--- license: cc-by-4.0 pretty_name: GoldiBench task_categories: - image-to-image tags: - agents - gui-agents - image-editing - benchmark size_categories: - n<1K --- # GoldiBench: Right Tools, Wrong Amount 500 editing tasks in five professional applications (darktable, RawTherapee, GIMP, Inkscape, Blender). Each task pairs a START image with a TARGET rendered from a hidden program, so the amount of every tool has an exact answer. Tasks are posed at three levels: L1 tools and values, L2 tools only, L3 goal only; solvable by writing a program or through the GUI. - Code, installers and the evaluation harness: https://github.com/uservan/GoldiBench - Project page: https://uservan.github.io/GoldiBench - Every run of the paper (model outputs, screenshots, scores, costs): https://huggingface.co/datasets/VanWang/GoldiBench-logs **Pass rule:** closeness = 1 - dE(result, TARGET) / dE(START, TARGET) (mean CIEDE2000, renders <= 1024 px); pass when closeness >= 0.75 and dE <= 4. **Use:** `hf download VanWang/GoldiBench --repo-type dataset --local-dir data` then `export GOLDIBENCH_DATA=$PWD/data` (see the code repository). Paths inside the files are relative to the dataset root. **Integrity:** `bench_b1_/FROZEN` holds the sha256 of every released `program.json`; the harness refuses changed tasks. `FROZEN.original` is the file frozen during the study; the released programs differ from those only by the removed machine-specific prefix of file paths (verified for all 500 tasks). ## Files Same layout as the code expects under `GOLDIBENCH_DATA`: ``` bench_b1_/ program channel, app in darktable rawtherapee gimp inkscape blender tasks.jsonl one task per line (100): task_id, app, kind (single / multi / long), program (the hidden answer {tool: {field: value}}), modules (the task's tools), order, intervals (accepted value ranges), intent (the look in words), l1_instruction (L1 text), source / source_path (input image or scene), start_target_de00, checks (verification results), generator, reasons, manual_pages, attempts, revisions FROZEN sha256 of every task program; runs refuse changed or unlisted tasks tasks//start.png START render (the input as the agent sees it) tasks//target.png TARGET render of the hidden program tasks//program.json the hidden program tasks//_val_*.png validation renders: oracle replay, x0.5 (half), x0.9, x1.1, over-strength verify.json per-task verification (oracle, strength scaling, single-tool removal) magnitude_curve.json closeness vs. strength scaling of every task (Fig. strength) v3_more.json, search.json extra checks / numeric-search reference (darktable) knowledge/ pre-rendered effect sheets and difference images of the L2 interventions bench_b1__gui/ GUI channel tasks.jsonl one GUI task per line and level (id = _): instruction, config (file to open), allowed_modules, program / gui_program, target, evaluator, kind, level tasks// start.png / target.png used by the GUI evaluator replay_validation*.json the hidden program replayed through the GUI (task kept only if replay reproduces TARGET) rejected.json, unreachable.json tasks dropped from the GUI channel and why sources/ input photos (PSBench) referenced by source_path assets/ Blender scenes (Poly Haven) and SVGs (Openclipart) referenced by source_path manuals/ application manuals (the --manual intervention); minimanual/: mini manuals and the task subsets of the Sec. 5 interventions (minimanual/subsets/.txt) ``` ## License and sources CC-BY-4.0 for the tasks, programs, renders and annotations. Input images keep their own licenses: PSBench photos (`sources/PSBench-data`, see the PSBench license), Poly Haven scenes and HDRIs (CC0, `assets/polyhaven`), Openclipart drawings (public domain, `assets/openclipart`). Application manuals (`manuals/`) belong to their projects (darktable, RawTherapee/RawPedia, GIMP, Inkscape, Blender documentation; see each manual's license). ## Citation ```bibtex @misc{yang2026goldibench, title = {GoldiBench: Right Tools, Wrong Amount -- Benchmarking Agents on Effect Judgement in Professional Editing}, author = {Yang, Wang and Li, Xinpeng and Zhang, Yanyan and Song, Chaoda and Wang, Shouren and Ganguly, Debargha and Singh, Vikash and Ma, Chuang and Cai, Xiaoran and Ye, Kai and Han, Xiaotian and Chaudhary, Vipin}, year = {2026} } ```