"""Offline re-analyzer for the Q3 confidence-elicitation manipulation (Section 6). Recomputes, from the shipped per-trial file with no endpoint, the per-model per-variant accuracy, mean confidence, five-bin ECE, and answer-agreement-with-default that the paper reports, and checks them against the shipped summary tcb_decouple.json. python3 analyze_decouple.py The manipulation re-elicits three top-accuracy models under prompt variants (default, hedged, bold, flat) that change only how confidence is reported, not what is answered; the flat variant is a mechanical worst case (forced mid-scale confidence) that bounds the manipulation. """ import json, pathlib from collections import defaultdict HERE = pathlib.Path(__file__).resolve().parent TRIALS = HERE / ".." / "data" / "tcb_decouple_trials.json" SUMMARY = HERE / ".." / "data" / "tcb_decouple.json" def ece5(items): """items: list of (conf_prob in [0,1], correct in {0,1}); five equal-width bins.""" bins = defaultdict(list) for cp, corr in items: bins[min(4, int(cp * 5))].append((cp, corr)) n = len(items) e = 0.0 for xs in bins.values(): mc = sum(x[0] for x in xs) / len(xs) ma = sum(x[1] for x in xs) / len(xs) e += len(xs) / n * abs(mc - ma) return e def main(): trials = json.load(open(TRIALS)) summary = json.load(open(SUMMARY)) # default-elicitation answers per (model, id) to compute answer agreement. default_ans = {} for t in trials: if t["variant"] == "default": default_ans[(t["model"], t["id"])] = t["answer"] by = defaultdict(list) for t in trials: by[(t["model"], t["variant"])].append(t) mismatches = 0 print(f"{'model':16} {'variant':8} {'acc':>6} {'mean_conf':>9} {'ece5':>7} {'agree_default':>13}") for (model, variant), rows in sorted(by.items()): n = len(rows) acc = sum(r["correct"] for r in rows) / n confs = [r["conf"] for r in rows if r["conf"] is not None] mean_conf = sum(confs) / len(confs) if confs else float("nan") items = [((0.5 if r["conf"] is None else r["conf"] / 100.0), r["correct"]) for r in rows] e = ece5(items) agree = sum(1 for r in rows if default_ans.get((model, r["id"])) == r["answer"]) / n print(f"{model:16} {variant:8} {acc:6.3f} {mean_conf:9.1f} {e:7.4f} {agree:13.2f}") ref = summary["per"][model][variant] # mean_conf is reported to one decimal in the summary, so allow that rounding. for label, got, want, tol in [("acc", acc, ref["accuracy"], 5e-3), ("ece5", e, ref["ece5"], 5e-3), ("mean_conf", mean_conf, ref["mean_conf"], 0.1)]: if abs(got - want) > tol: print(f" MISMATCH {label}: recomputed {got:.4f} vs shipped {want:.4f}") mismatches += 1 print("DECOUPLE OK" if mismatches == 0 else f"{mismatches} MISMATCHES") if __name__ == "__main__": main()