"""Controlled gpt-oss -> Magistral swap: matched run-pairs in the same seed whose persona->model map is identical EXCEPT gpt-oss and Magistral are swapped. For the personas that flip, compare comments-per-post under gpt-oss vs under Magistral.""" import sqlite3, json, re from collections import defaultdict from pathlib import Path import numpy as np RUNS=Path("runs");TET=RUNS/"tetratic" SHORT={"Qwen/Qwen3-32B":"Qwen","openai/gpt-oss-20b":"gpt-oss","mistralai/Magistral-Small-2509":"Mag","zai-org/GLM-4-32B-0414":"GLM-4","google/gemma-4-31B-it":"Gemma"} def seed_of(name): m=re.search(r"_s(\d+)",name) or re.search(r"_s(\d+)_r",name) m=re.search(r"s(\d+)",name); return m.group(1) if m else None def load(db,tet=False): base=db.stem if tet and (TET/f"{base}_checkpoint.json").exists():return None mp=str(db).replace(".db",".metadata.json") if not Path(mp).exists():return None try:amm=json.load(open(mp)).get("agent_model_map",{}) except:return None if not amm:return None fam={int(k)+1:SHORT.get(v["model"]) for k,v in amm.items()} if any(v is None for v in fam.values()):return None try: c=sqlite3.connect(db);posts=c.execute("SELECT post_id,user_id FROM post").fetchall();coms=c.execute("SELECT post_id,user_id FROM comment").fetchall();users=dict(c.execute("SELECT user_id,user_name FROM user").fetchall());c.close() except:return None if len(coms)<100:return None owner={p:u for p,u in posts};ind=defaultdict(int);npost=defaultdict(int) for p,cu in coms: o=owner.get(p) if o in fam and o!=cu:ind[o]+=1 for p,u in posts: if u in fam:npost[u]+=1 # per user_id: model, persona, cpp rec={} for u in fam: if npost[u]>=2:rec[u]={"model":fam[u],"persona":users.get(u,f"u{u}"),"cpp":ind[u]/npost[u]} return {"seed":re.search(r"s(\d+)",base).group(1),"name":base,"rec":rec} runs=[] for db in sorted(RUNS.glob("sweep_*.db")): if any(x in db.name for x in ["archive","olm","hermes","glm47","pilot_","snapshot","qwq"]):continue r=load(db); if r:runs.append(r) for db in sorted(TET.glob("tetra_s*_r*.db")): r=load(db,tet=True) if r:runs.append(r) print(len(runs),"runs loaded") byseed=defaultdict(list) for r in runs:byseed[r["seed"]].append(r) oss_vals=[];mag_vals=[];npairs=0;nflips=0 for seed,rs in byseed.items(): for i in range(len(rs)): for j in range(i+1,len(rs)): A,B=rs[i]["rec"],rs[j]["rec"] shared=set(A)&set(B) if len(shared)<10:continue # require same persona per shared slot, and model identical except oss<->mag ok=True;flips=[] for u in shared: if A[u]["persona"]!=B[u]["persona"]:ok=False;break ma,mb=A[u]["model"],B[u]["model"] if ma==mb:continue if {ma,mb}=={"gpt-oss","Mag"}:flips.append(u) else:ok=False;break if not ok or not flips:continue npairs+=1 for u in flips: oss=A[u] if A[u]["model"]=="gpt-oss" else B[u] mag=A[u] if A[u]["model"]=="Mag" else B[u] oss_vals.append(oss["cpp"]);mag_vals.append(mag["cpp"]);nflips+=1 o=np.array(oss_vals);m=np.array(mag_vals) print(f"matched swap pairs: {npairs}; flipped persona-observations: {nflips}") print(f"mean CPP powered by gpt-oss: {o.mean():.2f}") print(f"mean CPP powered by Magistral: {m.mean():.2f}") print(f"drop: {100*(o.mean()-m.mean())/o.mean():.0f}% fewer CPP under Magistral") # paired (same persona,pair) drop d=(o-m) print(f"paired mean drop: {d.mean():.2f} CPP ({100*d.mean()/o.mean():.0f}%); median paired drop {np.median(d):.2f}")