{"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"coding-context","scenario":"Coding assistance with realistic context","expected_result":"Use the current task and preserve its constraints when multiple windows or stale context are present.","observed_result":"One same-bug run missed the one-line fix; another similar multi-window run found it.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#proof-coding-bug","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#proof-current-task-control","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Two documented runs showed inconsistent behavior; they were similar but not a statistically controlled sample."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"coding-context","scenario":"Coding assistance with realistic context","expected_result":"Use the current task and preserve its constraints when multiple windows or stale context are present.","observed_result":"A clean Two Sum screen produced a relevant but truncated hash-map answer snippet; the cluttered-screen run selected stale context.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#proof-cluttered-coding","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#proof-clean-coding","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The clean and cluttered runs used different context conditions, and the clean answer was not executed."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"coding-context","scenario":"Coding assistance with realistic context","expected_result":"Use the current task and preserve its constraints when multiple windows or stale context are present.","observed_result":"The published review did not include a comparable coding test with clean and realistic multi-window context.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"An uploaded employment-history context run is not equivalent to this coding criterion."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"coding-context","scenario":"Coding assistance with realistic context","expected_result":"Use the current task and preserve its constraints when multiple windows or stale context are present.","observed_result":"A clean Two Sum screen produced a relevant brute-force answer; a separate cluttered-screen run selected stale context.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-cluttered-context","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-clean-coding","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The published tests cover a small set of coding scenarios, not every supported platform or language."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"coding-context","scenario":"Coding assistance with realistic context","expected_result":"Use the current task and preserve its constraints when multiple windows or stale context are present.","observed_result":"A tightly constrained clean prompt produced a relevant short answer; on a cluttered screen Parakeet AI guessed which visible task mattered and answered the wrong one, and a spoken follow-up triggered another answer to the previous task.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-cluttered-context","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-clean-prompt","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The published runs cover a small set of coding and follow-up scenarios in the tested desktop flow."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"coding-context","scenario":"Coding assistance with realistic context","expected_result":"Use the current task and preserve its constraints when multiple windows or stale context are present.","observed_result":"After Scan Code was triggered with unrelated JavaScript visible in VS Code, Final Round AI continued the previous URL-shortener system-design answer.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/final-round-ai#proof-stale-scan-code","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The result documents one clear current-context failure in Final Round AI 2.5.0; it is not a broad sample of every coding platform or language."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"precise-context-capture","scenario":"Precise context capture","expected_result":"Let the user target the relevant screen area or otherwise control which visible context reaches the AI.","observed_result":"Area screenshot or selected-text targeting was not found in the tested free-tier desktop flow.","coverage":"feature_sought","outcome_code":"not_found","outcome":"Not found","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#comparison","repeat_count":null,"limitations":"A later release or another plan may expose a feature that was not present in this test."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"precise-context-capture","scenario":"Precise context capture","expected_result":"Let the user target the relevant screen area or otherwise control which visible context reaches the AI.","observed_result":"The tested workflow used whole-screen screenshots; no precise area-targeting step was found.","coverage":"feature_sought","outcome_code":"not_found","outcome":"Not found","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#proof-cluttered-coding","repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Finding is limited to the tested macOS desktop flow."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"precise-context-capture","scenario":"Precise context capture","expected_result":"Let the user target the relevant screen area or otherwise control which visible context reaches the AI.","observed_result":"The review records Smart Area as present but clunky, but it does not publish enough direct evidence for a normalized result.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"A comparison-table assertion is not treated as direct behavioral evidence."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"precise-context-capture","scenario":"Precise context capture","expected_result":"Let the user target the relevant screen area or otherwise control which visible context reaches the AI.","observed_result":"No area capture or visible multi-screenshot context buffer was found in the tested flow.","coverage":"feature_sought","outcome_code":"not_found","outcome":"Not found","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-context-targeting","repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Finding is limited to the tested desktop build and configuration."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"precise-context-capture","scenario":"Precise context capture","expected_result":"Let the user target the relevant screen area or otherwise control which visible context reaches the AI.","observed_result":"No area screenshot or selected-text targeting step was found in the tested flow; the app selected context from the full visible screen.","coverage":"feature_sought","outcome_code":"not_found","outcome":"Not found","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-cluttered-context","repeat_count":null,"limitations":"A later version or different plan may expose a targeting feature that was not present in this test."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"precise-context-capture","scenario":"Precise context capture","expected_result":"Let the user target the relevant screen area or otherwise control which visible context reaches the AI.","observed_result":"No area screenshot or selected-text targeting step was found in the tested Scan Code flow.","coverage":"feature_sought","outcome_code":"not_found","outcome":"Not found","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/final-round-ai#proof-context-targeting","repeat_count":null,"limitations":"A later version or different plan may expose a targeting feature that was not present in this test."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"spoken-question-audio","scenario":"Spoken-question audio capture","expected_result":"Capture a spoken interview or coding question accurately enough to generate a relevant answer.","observed_result":"Cluely captured a spoken YouTube interview question and generated a relevant behavioral answer.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"pass","outcome":"Passed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/images/reviews/cluely/cluely-transcript-followup-noise.webp","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#proof-answer-shape","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"One published YouTube run is not a broad test of every audio route; the transcript also contained filler and noise."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"spoken-question-audio","scenario":"Spoken-question audio capture","expected_result":"Capture a spoken interview or coding question accurately enough to generate a relevant answer.","observed_result":"Across the published spoken-prompt runs, transcripts stalled, captured fragments, or produced a no-current-prompt answer.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#proof-audio","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The published review does not record the audio route precisely; paid tiers and later versions may differ."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"spoken-question-audio","scenario":"Spoken-question audio capture","expected_result":"Capture a spoken interview or coding question accurately enough to generate a relevant answer.","observed_result":"No transcription or answer appeared during the recorded Google Translate playback run.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/lockedin-ai#proof-system-audio","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The published video has no audio track, so it documents the visible app outcome rather than the audible prompt itself."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"Windows (Oracle VirtualBox)","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06-17","criterion_id":"spoken-question-audio","scenario":"Spoken-question audio capture","expected_result":"Capture a spoken interview or coding question accurately enough to generate a relevant answer.","observed_result":"Windows desktop-audio capture transcribed the supplied sorted-array constraints and produced a relevant two-pointer answer, but the answer missed the requested one-indexed output.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/images/reviews/ultracode/ultracode-system-audio-transcription.webp","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/images/reviews/ultracode/ultracode-system-audio-answer.webp","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"One Windows v8.10.0 sequence; it does not establish behavior for later builds or every audio route."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"spoken-question-audio","scenario":"Spoken-question audio capture","expected_result":"Capture a spoken interview or coding question accurately enough to generate a relevant answer.","observed_result":"Audio transcription captured some interview speech, but a spoken unit-test follow-up did not become the current task and transcript runs included filler-like or malformed context.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-spoken-follow-up","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-transcript-noise","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The review covers repeat runs in the tested macOS setup, not every microphone or system-audio route."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"spoken-question-audio","scenario":"Spoken-question audio capture","expected_result":"Capture a spoken interview or coding question accurately enough to generate a relevant answer.","observed_result":"The Copilot generated a substantive résumé-aware answer, but it also suggested replies to ordinary setup and acknowledgement remarks before the substantive response.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/final-round-ai#proof-setup-conversation","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/final-round-ai#proof-overlapping-answers","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The recording does not establish which automatic question-handling mode was active, so no Smart Mode-specific claim is made."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"focus-behavior","scenario":"Focus behavior","expected_result":"Using the assistant should not cause the interview or assessment window to lose focus.","observed_result":"Cluely became the active app and the test page lost focus with undetectable mode active.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#stealth-control","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested macOS free-tier flow."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"focus-behavior","scenario":"Focus behavior","expected_result":"Using the assistant should not cause the interview or assessment window to lose focus.","observed_result":"Using Interview Coder changed the active window in the focus-logger test.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#proof-focus-lost","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested macOS desktop flow."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"focus-behavior","scenario":"Focus behavior","expected_result":"Using the assistant should not cause the interview or assessment window to lose focus.","observed_result":"Using LockedIn changed the active window in the focus-logger test.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/lockedin-ai#proof-focus-lost","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested macOS desktop setup."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"focus-behavior","scenario":"Focus behavior","expected_result":"Using the assistant should not cause the interview or assessment window to lose focus.","observed_result":"Mouse interaction with ULTRACODE triggered a blur event on the active page.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-focus-lost","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested interactive-overlay mode."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"focus-behavior","scenario":"Focus behavior","expected_result":"Using the assistant should not cause the interview or assessment window to lose focus.","observed_result":"Moving and interacting with Parakeet AI repeatedly caused the active interview page to record blur events.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-focus-lost","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-focus-lost-repeat","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested desktop flow."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"focus-behavior","scenario":"Focus behavior","expected_result":"Using the assistant should not cause the interview or assessment window to lose focus.","observed_result":"The browser focus logger recorded BLUR and FOCUS events while the Final Round AI launch and configuration window was used.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/final-round-ai#proof-focus-lost","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The recording proves focus changes during setup-window interaction, not during every Final Round AI control."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"cursor-behavior","scenario":"Observable cursor behavior over assistant UI","expected_result":"The cursor should not visibly change or disappear when it crosses or interacts with assistant controls.","observed_result":"The pointer changed shape over Cluely controls while undetectable mode was active.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#stealth-control","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This is a local cursor observation, not a controlled receiver-side cursor test."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"cursor-behavior","scenario":"Observable cursor behavior over assistant UI","expected_result":"The cursor should not visibly change or disappear when it crosses or interacts with assistant controls.","observed_result":"The local pointer changed shape over Interview Coder controls.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#proof-cursor-unsafe","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This is a local cursor observation, not a controlled receiver-side cursor test."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"cursor-behavior","scenario":"Observable cursor behavior over assistant UI","expected_result":"The cursor should not visibly change or disappear when it crosses or interacts with assistant controls.","observed_result":"The local pointer changed over LockedIn controls while stealth mode was shown as active.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/lockedin-ai#proof-cursor-unsafe","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This is a local cursor observation, not a controlled receiver-side cursor test."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"cursor-behavior","scenario":"Observable cursor behavior over assistant UI","expected_result":"The cursor should not visibly change or disappear when it crosses or interacts with assistant controls.","observed_result":"The cursor changed over controls, and a separate local recording showed it disappear while typing into assistant UI.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-cursor-unsafe","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-cursor-disappearing","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Both are local cursor observations; the disappearance clip is not receiver-side screen-share evidence."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"cursor-behavior","scenario":"Observable cursor behavior over assistant UI","expected_result":"The cursor should not visibly change or disappear when it crosses or interacts with assistant controls.","observed_result":"The pointer changed over Parakeet AI resize surfaces, and the receiver-side share exposed a native validation tooltip from the hidden assistant UI.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-cursor-unsafe","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The receiver-side proof covers the tooltip; the resize-pointer observation is local."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"cursor-behavior","scenario":"Observable cursor behavior over assistant UI","expected_result":"The cursor should not visibly change or disappear when it crosses or interacts with assistant controls.","observed_result":"The pointer changed over Final Round AI surfaces, making interaction with the assistant observable through normal cursor behavior.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/final-round-ai#desktop-control","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This result concerns observable cursor behavior over the tested assistant UI."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"shortcut-isolation","scenario":"Shortcut isolation","expected_result":"Assistant shortcut events should not reach the active interview page or a relevant system-level monitor.","observed_result":"Modifier and shortcut key events still reached the active assessment page.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#stealth-control","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested Cluely shortcut configuration."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"shortcut-isolation","scenario":"Shortcut isolation","expected_result":"Assistant shortcut events should not reach the active interview page or a relevant system-level monitor.","observed_result":"The active browser page registered the Cmd/MetaLeft event during the Interview Coder shortcut interaction.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#proof-shortcut-leakage","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The event logger represents one observable layer, not every monitoring product."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"shortcut-isolation","scenario":"Shortcut isolation","expected_result":"Assistant shortcut events should not reach the active interview page or a relevant system-level monitor.","observed_result":"The active browser page registered the LockedIn shortcut combination.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/lockedin-ai#proof-hotkeys","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The event logger represents one observable layer, not every monitoring product."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"shortcut-isolation","scenario":"Shortcut isolation","expected_result":"Assistant shortcut events should not reach the active interview page or a relevant system-level monitor.","observed_result":"On macOS, a privileged session-level monitor detected the physical keys before ULTRACODE blocked them.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-shortcuts","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This privileged macOS observable layer does not represent every proctoring product or establish the Windows result."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"shortcut-isolation","scenario":"Shortcut isolation","expected_result":"Assistant shortcut events should not reach the active interview page or a relevant system-level monitor.","observed_result":"The active browser page registered Parakeet AI shortcut events during the tested assistant interaction.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-shortcut-leakage","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The browser event logger represents one observable layer, not every monitoring product."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"shortcut-isolation","scenario":"Shortcut isolation","expected_result":"Assistant shortcut events should not reach the active interview page or a relevant system-level monitor.","observed_result":"The published review does not include a shortcut event-logger result.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"No shortcut pass or failure is inferred from focus behavior."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"screen-share","scenario":"Receiver-side screen-share result","expected_result":"Assistant UI should remain absent from what a remote receiver sees during the tested full-screen share.","observed_result":"The published review did not include a controlled receiver-side screen-share result for the full Cluely UI.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Cursor behavior was tested separately; no full screen-share verdict is claimed."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"screen-share","scenario":"Receiver-side screen-share result","expected_result":"Assistant UI should remain absent from what a remote receiver sees during the tested full-screen share.","observed_result":"An Interview Coder control appeared in the remote Google Meet receiver view.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#proof-screen-share-visible","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the recorded Google Meet setup; Zoom was not part of the published receiver evidence."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"screen-share","scenario":"Receiver-side screen-share result","expected_result":"Assistant UI should remain absent from what a remote receiver sees during the tested full-screen share.","observed_result":"The published review did not include a controlled remote-receiver result.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"An app's own preview is not equivalent to a controlled remote receiver view."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"screen-share","scenario":"Receiver-side screen-share result","expected_result":"Assistant UI should remain absent from what a remote receiver sees during the tested full-screen share.","observed_result":"The main overlay stayed hidden, but an ULTRACODE language menu appeared in the receiver-side share.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-screen-share","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested menu and full-screen Google Meet flow."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"screen-share","scenario":"Receiver-side screen-share result","expected_result":"Assistant UI should remain absent from what a remote receiver sees during the tested full-screen share.","observed_result":"The main Parakeet AI panel stayed hidden, but a native validation tooltip appeared in the remote Google Meet receiver view.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-screen-share","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the recorded full-screen Google Meet receiver setup."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"screen-share","scenario":"Receiver-side screen-share result","expected_result":"Assistant UI should remain absent from what a remote receiver sees during the tested full-screen share.","observed_result":"The main assistant UI could remain hidden, but cursor changes and native tooltips could still expose assistant interaction during screen sharing.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/final-round-ai#desktop-control","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The mixed result distinguishes the hidden main window from cursor and native-tooltip surfaces."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"local-visibility","scenario":"Local app and process visibility","expected_result":"A normal Activity Monitor or Task Manager check should match any marketing claim about local invisibility or zero trace.","observed_result":"Cluely appeared by name in Activity Monitor and the Applications folder.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#stealth-control","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This checks normal system surfaces, not every possible process-hiding configuration."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"local-visibility","scenario":"Local app and process visibility","expected_result":"A normal Activity Monitor or Task Manager check should match any marketing claim about local invisibility or zero trace.","observed_result":"A systemcontainer process with a recognizable app icon appeared in Activity Monitor.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#proof-activity-monitor","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested macOS app identity."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"local-visibility","scenario":"Local app and process visibility","expected_result":"A normal Activity Monitor or Task Manager check should match any marketing claim about local invisibility or zero trace.","observed_result":"The main process could be renamed, but LockedIn helpers and recognizable identity remained visible.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/lockedin-ai#proof-renamed-processes","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested rename configuration."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"local-visibility","scenario":"Local app and process visibility","expected_result":"A normal Activity Monitor or Task Manager check should match any marketing claim about local invisibility or zero trace.","observed_result":"Branded ULTRACODE processes appeared in macOS Activity Monitor and Windows Task Manager.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-activity-monitor","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The process check covers the tested builds and normal operating-system tools."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"local-visibility","scenario":"Local app and process visibility","expected_result":"A normal Activity Monitor or Task Manager check should match any marketing claim about local invisibility or zero trace.","observed_result":"A blank or renamed top-level label still exposed the ParakeetAI executable and parakeetai-desktop support paths during normal Activity Monitor inspection.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-activity-monitor","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-renamed-process","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Result applies to the tested desktop app and normal Activity Monitor inspection."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"local-visibility","scenario":"Local app and process visibility","expected_result":"A normal Activity Monitor or Task Manager check should match any marketing claim about local invisibility or zero trace.","observed_result":"Windows Task Manager listed multiple Final Round and Final Round AI processes with the product icon.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/final-round-ai#proof-task-manager","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This is normal local-system inspection evidence, not receiver-side screen-share evidence."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"live-answer-shape","scenario":"Live answer readability","expected_result":"The configured output should be concise and easy to scan while an interviewer is waiting.","observed_result":"The content could be useful, but the published behavioral and system-design outputs were long written prose.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#proof-answer-shape","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Answer shape may vary with settings, prompts, and later versions."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"live-answer-shape","scenario":"Live answer readability","expected_result":"The configured output should be concise and easy to scan while an interviewer is waiting.","observed_result":"The review did not publish a comparable full live-answer-readability run.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"No behavioral result is claimed for this criterion."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"live-answer-shape","scenario":"Live answer readability","expected_result":"The configured output should be concise and easy to scan while an interviewer is waiting.","observed_result":"Concise settings still produced large code blocks and paragraph-heavy answers in the published runs.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"failed","outcome":"Failed in our test","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/lockedin-ai#proof-not-concise","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Output shape may vary by prompt, selected model, and later versions."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"live-answer-shape","scenario":"Live answer readability","expected_result":"The configured output should be concise and easy to scan while an interviewer is waiting.","observed_result":"The review did not publish a comparable normalized live-answer-readability run.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"No behavioral result is claimed for this criterion."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"live-answer-shape","scenario":"Live answer readability","expected_result":"The configured output should be concise and easy to scan while an interviewer is waiting.","observed_result":"Default responses were often dense paragraph walls, while one prompt that explicitly requested three short bullets produced a compact relevant answer.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-answer-shape","additional_evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-clean-prompt","details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"Answer shape varies with prompt wording, model selection, and later versions."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"live-answer-shape","scenario":"Live answer readability","expected_result":"The configured output should be concise and easy to scan while an interviewer is waiting.","observed_result":"Default mode produced dense output and left multiple answers competing in the stream; Short and Bullet Point modes were present but not evaluated.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"mixed","outcome":"Mixed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/final-round-ai#proof-overlapping-answers","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The result applies to the selected Default mode."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"follow-up-control","scenario":"Explicit follow-up or text-prompt control","expected_result":"Expose a clear control for asking a follow-up or entering a new text prompt.","observed_result":"The published UI shows an explicit follow-up input after the generated answer.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"pass","outcome":"Passed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/images/reviews/cluely/cluely-transcript-followup-noise.webp","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This verifies the visible control in the tested flow, not every follow-up scenario."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"follow-up-control","scenario":"Explicit follow-up or text-prompt control","expected_result":"Expose a clear control for asking a follow-up or entering a new text prompt.","observed_result":"An explicit follow-up or new text-prompt control was not found in the tested flow.","coverage":"feature_sought","outcome_code":"not_found","outcome":"Not found","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#comparison","repeat_count":null,"limitations":"A feature not found in the tested flow may exist in another plan or version."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"follow-up-control","scenario":"Explicit follow-up or text-prompt control","expected_result":"Expose a clear control for asking a follow-up or entering a new text prompt.","observed_result":"A chat/text prompt control was present in the published UI.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"pass","outcome":"Passed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/lockedin-ai#proof-context-handling","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This verifies the visible control, not every follow-up behavior."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"follow-up-control","scenario":"Explicit follow-up or text-prompt control","expected_result":"Expose a clear control for asking a follow-up or entering a new text prompt.","observed_result":"A text follow-up input was present and used in the published test flow.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"pass","outcome":"Passed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#proof-cursor-disappearing","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This verifies the tested desktop input, not a phone-based workflow."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"follow-up-control","scenario":"Explicit follow-up or text-prompt control","expected_result":"Expose a clear control for asking a follow-up or entering a new text prompt.","observed_result":"Manual in-session messages and pre-session context fields were present in the tested UI.","coverage":"tested","outcome_code":"pass","outcome":"Passed","evidence_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/parakeet-ai#proof-manual-control","additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"This verifies the visible controls; saved setup persistence and Auto Answer context reliability are separate findings."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"follow-up-control","scenario":"Explicit follow-up or text-prompt control","expected_result":"Expose a clear control for asking a follow-up or entering a new text prompt.","observed_result":"The published review does not include a clean test of an explicit follow-up or new text-prompt control.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"No feature-presence claim is inferred from public marketing or unrelated setup controls."} {"product_id":"cluely","product":"Cluely","version":"2.1.19","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free tier","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"phone-second-screen","scenario":"Phone or second-screen workflow","expected_result":"Provide a working phone or second-screen companion workflow where the product claims one.","observed_result":"A phone remote or second-screen companion was not found in the tested free-tier flow.","coverage":"feature_sought","outcome_code":"not_found","outcome":"Not found","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/cluely#comparison","repeat_count":null,"limitations":"A feature not found in the tested flow may exist in another plan or version."} {"product_id":"interview-coder","product":"Interview Coder","version":"3.0.1","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free / limited desktop flow","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"phone-second-screen","scenario":"Phone or second-screen workflow","expected_result":"Provide a working phone or second-screen companion workflow where the product claims one.","observed_result":"A phone remote or second-screen companion was not found in the tested flow.","coverage":"feature_sought","outcome_code":"not_found","outcome":"Not found","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/interview-coder#comparison","repeat_count":null,"limitations":"A feature not found in the tested flow may exist in another plan or version."} {"product_id":"lockedin-ai","product":"LockedIn AI","version":"1.7.7","platform":"macOS","plan":"Plan not recorded","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"phone-second-screen","scenario":"Phone or second-screen workflow","expected_result":"Provide a working phone or second-screen companion workflow where the product claims one.","observed_result":"The review records a phone/second-screen option as present, but it does not publish an operation test.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The separate Duo human-helper experience is unrelated and was not evaluated."} {"product_id":"ultracode","product":"ULTRACODE AI","version":"8.10.0","platform":"macOS + Windows","plan":"Free demo / trial flow","test_date":"2026-06/2026-07","criterion_id":"phone-second-screen","scenario":"Phone or second-screen workflow","expected_result":"Provide a working phone or second-screen companion workflow where the product claims one.","observed_result":"A phone remote or second-screen companion was not found in the tested flow.","coverage":"feature_sought","outcome_code":"not_found","outcome":"Not found","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":"https://www.ctrlpotato.com/compare/ultracode#comparison","repeat_count":null,"limitations":"A feature not found in the tested flow may exist in another version."} {"product_id":"parakeet-ai","product":"Parakeet AI","version":"3.9.3","platform":"macOS","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"phone-second-screen","scenario":"Phone or second-screen workflow","expected_result":"Provide a working phone or second-screen companion workflow where the product claims one.","observed_result":"Parakeet AI documents a concurrent mobile-optimized browser view, but this review did not test its operation or remote-control parity.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The benchmark records public documentation only and makes no operational pass/fail claim."} {"product_id":"final-round-ai","product":"Final Round AI","version":"2.5.0","platform":"macOS + Windows 11","plan":"Free trial","test_date":"2026-07","criterion_id":"phone-second-screen","scenario":"Phone or second-screen workflow","expected_result":"Provide a working phone or second-screen companion workflow where the product claims one.","observed_result":"Final Round AI documents mobile use, but this review did not test phone operation or second-screen remote-control behavior.","coverage":"not_tested","outcome_code":"not_tested","outcome":"Not tested","evidence_url":null,"additional_evidence_url":null,"details_url":null,"repeat_count":null,"limitations":"The benchmark records public documentation only and makes no operational pass/fail claim."}