--- license: apache-2.0 language: - en pretty_name: DadBench size_categories: - n<1K task_categories: - text-generation tags: - humor - evaluation - benchmark - llm-as-a-judge - reward-modeling - rlhf configs: - config_name: default data_files: - split: human_ratings path: data/human_ratings.jsonl --- # DadBench **A benchmark for dad-joke quality across language models — and a case study in how hard it is to measure a subjective objective without getting Goodharted.** DadBench scores model-written dad jokes on one question: *would a real dad be proud to inflict this?* It exists because the [DadBench project](https://aimatey.co/dadbench/) RL-trained a model (**PunTune**, a fine-tune of Thinking Machines' Inkling) to tell dad jokes, and needed an evaluation rigorous enough to tell whether training actually worked. The answer — *training didn't teach new wit, it taught the model to pick a punchline and stop* — only held up after the eval itself survived four instrument rebuilds and several fired judges. 📝 **Full write-up + live arena:** https://aimatey.co/dadbench/ ## What's in here | File | Contents | |---|---| | `data/human_ratings.jsonl` | **143 single-rater human ratings** (the calibration ground truth). Loads as the `human_ratings` split. | | `leaderboard.json` | Final model board — overall + per-track scores in permanent ladder units. | | `ladder.json` | The **frozen anchor ladder**: per-topic rungs a new model's jokes are placed against, so scores never drift. | | `joke_gallery.md` | Top and bottom jokes, verbatim, with scores — the qualitative texture. | ### `human_ratings.jsonl` fields `sitting` (rating session id) · `n` (index) · `joke` (verbatim text) · `source` (which model/round produced it) · `topic` · `rating` (1–5, blind). ## Method in one paragraph Jokes are scored across four tracks (plain topics, cultural references, comparisons, and long-context news articles). Each joke is placed in **9 blind, order-randomized rankings** against a **frozen ladder** of anchor jokes, and strength is a Bradley–Terry fit — so adding a model or checkpoint never moves anyone else's number. The judge is a **reasoning-parity panel** selected by correlation against the human ratings in this dataset. The project's recurring finding is that the reward is a Goodhart machine: any criterion every candidate satisfies goes invisible under group-relative RL, and uncontrolled thinking-token budgets silently reorder the board. That makes DadBench useful less as a "who's funniest" leaderboard and more as a **testbed for judge robustness and reward design**. ## Related - **Model:** [`aimatey/PunTune-0.6`](https://huggingface.co/aimatey/PunTune-0.6) · [`aimatey/PunTune-0.5`](https://huggingface.co/aimatey/PunTune-0.5), the Inkling fine-tunes this benchmark was built to measure. - **Code:** https://github.com/aimatey-co/dadbench - **Write-up + interactive arena:** https://aimatey.co/dadbench/ ## License Apache-2.0. Built on [Thinking Machines' Inkling](https://huggingface.co/thinkingmachines/Inkling) (also Apache-2.0).