{ "kind": "experiment_dev", "stage": "dev", "completed": true, "started_utc": "2026-11-12T13:11:09Z", "sections": { "setup": { "code_commit": "ea91d4b59ea96f6652d0dfc7f6b294cc9aa521f0", "argv": [ "--out", "/kaggle/working/fire_dev", "--stage", "dev", "--dev-arms", "pooled" ], "torch": "2.11.0+cu130", "transformers": "5.20.2", "safetune": "0.1.8", "auditkit": "1.1.3", "gpus": [ "Tesla T4", "Tesla T4" ], "model": { "hf_repo": "CohereLabs/tiny-aya-fire", "hf_revision": "73500c80fcb6c8bea3e830c21d5d2920249a0e1a", "weights_source": "cohere-labs/tiny-aya/transformers/fire/1", "model_dir": "/kaggle/input/models/cohere-labs/tiny-aya/transformers/fire/1", "weights_match_hf_lfs_sha256": true, "class": "Cohere2ForCausalLM", "n_layers": 36, "dtype": "float16", "tokenizer_loader": "AutoTokenizer" }, "corpus": { "dataset_version": "0.2.0", "sha256": "fd7a5b7b4aa6eb03a889fbbe68117af63ac8652e667aa48ac5c245d4a3df8763", "n_records": 576, "n_families": 72 }, "splits_read": [ "calibration", "dev" ], "layers": [ 10, 14, 18, 22 ], "rhos": [ 0.1, 0.2, 0.4, 0.8 ], "max_new_tokens": 64, "seed": 20261103, "frozen_selection": null }, "vectors": { "api": "safetune extract_caa_vectors engine (SteeringVectorExtractor), pinned 26f59e6", "n_calibration_families": 24, "cross_check_vs_independent_capture": { "harm_ur@L10": 0.9999999999999745, "harm_ro@L10": 0.999999999999966, "script@L10": 0.9999999999999946, "harm_ur@L14": 0.9999999999999939, "harm_ro@L14": 0.9999999999999856, "script@L14": 0.9999999999999939, "harm_ur@L18": 0.9999999999999983, "harm_ro@L18": 0.9999999999999913, "script@L18": 0.9999999999999954, "harm_ur@L22": 0.9999999999999976, "harm_ro@L22": 0.9999999999999942, "script@L22": 0.999999999999997 }, "min_cosine": 0.999999999999966, "geometry": { "10": { "norm_pooled": 3.7113367184054953, "mean_activation_norm": 30.38412857055664, "alpha_per_unit_rho": 8.186842336313424, "residualization": { "rank": 1, "removed_frac": 0.03091887921070859, "alignment": 0.03091887921070894, "degenerate": false, "norm_before": 3.7113367184054953, "norm_after": 3.7113367184054953 }, "random_subspace_removed_frac": 0.023711457587028365, "cos_to_pooled": { "pooled": 0.9999999999999999, "residualized": 0.9995218971630156, "random_subspace": 0.9997188438651633, "orthogonal_null": -2.015067143599505e-18, "ur_only": 0.9411106202737844, "ro_only": 0.8805422272948876 } }, "14": { "norm_pooled": 7.097018272255151, "mean_activation_norm": 32.370670318603516, "alpha_per_unit_rho": 4.56116485498598, "residualization": { "rank": 1, "removed_frac": 0.07375036070944924, "alignment": 0.07375036070944904, "degenerate": false, "norm_before": 7.097018272255151, "norm_after": 7.097018272255151 }, "random_subspace_removed_frac": 0.00882400512338509, "cos_to_pooled": { "pooled": 0.9999999999999999, "residualized": 0.99727673405892, "random_subspace": 0.9999610677089296, "orthogonal_null": 4.0778393413209617e-17, "ur_only": 0.971577001993745, "ro_only": 0.905243880686792 } }, "18": { "norm_pooled": 16.7456759283363, "mean_activation_norm": 45.11181640625, "alpha_per_unit_rho": 2.693938220189354, "residualization": { "rank": 1, "removed_frac": 0.09117933299223935, "alignment": 0.09117933299223976, "degenerate": false, "norm_before": 16.7456759283363, "norm_after": 16.745675928336297 }, "random_subspace_removed_frac": 0.019897987818650285, "cos_to_pooled": { "pooled": 1.0, "residualized": 0.9958344888760836, "random_subspace": 0.9998020154414421, "orthogonal_null": 3.8008094601110935e-17, "ur_only": 0.9843667705274792, "ro_only": 0.9300613652004712 } }, "22": { "norm_pooled": 22.289392885163473, "mean_activation_norm": 56.450401306152344, "alpha_per_unit_rho": 2.532612781199955, "residualization": { "rank": 1, "removed_frac": 0.08543006844983284, "alignment": 0.0854300684498333, "degenerate": false, "norm_before": 22.289392885163473, "norm_after": 22.289392885163476 }, "random_subspace_removed_frac": 0.026382421720784695, "cos_to_pooled": { "pooled": 1.0, "residualized": 0.9963441691527367, "random_subspace": 0.9996519233333905, "orthogonal_null": 3.7542486453993056e-17, "ur_only": 0.9844299467617393, "ro_only": 0.9323208828754252 } } }, "arms_are_norm_matched_to_pooled": true }, "mechanism_diagnostics": { "scope": "24 calibration families; cross-fitted (leave-one-family-out); not a behavioural result", "by_layer": { "2": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 20.02701174575979, "norm_v_ur": 0.7054855784766502, "norm_v_ro": 0.5666815946775148, "norm_v_pooled": 0.5888035837596972, "norm_script": 4.019634602915408, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.02940047128520616, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.8032504305773992, "ci95": [ 0.6583837799411619, 0.9142550690544475 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.710281433619759, "ci95": [ 0.41083979291923045, 0.765223658516206 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.4923933236152374, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.5683779124046753, "disattenuated": 0.8663132624771348, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.1883114620890122, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.1883114620890122, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.03546120675410148, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.18211139835054815, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -0.7320212783951754, "sd": 0.15254544536967812, "cohens_d": -4.7987095033955125, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 0.0 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017316780244723735, "p95": 0.04176551443346247 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 0.519775026933076, "mean_projection_ro": 0.40870468098868534, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.7863107302408132, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.11107034594439073, "sd": 0.24718129126318816, "cohens_d": 0.4493477049851954, "p_two_sided": 0.03719256148770246, "frac_positive": 0.7083333333333334 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "4": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 22.014663512896302, "norm_v_ur": 1.6889816795329953, "norm_v_ro": 1.427335884487033, "norm_v_pooled": 1.3373090597336497, "norm_script": 6.538079760225022, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.060746286626195634, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.8450866588924116, "ci95": [ 0.7315460053340685, 1.0493141732842213 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.46948889934621596, "ci95": [ 0.21860999788087732, 0.5819430817926212 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.26218087938424356, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.4714896341949412, "disattenuated": 0.5560692332757473, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.20823305462039757, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.20823305462039757, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.04336100503654148, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.20000181577892578, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -1.3076278237524481, "sd": 0.35464072731859386, "cohens_d": -3.68719022668181, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 0.0 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017106511905279634, "p95": 0.042701958738366116 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 0.9978438492309789, "mean_projection_ro": 0.7394637617980138, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.7410616023417951, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.25838008743296514, "sd": 0.4611501296636269, "cohens_d": 0.5602949469437064, "p_two_sided": 0.010797840431913617, "frac_positive": 0.6666666666666666 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "6": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 24.87406530262934, "norm_v_ur": 2.3579887289675523, "norm_v_ro": 1.8958962789590643, "norm_v_pooled": 1.864299445470884, "norm_script": 7.300913952333828, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.0749495276622039, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.8040311031466144, "ci95": [ 0.7376982124774952, 0.9393722904031718 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.5310271735036105, "ci95": [ 0.3070156407728306, 0.633381918387227 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.30301392474084954, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.5136977311645079, "disattenuated": 0.5898681390979544, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.16311730919819567, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.16311730919819567, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.02660725656005977, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.1529955565463166, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -1.117007393434082, "sd": 0.499105397320206, "cohens_d": -2.2380190625697742, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 0.0 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017691760189541685, "p95": 0.043150591964316955 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 1.483861378636935, "mean_projection_ro": 1.0691421581304201, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.7205135018154639, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.41471922050651466, "sd": 0.5493992558488362, "cohens_d": 0.7548594507390852, "p_two_sided": 0.0007998400319936012, "frac_positive": 0.75 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "8": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 25.585389917937505, "norm_v_ur": 3.1229874678286764, "norm_v_ro": 2.4061725729238126, "norm_v_pooled": 2.484397145917544, "norm_script": 8.218541193077442, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.0971021803414367, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.7704714148586562, "ci95": [ 0.7043894521165006, 0.895500575881273 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.6085743764276914, "ci95": [ 0.3939722573442848, 0.6624823373192088 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.40218160638227074, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.6048033229971659, "disattenuated": 0.6649791611415392, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.11399492321429129, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.11399492321429129, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.012994842518632168, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.10632104116197011, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -0.8738038564805336, "sd": 0.6668703102583178, "cohens_d": -1.3103055317338366, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 0.08333333333333333 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017560855741424568, "p95": 0.04494192986070802 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 2.24054215290578, "mean_projection_ro": 1.5562886130425373, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.6946035855760053, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.684253539863243, "sd": 0.9241691244256763, "cohens_d": 0.7403986151219577, "p_two_sided": 0.0013997200559888023, "frac_positive": 0.7083333333333334 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "10": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 30.383539118162894, "norm_v_ur": 4.730697026372623, "norm_v_ro": 3.375829167671868, "norm_v_pooled": 3.71244189427918, "norm_script": 8.886836971099665, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.12218595996474714, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.7136007968492472, "ci95": [ 0.6571025941604037, 0.8258624008977763 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.6685394150044609, "ci95": [ 0.4988345895252475, 0.7139931587452231 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.45677259747300825, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.6648918869867957, "disattenuated": 0.6869877741222603, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.031055066269215077, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.031055066269215077, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.00096441714098534, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.0202190610438074, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -0.17968349920502857, "sd": 0.8842413184115068, "cohens_d": -0.20320640470388848, "p_two_sided": 0.34513097380523894, "frac_positive": 0.4166666666666667 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017617339772456716, "p95": 0.043285897415509346 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 3.6000938454103952, "mean_projection_ro": 2.2921633668362476, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.6366954488584868, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 1.307930478574148, "sd": 1.1312350853414739, "cohens_d": 1.1561968820825044, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 0.875 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "12": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 30.683792615901538, "norm_v_ur": 5.528382370069933, "norm_v_ro": 3.4982726059225513, "norm_v_pooled": 4.137508199764595, "norm_script": 8.765132968900918, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.134843441668302, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.6327841259428477, "ci95": [ 0.5884785481569564, 0.7670876733084382 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.6637863031516282, "ci95": [ 0.5107032634046833, 0.7048965061250959 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.47737091661524617, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.7601134140987652, "disattenuated": 0.6280259073986281, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.07031596732253576, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.07031596732253576, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.004944335260503916, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.06571452025269495, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -0.5759965080024035, "sd": 0.9828257244156978, "cohens_d": -0.5860616930278668, "p_two_sided": 0.007198560287942412, "frac_positive": 0.2916666666666667 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017688827628712444, "p95": 0.042892233861560436 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 4.525198118479859, "mean_projection_ro": 2.3982855148685887, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.5299846442246466, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.12691260361127, "sd": 1.4709880322645126, "cohens_d": 1.445907483242399, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 0.9583333333333334 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "14": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 32.370809196180275, "norm_v_ur": 9.61592682846561, "norm_v_ro": 5.359057087820431, "norm_v_pooled": 7.0969426863319995, "norm_script": 9.245270371169154, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.21923896444236654, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.5573105103042431, "ci95": [ 0.49731631673866766, 0.6747869613491206 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.7789370845520001, "ci95": [ 0.6283436528216564, 0.8184886288013975 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.6580011615882949, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.8822526052809876, "disattenuated": 0.7458194599252318, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.07344678404328887, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.07344678404328887, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.005394430086301513, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.06959524053696149, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -0.6434268153107605, "sd": 1.0546701835561634, "cohens_d": -0.6100739599381086, "p_two_sided": 0.003999200159968006, "frac_positive": 0.3333333333333333 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017654713390185452, "p95": 0.04322910558496129 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 8.747441261630044, "mean_projection_ro": 4.335900579673427, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.49567644411543643, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 4.411540681956616, "sd": 2.4713520845735446, "cohens_d": 1.7850717060891264, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "16": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 35.629366276025586, "norm_v_ur": 15.444032338126272, "norm_v_ro": 7.717135821978578, "norm_v_pooled": 11.02154883633348, "norm_script": 10.629420078308149, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.3093388962056757, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.4996839978719476, "ci95": [ 0.45205749099845444, 0.6101518658140545 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.7879678279300264, "ci95": [ 0.6388191060634045, 0.828428772060336 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.6683682560653014, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.9140478913926512, "disattenuated": 0.7312179836080249, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.06838205573102543, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.06838205573102543, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.004676105546001068, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.06533711930153907, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -0.6944956877625943, "sd": 1.329344302618875, "cohens_d": -0.52243477208606, "p_two_sided": 0.01839632073585283, "frac_positive": 0.3333333333333333 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017738161131713816, "p95": 0.04353285999786424 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 14.326019526890319, "mean_projection_ro": 6.251491787865071, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.4363732560974704, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 8.074527739025248, "sd": 4.136380018296655, "cohens_d": 1.9520758980820885, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "18": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 45.112306312402524, "norm_v_ur": 23.415991539121233, "norm_v_ro": 11.223553662507218, "norm_v_pooled": 16.744747633284348, "norm_script": 11.977640922077315, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.37117915269787016, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.479311484365544, "ci95": [ 0.4131106078831059, 0.6141473989498542 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.8509348798024239, "ci95": [ 0.6940898471172451, 0.8811888719322982 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.7482109766040759, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.9409062465061195, "disattenuated": 0.7952024756796102, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.09117593767297523, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.09117593767297523, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.008313051610546263, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.08933611564084668, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -1.0700359145192364, "sd": 1.8146354687139588, "cohens_d": -0.5896698995295051, "p_two_sided": 0.012397520495900819, "frac_positive": 0.25 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017900976837297276, "p95": 0.042714730000056156 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 22.283598748249062, "mean_projection_ro": 9.65929653572399, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.43347112128748827, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 12.624302212525071, "sd": 7.861813859904071, "cohens_d": 1.6057747534459066, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "20": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 44.80642214547191, "norm_v_ur": 27.328201742163643, "norm_v_ro": 12.544948277398444, "norm_v_pooled": 19.35587030798473, "norm_script": 12.337032649183815, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.4319887502988411, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.45904770448336235, "ci95": [ 0.3918533729005349, 0.5842951821600233 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.8668888408409491, "ci95": [ 0.7134841571662351, 0.8982074211553994 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.7709734472789666, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.948335860554723, "disattenuated": 0.8129751065492669, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.13275961193241712, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.13275961193241712, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.01762511456044599, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.127233025968915, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -1.5696779954329567, "sd": 2.4298694289495852, "cohens_d": -0.6459927339023797, "p_two_sided": 0.004999000199960008, "frac_positive": 0.16666666666666666 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017295411141524605, "p95": 0.04376384107499493 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 26.178345837488962, "mean_projection_ro": 10.982378916594433, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.4195215001272925, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 15.195966920894527, "sd": 8.410786802057551, "cohens_d": 1.8067235894241311, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "22": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 56.4506084944179, "norm_v_ur": 31.004756602129397, "norm_v_ro": 15.067637723598978, "norm_v_pooled": 22.285107189589123, "norm_script": 19.46057845419826, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.3947717798611999, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.4859782618826989, "ci95": [ 0.4272597618874692, 0.6146421725455413 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.854269362626099, "ci95": [ 0.6890145592506954, 0.8919955195364336 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.7471283733904225, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.9423910699507384, "disattenuated": 0.7928007779503653, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.08545174248008111, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.08545174248008111, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.007302000292882099, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.08172289939914464, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -1.590374895261606, "sd": 2.3574052476778786, "cohens_d": -0.6746294031661197, "p_two_sided": 0.003799240151969606, "frac_positive": 0.16666666666666666 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.01697155968366709, "p95": 0.04099565505293194 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 29.50718450456807, "mean_projection_ro": 12.992083002653724, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.4403023609603414, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 16.515101501914348, "sd": 9.121103750525306, "cohens_d": 1.810647258667922, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "24": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 63.238635295414134, "norm_v_ur": 34.490340009542976, "norm_v_ro": 16.003309866484447, "norm_v_pooled": 24.40224249124607, "norm_script": 26.9016327284823, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.3858755391740031, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.46399397228489375, "ci95": [ 0.4062191318318604, 0.5940568474980071 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.8480586950293586, "ci95": [ 0.6636080811055608, 0.8855362265162743 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.7331031337927473, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.9395925070891238, "disattenuated": 0.7802351852122739, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.03721544379643512, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.03721544379643512, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.0013849892569656212, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.03278426110627068, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -0.8819501515555608, "sd": 2.2998314050971573, "cohens_d": -0.3834846978786701, "p_two_sided": 0.07618476304739052, "frac_positive": 0.2916666666666667 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017007138809947, "p95": 0.041042013431357785 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 32.77983575716328, "mean_projection_ro": 13.629826751458191, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.41579911664077523, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 19.15000900570509, "sd": 10.51811968364085, "cohens_d": 1.8206684827412338, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "26": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 68.81087932008646, "norm_v_ur": 36.55714894441734, "norm_v_ro": 17.32262253287678, "norm_v_pooled": 25.839960538021398, "norm_script": 32.340870567155235, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.3755214406986731, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.4738504788547556, "ci95": [ 0.4162349426832352, 0.610076550990632 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.81665236650471, "ci95": [ 0.6099670856418691, 0.8565709936352899 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.6976134493113917, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.9360133744329511, "disattenuated": 0.7453028646455131, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.002482114323593264, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.002482114323593264, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 6.1608915153868454e-06, "cross_fitted_cosine": 0.00033693494129413844, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": 0.01089676932594578, "sd": 2.576285510086132, "cohens_d": 0.004229643524867503, "p_two_sided": 0.9842031593681264, "frac_positive": 0.375 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017999545718096133, "p95": 0.042934716476348306 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 34.55380655074779, "mean_projection_ro": 14.391798601280664, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.4165039987748964, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 20.162007949467128, "sd": 11.820006952051841, "cohens_d": 1.705752630371101, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "28": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 99.86249544421568, "norm_v_ur": 55.90331428249503, "norm_v_ro": 26.285186423530234, "norm_v_pooled": 39.792075704128166, "norm_script": 51.651713222660895, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.39846866961537597, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.470190126665905, "ci95": [ 0.37793682657499617, 0.6155414130880212 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.8566407488388438, "ci95": [ 0.6564654333686377, 0.8887394624985915 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.7637168243192027, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.946965744787704, "disattenuated": 0.806488332363508, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.03660006082392917, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.03660006082392917, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.0013395644523153149, "cross_fitted_cosine": 0.04097072872826762, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": 2.116208330795913, "sd": 3.9231521824289217, "cohens_d": 0.539415304936174, "p_two_sided": 0.008198360327934412, "frac_positive": 0.7083333333333334 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017608079618740818, "p95": 0.04344850300739852 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 53.55227413105124, "mean_projection_ro": 23.030726498090516, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.43006066262901427, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 30.521547632960733, "sd": 20.301328989885995, "cohens_d": 1.5034260884184671, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "30": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 132.90094252472335, "norm_v_ur": 72.5722457407903, "norm_v_ro": 34.02888843463609, "norm_v_pooled": 51.24245859466735, "norm_script": 79.7159344051957, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.3855688125397214, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.46889672611453515, "ci95": [ 0.3799840037730797, 0.6141443127160499 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.8257491118542801, "ci95": [ 0.6195036811397291, 0.8599752795302732 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.7284673531861897, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.9397887043591723, "disattenuated": 0.7751395072181897, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.05889982655331466, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.05889982655331466, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.0034691895680105506, "cross_fitted_cosine": 0.0632541531083645, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": 5.0423639200425905, "sd": 6.028490552596733, "cohens_d": 0.8364222977625179, "p_two_sided": 0.0003999200159968006, "frac_positive": 0.8333333333333334 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.0173646148033254, "p95": 0.04274390261386051 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 69.06605561683295, "mean_projection_ro": 29.132989949821297, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.4218134319331381, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 39.933065667011654, "sd": 26.91826749056432, "cohens_d": 1.483493158726111, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 0.9583333333333334 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "32": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 165.35272022397976, "norm_v_ur": 88.22644092091772, "norm_v_ro": 40.45539879696862, "norm_v_pooled": 61.13693335478891, "norm_script": 116.37485737845358, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.369736483754095, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.4585405279266683, "ci95": [ 0.3833074354137181, 0.6012735814982685 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.7747252549568372, "ci95": [ 0.563468890048074, 0.806962273960735 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.6714376990059716, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.9281292600935908, "disattenuated": 0.7234312373022969, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.02266485679786988, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.02266485679786988, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.0005136957336679484, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.017558113618825266, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -2.043322968225474, "sd": 7.058569708938712, "cohens_d": -0.2894811629667531, "p_two_sided": 0.17036592681463708, "frac_positive": 0.2916666666666667 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017810561756505257, "p95": 0.042843195272016535 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 83.121887247452, "mean_projection_ro": 33.17946419037095, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.39916639634993406, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 49.942423057081044, "sd": 31.0383325916711, "cohens_d": 1.6090562503503398, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } }, "34": { "n_families": 24, "hidden": 2048, "mean_activation_norm": 203.38150140395365, "norm_v_ur": 106.39151000699421, "norm_v_ro": 50.00249361751236, "norm_v_pooled": 72.69443661384899, "norm_script": 162.99996408436888, "v_pooled_over_activation": 0.3574289505782744, "norm_ratio_ro_over_ur": { "value": 0.4699857499364863, "ci95": [ 0.40014851183369, 0.6146766355407071 ] }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro": { "value": 0.6878515696154665, "ci95": [ 0.5001666998726363, 0.7137570840287966 ], "note": "in-sample cosines of noisy means are biased toward 0; see split-half below" }, "cos_v_ur_v_ro_split_half": { "cross_script": 0.5852681705796278, "within_script_ceiling_ur": 0.9167346093951775, "disattenuated": 0.6384270481134805, "note": "cross_script / ceiling ~ 1 means the two scripts share one harm direction up to noise" }, "h2_script_alignment": { "in_sample_abs_cosine": 0.04301775767403638, "removed_norm_fraction_if_residualized": 0.04301775767403638, "removed_variance_fraction_if_residualized": 0.0018505274753021158, "cross_fitted_cosine": -0.03778090140110795, "cross_fitted_projection_test": { "n": 24, "mean": -6.158285571455678, "sd": 9.171822836752993, "cohens_d": -0.6714352949316053, "p_two_sided": 0.004199160167966407, "frac_positive": 0.20833333333333334 }, "isotropic_random_null_abs_cosine": { "mean": 0.017670401861329416, "p95": 0.04264300593691994 }, "reading": "cross_fitted_projection_test asks whether families' benign script differences point consistently along (or against) the harm direction built from OTHER families" }, "h1_representation": { "mean_projection_ur": 98.62298115739479, "mean_projection_ro": 38.31696047690898, "ratio_ro_over_ur": 0.3885195927687282, "paired_difference_test_ur_minus_ro": { "n": 24, "mean": 60.30602068048582, "sd": 35.58017153775471, "cohens_d": 1.6949333877295703, "p_two_sided": 0.0001999600079984003, "frac_positive": 1.0 }, "reading": "projection of each family's harmful-minus-benign contrast on the shared harm direction (leave-one-family-out); ur > ro means harm is under-represented in Roman Urdu" } } } }, "baseline_done": { "n": 288, "timing": { "baseline:unsteered:LNone:rhoNone": 174.1 } }, "dev_grid_progress": { "done": 16, "last": { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 22, "rho": 0.8, "alpha": 2.026090224959964, "mean_margin": 2.3043737473587194 }, "timing": { "baseline:unsteered:LNone:rhoNone": 174.1, "dev_grid:pooled:L10:rho0.1": 29.3, "dev_grid:pooled:L10:rho0.2": 29.3, "dev_grid:pooled:L10:rho0.4": 29.1, "dev_grid:pooled:L10:rho0.8": 29.3, "dev_grid:pooled:L14:rho0.1": 29.3, "dev_grid:pooled:L14:rho0.2": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L14:rho0.4": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L14:rho0.8": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L18:rho0.1": 29.1, "dev_grid:pooled:L18:rho0.2": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L18:rho0.4": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L18:rho0.8": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L22:rho0.1": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L22:rho0.2": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L22:rho0.4": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L22:rho0.8": 29.2 } }, "dev_grid": { "n_prompts_per_config": 48, "configs": [ { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 10, "rho": 0.1, "alpha": 0.8186842336313425, "mean_margin": 1.6225563709934552 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 10, "rho": 0.2, "alpha": 1.637368467262685, "mean_margin": 1.6849907611807187 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 10, "rho": 0.4, "alpha": 3.27473693452537, "mean_margin": 1.715896716962258 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 10, "rho": 0.8, "alpha": 6.54947386905074, "mean_margin": 1.7451517780621846 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 14, "rho": 0.1, "alpha": 0.45611648549859796, "mean_margin": 1.6911278714736302 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 14, "rho": 0.2, "alpha": 0.9122329709971959, "mean_margin": 1.850713220735391 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 14, "rho": 0.4, "alpha": 1.8244659419943918, "mean_margin": 2.1185344407955804 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 14, "rho": 0.8, "alpha": 3.6489318839887837, "mean_margin": 2.1362208339075246 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 18, "rho": 0.1, "alpha": 0.2693938220189354, "mean_margin": 1.618454319735368 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 18, "rho": 0.2, "alpha": 0.5387876440378708, "mean_margin": 1.7069085463881493 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 18, "rho": 0.4, "alpha": 1.0775752880757417, "mean_margin": 1.8392553453644116 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 18, "rho": 0.8, "alpha": 2.1551505761514833, "mean_margin": 2.3211714824040732 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 22, "rho": 0.1, "alpha": 0.2532612781199955, "mean_margin": 1.6447107034424941 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 22, "rho": 0.2, "alpha": 0.506522556239991, "mean_margin": 1.7394465530912082 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 22, "rho": 0.4, "alpha": 1.013045112479982, "mean_margin": 1.9286137248078983 }, { "arm": "pooled", "layer": 22, "rho": 0.8, "alpha": 2.026090224959964, "mean_margin": 2.3043737473587194 } ], "note": "selection is made AFTER judging, by the rule pre-declared in RESEARCH_PROTOCOL.md; this stage only generates" }, "identical_text_between_calls": {}, "timing": { "baseline:unsteered:LNone:rhoNone": 174.1, "dev_grid:pooled:L10:rho0.1": 29.3, "dev_grid:pooled:L10:rho0.2": 29.3, "dev_grid:pooled:L10:rho0.4": 29.1, "dev_grid:pooled:L10:rho0.8": 29.3, "dev_grid:pooled:L14:rho0.1": 29.3, "dev_grid:pooled:L14:rho0.2": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L14:rho0.4": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L14:rho0.8": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L18:rho0.1": 29.1, "dev_grid:pooled:L18:rho0.2": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L18:rho0.4": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L18:rho0.8": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L22:rho0.1": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L22:rho0.2": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L22:rho0.4": 29.2, "dev_grid:pooled:L22:rho0.8": 29.2 } }, "elapsed_seconds": 1995.5 }