"""Structural defect gate + question parser, extracted verbatim from annotate_v2.py so other drivers can reuse them without duplicating the logic. Measured on the first 362 generated questions: 12% had near-duplicate options and 5% a gold option unsupported by the source material.""" import collections, json, re _WORD = re.compile(r"[a-z0-9']{4,}") _STOP = set("""that this with from into over under after before then than which what were was been being have has had will would could should there here they them their your mine ours first second third fourth i my me the and or of to in on at for a an it its is are be""".split()) def _content(s): return {w for w in _WORD.findall(re.sub(r"^\s*[A-D][\.\)]\s*", "", s or "").lower()) if w not in _STOP} def structural_issues(q, desc): """Shape defects a blind-attack filter does not reliably catch. Measured on the first 362 questions: 12% had two near-duplicate options and 5% had a gold option whose content never appeared in the description. Compound questions are the main offender -- built as a factorial grid over only TWO values per slot, they collapse into a 2-way guess ("'Luyben Av' + minivan" vs "'Luyben Av' + van").""" issues = [] opts = q.get("options") or [] gold = str(q.get("answer", "")).upper()[:1] if len(opts) != 4 or gold not in "ABCD": return ["malformed"] bodies = [re.sub(r"^\s*[A-D][\.\)]\s*", "", o).strip() for o in opts] sets = [_content(b) for b in bodies] for i in range(4): for j in range(i + 1, 4): if sets[i] and sets[j]: jac = len(sets[i] & sets[j]) / len(sets[i] | sets[j]) if jac > 0.8: issues.append("dup_options") break if issues: break # a compound option set must not reuse the same component across most options if len(bodies) == 4: counts = collections.Counter() for b in bodies: for part in re.split(r"\s+and\s+|,\s+", b): p = " ".join(sorted(_content(part))) if p: counts[p] += 1 if counts and max(counts.values()) >= 3: issues.append("repeated_component") gi = "ABCD".index(gold) others = [len(b) for k, b in enumerate(bodies) if k != gi] if abs(len(bodies[gi]) - (sum(others) / 3)) > 30: issues.append("gold_len_outlier") dw = _content(desc) gw = sets[gi] if gw and len(gw - dw) / len(gw) > 0.7: issues.append("gold_unsupported_by_desc") return issues def parse_questions(txt): """Reasoning models often wrap the JSON in prose or a ```json fence despite response_format, and sometimes run out of budget mid-object. Recover what we can instead of dropping the round.""" if not txt: return [] qs = None for cand in (txt, (re.search(r"```(?:json)?\s*(.*?)```", txt, re.S) or [None, None])[1], (re.search(r"\{.*\}", txt, re.S) or [None])[0]): if not cand: continue try: obj = json.loads(cand) if isinstance(obj, dict): qs = obj.get("questions") elif isinstance(obj, list): qs = obj if qs: break except Exception: continue if not qs: # last resort: pull individual question objects out of a truncated array qs = [] for m in re.finditer(r'\{[^{}]*"question"\s*:.*?\}(?=\s*[,\]])', txt, re.S): try: qs.append(json.loads(m.group(0))) except Exception: pass if not qs: return [] out = [] for q in qs: if not isinstance(q, dict) or not q.get("question"): continue opts = q.get("options") or [] if len(opts) != 4 or str(q.get("answer", "")).upper()[:1] not in "ABCD": continue out.append(q) return out BATCH_SYS = ("Answer each numbered multiple-choice question independently. " 'Reply with ONLY JSON mapping question number to letter, e.g. {"1":"A","2":"C"}. ' "Answer every question; if unsure, still give your best single letter.")