.36, 0.49, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81e6d7b9fa7edb80_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.27, 0.17, 0.26, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c8aaf810641d5ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.72, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd863e4a3013af11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.25, 0.67, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a149eb16a5011205_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ed5e7e40e7b7617_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76604ba5364e7e1a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.98, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cf805cc059881e1c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.85, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f5bc2a1a31faf84_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.98, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0ede698a97c829c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.33, 0.56, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9022dc160bb7d83_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.25, 0.45, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8348a42ecc9ba7ea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.94, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e550a6f718e9d071_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.61, 0.0, 0.2], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b4a0cef64c63a2c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.24, 0.17, 0.23, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c1b29d7d28ec120_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.7, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98ac9171771b85c4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_49ec3a85fe6b0301_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.18, 0.55, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_adc2d31d4ca2e30c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b770fb1df3346424_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.15, 0.37, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a5aabf044b31077_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.29, 0.34, 0.23, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c011ca72960c698d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.5, 0.48, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_779ac60699d0048c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.09, 0.25, 0.46, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9202fb4e61a35ead_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.51, 0.47, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04977a2fa2c5d790_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1111, 0.5657, 0.2525, 0.0707], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d32a7091498464b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.11, 0.55, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe1a2056819f757d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.17, 0.19, 0.35, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98a8b2fbad46a9da_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.27, 0.16, 0.17, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79f0768a129efce3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.77, 0.0, 0.19], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2ac4041b44d64d8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_071fd11ab2ee02e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9f2bd6588d2de61_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0eb04e55399c6b45_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.14, 0.18, 0.29, 0.24, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c7284993ccee78f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.18, 0.37, 0.24, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b88892dd0f54f457_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.17, 0.39, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9fdd19878799a83_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13ee8acff45ea3e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6e4fcd30dbc7a32_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.92, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_218dd03f73e68be1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60fcfd5e79ef8bc3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.4, 0.34, 0.1, 0.11, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0962b4d66a919133_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.25, 0.19, 0.33, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c971df91191c863_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.41, 0.48, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e10abef76b1c169_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.23, 0.37, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_138ab2ab53b62934_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e550a6f718e9d071_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.27, 0.15, 0.24, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_451c59a5714b7fe6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2258f19bf70d3668_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5766cd4433f628fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.36, 0.55, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ed11d840dbb3d5e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51955409a3157abd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbc81b6f62b6773c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5dc7c22423c824f5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66d82516df1f215d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.63, 0.35, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e3e5cd68e303a9f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74556706d448c81c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.28, 0.16, 0.23, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b651bbebc0242ea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.56, 0.44, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8fa1aeccd3b3acfe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.16, 0.13, 0.37, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e23ce61b57a9bd8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.26, 0.18, 0.21, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f24d2b215cf9ed46_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.81, 0.17, 0.0, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4fb63829dd83c43_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.88, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cd20dccc26cacd7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.24, 0.45, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ae04c8e66e5866e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.17, 0.77, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8da0c9bd0322029c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_757b077b2d684671_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.89, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f570edc83a356db_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.04, 0.09, 0.49, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50f14e09534bc297_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.73, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_708ac42f7c493f5f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b0a354748ae495b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.65, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ede3c663774630ee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8373d976e2113f16_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.2, 0.49, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a877f825921ef75_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.14, 0.19, 0.35, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97577fe446558827_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.2, 0.44, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_efac05bb197b1ac8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdd9e0ab3dfd4bd5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.11, 0.29, 0.42, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4a698d027c9e812_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.16, 0.18, 0.32, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f7b71f691b5279d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fe934cb107fb962_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.74, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d21c8557969ce66_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.18, 0.12, 0.31, 0.24, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e341e07e49ba864_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.55, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6aee478ce0f12387_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.33, 0.12, 0.34, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1be232b70785f6b4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.17, 0.18, 0.32, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a29002c3487238c2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a65650e1d6e4309f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.9, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48ac3b7d8d0df0e2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d6f84bce5ef5fdb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.51, 0.35, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7279d10e97ee629f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.13, 0.51, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3594f3dfbffd172b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f70b73742830b65_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.32, 0.22, 0.17, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2afda46ea41a797_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.58, 0.41, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4e21bd1ee0c6300_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1828839efcae0c15_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.6, 0.07, 0.0, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b16518111d5ffd62_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.22, 0.56, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0c374b8ac32db8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.26, 0.2, 0.23, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a05e0990ecd024f8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.39, 0.5, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6e7bb1302337d0a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.29, 0.49, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35d7bd13fcd7e653_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13f130c4519ed045_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.24, 0.58, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa2b9955c4948032_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.2, 0.62, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fee95131dfd839a7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc8ef14cb795ff50_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f65cfb125610191d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.33, 0.35, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9266ff2d935c5d88_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.12, 0.2, 0.41, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c23a5a94e680598c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.88, 0.05, 0.01, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_929a40e0aad021e5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.71, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d206d67ec4ce32b3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.54, 0.33, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_407665d089e970a6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.08, 0.26, 0.47, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63a253fef7750195_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.21, 0.2, 0.43, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6926092d0fbf42ab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.84, 0.11, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24177e50dd7cb056_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.56, 0.42, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_051df887f5488d6d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d01f1f5496521e70_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.12, 0.3, 0.3, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8812ea149eac7c7a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.76, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c4a177905d24ebb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a647df04db78896_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.24, 0.21, 0.34, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a9f2efb5264c986_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.21, 0.4, 0.29, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c767cbb8250671f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.74, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1dc2fc50956dbcb0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.31, 0.45, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_169dcad569e531d0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.41, 0.53, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e329915b09739765_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.51, 0.32, 0.1, 0.05, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29cf5b4200a5b029_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.12, 0.37, 0.35, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e9e700c0878aa85_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e16609b9dc59cc0b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.65, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_02f9dc9cd3ffd199_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c08db6a38d6caa1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.18, 0.35, 0.26, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fffb1d9acc126e80_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fe934cb107fb962_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.23, 0.21, 0.29, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbafe9cee4b97883_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c7eeb2a72736325_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.73, 0.14], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55367e5546ead065_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.62, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eed02623a2bd312a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.07, 0.12, 0.48, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9a547fc2aeaa159_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.53, 0.06, 0.01, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4cfbb0d8365e7df7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb230fe65670a237_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.23, 0.21, 0.27, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_071fd11ab2ee02e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.22, 0.26, 0.22, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4904f57ab8867450_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.12, 0.4, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_483ef1c44d148f92_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.2, 0.5, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0fa646b90bd46d4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.05, 0.18, 0.6, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f861f40b286ff8df_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_705bbb659b81c168_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.101, 0.1414, 0.1414, 0.4646, 0.1414, 0.0101], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b7ed55fbab9f494_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.23, 0.05, 0.29, 0.11, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6dc3abf3a1f4e38e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.15, 0.72, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d21c8557969ce66_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.64, 0.2, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eced87fe52755f68_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd7f9579c876e1f1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.89, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_069a4c36fd6c02e4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.42, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_70ff45fca556b5ce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.7, 0.01, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c40aa3626914f58_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.99, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4e444ddbaeb07bb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97e1419b394b1860_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.96, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_411aa2e45fc2323e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.85, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_213352bafaa253c6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.21, 0.34, 0.34, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ac1ad0e0ac77f65_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.17, 0.38, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9149d19f41a1c9b6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.73, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a954048c2edaf33_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.03, 0.08, 0.29, 0.52, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36874861878759b1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.76, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1f7e52e6cd3b1f3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.11, 0.62, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_add587d996be287d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.18, 0.11, 0.37, 0.19, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be4af305a288780c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.73, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6663ac2be04cdeb5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.38, 0.46, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55245d5afc872260_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.1, 0.12, 0.2, 0.39, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34450c5d1aa51530_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.32, 0.59, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57975f21aa1b6fb5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.55, 0.25, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9a83d267e9a0cda_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0101, 0.0, 0.0101, 0.2626, 0.6869, 0.0303], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_092a6c735fc736c7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.79, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb399652de64f057_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.97, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_031d13a1117d8289_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.11, 0.16, 0.36, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d262f90ea672039_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.09, 0.32, 0.45, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b8aa6724ddf23cc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.16, 0.19, 0.33, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e84f3f02ac29f265_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.92, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6f987b9c3a42a21a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.09, 0.36, 0.34, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0eecbd3950f1ab0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.21, 0.68, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74c58ac5e0beda89_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.22, 0.24, 0.37, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cf122332f4d63841_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.88, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_49ec3a85fe6b0301_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.51, 0.47, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3da049fb535aa3af_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.32, 0.11, 0.28, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e35b4da83ea39048_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.13, 0.57, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5dfc6cee1d9452bb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.92, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_20efb5cacfafb13e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.09, 0.35, 0.42, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddd831a893d2e23c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.58, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36f35842f7e0fb82_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.43, 0.32, 0.12, 0.09, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88cf29c8724ae6c8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.11, 0.02, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a159f9c61d314e8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.88, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00832a8ce8346485_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dde850bd3c77f693_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75bb66e74294fd50_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.89, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3016b431f6819140_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.24, 0.66, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cd88fdc49a249d6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.1, 0.41, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bcf0c1173e7f629_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.32, 0.2, 0.1, 0.03, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbeb5ac6cf6923e6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b5469c2037a5fa6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9195cdeb2654a74a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3dac17087b62c30b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.18, 0.45, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_56d8cda897102347_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.68, 0.3, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_830207b316a5e1da_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.11, 0.1, 0.26, 0.35, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62f2f9bbbc02c773_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.27, 0.23, 0.24, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a01be49c4097605e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.37, 0.13, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe1be61e778ff96d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d97e81d5a5dc416_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.28, 0.17, 0.21, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91015fd03ffa49c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.7, 0.23, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_21571b7c9ee6cc05_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6adf022288e1f02_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0505, 0.8081, 0.1313, 0.0101], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a57b49d3ea5c0a9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91e81fe5d43da630_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.89, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f21bd542a7bb111_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.9, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d58f03f0d6e01ce2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7039eab9a56d4ffd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.31, 0.25, 0.24, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d237f578bcda0367_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.11, 0.29, 0.36, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2d1ab204549e21b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.07, 0.38, 0.44, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc321cb407314bac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.38, 0.34, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cac92197a93f0db0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.19, 0.23, 0.45, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8b4ee410b7a42a0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.08, 0.43, 0.41, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6adf022288e1f02_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e67b55837a18283_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a29002c3487238c2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.71, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_11a4bd3f36577898_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.29, 0.21, 0.18, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd53a10ae618f056_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.25, 0.22, 0.23, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73b667d44c368691_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.02, 0.86, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22eae71e74ff57bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.18, 0.11, 0.26, 0.28, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a320a34ba263c809_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.49, 0.5, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cd88fdc49a249d6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fab9abdff41fda0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.75, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ce15a476295225b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0767e27f7e5b1996_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3799b1ed2bf34b57_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.65, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bda21359290391ca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.2, 0.19, 0.28, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fa61469f7617a28_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.25, 0.32, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28b3b22ebd871f96_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.46, 0.48, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_570c1a1607865fe2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_332be9c0f5819bb8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6592eb1031e60ec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a33371bd5d50a4dd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cfd8e25a2a026d8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.46, 0.34, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e92cf01964dc8ff9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.24, 0.29, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d379257433b00be_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.13, 0.35, 0.34, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_662585bd27b95916_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.07, 0.29, 0.51, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c395e9ed6cf91bc2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_887cb52f678aab76_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.38, 0.61, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_128128f05aac6f39_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_387990be11db3d42_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.83, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e3da9c6b163ad83_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a25b65b2a89c6cde_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_998c7deeac9307cf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.28, 0.43, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fab9abdff41fda0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.31, 0.45, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec49a4ccab7ddab6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_284de8520ed4ec6f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.59, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ec271bc7d5ec161_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.56, 0.43, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4d070d618fddbba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b9d907251f56127_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cdb503690c0ea3d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd69484dd4d07a25_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60fcfd5e79ef8bc3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.62, 0.33, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_305aca5edd04dd34_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.35, 0.36, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39a2d07a151cf440_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.34, 0.01, 0.4], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc3f5bb784567fa4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.9, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ee64d2643646ef9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3334bf015a22a916_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6bdc4dc8011b2a2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bce008d9a1fa9a0f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.31, 0.2, 0.15, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcdf5217c7b86a11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.92, 0.07, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36ffdf052f8abc3f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cda67e2772e9b5db_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.13, 0.4, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_578a61b8f18ca488_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.08, 0.31, 0.49, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92b0a7da695164dc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2b7cb609a9e1974_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.44, 0.46, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1e23f8bcfd8bcf6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.18, 0.32, 0.29, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82e7af2431a0c8d6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f7b71f691b5279d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.89, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91ef90433b3af278_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.17, 0.35, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f455f647631f74ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9fdd19878799a83_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.63, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ea2ba5752c9e250_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.42, 0.41, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84fa9827c290a70a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.71, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_080b7948b739f609_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.14, 0.26, 0.44, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fa6333add4cbb23_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.11, 0.41, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_834bc0af8c72b28c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.1, 0.18, 0.45, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1b4814ba8898334_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.41, 0.49, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f467702fae1e0e6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.21, 0.41, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_993b9f22d533b2e1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b88892dd0f54f457_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.31, 0.65, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5933560d9a5e10d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.19, 0.11, 0.28, 0.17, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5df5203d45caa3b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_466d4a6b8552a504_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.19, 0.54, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d492104989ff4ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.16, 0.34, 0.28, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ae38229b29a077d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.21, 0.22, 0.34, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0e1d17a845b445f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.97, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6e9c4c1c298e22a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.29, 0.69, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2114999d7e453a7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.13, 0.26, 0.32, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fac9bd190b65a98d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.32, 0.14, 0.22, 0.08, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c73913d9a9c7eac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.08, 0.91, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1801c25e22bb84c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.45, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2869cf8c3b48d5bb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.16, 0.24, 0.34, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3a0f84d3a5775e2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.95, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31481b7b9b951098_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.12, 0.25, 0.43, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_825829be41736429_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.99, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1181232e4f1311b4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.07, 0.54, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c65bab6c9016d254_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_062acd516f9a4475_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad63178494777b24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.58, 0.36, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39d7c04320864fe7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.12, 0.75, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba5f1be369874261_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.18, 0.1, 0.37, 0.18, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3cb4ace4a55d2bf3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.83, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3b6baede3a776de_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4279eeddda04721_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.82, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd3718eaaa282606_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.94, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d1e933fcf40b8bb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.1, 0.56, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78ad06466c3a2bb1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.47, 0.51, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46003bdf92974e8b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81d4ee14ec8f2db0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_825829be41736429_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35d7bd13fcd7e653_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.77, 0.01, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7267bce22f7fcad7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.45, 0.28, 0.15, 0.09, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58deb5b8abd49332_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea6c4efe5daa3782_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.22, 0.49, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a50eab695eecc98f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d33ee7c9a36ccf6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.71, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea6c4efe5daa3782_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.22, 0.41, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eef83e366ac69e51_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.97, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d2edc0a8c9bd23c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.68, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60b594edb64e4c10_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.49, 0.38, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_922435ff689e8d08_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.1, 0.1, 0.39, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97562d96f489c102_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aaef30c1ff9bbd68_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.67, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d4b7141921c13d8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_248d55177f99c1ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.2, 0.37, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0ecfe60df0a8a93_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef4823036a267f61_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.25, 0.5, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2eba685187fb9b68_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.82, 0.0, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b763f454ee1d28a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.91, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c16dea76af200f7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9006bd5a380416bc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b4037abe537b2f0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.22, 0.18, 0.33, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ccbe5f87fc08fd86_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.12, 0.19, 0.33, 0.28, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47c5259fddbb2592_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.13, 0.45, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_138d837d02b37da9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.78, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95d0d0ef38a89d6c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d32a7091498464b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f376729b016cd0b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.15, 0.53, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b00cfeb687d329d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.21, 0.17, 0.29, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9749dfb36ac1b233_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.16, 0.35, 0.37, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3604ab4d3de0fa4f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.14, 0.72, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50777ead0d68bb9f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d620ca1e61957da5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.1, 0.33, 0.42, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2edd4efe2593f32_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.31, 0.42, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e64015fc9f4c3f57_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.17, 0.36, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b387976fef2e97c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.82, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e7ec9f50c5eb6ca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4bac033b82dfa12a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.12, 0.43, 0.38, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1352acaed0d38172_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.32, 0.62, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2fb3898fa1925e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.61, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c112cdcd04f5d6d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.19, 0.18, 0.31, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2acdfd3a4cea427_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.1, 0.48, 0.34, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad63178494777b24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.11, 0.38, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cced490efc6fe3a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76604ba5364e7e1a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.04, 0.03, 0.4, 0.45, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e95e349d766602fd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.17, 0.46, 0.19, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db36d10ce08f1d1a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.59, 0.01, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c10ad26d97189c24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_32dabb9b6c73f99d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d3b731c286627941_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36874861878759b1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16ad96277f64d94d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ee64d2643646ef9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.14, 0.46, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de0aefa088426aba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.07, 0.1, 0.3, 0.41, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_21c543b7b69598a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47f1acd41283641c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5383239cceeccd8d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.78, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a18b4e38d544d04_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.38, 0.29, 0.15, 0.12, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5823c57ca95beff3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.79, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd9c2cbe638886e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.14, 0.49, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9aea6dc6227d252a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03a58bf9e53fca6e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b4a0cef64c63a2c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.71, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b052cd013384b08_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddb1b3d931684256_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.08, 0.16, 0.41, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cb5a47944f5fbad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.18, 0.22, 0.3, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d219a1989507e102_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.71, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d76bad73f6f60aa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a7ed4755fa87d4b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.94, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79cdeb281651daaf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.23, 0.49, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d919600975474a2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a18b7a9be96fdfdc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dad748ce9155182_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5556, 0.404, 0.0202, 0.0202], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c9365105dac9b6f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e9cf306e2014572_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_19a601ed7e711266_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe8d92be547e687a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.41, 0.03, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44c7d434cc7fb02a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.23, 0.28, 0.3, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fc4fe46f2def680_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.16, 0.79, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fb8f5ee1762d55e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0baf7d5a58cff96_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.2, 0.28, 0.32, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d82877faebce2aff_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.09, 0.11, 0.5, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_882937067cd19159_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.51, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26d35f66060ac180_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.11, 0.15, 0.34, 0.26, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3d28a519d6bd873_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.12, 0.0, 0.21], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01b8a3f50a865bf2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f24d2b215cf9ed46_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.31, 0.15, 0.33, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d7eb78adb9010878_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.71, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2942dacba6af6e7c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_028c3814ad3113e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.21, 0.39, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0606f145296ccbac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_605b5cb348177aca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.17, 0.2, 0.35, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a1577e2ca538cdc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.06, 0.01, 0.76], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e2e797831fab52da_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.91, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d5aecbbbfc48753_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d3b437f57053940_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c01d61552a32299_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.13, 0.2, 0.29, 0.21, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9a0c1ec32c3bc774_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.15, 0.34, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_924e40e9bec049ac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.34, 0.15, 0.23, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eac67514a04a14af_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.34, 0.51, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03061856f9a3a150_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.7, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c55b4a1f2e7e8cac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.89, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae6bbe7238f9bc38_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.93, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe72b0e51ee9ada7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.16, 0.3, 0.31, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e63d166ee9054b01_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f91ef21d6968f82b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.66, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_32ea96fc0d69e206_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.87, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8a8d8d45e57243a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0707, 0.1313, 0.1717, 0.404, 0.202, 0.0202], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f3937f23b5b0920_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.26, 0.61, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e411c7a1f7dc1d68_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.2, 0.51, 0.18, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_27ef4cb7a1d58f8e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.55, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38594950802a2aaa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d624f7b8c152001_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22a194bdf0ec4876_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.17, 0.36, 0.35, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddd1ece04ede7e0c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.12, 0.28, 0.43, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8080ded628bf2b8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.46, 0.03, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e9710b399beeeb7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.26, 0.18, 0.3, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ef48e2ddc30b98c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_668b244710dd206f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b8f51bea835bab7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d76bad73f6f60aa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.45, 0.24, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d32835cec8826855_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.22, 0.45, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d1b129a9ececae5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.13, 0.04, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7228045a18f14ee0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6fdf7e51ec62d0c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.2, 0.24, 0.47, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_209d0867cc371fd0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.07, 0.46, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f44bf7278dce2b4d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.9, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4594ebe9afc46ab0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_08c88ec564dccf6f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.23, 0.13, 0.36, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0e51e7bb3f330b6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bff97cd0dabcc53c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_52fefc32b62e11fe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.17, 0.22, 0.2, 0.18, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_035931080431b392_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.11, 0.32, 0.36, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_849b1cd0463556d3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.51, 0.47, 0.0, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf3366b0a61b6da8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.66, 0.3, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01b8a3f50a865bf2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.21, 0.54, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58a1cfd7acaaeec2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.12, 0.15, 0.23, 0.25, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_affa7c28e10845e1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.43, 0.5, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f3937f23b5b0920_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.14, 0.6, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a5f2b25c6fc0a41_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.98, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1734d23384c5bd7c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34285c36c77cc644_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93dabed265c122f1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.12, 0.21, 0.49, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10774b0ce08b75d9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.19, 0.2, 0.39, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ebefe032dc3af51_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.33, 0.27, 0.22, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ea7f159b941afe3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.18, 0.15, 0.22, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a20b1d6add59c9fe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.45, 0.29, 0.03, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_df08aa5b203c3f97_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.57, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbafe9cee4b97883_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.31, 0.04, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2378b5e8dc98972a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.19, 0.24, 0.37, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91199c6bc9048392_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9ded394acdd6fa8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ffb5172c7f3a142f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e46e7eebd4723044_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.04, 0.07, 0.34, 0.45, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f26306b0972f3789_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.81, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6e1cd55748bb693_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.14, 0.26, 0.39, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_881f9687dad6959c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1ae3cfddb98a8ce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.06, 0.26, 0.54, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2da40a06387f7329_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.27, 0.44, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93e6d80474886241_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.6, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95d0d0ef38a89d6c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.32, 0.11, 0.24, 0.1, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e04a60682b804955_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f8f63521a68bc61_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.14, 0.19, 0.34, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b93135ffb585f4b2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.12, 0.14, 0.36, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_905549986f1a7eb3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8633319a76d9df2f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.88, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3d1b86472f754be_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.28, 0.17, 0.25, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d343022bcdab27a9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.13, 0.24, 0.27, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a5bff151b19fddb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a81285917fe7d23_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.94, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f266283cfcf0419_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.13, 0.5, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ecfae306bdef8d33_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.28, 0.72, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4009dcd330ee1fa0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.27, 0.22, 0.28, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54d981a44c9040a2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.06, 0.26, 0.48, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2d1ab204549e21b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.89, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a25a41d5d521dd24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.03, 0.08, 0.54, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4bdc40866b042bad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.36, 0.22, 0.16, 0.19, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_69c9f9c64368b6c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.26, 0.14, 0.17, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48c1f27aa576c012_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.31, 0.1, 0.44, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06f2955c3a0f313e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.07, 0.28, 0.5, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d34af0c05aeb9ad1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.3, 0.24, 0.18, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22a1256effcee9f6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.6, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d328c9d7076cf530_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fc23331e6ea00919_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ebfe64d471d0a02d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_167c97e9a96e102a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa692aafaeb314c2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd6f1df632da044e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.77, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a9f2efb5264c986_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.52, 0.45, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bde782372f71159_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddd1ece04ede7e0c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.72, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b43a8f4e04ed2f3d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.29, 0.43, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6473b91eed057e2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.17, 0.34, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4785d783ac3f8563_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63a253fef7750195_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b494b9d7806f153_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.16, 0.13, 0.31, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26e0d32e4d3f44fd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.26, 0.09, 0.31, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b66f8608349bd79_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e43a45c77de70459_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.21, 0.17, 0.39, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6aa98242c2deb609_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.51, 0.45, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0891ac5a0f355694_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_680c38b0691a3da8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.26, 0.17, 0.26, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06fb2a5104f2f4ed_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.31, 0.63, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7461d8922e7214a7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.35, 0.43, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6fdf7e51ec62d0c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.14, 0.33, 0.33, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f675ec93fd851856_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.38, 0.01, 0.19], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e365b1af052a36f6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.15, 0.34, 0.39, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb879da9369b760e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.9, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5fa12c096cb9bee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.17, 0.12, 0.3, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e1b69e9cbd80cb6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fdb72eefcb1dddb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f80bfc46ebf31df_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f41b91bee9918ecb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.16, 0.28, 0.4, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cc02c936694a0f7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_051eba4e90f2baa0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.1, 0.3, 0.35, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc9127211ff472f8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7525745dc365e91b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9259fd037d4dd57_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.15, 0.35, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ab836d0dcd84ee0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.19, 0.35, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85f930bea5f49d44_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.09, 0.47, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f359924626abc638_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.72, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc3f0cbefb781e00_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d68ff673e1757c1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.22, 0.43, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d33ee7c9a36ccf6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7718fcfb8399967_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.24, 0.44, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce5be725bc01fb42_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.1, 0.39, 0.36, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3aaa489343e6dd82_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.27, 0.17, 0.3, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59a2f7dd75b66164_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.21, 0.72, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d45aa02f84ceccef_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.4, 0.12, 0.26, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_814b5c4b8b2669cd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.33, 0.33, 0.3, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fccfaf8aafd73f0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b5303e3145ba17b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0808, 0.5455, 0.3434, 0.0303], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b35b62d6c8ec711_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.16, 0.67, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec49a4ccab7ddab6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.43, 0.01, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dd20067c634e925_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acabcd0439be4571_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.1, 0.25, 0.41, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d4f4733448b779e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d07cdfaafc4b806_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.14, 0.41, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45da1a1edc1d373b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.25, 0.19, 0.27, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b74c188a685c307_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_210623b187678795_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.38, 0.01, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1093c01951de545_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.28, 0.3, 0.26, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2636c7fd47d2fe5e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.3, 0.69, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d9ed44e96b76f01_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.83, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ea802234ba5c2e8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.22, 0.35, 0.26, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_908cd7505bd147fa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_783e6f300dd07d8f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_248d55177f99c1ec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bdc461d6963b58c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.78, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb5f3a160a6e7df6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d237f578bcda0367_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.56, 0.36, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78b777a9145ec999_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7274fbda9fbd87d7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88ed3c125ba153cf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac39de7ccf75b0d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.32, 0.24, 0.15, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42c650d943e47f98_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.57, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e71b1071bd1d6062_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.13, 0.22, 0.37, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5515def22a05b87_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7aec593c244322ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.85, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2edd4efe2593f32_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_950f7ac48024e089_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.14, 0.48, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d3b731c286627941_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.3, 0.5, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e83a6ca1d3453c66_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_750d507f2dc9dbfb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.5, 0.47, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_213352bafaa253c6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.39, 0.53, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10d6aa645308b709_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.62, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce7a50f563b5f82a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.24, 0.72, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8fa1aeccd3b3acfe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.76, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1fae28fa0ee960b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3594f3dfbffd172b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.13, 0.18, 0.3, 0.23, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb956f638039d6cd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.11, 0.54, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86ef1c1f69c464b5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.89, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dfa4f106efa03096_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.22, 0.45, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_251c2e943c22af3e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff38fc13fa0f3732_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.08, 0.34, 0.5, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cbfbc20a11984572_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_299b9fa1df851e6e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84fa9827c290a70a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bce008d9a1fa9a0f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eca8a6e23afebb1e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.6, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_170705eb7f96aac1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.63, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7461d8922e7214a7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9989ee2c64a78c93_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.22, 0.11, 0.24, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75aac9f3b816f254_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.24, 0.2, 0.3, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c2bd99b29f5812f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.11, 0.34, 0.41, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eebd7039292edf87_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88cd43ac604132a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f78a6d532643d3b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.36, 0.23, 0.19, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8145f795e5a26a53_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.52, 0.28, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_266668e55c03664a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a87251d367dcf63_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.84, 0.14, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cc2432992123bff_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ede7d6ace13cdefd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.1, 0.29, 0.43, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ebfe64d471d0a02d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.12, 0.22, 0.46, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_474f1f6f7f85361a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.84, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a970e93ab203960_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a848906ca754ff71_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0445ba81031084_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.19, 0.29, 0.26, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e9dc32ae2ac98f9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.21, 0.37, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cf9425392b4256d9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.03, 0.39, 0.54, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_253b1fdc7a241e9a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.32, 0.51, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_418f8441f9f34be8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ee4741f596d4f8a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51f0b1011e4d27ab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.13, 0.48, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61cd2f454a5ef22c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd2428f6f18e6fea_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42875d8ab1659d83_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.19, 0.39, 0.31, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dba82e97a177ca40_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.94, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ed5d3fb156ed57b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eae65305b3d59a60_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.37, 0.24, 0.21, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46003bdf92974e8b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.25, 0.56, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bef05adfb2128621_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.34, 0.64, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e7a7b6069ab061a6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.2, 0.18, 0.45, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb7967c1b2b191b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46003bdf92974e8b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.25, 0.18, 0.23, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8da2f62b03096f20_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de8080f79be81150_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5394a12fdefc86b9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.63, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fef8ade02ddb231_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.25, 0.15, 0.21, 0.08, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a114a06dc9122c19_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.49, 0.5, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3801056d6ff6712b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.14, 0.19, 0.31, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_545f742029f24e4c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f80bfc46ebf31df_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.08, 0.17, 0.22, 0.3, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_325119182c46f76e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.5657, 0.3939, 0.0404, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b19959b875873ff6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.31, 0.66, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50165a3c0724445b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1aefc29bf44fc10e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.99, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff3a91070fe362ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d5231c83acc6d84f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.24, 0.26, 0.29, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61b7b7a21c4165d1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.02, 0.07, 0.48, 0.39, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff3a91070fe362ac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.38, 0.47, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba579495f89670e7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.14, 0.54, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f0c0be36332edcb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.66, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f6ee401750aa219_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c39b3897a57b25f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.24, 0.36, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_633d80f46605efca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.07, 0.12, 0.41, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50b02636894513ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.5, 0.0, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81278611f63cec68_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.93, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ad3d4e7766a83fa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d53369579db06c8f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_affa7c28e10845e1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.04, 0.42, 0.43, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd7f9579c876e1f1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.1, 0.19, 0.34, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ab2746b8373a35e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.32, 0.21, 0.22, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd6cbda923f1ec72_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.14, 0.4, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86d184a6bb0b0218_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.38, 0.17, 0.16, 0.17, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07db4980affc34fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7039eab9a56d4ffd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77248188395dc186_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.11, 0.48, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0767e27f7e5b1996_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.35, 0.28, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_886556f5f8aff22e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.96, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_794ec1aa944f2239_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.09, 0.44, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd70e813590d52b8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.11, 0.27, 0.44, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_196110e0316c4708_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9d4c0accadcbb25_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.26, 0.36, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db84b49a8a2b69d2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.06, 0.34, 0.47, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_341645cd55f06293_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a15fb0c49a3ce293_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e604c6d9588ce4f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.17, 0.52, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04643e971ae0fbf6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.26, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fde93c6115a0e80_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b1e44e8f372460c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.16, 0.37, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8ad80b044104f2b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db4c4a73a440e5ab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.31, 0.64, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_624785ff8eb04b19_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.95, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73e843b781a716e9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.13, 0.25, 0.36, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0f9c574da88ecf5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6de4cfa81ab22873_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba5f1be369874261_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e35d01c5cdd2463_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39b88d4d5b309639_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.9, 0.09, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4764b33126946389_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.52, 0.4, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b2475756bc23809_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.22, 0.18, 0.3, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16261dbfca5e08b7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec49a4ccab7ddab6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3434, 0.3232, 0.1313, 0.1414, 0.0505, 0.0101], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c36431b0b43be806_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c516da54818bbee2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.16, 0.2, 0.26, 0.2, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_834286add85b715f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06b7c80b80c87e50_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.11, 0.23, 0.38, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88a65b5e879cafd6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.17, 0.36, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7d39f9c676ed539b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.88, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84f48bd29d028b33_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.08, 0.25, 0.49, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c0db038fe9784e3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb460fa09b3ef6d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.38, 0.44, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41e6b1d2a3c3eff6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.15, 0.2, 0.32, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88055425239e48a8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.03, 0.06, 0.23, 0.57, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bdc461d6963b58c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.13, 0.18, 0.27, 0.25, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6598c831abb9d16_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.18, 0.55, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8e7632ba7a9c7d2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.15, 0.67, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22a2cbb42ae33b24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.17, 0.35, 0.38, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10561bd9ddcab47b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe3198f901a8ea97_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37975b6c46cbb29a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.19, 0.67, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cdefb510cfad6af_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.33, 0.12, 0.27, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c477ddbb67eb5dca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.76, 0.14, 0.05, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6972e646ea5959b2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_363ac32feb9a610d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.03, 0.07, 0.53, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_117907106881a926_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e00642258a31152_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.48, 0.52, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dbc47c89d137c07_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.2, 0.3, 0.31, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67cb306f99b55dc0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a59a0d0da3fa0f9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.29, 0.51, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c08db6a38d6caa1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3fd8971a9f1b705_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.13, 0.35, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca88c1e23cbba57c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.16, 0.34, 0.36, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10259af8af35fbe4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb9983c989ff9663_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.57, 0.34, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c79379f276e0724_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.12, 0.16, 0.51, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0306e191fad09e4a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3b71466accfed62_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.38, 0.52, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8fb29232bf573816_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60028da33842baf9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.17, 0.27, 0.39, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ffd6927b13576819_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42ea6d09f218e1bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.22, 0.34, 0.28, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99be52ee361e747c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_797e9818378b3f9e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.15, 0.18, 0.23, 0.36, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_52fefc32b62e11fe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_283abd1c9480715b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47dba92e81c22aca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.14, 0.12, 0.33, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb13f118ae49dcb3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_924d8d775d5ed71a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.12, 0.17, 0.4, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5d98e954df8dee6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dff04f6f251eb554_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3eb74c14d0102a3d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.67, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_741d3ebd463dd62a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d3a4cf55f942286_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.54, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67162a234fdfe865_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.1, 0.29, 0.37, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d01f1f5496521e70_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50f354c2ff79b881_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.14, 0.37, 0.32, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_231dd69ad5870e3e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.81, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_afdd13db35af8544_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_21c543b7b69598a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.79, 0.2, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7245f9cd31a3686c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.81, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77fb0cec6945c1f4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.13, 0.16, 0.28, 0.29, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe10a8b6d891f4ce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45cd7c73604daf24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.23, 0.56, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b0193fe765548d5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.58, 0.32, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ebad2734366645d0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eebd7039292edf87_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.83, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dfda0edc53942193_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1414, 0.3434, 0.1717, 0.2727, 0.0606, 0.0101], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ab1c284f1d4e3e6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.34, 0.58, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff587332ff5dfadb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.47, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d6f5f7ce906e6f8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.11, 0.18, 0.34, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ae23a4a025e35bd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.44, 0.54, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a9b63d6b1625cd1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c171c11afc505c79_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.27, 0.26, 0.22, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_643486906cf8d7ab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.75, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d30bb39122f3bf8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bec4f01cda61ae44_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.5, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ee3b14fa3f5244f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.19, 0.07, 0.31, 0.21, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c8aaf810641d5ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.95, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d67fb3af9e2670e1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a738ef895e496a1c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.18, 0.71, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3fee836c8a81956_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_496f54aebf265aba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.41, 0.47, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aded383de96d1795_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88055425239e48a8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d7bd6885c989c88b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.39, 0.48, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_478aad9aa4133433_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.11, 0.39, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bda21359290391ca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76952880b0783330_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.2, 0.28, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_490700376b666127_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.39, 0.36, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd038d03e3dec320_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.55, 0.37, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c2dd7ea35e7d320_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.13, 0.36, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0545a3d4089a23e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.27, 0.16, 0.18, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_474f1f6f7f85361a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.19, 0.46, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_569882194e7b1b09_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae2f6fdd2aa6d677_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.35, 0.56, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c73913d9a9c7eac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.15, 0.28, 0.36, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b0a354748ae495b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.03, 0.53, 0.42, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e16818a8d63caf3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.64, 0.08, 0.0, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_627c603a04a7588d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.57, 0.22, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fe16ccf519704c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9aea6dc6227d252a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.51, 0.41, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0e6638e2c55403d6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.62, 0.35, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_80ab91df51694c85_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.08, 0.16, 0.39, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d258ad41c1c1ff5c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.15, 0.15, 0.41, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34855173921f9e59_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.88, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c12da5a1dc93b487_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a59a6563c22fd75_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.15, 0.42, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4766946ae62c36f4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.33, 0.19, 0.2, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cced490efc6fe3a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.28, 0.65, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a09f2f6046d4176e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0602325693aed705_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.11, 0.37, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75c8ced6f2f31674_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c9365105dac9b6f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.66, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d113ff5475ad3381_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e78671158036896a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7426dd5c6d42ae06_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b38a1021ec57cc8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.91, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a57c6eb724cebdb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.95, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc3f5bb784567fa4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.14, 0.38, 0.34, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2aadb041b9e2c5aa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.22, 0.11, 0.37, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_757854245a6a2407_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.17, 0.11, 0.35, 0.19, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab82b93547f56e98_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.21, 0.13, 0.37, 0.15, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2b583bfb559c238_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05a8da665bb02b0f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.28, 0.51, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0bf8b6047c45465c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.68, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cde7f598e003338_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.23, 0.23, 0.22, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db4bcd7fa4639b40_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.18, 0.2, 0.38, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1d9d1aed9fd28e4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.74, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b78ea3ed947dbc4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.87, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b64a06c478e9c99d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.21, 0.49, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fc4fe46f2def680_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c074a11b0185083_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.13, 0.53, 0.29, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac39de7ccf75b0d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.26, 0.57, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68987ffd95b266a2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36b19b21ceffb5f6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.6, 0.03, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_117907106881a926_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.94, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9835804e3c17fec2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b6fd0e38b070565_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.06, 0.14, 0.49, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1734d23384c5bd7c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.22, 0.4, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01e259f0de8e7e82_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06d9a62c09359f5f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.09, 0.15, 0.37, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1e2b6dd7183192b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.22, 0.18, 0.36, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b41724b81590ccb3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4eac2ceb096d1d2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.78, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d4f4733448b779e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.33, 0.24, 0.2, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb06a16190f12a4a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d17fdfd07314272b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.76, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8edfa71852a3aee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3c00dee3dd16681_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.84, 0.13, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5d97e48c84ee520_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.17, 0.31, 0.5], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6282ffba5c1854f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.17, 0.68, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7b84bd0cebbe2de_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.19, 0.13, 0.28, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29fc28bb27ec59dd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.29, 0.18, 0.23, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_025dc0740efb4ff9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.48, 0.49, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8fb1019e724cf87f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_daa294fda59fdfc0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.51, 0.43, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82f2f0222b46a77c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d01ddba1988f1001_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_868d306babf637ea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.23, 0.17, 0.38, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f570edc83a356db_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae963af43bd02225_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.57, 0.28, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3b107d6505c81ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea00da9e6dd0bc58_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.34, 0.48, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b159a46a8c8feae1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.27, 0.19, 0.21, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b064b0a17abaaaab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.28, 0.15, 0.21, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d768543415e796f2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_caf41e4893a6fca3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c395e9ed6cf91bc2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.23, 0.22, 0.24, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d47e1559d395009_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9e46cedc5b8e8b0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.62, 0.23, 0.02, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1cade7c53c7e4c32_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.36, 0.24, 0.17, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b73612ffdeadc11_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.25, 0.5, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_616a3f95c346315d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2300ac29352f7f0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.18, 0.26, 0.28, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05d1664d13ee5155_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.39, 0.47, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e365b1af052a36f6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.59, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a6ecc3d18090420_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.26, 0.15, 0.24, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60ce98eb90a70c5d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.08, 0.01, 0.71], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc736351158e18b6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61a41c28e66fb91d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.24, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6aee478ce0f12387_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe4de4ce2dca0fbe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_889461cb0a4e989d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b100fb38dbf7e8fb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.82, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d4f4733448b779e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.29, 0.6, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04643e971ae0fbf6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.94, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ebed074a5ce6c05_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.65, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73c696492e263188_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.14, 0.19, 0.21, 0.23, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ef48e2ddc30b98c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.07, 0.25, 0.5, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ecad290fa658f770_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.28, 0.26, 0.25, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d07cdfaafc4b806_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.8, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_954e0a9858ef76eb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.07, 0.11, 0.36, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ccddd6169de5c7a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_389d5d7d707653a8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7c44a7c0976ef24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.18, 0.55, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_073ad41d4edd5aa9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.2, 0.47, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d4e02e925c9b3c8d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.23, 0.19, 0.3, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eae9823b19bd585b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.28, 0.2, 0.2, 0.07, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cd11f99999e0f6d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.74, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d17d92fb53d09bb4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4c075f0e16564f54_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.28, 0.19, 0.27, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d343022bcdab27a9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.29, 0.54, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bd7af1622d1cf02_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dc39df6d92361a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c397030500c6aeed_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.22, 0.33, 0.27, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7fa254c60179fe3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2eba685187fb9b68_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63837adeed26d1a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.56, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e11d0937157876d3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.19, 0.16, 0.34, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_138d837d02b37da9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.13, 0.26, 0.51, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e067f83b1bcd1e50_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.14, 0.36, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a517b25ea06cad6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_984c426ac9893c36_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.14, 0.26, 0.43, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b02380b7f691f96e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d9bbd7c4c316dc94_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e43a45c77de70459_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.74, 0.2, 0.01, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59746fcf4b0221f5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.52, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d25400ebffdd0c99_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be6c5e7d12bfcddc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fbfc0437c073e75_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a1418e139c870a8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f4cd1930a2017b3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.97, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b1b8e41fa2951b1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.69, 0.29, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e341e07e49ba864_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.18, 0.22, 0.4, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c489283c6d52de1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.2, 0.79, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d980fb329712048e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2374e6331c4c61c6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.59, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d659d938261c8bc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.31, 0.55, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50c0ab549b207522_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.14, 0.23, 0.25, 0.21, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86d31f5884764e76_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.08, 0.39, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6136d281f1fa6445_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.87, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbeb5ac6cf6923e6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.26, 0.27, 0.2, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67318a0cce639427_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.16, 0.42, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_299b9fa1df851e6e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.06, 0.54, 0.36, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84f8051996bbe3aa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.39, 0.2, 0.1, 0.24, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38842b17388a2725_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8bebb96a8c3a439_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f779fbe0cadd6aa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.24, 0.24, 0.36, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b8f51bea835bab7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.16, 0.47, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5a7263d073f96d3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c4221b2c830f7be_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.15, 0.22, 0.38, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4fe15e7b27ca1a64_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.42, 0.44, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46fdcc2d5b1fda3f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90bf572a55d13153_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.76, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fbb92e7aa0d8d928_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_481bd7485830d7bc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26950359f5f105ba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.14, 0.32, 0.35, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ba78764bb199e77_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.14, 0.47, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b205053c5302e67_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.05, 0.59, 0.18], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06cabf300fbd6c03_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.66, 0.01, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05c52de9ef4d1993_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.23, 0.54, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48943a615774c9d0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eca81b1224a579ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.08, 0.38, 0.45, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25f558626b676e91_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.14, 0.72, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8842684e253552a7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.23, 0.32, 0.32, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddf976e2a790399b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.44, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc1918048abf8a61_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.12, 0.24, 0.37, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca704b59e740f2d1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_310e2392ac4759ce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e4a4d6c1eac223d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.28, 0.21, 0.26, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea451bff48b75d47_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a471b89d3838be2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.09, 0.43, 0.29, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_964c82945fed01ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.82, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d1e1398ac561999e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4c1dfc7c9457db2b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.17, 0.27, 0.3, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7513aa545ccc3c3f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.19, 0.13, 0.32, 0.23, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ee61ad1929a25fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.92, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_126d42f402cc2bc1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82c89e728b798d1f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.27, 0.58, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd75cbb4a3fbcd68_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.16, 0.32, 0.42, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d6f5f7ce906e6f8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.52, 0.4, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_11cd18fbd2f6f433_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a5f4974b34a57c0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17146e5d750b84b7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c32cf08354ec825a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.79, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e3a2ffab9af5341_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.24, 0.2, 0.28, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e614d1b026ccfaf0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.07, 0.06, 0.25, 0.47, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd6097bb39e6f4b0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0febfe30f4f537c8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da97b5b619ba76f1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00359e2a7bdf68e6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.22, 0.48, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_edb212bc91f2ff3e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b16518111d5ffd62_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.36, 0.55, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31d97169e6cf7351_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.55, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74e624c21110818e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.16, 0.54, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12a2d24c88ddb22e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76604ba5364e7e1a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50777ead0d68bb9f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.45, 0.02, 0.2], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9d62ed2209aa9ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.25, 0.16, 0.28, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_450e54fc0290866c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.33, 0.4, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5d24c3bce51dc0c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.11, 0.34, 0.42, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3021df90a1060015_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.18, 0.23, 0.24, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcbd545378decdd8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95d2371bbbcb84f4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.88, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c5203c805417fd7b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.34, 0.41, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db4ddbd65b397ce4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.12, 0.21, 0.47, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc885c63d8b6f995_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.09, 0.09, 0.34, 0.32, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db4bcd7fa4639b40_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd4dd9ed720023d1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.72, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb497ed4dec16afb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_833259ebd4bfc0bf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dd2029e05f62afa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_070549e1d29d7ac7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.6, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_269d38797a385439_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.11, 0.51, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7718fcfb8399967_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.7, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_237e35b758d3f852_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7891524d332d13fa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be6c5e7d12bfcddc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.2, 0.2, 0.23, 0.19, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a17859a5966f0d1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8a824979d41b930_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.34, 0.65, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5899e8ad4e78be1a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.11, 0.08, 0.26, 0.31, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f7944dd1948a814_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.84, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8da2f62b03096f20_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.14, 0.33, 0.33, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_089850a0b515c27e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.15, 0.67, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dae38be1bd4451dc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.2, 0.14, 0.25, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8390a3033f0ef105_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.18, 0.43, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e742dbb8051d64ac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.57, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f9baf87b4e27a85_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ac6664f1db14cbb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.36, 0.42, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73e843b781a716e9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_987084ddb3738555_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.33, 0.26, 0.19, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9021178d58805a70_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.29, 0.2, 0.27, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e9cf306e2014572_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.23, 0.63, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e44b0323b41beca9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_102c92933ebb23f5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.13, 0.28, 0.35, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_569882194e7b1b09_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.7, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7d25c5e9963364c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8083a9a11441753_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.73, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_389d5d7d707653a8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.13, 0.19, 0.31, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_195b3b28bca3f6aa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d82020a00198adc4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.11, 0.01, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_141f8b3e078161cc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.98, 0.02, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c5bbc106a3a80b4e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.85, 0.13, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e76d05b93d35070_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.34, 0.15, 0.14, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e56b1bf080431f10_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f3c56918168153d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4eb6a5a7f7d0b1fc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.22, 0.58, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2ac4041b44d64d8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.72, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0c41cee41c93840_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c4a374809451a3d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.14, 0.2, 0.34, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_19bbc121163af6c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.3, 0.24, 0.25, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22a2cbb42ae33b24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f319369f1e9d7de_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b427a36ff8c9217_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.1, 0.38, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d93febb78cc12531_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c51e933af9af5c3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.13, 0.12, 0.43, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe10a8b6d891f4ce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.1, 0.38, 0.32, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4a692eb074a3b42_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.11, 0.25, 0.44, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5394a12fdefc86b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8482416eba7a5fb2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50f14e09534bc297_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a149eb16a5011205_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.65, 0.29, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb0f04d6cb021321_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.11, 0.13, 0.46, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2697cdda73b4b409_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.2, 0.16, 0.41, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34c8f10c74909c69_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.54, 0.45, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f422b5a36ce431d1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ff1364fdc767c7c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36874861878759b1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.19, 0.39, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e3a2ffab9af5341_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf3366b0a61b6da8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.18, 0.54, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b93135ffb585f4b2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fe422cfabb5fda8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d24566099b99dcc0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5ef113e2faad60e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.51, 0.48, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2e9fb913046210a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.14, 0.16, 0.42, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63104ecfb24d3263_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.89, 0.11, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0254ef73eaf0baaf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.26, 0.17, 0.24, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84f48bd29d028b33_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.77, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76bfb0915524254b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.12, 0.53, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_741d3ebd463dd62a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.82, 0.09, 0.01, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ab1c284f1d4e3e6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.16, 0.19, 0.38, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a53469d3bf778a19_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a27257ddd6b6e235_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9e46cedc5b8e8b0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.24, 0.16, 0.31, 0.14, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddc9b4a37131356b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.08, 0.42, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b21fd1a1558e7fe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1439bd823b496215_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.21, 0.0, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a8d40ab5653ddd0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.16, 0.19, 0.22, 0.17, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88848c97a29406d1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47d87942f1a9a9e4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.03, 0.09, 0.55, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_add587d996be287d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.404, 0.1717, 0.0202, 0.404], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d4d92f162bac6ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.12, 0.24, 0.42, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0f9c574da88ecf5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.57, 0.14, 0.01, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b70384fdeb34120_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.36, 0.54, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6be36f3656f9a7b6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.78, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c24b2f86a1c336dd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.16, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49f10770c415d72_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8145f795e5a26a53_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8eaac9c94e5d03ee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3528eb88cea8fead_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4766946ae62c36f4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e24373876ea934b9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.16, 0.12, 0.31, 0.25, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_613d8d24a3d44593_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.1, 0.29, 0.27, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e227406608488dc8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.31, 0.2, 0.23, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_859d4927618b331a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bee747ffe3b4f738_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.12, 0.44, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b368c5b8f5e4d481_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae51e4312ef7e6b4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.3, 0.59, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1d85e0de3af235a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.06, 0.56, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c63b8c8c4fa5ab11_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.27, 0.1, 0.39, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c7ae87577c293d9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.45, 0.46, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ce15a476295225b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.12, 0.46, 0.35, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a55aa854da3530d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.79, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_237e35b758d3f852_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.38, 0.57, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6dc3abf3a1f4e38e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.09, 0.47, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91ec7023a086dd8a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.51, 0.48, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8d15d021b83f77e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb9713d8bc3d0c0e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7c3ef82d1dc36af_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60ce98eb90a70c5d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b838de754c03fa24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cac92197a93f0db0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.65, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_510a492a02b47497_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22a194bdf0ec4876_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.26, 0.52, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_add1fd6d27e54073_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.17, 0.33, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a332e9e2eb8a8ec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a90fe9fbf9a8e584_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdfc9ec9a7854b5a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40781cdad16ef44b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.23, 0.4, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2c60265bebe2d4d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.07, 0.06, 0.28, 0.42, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd3ee92f3059e5f7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.17, 0.27, 0.3, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55a696f67b7b3935_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.44, 0.44, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7400bda45066436_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.96, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5cda0a095301545_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.41, 0.3, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_830c7617ae6e070b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a74d2da620b13633_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a25b65b2a89c6cde_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.75, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c18968d81f5e9c3b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.11, 0.52, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63837adeed26d1a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b09c34b598f44aa2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2258f19bf70d3668_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.51, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d113ff5475ad3381_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.62, 0.25, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8119c14ff01f166_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_240412d633914396_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.33, 0.3, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_133632ac68e84e51_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.12, 0.38, 0.34, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9eb83a5214e3896c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.16, 0.18, 0.34, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb00cf2fdd62ccad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6ee9a232169c94a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03a9f445e748f0f8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_887859c306182bfe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.14, 0.33, 0.37, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6215b1706b5704c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.88, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7274fbda9fbd87d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.64, 0.29, 0.01, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cfd3ad5c0d565c7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.12, 0.13, 0.4, 0.22, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d4d92f162bac6ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a80813929f199647_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d62960fa8e49c09_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.06, 0.33, 0.46, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_170cf68aaa471230_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.07, 0.52, 0.34, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50d53e48b846c998_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.8, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af6a2433e64971e8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.22, 0.44, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_49a5ad926c5a7109_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.91, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_feb6a30e087650ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8054119f92305c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15c889b8dcb4115a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.21, 0.56, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5bbef50580f26289_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.04, 0.62, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad6cdc1e864619ba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_606b9a691f176b3e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0809aef0ded86f2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.15, 0.23, 0.32, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5e89b3cb8ffc155_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.25, 0.17, 0.3, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67ead6b218e82974_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.15, 0.14, 0.3, 0.26, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b78645914bd34a4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.2, 0.55, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e05b90b0fcc55e18_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.28, 0.12, 0.19, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5cdeddf7daa3f53_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.05, 0.18, 0.51, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4df62ea41b124107_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.2, 0.27, 0.25, 0.15, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6128ffb4d38e36ee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5eef09a50a82fad3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.19, 0.38, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1462e584cdf6616a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.74, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dae38be1bd4451dc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93f8391586255974_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.83, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b8aa6724ddf23cc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0009e18f5b189e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.45, 0.54, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d343022bcdab27a9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7c582f4264ead8a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.69, 0.15, 0.01, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28bf51570b71a218_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75be4f3e56b8dbc7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.2, 0.55, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_185a91b9fd9829e5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.54, 0.42, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d523ce2b7847a29d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c18425050c4e7f9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.25, 0.14, 0.29, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_876faba4f88569d9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_753d3f6f1602f7dd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c7eeb2a72736325_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.17, 0.14, 0.36, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e64756f4ea258a22_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a31b497a6eccd212_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.97, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eced87fe52755f68_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.19, 0.21, 0.29, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_83d2061130f79e1d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.16, 0.31, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c6ed0f275864779_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b63e18f55f7c7765_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.12, 0.43, 0.37, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0134d94b31395fb9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86af05bf58981268_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23ee54014177899f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c0899a8047e47f4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_881901fd0d242ac0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61b7b7a21c4165d1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_df22a3795418666a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4be0cc19ee6b56de_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.17, 0.56, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_529d7c6cc3a8ef8b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_240412d633914396_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aaef30c1ff9bbd68_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_938edf9a8d4f5135_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.3, 0.61, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe04feb055951c97_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.49, 0.36, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_affe97c3e1a934c1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.12, 0.18, 0.37, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3b71466accfed62_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d5dc03fe74a872e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb0353166c4251ca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.83, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8bee8210f240de1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.21, 0.01, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_031d13a1117d8289_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.92, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cb5a47944f5fbad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.7, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a26b10153a77fac0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bef5138c80a974bb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.87, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_441b0f63bc3806bd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3eb74c14d0102a3d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.16, 0.63, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93bffbe4515123b2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.32, 0.03, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e619d416de6500b3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.7, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89ff5ba8c5eb71d8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.22, 0.26, 0.29, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f568e820e44cd45_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.07, 0.26, 0.48, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e312a2c8080307c7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.63, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eeae4ec17fe576a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87ac1426751498d0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.69, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a5e87a148ab27b7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.12, 0.13, 0.2, 0.24, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_672e4828880fcdb2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f6638f1ee2daa2d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.8, 0.18], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7de238ac29e04893_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_52c986c35b117aad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.75, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b06925b9476c3dff_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.55, 0.4, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0bb8a5ce1c080226_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.28, 0.2, 0.3, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b368c5b8f5e4d481_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.69, 0.25, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a6b105984c92e5d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.86, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce7d44ca598de989_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.55, 0.41, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c69bf85871288af2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1734d23384c5bd7c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.48, 0.5, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bce008d9a1fa9a0f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.75, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_663d5b3292404609_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.46, 0.34, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c7eeb2a72736325_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ecad290fa658f770_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d44ec4c5c2df9716_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b27b267ae4c103dc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.26, 0.54, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66cc0191e6ed55da_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.46, 0.29, 0.17, 0.06, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dec0fd7b02613240_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b35b62d6c8ec711_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b8db5fb0e5c60b6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.13, 0.73, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46343f0392a90078_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.14, 0.2, 0.39, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3537a791dcdcaa0a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3426983da89424f2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.15, 0.31, 0.37, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa23dfc2e035dd8b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.24, 0.5, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e4a4d6c1eac223d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.71, 0.0, 0.14], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e82851c8e1efcdaa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.2, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de374701505a1d22_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dfa4f106efa03096_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.19, 0.41, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a15511488c5e906d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.08, 0.35, 0.45, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_686124f5a952a032_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4850f842718d9937_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.78, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_016c2dc94e1bfd08_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.12, 0.42, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2fca18dffa8cb61_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35a02e03e311d470_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.04, 0.04, 0.26, 0.53, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff58c7b7f8a90b9e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.19, 0.14, 0.28, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06d9a62c09359f5f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_155e1d3f8d654924_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ae92405c71a45d3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4857cb3847143659_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_060093385dece2fa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.2, 0.61, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_072e8d62a27a56bf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7fe201076c90ded9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.06, 0.29, 0.44, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fffe1738b375f3c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.74, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c23a6d49384591a8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.12, 0.18, 0.33, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2acecb96b39f7f5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.74, 0.22, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bffa17e994fcff0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.5657, 0.2323, 0.1919, 0.0101], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d89879c5486a3237_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.87, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c18425050c4e7f9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.49, 0.47, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_468bfc7a0831b09b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3c526b0d93edae7c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_167c97e9a96e102a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.11, 0.7, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f601fb271f6f612b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.74, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_067ee27cfdee3a6e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.15, 0.21, 0.38, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cbe8cb75e5359acc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.23, 0.22, 0.28, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67cb306f99b55dc0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.11, 0.26, 0.42, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea451bff48b75d47_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.27, 0.54, 0.15, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_856e542f0cb77b14_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.55, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d1e463e6c545c90c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.11, 0.14, 0.22, 0.34, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_141950134042a4b9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.54, 0.2, 0.0, 0.26], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fd70e4f04fbedea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.8, 0.09, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bd9cbbee65f76af_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.7, 0.19, 0.01, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3d28a519d6bd873_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.32, 0.07, 0.37, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eab7303ea50c0db8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fa6333add4cbb23_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e64172b8ec0cdb5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef4823036a267f61_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.14, 0.36, 0.33, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89ff5ba8c5eb71d8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.85, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0cad56ccd2fdc11_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.17, 0.52, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_710222e0cee323b0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5fe741c97ae95422_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.33, 0.24, 0.17, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_418f8441f9f34be8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.57, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9f2dbfc783c8eb7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.48, 0.49, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9b6b7da431529f6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.26, 0.58, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d546e99b21a977dc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.49, 0.37, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f736dbb9aa8d084f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.34, 0.64, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b1a8901ea1ddead_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.12, 0.22, 0.44, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9d96439cb82ff87_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbb290c3161df68d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.1, 0.65, 0.25, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee4413d41edc569f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c171c11afc505c79_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.85, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9b9318248e6c799_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.06, 0.09, 0.44, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b3f28ef7a03e5d5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.32, 0.19, 0.19, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5de76799b5f1817d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.9, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2a4435a53ef2418_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1079703b20997be_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.43, 0.55, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00936c68eb273519_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab0cddae26a4b435_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d1bde9b9584ee08_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0e6638e2c55403d6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e35d01c5cdd2463_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.6, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_09a40e88c929299f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.07, 0.22, 0.55, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a9492f3d256748d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.22, 0.22, 0.25, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dcf7738e84a2a333_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90ec9ad2095f07ce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8911f78489209c2a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.38, 0.14, 0.25, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca88c1e23cbba57c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6bea87b4cda8d218_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.27, 0.27, 0.25, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f455f647631f74ae_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.18, 0.25, 0.39, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_092a6c735fc736c7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4abcd43c9a88fa91_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.79, 0.13, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6aee478ce0f12387_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.86, 0.09, 0.0, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd0e503be71913ce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.65, 0.34, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_684d1ace663a8fe8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.95, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1ce311eb7018fb1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.13, 0.15, 0.35, 0.25, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37036c2dc688b942_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2707408f8ba506d4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.34, 0.39, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4996fa51ceb0b63_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3801056d6ff6712b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05d1664d13ee5155_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39b88d4d5b309639_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00832a8ce8346485_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.57, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3fee836c8a81956_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.47, 0.29, 0.11, 0.1, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6dfbe5148c4d89fe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d01ddba1988f1001_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.83, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbe5625636b4b890_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c6ed0f275864779_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.8, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9447cea71e4193b3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.9, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e365b1af052a36f6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_075ce3026e952ced_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.97, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd377d2159d15e60_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25302b8e514c8129_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f63539dff5526916_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5eef09a50a82fad3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.36, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba06c1ceab9a4e83_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5288d4302a5f595b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bb69cde1c1fbf03_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.67, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_967eba7051edcbe8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.21, 0.15, 0.28, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d92708b6dc39ba14_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_368fb3d4c3539a17_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a7a5af9f572c2fd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ae92405c71a45d3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0808, 0.1717, 0.101, 0.404, 0.202, 0.0404], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b04127b132fd7660_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.14, 0.48, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6592eb1031e60ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.09, 0.3, 0.45, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c23686ad39f52556_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.05, 0.25, 0.55, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d7cc8a1e4138741_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.9, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee90a5f7e0f357e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.14, 0.42, 0.38, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db36d10ce08f1d1a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.05, 0.95], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b838de754c03fa24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.09, 0.37, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49d7f65ff23f3c1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1026df530e81b7b8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.26, 0.42, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2300ac29352f7f0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.81, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2d1ab204549e21b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff8956041ecda4d3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.34, 0.53, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d28faebef23f4415_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.67, 0.32, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_209d0867cc371fd0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.57, 0.02, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d3b437f57053940_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.32, 0.43, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8edb9802c78e3c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb276511e4b3a28f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aeeb10f4dd9adafb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.21, 0.41, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2bad6767be5c0f6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.22, 0.39, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ed858b4f6d351ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.11, 0.16, 0.36, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93d4c8f6f7a501ab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dfda0edc53942193_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59a2f7dd75b66164_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.12, 0.56, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1be232b70785f6b4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.72, 0.27, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf043b8da232b120_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.27, 0.13, 0.29, 0.14, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5c143f947cb6cbb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.27, 0.46, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28aa159d52c85e88_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.2, 0.62, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43ea7e49e33bf138_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4e3023e2e121a10_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9d46ff74cc8f472_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.29, 0.15, 0.22, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78c2c77b1f4de5c7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.95, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eca81b1224a579ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.65, 0.33, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8e2f4ddbf001739_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9387bac96bdc49c2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.39, 0.52, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ccf40f8ad3cd4e0c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.08, 0.07, 0.39, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84f8051996bbe3aa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.61, 0.02, 0.17], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e7da013e1a0d629_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b121d6915246ccce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4937403766b9908d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.14, 0.37, 0.31, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc9813fc1cb5f2db_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dadf97ba304f4e1c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.63, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7de88f8412657666_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_834286add85b715f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.88, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d911b8368205401_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.96, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9330c4008d45e89f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.08, 0.31, 0.51, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_551c8871fc94b48c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.31, 0.55, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f48e7cd5e05b24a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.12, 0.13, 0.49, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad9e3d6471ad6266_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.54, 0.44, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d616b216ddc40146_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.11, 0.09, 0.25, 0.41, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39d7c04320864fe7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5fd62b80f6dee1e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.71, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eca8a6e23afebb1e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.22, 0.26, 0.33, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_316a1e0b12271080_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.29, 0.54, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5576dafdf8aa9b54_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7811001681c65ca6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.13, 0.18, 0.34, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f96318791ef650ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1db4db0d5176f4b1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.41, 0.45, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_462f3b660bc68450_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.54, 0.0, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cceb695d469d3a20_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc2d36b41cb15b70_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.46, 0.51, 0.01, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87d1d7be4cd4063c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.98, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_798c0b998f35acf2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.36, 0.51, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a022b6dc2467d63_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_067ee27cfdee3a6e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26aff861307a2ff5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.92, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59b3a7f5e22e3865_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93d4c8f6f7a501ab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.06, 0.72, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b041ef4de121779f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.77, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c67ade09d4fafcd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.39, 0.53, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50f354c2ff79b881_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c4a374809451a3d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9241bc8923300601_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.82, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f31b946044508bbf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.77, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_02a2bacae6031b44_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.43, 0.49, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_266668e55c03664a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.43, 0.51, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67115654fa39b6ea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.33, 0.17, 0.13, 0.06, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0306e191fad09e4a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.02, 0.62, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a8c6af71b024a03_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.05, 0.19, 0.58, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47d87942f1a9a9e4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.02, 0.66, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_109db888eb447d6b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.07, 0.3, 0.47, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e961ad5dc528533d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.41, 0.47, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73cbdd5e2d4f3c87_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.12, 0.34, 0.33, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_907b5a67393eaf63_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.34, 0.53, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f1c6411338cc93e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa2f790d56afebcc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.11, 0.19, 0.32, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ede3c663774630ee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.14, 0.48, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f47ce6e07c9e01e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.5, 0.02, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90dfa5f917e07e96_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.02, 0.03, 0.27, 0.59, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1643e6305ec20b99_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.82, 0.15, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39f690fd8974b3e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0505, 0.6869, 0.2626, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fdf0fe065d26c25_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5debf4498610dd5a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.9, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9030fd014f651fb2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_231214f9b52b90a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0869dedc5d94793d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.64, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3fee836c8a81956_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.35, 0.4, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2653962c5ae07bc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad9e3d6471ad6266_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6a42d2d9cae7081_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_02f9dc9cd3ffd199_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.18, 0.78, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86ef1c1f69c464b5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe3bb70c576958ef_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b6d2dcc79179282_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.22, 0.37, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_118cd540abb6f010_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce3c7ddaebd84f40_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0789cc2c61f25417_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.55, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ce15a476295225b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.77, 0.19, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5714009eae45399_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15bd20ebfd49a524_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.12, 0.19, 0.47, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fdb72eefcb1dddb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.2, 0.29, 0.28, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1144bf484cac98a3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34d98b7000e2baff_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.24, 0.74, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e3e5cd68e303a9f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.48, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6aa98242c2deb609_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.24, 0.38, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7c573563929ee86_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.25, 0.45, 0.26, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d523ce2b7847a29d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.36, 0.56, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33129a39428178d8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5067b3a21a8dce61_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2f97506162162c0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b93135ffb585f4b2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.91, 0.06, 0.01, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f942b76eac08a5ee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.07, 0.7, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb953ab3ef091e05_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.24, 0.19, 0.33, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e7ae770135b1a5d9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.25, 0.18, 0.23, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97e1419b394b1860_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b16518111d5ffd62_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3537a791dcdcaa0a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.17, 0.27, 0.33, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcd5a633bfc1c857_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c32b2b9d16a54bc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55367e5546ead065_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.08, 0.49, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f14e64f4bd6bae8d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a71c29843471d503_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.07, 0.41, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8694cc7f8791f93b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.07, 0.31, 0.44, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_124e033a99c2fb04_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ebef78954483e88_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ab594fe8817f897_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b02544d83355d80_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ed5e7e40e7b7617_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.45, 0.4, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a5bff151b19fddb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.03, 0.17, 0.61, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bb69cde1c1fbf03_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.2, 0.45, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e7914f96b93f3bf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad11e3f0601a1264_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.79, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a332e9e2eb8a8ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.32, 0.08, 0.31, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0baf7d5a58cff96_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2546820f83ce5c0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.11, 0.32, 0.35, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d7024b0372e7a74_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.8, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_53b4ded34a2324bf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.28, 0.07, 0.31, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba9fbe554b91f6da_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.74, 0.24, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce7a50f563b5f82a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.19, 0.42, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_635b305900db356a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.04, 0.96], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6629c45f9cfba802_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.72, 0.18, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_354b3f2ddbdfa705_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.53, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad244a8a577ce115_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.58, 0.17, 0.01, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7fe978590bd9c66_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.14, 0.04, 0.48], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2da399b24726942_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b61338592a87895_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcd54cd0949515bd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.19, 0.61, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8681059042263e6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0ef956d3af2e499_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.09, 0.25, 0.52, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7c582f4264ead8a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.1, 0.11, 0.29, 0.31, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c331713541c7ceb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.18, 0.29, 0.23, 0.18, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_397af398ef2629b8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d63186d23d5563ef_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a47f72d54db749f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.34, 0.23, 0.2, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55b60e789d22f55f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.86, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c64990bf807a638b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.09, 0.26, 0.37, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e1b69e9cbd80cb6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.1, 0.49, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_effd8eff68e8276d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.71, 0.04, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29725a4f7edb45e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.04, 0.23, 0.57, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e28b22dfabbba4b8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.22, 0.51, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcf8d81b1eb94851_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.12, 0.38, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d5dfe22fcda0045_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.46, 0.45, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_454af686cfb8bdaf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.86, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_afdd086ed73405e5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.78, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8f0afb0692d8977_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.5, 0.48, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a970d6e235f4b475_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd9fc754d5baa528_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.38, 0.62, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37d10950de599e45_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_efac05bb197b1ac8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.78, 0.03, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcbd545378decdd8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.16, 0.39, 0.29, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4857cb3847143659_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.11, 0.28, 0.49, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e7b8de1e33e7a9c9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34063b624755502e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.57, 0.32, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4887e97e63ef1d6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1af67086e6253cf5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.16, 0.24, 0.36, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f00afa69a6863ed_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a97dcdf69fa0364e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67115654fa39b6ea_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b60eb64f0c48dc99_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6972e646ea5959b2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.14, 0.12, 0.35, 0.26, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41ecb3b05fdfc7d8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.22, 0.25, 0.31, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45da1a1edc1d373b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2942dacba6af6e7c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.79, 0.2, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e376897559684ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_316a1e0b12271080_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.17, 0.2, 0.37, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_feb6a30e087650ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.55, 0.42, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd70e813590d52b8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.81, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_598b713d1c4b1484_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.89, 0.11, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5403d48269d11052_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.2, 0.37, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1869908c7bac1e26_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.14, 0.46, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40781cdad16ef44b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.29, 0.64, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb20a33ee5e2b6bb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.23, 0.71, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dd20067c634e925_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.85, 0.07, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_297c9262a928864b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.39, 0.3, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17777de2c92c76f1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7448fb1e1dc8ef6a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_725ec49cb03109a6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.1, 0.55, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03133a3484c1356f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.25, 0.33, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_072e8d62a27a56bf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.19, 0.51, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ac6664f1db14cbb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.34, 0.19, 0.19, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24ba653f73385bf5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.17, 0.15, 0.33, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae0a1a946c2a1102_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31d97169e6cf7351_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.27, 0.17, 0.34, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ac1700f285ba3d9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_32ea96fc0d69e206_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.09, 0.14, 0.45, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dabc9bbe9c19aeda_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.68, 0.01, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29c9870ff069ed49_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.36, 0.16, 0.24, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03c85abeed470c04_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.15, 0.53, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7813c4d76c9d3a6f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.2, 0.35, 0.29, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c40aa3626914f58_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a88688789f0a5d8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.19, 0.53, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_067125d61f13a4c6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c408e88c7b5cd5b3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.14, 0.29, 0.39, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c66484b3f2fc3478_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_837f5d6924a30a91_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.81, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_83a33f33441c7282_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.25, 0.14, 0.27, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b38674d3b4b84b92_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.9, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e92cf01964dc8ff9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.74, 0.25, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49f10770c415d72_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.16, 0.23, 0.32, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_271df68c34c8472f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_206a681a98c3d7b3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.8, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c0db038fe9784e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.15, 0.23, 0.37, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a647df04db78896_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55a696f67b7b3935_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_010ef6aa9d8967dc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d9710b2a6c465aee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.17, 0.4, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41bdb26f9b530ad8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef9b25fac0f87c89_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.19, 0.15, 0.3, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e0e124804b9ca06_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.51, 0.46, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_950f7ac48024e089_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.39, 0.51, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89865bec92ed175b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.22, 0.41, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75aac9f3b816f254_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.42, 0.55, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8fb173b83ec3336_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.42, 0.01, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cffcc2ba66c060cb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74ce7bd023ef85d6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb631e8cf8146772_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.09, 0.5, 0.33, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f661ac3e2aca0ed_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.17, 0.28, 0.34, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a46339527f41e2c3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2fca18dffa8cb61_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.2, 0.5, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d53369579db06c8f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.92, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_887091147a280a8a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.17, 0.34, 0.36, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c06d050d9cd1c6e9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.98, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1ac07559bf3d08a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.14, 0.23, 0.45, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c5a4b2b44c4b890c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.49, 0.22, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8340850e3babfe8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1141722b0c659d09_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.05, 0.27, 0.59, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66df5405ae90a3f1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2da399b24726942_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.18, 0.29, 0.34, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d21f51e06bdec0a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4483f0171bf17547_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.15, 0.37, 0.41, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0104fb6afdba011c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.7, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b73612ffdeadc11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.33, 0.55, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f33ac4479fbf7c86_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.62, 0.38, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae2f6fdd2aa6d677_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5394a12fdefc86b9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.35, 0.17, 0.19, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae963af43bd02225_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.09, 0.31, 0.45, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4eb5a457177e790_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16b77f4c64957668_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.88, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc8ef14cb795ff50_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.15, 0.38, 0.28, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0764cbf9aba1e886_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a26723251c76b8bd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb0f04d6cb021321_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90bf572a55d13153_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.07, 0.25, 0.42, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d89879c5486a3237_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f568e820e44cd45_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.45, 0.44, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9466645c0bc5421a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd21ad440378078f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.15, 0.48, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_952f20835d73db22_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.19, 0.19, 0.25, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9266ff2d935c5d88_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.68, 0.22, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34663cedb5dddf4d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.2, 0.4, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5403d48269d11052_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_092a6c735fc736c7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.11, 0.51, 0.35, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_598b713d1c4b1484_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.39, 0.22, 0.12, 0.19, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3934ef13917db101_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_218dd03f73e68be1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.26, 0.1, 0.29, 0.1, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a8b010f15cc603e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.38, 0.08, 0.17, 0.04, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa3f82b542f589fe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bba759833d3803ef_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.28, 0.16, 0.38, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d6f723e3eb0067c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.24, 0.17, 0.28, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_462cd72b15af52d6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e5d21dc75f2237f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.92, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb631e8cf8146772_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0772cc6cf82fb59_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4f57ea4c9e92b8d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a25ba79949d40e9c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.69, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2bac59ec2be4ec00_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.32, 0.19, 0.15, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_deee06d7c17c020f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0baf8363951a1e41_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.07, 0.93], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6608584486b4ccca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.85, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_680c38b0691a3da8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.55, 0.4, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4a692eb074a3b42_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.7, 0.27, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1adecccc931246f9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4766946ae62c36f4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.49, 0.42, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_faf7409119af7b1b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ec483c31de14d74_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1716427b4ea8a332_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.58, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b512b5e4d87d7eb6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8aa992a0c221d872_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb96b2228e2b0114_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.23, 0.66, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d9710b2a6c465aee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cbc944dfaa717069_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.28, 0.22, 0.26, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b38663d094a26c6b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_312b8096a9cdd57f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.14, 0.43, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_20ce1d4e8cbad99a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.25, 0.08, 0.32, 0.09, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2131034fd58a2752_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.08, 0.41, 0.45, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5df603e21aa09474_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.11, 0.2, 0.41, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78abb1234a535529_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_462f3b660bc68450_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1c3235969200c92_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.23, 0.01, 0.67], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1776b22ac0d43cd7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.3, 0.61, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb06a16190f12a4a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.11, 0.24, 0.42, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_18799b3017f5c26c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.17, 0.39, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e207abe2ff49429_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.59, 0.3, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a7f68bb282e31ab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15feb331a9a6404d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.66, 0.31, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40781cdad16ef44b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ede7d6ace13cdefd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.73, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a5aabf044b31077_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e828223d7408022f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.71, 0.17, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4eaa1b829ce4a6df_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.19, 0.26, 0.31, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2f458e475e06f4e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.71, 0.2, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_672d34a30b3c6b20_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb4b4fc3bcce0931_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f09e73b41e872877_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.88, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbd39986757b2633_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15f0ffe89f21a7e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.02, 0.06, 0.45, 0.43, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_231dd69ad5870e3e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bef05adfb2128621_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_589c5a5475d688e1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.06, 0.22, 0.35, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46d6ff2e71255197_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ec8467ef2bce89a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.34, 0.21, 0.21, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa07d54dddb323ea_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ffd6f2d174633d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.64, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35804a677ab5c8de_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.13, 0.14, 0.36, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea096e40bc78f97b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2489801cefd913cb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_993b680b41c20350_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7df5f7fe204d945e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fef8ade02ddb231_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d6f3a4d354aa749_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.28, 0.72, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c06e0e1c063d8f84_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.71, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aec93cafcc1e3d94_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.15, 0.13, 0.24, 0.19, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_303f7c592728e764_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a01be49c4097605e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0353c95405800598_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.57, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5714009eae45399_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.47, 0.4, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c30fbd597a554368_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.45, 0.53, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87cb4bfbeb302234_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.94, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_672ce128d1f40ccf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a10188087b42cd1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.34, 0.51, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e0e124804b9ca06_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37975b6c46cbb29a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.87, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b60eb64f0c48dc99_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.15, 0.47, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c32b2b9d16a54bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.07, 0.24, 0.51, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bf00e3ab45393d8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.2, 0.49, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_caed6ed68efe910e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.24, 0.16, 0.32, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ab2e9093047a283_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.17, 0.1, 0.32, 0.18, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b70384fdeb34120_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.1, 0.31, 0.42, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9149d19f41a1c9b6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8edc63854afcb4d4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.35, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e961ad5dc528533d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3741996dcb98caaa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.95, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e27059583f7bc69d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51073ca2d3cd17cf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.18, 0.22, 0.35, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7710978c7136c206_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.12, 0.58, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_710eb4437590fbc1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_063fbb064db7fac9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.46, 0.03, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0cb99ed6ddb68bb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.03, 0.16, 0.67, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce0d0853119921d1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8812ea149eac7c7a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.21, 0.2, 0.41, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f78af9b5a5b0af33_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbbb59d5640bcbd6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9839810b675977e7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.12, 0.23, 0.43, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a46339527f41e2c3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.29, 0.04, 0.37, 0.05, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b235aaaf6aaff49c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.45, 0.09, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d206d67ec4ce32b3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b02380b7f691f96e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.16, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fbb92e7aa0d8d928_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.91, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0480a9c26a0bc766_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.12, 0.41, 0.38, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acabcd0439be4571_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.61, 0.04, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce3c7ddaebd84f40_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.12, 0.34, 0.32, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e618ecc1d0082f6a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.22, 0.2, 0.26, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e618ecc1d0082f6a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.25, 0.72, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff024245c934862d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.23, 0.28, 0.22, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d9ed44e96b76f01_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3493dca982786adb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.18, 0.52, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe162982ac9e9d77_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58a1cfd7acaaeec2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2dce35eaf99ff72_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.13, 0.43, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33129a39428178d8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.7, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfc929ca357360d6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.06, 0.01, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec3752a3e0dfc8ae_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.24, 0.27, 0.24, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84df3f73826a79be_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.2, 0.48, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_adc2d31d4ca2e30c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.22, 0.3, 0.24, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7811001681c65ca6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0303, 0.9394, 0.0202, 0.0101], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17146e5d750b84b7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.2, 0.63, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d470d65b05ea96c0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f683487f579a0d92_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_071fd11ab2ee02e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.74, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae6bbe7238f9bc38_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91ef90433b3af278_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.13, 0.79, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72e849921ff1b13e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.2, 0.22, 0.28, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ba2c40ed8ef72fe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0a1277d82ed00ac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.16, 0.37, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f428efdd9a4a0155_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_65312a83e1f9b969_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.07, 0.08, 0.25, 0.41, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1462e584cdf6616a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.13, 0.15, 0.47, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90ec9ad2095f07ce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.4, 0.42, 0.08, 0.07, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_19a601ed7e711266_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.12, 0.78, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79f0768a129efce3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.04, 0.96], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c39deb783493e7c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.21, 0.47, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfc1b7170ee214b1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.69, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdca00d869c82efa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.79, 0.0, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c34b17566851751_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.39, 0.16, 0.24, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f09c787da6254468_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab0cddae26a4b435_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.76, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_daa294fda59fdfc0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9466645c0bc5421a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.34, 0.63, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b9884752e2f7991_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.17, 0.35, 0.25, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_889461cb0a4e989d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.19, 0.19, 0.24, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_998b9e8aaffa0c06_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_efae3d840ef5c79b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.17, 0.28, 0.27, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dec0fd7b02613240_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.09, 0.0, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_477cdff35e91cfc7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.28, 0.67, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd4a74a1c8c5fac5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.06, 0.05, 0.33, 0.46, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57d0c99cbd7ef9fd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.4, 0.58, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17777de2c92c76f1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.91, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0c41cee41c93840_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.33, 0.38, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0764cbf9aba1e886_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.34, 0.31, 0.31, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_474f1f6f7f85361a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8c4e3ff9d5c24c3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0b7aebbb1a27297_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.18, 0.14, 0.29, 0.22, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d7bd6885c989c88b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.29, 0.12, 0.29, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_106fa3d31e9090fd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.15, 0.22, 0.32, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4501d62e83117dfa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c06e0e1c063d8f84_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.11, 0.45, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6663ac2be04cdeb5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.09, 0.22, 0.45, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_463bae9fe0778e13_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.15, 0.39, 0.34, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0c2317b979cd033_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b66f8608349bd79_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.54, 0.45, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1db4db0d5176f4b1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.32, 0.2, 0.29, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3945bf0231c20f23_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9db6260186531ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.15, 0.19, 0.3, 0.21, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9839810b675977e7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.71, 0.19, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c96cb4d31ada8eee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.51, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a713d0c2168b4ca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c222c4aeb5aae066_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.87, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6dcf685dfdf25cf6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.26, 0.12, 0.36, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_358824d4f61be878_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.19, 0.38, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_138d837d02b37da9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d9ef47bb953c8dba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.92, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6091a53f7b082b9c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_554d0f1262bc23e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.12, 0.1, 0.43, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ef6defc66de7aa3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_772bc2735d3fe0e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.18, 0.21, 0.36, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f129805779ef6d21_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.21, 0.29, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e0b96c6ef8ea614_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aeb357993d169597_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_345dc0d676c661a3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f48264b596457fa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e0113d8b3b01131_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12e359990068825e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.28, 0.33, 0.24, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66c1ac70538876af_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.78, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0ef956d3af2e499_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b04f7777615759fb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.39, 0.53, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_513a85a86ad86278_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78c2c77b1f4de5c7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.28, 0.3, 0.18, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74677287ff2835c3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.37, 0.18, 0.11, 0.27, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2e9fb913046210a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.6, 0.01, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38f855a8aee68c04_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.87, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d37ca725064a2084_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_705bbb659b81c168_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_887859c306182bfe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.67, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e3353f5527aede7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.11, 0.31, 0.38, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd2428f6f18e6fea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.64, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8141cb9a15ff9e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dba82e97a177ca40_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_406562e1c47cb28d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.44, 0.41, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10d6aa645308b709_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.25, 0.24, 0.28, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_afdd13db35af8544_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.24, 0.21, 0.34, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_677998e4f5581771_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.79, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a715abde6c7f0c89_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3124efb71d486f6d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.33, 0.45, 0.21], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e618ecc1d0082f6a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b1e44e8f372460c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.81, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c78ce82d4984995e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.22, 0.32, 0.22, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5369c431090adaf8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.74, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b1a179d4d64d8ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.15, 0.13, 0.32, 0.22, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec898cb1c2f88954_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.26, 0.44, 0.25, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b38663d094a26c6b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.75, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c85090315f2d5e45_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.14, 0.2, 0.39, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_109622abd483491a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.19, 0.29, 0.37, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd6097bb39e6f4b0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.66, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_faf732b71149b87c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.66, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_592b4f9fede4ce41_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71d59ea2cfdf1703_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.36, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e703e3330339dbd8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.15, 0.72, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e59e12ac44faf81_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_164abb8a3c5dc478_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.18, 0.36, 0.23, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16261dbfca5e08b7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.35, 0.23, 0.16, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71bb4a8df2bad8e1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_150cbb5614b0c565_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddb1b3d931684256_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.61, 0.38, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67318a0cce639427_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd09292dd6fe93a6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a5f2b25c6fc0a41_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.12, 0.55, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a25a41d5d521dd24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_721d94bff0eb74f4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.56, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ea144bb2adeb688_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9361e12d519e868d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.88, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81c870e00a740b01_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ea802234ba5c2e8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7b4009acc69b0ed_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.17, 0.13, 0.38, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c015f62bcac28445_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.85, 0.01, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db33b67c181ec3f8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.48, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15a51253dcced303_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.1, 0.23, 0.41, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9a4a905d783c7dd4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.18, 0.59, 0.21], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8e56a3857dce606_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.36, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58e48fbf76767f6a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.41, 0.42, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1dc2fc50956dbcb0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.23, 0.42, 0.23, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4c2b7fb748e5a5e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.74, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_370de51125f45b5e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.62, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f428efdd9a4a0155_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.23, 0.25, 0.29, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a01be49c4097605e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.2, 0.1, 0.39, 0.24, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f129805779ef6d21_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6e4fcd30dbc7a32_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.29, 0.25, 0.19, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d942539a900f2f25_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba4aaf47feea6888_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca69647250e5348e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01e259f0de8e7e82_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.88, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88cd43ac604132a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.39, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d5dc03fe74a872e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.19, 0.28, 0.25, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dfa4f106efa03096_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f78af9b5a5b0af33_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.68, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_21c9bc68f541796d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.33, 0.11, 0.26, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9772df5ab3935d9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.08, 0.43, 0.43, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_18822a5cdee890d8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.75, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38594950802a2aaa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.56, 0.01, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f74641a897ba5f07_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.3, 0.61, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e9e700c0878aa85_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.28, 0.6, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8eaac9c94e5d03ee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.24, 0.23, 0.33, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2765e6561c410c4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.12, 0.13, 0.39, 0.26, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13acc2820cc0b93d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10259af8af35fbe4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.71, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49a2ca9e5bd88f8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.2, 0.13, 0.31, 0.2, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0d3aef03b87c73c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_009b022e08ab74b5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.62, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67d866c99176356e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.8, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3dac17087b62c30b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.92, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a25b65b2a89c6cde_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.16, 0.14, 0.39, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cced490efc6fe3a1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.13, 0.41, 0.29, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9505807fc9a3167_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.3, 0.49, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8276655b5ada2250_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.59, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d226c3ac889b105_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.28, 0.54, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b387976fef2e97c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.26, 0.21, 0.21, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e2527fd52db216c1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.21, 0.43, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23ffcac1cce6ec33_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.09, 0.01, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bdfaa088b3e48989_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_beaab8cb554ef240_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dd1cb4eb523af75_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d80c97929ee9f3bb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.15, 0.84, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55cdc36f5ecbe44e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.23, 0.19, 0.26, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c715ff61fa9ef9a7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_169dcad569e531d0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.13, 0.22, 0.31, 0.21, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e56b1bf080431f10_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.27, 0.09, 0.31, 0.15, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a707c3e30b147f71_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.14, 0.12, 0.39, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_605b5cb348177aca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a471b89d3838be2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_725ec49cb03109a6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.27, 0.7, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee426601e16ac79f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.43, 0.35, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec3752a3e0dfc8ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71158706f3643a84_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.96, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4e9096889813e1c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.04, 0.43, 0.49, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5afe23d40c58f9c3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.92, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00936c68eb273519_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.19, 0.25, 0.29, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ae44a6b7e5913cb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8761c8bc4b9a523_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.26, 0.21, 0.23, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_067125d61f13a4c6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.37, 0.53, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_09cf3eeb271ff65d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.31, 0.55, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b14291aef5a2dc9a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fda15ea033a4e19b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.35, 0.64, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_988343fdaa2db10b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_887cb52f678aab76_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.07, 0.37, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06e1bfe45986c008_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.21, 0.5, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4eac2ceb096d1d2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.12, 0.59, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_225300a2ed35298e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.16, 0.54, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_133632ac68e84e51_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0faae41ca5484655_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.34, 0.48, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_999129bb54db97c3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.8, 0.02, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f81c7d1921d0bba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5067b3a21a8dce61_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.39, 0.16, 0.22, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_11841544fb283fb8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a9b63d6b1625cd1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.07, 0.1, 0.37, 0.34, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0d90bce49de335c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.24, 0.18, 0.3, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d78fbca79e7944bf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.24, 0.23, 0.28, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a42b17e5a18e139e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_186728026fde4888_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47a829af0c36114c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e23752d1928b278_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.81, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b57fe7cd8a734a2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6501a694665dcf6f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3a61f0ad345b264_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.6, 0.37, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57f306f170490d26_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eca81b1224a579ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d6f5f7ce906e6f8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab4582ccc8e9cb1b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.16, 0.15, 0.41, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_833259ebd4bfc0bf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.14, 0.6, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2c9e29ff6af566e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.11, 0.27, 0.44, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_515e6d7494f5da24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.14, 0.43, 0.33, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03ca3d8a3322d4ee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.78, 0.21, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dea6a1751da3e485_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9ac554c1326b728_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ba8d3b9f327f18b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.08, 0.3, 0.48, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b3f28ef7a03e5d5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af62c122e13e5731_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a8b010f15cc603e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88ed3c125ba153cf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.58, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b01cbc52f1df7daa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.11, 0.1, 0.27, 0.3, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c23c78d1581f6202_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b38e8a10d91759e7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b5303e3145ba17b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e5d21dc75f2237f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3eca5be5868fef5a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91ec7023a086dd8a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f83aca5dfddfe600_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec516bacc14ea831_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_30f7f70f699d5041_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.8, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_462cd72b15af52d6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.98, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b74c188a685c307_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.22, 0.25, 0.31, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_710eb4437590fbc1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.11, 0.27, 0.34, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_905549986f1a7eb3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.23, 0.46, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bad1cdac1977705a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cfd3ad5c0d565c7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1016ffec40dc6edb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.14, 0.43, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b0bbdf522343417_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7906366c8a8183ea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.19, 0.22, 0.44, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_196110e0316c4708_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.23, 0.53, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7d2e16a9bf8bce49_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.11, 0.31, 0.46, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac85e127121c4999_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.1, 0.2, 0.34, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bbf05100802de903_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.21, 0.34, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c19b83cbccc5c388_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_473f5381cca31923_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0beb12005b493ac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.36, 0.18, 0.21, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_27f64c0fccd7ee19_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_924d8d775d5ed71a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.58, 0.27, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96d2721da2c5b825_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7448fb1e1dc8ef6a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.17, 0.3, 0.33, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d846fd725daf43f5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.29, 0.43, 0.2, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68f41527f85dead3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.31, 0.18, 0.18, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9a547fc2aeaa159_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5149b9a403327f12_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.35, 0.37, 0.12, 0.12, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d4406ca7ebf4365_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.07, 0.44, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a5e5226c53de0ab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c246447b2e1a189e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.27, 0.27, 0.21, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a09f2f6046d4176e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.48, 0.21, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eeae4ec17fe576a5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.23, 0.18, 0.35, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5c6d2b46788e85b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be3af8f2ac3a5251_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.21, 0.23, 0.29, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25318e8c039aa72d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.62, 0.33, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8e7d7b9b5f0c194_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.69, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_043d5cfa47e991ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.07, 0.13, 0.42, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6136d281f1fa6445_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd8edfc073ac3341_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a5300e940c06a9f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.46, 0.18, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26d35f66060ac180_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8f88ea6ba2be811_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_568e43e2d4dd5d3d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.12, 0.37, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_069a4c36fd6c02e4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.15, 0.27, 0.36, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99c5e7c55fac52e5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_345dc0d676c661a3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.77, 0.23, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6cf2feec9209e81a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94a81f3e6e47c88a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.7, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e524f32d0b2bd9f9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.3, 0.52, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8d15d021b83f77e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.83, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a15511488c5e906d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.7, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a89ba25c692370b2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_912fe7c74d22c7eb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.17, 0.19, 0.21, 0.19, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e35b4da83ea39048_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a707c3e30b147f71_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdcd382fdd257404_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.06, 0.39, 0.41, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4996fa51ceb0b63_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.45, 0.48, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb96b2228e2b0114_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7aded06df5290b8e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.35, 0.17, 0.22, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4c1dfc7c9457db2b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.68, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f455f647631f74ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.27, 0.66, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8373d976e2113f16_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b57eee5d25f46c7b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.39, 0.55, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d942539a900f2f25_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.52, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2602f6f2b89c8790_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.52, 0.45, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ab594fe8817f897_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.13, 0.13, 0.27, 0.32, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e5b1e8b399c29ec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.49, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7267bce22f7fcad7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.91, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d6ca68508098c0f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.25, 0.66, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_455cb532d1800b23_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.59, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1dd04a6a765434a9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_375cf576e7c776e9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.07, 0.0, 0.63], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_508694e78b7683c9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5cfee2f71c05bdfb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b1b8e41fa2951b1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5383239cceeccd8d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78c2c77b1f4de5c7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10fc018248bebe27_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2d29513caab6e24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.11, 0.73, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_faf732b71149b87c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.1, 0.31, 0.39, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5499fb1fad1cbca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.14, 0.18, 0.38, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3009bf8b3969803a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.89, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29371956a4d687cd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34d98b7000e2baff_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_013644cde61732c3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c62d3d2ecc2590fd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.63, 0.35, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b43a8f4e04ed2f3d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ffd6927b13576819_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.59, 0.37, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9d46ff74cc8f472_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7c573563929ee86_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07a646fc2a50472e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81d4ee14ec8f2db0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.18, 0.32, 0.27, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f278627a39c6259f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_059a2fd32d0ae2c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.12, 0.17, 0.26, 0.3, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d60e5df51153323a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95aadbb3a443cea9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0cad56ccd2fdc11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.71, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36ae23213e9149b7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.67, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1016ffec40dc6edb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.8, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba06c1ceab9a4e83_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.51, 0.46, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_584f56b861d7e612_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.25, 0.69, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25812ef76d2e90db_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9201a8baff9ece02_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.29, 0.26, 0.17, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d14c910ce46c5f5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_badfaabf1dee8539_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.21, 0.64, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b70d7431116a96e7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.63, 0.35, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e604c6d9588ce4f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb25d011b2b77583_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.2, 0.4, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d234084be15c3479_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d379257433b00be_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_495be9831b4ec343_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29fee1aceeff4036_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.55, 0.39, 0.02, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9202fb4e61a35ead_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.08, 0.46, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15bd20ebfd49a524_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_545f742029f24e4c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddb1b3d931684256_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b78b562608d90abf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.31, 0.15, 0.23, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_210e64324e573215_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.71, 0.25, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a31b497a6eccd212_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c23a6d49384591a8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d911b8368205401_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.34, 0.42, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_64a63814dafcbb44_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb497ed4dec16afb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.89, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f96318791ef650ac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.32, 0.45, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfb8feae45934967_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.05, 0.95], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ed02725611d1159_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.06, 0.13, 0.43, 0.34, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a639365b37e4c72_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85973da56f484e17_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.13, 0.15, 0.24, 0.28, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50b02636894513ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3eb74c14d0102a3d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_171a5cdeff73a324_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.14, 0.1, 0.31, 0.26, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_483d0562cb89005f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00e2c5936982d693_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_358824d4f61be878_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.67, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdca00d869c82efa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_756aa32d830f060c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_80d83f7b5b5a4928_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.45, 0.24, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2904970c65d1868_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.27, 0.27, 0.26, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b90aefebfd1599ff_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4df685d321a760e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.86, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c44f50ed38299512_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.12, 0.1, 0.35, 0.28, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1716427b4ea8a332_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.18, 0.47, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54e7b40e5a96ea07_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.15, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e458eddac744d3a6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eeae4ec17fe576a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.27, 0.63, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3c6f62d9b325559f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54106c2fd79b3455_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.24, 0.1, 0.38, 0.12, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2131034fd58a2752_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee53c50efa24de24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.25, 0.17, 0.26, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e71ec835c48a782a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c663d5d207866cce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e95e349d766602fd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b13375d2c63ca3a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.24, 0.56, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58b4def726749712_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.27, 0.18, 0.3, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0febfe30f4f537c8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.98, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_233a2b84038ca3c6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.57, 0.01, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_508694e78b7683c9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.31, 0.54, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c663d5d207866cce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.14, 0.2, 0.26, 0.25, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7b84bd0cebbe2de_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.09, 0.01, 0.77], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e17134288a50909_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7198dbf2d313281_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.11, 0.47, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5bbef50580f26289_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.09, 0.4, 0.37, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3c7a99311f322c89_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8861e5cf634e8da5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a848906ca754ff71_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.2, 0.42, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38f855a8aee68c04_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.18, 0.38, 0.24, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4362367219a2f885_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.2, 0.28, 0.29, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39e1b1a3d7f8a866_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ca3f07191591401_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.21, 0.2, 0.2, 0.13, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cac92251cf0231f1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_592975c0a52405ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.24, 0.45, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0cb99ed6ddb68bb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.5, 0.23, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0a1277d82ed00ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c90a5ec003396783_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.65, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae511a8fadd11913_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.66, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00e829fda703cded_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.26, 0.0, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c69465c5bc21ca80_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.24, 0.5, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcb470bfba078263_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26009b6a2d577c7b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.25, 0.42, 0.24, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04fd18da7726df3a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.13, 0.22, 0.24, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8390a3033f0ef105_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.47, 0.35, 0.17], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4cfbb0d8365e7df7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.45, 0.46, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcf276eeba6ae7ab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.26, 0.05, 0.26, 0.17, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57072c742b1a7232_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81dbd7daed20a6e6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_19a41545024064ff_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.23, 0.44, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d15e00a8fcf5ca33_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.34, 0.56, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2820c8d0fb92d299_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.11, 0.29, 0.41, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5df603e21aa09474_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9401feb77bf162a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.08, 0.41, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad13ef1f23849c58_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b38a1021ec57cc8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.16, 0.55, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e24373876ea934b9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.82, 0.17, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57038f26952b492e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8054119f92305c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.12, 0.09, 0.32, 0.37, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cde4ba1a4d8ce8b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.04, 0.96], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6128ffb4d38e36ee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.1, 0.58, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddaeef11b84be303_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.59, 0.33, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7400bda45066436_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.18, 0.45, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f942b76eac08a5ee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92788b4efcfcc4ba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.62, 0.34, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d94a73ee5557edfc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad244a8a577ce115_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fb8f5ee1762d55e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.14, 0.45, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36c91376814dd22d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74e624c21110818e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.71, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9cbf6e7dea05a12_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.15, 0.1, 0.25, 0.22, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2c60265bebe2d4d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.07, 0.92, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b06ed2be4ef6b1c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c63b8c8c4fa5ab11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.79, 0.17, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17777de2c92c76f1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.13, 0.44, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45d2feb2c1001c42_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.56, 0.41, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2f3ea8003e9bc5c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.63, 0.2], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce7d44ca598de989_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1f7e52e6cd3b1f3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1756212e7fabf39d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.33, 0.54, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b22570a7bd10d3d6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29c3f1790575114e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e3e5cd68e303a9f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.28, 0.18, 0.26, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_845b7821e052aa94_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.32, 0.63, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63ae634682986406_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_037f8ad389eb3785_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.16, 0.61, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2eacae7898cc8471_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.11, 0.23, 0.49, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f861f40b286ff8df_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.15, 0.23, 0.26, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d48c67b908af469_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.15, 0.25, 0.42, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2489801cefd913cb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.27, 0.29, 0.25, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6d14d74dd7467fc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1414, 0.2727, 0.1818, 0.2929, 0.101, 0.0101], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4db14457a0572441_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.33, 0.19, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6e6fe728abef407c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_09a40e88c929299f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a26ab97bce2ff3d5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.89, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_010ef6aa9d8967dc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.71, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7347d29c16aaf2cd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.45, 0.55, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb68605efc2c57e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.22, 0.14, 0.32, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_859b05a56e4fbebe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.23, 0.49, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d125dd130a81dc1d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b257fdb7758e32e7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.09, 0.34, 0.48, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1faabc82b847b7a0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b27b267ae4c103dc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.29, 0.18, 0.23, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1e2077f11b2e870_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.16, 0.06, 0.28, 0.28, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0984569104b23a45_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.08, 0.37, 0.47, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c489283c6d52de1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b04f7777615759fb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a9fcf208113a015_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.19, 0.22, 0.35, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa5b601e2ab2379b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.2, 0.01, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd52058f17240b50_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.56, 0.14, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_998b9e8aaffa0c06_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.6, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03ff63ac08b1d82e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_182acd065d4c85b3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb98cf3caa5052b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be80cfb3e7ffb835_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.31, 0.23, 0.25, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea096e40bc78f97b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.78, 0.14, 0.01, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84f9ae76d5ce1afd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5ce52a7d70fe7cd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4280d5dbac4a006e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29fb750721510769_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b61338592a87895_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.18, 0.26, 0.33, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90ec9ad2095f07ce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.78, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_025dc0740efb4ff9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1d98f91130f15fb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7707d7f93b6e4fee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_325119182c46f76e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.22, 0.1, 0.36, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0baf8363951a1e41_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.29, 0.6, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4abaa027500be947_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.29, 0.17, 0.32, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13ee8acff45ea3e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.1, 0.63, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ea2b30907983dce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0101, 0.0505, 0.2525, 0.5556, 0.1313, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e42e732428a7a1bf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.35, 0.21, 0.21, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb8168c36183ff1c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.05, 0.48, 0.43, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_987084ddb3738555_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.88, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_30526f5697674e94_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.27, 0.65, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82be5100c3b8df0a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.84, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddecaa6debf6a289_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8dd6cf677376c2f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b8f8fb18ec82fe9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.69, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6926092d0fbf42ab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.34, 0.3, 0.15, 0.16, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f76bea705f39865c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.74, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94702060630acfd0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.19, 0.18, 0.39, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0009e18f5b189e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50b02636894513ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.2, 0.07, 0.34, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_809f06afb9ed27fe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.72, 0.26, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17e6cacb54ca16e8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fb3d9413901b46b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31109ee3d91cbd23_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d45aa02f84ceccef_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db84b49a8a2b69d2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1dd04a6a765434a9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.84, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b26191c7d977f634_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.4, 0.41, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3758f9a04e75cae5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.46, 0.03, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3dcd25299e46f439_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.3, 0.28, 0.17, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8edfa71852a3aee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.05, 0.04, 0.36, 0.38, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cf122332f4d63841_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.17, 0.54, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fda15ea033a4e19b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.15, 0.43, 0.32, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a7a5af9f572c2fd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.26, 0.61, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_017ecd1123796e24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.51, 0.45, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e891c0870b7562a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4eb6a5a7f7d0b1fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e411c7a1f7dc1d68_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.72, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc2d36b41cb15b70_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.08, 0.16, 0.54, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39d521722e7d1f94_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.09, 0.3, 0.44, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b38b1be52944e2d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c09b0adffb4485e8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_768c8fbb52c8f38c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.44, 0.55, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_266a29d48bdfac69_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.57, 0.37, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dcd07e0be7b830fa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.32, 0.26, 0.15, 0.21, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dd20067c634e925_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.41, 0.18, 0.19, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2869cf8c3b48d5bb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f570edc83a356db_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.31, 0.68, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_09a40e88c929299f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.52, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_caf41e4893a6fca3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.65, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_028c3814ad3113e3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef4823036a267f61_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15e676a1899a10da_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.36, 0.61, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_beefe3844a73d87d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.45, 0.28, 0.11, 0.13, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_064abd09c5af6910_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.1, 0.59, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3016b431f6819140_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67d866c99176356e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.09, 0.15, 0.38, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4bdc40866b042bad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.95, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2809d8d0c8a941f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_69289eab656961b0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.22, 0.39, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e23752d1928b278_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_411c6c1a92152cd9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.94, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad822f4eb69ba64a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b401deebf5f444eb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a44f4ae329bf9d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.36, 0.44, 0.16], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f942b76eac08a5ee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.09, 0.31, 0.45, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ebefe032dc3af51_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfb8feae45934967_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.29, 0.08, 0.24, 0.11, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f67b3b7d4dec1491_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8dd6cf677376c2f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.24, 0.26, 0.34, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9373fabb1115421f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.83, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6972e646ea5959b2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.43, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67d06245b0ad385f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.07, 0.08, 0.39, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f089311be06ddef3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.1, 0.61, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c62845d48644785c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.65, 0.34, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ab836d0dcd84ee0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.89, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e0e124804b9ca06_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.09, 0.23, 0.33, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a1e47e7f12a6b56_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cdd20fae554d60e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.11, 0.1, 0.46, 0.21, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c51e933af9af5c3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.9, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8bc7737f415f21f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.71, 0.23, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2539342466cb8ab4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84bc2db0db9c6889_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4617f9dd111311a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.15, 0.22, 0.27, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b512b5e4d87d7eb6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.08, 0.57, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6f192c347301ba6a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b69d64509f4c082a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.12, 0.37, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8dea2e4e3eee809b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_211396c7c3fca64a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.73, 0.05, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acf46ede60128b4a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.24, 0.17, 0.36, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84bc2db0db9c6889_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.7, 0.15, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e0b96c6ef8ea614_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.12, 0.37, 0.31, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22c7bb3cc7db6254_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2430cc20bd82e5ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_508694e78b7683c9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.19, 0.43, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb13f118ae49dcb3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.12, 0.47, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82be5100c3b8df0a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.24, 0.56, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f736dbb9aa8d084f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.03, 0.05, 0.34, 0.51, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03133a3484c1356f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.61, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_583e34b06b333196_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.84, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5fd62b80f6dee1e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7fe5d220025dc5c2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd4a74a1c8c5fac5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_919fee624df1c11c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.11, 0.43, 0.34, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c7d156f4b6bb1b4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.27, 0.09, 0.27, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0104fb6afdba011c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c79379f276e0724_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.45, 0.54, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f7ff3fdd0d2e8bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.12, 0.19, 0.39, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75c8ced6f2f31674_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.62, 0.31, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_263e2d07f8267165_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.84, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e067f83b1bcd1e50_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d94a73ee5557edfc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.93, 0.07, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d88421419165887_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.36, 0.59, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91199c6bc9048392_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.32, 0.57, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af2ca37f7ea3c954_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.87, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f90a3a7483f8d00f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a1577e2ca538cdc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34e25626bc0e6dab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.06, 0.29, 0.54, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_085ba6f426efe4d3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f2560ef2994428f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8812ea149eac7c7a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a5b096d6c0b94b8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6e6fe728abef407c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.07, 0.2, 0.53, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a09f2f6046d4176e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.22, 0.5, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c63e879a56cc720_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.16, 0.27, 0.33, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c112cdcd04f5d6d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.86, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59d6294125026ae6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.15, 0.37, 0.34, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee8661a4dc9336cf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.12, 0.39, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0231e855776efbb4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.15, 0.12, 0.27, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e64756f4ea258a22_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.19, 0.68, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41cd6483cdb98166_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.06, 0.07, 0.28, 0.46, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_32dabb9b6c73f99d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.41, 0.56, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22c7bb3cc7db6254_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.62, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6de4cfa81ab22873_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.2, 0.15, 0.26, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78b58eebb65885ca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.29, 0.55, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fc4f6ab949defd7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ffd6f2d174633d7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79f0768a129efce3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.36, 0.31, 0.13, 0.16, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac3aadc60435612f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.31, 0.31, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_786876963cacfb54_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.19, 0.32, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58fa6ff32d1b15ea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.16, 0.58, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6e6fe728abef407c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.53, 0.47, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f512f2395f7dc2e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.28, 0.18, 0.16, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c18c499a0ccf92f0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8df45f14adb49414_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.24, 0.12, 0.26, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61b7b7a21c4165d1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.16, 0.59, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5899e8ad4e78be1a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6e1cd55748bb693_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b231790ccfaf542e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f47ce6e07c9e01e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31246ae345df3c6b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.44, 0.51, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5910ef9ecdb08021_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.22, 0.18, 0.3, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c1fbb39c6c4935a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.26, 0.21, 0.25, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d7cc8a1e4138741_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78ad06466c3a2bb1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.09, 0.17, 0.48, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99dda34017b96321_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.75, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b203234d2b9b8cc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12056675f35933c9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3a19e6edf329478_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.67, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dcffd95f3e2c493c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.31, 0.01, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c951d3eaa4dfb33_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.15, 0.44, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8172863914d4989_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.27, 0.52, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43b89ce30c56f811_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.86, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0480a9c26a0bc766_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.33, 0.6, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d27546d829934c7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.16, 0.41, 0.32, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c397030500c6aeed_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.93, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2eacae7898cc8471_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.84, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_786876963cacfb54_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.74, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b427a36ff8c9217_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a27257ddd6b6e235_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.76, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_348ec7f945569dfc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b38674d3b4b84b92_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3426983da89424f2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.89, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aed6615a1c2517db_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.16, 0.23, 0.36, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ebef78954483e88_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.12, 0.4, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bff5e03042a3b53c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_624785ff8eb04b19_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.08, 0.14, 0.45, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_141f8b3e078161cc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.2, 0.04, 0.23, 0.16, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d470d65b05ea96c0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.16, 0.78, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4df685d321a760e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.15, 0.34, 0.36, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1769ea99f7ed821d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72e849921ff1b13e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.23, 0.69, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98a8b2fbad46a9da_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.7, 0.01, 0.16], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9b9318248e6c799_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.91, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_563e642da0580b2e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_605b5cb348177aca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.02, 0.86, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ceff4ea4c60301a4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.58, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5910ef9ecdb08021_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.93, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_772bc2735d3fe0e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99c263c3583cad23_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00534ee46533ac59_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6bd01c191db322c7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fa5324ba75bd6c7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.82, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acba33ccf6514d92_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.94, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a44f4ae329bf9d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.23, 0.42, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_809f06afb9ed27fe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_700c2af0678f68cc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fd3983dda979497_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46b2ce16e616d89a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47c323c3d2bb0bc8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c63e879a56cc720_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.95, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6185f252539612d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.29, 0.11, 0.21, 0.13, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15013f8c4711e849_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.05, 0.95], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95b9dda94e5e588e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_426ab197b4ce44f9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c7a1e23786f4d4d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0eb04e55399c6b45_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.27, 0.58, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6e7bb1302337d0a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae511a8fadd11913_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.11, 0.22, 0.53, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f089311be06ddef3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.94, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af662594cec46263_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.13, 0.27, 0.33, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4594ebe9afc46ab0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.51, 0.04, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d328c9d7076cf530_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.1, 0.17, 0.43, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a9c20fa4df9191f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.82, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e2160dd6f162d49_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1dfd635a575ae02c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb59ccda17a518ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b2a8662f2d56d50_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.12, 0.34, 0.34, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5588c72dd2fd659a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.39, 0.56, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f26306b0972f3789_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.08, 0.34, 0.43, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ceff4ea4c60301a4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82fafc5fb8470a1f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.91, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5823c57ca95beff3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b79603b438f1cde7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.83, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f232bbc81fd69089_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cde9f88c14265e87_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.94, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46343f0392a90078_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.6, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6b7e1bc0cd8afdd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.74, 0.25, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_beebf83b4171be26_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.32, 0.5, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa1ab0db77e7fe94_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.16, 0.35, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43cd639dd36b84e2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.98, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac936dfec986746e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.79, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_520a9d0ae2fe46a3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.32, 0.26, 0.16, 0.21, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c37e1972dc49403_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.83, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48943a615774c9d0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.23, 0.31, 0.25, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d3d05628c9f54b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d7f84b9d3060d9da_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.32, 0.64, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b37063d5f197ef0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.02, 0.04, 0.29, 0.57, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f4e9656333f667c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e16818a8d63caf3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.22, 0.12, 0.35, 0.14, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5588c72dd2fd659a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9d62ed2209aa9ec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.81, 0.08, 0.01, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10259af8af35fbe4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.06, 0.14, 0.48, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcbd545378decdd8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.44, 0.51, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ece71cce84eab9f7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6de1b76cea1dfcbe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.04, 0.96], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f7cb434924533d5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.81, 0.19, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8359be577c136ad9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.28, 0.18, 0.24, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68f41527f85dead3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa23dfc2e035dd8b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b04f7777615759fb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.27, 0.18, 0.24, 0.04, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6f8c588427ad8d9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.27, 0.15, 0.34, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_582e762dd2332488_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.22, 0.36, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88bd8671239c3bdc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.62, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92b0a7da695164dc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.6, 0.38, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0ede698a97c829c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.25, 0.44, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c67c26be5324af14_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.21, 0.51, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c74dfd598980efc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c24b2f86a1c336dd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78b777a9145ec999_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.09, 0.12, 0.51, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa07d54dddb323ea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1111, 0.8081, 0.0707, 0.0101], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4fe15e7b27ca1a64_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.36, 0.15, 0.25, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6e64d5182210cd5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15840c15ff28932e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.32, 0.19, 0.27, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fbfc0437c073e75_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.81, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e597224516b6fba3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1901208013bc1aab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.63, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_badfaabf1dee8539_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66094535c1e608f3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d6f84bce5ef5fdb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ea028e2f5422b69_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8172863914d4989_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.44, 0.03, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dae38be1bd4451dc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.29, 0.43, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd614d02adb48171_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.16, 0.17, 0.17, 0.17, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03061856f9a3a150_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72674c4a3100ee77_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f64190dca26d5cf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.21, 0.23, 0.32, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb230fe65670a237_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_677998e4f5581771_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_306c5cc0ec1ec91a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.19, 0.34, 0.33, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50165a3c0724445b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.77, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88cf29c8724ae6c8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.13, 0.07, 0.33, 0.27, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17e6cacb54ca16e8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.16, 0.39, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddaeef11b84be303_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff8bdebac5f3fa6b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.78, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f70524738c34e6cb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.59, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_64a63814dafcbb44_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.15, 0.37, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6e7bb1302337d0a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.31, 0.22, 0.18, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab03b28159be92b3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6703c953e2dffcc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.04, 0.31, 0.59, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40bb320bebccc92d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.6, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a42585b698fd460_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.49, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7228045a18f14ee0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.34, 0.2, 0.16, 0.13, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7387c350356d325e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47047be2c096f4c1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.11, 0.28, 0.49, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b205053c5302e67_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.12, 0.33, 0.34, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_640c321b87f63fb5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.76, 0.01, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_353cd8dd73270852_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22a194bdf0ec4876_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8119c14ff01f166_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.5, 0.43, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_225300a2ed35298e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.46, 0.19, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5fffc439470ea70_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.34, 0.64, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d62ec8f3b3b0529_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.12, 0.56, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8141cb9a15ff9e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.41, 0.52, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_188949afce8abc5f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.54, 0.01, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d492104989ff4ec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d546e99b21a977dc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.35, 0.48, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13ee8acff45ea3e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.42, 0.16, 0.11, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3446cd3e64db2624_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.07, 0.93], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f9cb946ba8305d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.63, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5067b3a21a8dce61_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0404, 0.6869, 0.2727, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_428ee68e1664ec1a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.09, 0.48, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fb3138d76999487_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.03, 0.29, 0.63, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e955c73f3dc30554_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0a1669a13720b51_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.67, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff38fc13fa0f3732_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_431c692d9be8f0f5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.1, 0.17, 0.33, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0aae7adc9d07432_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.8, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b838de754c03fa24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.26, 0.34, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1093c01951de545_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15c889b8dcb4115a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.8, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e64015fc9f4c3f57_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.74, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_583e34b06b333196_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.19, 0.34, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4e21bd1ee0c6300_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.37, 0.52, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee8aa095c97bcaf0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.21, 0.21, 0.31, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_479d261cc937d866_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.13, 0.15, 0.21, 0.33, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99dda34017b96321_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.32, 0.17, 0.25, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4203d79b11befa7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff8956041ecda4d3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.24, 0.27, 0.2, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7525745dc365e91b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.27, 0.38, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3285d91e3d8e0547_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5cfee2f71c05bdfb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.08, 0.31, 0.49, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4328a05ea866f370_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.2, 0.38, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bff5e03042a3b53c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.79, 0.1, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9a3f944e239effe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.2, 0.09, 0.26, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bac33d524cdef3d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b160d098e8223177_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.02, 0.74, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10fc018248bebe27_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.25, 0.2, 0.31, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05a8da665bb02b0f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_27ef4cb7a1d58f8e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb879da9369b760e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.31, 0.31, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1756212e7fabf39d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a78a9a4c2c1414eb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.97, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2114999d7e453a7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94284c091bfbe5a8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1589eb1edb963933_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d32835cec8826855_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1973f1b948090ea3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.95, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_209a9953e20a7ea8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.65, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_411aa2e45fc2323e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.25, 0.28, 0.17, 0.09, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36e835f6e96cfe1c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c39217ba6084b3b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.23, 0.21, 0.33, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43bba879bf04885b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.17, 0.1, 0.28, 0.28, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d93febb78cc12531_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.91, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6e4fcd30dbc7a32_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a30f1abaf564706d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.13, 0.2, 0.39, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3800aa310f735135_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94284c091bfbe5a8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.81, 0.12, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4c075f0e16564f54_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_075ce3026e952ced_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd863e4a3013af11_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.27, 0.19, 0.24, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68ea0f3d1a52cf15_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a89ba25c692370b2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.75, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b6ed6bf81b13eee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.05, 0.31, 0.45, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5eef09a50a82fad3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ae9254d5c32ba37_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.09, 0.42, 0.36, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f7cb434924533d5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_211396c7c3fca64a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.09, 0.27, 0.43, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1a4cad39a9de69d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec4804228b33e596_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9006bd5a380416bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.27, 0.16, 0.38, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7bcacccd9793f5a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.94, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_240412d633914396_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.17, 0.45, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55b60e789d22f55f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fef8ade02ddb231_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.47, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4937403766b9908d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5ef113e2faad60e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ead4e334d514c361_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.1, 0.29, 0.38, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2acecb96b39f7f5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.19, 0.09, 0.35, 0.22, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1e2b6dd7183192b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.37, 0.59, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_080b7948b739f609_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22d11d9e20d93128_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.21, 0.3, 0.28, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_272e46c5ceb33bb9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.3, 0.25, 0.11, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1828839efcae0c15_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f91ef21d6968f82b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7c44a7c0976ef24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.86, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42d28d8f36309d35_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.14, 0.47, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9105151aae33f4de_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0a1669a13720b51_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10774b0ce08b75d9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f319369f1e9d7de_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.31, 0.18, 0.23, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_11cd18fbd2f6f433_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.35, 0.2, 0.22, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3ceaa9011c05854_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.08, 0.51, 0.39, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb5f3a160a6e7df6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.2, 0.61, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f09c787da6254468_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.32, 0.21, 0.15, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d47e1559d395009_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.83, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_450e54fc0290866c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.18, 0.35, 0.35, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0b510700ccfa95_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_859b05a56e4fbebe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ab818ba1db1b7a9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6be9cae69b2043e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.81, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60028da33842baf9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.96, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd7f9579c876e1f1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01e14cdff0ea4d75_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8ef4c4099eb2dc8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.86, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5295cce379eefbce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_341645cd55f06293_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.37, 0.27, 0.12, 0.17, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1f8e0a32b15949b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07a646fc2a50472e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.97, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_70f137fea64fe0bd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.49, 0.47, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f6638f1ee2daa2d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.14, 0.22, 0.34, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a80813929f199647_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.88, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0b3606435c55762_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.61, 0.35, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b54ccff71388b7e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.6, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_700c2af0678f68cc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.96, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_69289eab656961b0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76f2d4c8146e1c5e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.06, 0.0, 0.71], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_473b9056ad865a61_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.13, 0.47, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1c4de7bda344186_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.46, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6e9c4c1c298e22a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a5cd2638f4f3746_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.46, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8119c14ff01f166_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.06, 0.1, 0.37, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00f47dac6d9b44d5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39e1b1a3d7f8a866_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.07, 0.29, 0.53, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62352236253150e2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b776ffd28d74d24c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c7ae87577c293d9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.14, 0.35, 0.34, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dbc47c89d137c07_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5288d4302a5f595b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.23, 0.23, 0.24, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb1c03b506d81aec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.04, 0.96], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5295cce379eefbce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.56, 0.4, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8986e51334b11b4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d5231c83acc6d84f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fb8f5ee1762d55e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.31, 0.46, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b100fb38dbf7e8fb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.19, 0.34, 0.31, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84a42dbf81a7906a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.94, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b0e96ec824f2885_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.25, 0.18, 0.33, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cedc4428541bc17_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89865bec92ed175b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.94, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88684eb281547e56_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.88, 0.1, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_affa7c28e10845e1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f068121ec7f4f7e1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.14, 0.56, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77248188395dc186_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9a4a905d783c7dd4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba04302a009418ee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9ded394acdd6fa8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.09, 0.29, 0.43, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0510a9a1f3eb5954_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.73, 0.05, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_686124f5a952a032_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.19, 0.2, 0.31, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_668b244710dd206f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.63, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03ff63ac08b1d82e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.26, 0.16, 0.34, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a9b63d6b1625cd1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.87, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45d2feb2c1001c42_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2afda46ea41a797_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e27059583f7bc69d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.13, 0.23, 0.36, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5579c4b5093ae7b9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.86, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d07efc090b7f04c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03a9f445e748f0f8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.75, 0.09, 0.01, 0.15], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5c8038d0438afde_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.07, 0.33, 0.48, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dfd2ccdeafd37ff9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.16, 0.33, 0.44, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0778ddc2552d1d3b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b0b4a66859092dd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.17, 0.0, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55230b512fff71fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.4, 0.36, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9772df5ab3935d9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_067125d61f13a4c6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.26, 0.22, 0.25, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f601fb271f6f612b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.1, 0.26, 0.38, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_740dea955ef0f525_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.75, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87ac1426751498d0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.13, 0.25, 0.4, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae6bbe7238f9bc38_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.38, 0.24, 0.17, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74c58ac5e0beda89_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1b1a25711bcea68_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_090c98f8f3b89fdc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.39, 0.38, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dabc9bbe9c19aeda_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.13, 0.35, 0.2, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d656dde86ddff97_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b3f28ef7a03e5d5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.22, 0.62, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5d24c3bce51dc0c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.16, 0.68, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_066b37a6808537cb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.22, 0.15, 0.34, 0.17, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63a253fef7750195_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.38, 0.01, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_53ba4720d9461da9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.17, 0.33, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_551b89dbfc52377f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.16, 0.22, 0.33, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8569afc62e08276a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ed4493131adb055_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cffcc2ba66c060cb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.66, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be49d2379c3f8e20_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.08, 0.91, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81d4ee14ec8f2db0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.3, 0.62, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92d0451b45e0009f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.92, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6663ac2be04cdeb5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67ead6b218e82974_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.15, 0.7, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d942539a900f2f25_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.03, 0.02, 0.33, 0.48, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4abcd43c9a88fa91_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.3, 0.18, 0.2, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_305aca5edd04dd34_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.13, 0.31, 0.42, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e16609b9dc59cc0b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.11, 0.51, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_710222e0cee323b0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.05, 0.31, 0.51, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcd5a633bfc1c857_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.06, 0.32, 0.47, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38842b17388a2725_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.9, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c7ae87577c293d9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01bc743ede1fd90d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.11, 0.45, 0.32, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b176f60dd1bcbe1c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.29, 0.51, 0.01, 0.19], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5a2f976d93ad1a1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.1, 0.44, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54d981a44c9040a2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55cdc36f5ecbe44e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.78, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bbee4b07ce71cf50_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_554d0f1262bc23e3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9baa01c777320194_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.97, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_afdd13db35af8544_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.52, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35d7bd13fcd7e653_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.12, 0.12, 0.35, 0.29, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3c538ce172346b6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.62, 0.2, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74cdcf04a4fda3ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d26a129709561014_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_441b0f63bc3806bd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.16, 0.42, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10489f20265c8779_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.79, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a16e1c79252e754_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.65, 0.28, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_822f6c6ff0b15ed3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.47, 0.42, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5fc00cae355aad9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.16, 0.15, 0.29, 0.24, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22c7bb3cc7db6254_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.19, 0.35, 0.3, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8529b1b58bca5dc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.59, 0.18, 0.02, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f8bea13351143a8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.76, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_297c9262a928864b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_622476f10045f8df_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec8cda071d844cdc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a18b7a9be96fdfdc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.64, 0.19, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7fe978590bd9c66_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eecb916b31a8691c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.13, 0.28, 0.24, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99ed03fa649c5c99_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.23, 0.06, 0.32, 0.13, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_df08aa5b203c3f97_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f69c4384d940c19_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da97b5b619ba76f1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.08, 0.47, 0.35, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_993b9f22d533b2e1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.14, 0.19, 0.38, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2929e272de6497d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3945bf0231c20f23_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.31, 0.44, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a910b764d3444cba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.24, 0.33, 0.25, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ea2b30907983dce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25318e8c039aa72d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.19, 0.39, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b288b8b079cd0de0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.12, 0.36, 0.3, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5afe23d40c58f9c3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.2, 0.47, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6b86c2fa42ddd50_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.13, 0.3, 0.36, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2273ae6d05637af1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81312664a028af6b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.16, 0.01, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00e2c5936982d693_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.21, 0.38, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d1e933fcf40b8bb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.54, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da8f2e680adadd55_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_043d5cfa47e991ec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.61, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0445ba81031084_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.17, 0.69, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d30bb39122f3bf8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.97, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d659d938261c8bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.12, 0.32, 0.33, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d47e1559d395009_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.14, 0.38, 0.34, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0da7ad42b232c868_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b06925b9476c3dff_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba4aaf47feea6888_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.63, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50eb2752aff4a9ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.39, 0.49, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c222c4aeb5aae066_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.24, 0.22, 0.33, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0231e855776efbb4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.81, 0.19, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_70ff45fca556b5ce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.28, 0.19, 0.32, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75740e522fb17909_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.17, 0.31, 0.39, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8681059042263e6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.11, 0.36, 0.34, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bf00e3ab45393d8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_70f137fea64fe0bd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.24, 0.2, 0.22, 0.12, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50eb2752aff4a9ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f1c6411338cc93e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.29, 0.71, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74c58ac5e0beda89_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.56, 0.29, 0.0, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3b4f134290499b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcaba9b3a072961e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de914d2c39df5630_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_18535c3ce887857a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_716586c4941c5525_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79b07270c09f2521_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23ce4baf3279eb9a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.11, 0.46, 0.33, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_633d80f46605efca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_492e3a6070a1619d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.08, 0.4, 0.38, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c90a5ec003396783_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43bba879bf04885b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.78, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12e359990068825e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.38, 0.32, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_980e74dc6c9fda8a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.65, 0.35, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e73add9e4eb4e0a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.2, 0.68, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c5203c805417fd7b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c36431b0b43be806_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.09, 0.38, 0.47, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c654038aabb0d88b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fbcf9150d4f7890_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5354, 0.2727, 0.0505, 0.1414], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb40daae90024c24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.13, 0.52, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e74f6283f9d39ed_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b74f4ac18e62ed27_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1e764f9a3f530dac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.27, 0.7, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95aadbb3a443cea9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.08, 0.76, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c802f7798fd16378_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.79, 0.14, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4ab42c7f2c8a066_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d1ddf8b034c9adb9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.56, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f2b3c8196bd530a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3ed21dbe30c7d30_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c10c7b2e5882862f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.79, 0.19, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcf276eeba6ae7ab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.86, 0.11, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_948c5286e5c3b046_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2f458e475e06f4e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.11, 0.42, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00832a8ce8346485_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.32, 0.25, 0.22, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_015f125b4424cbf2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79cdeb281651daaf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c73c382f5c6e3e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.17, 0.34, 0.3, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9566a1ccfb4ccf2b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.64, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0da9b4b81b5b270_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.25, 0.23, 0.26, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66d940237e05c815_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.17, 0.24, 0.34, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b64bafeedf0e88c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.28, 0.45, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b0d89024ad447e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.02, 0.67, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8340850e3babfe8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.58, 0.32, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_451ee627e372d206_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.42, 0.28, 0.15, 0.12, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29bfb6a9eeb03b1e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.1, 0.17, 0.35, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f683487f579a0d92_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.31, 0.17, 0.23, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd3718eaaa282606_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a28b9475ee217ee8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.56, 0.3, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fc2ecd7d5151e0b5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.89, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb06a16190f12a4a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.78, 0.17, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_551b89dbfc52377f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.56, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8390a3033f0ef105_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f44bf7278dce2b4d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5de76799b5f1817d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eee726f11d9216c1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6aa98242c2deb609_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc3f4db3558e8ad8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.38, 0.5, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab4c1431ac2f6ea9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.27, 0.36, 0.26, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3eca5be5868fef5a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.1, 0.44, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe72b0e51ee9ada7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ae04c8e66e5866e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c36431b0b43be806_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.59, 0.23, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee8661a4dc9336cf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.96, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd24ce2e54a27517_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.17, 0.61, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d37906e56f857b0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.01, 0.85, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97af7ee9f4fe0bd8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.07, 0.93], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd21ad440378078f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07c338287080a96d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.69, 0.24, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ccbe5f87fc08fd86_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3800aa310f735135_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.11, 0.52, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04fd18da7726df3a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.85, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_568e43e2d4dd5d3d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.69, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2f458e475e06f4e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34acfabc0fc62213_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.27, 0.47, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c82cb96c076b836d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6a72cbc4b9472f7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_11ad00bd642f10ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.3, 0.52, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5fffc439470ea70_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1f7e52e6cd3b1f3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.16, 0.31, 0.34, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cedc4428541bc17_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.16, 0.48, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_882937067cd19159_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ed11d840dbb3d5e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.23, 0.24, 0.25, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7b365ddddece4ff_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.72, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c39deb783493e7c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.8, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_124e033a99c2fb04_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.16, 0.03, 0.14], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cd8baa9010aa2f1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.26, 0.58, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acf46ede60128b4a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.46, 0.49, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59c340a77a18629f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.55, 0.31, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e1b69e9cbd80cb6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.04, 0.75, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8080ded628bf2b8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.14, 0.35, 0.28, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_794ec1aa944f2239_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f25436f19a64749_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.1, 0.32, 0.45, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd8edfc073ac3341_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.16, 0.71, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4328a05ea866f370_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ffb7fce2e0158c97_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.74, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b25ca7192758167e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa23dfc2e035dd8b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.46, 0.3, 0.11, 0.1, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e71b1071bd1d6062_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.91, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84df3f73826a79be_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d93f62b3566bb9d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba04302a009418ee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.53, 0.45, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_742a4dd8289ab775_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.93, 0.06, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5a53945828c6240_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.36, 0.2, 0.2, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7873ca98cd8ba86e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.27, 0.17, 0.17, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cc2432992123bff_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.26, 0.15, 0.24, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10561bd9ddcab47b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.21, 0.53, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c7a1e23786f4d4d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.18, 0.66, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb8b0ff9c4677590_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.37, 0.5, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e327632ab80b9b31_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.19, 0.01, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf389f2ce1c5b6b8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.21, 0.14, 0.36, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4998dce24f528325_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.16, 0.38, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41bdb26f9b530ad8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.2, 0.69, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe8d92be547e687a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4a698d027c9e812_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.78, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_139a3e406064c1ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_768c8fbb52c8f38c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b938cb25ed3b0725_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c5be2593a9da4b2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.58, 0.02, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34acfabc0fc62213_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.31, 0.17, 0.24, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3934ef13917db101_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.28, 0.25, 0.3, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_585d1d60667f78ab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a8d40ab5653ddd0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_afbf025f3785dacb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5714009eae45399_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.2, 0.31, 0.29, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb00cf2fdd62ccad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.17, 0.25, 0.42, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b09c34b598f44aa2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.28, 0.13, 0.29, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1026df530e81b7b8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_753d3f6f1602f7dd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.86, 0.0, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66c1ac70538876af_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.15, 0.23, 0.47, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7c7a247b903e451_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.49, 0.03, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35719f9cb9689a76_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.17, 0.4, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e71ec835c48a782a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.73, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10489f20265c8779_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.17, 0.2, 0.4, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49dcb68ae674c72_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.54, 0.33, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7df5f7fe204d945e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.62, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e51f462983a2bce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.06, 0.13, 0.43, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_437efcb8afc69293_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15892e0af59af9b2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_229260b0581b67c4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.37, 0.13, 0.16, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c5203c805417fd7b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.24, 0.53, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_231dd69ad5870e3e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.15, 0.24, 0.39, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da97b5b619ba76f1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.3, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d58f03f0d6e01ce2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.04, 0.09, 0.47, 0.33, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_964c82945fed01ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c67ade09d4fafcd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0891ac5a0f355694_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.32, 0.14, 0.29, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f4851282ab417e1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9022dc160bb7d83_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.76, 0.07, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3b5b8472a172147_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf847bdcdeaed7ef_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb497ed4dec16afb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.27, 0.42, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_128128f05aac6f39_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.1, 0.68, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_987084ddb3738555_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f48d3b754167c08b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5cda0a095301545_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.07, 0.28, 0.52, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22a1256effcee9f6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.16, 0.28, 0.43, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c9a4715916f6a21_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.11, 0.71, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01bc743ede1fd90d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a51c5e2bfba0dca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.13, 0.18, 0.36, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8373d976e2113f16_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.57, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7de238ac29e04893_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.16, 0.54, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab82b93547f56e98_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9878b0524212015_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.24, 0.12, 0.24, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b63e18f55f7c7765_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34c8f10c74909c69_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f76bea705f39865c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.21, 0.53, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d1f8d6e9dda3724_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89c065dc9eac2d92_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d0a059d90bf5300_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_52fefc32b62e11fe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.92, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cde9f88c14265e87_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.07, 0.34, 0.42, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98037b7867162646_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.19, 0.75, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41dff1b21b2dff7c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.16, 0.37, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef01a0bba123dd34_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.72, 0.23, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49dcb68ae674c72_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aec93cafcc1e3d94_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5933560d9a5e10d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.55, 0.4, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c4a177905d24ebb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.9, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf043b8da232b120_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d60bc9d71716899f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4785d783ac3f8563_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.49, 0.49, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc2803229f4a4b94_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.28, 0.18, 0.43, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e327632ab80b9b31_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66339b1f067715c6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f4851282ab417e1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.05, 0.21, 0.6, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7b68bacd74b733d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b159a46a8c8feae1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10561bd9ddcab47b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.54, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48b8be86a3d382fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_922435ff689e8d08_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.01, 0.67, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4e3023e2e121a10_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.47, 0.48, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e5e44806cffbc0b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.16, 0.27, 0.38, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf412ae6628d2989_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b15382332aaf44b2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.09, 0.16, 0.48, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dcf7738e84a2a333_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.86, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a53d545421761987_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.07, 0.08, 0.54, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fa5324ba75bd6c7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.09, 0.47, 0.4, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbd390dc712d7916_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36c91376814dd22d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.12, 0.37, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1d9d1aed9fd28e4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.14, 0.44, 0.25, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f3c56918168153d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.95, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2736514b6bdcf013_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.11, 0.2, 0.44, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee7eddd9fc79aa87_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.88, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1776b22ac0d43cd7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_868d306babf637ea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.59, 0.39, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_907b5a67393eaf63_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ae23a4a025e35bd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c7bd247a47428cc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_010d3cdb6e33b340_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.14, 0.39, 0.39, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06e1bfe45986c008_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.47, 0.41, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5c8038d0438afde_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.43, 0.34, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e82851c8e1efcdaa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e05b90b0fcc55e18_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.11, 0.01, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff8bdebac5f3fa6b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_963ff9e228928020_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.95, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_306c5cc0ec1ec91a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e64015fc9f4c3f57_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f266283cfcf0419_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc3f4db3558e8ad8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67be76803491cd5a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.11, 0.21, 0.45, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff8956041ecda4d3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94702060630acfd0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.49, 0.48, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0baf7d5a58cff96_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.36, 0.52, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_befa96bbbef35865_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9959e48b23a85a6d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.69, 0.22, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf847bdcdeaed7ef_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.62, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81a89e6cd8e88b3c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.88, 0.08, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a71797ba97b97978_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a9fcf208113a015_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b4037abe537b2f0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd9c2cbe638886e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.4, 0.55, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c7bd247a47428cc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.45, 0.44, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67073d723b968bdb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.17, 0.22, 0.3, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13b5d8ad489bc38c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.17, 0.36, 0.32, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_684d1ace663a8fe8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c37e1972dc49403_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.08, 0.49, 0.4, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35719f9cb9689a76_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.61, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b20ac786ace3334a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.14, 0.16, 0.29, 0.26, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b64a06c478e9c99d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c2b9b876a20f960_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2f9851c871f2bfe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9241bc8923300601_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f6ee401750aa219_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.19, 0.29, 0.27, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f00c1d842e73b32_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_031d13a1117d8289_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36819b2363664fbf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.09, 0.26, 0.52, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2942dacba6af6e7c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.17, 0.06, 0.28, 0.2, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07db4980affc34fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.62, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d67fb3af9e2670e1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.82, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6be36f3656f9a7b6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.25, 0.27, 0.25, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0acb8cf92842714e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.24, 0.16, 0.3, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e2e797831fab52da_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.46, 0.29, 0.15, 0.08, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68d87f91728ef63f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.19, 0.16, 0.2, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37d10950de599e45_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.88, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25302b8e514c8129_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.33, 0.18, 0.19, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac3aadc60435612f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5dcde1ceb257eea0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f62d8ea69ac5e9a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.69, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ed4493131adb055_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.34, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49f10770c415d72_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.34, 0.48, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6a72cbc4b9472f7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.12, 0.48, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb460fa09b3ef6d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c18425050c4e7f9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77a999c57ad4685e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.37, 0.39, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1352acaed0d38172_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_911f4898dee50517_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.71, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f0de95ea7307cab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_999129bb54db97c3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.22, 0.22, 0.17, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b6e42e75c87a3c0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cec09d9ee4da8db5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.04, 0.0, 0.87], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_856b77cc1bc36ef8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.24, 0.26, 0.24, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e7da013e1a0d629_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.0303, 0.3434, 0.5556, 0.0707, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c67c26be5324af14_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81278611f63cec68_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_696433981ab5660d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.88, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfc3f3a0b1e6c8c9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e64db7048c803631_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.57, 0.33, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66df5405ae90a3f1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.1, 0.33, 0.36, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_334d5b43492639a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee53c50efa24de24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ce9aa3ee0dc9bb2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bad1cdac1977705a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.09, 0.54, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7274fbda9fbd87d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.16, 0.15, 0.36, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd52058f17240b50_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ba2c40ed8ef72fe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.57, 0.29, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_726ed6ebea64b7e7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.13, 0.4, 0.42, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_984c426ac9893c36_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_353cd8dd73270852_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.38, 0.14, 0.15, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8c201e02b11bfb2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84a42dbf81a7906a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.17, 0.41, 0.25, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17dcb9c756bd497d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.11, 0.02, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a00aac9297a044cf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b6ed6bf81b13eee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f5bc2a1a31faf84_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.05, 0.39, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_716586c4941c5525_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.2, 0.22, 0.31, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a970e93ab203960_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.29, 0.18, 0.28, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4fadc1ac03180e47_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.69, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4a596b27dcdde16_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3da049fb535aa3af_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.97, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5d97e48c84ee520_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9cbf6e7dea05a12_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76952880b0783330_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.07, 0.91, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f66febcfdf1366e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.12, 0.06, 0.18, 0.38, 0.17], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_475a3f7f8c5a0480_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1acef87ed4e52a98_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd6cbda923f1ec72_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.68, 0.32, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd9fc754d5baa528_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_483ef1c44d148f92_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.61, 0.39, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec1e8e4a0d61dadb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.12, 0.15, 0.29, 0.2, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0038babd7f4be7f1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25520cfa3fab30e5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.54, 0.38, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6e0edb772b66af27_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e84f3f02ac29f265_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b56eb84c037fd7a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b928a73a36ec42a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62900bb5c075f39c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.08, 0.14, 0.29, 0.36, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9241bc8923300601_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.16, 0.18, 0.31, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03c85abeed470c04_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d5a65237505c933_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.16, 0.4, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_070549e1d29d7ac7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.33, 0.15, 0.23, 0.11, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45cee347363e3533_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.19, 0.11, 0.35, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_911f4898dee50517_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.26, 0.54, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2b583bfb559c238_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.96, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f70b73742830b65_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74f91a7326607884_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c9365105dac9b6f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.22, 0.39, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_015f125b4424cbf2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.28, 0.23, 0.2, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4856be5b920e6ca2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.2, 0.46, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_822f6c6ff0b15ed3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.12, 0.32, 0.32, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe1a2056819f757d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.2, 0.73, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_999d550e4ea76be6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.39, 0.58, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff58c7b7f8a90b9e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.18, 0.01, 0.67], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b1b8e41fa2951b1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.23, 0.54, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d125dd130a81dc1d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.12, 0.2, 0.41, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68987ffd95b266a2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.21, 0.43, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89c065dc9eac2d92_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.04, 0.0, 0.85], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b387e435a588e28_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.13, 0.15, 0.3, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b6ed6bf81b13eee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.52, 0.3, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5cf4c222025ac4b3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.03, 0.12, 0.58, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e5b1e8b399c29ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.22, 0.42, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd90f85fd91c1fab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.23, 0.38, 0.22, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bdef255133378695_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06b7c80b80c87e50_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.42, 0.46, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b76f1f4fc6400854_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c654038aabb0d88b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.88, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45cd7c73604daf24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca9fb5129f88ab4e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.4, 0.01, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1769ea99f7ed821d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.15, 0.76, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c171c11afc505c79_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_613a0e91d2d0a839_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d9bb7869ceb6071_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ada303333a657e23_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.73, 0.23, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5384a1953fa2f6e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.37, 0.32, 0.09, 0.19, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b26191c7d977f634_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.07, 0.07, 0.41, 0.32, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_141950134042a4b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce965c3d3d51bfc9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.31, 0.11, 0.28, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa1ab0db77e7fe94_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.61, 0.38, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c8b2bb406c2db09_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.19, 0.57, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_319a8fc3669e70c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.09, 0.14, 0.43, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_066b37a6808537cb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.45, 0.4, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_316a1e0b12271080_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c654038aabb0d88b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.22, 0.35, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ad48aa9e97a60de_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.66, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93f8391586255974_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4bdc13370035f6ae_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.27, 0.6, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7b4009acc69b0ed_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15994e88a4365bee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_904a63b188e48e8d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.14, 0.21, 0.32, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_592975c0a52405ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.2, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2736514b6bdcf013_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.57, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95d2371bbbcb84f4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b770fb1df3346424_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.86, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ada785ba61765798_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a26723251c76b8bd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.101, 0.1414, 0.101, 0.2828, 0.3232, 0.0505], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddecaa6debf6a289_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.23, 0.39, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9df8d9e42f62d6cd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.88, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_568e43e2d4dd5d3d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0ede698a97c829c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_598b713d1c4b1484_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d46365d7c2289ab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_616a3f95c346315d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.48, 0.46, 0.03, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99c5e7c55fac52e5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.24, 0.5, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_957be0500a26aea2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9472475add1efc7a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e11d0937157876d3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca7f377d5f54e0e4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c0899a8047e47f4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.75, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_849b1cd0463556d3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dec0ac19c13d5c27_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8569afc62e08276a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.34, 0.17, 0.21, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b159a46a8c8feae1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.23, 0.46, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25cdd00692202c9f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7525745dc365e91b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.34, 0.5, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b29c180fdc02ce4d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.53, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50c068ad45059069_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.3, 0.67, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b431e7f81bc6fe51_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.5, 0.33, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6390ef0f11bb0dbf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.23, 0.4, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdfb36135b5289a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_411c6c1a92152cd9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.18, 0.34, 0.22, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eae65305b3d59a60_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cd8baa9010aa2f1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.27, 0.26, 0.21, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fbd708a28f8eed13_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d01f1f5496521e70_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.89, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81e6d7b9fa7edb80_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cae479533bf8461_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.8, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8fb1019e724cf87f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.22, 0.12, 0.3, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aded383de96d1795_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.49, 0.05, 0.0, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef23a1d4491e228b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2448cdc02ace69a8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.88, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8be31727cab06835_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.07, 0.32, 0.47, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cdf64b2ad9322e9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9ac554c1326b728_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.66, 0.22, 0.01, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e2527fd52db216c1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a15114e99c80978_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.32, 0.43, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2bba76112c3b19f7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a92526f01af0e59b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.26, 0.25, 0.25, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e82851c8e1efcdaa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.17, 0.5, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8986e51334b11b4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.66, 0.26, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae0c22d30e47f691_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.7, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4850f842718d9937_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f66febcfdf1366e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.73, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_773208eccaa8fbfa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4c0b2e5a7c1f76e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.55, 0.27, 0.1, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cdd20fae554d60e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.3, 0.01, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f41b91bee9918ecb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dcf7738e84a2a333_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.2, 0.17, 0.27, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b90aefebfd1599ff_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.06, 0.33, 0.44, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_109db888eb447d6b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b13375d2c63ca3a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.18, 0.27, 0.31, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c1b29d7d28ec120_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a25ba79949d40e9c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22d1642a0e5f53a0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1f858b27796f1ed_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.08, 0.36, 0.45, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8dd6cf677376c2f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.97, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e43a45c77de70459_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38afb067b9ab2dcb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.2, 0.24, 0.34, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75740e522fb17909_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.75, 0.15, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2bc58b5f0fad3c9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.05, 0.95], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1823897ca68a9804_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.59, 0.38, 0.01, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d5a65237505c933_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.61, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68ea0f3d1a52cf15_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.69, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e59e12ac44faf81_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.07, 0.42, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b19959b875873ff6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_756aa32d830f060c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.68, 0.2, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8aba9669cd219da1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.92, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fa6333add4cbb23_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.21, 0.62, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bff5e03042a3b53c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.11, 0.2, 0.32, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_211396c7c3fca64a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87cb4bfbeb302234_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.26, 0.33, 0.18, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfb8feae45934967_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.41, 0.45, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73dffe64ea8d05c6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.19, 0.22, 0.26, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cd20dccc26cacd7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.2, 0.71, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4c3bd5d43a7c268_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4698d32127cdebc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c951d3eaa4dfb33_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.67, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6de1b76cea1dfcbe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.31, 0.18, 0.24, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff587332ff5dfadb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.11, 0.39, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6639475a2edef782_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.12, 0.19, 0.26, 0.25, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58e7ac4626093cba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.81, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_418f8441f9f34be8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.13, 0.45, 0.34, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07496833cada735b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.88, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_451c59a5714b7fe6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.09, 0.23, 0.44, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_753d3f6f1602f7dd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.4, 0.14, 0.13, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b8aa6724ddf23cc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.4, 0.5, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d5e8080afca86f4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.51, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3fd8971a9f1b705_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.64, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e35b4da83ea39048_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.72, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ec8467ef2bce89a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.59, 0.38, 0.0, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8fb29232bf573816_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.1, 0.34, 0.35, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d38934c5dbf445a2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.21, 0.63, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_157c0823d82121e1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.05, 0.05, 0.24, 0.51, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fee2f509f2634a6d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76243abea267f735_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.15, 0.62, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fc7fa37686c97d4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.32, 0.2, 0.3, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05c6e31d3f40cae2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.24, 0.14, 0.32, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58b4def726749712_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b5469c2037a5fa6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.4, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bd86927cf093ea1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc47c04dfd425265_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.25, 0.0, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8873489ae41b5f26_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdedd4ba120c2618_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92788b4efcfcc4ba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.2, 0.48, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37c0b47b53758b18_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.51, 0.43, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36e835f6e96cfe1c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.21, 0.27, 0.32, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4bac033b82dfa12a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.47, 0.44, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c524570fe270d3b2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.85, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8f0afb0692d8977_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_80c1c6da5808923f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1be232b70785f6b4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b364bfdb91a79700_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5afe23d40c58f9c3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e891c0870b7562a5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.33, 0.18, 0.21, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdcd382fdd257404_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0404, 0.5657, 0.3939, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd53a10ae618f056_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b15382332aaf44b2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.6768, 0.2727, 0.0505, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c91e6f0458f05b0a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6edfe2d1804f24bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.11, 0.5, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e067f83b1bcd1e50_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.72, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_312b8096a9cdd57f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9eb83a5214e3896c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d475269ac5c622b0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.23, 0.2, 0.29, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c408e88c7b5cd5b3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.5, 0.46, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7b68bacd74b733d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.85, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e42e732428a7a1bf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.59, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5cda0a095301545_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b60c9e834f06281d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.78, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b38663d094a26c6b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.08, 0.17, 0.42, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1659a0cbd7c9f7df_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.22, 0.5, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d846fd725daf43f5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a10188087b42cd1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a444e3d8082f5e2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c593a2324f163010_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.54, 0.06, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cb314b22fb6938e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.94, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34063b624755502e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.07, 0.36, 0.46, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0009e18f5b189e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.14, 0.3, 0.41, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_27ef4cb7a1d58f8e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.2, 0.26, 0.27, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c79379f276e0724_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d980fb329712048e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.13, 0.43, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddaeef11b84be303_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.14, 0.14, 0.34, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_397af398ef2629b8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.1, 0.51, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15892e0af59af9b2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.26, 0.53, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb1c03b506d81aec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.25, 0.12, 0.3, 0.16, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e63d166ee9054b01_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.65, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67cb306f99b55dc0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.85, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3285d91e3d8e0547_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.37, 0.15, 0.22, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_601ca9f8784cb533_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.81, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a36f21f4c8b7d276_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.79, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_272e46c5ceb33bb9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1181232e4f1311b4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8348a42ecc9ba7ea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.25, 0.22, 0.21, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_665dfbbd8eeae322_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a70c778dc21e2132_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.52, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a52ac9d214a840a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_509ad53eb58b8d84_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_908cd7505bd147fa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.5, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f24c75d4e4bb2635_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.28, 0.1, 0.24, 0.15, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_428ee68e1664ec1a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.18, 0.49, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d1e1398ac561999e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.11, 0.6, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4fadc1ac03180e47_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8ad80b044104f2b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.77, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6adf022288e1f02_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.42, 0.31, 0.15, 0.07, 0.03, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c767cbb8250671f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.19, 0.27, 0.25, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22e6a701a15969a0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.14, 0.63, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68d87f91728ef63f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.09, 0.83, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07496833cada735b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.14, 0.32, 0.28, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39dddf104abfd864_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcdf5217c7b86a11_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e2dcfa5e9d4c813_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_859b05a56e4fbebe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.39, 0.16, 0.17, 0.13, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_170705eb7f96aac1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.2, 0.45, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90dfa5f917e07e96_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.49, 0.47, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16bbfcd419b64e4f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.56, 0.01, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ffef3cdaa55c663_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.13, 0.01, 0.46], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6cf2feec9209e81a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.52, 0.01, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ece71cce84eab9f7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.53, 0.44, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec8cda071d844cdc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.3, 0.65, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f8bea13351143a8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42ed33edb6eec77b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.05, 0.93, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84bc2db0db9c6889_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.11, 0.3, 0.37, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13a5d6f472d8ab89_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e473af8f7ff62e79_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.76, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f4e9656333f667c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.34, 0.14, 0.14, 0.23, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29c72b750643edf8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.12, 0.19, 0.26, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_abaf40ff178f487b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4c0b2e5a7c1f76e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ac6664f1db14cbb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a55aa854da3530d7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd4dd9ed720023d1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.22, 0.62, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7b9161483deed3d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.96, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_309722ffb5ae9d66_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.07, 0.27, 0.42, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_643486906cf8d7ab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.33, 0.24, 0.2, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dde850bd3c77f693_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.61, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fb7506d54b39918_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.45, 0.52, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_251c2e943c22af3e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.02, 0.86, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1e23f8bcfd8bcf6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a970e93ab203960_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.67, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_291e432f4e05e1e1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.14, 0.46, 0.27, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78b58eebb65885ca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b56eb84c037fd7a1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.12, 0.13, 0.41, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79eb776a857a93ca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.26, 0.61, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc2803229f4a4b94_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12e359990068825e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_969a5353653d8d45_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.68, 0.0, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acf46ede60128b4a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d37ca725064a2084_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.67, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab4c1431ac2f6ea9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.09, 0.89, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4e9096889813e1c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.79, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5384a1953fa2f6e3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3ef5b2e0c71e2a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.8, 0.17, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_686124f5a952a032_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.45, 0.45, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c715ff61fa9ef9a7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.16, 0.23, 0.27, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f2b1cf7f32916e6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.2, 0.38, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f25436f19a64749_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.58, 0.24, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2b330ebd90f997c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.25, 0.18, 0.27, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4552c2084fff26c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.54, 0.46, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b38674d3b4b84b92_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.23, 0.58, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04d87ab5b20cf7ac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.81, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2489801cefd913cb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.89, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f422b5a36ce431d1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.22, 0.61, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_509ad53eb58b8d84_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0404, 0.0303, 0.0404, 0.2828, 0.5657, 0.0404], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bda21359290391ca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.77, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29820e5e24e1fbc7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_08348ed32ffff9db_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.18, 0.21, 0.26, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b0bbdf522343417_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.34, 0.18, 0.2, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23b32508e247ad7e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.48, 0.48, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57d0c99cbd7ef9fd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.11, 0.43, 0.32, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f779fbe0cadd6aa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4856be5b920e6ca2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4764b33126946389_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b205053c5302e67_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5515def22a05b87_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.24, 0.26, 0.32, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af6a2433e64971e8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_beaab8cb554ef240_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.52, 0.4, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1636eee4b688c47b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.16, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_251c2e943c22af3e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.12, 0.23, 0.3, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_005d9ee8daf7292a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a50372a9c770e2b6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f06a38cf535a036_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.12, 0.46, 0.35, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2bac59ec2be4ec00_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47a290f1ee39cd0e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.67, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b57fe7cd8a734a2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.21, 0.2, 0.3, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92b0a7da695164dc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.3, 0.22, 0.25, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f50f372396e7117_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.13, 0.52, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5988c4ebee1c8f3e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f62d8ea69ac5e9a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2771db13a5f1681c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd5424e23bdf8e33_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9516e0516b94be69_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce5be725bc01fb42_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.57, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b9884752e2f7991_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.95, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_563b209603516b98_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b76f1f4fc6400854_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.67, 0.32, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3f91db07f8ebd8a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.07, 0.1, 0.42, 0.32, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd5424e23bdf8e33_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.2, 0.32, 0.46], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e64db7048c803631_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36b19b21ceffb5f6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.16, 0.14, 0.37, 0.23, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_473f5381cca31923_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.86, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b059638dc6b2d87_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_958c36110a29d645_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.84, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_814b5c4b8b2669cd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.21, 0.2, 0.29, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8bb0c3ea6e024e63_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.59, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fbfc0437c073e75_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.1, 0.14, 0.32, 0.26, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f48264b596457fa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.5, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57975f21aa1b6fb5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5fa0215202638ad6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4c2e709bb04ff566_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b763f454ee1d28a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_904a63b188e48e8d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4203d79b11befa7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.2, 0.58, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a5e5226c53de0ab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.76, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_370de51125f45b5e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ed11d840dbb3d5e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.3, 0.25, 0.3, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b059638dc6b2d87_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.22, 0.6, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4fb63829dd83c43_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.17, 0.48, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7039eab9a56d4ffd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.24, 0.75, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8960aea49b504782_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.07, 0.32, 0.39, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17dcb9c756bd497d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.11, 0.12, 0.37, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_335cd89d2a608000_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66f66fd19409e345_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46d6ff2e71255197_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.17, 0.59, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fee95131dfd839a7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.45, 0.54, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_495be9831b4ec343_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.17, 0.28, 0.2, 0.16, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_237e35b758d3f852_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.18, 0.37, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_122d51aa790b5bfa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.21, 0.26, 0.32, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86dcffde18768f92_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_037f8ad389eb3785_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f47b70a676d68d43_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.35, 0.49, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ad3d4e7766a83fa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.63, 0.08, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84f9ae76d5ce1afd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.57, 0.36, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2acdfd3a4cea427_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a5b096d6c0b94b8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.42, 0.53, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c357efaaa7ce4472_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.42, 0.1, 0.46], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9f7b19d07dee7b7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.09, 0.54, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0c2317b979cd033_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.62, 0.34, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c6a4edba35f683d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44158ca4ea8fa8a4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.16, 0.39, 0.24, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f22c2289566f1876_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_80ab91df51694c85_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.39, 0.48, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b938cb25ed3b0725_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.56, 0.01, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43ea7e49e33bf138_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.21, 0.19, 0.42, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2c9e29ff6af566e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.67, 0.21, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ebef78954483e88_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.37, 0.58, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5383239cceeccd8d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.06, 0.47, 0.44, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50c068ad45059069_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.23, 0.29, 0.29, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe4de4ce2dca0fbe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.07, 0.36, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e51f462983a2bce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.87, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e56b1bf080431f10_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.08, 0.01, 0.71], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2a66427f20ac0ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd6097bb39e6f4b0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.06, 0.3, 0.5, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2c97687a4d59a83_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.97, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a26ab97bce2ff3d5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31246ae345df3c6b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.28, 0.22, 0.28, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1acef87ed4e52a98_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.63, 0.33, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0e6ca893a577e005_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_832746248178573b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.34, 0.28, 0.17, 0.17, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_150781528438a35e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d80c97929ee9f3bb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.16, 0.23, 0.35, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5149b9a403327f12_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddf976e2a790399b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e597224516b6fba3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.77, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33c4f9f401b3e78f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.68, 0.29, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ab49e6369927eb6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.75, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07ee756c4fba74b0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_475a3f7f8c5a0480_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.55, 0.39, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bef27c87469f3e4f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.11, 0.28, 0.46, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87e35e1ce6c99c13_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.06, 0.24, 0.51, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31109ee3d91cbd23_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.53, 0.34, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_18822a5cdee890d8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03ca3d8a3322d4ee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.22, 0.11, 0.26, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f05e5a93c0f1b8da_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.88, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eac67514a04a14af_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.18, 0.6, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_856b77cc1bc36ef8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.86, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_477cdff35e91cfc7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.37, 0.15, 0.31, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0e131c682cf8f44_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.09, 0.28, 0.48, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44158ca4ea8fa8a4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.62, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_716376af494ff6b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a25ba79949d40e9c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.11, 0.25, 0.37, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcd54cd0949515bd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.09, 0.57, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c246447b2e1a189e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1872e931846932fe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.3, 0.66, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a42585b698fd460_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9361e12d519e868d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_186728026fde4888_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.22, 0.32, 0.29, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb98cf3caa5052b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.15, 0.21, 0.3, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd038d03e3dec320_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ba78764bb199e77_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.68, 0.3, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0fa646b90bd46d4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bad1cdac1977705a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.76, 0.23, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a57c6eb724cebdb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.36, 0.4, 0.11, 0.11, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cd20dccc26cacd7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fa7d3df4868ebb5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8083a9a11441753_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.19, 0.69, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbe5625636b4b890_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.39, 0.2, 0.2, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d7ec7ffc680af63_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3009bf8b3969803a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00936c68eb273519_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.08, 0.91, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8b5ab7d9f6de80a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.43, 0.49, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8f88ea6ba2be811_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.78, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_988343fdaa2db10b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.39, 0.44, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17ae4171fd51ae51_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.87, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9195cdeb2654a74a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.42, 0.56, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0353c95405800598_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0baf8363951a1e41_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.28, 0.16, 0.26, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75be4f3e56b8dbc7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.09, 0.6, 0.29, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b85e1cc1d53df38a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.08, 0.23, 0.51, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04d87ab5b20cf7ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b2ee0e5f44b2113_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72379f70b2183d3c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.9, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b160d098e8223177_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.08, 0.28, 0.44, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_332be9c0f5819bb8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.28, 0.17, 0.23, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34d98b7000e2baff_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.2, 0.52, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24a759a3c29882ce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.06, 0.74, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ffb5172c7f3a142f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.21, 0.73, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35a02e03e311d470_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.92, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_152dfc3c34363d36_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f07f3013f02c83f4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.11, 0.42, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_270f14184630ffe3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.2, 0.46, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e7ae770135b1a5d9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99143c50846a5ec7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0101, 0.5556, 0.404, 0.0303], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c73c382f5c6e3e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bd9cbbee65f76af_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b0a354748ae495b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cdba4d0f48d44e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.6, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_081e9317a677e2e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.99, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f09e73b41e872877_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.1, 0.23, 0.43, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0231e855776efbb4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9516e0516b94be69_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.18, 0.23, 0.33, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d20a5f7cc326010b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.12, 0.31, 0.44, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42875d8ab1659d83_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.52, 0.43, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4698d32127cdebc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.13, 0.15, 0.35, 0.26, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0134d94b31395fb9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.19, 0.18, 0.31, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e67b55837a18283_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.19, 0.41, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05c52de9ef4d1993_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d59f2180183b723f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.3, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d3af0c6baf5e688_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c08db6a38d6caa1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.57, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3cccfe01bc81141_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.82, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71d59ea2cfdf1703_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f0c0be36332edcb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_080b7948b739f609_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.61, 0.38, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f58cf349047fb9b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bde782372f71159_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.72, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ceb1a229e44e121c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcc32bce8cac8bd7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.19, 0.65, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63ae634682986406_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.92, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6128ffb4d38e36ee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.7, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca1ad1799ae0331c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b94e0fa5ca38641c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.82, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fccfaf8aafd73f0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.12, 0.39, 0.33, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfa7fd59e9d840e8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5790a5431e0abdd5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1132d19d14eb74d3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.44, 0.42, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa07d54dddb323ea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.18, 0.27, 0.36, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d7c4bdb9734f259_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.9, 0.01, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93d0d3ffc848676f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.2, 0.41, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b5303e3145ba17b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.26, 0.2, 0.26, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92d0451b45e0009f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74cdcf04a4fda3ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.2, 0.14, 0.35, 0.18, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eebd7039292edf87_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.1, 0.25, 0.27, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fe422cfabb5fda8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.69, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5fa0215202638ad6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.92, 0.06, 0.0, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f690a1b57257878f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_426ab197b4ce44f9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.81, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f55c829ccb90f9f0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.88, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0134d94b31395fb9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.16, 0.77, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ab818ba1db1b7a9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.4, 0.52, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdbbf88896e04789_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.12, 0.49, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2bba76112c3b19f7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.13, 0.18, 0.3, 0.21, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f2ac5e599f8a855_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61a41c28e66fb91d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eca8a6e23afebb1e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4617f9dd111311a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_613d8d24a3d44593_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48235130d3bb76c6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.78, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2356ccf13a41b67_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.41, 0.34, 0.12, 0.11, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66818731370a2051_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f04fd812e665570_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7168aec5f1222e7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.34, 0.09, 0.3, 0.12, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2441bf4463e1ca2e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.11, 0.21, 0.43, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bdcab1a43c6971c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.86, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ccf40f8ad3cd4e0c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_283abd1c9480715b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.08, 0.34, 0.46, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0917fd1d6baf4d5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.74, 0.26, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6473b91eed057e2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.07, 0.59, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7b365ddddece4ff_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c85090315f2d5e45_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c62845d48644785c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d3666c5c564a257_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47a290f1ee39cd0e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.28, 0.18, 0.3, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d30bb39122f3bf8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.07, 0.64, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6de1b76cea1dfcbe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.41, 0.0, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_120ac157060b1f82_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.61, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74fe79fddd098d84_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c6ed0f275864779_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.27, 0.4, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d86c20890ab162ed_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.82, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_450cdc860a6bffa2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.46, 0.49, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9361e12d519e868d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.14, 0.61, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_221c5d68c975798a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.12, 0.4, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c97fc0e429d6b8d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.36, 0.61, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_757b077b2d684671_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.07, 0.12, 0.43, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40bb320bebccc92d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.25, 0.24, 0.3, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82be5100c3b8df0a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22c877d8e2fb8c7a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.25, 0.57, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_341645cd55f06293_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.57, 0.16, 0.02, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a6de3bc90f84b127_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.62, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1746ba1aaceba612_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.15, 0.14, 0.4, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa1ab0db77e7fe94_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62a7d8f5f9b69590_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_354b3f2ddbdfa705_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc9813fc1cb5f2db_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.09, 0.33, 0.42, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dde850bd3c77f693_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.22, 0.19, 0.25, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dc5fa52c4efe6cb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.14, 0.16, 0.32, 0.25, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f07f3013f02c83f4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfa3f860a62f30c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.56, 0.36, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9a547fc2aeaa159_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.21, 0.16, 0.28, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad7dda65f6a7e898_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96426e1ede0b1938_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.14, 0.24, 0.37, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1746ba1aaceba612_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b78645914bd34a4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e92a6134661bb736_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9201a8baff9ece02_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.42, 0.38, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6cb886531ff8db2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fff312a964c17fb0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b8db5fb0e5c60b6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.81, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_420ef7a7edb99760_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.89, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f319369f1e9d7de_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.46, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bffa17e994fcff0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_912fe7c74d22c7eb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.7, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7513aa545ccc3c3f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_640c321b87f63fb5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8529b1b58bca5dc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5910ef9ecdb08021_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ebad2734366645d0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.3, 0.3, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45cd7c73604daf24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.87, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15840c15ff28932e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b5fe1c2c99295a6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.91, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ef130e10c11831d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e8d1d61d69ddc81_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54d6121fb4c8ed8f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a59b5658985d6a58_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.19, 0.24, 0.25, 0.17, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e473af8f7ff62e79_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.15, 0.37, 0.32, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5fa12c096cb9bee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.61, 0.38, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f428efdd9a4a0155_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.31, 0.43, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c0db038fe9784e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.61, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7811001681c65ca6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9f2dbfc783c8eb7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d7ec7ffc680af63_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.19, 0.16, 0.27, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86974afdaed8e754_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.26, 0.5, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a42b17e5a18e139e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.21, 0.16, 0.37, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be6c5e7d12bfcddc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.23, 0.03, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a94a755f90de6856_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e46773b09e3370ef_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_684d1ace663a8fe8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.31, 0.25, 0.24, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46343f0392a90078_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c397030500c6aeed_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d3b437f57053940_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.23, 0.61, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47a829af0c36114c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.27, 0.4, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e47e7126a3eaa197_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.84, 0.11, 0.0, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50b422f18b992d78_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.91, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d846fd725daf43f5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.23, 0.22, 0.28, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd90f85fd91c1fab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_56e03c68e5049f08_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.68, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f04fd812e665570_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.57, 0.4, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16b77f4c64957668_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.07, 0.14, 0.43, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_005d9ee8daf7292a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.59, 0.0, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e04a60682b804955_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.2, 0.75, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61800956d7687c2b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.35, 0.28, 0.13, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ce421564f81f2c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.21, 0.3, 0.28, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4904f57ab8867450_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da8f2e680adadd55_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.75, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c23c78d1581f6202_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.71, 0.19, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_630e3bf2d340f745_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c23a6d49384591a8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.48, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_df08aa5b203c3f97_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.21, 0.22, 0.32, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad244a8a577ce115_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.17, 0.11, 0.39, 0.22, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_70ec9ea2999f56ce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.17, 0.17, 0.35, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f336c6425b8a526d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.24, 0.18, 0.29, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1dad20b866b4b3c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.22, 0.44, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b058cc284758116f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b79603b438f1cde7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0306e191fad09e4a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.17, 0.42, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fbcf9150d4f7890_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.07, 0.09, 0.25, 0.43, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79eb776a857a93ca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.88, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ef066fb334616d3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.09, 0.1, 0.31, 0.33, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40ae5b2b89014ec0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_640c321b87f63fb5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.12, 0.39, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_11cd18fbd2f6f433_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.53, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4904f57ab8867450_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.32, 0.58, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4857cb3847143659_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.88, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a33f6b026daf6c2a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.64, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e828223d7408022f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ceabc4fc12044813_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.08, 0.11, 0.34, 0.33, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2edac46ed21ccb3e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.27, 0.11, 0.2, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5648ef750c059b5c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.22, 0.49, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_874d779684283d80_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.16, 0.52, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f44f1e793ae539c6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.58, 0.35, 0.04, 0.03, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a20b1d6add59c9fe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a33371bd5d50a4dd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.06, 0.46, 0.39, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc609347afba0490_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.83, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c4221b2c830f7be_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.96, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0e6638e2c55403d6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.16, 0.45, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab03b28159be92b3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.07, 0.53, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50cc3d80ae4e40da_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcb470bfba078263_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.28, 0.16, 0.36, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a28eeaa594f59e48_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.97, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_779ac60699d0048c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.66, 0.21, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8c3f91d1578217c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.69, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b176f60dd1bcbe1c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.17, 0.14, 0.37, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b11859ee2c2d82f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.63, 0.36, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_befa96bbbef35865_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.64, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ee3b14fa3f5244f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.11, 0.01, 0.71], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94fc41072152c596_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.18, 0.37, 0.28, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_013644cde61732c3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.58, 0.35, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a15114e99c80978_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.71, 0.25, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_830c7617ae6e070b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.83, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8083a9a11441753_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_827db81b24f00934_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.54, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_139a3e406064c1ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.7, 0.26, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f48d3b754167c08b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.92, 0.04, 0.0, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2653962c5ae07bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.15, 0.15, 0.25, 0.27, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f74641a897ba5f07_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d4406ca7ebf4365_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf847bdcdeaed7ef_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.18, 0.52, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe162982ac9e9d77_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.08, 0.43, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd377d2159d15e60_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.07, 0.23, 0.32, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f3937f23b5b0920_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_add587d996be287d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43b89ce30c56f811_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0254ef73eaf0baaf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.61, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3594f3dfbffd172b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.52, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79eb776a857a93ca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b2475756bc23809_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.47, 0.36, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef9b25fac0f87c89_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.65, 0.04, 0.01, 0.3], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a50372a9c770e2b6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.85, 0.0, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c0dbf6c85d24101_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.88, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87ac1426751498d0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d3666c5c564a257_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.39, 0.01, 0.34], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e76d05b93d35070_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24177e50dd7cb056_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.09, 0.2, 0.47, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4e6fc9507774b93_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce84cdb5d95c6f1b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39b16ed27c99318d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f68a408fa50c1243_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0101, 0.0505, 0.2424, 0.5657, 0.1313, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b78645914bd34a4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.92, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48943a615774c9d0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.55, 0.36, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dea6a1751da3e485_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.26, 0.33, 0.19, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f90a3a7483f8d00f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.15, 0.69, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6e5708033bf2ae4f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.13, 0.83, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74b2a6a0cc83633b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd863e4a3013af11_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af62c122e13e5731_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.96, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3ed21dbe30c7d30_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.8, 0.13, 0.01, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e9cf306e2014572_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.23, 0.21, 0.23, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75bb66e74294fd50_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3ef5b2e0c71e2a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_950ab409de6ab04d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.8, 0.13, 0.01, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd3845eab6628cdf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.14, 0.73, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbd390dc712d7916_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.19, 0.78, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b363d4c9e3811766_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.5, 0.21, 0.19], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb5856c165d5bcb1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.12, 0.38, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_daa294fda59fdfc0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.2, 0.27, 0.27, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99be52ee361e747c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.53, 0.27, 0.13, 0.06, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf470dfa4f035fd5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.49, 0.4, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c895998a107e89fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.7, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a90fe9fbf9a8e584_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.1, 0.17, 0.2, 0.25, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0752cb9ec510bb36_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.13, 0.23, 0.45, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4d86a78c503f793_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.01, 0.7, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_830207b316a5e1da_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.87, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81c870e00a740b01_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.32, 0.22, 0.25, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a3f2b36fa634eb1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.24, 0.72, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba579495f89670e7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_742a4dd8289ab775_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b795dd0c6834318_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.26, 0.32, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a954048c2edaf33_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f2b3c8196bd530a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.27, 0.24, 0.27, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ecad290fa658f770_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.34, 0.54, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b70dfd18560e0b06_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.86, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de0aefa088426aba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d492104989ff4ec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.76, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66818731370a2051_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.64, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b763f454ee1d28a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.101, 0.1313, 0.2828, 0.3333, 0.1414, 0.0101], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a9c20fa4df9191f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.18, 0.51, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_945ff782847f78d4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.19, 0.59, 0.19, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03ff63ac08b1d82e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1717, 0.6869, 0.1414, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_887091147a280a8a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.62, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d1e529e37bdf376_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6e0edb772b66af27_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.14, 0.56, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d1fa9b51b7b385b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.31, 0.58, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9929e0623827c448_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.78, 0.21, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4c8fbbda40ca67b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd24ce2e54a27517_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.25, 0.15, 0.2, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89865bec92ed175b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfac52093992eaf5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.94, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f889b429c3a9d24c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_170cf68aaa471230_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.84, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a74c9d38af60996c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.53, 0.03, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_700c2af0678f68cc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.18, 0.12, 0.19, 0.16, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_496f54aebf265aba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.28, 0.18, 0.31, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eda59c2337636439_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.07, 0.14, 0.38, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8a8d8d45e57243a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.12, 0.87, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ed5d3fb156ed57b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.18, 0.61, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdbbf88896e04789_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.03, 0.43, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7427e22bba99f6e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.58, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1872e931846932fe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_20efb5cacfafb13e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c85823ad593234f0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36536696e2c3865d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee90a5f7e0f357e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.68, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc9bfea33a1d1942_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.54, 0.31, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10a038a287e81cbb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.14, 0.25, 0.32, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_387990be11db3d42_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_263e2d07f8267165_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f6638f1ee2daa2d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_837f5d6924a30a91_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_70ec9ea2999f56ce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acabcd0439be4571_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_578a61b8f18ca488_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.47, 0.4, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad13ef1f23849c58_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.39, 0.49, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8861e5cf634e8da5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.11, 0.41, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62876bf3314be7cd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.09, 0.34, 0.36, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1823897ca68a9804_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3c526b0d93edae7c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.83, 0.16, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_616a3f95c346315d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.25, 0.18, 0.28, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60cce234e6a0b11c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.11, 0.49, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3f91db07f8ebd8a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.79, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54fcc85aadd03beb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e9f96655077878f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96d620a7a05360d4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce0d0853119921d1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.7, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2d29513caab6e24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28b3b22ebd871f96_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.08, 0.29, 0.53, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9434361071716633_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.86, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75eea3b3202654ec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.59, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a57b49d3ea5c0a9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.79, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fe16ccf519704c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.09, 0.13, 0.47, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_391de218a986c03e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35a02e03e311d470_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34063b624755502e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a9c20fa4df9191f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95d2371bbbcb84f4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.14, 0.28, 0.3, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2765e6561c410c4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_69c9f9c64368b6c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.6, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_150781528438a35e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.26, 0.18, 0.28, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29371956a4d687cd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.05, 0.3, 0.53, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9f7b19d07dee7b7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26950359f5f105ba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bbf05100802de903_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.85, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b4a0cef64c63a2c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0e029f3bfa069cca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad5bcc20a3e4ca04_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.95, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b928a73a36ec42a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.63, 0.32, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e2e797831fab52da_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_580f7804edad4bcc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.21, 0.35, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_451ee627e372d206_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1313, 0.5657, 0.2828, 0.0202], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0aec3770db077c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.03, 0.65, 0.21], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_428ee68e1664ec1a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ef130e10c11831d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.14, 0.4, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_945ff782847f78d4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.62, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d4e02e925c9b3c8d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.6, 0.36, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2114999d7e453a7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.24, 0.61, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b058cc284758116f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.78, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff929524452fbead_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9f2bd6588d2de61_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.25, 0.22, 0.34, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e70c5b7689d9cce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.29, 0.24, 0.3, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a989a1587933c62_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86d31f5884764e76_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e78671158036896a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.28, 0.11, 0.29, 0.15, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57f0dd5b858119ed_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c64edbe96549455_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.64, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40e0aeba18c59f0b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47a290f1ee39cd0e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c05ea3e601fb24df_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91ef90433b3af278_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c30c0b63704e9272_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.62, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9a83d267e9a0cda_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d3af0c6baf5e688_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.28, 0.35, 0.27, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34e25626bc0e6dab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.24, 0.69, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3a43949d710ec11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.98, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0e029f3bfa069cca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.89, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58e7ac4626093cba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.2, 0.35, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b469d0adfd6ca5a8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ea1b05f689a411c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.28, 0.19, 0.27, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_169dcad569e531d0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1acdc18468365b74_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.06, 0.5, 0.41, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4280d5dbac4a006e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.19, 0.21, 0.36, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15994e88a4365bee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.77, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a114a06dc9122c19_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.2, 0.19, 0.38, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb840dd8d61fbb75_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.55, 0.31, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5e89b3cb8ffc155_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc736351158e18b6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.47, 0.09, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ecfcd9dc58e6c82_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.14, 0.27, 0.45, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a7f68bb282e31ab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.22, 0.31, 0.27, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e17134288a50909_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.12, 0.19, 0.32, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a2f0c6ba6910e67_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.28, 0.24, 0.21, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcc32bce8cac8bd7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.07, 0.35, 0.45, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85421b49f29befa9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb9571ada44676bb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.09, 0.32, 0.43, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f089e304cceb1316_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.29, 0.65, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d9968a980a1c1a45_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.81, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b1a179d4d64d8ec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6837b018cb3f4c8c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d616b216ddc40146_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.91, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe04feb055951c97_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59dc00bd34a22b76_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3c6f62d9b325559f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.99, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ffd6f2d174633d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.14, 0.17, 0.41, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ea38b1b7016a972_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.68, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_830207b316a5e1da_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0eecbd3950f1ab0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9401feb77bf162a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8fb173b83ec3336_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.42, 0.24, 0.12, 0.19, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85d0c8849a9197d4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.93, 0.03, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d6ca68508098c0f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.19, 0.33, 0.21, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5a7263d073f96d3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f4851282ab417e1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.96, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_633d80f46605efca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.05, 0.94, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42bd318a5d3e9edc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.7, 0.25, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4a692eb074a3b42_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b14291aef5a2dc9a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.21, 0.26, 0.27, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d24566099b99dcc0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.35, 0.48, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5fc00cae355aad9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e70c5b7689d9cce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6f219dd9f0c436f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.56, 0.4, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62876bf3314be7cd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.39, 0.24, 0.37, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a71c29843471d503_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bcf0c1173e7f629_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.9, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b651bbebc0242ea_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a89ba25c692370b2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.09, 0.57, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdfb36135b5289a5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.09, 0.22, 0.38, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_befa96bbbef35865_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.08, 0.18, 0.44, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb09cc00d7749f2d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.25, 0.15, 0.26, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b13375d2c63ca3a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88afbc50d21b003e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d68ff673e1757c1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.69, 0.3, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c18968d81f5e9c3b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.51, 0.42, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b222c9d9bb067923_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.26, 0.21, 0.25, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41233562842a8ee4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f0458094bbfc243_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2374e6331c4c61c6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_580f7804edad4bcc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c7d156f4b6bb1b4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.54, 0.38, 0.0, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_624785ff8eb04b19_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca704b59e740f2d1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.15, 0.44, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4258e150e17defb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.11, 0.03, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f41b91bee9918ecb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.61, 0.35, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a877f825921ef75_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.44, 0.52, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdd8c769b0183e18_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.97, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a9492f3d256748d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f43673930f8c56f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.52, 0.46, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_738d61efddc39aa2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.76, 0.16, 0.01, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46a3c8093cdf7afa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b719c3fb4253aa4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.49, 0.5, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_411c6c1a92152cd9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a42026caca16025_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.57, 0.01, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_80d83f7b5b5a4928_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.29, 0.44, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b78b562608d90abf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f64190dca26d5cf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.79, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6db8afd3187bdb0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.43, 0.52, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_872b3c32fa497836_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a59b5658985d6a58_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25cdd00692202c9f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.15, 0.16, 0.36, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_921379c0e530be54_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97d4aa59262fa206_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.4, 0.07, 0.22, 0.05, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a52ac9d214a840a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.15, 0.22, 0.38, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfac52093992eaf5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.17, 0.14, 0.28, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d258ad41c1c1ff5c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d12fa8fe9b41a8c1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.57, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4c2e709bb04ff566_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.17, 0.65, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fa9fbb237d12fa4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.77, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b56eb84c037fd7a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.88, 0.1, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37c0b47b53758b18_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eaf01799cea09b35_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.18, 0.19, 0.29, 0.16, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_998c7deeac9307cf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.52, 0.02, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d7024b0372e7a74_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.24, 0.25, 0.25, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2765e6561c410c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.43, 0.48, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9a5956df6eabb6ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4bca8f7ea703828_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_804ecb94cb380a3a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfe4db10ae47cf37_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.83, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0984569104b23a45_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fee95131dfd839a7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.08, 0.13, 0.38, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55230b512fff71fc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.3, 0.16, 0.19, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3f91db07f8ebd8a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb96b2228e2b0114_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.14, 0.31, 0.35, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67ead6b218e82974_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35804a677ab5c8de_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.75, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8340850e3babfe8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.08, 0.69, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f43673930f8c56f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fea659043d7e4514_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.36, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc47c04dfd425265_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.18, 0.17, 0.34, 0.15, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f422b5a36ce431d1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.92, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88afbc50d21b003e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.55, 0.37, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad4664f7f0770acf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a05e0990ecd024f8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.26, 0.3, 0.22, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f05e5a93c0f1b8da_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.14, 0.08, 0.27, 0.3, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8986e51334b11b4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.05, 0.32, 0.57, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81278611f63cec68_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.09, 0.36, 0.45, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c67c26be5324af14_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.54, 0.03, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5790a5431e0abdd5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.12, 0.36, 0.43, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73e843b781a716e9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.44, 0.44, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9516e0516b94be69_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.61, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a444e3d8082f5e2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.4, 0.59, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_18799b3017f5c26c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.37, 0.53, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce23815229556027_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.49, 0.38, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc9127211ff472f8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.62, 0.02, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c10c7b2e5882862f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.17, 0.17, 0.35, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8c73476e0422649_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.57, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_49ec3a85fe6b0301_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b0e96ec824f2885_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ada8455d9abba8e3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a6353cd0eed6364_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.36, 0.01, 0.45], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6608584486b4ccca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.15, 0.23, 0.34, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1144bf484cac98a3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.14, 0.26, 0.37, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7a4c1a5819589e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.2, 0.19, 0.37, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b203234d2b9b8cc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0202, 0.0404, 0.2323, 0.5455, 0.1616, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_881f9687dad6959c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.36, 0.53, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1a4cad39a9de69d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.16, 0.14, 0.4, 0.2, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6d1fa3d61b49c60_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.13, 0.29, 0.3, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f126c69cd18672d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.17, 0.55, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d07cdfaafc4b806_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bde782372f71159_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.19, 0.42, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_990872f1b07b317a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.16, 0.78, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba06c1ceab9a4e83_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.14, 0.26, 0.35, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9630988cb76ca617_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.92, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_635b305900db356a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.31, 0.09, 0.31, 0.07, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3dac17087b62c30b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15feb331a9a6404d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.06, 0.32, 0.47, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e74f6283f9d39ed_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.85, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_407665d089e970a6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0101, 0.8182, 0.1717, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f031dd1296a53f2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.22, 0.35, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1037b0b0349e014_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90b982d080481a5e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34c6365e5611f430_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.77, 0.17, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a3f2b36fa634eb1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c4a374809451a3d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.97, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fda15ea033a4e19b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41ecb3b05fdfc7d8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.49, 0.03, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c99769ae8100a0e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.81, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec724e4d0e10e0cb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.08, 0.37, 0.34, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7d39f9c676ed539b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.05, 0.32, 0.53, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_426ab197b4ce44f9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.28, 0.22, 0.19, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f78a6d532643d3b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb230fe65670a237_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.56, 0.0, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ebed074a5ce6c05_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.16, 0.27, 0.33, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c62ff3dcbe8727a4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db4ddbd65b397ce4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e41497332b56201_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.9, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0606f145296ccbac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.53, 0.43, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd285af91b79c603_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dd1cb4eb523af75_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.09, 0.33, 0.35, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2378b5e8dc98972a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28bd64b4baf2b965_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.73, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50777ead0d68bb9f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.3, 0.15, 0.22, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59d6294125026ae6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.62, 0.35, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ece71cce84eab9f7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.15, 0.45, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e23ce61b57a9bd8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cdc2386a3a045e2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.1, 0.16, 0.34, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ed858b4f6d351ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.88, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc8ef14cb795ff50_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.65, 0.33, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22293ff7730c3b77_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ea38b1b7016a972_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.06, 0.07, 0.4, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_df22a3795418666a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.53, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d4e02e925c9b3c8d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_411aa2e45fc2323e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04977a2fa2c5d790_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.28, 0.35, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4a33bc7dfae5c0a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.13, 0.01, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd4dd9ed720023d1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bee747ffe3b4f738_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e619d416de6500b3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93033e889d28509c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.91, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3446cd3e64db2624_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.32, 0.13, 0.28, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ecdbbdba95c7c3a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.31, 0.65, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ac1ad0e0ac77f65_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.75, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa746dfcb581c340_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.06, 0.38, 0.48, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_53b4ded34a2324bf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.49, 0.01, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8357705f5468bedb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.34, 0.16, 0.28, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e7a7b6069ab061a6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.22, 0.23, 0.2, 0.13, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9149d19f41a1c9b6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.19, 0.26, 0.15, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50d53e48b846c998_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.21, 0.24, 0.28, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1823897ca68a9804_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.21, 0.21, 0.4, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ea7f159b941afe3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb9983c989ff9663_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_845b7821e052aa94_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.34, 0.34, 0.15, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f25436f19a64749_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_051df887f5488d6d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.15, 0.39, 0.44], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59746fcf4b0221f5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f05e5a93c0f1b8da_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ffb7fce2e0158c97_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8f0afb0692d8977_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.06, 0.46, 0.36, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d9ef47bb953c8dba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.06, 0.08, 0.37, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fab9abdff41fda0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb05d092f288da91_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.25, 0.26, 0.3, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50cc3d80ae4e40da_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.54, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6854ffbad0ae400b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.15, 0.43, 0.34, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb31cb13c9e5652b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.84, 0.05, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d241f4d081e0c96_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.16, 0.19, 0.34, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f783f4fc0085b2d5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.46, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e46b9c178ebdd590_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f05d90f5f9c6b5a3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.07, 0.46, 0.34, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c8b2bb406c2db09_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.31, 0.19, 0.17, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93e6d80474886241_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.25, 0.18, 0.23, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bd7af1622d1cf02_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.18, 0.24, 0.41, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58e48fbf76767f6a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.42, 0.26, 0.13, 0.15, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9a5956df6eabb6ac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.38, 0.54, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a5e87a148ab27b7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.82, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad7169e4eba1fcee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee426601e16ac79f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.2, 0.25, 0.3, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b38e8a10d91759e7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.16, 0.47, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c6a4edba35f683d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.13, 0.13, 0.28, 0.32, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9387bac96bdc49c2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.15, 0.23, 0.36, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ada303333a657e23_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f50f372396e7117_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.19, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff8bdebac5f3fa6b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.21, 0.23, 0.25, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_284de8520ed4ec6f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.28, 0.26, 0.26, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_896e5ffcedd0130c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cde9f88c14265e87_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.39, 0.6, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29bfb6a9eeb03b1e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.61, 0.39, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2441bf4463e1ca2e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dfbbfda8498092a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.38, 0.12, 0.13, 0.07, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a3f2b36fa634eb1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.24, 0.29, 0.28, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb25d011b2b77583_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6a72cbc4b9472f7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.6, 0.39, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb40daae90024c24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.54, 0.4, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e46773b09e3370ef_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.73, 0.26, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c7bd247a47428cc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.2, 0.25, 0.36, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8960aea49b504782_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.26, 0.7, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8bc7737f415f21f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41cd6483cdb98166_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.67, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_20726cfb6746006c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb460fa09b3ef6d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.17, 0.29, 0.37, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a18b4e38d544d04_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.24, 0.53, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91d402bfd8551f05_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.89, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_178afd440fa0112e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_80c1c6da5808923f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.81, 0.09, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22d11d9e20d93128_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.56, 0.29, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_daa15178bcbea70c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.18, 0.34, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d4406ca7ebf4365_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.58, 0.35, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b470a2a01a52b27_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.1, 0.32, 0.36, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fdbb6aa9307be74_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.03, 0.38, 0.56, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43261ed2894b1d49_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.15, 0.33, 0.41, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ea1b05f689a411c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.64, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_856e542f0cb77b14_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.14, 0.17, 0.3, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d93febb78cc12531_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.16, 0.28, 0.35, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d07efc090b7f04c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.15, 0.46, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbaef125891d95df_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.81, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea05a6f4448011f7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.41, 0.5, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95a3474d2cb7cc3a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b116b64c9b46d1f8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.21, 0.2, 0.34, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f00e7c5c7171462_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.94, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0e131c682cf8f44_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a8b7c6bf6265d17_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.18, 0.54, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f661ac3e2aca0ed_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5fa67ce15a69575_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.21, 0.18, 0.32, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c012d5b21909814_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.07, 0.36, 0.23, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67d06245b0ad385f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82fafc5fb8470a1f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.15, 0.32, 0.31, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d125dd130a81dc1d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.59, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e05b90b0fcc55e18_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2bcc556c15b64230_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.91, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ce5c9e4dbf2f0a7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a52ac9d214a840a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.71, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48206536b070e71c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.65, 0.29, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d219a1989507e102_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.26, 0.44, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c2dd7ea35e7d320_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7a4c1a5819589e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fffe1738b375f3c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95d0d0ef38a89d6c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.37, 0.1, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4280d5dbac4a006e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.9, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb05d092f288da91_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.55, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ce9aa3ee0dc9bb2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.73, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f467702fae1e0e6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.68, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_694d0b549658d036_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.95, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d7bd6885c989c88b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_319b32287dc43cb0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.6, 0.14, 0.01, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a36c57c87552074_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.14, 0.62, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2d8ae42f84c21ca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.11, 0.13, 0.47, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2e9fb913046210a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e8264c6f6125208_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97577fe446558827_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae51e4312ef7e6b4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3604ab4d3de0fa4f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.06, 0.33, 0.47, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c7d156f4b6bb1b4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.05, 0.95], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0e029f3bfa069cca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.28, 0.23, 0.17, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2164a3c982db7b48_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd24ce2e54a27517_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77fb0cec6945c1f4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_515660117aaec3a8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a19159f43b5c64d3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54fcc85aadd03beb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.38, 0.18, 0.19, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dff04f6f251eb554_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.75, 0.25, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_312b8096a9cdd57f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.2, 0.67, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74f91a7326607884_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.15, 0.25, 0.33, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_49a5ad926c5a7109_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.33, 0.18, 0.13, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b8db5fb0e5c60b6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff587332ff5dfadb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec516bacc14ea831_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.17, 0.22, 0.32, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22a2cbb42ae33b24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.59, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d48c67b908af469_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a682746733369422_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec7e00481620421c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a9492f3d256748d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.25, 0.7, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03e61afdc8e348b9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.16, 0.44, 0.31, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93dabed265c122f1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_46a3c8093cdf7afa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.25, 0.18, 0.31, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e227406608488dc8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95f0b2e6dd52f27e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ecfcd9dc58e6c82_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfc3f3a0b1e6c8c9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.09, 0.18, 0.46, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91199c6bc9048392_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.15, 0.25, 0.33, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16bbfcd419b64e4f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.27, 0.21, 0.25, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_301a0fe012fb6eb7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.17, 0.2, 0.34, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af146c450c7311eb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.06, 0.39, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ba2c40ed8ef72fe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.1, 0.25, 0.46, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_468bfc7a0831b09b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.31, 0.14, 0.2, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c23a5a94e680598c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.24, 0.12, 0.35, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1dfd635a575ae02c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.11, 0.41, 0.29, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93bffbe4515123b2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_297c9262a928864b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.03, 0.31, 0.6, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_882937067cd19159_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.07, 0.36, 0.45, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa9d7bc2fbcdb912_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.72, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eaf01799cea09b35_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b1a8901ea1ddead_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.63, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5d97e48c84ee520_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.38, 0.36, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d63186d23d5563ef_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.05, 0.22, 0.52, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7f897090ad348d6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.1, 0.31, 0.4, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f00c1d842e73b32_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.13, 0.28, 0.41, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3b71466accfed62_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.15, 0.13, 0.41, 0.21, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4abaa027500be947_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_455cb532d1800b23_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.23, 0.18, 0.3, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2edac46ed21ccb3e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.48, 0.26, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12ccbb3c262ed036_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.26, 0.71, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63104ecfb24d3263_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_797e9818378b3f9e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c2845204952f896_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e742dbb8051d64ac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.19, 0.16, 0.35, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc47c04dfd425265_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0aae7adc9d07432_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a50eab695eecc98f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.4, 0.45, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54d6121fb4c8ed8f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.11, 0.19, 0.28, 0.18, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5dfc6cee1d9452bb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93d0d3ffc848676f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.77, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f7b67d720975e61_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1db87b833fed14e8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.74, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfa7fd59e9d840e8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.07, 0.22, 0.48, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3cb4ace4a55d2bf3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.1, 0.47, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_477cdff35e91cfc7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f9d22bbfc663ad2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.37, 0.28, 0.34, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_188949afce8abc5f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61800956d7687c2b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.11, 0.57, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cbc944dfaa717069_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.92, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_185a91b9fd9829e5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca704b59e740f2d1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.75, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddd1ece04ede7e0c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_761b3a2d76c1685c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.08, 0.26, 0.48, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3c00dee3dd16681_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48235130d3bb76c6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.2, 0.18, 0.32, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c0dbf6c85d24101_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1db2d5b7fb25838_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.19, 0.52, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5fe741c97ae95422_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_63837adeed26d1a1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.12, 0.18, 0.32, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68987ffd95b266a2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.69, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ec271bc7d5ec161_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_073ad41d4edd5aa9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.15, 0.27, 0.29, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec516bacc14ea831_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.39, 0.54, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba579495f89670e7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.17, 0.36, 0.28, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81a89e6cd8e88b3c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.18, 0.16, 0.34, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6926092d0fbf42ab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b19959b875873ff6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.13, 0.17, 0.35, 0.25, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3c7a99311f322c89_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.26, 0.69, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41dff1b21b2dff7c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.39, 0.59, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36e835f6e96cfe1c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.45, 0.5, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb27aae97d5ac508_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.14, 0.43, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_136f842942ce6b0a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.82, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33bc98326a7ab0cf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.73, 0.07, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc8f72930682b059_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.12, 0.18, 0.39, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f783f4fc0085b2d5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.16, 0.22, 0.38, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_231214f9b52b90a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.42, 0.57, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5e6f8a10e8d75a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.46, 0.51, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c012d5b21909814_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.59, 0.39, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6da0acb085f16f9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.13, 0.81, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_005d9ee8daf7292a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.17, 0.06, 0.4, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_83a33f33441c7282_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb840dd8d61fbb75_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.1, 0.44, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf6c9078916297bc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.27, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_933547979d8c63d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.22, 0.27, 0.25, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8a824979d41b930_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e84f3f02ac29f265_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.13, 0.27, 0.36, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58b9d937652d8923_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.23, 0.28, 0.25, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00f669450cdb73d2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb7ce3f3d3337763_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f00afa69a6863ed_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.08, 0.35, 0.43, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e9710b399beeeb7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.18, 0.66, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a7ed4755fa87d4b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.05, 0.23, 0.53, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6854ffbad0ae400b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_accff5af23f86f4b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.51, 0.4, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db36d10ce08f1d1a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.27, 0.11, 0.36, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_085ba6f426efe4d3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.93, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1dbdee40d2d2108_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b57eee5d25f46c7b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e974031d3eff7532_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa5b12130bd33ba9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c32cf08354ec825a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c951d3eaa4dfb33_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0beb12005b493ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eecb916b31a8691c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0869dedc5d94793d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c84603f35d717897_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_081f72f3e515a197_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.14, 0.67, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fb3d9413901b46b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.29, 0.66, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03bc0d553aa33b95_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.37, 0.54, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1386fa7754a8cb74_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7d2e16a9bf8bce49_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.53, 0.25, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e7a7b6069ab061a6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0510a9a1f3eb5954_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.19, 0.38, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3fdc0c1c08176f1d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eee726f11d9216c1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.26, 0.46, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e2199ddbe8e08c8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.86, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31256e65c197de49_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.16, 0.22, 0.32, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f129315f204a5b1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.68, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a46339527f41e2c3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.84, 0.16, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdfb36135b5289a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.54, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9373fabb1115421f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.22, 0.35, 0.25, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9d4c0accadcbb25_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.9, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_051eba4e90f2baa0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eac67514a04a14af_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c01d61552a32299_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.78, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b2a8662f2d56d50_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f359924626abc638_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.18, 0.22, 0.38, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce84cdb5d95c6f1b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.09, 0.32, 0.47, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a989a1587933c62_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.13, 0.41, 0.39, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f78af9b5a5b0af33_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.14, 0.19, 0.45, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b427a36ff8c9217_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.65, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88bd8671239c3bdc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c62ff3dcbe8727a4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.05, 0.28, 0.53, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93d4c8f6f7a501ab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.07, 0.31, 0.44, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bef05adfb2128621_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.08, 0.22, 0.44, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e63d166ee9054b01_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.08, 0.15, 0.51, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f232bbc81fd69089_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.18, 0.17, 0.42, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a88688789f0a5d8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_957be0500a26aea2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.61, 0.03, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0962b4d66a919133_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e3353f5527aede7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_828e1cfb84055459_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a1418e139c870a8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.07, 0.28, 0.49, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34505f5883172d77_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.11, 0.47, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6f219dd9f0c436f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.11, 0.19, 0.43, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06fb2a5104f2f4ed_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.06, 0.13, 0.52, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d1bde9b9584ee08_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.18, 0.3, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e2199ddbe8e08c8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.2, 0.61, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0d8ef93daf87163_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29a37a92424e7424_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_726ed6ebea64b7e7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.92, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_248d55177f99c1ec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0707, 0.8182, 0.1111, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31ef5ae385015b7c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.29, 0.26, 0.15, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2820c8d0fb92d299_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4d86a78c503f793_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_513a85a86ad86278_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.22, 0.18, 0.26, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26d35f66060ac180_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.79, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_009b022e08ab74b5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.24, 0.53, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f64190dca26d5cf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36ae23213e9149b7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15013f8c4711e849_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.24, 0.09, 0.32, 0.1, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9749dfb36ac1b233_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2254ee00de8699a2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.15, 0.17, 0.23, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_170391cd941a5594_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.05, 0.07, 0.47, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b2475756bc23809_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_665dfbbd8eeae322_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.18, 0.24, 0.38, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a5300e940c06a9f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.18, 0.52, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aae343c99bea0534_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dccc1be1e015ff02_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.55, 0.28, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0e131c682cf8f44_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.07, 0.64, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9df8d9e42f62d6cd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.35, 0.2, 0.14, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a6de2a92b7228ae0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.42, 0.46, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37910017d3166b16_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.22, 0.31, 0.24, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf389f2ce1c5b6b8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f783f4fc0085b2d5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa1644af299d1a71_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.06, 0.19, 0.54, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb09cc00d7749f2d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f266283cfcf0419_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.45, 0.47, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_051eba4e90f2baa0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.4, 0.55, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49d7f65ff23f3c1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.22, 0.27, 0.26, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb20a33ee5e2b6bb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_08d6f940ad7321cd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee8aa095c97bcaf0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.85, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3115f57746f35692_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.79, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79b36a2462e33cc7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.1, 0.26, 0.4, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2afda46ea41a797_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.12, 0.26, 0.43, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41cd6483cdb98166_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4328a05ea866f370_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.29, 0.46, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7387c350356d325e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.62, 0.23, 0.07, 0.06, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb5856c165d5bcb1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec8cda071d844cdc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.12, 0.2, 0.33, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1c4de7bda344186_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.36, 0.22, 0.25, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ca3f07191591401_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74677287ff2835c3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9959e48b23a85a6d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.14, 0.22, 0.43, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a53469d3bf778a19_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.3, 0.64, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1e764f9a3f530dac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cfd3ad5c0d565c7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.69, 0.0, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59b3a7f5e22e3865_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.16, 0.24, 0.32, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdfc9ec9a7854b5a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.98, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4aba70f3fa6107a7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.16, 0.24, 0.37, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71158706f3643a84_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.07, 0.28, 0.53, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dba82e97a177ca40_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.13, 0.38, 0.36, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3ef5b2e0c71e2a5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.15, 0.31, 0.41, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1643e6305ec20b99_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.12, 0.11, 0.46, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76243abea267f735_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_905549986f1a7eb3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.37, 0.35, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_319a8fc3669e70c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_affe97c3e1a934c1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.23, 0.67, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61800956d7687c2b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_081e9317a677e2e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ba8d3b9f327f18b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.56, 0.37, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91c57126268cab15_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.54, 0.32, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4483f0171bf17547_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_963ff9e228928020_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66cc0191e6ed55da_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8529b1b58bca5dc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.29, 0.12, 0.2, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d980fb329712048e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.72, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3446cd3e64db2624_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.69, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_037f8ad389eb3785_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.18, 0.16, 0.27, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1b1a25711bcea68_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.32, 0.62, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be80cfb3e7ffb835_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd0e503be71913ce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6e5708033bf2ae4f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_463bae9fe0778e13_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a9f2efb5264c986_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2809d8d0c8a941f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.06, 0.01, 0.62], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07c04d38f804a97a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_584f56b861d7e612_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.04, 0.04, 0.39, 0.44, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_466d4a6b8552a504_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_266668e55c03664a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.28, 0.48, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f3299ba8b5897161_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.38, 0.59, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2f97506162162c0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.62, 0.17, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_738d61efddc39aa2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f09730d84367d05b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.12, 0.32, 0.39, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_affe97c3e1a934c1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13f130c4519ed045_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05c6e31d3f40cae2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72379f70b2183d3c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b335ad3d21a259d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4009dcd330ee1fa0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.67, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce23815229556027_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fdf0fe065d26c25_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.12, 0.29, 0.37, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_df22a3795418666a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.08, 0.23, 0.39, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3f612a65b4b1df1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.75, 0.14], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29fee1aceeff4036_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.27, 0.16, 0.24, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_627c603a04a7588d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.32, 0.58, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de0aefa088426aba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.93, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5369c431090adaf8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2bba76112c3b19f7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.21, 0.45, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ef48e2ddc30b98c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.39, 0.53, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b494b9d7806f153_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.79, 0.18, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f21bd542a7bb111_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.16, 0.29, 0.44, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca04d5ef618a0136_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.67, 0.03, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9447cea71e4193b3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.23, 0.32, 0.27, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d4b7141921c13d8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.9, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc9813fc1cb5f2db_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.49, 0.31, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6cb886531ff8db2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.87, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f336b260e48b64b4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.6, 0.39, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a5e87a148ab27b7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae2f6fdd2aa6d677_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.11, 0.37, 0.4, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcb470bfba078263_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.29, 0.53, 0.01, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c011ca72960c698d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c62ff3dcbe8727a4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.14, 0.56, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc8f72930682b059_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.67, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_090c98f8f3b89fdc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.39, 0.12, 0.15, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c10ad26d97189c24_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.1, 0.11, 0.32, 0.33, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31481b7b9b951098_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.08, 0.91, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0e51e7bb3f330b6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.26, 0.21, 0.21, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28bb90b182213669_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a0a4c5a03b9ccb4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.38, 0.35, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_badfaabf1dee8539_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.37, 0.36, 0.14, 0.1, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d67900bbe1a5dfb1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.16, 0.32, 0.29, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_580f7804edad4bcc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.88, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce73c81de3afd4fd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.27, 0.4, 0.21, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81664d7c757f20bd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.29, 0.63, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c39b3897a57b25f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.73, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9929e0623827c448_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.12, 0.23, 0.49, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbaef125891d95df_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31256e65c197de49_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8aa992a0c221d872_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.7, 0.01, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4eb6a5a7f7d0b1fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.91, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7223b082e94bd9c1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c074a11b0185083_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f14e64f4bd6bae8d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.8, 0.01, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3741996dcb98caaa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d5dfe22fcda0045_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.32, 0.28, 0.17, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8c3f91d1578217c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0104fb6afdba011c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.19, 0.31, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d20a5f7cc326010b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4468c4ddabe1b3e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.14, 0.34, 0.28, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04d91636c4de2278_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_270f14184630ffe3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.66, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_907b5a67393eaf63_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.2, 0.45, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_896e5ffcedd0130c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.13, 0.57, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29c3f1790575114e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.61, 0.36, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a0a4c5a03b9ccb4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.18, 0.58, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbc81b6f62b6773c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.64, 0.27, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51e92ac653245ed0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.18, 0.23, 0.44, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b29c180fdc02ce4d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2707408f8ba506d4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.18, 0.64, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e8ad2004f0fdb58_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba4aaf47feea6888_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.2, 0.61, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c67ade09d4fafcd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.33, 0.11, 0.25, 0.04, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2b583bfb559c238_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.22, 0.26, 0.24, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82b5499df41904c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.54, 0.0, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44643d7118da6e5a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc6058933795f5f9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b3f21f7abeae9fc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.28, 0.22, 0.27, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ab2e9093047a283_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b70d7431116a96e7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6bd01c191db322c7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.19, 0.39, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2acdfd3a4cea427_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.51, 0.02, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9a5956df6eabb6ac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.26, 0.14, 0.27, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2809d8d0c8a941f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.23, 0.14, 0.24, 0.13, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b651bbebc0242ea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.16, 0.28, 0.44, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bfa7fd59e9d840e8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.55, 0.38, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8cd171a51c908ae_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.23, 0.26, 0.38, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e614d1b026ccfaf0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_adc2d31d4ca2e30c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.92, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5369c431090adaf8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.24, 0.26, 0.27, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae0c22d30e47f691_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.19, 0.17, 0.27, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_210e64324e573215_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.28, 0.17, 0.32, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ffacbc5e3764ae8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.58, 0.39, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_998b9e8aaffa0c06_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.13, 0.08, 0.22, 0.33, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ab594fe8817f897_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.25, 0.66, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_062acd516f9a4475_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.24, 0.25, 0.25, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbe5625636b4b890_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.51, 0.47, 0.0, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23ee54014177899f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.16, 0.32, 0.45, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_881901fd0d242ac0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.2, 0.2, 0.35, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5bcdda532fd61a9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.21, 0.24, 0.37, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5cf4c222025ac4b3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.79, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a57b49d3ea5c0a9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.1, 0.13, 0.37, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bda57529422533b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.19, 0.16, 0.37, 0.16, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aff7b8f494383220_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.35, 0.52, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cda41f8f6fa96b2a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f3a1b53d92854c17_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3c538ce172346b6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa6ccd3eb93ab9e8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.07, 0.32, 0.52, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f9baf87b4e27a85_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.36, 0.6, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b85e1cc1d53df38a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60b594edb64e4c10_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c1fbb39c6c4935a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa6ccd3eb93ab9e8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.63, 0.32, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77e26e2730065fe5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.25, 0.18, 0.23, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85421b49f29befa9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.12, 0.49, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c30fbd597a554368_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.25, 0.5, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e9f96655077878f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.48, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdd9e0ab3dfd4bd5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b54ccff71388b7e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.09, 0.43, 0.33, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72b566f7607873fa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.79, 0.09, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_693fb533ddc942c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.89, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9989ee2c64a78c93_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.16, 0.01, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99c5e7c55fac52e5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.42, 0.43, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2636c7fd47d2fe5e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.08, 0.33, 0.42, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d62ec8f3b3b0529_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.59, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42ed33edb6eec77b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f2b3c8196bd530a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.84, 0.01, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25520cfa3fab30e5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bff97cd0dabcc53c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.05, 0.33, 0.58, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_14ed34739764d99a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c12da5a1dc93b487_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.21, 0.35, 0.21, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_740dea955ef0f525_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aae343c99bea0534_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.49, 0.34, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8694cc7f8791f93b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f336c6425b8a526d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4c2b7fb748e5a5e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.16, 0.22, 0.29, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cf805cc059881e1c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.14, 0.23, 0.42, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_196d8913ba989710_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7bf82621311ee8a1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.28, 0.55, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7c7a247b903e451_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c767cbb8250671f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3aaa489343e6dd82_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c01340287574a80_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.27, 0.29, 0.27, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c971df91191c863_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22fab628b8bc2aca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0e6ca893a577e005_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.89, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82c89e728b798d1f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_120ac157060b1f82_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47c323c3d2bb0bc8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.11, 0.22, 0.38, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3cb4ace4a55d2bf3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4258e150e17defb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.23, 0.19, 0.29, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a517b25ea06cad6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.66, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2bdab6c894b4ebd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ecfae306bdef8d33_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39e1b1a3d7f8a866_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.9, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c05ea3e601fb24df_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.74, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d7f2c082e6b535e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.22, 0.19, 0.31, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48ac3b7d8d0df0e2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.2, 0.34, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd53a10ae618f056_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.33, 0.65, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2448cdc02ace69a8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.17, 0.34, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98b49cb7ed97f574_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.73, 0.2, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59a488c072b66ee2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.75, 0.1, 0.01, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_740dea955ef0f525_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.12, 0.2, 0.37, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f4e9656333f667c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.57, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4258e150e17defb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_950ab409de6ab04d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.21, 0.18, 0.38, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2edac46ed21ccb3e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84f48bd29d028b33_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_abf8dce6f012c45f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.43, 0.54, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a59a0d0da3fa0f9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.75, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d25400ebffdd0c99_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.02, 0.75, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_999129bb54db97c3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1e2b6dd7183192b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7bf82621311ee8a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_828e1cfb84055459_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.29, 0.16, 0.29, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb0353166c4251ca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c39217ba6084b3b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.56, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2771db13a5f1681c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.92, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e72970b78583de0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.14, 0.57, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6e64d5182210cd5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.15, 0.39, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce73c81de3afd4fd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.51, 0.31, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5e6f8a10e8d75a5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.26, 0.15, 0.37, 0.09, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1776b22ac0d43cd7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.14, 0.19, 0.34, 0.18, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50f354c2ff79b881_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.15, 0.6, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab92da306223831c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b249fa4ade8ac7e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29cf5b4200a5b029_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.71, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d5a1653c52517115_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.75, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dcd07e0be7b830fa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb19b94b3a804659_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.32, 0.37, 0.14, 0.12, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43ea7e49e33bf138_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.57, 0.01, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28bf51570b71a218_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.23, 0.73, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_830c7617ae6e070b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.12, 0.25, 0.48, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36819b2363664fbf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f861f40b286ff8df_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.55, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03a17af52e37011c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.05, 0.06, 0.38, 0.41, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_075ce3026e952ced_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.06, 0.08, 0.41, 0.34, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_919fee624df1c11c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad63178494777b24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d1ddf8b034c9adb9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.27, 0.25, 0.26, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de8080f79be81150_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.09, 0.49, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f467702fae1e0e6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c34b17566851751_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b0b4a66859092dd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57038f26952b492e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.03, 0.26, 0.59, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39dddf104abfd864_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.11, 0.12, 0.26, 0.29, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fadce75370c27224_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.18, 0.29, 0.24, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcf8d81b1eb94851_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86890f39cc660dc8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.07, 0.07, 0.46, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af2ca37f7ea3c954_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b231790ccfaf542e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.93, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c1f246213b9a383_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.41, 0.47, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_152dfc3c34363d36_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.74, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0c41cee41c93840_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.61, 0.31, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9307b4cb2ce1ddc5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.18, 0.4, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_635b305900db356a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.64, 0.28, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8dcc252d59301230_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2edd4efe2593f32_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.66, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74556706d448c81c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.92, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e25876c9cdbc676a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.52, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6db8afd3187bdb0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.31, 0.13, 0.19, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bac33d524cdef3d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.07, 0.21, 0.42, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3334bf015a22a916_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.22, 0.2, 0.28, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8694cc7f8791f93b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.91, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_303f7c592728e764_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.18, 0.24, 0.3, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9ef23194f00e379_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.44, 0.25, 0.16, 0.11, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_441b0f63bc3806bd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.52, 0.48, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67162a234fdfe865_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f68a408fa50c1243_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e604c6d9588ce4f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.46, 0.47, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ab1c284f1d4e3e6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2da1ba99a09efa2e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.32, 0.29, 0.21, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48211e86f6328f25_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.32, 0.63, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a159f9c61d314e8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.13, 0.25, 0.4, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e458eddac744d3a6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.26, 0.27, 0.19, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d470d65b05ea96c0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.05, 0.42, 0.43, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b4037abe537b2f0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.33, 0.01, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38263e4fa9962b04_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9ac554c1326b728_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.32, 0.2, 0.23, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_52c986c35b117aad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.22, 0.16, 0.2, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97d4aa59262fa206_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06fb2a5104f2f4ed_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1cade7c53c7e4c32_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.84, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d32835cec8826855_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.23, 0.67, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8c878d7f77503ab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.32, 0.29, 0.14, 0.17, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7d25c5e9963364c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.92, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6cf2feec9209e81a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.14, 0.12, 0.44, 0.21, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36f35842f7e0fb82_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.74, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b235aaaf6aaff49c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4db14457a0572441_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.11, 0.31, 0.47, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f65cfb125610191d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5fa67ce15a69575_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b69d64509f4c082a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.05, 0.93, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddecaa6debf6a289_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.48, 0.5, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37468dadb2d85967_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.13, 0.5, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5384a1953fa2f6e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.91, 0.0, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2164a3c982db7b48_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.03, 0.28, 0.58, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8379018e170dbfa3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.56, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8edc63854afcb4d4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.12, 0.43, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_529d7c6cc3a8ef8b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.82, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a05e0990ecd024f8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7279d10e97ee629f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.5, 0.33, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22293ff7730c3b77_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.26, 0.09, 0.27, 0.13, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2da40a06387f7329_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0e8c21aecec6468_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.17, 0.21, 0.37, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_209a9953e20a7ea8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.18, 0.41, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_686ff6d4850a1dbf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e14416acb6585ab6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.11, 0.45, 0.33, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_333ea078203307a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.78, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3b107d6505c81ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.11, 0.39, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f0c0be36332edcb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.07, 0.12, 0.31, 0.36, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fa7d3df4868ebb5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.21, 0.24, 0.36, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ed5e7e40e7b7617_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.36, 0.19, 0.21, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e44b0323b41beca9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.26, 0.15, 0.24, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7177ef7f91466d5e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.27, 0.19, 0.19, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d7cc8a1e4138741_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.19, 0.57, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c63e879a56cc720_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b155ea976944d75_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.32, 0.45, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42bf7cb4e4572836_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7198dbf2d313281_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a5b096d6c0b94b8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.15, 0.38, 0.29, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d01ddba1988f1001_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.21, 0.41, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45da1a1edc1d373b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.76, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88cd43ac604132a5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.14, 0.49, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_919fee624df1c11c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.88, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06f2955c3a0f313e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.67, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_229260b0581b67c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.78, 0.19, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c18c499a0ccf92f0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.07, 0.32, 0.43, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74f91a7326607884_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.91, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6cdc1821d7246578_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.13, 0.28, 0.48, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d3f92ba31f4d810_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.64, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25e6fe62b9d71ef9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.08, 0.4, 0.41, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4be0cc19ee6b56de_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.88, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50c0ab549b207522_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.03, 0.77, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a36c57c87552074_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.88, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_30526f5697674e94_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0eb04e55399c6b45_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d5ce8ae4befc497_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.19, 0.14, 0.2, 0.16, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43261ed2894b1d49_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1769ea99f7ed821d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.18, 0.25, 0.31, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f220dcbdddfbb25_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.14, 0.4, 0.39, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4501d62e83117dfa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.5, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0ecfe60df0a8a93_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.04, 0.04, 0.46, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea6c4efe5daa3782_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41e6b1d2a3c3eff6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.34, 0.59, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a6aa9908fc3e85c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.11, 0.25, 0.43, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_761b3a2d76c1685c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.82, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b335ad3d21a259d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.16, 0.35, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdedd4ba120c2618_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.46, 0.43, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eaf01799cea09b35_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.2, 0.7, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01bc743ede1fd90d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.5, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ccae54e8439134ae_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.03, 0.3, 0.62, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b3f21f7abeae9fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f068121ec7f4f7e1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9a0c1ec32c3bc774_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_496f54aebf265aba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3124efb71d486f6d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.21, 0.47, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a16e1c79252e754_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.21, 0.54, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5d98e954df8dee6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.14, 0.58, 0.23, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d1fa9b51b7b385b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.16, 0.53, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1636eee4b688c47b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf470dfa4f035fd5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.05, 0.21, 0.51, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d7557db951ceddd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.68, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_342ee7da22a6cd54_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.09, 0.47, 0.38, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29c9870ff069ed49_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.72, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd808fa8de675355_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.96, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31256e65c197de49_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.16, 0.46, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b57fe7cd8a734a2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.61, 0.35, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_32d34568cd939f10_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca69647250e5348e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.81, 0.16, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1801c25e22bb84c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.23, 0.25, 0.31, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cdb503690c0ea3d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.82, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca456010321f11ff_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2da1ba99a09efa2e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.8, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d9bbd7c4c316dc94_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.3, 0.1, 0.42, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cd0a50f0fe6bfb3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.23, 0.5, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_150cbb5614b0c565_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.08, 0.19, 0.34, 0.17], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa1644af299d1a71_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1352acaed0d38172_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.14, 0.31, 0.37, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57d0c99cbd7ef9fd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4279eeddda04721_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.16, 0.45, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_761b3a2d76c1685c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81e6d7b9fa7edb80_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.58, 0.02, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1ce311eb7018fb1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_906ef4410aec97c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.66, 0.33, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d2edc0a8c9bd23c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.27, 0.46, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88bd8671239c3bdc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.18, 0.6, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8276655b5ada2250_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.05, 0.26, 0.52, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4468c4ddabe1b3e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8eaac9c94e5d03ee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.86, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f819b236e4738c4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.2, 0.27, 0.24, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc6058933795f5f9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.1, 0.27, 0.45, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aeb357993d169597_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.3, 0.14, 0.34, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9259fd037d4dd57_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.76, 0.02, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4998dce24f528325_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.08, 0.84, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3402279674add094_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.67, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b10cd6d9461d32f0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_253b1fdc7a241e9a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_682cfe0c95ae2897_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.44, 0.38, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6cd9cd2fdc374b58_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.5, 0.12, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_263e2d07f8267165_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.22, 0.5, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dfbbfda8498092a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.8, 0.04, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a682746733369422_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.34, 0.65, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0445ba81031084_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb4b4fc3bcce0931_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.12, 0.28, 0.43, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8f88ea6ba2be811_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.3, 0.21, 0.27, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_49274b93a729d0d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.2, 0.57, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb98cf3caa5052b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.84, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4d86a78c503f793_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.11, 0.14, 0.48, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdb962a669cfd95b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29371956a4d687cd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a3f2470ada1364e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.16, 0.2, 0.28, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22a1256effcee9f6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76489ff9bcaca304_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.33, 0.33, 0.2, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4c872647eba2e93_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.09, 0.3, 0.47, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1f8e0a32b15949b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_65312a83e1f9b969_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b54ccff71388b7e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe1be61e778ff96d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.72, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc1918048abf8a61_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c73c382f5c6e3e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.75, 0.1, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_37910017d3166b16_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad4664f7f0770acf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.16, 0.22, 0.4, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3a61f0ad345b264_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.07, 0.93], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5d24c3bce51dc0c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1adecccc931246f9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.03, 0.34, 0.52, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_881901fd0d242ac0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.39, 0.57, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d1ddf8b034c9adb9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab4c1431ac2f6ea9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b469d0adfd6ca5a8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.32, 0.14, 0.16, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ea1b05f689a411c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_08348ed32ffff9db_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5648ef750c059b5c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88cf29c8724ae6c8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd75cbb4a3fbcd68_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7f897090ad348d6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5df603e21aa09474_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.75, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c85090315f2d5e45_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.64, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d620ca1e61957da5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aeeb10f4dd9adafb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99ed03fa649c5c99_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.51, 0.42, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e41497332b56201_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_957be0500a26aea2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.08, 0.31, 0.44, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa5b12130bd33ba9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.16, 0.45, 0.22, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad7dda65f6a7e898_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.75, 0.11, 0.01, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b07ed3bc053ff6a6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.9, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c5bbc106a3a80b4e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.3, 0.43, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5ffeab894967f69_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.12, 0.22, 0.42, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_896e5ffcedd0130c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.28, 0.64, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93e6d80474886241_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6bdc4dc8011b2a2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.81, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e3da9c6b163ad83_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.15, 0.14, 0.3, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cde7f598e003338_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d659d938261c8bc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d7f84b9d3060d9da_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.28, 0.09, 0.37, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c304d685f1b1336e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.87, 0.13, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8080ded628bf2b8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.05, 0.95], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd614d02adb48171_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.64, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd3ee92f3059e5f7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0404, 0.3333, 0.5556, 0.0707], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_21c9bc68f541796d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.31, 0.45, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_387990be11db3d42_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.1, 0.1, 0.38, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fa61469f7617a28_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3a43949d710ec11_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e92a6134661bb736_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.08, 0.38, 0.46, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73dffe64ea8d05c6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.26, 0.66, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_02a2bacae6031b44_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.22, 0.14, 0.36, 0.11, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9022dc160bb7d83_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3419aaaf4b60485_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.7, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5ffeab894967f69_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.89, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_887859c306182bfe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8172863914d4989_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_edb212bc91f2ff3e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.18, 0.43, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_495be9831b4ec343_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.22, 0.6, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eae9823b19bd585b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62a7d8f5f9b69590_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.11, 0.24, 0.44, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef56a32a57df886e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.69, 0.29, 0.0, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9878b0524212015_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.4, 0.35, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_765c5309e02233a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.08, 0.02, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c1f246213b9a383_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.28, 0.25, 0.25, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3291f9bc175628f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.14, 0.07, 0.4, 0.22, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_233a2b84038ca3c6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.34, 0.27, 0.22, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c51e933af9af5c3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d656dde86ddff97_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.06, 0.06, 0.5, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_922435ff689e8d08_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0869dedc5d94793d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.11, 0.09, 0.28, 0.34, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0b7aebbb1a27297_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1144bf484cac98a3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.48, 0.48, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42c650d943e47f98_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea07bc4582ce1cd2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_beaab8cb554ef240_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.3, 0.16, 0.22, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c0dbf6c85d24101_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.33, 0.18, 0.17, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2254ee00de8699a2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1746ba1aaceba612_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.6, 0.35, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5dc0399422e11119_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2b7cb609a9e1974_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.11, 0.13, 0.2, 0.35, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9201a8baff9ece02_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3fd7bd996b281367_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.33, 0.55, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54e7b40e5a96ea07_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ab818ba1db1b7a9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.13, 0.29, 0.46, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f90448befd5e2a57_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.37, 0.41, 0.14, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4b77154e97a8d09_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.81, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddf91359d686cc52_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_171a5cdeff73a324_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.77, 0.02, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3a61f0ad345b264_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.32, 0.15, 0.26, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73dffe64ea8d05c6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42ed33edb6eec77b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.19, 0.2, 0.29, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2be341237fd07f11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.68, 0.23, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0602325693aed705_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7177ef7f91466d5e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.84, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec898cb1c2f88954_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f50f372396e7117_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0809aef0ded86f2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.53, 0.41, 0.04, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f68a408fa50c1243_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.39, 0.44], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b6e42e75c87a3c0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.24, 0.66, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee4413d41edc569f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.24, 0.27, 0.25, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fa9fbb237d12fa4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.17, 0.51, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_30f7f70f699d5041_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7fe5d220025dc5c2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.06, 0.29, 0.46, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_334d5b43492639a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.66, 0.04, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a17d8748a0d193b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.66, 0.33, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ae92405c71a45d3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.47, 0.52, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdd9e0ab3dfd4bd5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.42, 0.05, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d523ce2b7847a29d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.21, 0.21, 0.33, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c18c499a0ccf92f0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.71, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdfc9ec9a7854b5a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.17, 0.26, 0.35, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ceb1a229e44e121c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.23, 0.1, 0.38, 0.14, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1fc54b19fa42fdd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.96, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8b4ee410b7a42a0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.39, 0.61, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87d1d7be4cd4063c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.19, 0.2, 0.24, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4abaa027500be947_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.53, 0.01, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_122d51aa790b5bfa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ca982933bdb380c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_309722ffb5ae9d66_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_017ecd1123796e24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34505f5883172d77_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.09, 0.74, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e28b22dfabbba4b8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38b3c8720e2f2624_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.61, 0.25, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f819b236e4738c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.84, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acfa8a8d32865a21_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.34, 0.17, 0.14, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b11859ee2c2d82f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51955409a3157abd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.24, 0.76, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d67fb3af9e2670e1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.11, 0.35, 0.35, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47dba92e81c22aca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b57eee5d25f46c7b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.12, 0.41, 0.3, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad11e3f0601a1264_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.18, 0.36, 0.27, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a25a41d5d521dd24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.21, 0.78, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0306506d08096173_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.83, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6b7e1bc0cd8afdd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.07, 0.93], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_613d8d24a3d44593_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.82, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_016c2dc94e1bfd08_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a6353cd0eed6364_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.26, 0.1, 0.42, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1ae3cfddb98a8ce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88848c97a29406d1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.3, 0.19, 0.16, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82b5499df41904c4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.27, 0.16, 0.32, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e72a9f110cb9344_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.04, 0.26, 0.6, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b494b9d7806f153_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ec483c31de14d74_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.95, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34c6365e5611f430_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.14, 0.57, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8ebad6280793f9f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.45, 0.19, 0.11, 0.2, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cdb503690c0ea3d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.15, 0.31, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c19b83cbccc5c388_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.19, 0.26, 0.25, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a28b9475ee217ee8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.17, 0.14, 0.32, 0.2, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b7f2c3d8adb838a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.15, 0.15, 0.33, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7223b082e94bd9c1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.12, 0.47, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c40aa3626914f58_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.15, 0.45, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b6fd0e38b070565_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.26, 0.33, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a25ee6c93548556_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.38, 0.6, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25f558626b676e91_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca456010321f11ff_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.16, 0.39, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_492e3a6070a1619d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.64, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4308b03e13be070e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.16, 0.19, 0.4, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75eea3b3202654ec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a53d545421761987_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58e7ac4626093cba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34285c36c77cc644_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.85, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eed02623a2bd312a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.69, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_53ba4720d9461da9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_122d51aa790b5bfa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.46, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_adbc5d978ea68951_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.23, 0.56, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4e6fc9507774b93_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.89, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9401feb77bf162a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.82, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d4d92f162bac6ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.57, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c10c7b2e5882862f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67073d723b968bdb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.68, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd9cdb632f2e0bad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2539342466cb8ab4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.74, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8fb29232bf573816_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.36, 0.6, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2771db13a5f1681c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.22, 0.28, 0.23, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f74641a897ba5f07_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.15, 0.41, 0.36, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4b80f98a6378624_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77a999c57ad4685e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.48, 0.31, 0.09, 0.09, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9a3f944e239effe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.03, 0.0, 0.91], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4eaa1b829ce4a6df_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.27, 0.65, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7223b082e94bd9c1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.69, 0.28, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8357705f5468bedb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4efb2da1fe55d390_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.07, 0.34, 0.42, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d53369579db06c8f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.12, 0.3, 0.36, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51e2ec5ccff24e51_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.69, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d89879c5486a3237_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.29, 0.17, 0.24, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0545a3d4089a23e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.23, 0.56, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10277fdcb4c9da10_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.08, 0.19, 0.42, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f71cca40428fff0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.69, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79d51f986929ad53_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.7, 0.29, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ebb6189214c2317_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.61, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9505807fc9a3167_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91c57126268cab15_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.1, 0.14, 0.42, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b948e2f6a8e00f71_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.09, 0.45, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6f8c588427ad8d9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.85, 0.0, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_483ef1c44d148f92_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88a65b5e879cafd6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d241f4d081e0c96_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b37e3c498aa80ab5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.4, 0.29, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f67b3b7d4dec1491_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.15, 0.26, 0.19, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d6ae3f234998b20_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.3, 0.63, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e47e7126a3eaa197_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.34, 0.07, 0.31, 0.07, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e40bbabf32dd0e9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.08, 0.42, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_392174c204e0b2ed_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_025dc0740efb4ff9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.27, 0.21, 0.27, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74fe79fddd098d84_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.26, 0.48, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71355f60ae325e56_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6b21fd1a1558e7fe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.89, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7d2e16a9bf8bce49_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a71797ba97b97978_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.15, 0.26, 0.34, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9630988cb76ca617_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1869908c7bac1e26_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1e2077f11b2e870_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f0258a2ec84673d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.72, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b249fa4ade8ac7e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.23, 0.21, 0.26, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4cfbb0d8365e7df7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.11, 0.28, 0.39, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0aec4d77d858e5c3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.48, 0.32, 0.16], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e327632ab80b9b31_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.19, 0.07, 0.4, 0.21, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9387bac96bdc49c2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_310e2392ac4759ce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.55, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72674c4a3100ee77_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.97, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d32a7091498464b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.7, 0.29, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5499fb1fad1cbca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af4a05306ab6d23a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5766cd4433f628fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c39e6ff11162f62f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.78, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60c19fad633f2aaf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.36, 0.63, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25f656c68847c5f6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dd2029e05f62afa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.06, 0.07, 0.47, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5579c4b5093ae7b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54535ed03d0465fb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.84, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72e849921ff1b13e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d38934c5dbf445a2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.1, 0.16, 0.43, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8873489ae41b5f26_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.6, 0.01, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a2f0c6ba6910e67_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb879da9369b760e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad5bcc20a3e4ca04_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.11, 0.49, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ee4741f596d4f8a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.57, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe1be61e778ff96d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.18, 0.36, 0.32, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59751c9a8ef9e238_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.15, 0.29, 0.37, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2c97687a4d59a83_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b22570a7bd10d3d6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.31, 0.47, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d9ed44e96b76f01_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.17, 0.46, 0.21, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d7eb78adb9010878_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.15, 0.33, 0.4, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04d91636c4de2278_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.09, 0.31, 0.39, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55245d5afc872260_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_696433981ab5660d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.16, 0.66, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d7f84b9d3060d9da_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_332a226d26766c56_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.27, 0.22, 0.34, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45ecca747d7e0ab2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_effd8eff68e8276d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.08, 0.31, 0.47, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f47b70a676d68d43_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9d96439cb82ff87_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.28, 0.72, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b1a8901ea1ddead_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50d3def6d8cedde3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c524570fe270d3b2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c37e1972dc49403_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce3c7ddaebd84f40_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.81, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d3a4cf55f942286_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.16, 0.2, 0.34, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b222c9d9bb067923_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7c573563929ee86_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.31, 0.69, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_798c0b998f35acf2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b01cbc52f1df7daa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.53, 0.12, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b38b1be52944e2d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.25, 0.65, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acd4909462fc26d1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_53b4ded34a2324bf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c809855125cc15a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.28, 0.67, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_70ff45fca556b5ce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_baa07f246f7db63e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.68, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_353cd8dd73270852_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.94, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2bc58b5f0fad3c9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.2, 0.22, 0.34, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6ab2746b8373a35e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.67, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a970d6e235f4b475_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.35, 0.4, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31109ee3d91cbd23_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.11, 0.36, 0.32, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72e953ebaf54b0a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.26, 0.73, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0c374b8ac32db8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.92, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a51c5e2bfba0dca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8e2f4ddbf001739_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.88, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_196d8913ba989710_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.24, 0.47, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fc4f6ab949defd7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.02, 0.87, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dff04f6f251eb554_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.1, 0.16, 0.41, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ce421564f81f2c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.96, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44643d7118da6e5a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.34, 0.2, 0.18, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b76f1f4fc6400854_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.13, 0.27, 0.31, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_19a601ed7e711266_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.14, 0.16, 0.37, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ada8455d9abba8e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.93, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1756212e7fabf39d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.03, 0.25, 0.65, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_845b7821e052aa94_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34450c5d1aa51530_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_291e432f4e05e1e1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f63a6fa728ac806_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.72, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17dcb9c756bd497d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_756aa32d830f060c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.11, 0.45, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e0113d8b3b01131_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.75, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a26ab97bce2ff3d5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.13, 0.49, 0.33, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea00da9e6dd0bc58_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.13, 0.52, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94702060630acfd0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22c01852ef6598a7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.78, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_823ce5508f4970db_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.06, 0.14, 0.36, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a33f6b026daf6c2a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.2, 0.2, 0.37, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0306506d08096173_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.01, 0.04, 0.35, 0.55, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f3c3c233971851de_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d0988db92efb5d1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3dcd25299e46f439_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cdc2386a3a045e2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d258ad41c1c1ff5c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.4, 0.02, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ae23a4a025e35bd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.35, 0.4, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d241f4d081e0c96_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.49, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_389d5d7d707653a8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.86, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_284de8520ed4ec6f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96d620a7a05360d4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.27, 0.19, 0.28, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78abb1234a535529_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.83, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe8d92be547e687a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.15, 0.15, 0.25, 0.26, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67be76803491cd5a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.43, 0.46, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c1f246213b9a383_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff2c855c7e8effb4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_213352bafaa253c6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6473b91eed057e2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_694d0b549658d036_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.16, 0.31, 0.3, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23b32508e247ad7e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.17, 0.19, 0.38, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0ef956d3af2e499_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.6, 0.23, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_952f20835d73db22_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.84, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f7f897090ad348d6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.37, 0.52, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6ee9a232169c94a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.34, 0.59, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3419aaaf4b60485_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cde4ba1a4d8ce8b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.76, 0.11, 0.01, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c66484b3f2fc3478_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.13, 0.34, 0.46, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae141c6f91ec3292_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e8264c6f6125208_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.34, 0.45, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_106fa3d31e9090fd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3927949ca4e9c71_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.16, 0.29, 0.33, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb3e801e51772bf4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.09, 0.62, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_102c92933ebb23f5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e25876c9cdbc676a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84fa9827c290a70a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.05, 0.29, 0.54, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb7ce3f3d3337763_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.18, 0.28, 0.25, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60ce98eb90a70c5d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.12, 0.1, 0.27, 0.25, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e3a2ffab9af5341_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.19, 0.71, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a65650e1d6e4309f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_32385eb1c0432a93_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.75, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97c87d0333f205d9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.78, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8861e5cf634e8da5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.79, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a848906ca754ff71_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.92, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_20ce1d4e8cbad99a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bee747ffe3b4f738_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.9, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de914d2c39df5630_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.17, 0.4, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f69c4384d940c19_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.67, 0.33, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbd39986757b2633_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.27, 0.58, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3934ef13917db101_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.64, 0.36, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e312a2c8080307c7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.24, 0.49, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d60e5df51153323a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.8, 0.17, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25e6fe62b9d71ef9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.1, 0.72, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ef7a20540d39c2d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.22, 0.28, 0.27, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ab7dc0527eded64_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.37, 0.57, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0778ddc2552d1d3b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.26, 0.31, 0.22, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f81c7d1921d0bba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.84, 0.15], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b512b5e4d87d7eb6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.07, 0.83, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7b365ddddece4ff_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.17, 0.29, 0.33, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0e27dd5aff2f3d0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_157c0823d82121e1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.6, 0.36, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3b4f134290499b9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.0, 0.93, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72b566f7607873fa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e41497332b56201_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.2, 0.35, 0.27, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a42026caca16025_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c32b2b9d16a54bc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.96, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5bcdda532fd61a9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.69, 0.26, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e955c73f3dc30554_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.8, 0.01, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe5b9cd54af6b4fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0d8ef93daf87163_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.24, 0.16, 0.27, 0.15, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_563b209603516b98_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.29, 0.21, 0.29, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5933560d9a5e10d7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b7f2c3d8adb838a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0038babd7f4be7f1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.23, 0.71, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_388faceb88fc122a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.13, 0.28, 0.29, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d12fa8fe9b41a8c1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.31, 0.32, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cd11f99999e0f6d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98b49cb7ed97f574_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_950f7ac48024e089_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_117907106881a926_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.08, 0.11, 0.38, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_721d94bff0eb74f4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.17, 0.32, 0.29, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_feb6a30e087650ae_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.07, 0.09, 0.45, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84df3f73826a79be_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.76, 0.05, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbb290c3161df68d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.84, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00534ee46533ac59_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.23, 0.49, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3dcd25299e46f439_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.79, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_09cf3eeb271ff65d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b795dd0c6834318_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.89, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b116b64c9b46d1f8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_efb85c41732b6a2b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.58, 0.02, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28bd64b4baf2b965_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.15, 0.5, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe3198f901a8ea97_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.16, 0.37, 0.17, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3a43949d710ec11_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.13, 0.29, 0.36, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc88379c81c8b217_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa5b12130bd33ba9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.67, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2d8ae42f84c21ca_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_535e5d350d206288_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.34, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d1f8d6e9dda3724_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.11, 0.14, 0.33, 0.23, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a6de3bc90f84b127_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.18, 0.39, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_19bbc121163af6c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.67, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3493dca982786adb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c2b9b876a20f960_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.74, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1026df530e81b7b8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.86, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58deb5b8abd49332_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.57, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9ded394acdd6fa8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.22, 0.57, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79dd719541484445_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bef5138c80a974bb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec898cb1c2f88954_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.16, 0.84, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b06925b9476c3dff_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.07, 0.38, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da428d9f6325f81b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.13, 0.39, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54fcc85aadd03beb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.24, 0.55, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d59f2180183b723f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.05, 0.05, 0.39, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cdf64b2ad9322e9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.29, 0.55, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc3f5bb784567fa4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77fb0cec6945c1f4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.49, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c12da5a1dc93b487_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.55, 0.0, 0.13], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be36407938251fb9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.93, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31d97169e6cf7351_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54106c2fd79b3455_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.53, 0.43, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fac9bd190b65a98d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.61, 0.2, 0.02, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6fdf7e51ec62d0c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f09c787da6254468_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.94, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ea028e2f5422b69_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.13, 0.25, 0.39, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4b77154e97a8d09_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.3, 0.48, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1ae3cfddb98a8ce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.5, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_faf732b71149b87c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_725ec49cb03109a6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_178afd440fa0112e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.73, 0.25, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f47ce6e07c9e01e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.14, 0.14, 0.4, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0a1277d82ed00ac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.87, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcc32bce8cac8bd7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c66484b3f2fc3478_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.5, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59c340a77a18629f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.17, 0.44, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab82b93547f56e98_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.53, 0.06, 0.0, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6edfe2d1804f24bc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.8, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c4a177905d24ebb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.1, 0.14, 0.36, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_712e44acd5e64c57_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01e259f0de8e7e82_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.12, 0.56, 0.29, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_804ecb94cb380a3a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.47, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b26191c7d977f634_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6390ef0f11bb0dbf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.65, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4362367219a2f885_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.24, 0.7, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cb246a0957e28a7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.66, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eae9823b19bd585b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.29, 0.47, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ad3d4e7766a83fa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.13, 0.38, 0.38, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d97e81d5a5dc416_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.85, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_309722ffb5ae9d66_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.91, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dad748ce9155182_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.18, 0.16, 0.31, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ac1700f285ba3d9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.14, 0.51, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a5aabf044b31077_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.95, 0.02, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_335cd89d2a608000_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.02, 0.32, 0.63, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59a488c072b66ee2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.23, 0.17, 0.31, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81d6f399208a3529_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d28faebef23f4415_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_783e6f300dd07d8f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.27, 0.2, 0.25, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91c32bd058ca7b71_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.27, 0.48, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ebfe64d471d0a02d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.31, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39a2d07a151cf440_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbd39986757b2633_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.3, 0.21, 0.23, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1673376740932a4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.05, 0.39, 0.53, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6f2e41bbd90b76ea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.12, 0.5, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36ae23213e9149b7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.25, 0.41, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b431e7f81bc6fe51_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.14, 0.19, 0.32, 0.24, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f24c75d4e4bb2635_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.33, 0.03, 0.38], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0d3aef03b87c73c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.24, 0.26, 0.26, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49a2ca9e5bd88f8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.81, 0.09, 0.01, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6be9cae69b2043e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f19ad8c28e11b9e6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.71, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f162c74a0074ce1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.49, 0.34, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4c872647eba2e93_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8482416eba7a5fb2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.94, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c64edbe96549455_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.12, 0.14, 0.33, 0.26, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33c4f9f401b3e78f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.2, 0.2, 0.33, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1723dad366370e5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.31, 0.22, 0.23, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_859d4927618b331a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.47, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3285d91e3d8e0547_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.81, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0b958a1ed820057_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_291e432f4e05e1e1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.18, 0.5, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d88421419165887_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d234084be15c3479_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.09, 0.24, 0.44, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e78671158036896a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.48, 0.49, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c9a4715916f6a21_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.07, 0.42, 0.38, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4aba70f3fa6107a7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fd3983dda979497_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.62, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c015f62bcac28445_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.3, 0.24, 0.24, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_515e6d7494f5da24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28b3b22ebd871f96_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9330c4008d45e89f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.8, 0.19, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b74f4ac18e62ed27_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.81, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdd8c769b0183e18_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62900bb5c075f39c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04fd18da7726df3a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f63539dff5526916_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.33, 0.19, 0.16, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f6a42d2d9cae7081_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.67, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9195cdeb2654a74a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.07, 0.23, 0.56, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b776ffd28d74d24c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.11, 0.32, 0.37, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e458eddac744d3a6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.83, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8341fdbab1805a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7198dbf2d313281_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.62, 0.36, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f221e7505dfd0d11_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.51, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aec93cafcc1e3d94_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.75, 0.17], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f512f2395f7dc2e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.45, 0.42, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5cfee2f71c05bdfb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.49, 0.06, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7c2b9b876a20f960_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.15, 0.42, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c895998a107e89fc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.21, 0.26, 0.26, 0.16, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_662585bd27b95916_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.81, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b249fa4ade8ac7e0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.59, 0.18, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc88379c81c8b217_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.16, 0.47, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34ee090563e4867f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d113ff5475ad3381_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.32, 0.47, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_136f842942ce6b0a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.19, 0.18, 0.24, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_354b3f2ddbdfa705_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.14, 0.55, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_283abd1c9480715b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.47, 0.51, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f47b70a676d68d43_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.2, 0.24, 0.29, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66094535c1e608f3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.31, 0.18, 0.23, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d21f51e06bdec0a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.78, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_243d1666fe40b9e6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96669081690244a6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_363ac32feb9a610d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee426601e16ac79f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4a33bc7dfae5c0a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.2, 0.13, 0.25, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50b422f18b992d78_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7707d7f93b6e4fee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.95, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f512f2395f7dc2e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d1fa9b51b7b385b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33fe919b8dd847c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.56, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8c4e3ff9d5c24c3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.27, 0.48, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_20726cfb6746006c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.27, 0.49, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a92526f01af0e59b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_064abd09c5af6910_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca456010321f11ff_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.54, 0.33, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9006bd5a380416bc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.67, 0.22, 0.01, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_adbc5d978ea68951_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03c85abeed470c04_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.1, 0.16, 0.39, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4bdc13370035f6ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39b16ed27c99318d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.19, 0.29, 0.32, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3f612a65b4b1df1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_886556f5f8aff22e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ed7caff225e44c76_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.63, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f9d22bbfc663ad2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13903f14fc1bc700_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.1, 0.23, 0.44, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7873ca98cd8ba86e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.82, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c7284993ccee78f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.37, 0.58, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0752cb9ec510bb36_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82fafc5fb8470a1f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05d1664d13ee5155_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.04, 0.43, 0.5, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_effd8eff68e8276d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a36c57c87552074_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66d940237e05c815_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.02, 0.81, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_478aad9aa4133433_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.84, 0.05, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_087bed6704d4237e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.61, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be470f70591b4e83_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f089e304cceb1316_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.24, 0.42, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_804ecb94cb380a3a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.27, 0.27, 0.27, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96669081690244a6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.48, 0.3, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91d402bfd8551f05_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d768543415e796f2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.04, 0.06, 0.53, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f06a38cf535a036_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bbf05100802de903_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af662594cec46263_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.44, 0.37, 0.14, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1141722b0c659d09_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ae44a6b7e5913cb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.54, 0.27, 0.11, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c4221b2c830f7be_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42bf7cb4e4572836_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.09, 0.19, 0.46, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6d14d74dd7467fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.89, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d9710b2a6c465aee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.71, 0.29, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3ed21dbe30c7d30_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.12, 0.14, 0.38, 0.24, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1132d19d14eb74d3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.29, 0.14, 0.27, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82e7af2431a0c8d6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.76, 0.0, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_150cbb5614b0c565_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.22, 0.73, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be36407938251fb9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.16, 0.09, 0.3, 0.25, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57119c6a88e78377_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.41, 0.22, 0.14, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb7ce3f3d3337763_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.24, 0.67, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_88055425239e48a8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.72, 0.04, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dc5fa52c4efe6cb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.67, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00f669450cdb73d2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.84, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c78ce82d4984995e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.84, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6d14d74dd7467fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c8b2bb406c2db09_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7347d29c16aaf2cd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.12, 0.35, 0.44, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_221c5d68c975798a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_067ee27cfdee3a6e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.3, 0.43, 0.19, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc736351158e18b6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.12, 0.16, 0.37, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4617f9dd111311a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.49, 0.47, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_70ec9ea2999f56ce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.4, 0.42, 0.15, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6edfe2d1804f24bc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c2fc7fe6f328017_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_363ac32feb9a610d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.89, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d1e1398ac561999e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.13, 0.1, 0.29, 0.33, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb13f118ae49dcb3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.83, 0.14], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e2160dd6f162d49_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.57, 0.42, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf412ae6628d2989_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.53, 0.13, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3fd8971a9f1b705_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1973f1b948090ea3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5c143f947cb6cbb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12ccbb3c262ed036_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.14, 0.21, 0.32, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_efb85c41732b6a2b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_757b077b2d684671_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e4203d79b11befa7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.56, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a114a06dc9122c19_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b0193fe765548d5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.05, 0.51, 0.42, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71158706f3643a84_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d97096968be652e7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fa61469f7617a28_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.89, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_750d507f2dc9dbfb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_980e74dc6c9fda8a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.29, 0.47, 0.2, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96a4fffe9ef5a2aa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1901208013bc1aab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.35, 0.2, 0.14, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7aec593c244322ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f00e7c5c7171462_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aeb364d3815cb53e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.44, 0.23, 0.09, 0.17, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b1deb56a8ef0cdce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22c01852ef6598a7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9472475add1efc7a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.12, 0.29, 0.33, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04977a2fa2c5d790_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ab49e6369927eb6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_840508fe083ddb01_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.09, 0.26, 0.39, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9018651ba7c2bdc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b8f51bea835bab7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.8, 0.15, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42bd318a5d3e9edc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.11, 0.47, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a10188087b42cd1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.23, 0.23, 0.33, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bda57529422533b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d206d67ec4ce32b3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.19, 0.36, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d8b4ee410b7a42a0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b25ca7192758167e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.14, 0.27, 0.38, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7fe978590bd9c66_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.16, 0.16, 0.35, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_798c0b998f35acf2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.25, 0.45, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e44df57367945d5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.89, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_02a2bacae6031b44_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a269d903a7488899_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d17d92fb53d09bb4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.5, 0.48, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5499fb1fad1cbca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.77, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4aba70f3fa6107a7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.02, 0.84, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_619bde0cc5d177f5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.23, 0.45, 0.27, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36a6070c14bf9df7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e64756f4ea258a22_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.93, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_455cb532d1800b23_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0e1d17a845b445f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ffb7fce2e0158c97_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.06, 0.43, 0.48, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9b6b7da431529f6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.91, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d94a73ee5557edfc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.58, 0.19, 0.07, 0.13, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fa9fbb237d12fa4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6639475a2edef782_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.91, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4efb2da1fe55d390_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.72, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91c57126268cab15_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e207abe2ff49429_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_958c36110a29d645_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.21, 0.35, 0.34, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f78a6d532643d3b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.94, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f359924626abc638_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8e7d7b9b5f0c194_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.06, 0.41, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b364bfdb91a79700_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.87, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea05a6f4448011f7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.29, 0.12, 0.34, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b2a8662f2d56d50_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.7, 0.29, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f3299ba8b5897161_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.19, 0.4, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b8f8fb18ec82fe9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb19b94b3a804659_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a71797ba97b97978_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.53, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f0258a2ec84673d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.21, 0.25, 0.25, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e72970b78583de0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aeeb10f4dd9adafb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.6, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cdd20fae554d60e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a36f21f4c8b7d276_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.21, 0.37, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0b958a1ed820057_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.21, 0.54, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c20afb325785a4b7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6f192c347301ba6a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.22, 0.51, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ed02725611d1159_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_171a5cdeff73a324_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a639365b37e4c72_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.59, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_64cd688a6485e45f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.71, 0.13, 0.01, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e7ec9f50c5eb6ca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.14, 0.41, 0.26, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b94e0fa5ca38641c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f3a1b53d92854c17_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.39, 0.49, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2a66427f20ac0ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.7, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b064b0a17abaaaab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.56, 0.01, 0.23], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_059a2fd32d0ae2c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.63, 0.23, 0.04, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f736dbb9aa8d084f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3537a791dcdcaa0a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.36, 0.55, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_310e2392ac4759ce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0707, 0.2828, 0.2727, 0.2828, 0.0808, 0.0101], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39d521722e7d1f94_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.49, 0.48, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1673376740932a4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.94, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b059638dc6b2d87_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.2, 0.23, 0.25, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76489ff9bcaca304_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.36, 0.52, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfc1b7170ee214b1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4552c2084fff26c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.19, 0.52, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26e0d32e4d3f44fd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34663cedb5dddf4d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.95, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3b5b8472a172147_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.46, 0.29, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da8b61a6f750bab3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82a4a31e4c6ff5f7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33c4f9f401b3e78f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a6353cd0eed6364_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3426983da89424f2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bd9cbbee65f76af_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.14, 0.12, 0.36, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16ad96277f64d94d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.24, 0.26, 0.32, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cda67e2772e9b5db_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.86, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_545f742029f24e4c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.04, 0.28, 0.58, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36ffdf052f8abc3f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.28, 0.1, 0.29, 0.07, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_08c88ec564dccf6f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dec0fd7b02613240_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.4, 0.27, 0.14, 0.15, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f3a1b53d92854c17_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.07, 0.27, 0.5, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_02f9dc9cd3ffd199_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.31, 0.33, 0.19, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_868c3bf23f527a11_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.16, 0.36, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5403d48269d11052_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.68, 0.23, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76f2d4c8146e1c5e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.3, 0.31, 0.12, 0.15, 0.09, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ee3e548d3dfd5b9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.54, 0.44, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d475269ac5c622b0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0faae41ca5484655_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_301a0fe012fb6eb7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_606b9a691f176b3e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.3, 0.54, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71355f60ae325e56_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.72, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddc9b4a37131356b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c895998a107e89fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57f306f170490d26_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.83, 0.14], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12ccbb3c262ed036_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_505ee55b0f639fe9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10774b0ce08b75d9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.76, 0.17, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_56e03c68e5049f08_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.13, 0.25, 0.37, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16ad96277f64d94d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.88, 0.03, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0594acf366b052a6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.79, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ad48aa9e97a60de_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfa3f860a62f30c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_182acd065d4c85b3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.29, 0.63, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50d53e48b846c998_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a3f2470ada1364e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_133632ac68e84e51_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.61, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea07bc4582ce1cd2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.05, 0.21, 0.52, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29fee1aceeff4036_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6fc1300457bd0dc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_08348ed32ffff9db_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.83, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9ef23194f00e379_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.9, 0.03, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76243abea267f735_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.49, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_032fa1fab9507513_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.36, 0.26, 0.19, 0.15, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2254ee00de8699a2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.1, 0.68, 0.19], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7267bce22f7fcad7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81312664a028af6b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84f9ae76d5ce1afd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.19, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ec483c31de14d74_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.11, 0.26, 0.45, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_102c92933ebb23f5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.59, 0.41, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_069a4c36fd6c02e4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25cfc5dc339fd927_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.98, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_591eaed9b4a8e248_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d0c5da8b552b699_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1e764f9a3f530dac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.13, 0.53, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26d9b614548b9019_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eda59c2337636439_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.71, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7427e22bba99f6e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.22, 0.44, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3bb7967c1b2b191b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.12, 0.37, 0.39, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a90fe9fbf9a8e584_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.71, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0aae7adc9d07432_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.11, 0.15, 0.3, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b55defcd9f49842_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.24, 0.18, 0.26, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_49274b93a729d0d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.46, 0.43, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fdbb6aa9307be74_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_990872f1b07b317a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58deb5b8abd49332_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.08, 0.11, 0.33, 0.35, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f6ef59afbdd8a2c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.07, 0.16, 0.53, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bcf276eeba6ae7ab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a444e3d8082f5e2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.07, 0.06, 0.46, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_757854245a6a2407_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.55, 0.39, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_49274b93a729d0d7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f889b429c3a9d24c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.98, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef23a1d4491e228b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.35, 0.52, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aded383de96d1795_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.3, 0.06, 0.36, 0.06, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22c877d8e2fb8c7a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fdb72eefcb1dddb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.97, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a80813929f199647_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.2, 0.24, 0.31, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cb5a47944f5fbad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0663beaeebec89a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0808, 0.1414, 0.2626, 0.3434, 0.1616, 0.0101], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78b777a9145ec999_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.21, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51e92ac653245ed0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.58, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3402279674add094_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.18, 0.43, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00f669450cdb73d2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.07, 0.17, 0.37, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_daa15178bcbea70c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.11, 0.43, 0.35, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05dc02a47ebd9866_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.06, 0.66, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_faf7409119af7b1b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.25, 0.28, 0.21, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e72e33858982076b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbbb59d5640bcbd6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.4, 0.14, 0.23, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4eb5a457177e790_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.97, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7df5f7fe204d945e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.31, 0.17, 0.25, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_520a9d0ae2fe46a3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.6, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_192ba6cd36ac90b7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.62, 0.31, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b66f8608349bd79_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.12, 0.17, 0.31, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8c4e3ff9d5c24c3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.51, 0.29, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d6ae3f234998b20_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.2, 0.22, 0.3, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99c263c3583cad23_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.42, 0.35, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e7ae770135b1a5d9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.09, 0.88, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_baa07f246f7db63e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.34, 0.23, 0.23, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e54f1a2beab4d9b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.49, 0.35, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43cd639dd36b84e2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.03, 0.04, 0.52, 0.33, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bec99b14ba88cbdf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.64, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_655f05254fcea291_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c18968d81f5e9c3b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_761c36609761e16b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.87, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6592eb1031e60ec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.55, 0.42, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8dcc252d59301230_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.59, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0ef54bae31cf35b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.37, 0.2, 0.2, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34450c5d1aa51530_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.16, 0.19, 0.25, 0.21, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_beebf83b4171be26_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66df5405ae90a3f1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.83, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dea6a1751da3e485_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.42, 0.46, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e15ed57b63133507_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4c8fbbda40ca67b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.24, 0.66, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6598c831abb9d16_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_016213027034a831_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.12, 0.17, 0.43, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f336b260e48b64b4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03a17af52e37011c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.79, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af62c122e13e5731_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.37, 0.32, 0.14, 0.13, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f55c829ccb90f9f0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d05b9875c2de6f7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ca3f07191591401_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.9, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dcffd95f3e2c493c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.3, 0.11, 0.29, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe3bb70c576958ef_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.29, 0.11, 0.24, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3f612a65b4b1df1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.14, 0.26, 0.37, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42687113c9714408_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.16, 0.73, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8359be577c136ad9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.24, 0.6, 0.02, 0.14], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59c340a77a18629f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5648ef750c059b5c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.14, 0.32, 0.34, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6fc1300457bd0dc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.96, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a92526f01af0e59b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.95, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6db8afd3187bdb0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef01a0bba123dd34_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.18, 0.14, 0.24, 0.23, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f48264b596457fa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.2, 0.33, 0.27, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_924e40e9bec049ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.35, 0.65], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_490700376b666127_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.12, 0.19, 0.38, 0.18, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_078c98b9af9f8b04_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.94, 0.03, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_55230b512fff71fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ce8fabb7a83db6e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5f3104fc5a329c1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48c1f27aa576c012_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d4aef3fd47063a84_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.23, 0.24, 0.35, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa3f82b542f589fe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.12, 0.38, 0.21, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8276655b5ada2250_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e40bbabf32dd0e9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.53, 0.45, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6be9cae69b2043e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.21, 0.32, 0.32, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7fe5d220025dc5c2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.03, 0.85, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fde93c6115a0e80_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.7, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1a8a18ffe08ccd0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.16, 0.4, 0.27, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_773208eccaa8fbfa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.16, 0.23, 0.36, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3799b1ed2bf34b57_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_325119182c46f76e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0e8c21aecec6468_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.3, 0.58, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9a83d267e9a0cda_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.7, 0.27], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2c9e29ff6af566e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5988c4ebee1c8f3e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.34, 0.2, 0.09, 0.22, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12056675f35933c9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.22, 0.26, 0.27, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a8b7c6bf6265d17_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_32385eb1c0432a93_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2636c7fd47d2fe5e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c39b3897a57b25f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d4707a779418a25_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.08, 0.37, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0fa646b90bd46d4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.83, 0.15, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_83d43129c0f30303_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_708ac42f7c493f5f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.42, 0.26, 0.14, 0.15, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bd7af1622d1cf02_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.45, 0.39, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b66f50ddb5a4e8cd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0606f145296ccbac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.09, 0.36, 0.36, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd6cbda923f1ec72_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_908cd7505bd147fa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0202, 0.0303, 0.202, 0.4545, 0.2828, 0.0101], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1fc54b19fa42fdd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.22, 0.48, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4ab42c7f2c8a066_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.21, 0.73, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_662585bd27b95916_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea07bc4582ce1cd2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.75, 0.22], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28bf51570b71a218_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.14, 0.32, 0.37, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2378b5e8dc98972a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.3, 0.56, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c39deb783493e7c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_035931080431b392_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.17, 0.68, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f232bbc81fd69089_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.64, 0.07, 0.01, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c2dd7ea35e7d320_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.56, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1801c25e22bb84c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b401deebf5f444eb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.44, 0.53, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01359542b9c74b2d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.08, 0.14, 0.43, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_56e03c68e5049f08_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b38b1be52944e2d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.23, 0.28, 0.31, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cde7f598e003338_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.6, 0.4, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_911f4898dee50517_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17ca8ad52877a316_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.36, 0.23, 0.12, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f22c2289566f1876_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.78, 0.19], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2b330ebd90f997c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_087bed6704d4237e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51f0b1011e4d27ab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.33, 0.48, 0.18], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bec99b14ba88cbdf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a88688789f0a5d8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.41, 0.5, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aeb364d3815cb53e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.96, 0.04, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d7f2c082e6b535e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.54, 0.01, 0.22], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f33ac4479fbf7c86_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.13, 0.3, 0.44, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ead4e334d514c361_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22293ff7730c3b77_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.94, 0.06, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c50eb88b381f05e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.39, 0.13, 0.19, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51955409a3157abd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.21, 0.42, 0.22, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f07f3013f02c83f4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.65, 0.25, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d34af0c05aeb9ad1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.35, 0.47, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_334d5b43492639a5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.25, 0.2, 0.33, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_209a9953e20a7ea8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a1577e2ca538cdc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.16, 0.05, 0.33, 0.23, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_138ab2ab53b62934_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.31, 0.31, 0.25, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54d981a44c9040a2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.47, 0.33, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d21fc20b0a8ab7b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.73, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0789cc2c61f25417_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.12, 0.09, 0.26, 0.31, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b4bca8f7ea703828_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.07, 0.55, 0.35, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ebad2734366645d0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.97, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0acb8cf92842714e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f8bc7737f415f21f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.07, 0.07, 0.42, 0.33, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_26d9b614548b9019_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.72, 0.2, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_12a2d24c88ddb22e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.16, 0.55, 0.25, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_950f0fd887a7c63d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.23, 0.76, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4c76f527c3eb2e7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.31, 0.14, 0.31, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73469fa09077ee1f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.2, 0.33, 0.24, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_066b37a6808537cb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_391de218a986c03e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.38, 0.21, 0.08, 0.23, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1acef87ed4e52a98_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.14, 0.13, 0.36, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98037b7867162646_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.33, 0.21, 0.23, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd12809924068cef_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.68, 0.31, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cd0a50f0fe6bfb3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.38, 0.58, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_010d3cdb6e33b340_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.22, 0.78, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36536696e2c3865d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.89, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_adbc5d978ea68951_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.49, 0.48, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d0c5da8b552b699_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.2, 0.04, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db4ddbd65b397ce4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.81, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4009dcd330ee1fa0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92075f536782660c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.9, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34c8f10c74909c69_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.32, 0.19, 0.19, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38263e4fa9962b04_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.08, 0.33, 0.26, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1b1a25711bcea68_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.23, 0.34, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33fe919b8dd847c4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa5b601e2ab2379b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_649dde989385441a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.87, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e44df57367945d5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1ac07559bf3d08a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b196f4907455911_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.79, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07ee756c4fba74b0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.1, 0.17, 0.37, 0.32, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a17d8748a0d193b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f7b67d720975e61_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.69, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_059a2fd32d0ae2c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d624f7b8c152001_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.14, 0.38, 0.46], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d2edc0a8c9bd23c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0beb12005b493ac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.28, 0.5, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb68605efc2c57e3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0c374b8ac32db8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ec271bc7d5ec161_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.08, 0.13, 0.46, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cda67e2772e9b5db_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c01340287574a80_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.26, 0.48, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e5bcdda532fd61a9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6f987b9c3a42a21a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.01, 0.53, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b28c124b850d1ce8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ca982933bdb380c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.88, 0.09, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a6ecc3d18090420_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1872e931846932fe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.09, 0.49, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a29002c3487238c2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.09, 0.37, 0.4, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa6ccd3eb93ab9e8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a7ed4755fa87d4b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_08060c4e518c28ec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.06, 0.88, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae0a1a946c2a1102_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.3, 0.18, 0.24, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef56a32a57df886e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.21, 0.25, 0.33, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b06ed2be4ef6b1c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.23, 0.64, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95b9dda94e5e588e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.28, 0.18, 0.17, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_deee06d7c17c020f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.85, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e742dbb8051d64ac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2ac4041b44d64d8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.08, 0.48, 0.39, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5fd62b80f6dee1e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.25, 0.26, 0.24, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef9b25fac0f87c89_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_138ab2ab53b62934_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.86, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77e0cd341809da8d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c012d5b21909814_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc9bfea33a1d1942_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.07, 0.28, 0.55, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a97dcdf69fa0364e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.15, 0.31, 0.31, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31481b7b9b951098_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa9d7bc2fbcdb912_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.26, 0.24, 0.3, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_089850a0b515c27e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.27, 0.38, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75eea3b3202654ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.2, 0.45, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_27f64c0fccd7ee19_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.52, 0.24, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8e7d7b9b5f0c194_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03a17af52e37011c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66094535c1e608f3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.64, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48211e86f6328f25_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.53, 0.34, 0.09, 0.04, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5576dafdf8aa9b54_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.8, 0.18, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff024245c934862d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.84, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4b470a2a01a52b27_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f71cca40428fff0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75c8ced6f2f31674_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.15, 0.4, 0.36, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9835804e3c17fec2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.36, 0.46, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a2a4435a53ef2418_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.41, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfc929ca357360d6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.26, 0.07, 0.33, 0.15, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e9f96655077878f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.28, 0.22, 0.24, 0.13, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_665dfbbd8eeae322_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.74, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_663d5b3292404609_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b45efe0458178b1b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f0de95ea7307cab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.21, 0.54, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfc1b7170ee214b1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.15, 0.42, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b5fe1c2c99295a6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.24, 0.3, 0.24, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1eb0ba31983a42c7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd09292dd6fe93a6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.98, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60c19fad633f2aaf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.24, 0.3, 0.28, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b052cd013384b08_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.03, 0.02, 0.2, 0.65, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f19ad8c28e11b9e6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b203234d2b9b8cc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.18, 0.47, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2b0e96ec824f2885_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.6869, 0.2727, 0.0202, 0.0202], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a9fdd19878799a83_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.09, 0.22, 0.4, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c78ce82d4984995e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85d0c8849a9197d4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3fd7bd996b281367_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42687113c9714408_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.16, 0.16, 0.27, 0.21, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68d87f91728ef63f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b041ef4de121779f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_01e14cdff0ea4d75_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.06, 0.93, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cb314b22fb6938e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89ff5ba8c5eb71d8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_473f5381cca31923_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.05, 0.12, 0.34, 0.37, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8ba75ea1a4c1af2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.78, 0.17, 0.01, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e10abef76b1c169_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bba759833d3803ef_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.43, 0.27, 0.16, 0.09, 0.03, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d33ee7c9a36ccf6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.08, 0.22, 0.48, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39dddf104abfd864_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.12, 0.67, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0b958a1ed820057_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.19, 0.45, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6d1fa3d61b49c60_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_765c5309e02233a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.32, 0.68], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b29c180fdc02ce4d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.07, 0.21, 0.51, 0.12], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34855173921f9e59_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98ac9171771b85c4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.83, 0.14], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86890f39cc660dc8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.56, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9434361071716633_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.12, 0.22, 0.42, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e17134288a50909_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.57, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ad10a394c20b6d0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13a5d6f472d8ab89_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.6, 0.32, 0.01, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_17146e5d750b84b7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.23, 0.23, 0.3, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d9bb7869ceb6071_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.84, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47f1acd41283641c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.36, 0.54, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_060093385dece2fa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.27, 0.63, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92075f536782660c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.04, 0.16, 0.55, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc3f0cbefb781e00_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.05, 0.08, 0.34, 0.41, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbeb5ac6cf6923e6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.41, 0.48, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96669081690244a6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.05, 0.06, 0.52, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_406562e1c47cb28d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cd8baa9010aa2f1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a28eeaa594f59e48_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bdef255133378695_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.96, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddf91359d686cc52_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.05, 0.93, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24aaf87ea09ec7fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.33, 0.01, 0.47], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9cbf6e7dea05a12_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.05, 0.0, 0.59], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_483d0562cb89005f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.27, 0.21, 0.19, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e8264c6f6125208_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.12, 0.21, 0.35, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48206536b070e71c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.31, 0.19, 0.22, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59a2f7dd75b66164_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3b5b8472a172147_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.05, 0.06, 0.55, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6dcf685dfdf25cf6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_955b12ed8656e805_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.15, 0.46, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ea028e2f5422b69_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.34, 0.6, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24177e50dd7cb056_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_141950134042a4b9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.25, 0.09, 0.32, 0.15, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f3c3c233971851de_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.17, 0.69, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97057f8bf7268362_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34663cedb5dddf4d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f9fc425524d2712_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.09, 0.38, 0.33, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0e6ca893a577e005_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.11, 0.2, 0.22, 0.28, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9472475add1efc7a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.81, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f90448befd5e2a57_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.1, 0.89, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a17d8748a0d193b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.13, 0.18, 0.37, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6be36f3656f9a7b6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbb290c3161df68d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40ae5b2b89014ec0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.07, 0.11, 0.49, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_950f0fd887a7c63d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.05, 0.07, 0.33, 0.46, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0f9c574da88ecf5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.29, 0.06, 0.3, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc885c63d8b6f995_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.14, 0.01, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b28c124b850d1ce8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.28, 0.64, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9baa01c777320194_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.28, 0.19, 0.19, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1181232e4f1311b4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77373f2432edd690_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.29, 0.22, 0.19, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d7f2c082e6b535e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_032fa1fab9507513_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_671810a3f325714b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.27, 0.65, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f601fb271f6f612b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7bb57a7fae2bcee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.27, 0.11, 0.34, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9fbf246bf10ecff_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd0e503be71913ce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.38, 0.24, 0.13, 0.22, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33bc98326a7ab0cf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_27f64c0fccd7ee19_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.33, 0.47, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_712e44acd5e64c57_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.33, 0.38, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e74b0ee18e627cf_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1af67086e6253cf5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1111, 0.5657, 0.3131, 0.0101], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81312664a028af6b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.17, 0.11, 0.29, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c394c055af579d6c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.14, 0.4, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fdf0fe065d26c25_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.42, 0.49, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7891524d332d13fa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1111, 0.1717, 0.2828, 0.3333, 0.0909, 0.0101], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aae343c99bea0534_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.11, 0.29, 0.45, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa692aafaeb314c2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.11, 0.03, 0.67], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36a6070c14bf9df7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.18, 0.17, 0.28, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_16261dbfca5e08b7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.48, 0.52, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1dc2fc50956dbcb0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d234084be15c3479_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.95, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae51e4312ef7e6b4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.06, 0.08, 0.54, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b100fb38dbf7e8fb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03e61afdc8e348b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_210623b187678795_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.15, 0.07, 0.47, 0.15, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_954e0a9858ef76eb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.93, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47c5259fddbb2592_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43b89ce30c56f811_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.11, 0.14, 0.32, 0.25, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d1e529e37bdf376_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.68, 0.29, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1cade7c53c7e4c32_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e703e3330339dbd8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.16, 0.14, 0.27, 0.24, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e16609b9dc59cc0b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ae04c8e66e5866e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.24, 0.24, 0.18, 0.05, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe04feb055951c97_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.24, 0.3, 0.3, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a8d40ab5653ddd0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.9, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d5ce8ae4befc497_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.44, 0.06, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92075f536782660c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_078c98b9af9f8b04_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ba8d3b9f327f18b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f0258a2ec84673d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b64a06c478e9c99d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.27, 0.63, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a59a0d0da3fa0f9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b719c3fb4253aa4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc885c63d8b6f995_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_118d5d401c6d973c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.11, 0.29, 0.4, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2bc58b5f0fad3c9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.28, 0.46, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57f306f170490d26_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.33, 0.26, 0.13, 0.18, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36ffdf052f8abc3f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.41, 0.0, 0.4], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dbc47c89d137c07_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.94, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b1a9035cd5e97bfb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.17, 0.78, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9d96439cb82ff87_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.16, 0.16, 0.36, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7707d7f93b6e4fee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.35, 0.27, 0.22, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb25d011b2b77583_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.91, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be3af8f2ac3a5251_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1439bd823b496215_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1973f1b948090ea3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.31, 0.25, 0.2, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d5dfe22fcda0045_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57072c742b1a7232_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.75, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b27b267ae4c103dc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74ce7bd023ef85d6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.08, 0.11, 0.47, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_554d0f1262bc23e3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.95, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee7eddd9fc79aa87_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03e61afdc8e348b9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.31, 0.69, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_643486906cf8d7ab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa2f790d56afebcc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_30f7f70f699d5041_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.21, 0.49, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fc2ecd7d5151e0b5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.12, 0.44, 0.38, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1ac07559bf3d08a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.89, 0.11, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cdf64b2ad9322e9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.42, 0.21, 0.35], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_70f137fea64fe0bd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_269d38797a385439_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc8f72930682b059_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a269d903a7488899_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.72, 0.25, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6fde93c6115a0e80_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.14, 0.21, 0.29, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_098dd74c92517ce7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.58, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c593a2324f163010_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.07, 0.27, 0.48, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de85922d1bcd7c97_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.43, 0.45, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b11859ee2c2d82f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.26, 0.21, 0.39, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e40bbabf32dd0e9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_825829be41736429_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.06, 0.34, 0.49, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_08060c4e518c28ec_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.04, 0.06, 0.29, 0.54, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6f987b9c3a42a21a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_920491625f6aa055_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.7, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d74fa7f46de4cce_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_330038ab18de3c19_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.47, 0.49, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_299b9fa1df851e6e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.56, 0.42, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca88c1e23cbba57c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.15, 0.84, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a713d0c2168b4ca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.58, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e28b22dfabbba4b8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.77, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34c6365e5611f430_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91ba8cf2066423b4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.68, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f9f7b19d07dee7b7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.68, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2f9851c871f2bfe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.92, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd09292dd6fe93a6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.13, 0.39, 0.3, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_672d34a30b3c6b20_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.13, 0.24, 0.42, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_efae3d840ef5c79b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.38, 0.49, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c74dfd598980efc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.75, 0.24, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0d90bce49de335c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.59, 0.32, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_118d5d401c6d973c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.56, 0.35, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a5cd2638f4f3746_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_765c5309e02233a1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.28, 0.22, 0.27, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_51e2ec5ccff24e51_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4df62ea41b124107_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.24, 0.72, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_451ee627e372d206_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8ef4c4099eb2dc8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_150781528438a35e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.7, 0.27, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b116b64c9b46d1f8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.2, 0.7, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77e26e2730065fe5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.92, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff3a91070fe362ac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.11, 0.13, 0.29, 0.34, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b63e18f55f7c7765_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.63, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4887e97e63ef1d6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.35, 0.45, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_945ff782847f78d4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5cf4c222025ac4b3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8054119f92305c5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.64, 0.24, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b38e8a10d91759e7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.38, 0.55, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ea38b1b7016a972_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87cb4bfbeb302234_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06dc600ccc591143_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.93, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29fc28bb27ec59dd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.37, 0.53, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74b2a6a0cc83633b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.6, 0.05, 0.01, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4d070d618fddbba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.12, 0.19, 0.39, 0.25, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d5dfc0e7dddb3e2b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dadf97ba304f4e1c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_209d0867cc371fd0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e73add9e4eb4e0a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.47, 0.53], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a8bebb96a8c3a439_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.04, 0.1, 0.47, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e961ad5dc528533d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.23, 0.17, 0.3, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c19b83cbccc5c388_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0404, 0.8182, 0.1414, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c971df91191c863_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1111, 0.101, 0.1414, 0.3232, 0.2828, 0.0404], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c62845d48644785c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.32, 0.2, 0.19, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1dbdee40d2d2108_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.77, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74677287ff2835c3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.9, 0.09, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0917fd1d6baf4d5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7710978c7136c206_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.18, 0.19, 0.23, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f48e7cd5e05b24a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1f858b27796f1ed_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2da1ba99a09efa2e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6d1fa3d61b49c60_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.7, 0.3, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab92da306223831c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.66, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62a7d8f5f9b69590_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.72, 0.25, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_613a0e91d2d0a839_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.3, 0.47, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f126c69cd18672d7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9105151aae33f4de_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.44, 0.55, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ede3c663774630ee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.15, 0.62, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4abcef60be92938f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.44, 0.52, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79dd719541484445_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.31, 0.69, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_672ce128d1f40ccf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.83, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f278627a39c6259f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.48, 0.48, 0.01, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_591eaed9b4a8e248_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.16, 0.53, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a6de3bc90f84b127_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b364bfdb91a79700_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.13, 0.35, 0.39, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9bb69cde1c1fbf03_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d6f3a4d354aa749_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.08, 0.49, 0.29, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fcf8d81b1eb94851_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.4, 0.3, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_83d2061130f79e1d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.82, 0.17, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d1e529e37bdf376_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.06, 0.09, 0.49, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f63539dff5526916_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.87, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b1deb56a8ef0cdce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.21, 0.1, 0.36, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cdefb510cfad6af_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2430cc20bd82e5ac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.92, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ae44a6b7e5913cb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.11, 0.15, 0.3, 0.27, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_be36407938251fb9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_83a33f33441c7282_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.85, 0.01, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa692aafaeb314c2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.23, 0.16, 0.28, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab4582ccc8e9cb1b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_649dde989385441a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b121d6915246ccce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.13, 0.24, 0.47, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91e81fe5d43da630_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50d5a926fd031c5a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.83, 0.13], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_761c36609761e16b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.12, 0.11, 0.28, 0.28, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b052cd013384b08_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.92, 0.07], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b41724b81590ccb3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.14, 0.59, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7de88f8412657666_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.74, 0.25, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c5be2593a9da4b2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e5e44806cffbc0b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10a038a287e81cbb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd75cbb4a3fbcd68_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.31, 0.69, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd614d02adb48171_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a149eb16a5011205_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.34, 0.23, 0.24, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_21571b7c9ee6cc05_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.19, 0.15, 0.08, 0.18, 0.33, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71d59ea2cfdf1703_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.03, 0.04, 0.26, 0.58, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5a2f976d93ad1a1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7448fb1e1dc8ef6a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.33, 0.58, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29bfb6a9eeb03b1e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.93, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_039cd8dafadfe5a2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.08, 0.41, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_954e0a9858ef76eb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a19159f43b5c64d3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.41, 0.52, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ffacbc5e3764ae8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.24, 0.53, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dec0ac19c13d5c27_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.17, 0.63, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1fae28fa0ee960b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.3, 0.41, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39d7c04320864fe7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.1, 0.11, 0.23, 0.37, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8348a42ecc9ba7ea_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c802f7798fd16378_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fd70e4f04fbedea_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_196110e0316c4708_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.53, 0.16, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9d4c0accadcbb25_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78b58eebb65885ca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.16, 0.22, 0.36, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce7a50f563b5f82a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddd831a893d2e23c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.12, 0.19, 0.3, 0.23, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86d184a6bb0b0218_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62393106e36f8320_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.19, 0.71, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_da428d9f6325f81b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ed4493131adb055_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.15, 0.08, 0.32, 0.3, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd2428f6f18e6fea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.21, 0.44, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb1c03b506d81aec_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.73, 0.18, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5cdeddf7daa3f53_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cc9127211ff472f8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.25, 0.08, 0.36, 0.13, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f83aca5dfddfe600_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.18, 0.24, 0.4, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86ef1c1f69c464b5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.37, 0.13, 0.14, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8be31727cab06835_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e23752d1928b278_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.1, 0.29, 0.38, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c112cdcd04f5d6d7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9eb83a5214e3896c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.58, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d17d92fb53d09bb4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.18, 0.52, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad6cdc1e864619ba_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.09, 0.08, 0.23, 0.33, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_483d0562cb89005f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.39, 0.53, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29fb750721510769_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.14, 0.4, 0.34, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e92c0c7209f93271_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.06, 0.89, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_56d8cda897102347_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5df5203d45caa3b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.96, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38842b17388a2725_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.24, 0.49, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_109622abd483491a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.43, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ce86aeb5ed42794_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.31, 0.13, 0.27, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c91e6f0458f05b0a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.84, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3c7a99311f322c89_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.18, 0.23, 0.32, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_229260b0581b67c4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24a759a3c29882ce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.11, 0.16, 0.32, 0.29, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1faabc82b847b7a0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.06, 0.1, 0.41, 0.34, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb05d092f288da91_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8341fdbab1805a1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.14, 0.24, 0.34, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9835804e3c17fec2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.43, 0.42, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f089e304cceb1316_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22d1642a0e5f53a0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.21, 0.4, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_584f56b861d7e612_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a94a755f90de6856_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.14, 0.29, 0.27, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6f8c588427ad8d9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6cd9cd2fdc374b58_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3d28a519d6bd873_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f04fd812e665570_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.12, 0.19, 0.4, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a50372a9c770e2b6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.31, 0.11, 0.25, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94a81f3e6e47c88a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.09, 0.59, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf3366b0a61b6da8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.22, 0.78], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07c338287080a96d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.1, 0.32, 0.46, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1826ae56c5bebff1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.8, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50165a3c0724445b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.13, 0.71, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f0458094bbfc243_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.18, 0.77, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d6bdc4dc8011b2a2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.08, 0.15, 0.56, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d46365d7c2289ab_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.14, 0.13, 0.36, 0.17, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_938edf9a8d4f5135_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.34, 0.17, 0.22, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b55defcd9f49842_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.68, 0.32, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_832746248178573b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.99, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b355c14ba7fedfc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.56, 0.08, 0.01, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6931beebad11369_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.92, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b55defcd9f49842_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ff58c7b7f8a90b9e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0bf8b6047c45465c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.19, 0.33, 0.34, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cc02c936694a0f7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.6, 0.38, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_577eb75e2c07918c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_039cd8dafadfe5a2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fd70e4f04fbedea_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.06, 0.13, 0.48, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1087462e712666c3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.8, 0.13, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c06d050d9cd1c6e9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.3, 0.13, 0.23, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_deee06d7c17c020f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.12, 0.2, 0.36, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bec4f01cda61ae44_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.12, 0.29, 0.45, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_139a3e406064c1ae_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.06, 0.38, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_920491625f6aa055_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.12, 0.17, 0.27, 0.29, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_75bb66e74294fd50_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.18, 0.24, 0.3, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_589c5a5475d688e1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.01, 0.87, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44c7d434cc7fb02a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.76, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_272e46c5ceb33bb9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.13, 0.23, 0.5, 0.14], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e46e7eebd4723044_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0505, 0.6869, 0.2626, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1c6a4edba35f683d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.53, 0.37, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95f0b2e6dd52f27e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.21, 0.64, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c0772cc6cf82fb59_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.72, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b795dd0c6834318_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7b38a1021ec57cc8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb953ab3ef091e05_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.38, 0.31, 0.01, 0.3], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a471b89d3838be2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.79, 0.01, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66d940237e05c815_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9cfd8e25a2a026d8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13903f14fc1bc700_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79d51f986929ad53_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2fb3898fa1925e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4c1dfc7c9457db2b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_009b022e08ab74b5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b78b562608d90abf_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.7, 0.26, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61a41c28e66fb91d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.05, 0.14, 0.36, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0510a9a1f3eb5954_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f469e638c8bf7660_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.23, 0.28, 0.2, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e6282ffba5c1854f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.33, 0.21, 0.21, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_955b12ed8656e805_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54e7b40e5a96ea07_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.18, 0.43, 0.27, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_963ff9e228928020_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.17, 0.27, 0.37, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3aaa489343e6dd82_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.75, 0.17, 0.0, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4362367219a2f885_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fef83bce0d5b0590_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_668b7d184cd0aad3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.68, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1db2d5b7fb25838_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.34, 0.17, 0.17, 0.04, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_649dde989385441a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.3, 0.17, 0.18, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9fffe1738b375f3c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.19, 0.22, 0.27, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a27257ddd6b6e235_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.08, 0.21, 0.47, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68ea0f3d1a52cf15_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.18, 0.3, 0.34, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_195b3b28bca3f6aa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.2, 0.4, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99c263c3583cad23_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.14, 0.2, 0.31, 0.26, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e25876c9cdbc676a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.12, 0.42, 0.35, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b94e0fa5ca38641c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.07, 0.21, 0.54, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4308b03e13be070e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_668b244710dd206f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.04, 0.22, 0.56, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d3a4cf55f942286_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bd86927cf093ea1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.78, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dd2029e05f62afa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.73, 0.22, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e14416acb6585ab6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.86, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38b3c8720e2f2624_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.12, 0.38, 0.43, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b0d89024ad447e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.09, 0.34, 0.39, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7513aa545ccc3c3f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.44, 0.51, 0.0, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0774ff6da0b8c75_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ab49e6369927eb6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.12, 0.26, 0.42, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62f2f9bbbc02c773_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f675ec93fd851856_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84f8051996bbe3aa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_abaf40ff178f487b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.19, 0.23, 0.28, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90dfa5f917e07e96_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cf805cc059881e1c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62876bf3314be7cd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cde01a545ea39abe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.09, 0.2, 0.4, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29820e5e24e1fbc7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0101, 0.8182, 0.1717, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f24c75d4e4bb2635_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6854ffbad0ae400b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.27, 0.73, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e524f32d0b2bd9f9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0101, 0.0202, 0.0404, 0.1313, 0.5657, 0.2323], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89970721cf9e0f50_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.4, 0.56, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fd90f85fd91c1fab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.96, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c90a5ec003396783_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.15, 0.58, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d958b5e3965864e1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_86dcffde18768f92_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.13, 0.25, 0.37, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d159ba4964323329_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.11, 0.14, 0.42, 0.22, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cfc929ca357360d6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1093c01951de545_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.13, 0.58, 0.29, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_551c8871fc94b48c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a15511488c5e906d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f0458094bbfc243_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.31, 0.25, 0.22, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_589c5a5475d688e1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36c91376814dd22d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.82, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7aded06df5290b8e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_475a3f7f8c5a0480_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.29, 0.3, 0.24, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_266a29d48bdfac69_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.14, 0.37, 0.19, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_578a61b8f18ca488_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c91e6f0458f05b0a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.17, 0.27, 0.27, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b64bafeedf0e88c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d76bad73f6f60aa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.28, 0.38, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_613a0e91d2d0a839_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.55, 0.39, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f2ac5e599f8a855_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.85, 0.08, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6e471102ff8ead2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67115654fa39b6ea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.7, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_98ac9171771b85c4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.02, 0.08, 0.49, 0.37, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3a59a6563c22fd75_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eb956f638039d6cd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ef6defc66de7aa3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.76, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6d705ff67005fa68_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.47, 0.27, 0.08, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8fa1aeccd3b3acfe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a8b7c6bf6265d17_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.18, 0.82, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42687113c9714408_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29c72b750643edf8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0e27dd5aff2f3d0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.09, 0.39, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0aec3770db077c4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_afbf025f3785dacb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.34, 0.65, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce0d0853119921d1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.1, 0.12, 0.36, 0.28, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c5bbc106a3a80b4e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e891c0870b7562a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.61, 0.38, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_716376af494ff6b9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.31, 0.67, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a94a755f90de6856_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.37, 0.55, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2bad6767be5c0f6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.44, 0.17, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8911f78489209c2a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b04127b132fd7660_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3ceaa9011c05854_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f26306b0972f3789_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.92, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67d866c99176356e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c85823ad593234f0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.79, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a15fb0c49a3ce293_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.04, 0.11, 0.34, 0.44, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_663d5b3292404609_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.11, 0.19, 0.34, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66d82516df1f215d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4850f842718d9937_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.28, 0.32, 0.22, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f44bf7278dce2b4d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.15, 0.2, 0.32, 0.22, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_479d261cc937d866_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ea2ba5752c9e250_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.27, 0.29, 0.21, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_72e953ebaf54b0a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_515660117aaec3a8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.02, 0.77, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8145f795e5a26a53_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.19, 0.29, 0.3, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96a4fffe9ef5a2aa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.46, 0.42, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d60bc9d71716899f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.88, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24aaf87ea09ec7fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ebefe032dc3af51_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.37, 0.62, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e9d46ff74cc8f472_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.47, 0.37, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f65cfb125610191d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.16, 0.08, 0.24, 0.25, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03133a3484c1356f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f63a6fa728ac806_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.15, 0.23, 0.4, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9030fd014f651fb2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.09, 0.18, 0.34, 0.31, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e47204a711628116_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.5, 0.38, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_999d550e4ea76be6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b45efe0458178b1b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.12, 0.21, 0.41, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06e1bfe45986c008_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_849b1cd0463556d3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.23, 0.18, 0.35, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b14291aef5a2dc9a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.29, 0.64, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_05c52de9ef4d1993_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.92, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_52c986c35b117aad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_450e54fc0290866c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2c73913d9a9c7eac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_07ee756c4fba74b0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.06, 0.94, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0e51e7bb3f330b6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.18, 0.8, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca7f377d5f54e0e4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.06, 0.33, 0.47, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8cdc2386a3a045e2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.44, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d4707a779418a25_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.35, 0.43, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d17fdfd07314272b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.17, 0.48, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_231214f9b52b90a1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.18, 0.2, 0.34, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1db12fa00db75fd7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96a4fffe9ef5a2aa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.07, 0.16, 0.55, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60cce234e6a0b11c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.05, 0.92, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d9ef47bb953c8dba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ef6defc66de7aa3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.14, 0.27, 0.42, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_65312a83e1f9b969_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.88, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8c73476e0422649_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.08, 0.92], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb40daae90024c24_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2aadb041b9e2c5aa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.41, 0.51, 0.08, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fccfaf8aafd73f0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.79, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_124e033a99c2fb04_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.31, 0.11, 0.23, 0.1, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93033e889d28509c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0909, 0.2323, 0.2828, 0.2828, 0.101, 0.0101], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7a87251d367dcf63_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ccae54e8439134ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.47, 0.3, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fc2a38b8ea4155d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.06, 0.1, 0.47, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8df45f14adb49414_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_015f125b4424cbf2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.72, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab0cddae26a4b435_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.13, 0.13, 0.4, 0.22, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_61cd2f454a5ef22c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.86, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2f48e7cd5e05b24a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.76, 0.15, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_185a91b9fd9829e5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.19, 0.41, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_450cdc860a6bffa2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.24, 0.4, 0.18, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c65bab6c9016d254_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.57, 0.43, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b155ea976944d75_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.4, 0.21, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f690a1b57257878f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.61, 0.28, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_630e3bf2d340f745_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.21, 0.17, 0.34, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3115f57746f35692_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d58f218228404af1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.1, 0.9], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_451c59a5714b7fe6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.8, 0.03, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce965c3d3d51bfc9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e3cccfe01bc81141_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_872b3c32fa497836_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.52, 0.47, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50d5a926fd031c5a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.13, 0.49, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_196d8913ba989710_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.91, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c74dfd598980efc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.24, 0.07, 0.41, 0.09, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_303f7c592728e764_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.2, 0.22, 0.48, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3b74c188a685c307_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.86, 0.02, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e2527fd52db216c1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.2, 0.39, 0.36], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_950f0fd887a7c63d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_caed6ed68efe910e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a4f57ea4c9e92b8d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.43, 0.45, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c006ce1ccddefa0a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.17, 0.45, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_84a42dbf81a7906a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_955b12ed8656e805_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.46, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_efb85c41732b6a2b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.38, 0.33, 0.12, 0.12, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1acdc18468365b74_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.44, 0.53, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1aefc29bf44fc10e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_22fab628b8bc2aca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.21, 0.22, 0.29, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6e471102ff8ead2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.55, 0.38, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0bb8a5ce1c080226_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fac9bd190b65a98d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c516da54818bbee2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0cad56ccd2fdc11_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34bc65b940f184ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.14, 0.5, 0.36, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4df62ea41b124107_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d616b216ddc40146_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.33, 0.67], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4c075f0e16564f54_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.53, 0.46, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbaef125891d95df_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.06, 0.42, 0.46, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de374701505a1d22_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.63, 0.37, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c39e6ff11162f62f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.18, 0.22, 0.32, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fa1644af299d1a71_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.43, 0.43, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7bf82621311ee8a1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.42, 0.44, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1a8a18ffe08ccd0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4abcd43c9a88fa91_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e4a4d6c1eac223d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29c72b750643edf8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.81, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29a37a92424e7424_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.55, 0.38, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96426e1ede0b1938_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.36, 0.59, 0.03, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e8d1d61d69ddc81_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.13, 0.18, 0.29, 0.24, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58b9d937652d8923_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.88, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0b3606435c55762_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.36, 0.17, 0.27, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66833285e552c844_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.35, 0.17, 0.21, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b776ffd28d74d24c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.27, 0.66, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_682cfe0c95ae2897_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a8c6af71b024a03_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.43, 0.5, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cf25cf58581a4da7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0da7ad42b232c868_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.02, 0.35, 0.6, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d237f578bcda0367_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74b2a6a0cc83633b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.21, 0.13, 0.42, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c99769ae8100a0e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.17, 0.55, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_71bbd91e370f9841_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.8, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ec1e8e4a0d61dadb_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.9, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b387e435a588e28_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.68, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_93f8391586255974_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.17, 0.55, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c8ebad6280793f9f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8be31727cab06835_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.98, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97562d96f489c102_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.13, 0.25, 0.36, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2707408f8ba506d4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b235aaaf6aaff49c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.17, 0.34, 0.28, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_306c5cc0ec1ec91a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.21, 0.56, 0.2], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ceabc4fc12044813_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.87, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0a7450f6188f386_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.19, 0.23, 0.33, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f76bea705f39865c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a6f6e4706955c4c7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.77, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa746dfcb581c340_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bb8b0ff9c4677590_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.19, 0.65, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f278627a39c6259f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.3, 0.2, 0.25, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e974031d3eff7532_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.76, 0.23, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ffb5172c7f3a142f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.17, 0.22, 0.37, 0.16, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_644d65a103cfbec0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.72, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd377d2159d15e60_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.72, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d92708b6dc39ba14_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.13, 0.17, 0.25, 0.25, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04643e971ae0fbf6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.07, 0.06, 0.31, 0.48, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77e0cd341809da8d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.14, 0.53, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2539342466cb8ab4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.18, 0.21, 0.36, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f568e820e44cd45_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b60c9e834f06281d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.05, 0.14, 0.39, 0.36, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0d63fa3ee5714ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a70c778dc21e2132_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.43, 0.33, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fc2a38b8ea4155d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d07efc090b7f04c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.43, 0.43, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24ba653f73385bf5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.25, 0.67, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34505f5883172d77_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67073d723b968bdb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a74c9d38af60996c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c62d3d2ecc2590fd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.15, 0.54, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f9fc425524d2712_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66f66fd19409e345_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.35, 0.24, 0.18, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0a7450f6188f386_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.22, 0.76, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a26723251c76b8bd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.03, 0.96, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b15382332aaf44b2_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76952880b0783330_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77a999c57ad4685e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9f9cb946ba8305d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.1, 0.08, 0.33, 0.33, 0.06], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e488b784faa79b9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.94, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_671810a3f325714b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.2, 0.23, 0.37, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d34af0c05aeb9ad1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97562d96f489c102_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.23, 0.66, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb399652de64f057_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb3e801e51772bf4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c246447b2e1a189e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.24, 0.56, 0.11], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_515e6d7494f5da24_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.82, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3927949ca4e9c71_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.53, 0.42, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47c323c3d2bb0bc8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.91, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5295cce379eefbce_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.24, 0.2, 0.3, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_83d43129c0f30303_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.06, 0.06, 0.42, 0.38, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7168aec5f1222e7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.74, 0.16, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5097b471cd65c307_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.11, 0.2, 0.37, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2356ccf13a41b67_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.48, 0.0, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6cd9cd2fdc374b58_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.14, 0.36, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10277fdcb4c9da10_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e329915b09739765_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ae9254d5c32ba37_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.68, 0.32, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cd0a50f0fe6bfb3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.27, 0.73], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5588c72dd2fd659a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.1, 0.32, 0.37, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_529d7c6cc3a8ef8b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.17, 0.26, 0.34, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acfa8a8d32865a21_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_57119c6a88e78377_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.4, 0.52, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d58f218228404af1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.64, 0.36, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_128128f05aac6f39_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.12, 0.21, 0.3, 0.26, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_348ec7f945569dfc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.14, 0.24, 0.29, 0.15, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fff312a964c17fb0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.1, 0.18, 0.42, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62d84dd3ce2fdfcd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.18, 0.38, 0.22, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f129805779ef6d21_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5579c4b5093ae7b9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.15, 0.41, 0.34, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_696433981ab5660d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b6d2dcc79179282_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.77, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94284c091bfbe5a8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.11, 0.14, 0.42, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e64172b8ec0cdb5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.26, 0.33, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c2bdab6c894b4ebd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.06, 0.3, 0.46, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c593a2324f163010_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_41233562842a8ee4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.03, 0.36, 0.6, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e10ac529349da849_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b7f2c3d8adb838a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.38, 0.51, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45cee347363e3533_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.13, 0.87], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b02544d83355d80_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.73, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00e829fda703cded_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_28bb90b182213669_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.51, 0.45, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8dcc252d59301230_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.26, 0.36, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81dbd7daed20a6e6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.87, 0.06, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b058cc284758116f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.12, 0.19, 0.45, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67be76803491cd5a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91015fd03ffa49c4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.15, 0.7, 0.14, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1db87b833fed14e8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_693fb533ddc942c5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.14, 0.51, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1141722b0c659d09_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.85, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8e74b0ee18e627cf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.21, 0.32, 0.29, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e7da013e1a0d629_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.49, 0.39, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fe934cb107fb962_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0d63fa3ee5714ad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.13, 0.16, 0.47, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc2e892acb163c5f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.88, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8f2b1cf7f32916e6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9ea2ba5752c9e250_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b719c3fb4253aa4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.15, 0.53, 0.19, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f2560ef2994428f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.29, 0.14, 0.23, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_77248188395dc186_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.8, 0.2], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03a58bf9e53fca6e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.77, 0.2, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b0bbdf522343417_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.78, 0.11, 0.01, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e974031d3eff7532_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.26, 0.2, 0.25, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d226c3ac889b105_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.32, 0.67, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1386fa7754a8cb74_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.01, 0.89, 0.09], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ce5be725bc01fb42_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e227406608488dc8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.29, 0.59, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97057f8bf7268362_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.09, 0.4, 0.31, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50d3def6d8cedde3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.1, 0.45, 0.34, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_21c9bc68f541796d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15994e88a4365bee_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.36, 0.28, 0.16, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1eb0ba31983a42c7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.05, 0.06, 0.4, 0.41, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ee61ad1929a25fc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1826ae56c5bebff1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.7, 0.3], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42ea6d09f218e1bc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.7, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba9fbe554b91f6da_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0101, 0.2323, 0.4646, 0.2727, 0.0202, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b1e44e8f372460c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3009bf8b3969803a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.34, 0.21, 0.2, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f2ac5e599f8a855_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.34, 0.23, 0.23, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_54535ed03d0465fb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_36a6070c14bf9df7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.8, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13a5d6f472d8ab89_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.37, 0.29, 0.13, 0.17, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_686ff6d4850a1dbf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.14, 0.49, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a15114e99c80978_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1b4814ba8898334_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.03, 0.18, 0.58, 0.19, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5745c1a9f37dcf0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f67b3b7d4dec1491_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.77, 0.22, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dfda0edc53942193_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.63, 0.35, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cac92197a93f0db0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bef27c87469f3e4f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ac3aadc60435612f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.23, 0.47, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ebfa84d46d283f8b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.11, 0.37, 0.45, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5de76799b5f1817d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.16, 0.27, 0.35, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_887cb52f678aab76_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.25, 0.75], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d4aef3fd47063a84_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_619bde0cc5d177f5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.21, 0.78, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0da9b4b81b5b270_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ab7dc0527eded64_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.61, 0.39], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00f47dac6d9b44d5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.2, 0.06, 0.01, 0.73], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3f162c74a0074ce1_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.12, 0.88], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7c3ef82d1dc36af_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.2, 0.12, 0.38, 0.18, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e67b55837a18283_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.4, 0.5, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_592b4f9fede4ce41_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.1, 0.01, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fffb1d9acc126e80_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.17, 0.13, 0.31, 0.2, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_601ca9f8784cb533_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc609347afba0490_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.25, 0.21, 0.34, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_afdd086ed73405e5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e71ec835c48a782a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.15, 0.24, 0.34, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c32cf08354ec825a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.18, 0.33, 0.29, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e9dc32ae2ac98f9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a6aa9908fc3e85c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.51, 0.41, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_14ed34739764d99a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.11, 0.68, 0.12], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1828839efcae0c15_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.3, 0.18, 0.26, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b196f4907455911_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a50eab695eecc98f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.3, 0.43, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d05b9875c2de6f7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.1, 0.34, 0.43, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8b5ab7d9f6de80a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.14, 0.29, 0.33, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_33bc98326a7ab0cf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.07, 0.1, 0.22, 0.42, 0.09], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd3718eaaa282606_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.08, 0.14, 0.53, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96426e1ede0b1938_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6629c45f9cfba802_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a20b1d6add59c9fe_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.09, 0.15, 0.35, 0.31, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d1f8d6e9dda3724_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.43, 0.01, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c851477f21ff720_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9307b4cb2ce1ddc5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.08, 0.53, 0.34, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0545a3d4089a23e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40e0aeba18c59f0b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.2, 0.57, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9959e48b23a85a6d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_13acc2820cc0b93d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.14, 0.29, 0.38, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fa5324ba75bd6c7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f49a2ca9e5bd88f8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca69647250e5348e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.2, 0.5, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fce6a105722fb328_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.08, 0.16, 0.45, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2258f19bf70d3668_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.1, 0.3, 0.4, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e44b0323b41beca9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.56, 0.42, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dcffd95f3e2c493c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c006ce1ccddefa0a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_31ef5ae385015b7c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.26, 0.69, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fb7506d54b39918_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_454af686cfb8bdaf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.15, 0.58, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96d2721da2c5b825_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.05, 0.61, 0.16], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aa9d7bc2fbcdb912_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ed858b4f6d351ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_773208eccaa8fbfa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.74, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad5bcc20a3e4ca04_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c64990bf807a638b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.92, 0.06], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_388faceb88fc122a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd808fa8de675355_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.19, 0.23, 0.26, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ea00da9e6dd0bc58_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4552c2084fff26c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.78, 0.22], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2697cdda73b4b409_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.73, 0.13, 0.01, 0.13], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d82020a00198adc4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4698d32127cdebc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.38, 0.53, 0.0, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c30fbd597a554368_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ae8b545774e2251_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.25, 0.66, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc2d36b41cb15b70_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0990702cf66f5de_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.12, 0.31, 0.51, 0.05, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c39217ba6084b3b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_20ce1d4e8cbad99a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.81, 0.17, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b355c14ba7fedfc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d518e3bf8f989a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a53a4ab1fc3944be_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.16, 0.16, 0.13, 0.37, 0.16, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cde01a545ea39abe_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.33, 0.49, 0.13], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c82cb96c076b836d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.13, 0.43, 0.36, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4887e97e63ef1d6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.16, 0.58, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddf91359d686cc52_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.12, 0.35, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ad10a394c20b6d0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.21, 0.79, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03ca3d8a3322d4ee_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ecdbbdba95c7c3a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.6, 0.4], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_938edf9a8d4f5135_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.74, 0.26], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d93f62b3566bb9d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.89, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d1a7a7754194033_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.22, 0.23, 0.3, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_319b32287dc43cb0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.26, 0.15, 0.34, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_47a829af0c36114c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.27, 0.65, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_301a0fe012fb6eb7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.18, 0.53, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c06e0e1c063d8f84_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_67162a234fdfe865_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.1, 0.47, 0.38, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6a8c6af71b024a03_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.39, 0.61], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d82877faebce2aff_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.0, 0.41, 0.59, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ef066fb334616d3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.52, 0.47, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_58b4def726749712_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.4, 0.59, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e7b8de1e33e7a9c9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.5, 0.47, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5fa0215202638ad6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.21, 0.16, 0.32, 0.15, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3a0f84d3a5775e2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0808, 0.2828, 0.2424, 0.2828, 0.101, 0.0101], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de87083d30d8771e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0353c95405800598_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.32, 0.28, 0.18, 0.17, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe4de4ce2dca0fbe_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2a6ecc3d18090420_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.3, 0.58, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_043d5cfa47e991ec_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8842684e253552a7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.84, 0.16], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a55aa854da3530d7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.25, 0.28, 0.22, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_38594950802a2aaa_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.16, 0.5, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0fdbb6aa9307be74_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.01, 0.63, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_96d620a7a05360d4_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.42, 0.58, 0.0, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d3909950c96eed8c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0d8ef93daf87163_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.31, 0.04, 0.4], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c20afb325785a4b7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.33, 0.12, 0.28, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29cf5b4200a5b029_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0774ff6da0b8c75_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.53, 0.45, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_332a226d26766c56_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.68, 0.3, 0.01, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8da2f62b03096f20_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.86, 0.07], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_135814e0613f8404_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.14, 0.45, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_186728026fde4888_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.32, 0.47, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c42840970c79940f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.75, 0.22, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4e341e07e49ba864_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.54, 0.46], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a70c778dc21e2132_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_583e34b06b333196_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1132d19d14eb74d3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_64cd688a6485e45f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4bac033b82dfa12a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2374e6331c4c61c6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.11, 0.29, 0.42, 0.13, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25f656c68847c5f6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.61, 0.06, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d768543415e796f2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.25, 0.17, 0.55, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ffef3cdaa55c663_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1fae28fa0ee960b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.31, 0.16, 0.19, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b70d7431116a96e7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.02, 0.06, 0.33, 0.52, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_330038ab18de3c19_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.1, 0.3, 0.36, 0.1], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_192ba6cd36ac90b7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.29, 0.18, 0.2, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5097b471cd65c307_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6e1cd55748bb693_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.97, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbafe9cee4b97883_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.14, 0.18, 0.33, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fef83bce0d5b0590_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.02, 0.29, 0.59, 0.1, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_135814e0613f8404_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.33, 0.64, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ee8aa095c97bcaf0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_672ce128d1f40ccf_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.09, 0.35, 0.36, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a0ecfe60df0a8a93_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9aea6dc6227d252a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.05, 0.07, 0.22, 0.52, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d5dfc0e7dddb3e2b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.55, 0.01, 0.18], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9307b4cb2ce1ddc5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d0a059d90bf5300_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.19, 0.41, 0.01, 0.39], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_af662594cec46263_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_83d2061130f79e1d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0cc2432992123bff_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.23, 0.68, 0.01, 0.08], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f9796147ed4297a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_592975c0a52405ad_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7ab836d0dcd84ee0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cdb962a669cfd95b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.3, 0.46, 0.18, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f089311be06ddef3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca1ad1799ae0331c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.11, 0.16, 0.35, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_060093385dece2fa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.19, 0.81], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef01a0bba123dd34_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_206a681a98c3d7b3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7cd11f99999e0f6d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.3, 0.18, 0.23, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1a8a18ffe08ccd0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.9, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f19ad8c28e11b9e6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.25, 0.47, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2c97687a4d59a83_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.14, 0.29, 0.35, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_856e542f0cb77b14_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85f930bea5f49d44_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.34, 0.26, 0.37, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_40ae5b2b89014ec0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.28, 0.12, 0.54, 0.06], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d14c910ce46c5f5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.12, 0.22, 0.34, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8edc63854afcb4d4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.29, 0.71], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0aec4d77d858e5c3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.06, 0.25, 0.54, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_073ad41d4edd5aa9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0b37063d5f197ef0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.88, 0.12], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dcd07e0be7b830fa_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.37, 0.56, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_50d3def6d8cedde3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.55, 0.28, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15e676a1899a10da_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.17, 0.33, 0.31, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48b8be86a3d382fc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.87, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24232c89272d219c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.22, 0.15, 0.29, 0.09, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fdbbf88896e04789_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_04d91636c4de2278_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.6, 0.31, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b121d6915246ccce_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.5, 0.3, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_24232c89272d219c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae0a1a946c2a1102_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.7, 0.14, 0.01, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dbbb59d5640bcbd6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.23, 0.61, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6639475a2edef782_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.9, 0.07], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd69484dd4d07a25_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.2, 0.39, 0.27, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_253b1fdc7a241e9a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.26, 0.19, 0.26, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e0990702cf66f5de_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.82, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3493dca982786adb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.23, 0.35, 0.3, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d546e99b21a977dc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.18, 0.82], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b0b4a66859092dd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.31, 0.18, 0.27, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a51c5e2bfba0dca_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.06, 0.88, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c55b4a1f2e7e8cac_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a6b105984c92e5d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1462e584cdf6616a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_11ad00bd642f10ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0f62d8ea69ac5e9a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.08, 0.24, 0.35, 0.16], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb8168c36183ff1c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95b9dda94e5e588e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.32, 0.44, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_856b77cc1bc36ef8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8873489ae41b5f26_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.24, 0.21, 0.32, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d82020a00198adc4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.17, 0.31, 0.17, 0.25, 0.08, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0594acf366b052a6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.08, 0.28, 0.53, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_044833e1ab47e0bc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.14, 0.58, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62f2f9bbbc02c773_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.47, 0.42, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a715abde6c7f0c89_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.65, 0.27, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4c76f527c3eb2e7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62393106e36f8320_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8cd171a51c908ae_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.66, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddc9b4a37131356b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.61, 0.36, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a707c3e30b147f71_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.79, 0.18, 0.0, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_089850a0b515c27e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e72e33858982076b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.41, 0.53, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dba0e0a3458fa87_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.21, 0.79], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_59746fcf4b0221f5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.21, 0.25, 0.28, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dfbbfda8498092a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a5e6f8a10e8d75a5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25f656c68847c5f6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.13, 0.15, 0.46, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9566a1ccfb4ccf2b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.06, 0.22, 0.47, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad11e3f0601a1264_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.79, 0.21], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5fffc439470ea70_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.16, 0.24, 0.31, 0.15, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95aadbb3a443cea9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0202, 0.0303, 0.202, 0.5556, 0.1919, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_270f14184630ffe3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25302b8e514c8129_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.31, 0.0, 0.58], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f4996fa51ceb0b63_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.09, 0.19, 0.43, 0.24, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1643e6305ec20b99_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.9, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_993b9f22d533b2e1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.24, 0.75, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d6f3a4d354aa749_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_969a5353653d8d45_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.23, 0.11, 0.4, 0.06, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94fc41072152c596_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_25812ef76d2e90db_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.2, 0.76, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39b88d4d5b309639_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.44, 0.22, 0.11, 0.19, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_081f72f3e515a197_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.12, 0.79, 0.07], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1ecfcd9dc58e6c82_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.49, 0.49, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db84b49a8a2b69d2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.46, 0.42, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3a19e6edf329478_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.16, 0.54, 0.25, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8b78ea3ed947dbc4_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.43, 0.4, 0.11, 0.05, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e8cd171a51c908ae_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.46, 0.54], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5f6ef59afbdd8a2c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.34, 0.66], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23ce4baf3279eb9a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.2, 0.13, 0.59, 0.08], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a1e2077f11b2e870_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.6667, 0.2828, 0.0404, 0.0101], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1d98f91130f15fb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.21, 0.37, 0.27, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7f9baf87b4e27a85_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.29, 0.16, 0.22, 0.11, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4ba78764bb199e77_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.81, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0b3606435c55762_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.36, 0.64], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe3198f901a8ea97_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.15, 0.79, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_359db6e590faabb3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.74, 0.23, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8d6ca68508098c0f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3b6baede3a776de_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.08, 0.25, 0.48, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4eaa1b829ce4a6df_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.5, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_19bbc121163af6c5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_34e25626bc0e6dab_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_345dc0d676c661a3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.19, 0.43, 0.18, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_39b16ed27c99318d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.92, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1589eb1edb963933_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.18, 0.3, 0.4, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4f8d38763ce01b38_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.12, 0.7, 0.17, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_43a888ec41447ae5_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.2, 0.3, 0.18, 0.23, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_90b982d080481a5e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.29, 0.3, 0.16, 0.2, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35923327e32c9527_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.66, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba9fbe554b91f6da_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.37, 0.63], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e72a9f110cb9344_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29725a4f7edb45e0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.24, 0.76], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_acba33ccf6514d92_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.96, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ff1364fdc767c7c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.51, 0.31, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6c809855125cc15a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dfd2ccdeafd37ff9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.56, 0.43, 0.01, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_070549e1d29d7ac7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_876faba4f88569d9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.37, 0.62, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_952f20835d73db22_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c16dea76af200f7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.58, 0.08, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0d911b8368205401_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bf2259322e435e3f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.17, 0.09, 0.28, 0.29, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3ea802234ba5c2e8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.37, 0.53, 0.04], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ddd831a893d2e23c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c7718fcfb8399967_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.41, 0.59], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3bed143f4a43483_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.17, 0.17, 0.29, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ffd6927b13576819_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.35, 0.29, 0.11, 0.16, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_237da6cb2d572d95_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.16, 0.55, 0.23, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1fcdc4b14eaa0e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.24, 0.28, 0.25, 0.18, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dc2e892acb163c5f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.09, 0.26, 0.46, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7fa254c60179fe3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.12, 0.59, 0.26, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f1e23f8bcfd8bcf6_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.78, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ceb1a229e44e121c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.13, 0.01, 0.61], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ab03b28159be92b3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.98, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8df45f14adb49414_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.48, 0.33, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82daaf4668005293_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.16, 0.31, 0.4, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e23ce61b57a9bd8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.12, 0.43, 0.41, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5a6aa9908fc3e85c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4d3d05628c9f54b9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.44, 0.51, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c3b107d6505c81ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.7, 0.23, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d37ca725064a2084_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.11, 0.2, 0.39, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_48235130d3bb76c6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b5e6246ce1a00636_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.38, 0.62], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42875d8ab1659d83_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95a3474d2cb7cc3a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.11, 0.21, 0.35, 0.24, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7347d29c16aaf2cd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9330c4008d45e89f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9c3a25895f2913ba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00534ee46533ac59_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.87, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_91d402bfd8551f05_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.28, 0.16, 0.09, 0.12, 0.24, 0.11], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_64cd688a6485e45f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.23, 0.13, 0.33, 0.14, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae963af43bd02225_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ebfa84d46d283f8b_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.32, 0.65, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d97096968be652e7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.22, 0.23, 0.35, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_827db81b24f00934_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.3, 0.7], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b6931beebad11369_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.52, 0.48], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d0e1d17a845b445f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.0101, 0.0101, 0.0303, 0.3737, 0.5657, 0.0101], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7fe201076c90ded9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.48, 0.5, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_462f3b660bc68450_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.21, 0.24, 0.1, 0.3, 0.12, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d80c97929ee9f3bb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b79603b438f1cde7_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.13, 0.15, 0.45, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_814b5c4b8b2669cd_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.48, 0.52], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4abcef60be92938f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.26, 0.28, 0.15, 0.22, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_79b07270c09f2521_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.84, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0da7ad42b232c868_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.09, 0.19, 0.72, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_74fe79fddd098d84_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.24, 0.64, 0.11], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_06cabf300fbd6c03_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cb246a0957e28a7_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.56, 0.44], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a6de2a92b7228ae0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.18, 0.25, 0.26, 0.17, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f675ec93fd851856_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.39, 0.14, 0.26, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b01cbc52f1df7daa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_29c9870ff069ed49_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b363d4c9e3811766_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c50eb88b381f05e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.93, 0.0, 0.05], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_710222e0cee323b0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.44, 0.36, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6f2e41bbd90b76ea_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.44, 0.54, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cd1938168df5cf36_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b2acecb96b39f7f5_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.26, 0.74], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5d62960fa8e49c09_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.01, 0.97, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5ee3e548d3dfd5b9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.08, 0.16, 0.51, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_368fb3d4c3539a17_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.11, 0.12, 0.29, 0.31, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fadce75370c27224_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5988c4ebee1c8f3e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.82, 0.15, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f48d3b754167c08b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.18, 0.25, 0.11, 0.34, 0.1, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e376897559684ad_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.04, 0.33, 0.53, 0.1], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73469fa09077ee1f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_342ee7da22a6cd54_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ef56a32a57df886e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.43, 0.57], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c01340287574a80_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7245f9cd31a3686c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.19, 0.29, 0.29, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3021df90a1060015_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_010ef6aa9d8967dc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.02, 0.05, 0.32, 0.52, 0.09, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f0a1669a13720b51_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.09, 0.22, 0.34, 0.26, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_757854245a6a2407_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.28, 0.72], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_988343fdaa2db10b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.12, 0.18, 0.32, 0.21, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_35719f9cb9689a76_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca68e3cfc071c95c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.1, 0.71, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dad748ce9155182_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.72, 0.28], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f70524738c34e6cb_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.29, 0.17, 0.31, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cdba4d0f48d44e3_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.19, 0.5, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1fd14c1f872e8de8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.54, 0.42, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c6b7e1bc0cd8afdd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.12, 0.14, 0.15, 0.37, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7bb57a7fae2bcee_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.46, 0.48, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b8d15d021b83f77e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.15, 0.52, 0.2, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c42840970c79940f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.08, 0.42, 0.45, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_beebf83b4171be26_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.19, 0.21, 0.38, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d26a129709561014_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.27, 0.73, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_881f9687dad6959c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.92, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f44f1e793ae539c6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7426dd5c6d42ae06_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.16, 0.79, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dec0ac19c13d5c27_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.14, 0.8, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_66f66fd19409e345_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.96, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60028da33842baf9_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.86, 0.14], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5dcde1ceb257eea0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.08, 0.11, 0.49, 0.22, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9a0c1ec32c3bc774_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.3, 0.59, 0.1, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_183523c966791840_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.29, 0.21, 0.28, 0.06, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, under reduced staffing. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_53ba4720d9461da9_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.67, 0.31, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_969a5353653d8d45_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_87d1d7be4cd4063c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.53, 0.47], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_237da6cb2d572d95_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.48, 0.43, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_97e1419b394b1860_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.03, 0.03, 0.27, 0.58, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_622476f10045f8df_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.17, 0.25, 0.34, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a910b764d3444cba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6091a53f7b082b9c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.56, 0.37, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1079703b20997be_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.11, 0.48, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd9cdb632f2e0bad_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.03, 0.19, 0.61, 0.16, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1a25ee6c93548556_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.08, 0.52, 0.24, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_420ef7a7edb99760_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A proposed mechanism postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_23ee54014177899f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.68, 0.32, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_68f41527f85dead3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.93, 0.0, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c85823ad593234f0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.13, 0.13, 0.24, 0.29, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_783e6f300dd07d8f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.22, 0.71, 0.04, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1065aae764ec8126_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.65, 0.35], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b3b6baede3a776de_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.32, 0.46, 0.21], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ba5f1be369874261_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.72, 0.21, 0.07, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_73c696492e263188_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.07, 0.8, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2bad6767be5c0f6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ad6cdc1e864619ba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.41, 0.02, 0.31], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_18535c3ce887857a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.9, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2820c8d0fb92d299_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.09, 0.69, 0.19, 0.03], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_dd6f1df632da044e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.26, 0.23, 0.18, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6bea87b4cda8d218_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.02, 0.94, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ed7caff225e44c76_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.25, 0.24, 0.32, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_45ecca747d7e0ab2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.57, 0.39, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_492e3a6070a1619d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.68, 0.32], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_016213027034a831_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_db33b67c181ec3f8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.58, 0.42], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_933547979d8c63d7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.07, 0.29, 0.6, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f09e73b41e872877_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3e8ad2004f0fdb58_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.39, 0.21, 0.23, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_141f8b3e078161cc_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.11, 0.89], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd285af91b79c603_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.79, 0.18, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_42d28d8f36309d35_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.85, 0.1], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_60fcfd5e79ef8bc3_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.75, 0.25], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0acb8cf92842714e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.72, 0.09, 0.0, 0.19], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d2546820f83ce5c0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_087bed6704d4237e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.28, 0.15, 0.26, 0.12, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, immediately after go-live. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8ed02725611d1159_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.93, 0.04], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2be341237fd07f11_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.1, 0.39, 0.44, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bd86927cf093ea1_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.07, 0.07, 0.3, 0.42, 0.04], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, following a recent audit. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de87083d30d8771e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.06, 0.45, 0.46, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e0113d8b3b01131_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.13, 0.12, 0.18, 0.45, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_585d1d60667f78ab_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.28, 0.45, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during normal operations. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_94fc41072152c596_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.05, 0.76, 0.18, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9b6d2dcc79179282_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.89, 0.11], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a36f21f4c8b7d276_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_27f9e92b3495ac11_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_85f930bea5f49d44_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.64, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_99dda34017b96321_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a7c7a247b903e451_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.19, 0.2, 0.38, 0.12, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bc321cb407314bac_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.25, 0.29, 0.21, 0.16, 0.07, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_81dbd7daed20a6e6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.32, 0.25, 0.16, 0.16, 0.08, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, immediately after go-live. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_081e9317a677e2e0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.08, 0.11, 0.43, 0.32, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7cfcc58fba8ac3d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.02, 0.78, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b9505807fc9a3167_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.04, 0.04, 0.29, 0.53, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d1e463e6c545c90c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.78, 0.19, 0.0], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e828223d7408022f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.06, 0.17, 0.38, 0.3, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bef27c87469f3e4f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.22, 0.75, 0.03, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: in the journal club, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_563b209603516b98_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.17, 0.59, 0.24, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2cd98984134f1fe0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.93, 0.04, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b28c124b850d1ce8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.08, 0.1, 0.33, 0.36, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_210623b187678795_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.2, 0.8], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b25ca7192758167e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.74, 0.14, 0.12, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c802f7798fd16378_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.06, 0.2, 0.51, 0.21, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10489f20265c8779_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.09, 0.91], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2d0a059d90bf5300_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.31, 0.33, 0.15, 0.17, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a53a4ab1fc3944be_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.14, 0.86], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0ee3b14fa3f5244f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.77, 0.23], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, under an active deadline. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_df5bd6909b54ff5d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.71, 0.27, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b0e27dd5aff2f3d0_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.16, 0.82, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8911f78489209c2a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.19, 0.43, 0.36, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_592b4f9fede4ce41_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.18, 0.07, 0.38, 0.21, 0.05], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_655f05254fcea291_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.15, 0.79, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_3d21fc20b0a8ab7b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.07, 0.07, 0.11, 0.44, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4308b03e13be070e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.87, 0.1, 0.02, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_82b5499df41904c4_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.73, 0.27], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during normal operations. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a16e1c79252e754_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.31, 0.69], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c9018651ba7c2bdc_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.18, 0.51, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a6de2a92b7228ae0_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.66, 0.34], "state": "A hypothesis explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1bf00e3ab45393d8_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.22, 0.33, 0.13, 0.19, 0.09, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, shortly after a software update. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7bcacccd9793f5a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.24, 0.32, 0.21, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7dc39df6d92361a5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.92, 0.03, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c331713541c7ceb_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for a grant review, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4e21bd1ee0c6300_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.21, 0.25, 0.27, 0.16, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ae38229b29a077d_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_967eba7051edcbe8_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.26, 0.32, 0.06, 0.36], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0a47f72d54db749f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.06, 0.94], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4a713d0c2168b4ca_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.15, 0.21, 0.46, 0.07, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, shortly after a software update. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a18b7a9be96fdfdc_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.09, 0.18, 0.33, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_89c065dc9eac2d92_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.34, 0.21, 0.13, 0.26, 0.05, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_779ac60699d0048c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.57, 0.43], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4b80f98a6378624_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.12, 0.85, 0.03], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: at the thesis defense, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_95ebf11983333d6a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.11, 0.39, 0.0, 0.5], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5debf4498610dd5a_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.12, 0.29, 0.48, 0.09, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9baa01c777320194_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.17, 0.83], "state": "A predictive model requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_aff7b8f494383220_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.09, 0.19, 0.16, 0.4, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9e64172b8ec0cdb5_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.05, 0.45, 0.41, 0.09], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f2f97506162162c0_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.15, 0.14, 0.18, 0.37, 0.14, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_20efb5cacfafb13e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.11, 0.88, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_10277fdcb4c9da10_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.52, 0.46, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_92788b4efcfcc4ba_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for a grant review, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a910b764d3444cba_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.04, 0.8, 0.15, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d219a1989507e102_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.59, 0.41], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2ae38229b29a077d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.17, 0.77, 0.06, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2aadb041b9e2c5aa_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.69, 0.31], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, following a recent audit. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_4998dce24f528325_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.82, 0.18], "state": "An observed correlation explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for a grant review, during the quarterly review. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca1ad1799ae0331c_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.97, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, during peak load. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ae141c6f91ec3292_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.07, 0.1, 0.46, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c84603f35d717897_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.23, 0.2, 0.34, 0.13, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_76bfb0915524254b_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_7e8d1d61d69ddc81_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.03, 0.82, 0.15, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for the press release, during peak load. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b70dfd18560e0b06_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.55, 0.45], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fb399652de64f057_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.23, 0.33, 0.23, 0.16, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0c40d5c0cab4e786_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.08, 0.9, 0.02, 0.0], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b09c34b598f44aa2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.37, 0.61, 0.0, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during an external partner integration. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_126d42f402cc2bc1_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.75, 0.06, 0.0, 0.19], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c108aec8f7fcb48f_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.42, 0.58], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, while legacy systems are still active. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e1079703b20997be_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: at the thesis defense, under reduced staffing. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9266ff2d935c5d88_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1f21bd542a7bb111_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.51, 0.49], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5bbef50580f26289_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.67, 0.33], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: at the thesis defense, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a738ef895e496a1c_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.1, 0.31, 0.4, 0.14, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: for a grant review, during peak load. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b22570a7bd10d3d6_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.07, 0.14, 0.45, 0.3, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: for the press release, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8c2fc7fe6f328017_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.08, 0.1, 0.2, 0.31, 0.28, 0.03], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c011ca72960c698d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.1, 0.29, 0.48, 0.11, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2fd3983dda979497_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.06, 0.22, 0.54, 0.08], "state": "An observed correlation requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for the press release, under an active deadline. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eef83e366ac69e51_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.62, 0.38], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_109622abd483491a_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.85, 0.15], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: in the journal club, under reduced staffing. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_039cd8dafadfe5a2_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.0, 0.0, 0.99, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during an external partner integration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_de85922d1bcd7c97_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.63, 0.37], "state": "A proposed mechanism explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for a grant review, mid-incident. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_ca68e3cfc071c95c_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.71, 0.29], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, during normal operations. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f5ffeab894967f69_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.15, 0.85], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, during the system migration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_e703e3330339dbd8_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.49, 0.51], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: a confound explains the result?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44e93877a30cdb6d_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.24, 0.2, 0.25, 0.15, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5e54f1a2beab4d9b_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.25, 0.12, 0.31, 0.21, 0.05], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_cb59ccda17a518ac_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.5, 0.29, 0.21, 0.0], "state": "An observed correlation relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the system migration. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_b7c3ef82d1dc36af_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.74, 0.25, 0.0, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c1b4814ba8898334_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.45, 0.55], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_62352236253150e2_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.11, 0.11, 0.45, 0.21, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_00359e2a7bdf68e6_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.23, 0.77], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: at the thesis defense, during the quarterly review. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9989ee2c64a78c93_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.16, 0.84], "state": "A predictive model is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9d27546d829934c7_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.02, 0.45, 0.51, 0.02], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, during the morning shift. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5b0b510700ccfa95_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.11, 0.32, 0.13, 0.3, 0.11, 0.03], "state": "A predictive model reduces to the known theory in the limit; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: for the press release, during an external partner integration. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_8a3f2470ada1364e_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.25, 0.62, 0.13, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis requires a new particle with no decay signature; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, during an external partner integration. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1d7557db951ceddd_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.03, 0.06, 0.12, 0.43, 0.34, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_fe3bb70c576958ef_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.5, 0.29, 0.19, 0.02], "state": "An observed correlation is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally reduces to the known theory in the limit. Context: at the thesis defense, during a scheduled maintenance window. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_2e488b784faa79b9_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.07, 0.08, 0.33, 0.45, 0.02], "state": "A hypothesis postulates an undetectable medium; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_9dba0e0a3458fa87_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.27, 0.17, 0.19, 0.28, 0.08, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_6501a694665dcf6f_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.05, 0.05, 0.09, 0.54, 0.26, 0.01], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, while on-call rotation changed. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_d82877faebce2aff_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.83, 0.17], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally postulates an undetectable medium. Context: in the journal club, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5c2bd99b29f5812f_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.03, 0.65, 0.26, 0.06], "state": "A hypothesis survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: for the press release, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_1b73612ffdeadc11_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.76, 0.24], "state": "A proposed mechanism has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: for the press release, shortly after a software update. Reported by the on-call engineer.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_78abb1234a535529_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.14, 0.25, 0.23, 0.33, 0.04, 0.01], "state": "A predictive model predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: at the thesis defense, with staffing at reduced levels. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_44e93877a30cdb6d_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.25, 0.2, 0.37, 0.18], "state": "A predictive model explains all observations but forbids no outcome; additionally makes a novel falsifiable prediction. Context: in the journal club, mid-incident. Reported by the automated check.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_5576dafdf8aa9b54_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.04, 0.12, 0.14, 0.39, 0.26, 0.05], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: at the thesis defense, immediately after go-live. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_167c97e9a96e102a_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.68, 0.21, 0.1], "state": "A proposed mechanism is supported by 4 independent replications; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: for the press release, under reduced staffing. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_bd52058f17240b50_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.1, 0.16, 0.2, 0.31, 0.19, 0.04], "state": "A predictive model survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally explains all observations but forbids no outcome. Context: for a grant review, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Rate novelty for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_c4c2b7fb748e5a5e_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.4, 0.6], "state": "A predictive model postulates an undetectable medium; additionally is supported by 4 independent replications. Context: in the journal club, during the morning shift. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the evidence supports the claim?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_f05d90f5f9c6b5a3_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.02, 0.85, 0.12], "state": "An observed correlation has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor. Context: for the press release, during the holiday freeze. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_0752cb9ec510bb36_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["strongly_supported", "tentatively_supported", "unsupported", "contradicted"], "target": [0.01, 0.86, 0.12, 0.01], "state": "A proposed mechanism survived a preregistered adversarial test; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: in the journal club, as part of a compliance sweep. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Verdict for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_03a58bf9e53fca6e_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.01, 0.04, 0.17, 0.58, 0.2, 0.0], "state": "A hypothesis predicts a 15% effect with a 3% measured noise floor; additionally relies on a single unblinded observation. Context: for a grant review, with a new vendor onboarded. Reported by the review queue.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_106fa3d31e9090fd_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.01, 0.7, 0.28, 0.01], "state": "A hypothesis makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally has a circular dependency in its assumptions. Context: at the thesis defense, under an active deadline. Reported by the monitoring system.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_a3a19e6edf329478_n", "kind": "noul", "options": ["false", "true"], "target": [0.44, 0.56], "state": "A predictive model has a circular dependency in its assumptions; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: for a grant review, during the system migration. Reported by the operator.", "question": "Is this scenario one where: the hypothesis is falsifiable?", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_15013f8c4711e849_c", "kind": "choice", "options": ["replicate", "design_falsification_test", "abandon", "fund_fully"], "target": [0.68, 0.09, 0.0, 0.23], "state": "A predictive model makes a novel falsifiable prediction; additionally survived a preregistered adversarial test. Context: in the journal club, at the end of the fiscal period. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Next step for this scenario.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"} {"id": "v3_eef83e366ac69e51_s", "kind": "score", "options": ["0", "1", "2", "3", "4", "5"], "target": [0.06, 0.1, 0.14, 0.39, 0.29, 0.02], "state": "A proposed mechanism relies on a single unblinded observation; additionally requires a new particle with no decay signature. Context: in the journal club, during normal operations. Reported by the supervisor.", "question": "Rate evidence strength for this scenario on a 0-5 scale.", "domain": "hypothesis_eval", "family": "science", "source": "yuri_v3"}