{ "task_id": "b034", "app": "darktable", "kind": "long", "steps": 5, "generator": "qwen35", "source": "PSBench:458", "source_path": "sources/PSBench-data/458/458_start.jpg", "intent": "Create a rich, dramatic autumn still-life with intense warm tones, a darkened frame for atmosphere, and significantly sharpened textures while boosting overall color vibrancy.", "intent_draft": "Create a rich, dramatic autumn still-life with enhanced warm tones, deeper atmosphere, and pronounced textures while preserving detail throughout.", "program": { "exposure": { "exposure": -0.471 }, "shadhi": { "shadows": 43.756, "highlights": -24.777 }, "colorbalancergb": { "highlights_H": 54.899, "highlights_C": 0.234, "vibrance": 0.259, "saturation_global": 0.253 }, "bilat": { "detail": 2.087 }, "vignette": { "brightness": -0.341, "scale": 57.833 } }, "order": [ "exposure", "shadhi", "colorbalancergb", "bilat", "vignette" ], "intervals": { "exposure": { "exposure": [ -0.5, -0.2 ] }, "shadhi": { "shadows": [ 25.0, 45.0 ], "highlights": [ -30.0, -10.0 ] }, "colorbalancergb": { "highlights_H": [ 35.0, 55.0 ], "highlights_C": [ 0.15, 0.25 ], "vibrance": [ 0.25, 0.5 ], "saturation_global": [ 0.1, 0.3 ] }, "bilat": { "detail": [ 1.5, 3.0 ] }, "vignette": { "brightness": [ -0.5, -0.25 ], "scale": [ 45.0, 65.0 ] } }, "interval_clipped": [], "reasons": { "exposure": "Darkens the entire image significantly, reducing overall contrast and saturation while shifting colors slightly cooler.", "shadhi": "Brightens the image globally to recover the initial exposure loss, lifting shadows and adding warmth and saturation.", "colorbalancergb": "Strongly increases color saturation and shifts the overall tone significantly warmer and more yellow, particularly in the highlights.", "bilat": "Enhances local contrast and texture significantly, making fine details much crisper and increasing tonal contrast throughout.", "vignette": "Darkens the borders of the image to create a dramatic frame, slightly cooling and desaturating the edges." }, "reasons_draft": { "exposure": "Darken the overall image to create a moodier, more dramatic atmosphere typical of classical still-life paintings.", "shadhi": "Lift shadows significantly to recover detail in dark areas while compressing highlights to prevent blowout on white pumpkins and flowers.", "colorbalancergb": "Apply strong warm color grading to highlights for golden autumn light and boost vibrance to make fruits and flowers richly saturated.", "bilat": "Significantly enhance local contrast to bring out textures in corn husks, pumpkin skins, woven baskets, and flower petals.", "vignette": "Apply a pronounced vignette to draw focus to the central arrangement and enhance the classical painting aesthetic." }, "violations": [], "manual_pages": [ "darktable/docs.darktable.org/usermanual/5.6/en/overview/workflow/process/index.html", "darktable-5.6-text/exposure.txt", "darktable-5.6-text/contrast-brightness-saturation.txt", "darktable-5.6-text/levels.txt", "darktable-5.6-text/shadows-and-highlights.txt", "darktable-5.6-text/color-balance-rgb.txt", "darktable-5.6-text/local-contrast.txt", "darktable-5.6-text/sharpen.txt", "darktable-5.6-text/vignetting.txt", "darktable-5.6-text/haze-removal.txt" ], "start_target_de00": 6.484, "modules": [ "bilat", "colorbalancergb", "exposure", "shadhi", "vignette" ], "l1_instruction": "In darktable, apply these modules with exactly these settings: exposure (exposure): exposure = -0.471; shadows and highlights (shadhi): shadows = 43.756, highlights = -24.777; color balance rgb (colorbalancergb): highlights_H = 54.899, highlights_C = 0.234, saturation_global = 0.253, vibrance = 0.259; local contrast (bilat): detail = 2.087; vignetting (vignette): brightness = -0.341, scale = 57.833.", "checks": { "C3_total": { "de": 6.484, "range": [ 6.0, 45.0 ], "ok": true }, "CLIP": { "blown": [ 0.0007, 0.0 ], "crushed": [ 0.2275, 0.3251 ], "max_growth": 0.1, "gated": true, "ok": true }, "C2_repeat": { "de": 0.0, "max_px": 0, "max": 0.05, "ok": true }, "C7_identity": { "de": 6.484, "ok": true }, "V3": { "mean_shift": { "de": 6.76, "closeness": -0.043, "pass": false }, "reinhard": { "de": 5.708, "closeness": 0.12, "pass": false }, "ok": true }, "C4_necessary": { "exposure": { "de": 2.917, "closeness": 0.55, "ok": true }, "shadhi": { "de": 3.134, "closeness": 0.517, "ok": true }, "colorbalancergb": { "de": 4.169, "closeness": 0.357, "ok": true }, "bilat": { "de": 4.801, "closeness": 0.26, "ok": true }, "vignette": { "de": 1.676, "closeness": 0.742, "ok": true } }, "V2": { "0.9": { "de": 0.869, "clipped": false, "should_pass": true, "ok": true }, "1.1": { "clipped": true, "ok": true }, "0.5": { "de": 3.401, "clipped": false, "should_pass": false, "ok": true }, "1.5": { "de": 4.97, "clipped": true, "should_pass": false, "ok": true } }, "ssim_start_target": 0.7583, "plausible": { "judgments": [ { "acceptable": true, "defects": [], "reason": "The edit delivers the requested warm, vibrant autumn tones with a darkened vignette frame and crisper textures, without any colour cast, crushed blacks, banding, or halos.", "judge": "glm53" }, { "acceptable": true, "defects": [], "reason": "The image successfully delivers the requested intense warm tones, darkened atmospheric frame, and boosted vibrancy without introducing unacceptable artifacts like crushing blacks or unnatural color casts that ruin the subject.", "judge": "qwen35" } ], "status": "ok", "ok": true } }, "attempts": 5, "revisions": [ { "revision": 0, "status": "CLIP blown 0->0% crushed 23->39%", "program": { "levels": { "levels": [ 0.104, 0.475, 0.942 ] }, "colorbalancergb": { "highlights_H": 47.105, "highlights_C": 0.116, "vibrance": 0.303 }, "bilat": { "detail": 2.772 }, "sharpen": { "amount": 1.26, "radius": 1.103 }, "vignette": { "brightness": -0.303, "scale": 47.062 } }, "intervals": { "levels": { "levels": [ [ 0.05, 0.45, 0.85 ], [ 0.15, 0.55, 0.95 ] ] }, "colorbalancergb": { "highlights_H": [ 40.0, 60.0 ], "highlights_C": [ 0.1, 0.25 ], "vibrance": [ 0.2, 0.5 ] }, "bilat": { "detail": [ 1.5, 3.0 ] }, "sharpen": { "amount": [ 0.8, 1.5 ], "radius": [ 0.8, 1.2 ] }, "vignette": { "brightness": [ -0.6, -0.3 ], "scale": [ 40.0, 60.0 ] } } }, { "revision": 1, "status": "C3 total dE 3.31", "program": { "exposure": { "exposure": -0.282 }, "shadhi": { "shadows": 21.105, "highlights": -17.432 }, "colorbalancergb": { "highlights_H": 50.088, "highlights_C": 0.084, "vibrance": 0.166 }, "bilat": { "detail": 1.149 }, "vignette": { "brightness": -0.227, "scale": 62.034 } }, "intervals": { "exposure": { "exposure": [ -0.3, 0.2 ] }, "shadhi": { "shadows": [ 15.0, 35.0 ], "highlights": [ -20.0, -5.0 ] }, "colorbalancergb": { "highlights_H": [ 40.0, 60.0 ], "highlights_C": [ 0.08, 0.2 ], "vibrance": [ 0.15, 0.4 ] }, "bilat": { "detail": [ 1.0, 2.5 ] }, "vignette": { "brightness": [ -0.4, -0.2 ], "scale": [ 50.0, 70.0 ] } } }, { "revision": 2, "status": "ok", "program": { "exposure": { "exposure": -0.471 }, "shadhi": { "shadows": 43.756, "highlights": -24.777 }, "colorbalancergb": { "highlights_H": 54.899, "highlights_C": 0.234, "vibrance": 0.259, "saturation_global": 0.253 }, "bilat": { "detail": 2.087 }, "vignette": { "brightness": -0.341, "scale": 57.833 } }, "intervals": { "exposure": { "exposure": [ -0.5, -0.2 ] }, "shadhi": { "shadows": [ 25.0, 45.0 ], "highlights": [ -30.0, -10.0 ] }, "colorbalancergb": { "highlights_H": [ 35.0, 55.0 ], "highlights_C": [ 0.15, 0.25 ], "vibrance": [ 0.25, 0.5 ], "saturation_global": [ 0.1, 0.3 ] }, "bilat": { "detail": [ 1.5, 3.0 ] }, "vignette": { "brightness": [ -0.5, -0.25 ], "scale": [ 45.0, 65.0 ] } } } ], "final_feedback_rounds": 2 }